“Your Credibility with Me is about None”: CNN Trial Goes From Bad to Worse

In following the defamation trial against CNN by veteran Zachary Young, we have previously (herehere, and here) marveled at how bad things were going for the network.  It appears that they are getting even worse. This has been a brutal week as CNN figures, including host Jake Tapper, took the stand. If “this is CNN,” the judge (and possibly the jury) are not liking what they are seeing.

The report at the heart of the case aired on CNN’s “The Lead with Jake Tapper” on Nov. 11, 2021, and was shared on social media and (a different version on) CNN’s website. In the segment, Tapper told his audience ominously how CNN correspondent Alex Marquardt discovered that “Afghans trying to get out of the country face a black market full of promises, demands of exorbitant fees, and no guarantee of safety or success.”

Marquardt piled on in the segment, claiming that “desperate Afghans are being exploited” and need to pay “exorbitant, often impossible amounts” to flee the country. He then named Young and his company as an example of that startling claim.The evidence included messages from Marquardt that he wanted to “nail this Zachary Young mf**ker” and thought the story would be Young’s “funeral.” After promising to “nail” Young, CNN editor Matthew Philips responded: “gonna hold you to that cowboy!” Likewise, CNN senior editor Fuzz Hogan described Young as “a shit.”

As is often done by media, CNN allegedly gave Young only two hours to respond before the story ran. It is a typical ploy of the press to claim that they waited for a response while giving the target the smallest possible window.In this case, Young was able to respond in the short time and Marquardt messaged a colleague, “f**king Young just texted.”

In the last week, Tapper was seen on video by the jury and was mocked for claiming under oath that he “doesn’t pay attention to ratings,” a claim that could make him unique as a network host. While Tapper can argue that he was referencing the following of daily numbers, critics hammered him by showing repeated clips where he discussed ratings.

However, the most damaging testimony may have come from top producers who told the jurors that they opposed the modest apology given to Young on air. Since Young seemed to do well before the jury, the testimony of senior editor Fuzz Hogan, CNN correspondent Alex Marquardt, CNN producer Michael Conte, CNN’s executive vice president of editorial Virginia Moseley, and CNN supervising producer Michael Callahan undermined any effort to portray the network as seeking to amend a wrong or reduce damage to Young.

Arguably, the worst moment came with an argument by CNN’s lead attorney, David Axelrod. Axelrod introduced a document that he claimed was a smoking gun and showed that Young was a liar. Pointing dramatically at Young and waiving the document in the air, Axelrod declared that he had the proof:

“Plaintiff’s entire case, sitting right there, is that after the publications, he couldn’t get any work…Mr. Young knew, when he filed this lawsuit that he had entered into a new consulting agreement with a government contractor one month after CNN’s publication. This entire lawsuit was a fraud on this court. It was a fraud on CNN. This man knew it. I don’t know what they know. But when his came up in discovery, CNN’s counsel asked Mr. Young about the Helios connection, and he completely lied in his deposition. Over and over again, he made up some incredible ruse that Helios just had his security clearance because it was a company that held security clearances. It makes no sense. He knew at that time that he had a consulting agreement with Helios Global and he didn’t disclose it. It was an outright lie.”

However, it turned out that the document merely was Young’s application to maintain his security clearance.

Young’s attorney, Vel Freedman, later laid waste to CNN. He told the court that Young had lost his security clearance back in 2022 and that he hadn’t been aware of that until he double-checked after his testimony in the case. Freedman asked for the right to present a witness who would testify on the issue and Axelrod objected. Judge Henry had had enough and blew up at CNN. He read back Axelrod’s comments and said “You called him a liar multiple times there.” He told Axelrod that he owed an apology to the plaintiff. After telling CNN that “this isn’t Kindergarten, ” he added “Right now, your credibility with me, Mr. Axelrod, is about none.”

That is never a good thing to hear from a judge.

Axelrod apologized but the damage is clearly considerable.

The most chilling aspect from a litigation perspective? Axelrod replaced the earlier lead counsel who also imploded in court over ill-considered arguments.

