Cleaning Up: Report Details Pattern of Overcharges By Louisiana Contractors and Sheriff For BP Oil Spill

There is a report by Pro Publica that has not received the attention that it deserves. The group looked at charges against BP and found gross overcharges that would seem to constitute nothing short of fraud — including charges by the parish sheriff. They are listed as the new “spillionaires” who cleaned up while others were suffering from the spill.


Wayne Landry, the chairman of the St. Bernard Parish Council has admitted that “[t]his parish raped BP.”

The report notes that on contractor charged BP $15,400 a month for a generator that costs $1,500 a month. The one that was most striking to me was the allegation that the parish sheriff charged BP $1 million a month for a parcel of land that usually fetches $1,700. Sheriff Jack Stephens (left) and St. Bernard’s parish president Craig Taffaro Jr. (right), have been criticized in local papers as had for their use of such funds for friends and associates.

The report below states that the parish proceeded to spend on a variety of less than pressing projects:

Parish employees went shopping for cameras, printers, a file cabinet, staplers, six pairs of children’s scissors and 712 shirts emblazoned with the parish name. Some of the money also went to overtime pay for more than 40 parish employees, including three who claimed overtime for picking up dog food for the animal shelter. St. Bernard’s homeland security director, David Dysart, a salaried employee and Taffaro’s good friend, was paid almost $23,000 for working 497 hours of overtime in less than seven weeks. That meant he was working an average of more than 16 hours a day, including weekends.

What I fail to understand is why some of these obvious overcharges were not the basis for a criminal investigation into the alleged self-dealing, fraud, and corruption.

Here is the report by ProPublica

Jonathan Turley

14 thoughts on “Cleaning Up: Report Details Pattern of Overcharges By Louisiana Contractors and Sheriff For BP Oil Spill”

  1. Paul Molinary is a friend of mine and of my family for many years, as the real estate market crash and what effects took place in local parish government did to assist in hurting our real estate market, I asked Paul if he would let me advertise his boat skimmers for sale on a commission basis only to be paid should I find anyone interested. For the record here, I did not sell any but I do appreciate the opportunity to learn about new business potential when it is presented to me. I choose to work not get handouts. I resent the accusations here. Judy G

  2. Brief internet search turns this up:

    For a private demonstration and viewing of this incredible recovery vessel call and schedule an appointment. We can also customize to your special needs. Judy Giglio – Sales Representative (504-259-1873 Shallow Draft Oil Recovery, LLC Violet Louisiana, 70092

    And from the Louisiana Secretary of State web page:

    SHALLOW DRAFT OIL RECOVERY, LLC Limited Liability Company VIOLET Active

    Business: SHALLOW DRAFT OIL RECOVERY, LLC
    Charter Number: 40250398 K
    Registration Date: 7/12/2010

    Officer: PAUL MOLINARY
    Title: Member, Manager
    Address 1: 3300 DELILLE STREET
    City, State, Zip: CHALMETTE, LA 70043

    Something does not smell right regarding the demands of Angelina Geraci. Perhaps she will enlighten us.

    1. After review, it appears Ms. Geraci is the owner of SHALLOW DRAFT ELEVATING BOATS, not SHALLOW DRAFT OIL RECOVERY, a different company altogether. Please advise Ms. Geraci of the difference. The comments apply clearly to Shallow Draft Oil Recovery and not Elevating boats.

    1. Fromt the Secretary of State, State of Louisiana, Corporations Search Module.

      HALLOW DRAFT OIL RECOVERY, LLC Limited Liability Company VIOLET Active
      Business: SHALLOW DRAFT OIL RECOVERY, LLC
      Charter Number: 40250398 K
      Registration Date: 7/12/2010
      Domicile Address
      6013 EAST ST. BERNARD HIGHWAY
      VIOLET, LA 70092
      Mailing Address
      6013 EAST ST. BERNARD HIGHWAY
      VIOLET, LA 70092
      Status
      Status: Active
      Annual Report Status: Not In Good Standing for failure to file Annual Report
      File Date: 7/12/2010
      Last Report Filed: N/A
      Type: Limited Liability Company
      Registered Agent(s)
      Agent: CULLEN TONRY
      Address 1: 2114 PARIS ROAD
      City, State, Zip: CHALMETTE, LA 70043
      Appointment Date: 7/12/2010
      Officer(s) Additional Officers: No
      Officer: PAUL MOLINARY
      Title: Member, Manager
      Address 1: 3300 DELILLE STREET
      City, State, Zip: CHALMETTE, LA 70043
      Officer: BRADLEY CANTRELLE, JR.
      Title: Member, Manager
      Address 1: 6013 EAST ST. BERNARD HIGHWAY
      City, State, Zip: VIOLET, LA 70092
      Amendments on File
      No Amendments on file
      Back to Search Results New Search View Shopping Cart..

      and this

      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LiElJymjvis
      Uploaded by JGiglio1 on Jul 16, 2010 $225,000 Shallow water oil skimmer, all aluminum, state of the art skimmer, This skimmer has capability to skim 25 ft at a time, it measures 25′ x 8.6″x 37″ depth, holds 24 barrels of oil, features checker plated deck, 42″ rails, built in fuel tank, also includes (2) 38 HP Pro drive Mud Engines and a 27 ft. duel axle all aluminum trailer. For a private demonstration and viewing of this incredible recovery vessel call and schedule an appointment. We can also customize to your special needs.

      Judy Giglio – Sales Representative(504-259-1873Shallow Draft Oil Recovery, LLC

      All I know is what I just found yet again at the Secretary of State’s corporate database and what was posted on YouTube above.