None of this bodes well for the network. Alienating the judge is obviously never good, but it also could have a material impact if there is an award that CNN wants reduced by a order of remittitur. In addition, having top producers expressing a lack of regret and even opposition to the on-air apology could push such damages higher for a jury. Both sides are arguing that “this is CNN,” but these moments are building a more negative view of what that is.

Jonathan Turley is the Shapiro Professor of Public Interest Law at George Washington University. He is the author of “The Indispensable Right: Free Speech in an Age of Rage.”

297 thoughts on ““Your Credibility with Me is about None”: CNN Trial Goes From Bad to Worse”

  1. President Trump does Californians a solid! And, he ain’t even President yet! An excerpt:

    California’s Air Resources Board sent a letter on Jan. 14 to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, withdrawing its prior waiver request that would have forced a transition from diesel to zero-emission trucks in the state.

    The federal environmental agency responded to the board’s withdrawal request on Jan. 14 with notice that no further action will be taken, and the matter is considered closed.

    Regulators had previously requested in November 2023 that the agency approve a waiver to allow the state to enforce stricter rules for automobiles and diesel trucks.

    One state lawmaker said the decision to rescind the waiver request would benefit the state’s economy and noted the decision could be one of the other policy shifts seen soon as state agencies respond to a change of power at the federal level.

    “I think it’s great news. This is good for everyone,” Republican Leader Assemblyman James Gallagher told The Epoch Times on Jan. 15.

    “They’re waving the white flag because they couldn’t get the waiver approved before the Trump administration came in.”

    Highlighting the integral role trucks play in delivering many of the goods Californians rely on, he expressed concern that if only electric vehicles were allowed, costs would inevitably increase.

    https://www.zerohedge.com/political/great-news-good-everyone-california-abandons-regulations-phasing-out-diesel-trucks

    PS: Dennis McIntyre, tell Trump, Thank You!

    1. That is fantastic news. CARB already caused great mayhem in trucking. It unilaterally decreed that no medium and heavy duty trucks built prior to 2010 could be registered in the state. That affected trucking companies, and any business or individual that relied on larger vehicles. The company that pumps septic tanks in my neighborhood had to buy an all new fleet, which skyrocketed prices, and those trucks are not strong enough to drive up steep hills. The new engines are far less powerful. Truckers already had to buy new vehicles, because retrofitting to meet the CARB requirements just blew up their engines. This also affected people with horses who had medium duty trucks to haul.

      Thus, CARB already jacked up the cost of most goods and services, by requiring transportation companies to buy new vehicles that cost anywhere from $80,000 to $200,000, each.

      CARB was on a roll, and had determined to destroy the economy with that mandate for EV trucks.

      California has an unstable power grid. They shut the power off when there are high winds. In fact, my son’s school is still shut down due to no power. We rely on gas-powered generators, but Newsom banned those, too, beginning in 2028, if I recall correctly. Mandating electric vehicles will kill people. You can’t charge an EV during a power cut, and you can’t escape a fire if the car won’t start. I have asthma. If I suffered an exacerbation when there’s smoke (like every year) during power cuts, if I can’t get the generator started, I could always plug it into my car with an adaptor. With an EV, I couldn’t even do that. I live in an area without cell service. A generator allows us to have WiFi, and runs the pump for our well, during the day while we run it. Banning generators means people like me won’t receive emergency evacuation notices, and we won’t have water, and if we have an EV, we won’t be able to leave, either, unless we hike for miles through arid drylands. Western movies have been filmed in this region of California, so you’d be hiking out, through a wildfire, in the setting of a Clint Eastwood movie. It’s getting harder to find anyone who can work on a generator, as well, because with the ban looming, that industry is leaving the state.

      Democrat supermajorities have enacted policies that have been catastrophic.

      The decisions that Democrat Supermajority California have made in the past few decades have killed people. This isn’t just Newsom’s fault. There are thousands of people just like him, ready to take his place. No one should vote Democrat again in California for years, until or unless the party corrects course and becomes recognizable. It would also help if Democrats would cease the war on my gender, and female athletes. My gender is not just a state of mind.

  2. I often wonder what comment-section nasties like those who attack Prof. Turley and conservative participants did before there was the internet.

    1. Mary: The issue isn’t “the internet”–it’s MAGA–established by billionaires to spread disinformation and misinformation and to push back against mainstream media, telling MAGAs that mainstream media cannot be trusted while they attack Democrats and spread MAGA lies. Mainstream media doesn’t spread the message that MAGA media can’t be trusted–and that’s only all the difference in the world. Now, Trump has bullied social media companies into dropping fact-checking–why? It’s because he is a pathological liar. If you don’t even understand that basic premise, then you don’t know what you’re talking about. It’s not “nasty” to point out that Turley’s opinions are purchased by Rupert Murdoch, who has said he started Fox after the Watergate scandal because he believed that Nixon’s presidency could have been saved if there were alternative media to accuse Woodward and Goldstein of lying, of ulterior motives, or to just cast doubt on the truth about Nixon’s involvement in the break-in.

      1. Wrong. MSM is not to be trusted as they did that all to themselves. It is evident by viewers are switching off MSM. Why? MSM has been lying and gaslighting Americans for years. Americans know and see it. They dont need anyone to tell them. They are tired of MSM. They are switching to independent media, even willing to pay for quality content like I do with a subscription to The Free Press. Other independent journalists to follow are Matt Taibbi, Glenn Greenwald, Sharyl Attkisson to name a few.

      2. The MSM can not be trusted because IT is the largest ource of knowingly false information in the US.
        That is why they are not trusted.

        Trump has not bullied anyone – Slowly Zuckerburg is speaking out – the pressure campaign Facebook was subjected to makes what was done at Twitte look tame.

        FaceBook was Bullied – by the Biden administration. Hoepfully Zuckerburg will call in Weis, Taibbi and Shellenberg to do the facebook files.

        Factchecking would be great – if the fact checkers was not hyperpartisan woke left wing nuts with a lunatic agenda.

        Today they are no different than the Stassi.
        Good riddance.

        Nothing prohibits you from doing your own fact checking.

        I fact check you constantly – like in this response to your post.

        That is how “fact checking” is actually done in a free society.
        Individuals challenging each other, no one holding any special power or authority beyond their knowledge of the truth.

        “If you don’t even understand that basic premise”
        The basic premise of left wing nut fact checkers is ideological censorship.

        I would note that always happens when you give people power.
        Power corrupts.
        Absolute power corrupts absolutely.

        Getting the truth is hard work, you must do it yourself. You can not trust others with a vested intered to reach it.
        The best of us know we can not even trust ourselves and work hard to check our own biases.

        “It’s not “nasty” to point out that Turley’s opinions are purchased by Rupert Murdoch”
        It is not – it is nastyu to presume without evidence that Turley alters his oppinions because murdock pays for them

        Everyone in the MSM is paid – just like Turley. Most are NOT correct.

        “who has said he started Fox after the Watergate scandal because he believed that Nixon’s presidency could have been saved”
        Almost certainly true – Nixon was an angel compared to LBJ .
        Nixon was involved int he coverup of the watergate breakin – essentially seeking funding to represent the defendants.
        That is commonplace now. Democrats openly fund legal services for criminals.

        Nixon was a great president on foreign policy – but he was a disaster economically.
        He was domestically one of the most left leaning presidents in history.

        There was no “woodward and Goldstein” and there is pretty much no investigative journalism today.
        No one needed to accuse “Woodward and Bernstein” of anything just find the facts.
        Deep troat was a disgruntled ranking FBI official that Nixon passed over for FBI director.
        He had an axe to grind.

        “Now Watergate does not bother me, uh-uh
        Does your conscience bother you? Tell the truth
        Sweet home Alabama
        Where the skies are so blue
        Sweet home Alabama (oh, my baby)
        Lord, I’m comin’ home to you (here I come, Alabama)
        Speak your mind”

        Nixon had no involvement in the breakin.

    2. @Mary

      I can actually tell you, the mentality at least, is not new: if they weren’t rich, they stood on street corners with cardboard signs and shouted; if they were rich they funded other people who stood on street corners with cardboard signs. Or they stayed at home and wrote manifestos that no one would ever read. In spite of it all, I actually prefer things the way they are now; we know precisely who the psychos and unhinged are, and can make more informed decisions. It is astonishing or not, depending on one’s perspective, that so many of them are so high up in the everyday echelons.