  3. In reference to this comment posted on Sunday at 10:37pm: “Judy Giglio has worked for Shallow Draft, owned by Paul Molinary. Now actively endorsing Dave Peralta for Parish President, also a realtor and has reasons for the connected to win.”

    As the owner of Shallow Draft I am asking you to remove this post, since I have NEVER employed, or nor do I know who Judy Giglio or Paul Molinary is. Here at Shallow Draft we are not looking to take sides or use our company name in any advertising for any campaign.

    Also, we don NOT have any relation to the person who gave you this information. I do not want to give my resourse.

    Thank You & Please remove this post.

    Angelina Geraci
    Owner of Shallow Draft
    ..

  4. Wayne Landry, the chairman of the St. Bernard Parish Council has admitted that “[t]his parish raped BP.”

    While some and I say some of these allegations may have some truth to them, Mr. Landry yes he says it happened under his watch BUT he was the Chairman of the Council, the meetings held in the SAME building with the President who mind you had not committed any crime and at the oil spill command center. Mr. Landry said NOTHING during the entire two year period this was happening. He embarrassed his community nationwide when he should have been asking questions from the beginning. Why didn’t he? Please. Fishermen were complaining and they LIVE IN MR. LANDRY’S neighborhood.

    What this is/was is a PUBLICITY stunt to open up his bid for Sheriff. When you google Mr. Landry’s name the “spillionaire” story pops up. Mr. Landry is looking to control the parish with he and his friends. His campaign aid and friend Mr. Metzler has more experience than he does. He is looking to control the entire parish.

    2003 Wayne Landry ran for Senator and lost

    2008 Wayne Landry elected councilman

    2009 Wayne Landry Chairman of the Hospital Service district

    2009 to present Wayne Landry-St. Bernard Parish Mortgage Authority

    2009-10 Wayne Landry DID agree to Meraux LAND Hospital deal and said ITS A GOOD THING

    2011 Appoints former employee and friend to Hospital Service district
    2009 to present Wayne Landry-St. Bernard Parish Mortgage Authority

    2011 Wayne NOW want to be Sheriff with his friends running other offices

    2011 Wayne Landry embarrasses Parish country wide with BP rape statement

    Wayne Landry did not actively and loudly try to protect this parish from the racism claims landed against us because of stupid parish leaders who were not trying to be racist but rather trying to stop the rampant buying of damaged homes and glutting the parish with rentals in neighborhoods that were previously single family homes and overcharging outrageous rents (still happening).

    Wayne Landry did buy lots in Lexington Place (2006 right after storm) and now has approved permissive use permits on 3 of them.

    Wayne Landry pulled publicity stunt to try yet again to obtain a major role in controlling our parish. These are his friends running for major offices.

    John Metzler-see resume-friend of WL, campaign advisor, former employee SBSO

    Related to

    Paul Molinary-contractor who worked on Metzler’s interest in Barrister’s restaurant running for Parish President,

    Related to

    Gene Molinary relative of Paul, contractor and land purchaser running for assessor who will assess uh land who has done business with those who have bought MANY destroyed houses cheaply and have turned them into overpriced rentals in places that were single family neighborhoods

    2011 Wayne NOW want to be Sheriff with his friends running other offices

    2011 Wayne Landry embarrasses Parish country wide with BP rape statement

    Wayne Landry did not actively and loudly try to protect this parish from the racism claims landed against us.

    Wayne Landry did buy lots in Lexington Place (2006 right after storm) and now has approved permissive use permits on 3 of them.

    John Metzler-see resume-friend of WL, campaign advisor, former employee SBSO Related to

    Paul Molinary-contractor who worked on Metzler’s interest in Barrister’s restaurant running for Parish President,

    Related to

    Gene Molinary relative of Paul, contractor and land purchaser running for assessor who will assess uh land who has done business with those who have bought MANY destroyed houses cheaply and have turned them into overpriced rentals in places that were single family neighborhoods

    Dana Arcement-realtor-has interests in duh properties-Backing Landry- who has interests in property (no disrespect to Dana’s fight) but has an interest in Landry and his connections to WIN.

    Judy Giglio has worked for Shallow Draft, owned by Paul Molinary. Now actively endorsing Dave Peralta for Parish President, also a realtor and has reasons for the connected to win.

  5. “If I can’t defraud someone, how am I supposed to make money?”
    The new American Dream!

  6. http://www.salon.com/news/opinion/glenn_greenwald/

    Thursday, Apr 14, 2011

    The two-tiered justice system: an illustration

    By Glenn Greenwald

    Of all the topics on which I’ve focused, I’ve likely written most about America’s two-tiered justice system — the way in which political and financial elites now enjoy virtually full-scale legal immunity for even the most egregious lawbreaking, while ordinary Americans, especially the poor and racial and ethnic minorities, are subjected to exactly the opposite treatment: the world’s largest prison state and most merciless justice system. (end excerpt)

    … and vigilante “justice” becomes the norm…

  7. If BP agreed to those outrageous prices in a bid to avoid bad publicity or get equipment immediately, I’m not sure a crime has been committed. If the people involved were fraudulently trying to scam BP by presenting false reports of their actual costs then criminal charges should be brought.

  8. “What I fail to understand is why some of these obvious overcharges were not the basis for a criminal investigation into the alleged self-dealing, fraud, and corruption.”
    Really? You don’t understand why?

  9. “But in at least one corner of Louisiana, the dramatic differences can be traced in part to local powerbrokers.” -ProPublica

    A whole lot of this kind of thing going on all over this country…, with a little help from DHS and the like…

Comments are closed.