      The saddest thing to me is that the modern left, particularly the young modern left, remind me more and more of people like the idiotic Aryan Youth movements of long ago, or the violent and brain dead activist groups of the 70s. There is no there, there, it’s only rage and madness, and it will fail again in our only true free country, as it has in the past.

      The difference now is the scale of the damage done by these psychotic clowns – it will take a long time to fix it, so stay stalwart. We do not get to relax yet, not even close. The years ahead, though better, will still be a phenomenal challenge. Likely for at least a decade or more.

      1. Mary: to fall for MAGA, you have to believe the following: 1. that it’s OK to grab women by the genitals, and that they will let you get away with it because you are “famous”; can you imagine Eisenhower saying something like this? 2. that it’s OK to lie when you lose an election, to claim there is widespread voter fraud, without any proof, to try to bully Secretaries of State to “find” votes you didn’t receive, to call your fans to Washington, D.C. to disrupt the certification of the election winner, to sit by, for over 3 hours, knowing that your fans are hunting down the Vice President with a noose, intending to lynch him because he couldn’t be bullied into refusing to accept certified votes, and to respond “So what”?; to get people to sign false Electoral College documents claiming that you won, knowing that you didn’t; and to refuse to back down when you can’t come up with any factual proof of widespread voter fraud; 3. to steal from a charitable foundation; 4. to dupe people into paying large sums of money to sign up for “Trump University”–found to be fraudulent; 5. to lie to the American people about being able to “immediately” bring down the cost of groceries, knowing you didn’t have any ability to do so, and taking advantage of the fact that Americans are worried about the price of food and don’t understand the complexities of economics that cause food prices to be high right now (they are coming down); 6. to steal classified documents, refuse to return them, lie about returning them, and hide them to prevent the National Archives from retrieving them–all because your ego causes you to resent being told you can’t have something; 6. to dodge the draft by faking bone spurs, and to call memebers of our military “suckers and losers”. These are just for starters. Do you believe these things? If you do, then you are a MAGA.

        Mainstream media publishes the truth about these and other faults of Trump, which is why MAGA media got started–to push back against his lies, to attack those who point out that he lies, that he is not qualified to be the leader of the free world, and get Trump elected. So, who’s “psycho” here–those who disclose lies, unpatriotic conduct, attacks on our military, theft of classified documents, and attacks on mainstream media that fact-checks stories before publishing them, or MAGA media? Part of the MAGA media indoctrination is to attack anyone who doesn’t agree with you or who dares to fact-check Trump–their message is that anyone who isn’t MAGA is “psycho”, lying, and so on. James speaks of “rage and madness”–the best example of “rage” are the late-night “Truth Social” tantrums by Trump.

        If you are concerned with the truth, as every American should be, then it ought to worry you that Trump has bullied social media CEOs to stop fact-checking him. It also ought to concern you that billionaires like Elon Musk have purchased the power to go around bossing members of Congress, contacting heads of foreign countries, or even being involved in government at all–Trump hasn’t even taken office yet.

        1. “can you imagine Eisenhower saying something like this?”
          No but I have no problem immaging him or JFK or RFK or LBJ or Clinton or Biden DOING that – because the did.

          It is OK to challenge an election – democrats do it all the time.
          We listened to you LIE about the 2016 election for a decade.

          It is OK to [protest an election – democrats do it all the time.
          It is OK to try to disrupt the certification of an election – there is video of democrats doing that all the time.

          There was no noose there was a rickey faux gallows that could not hand a teddy bear.

        2. The fact checkers are still free to fact check trump.
          All that is changes is that Zuckerberg is no longer paying them to do so.
          If you value thir politically biased nonsense – you pay them. No one is stopping you.

        3. Zuckerberg was YOUR billionaire until a few weeks ago. He contributed half a billion to rigging 2020.
          You lost in 2024 because Republicans were on to the fraud and deployed 260K election obeservers and 9K lawyers – almost entirely to 6 cities in 6 swing states that were responsible for the 2020 fraud.

          Zuckerberg has always claimed to be a free speech advocate. He hopefully has returned to “walking the walk”.

          How in gods name do you think Trump “bullied” Zuckerberg. ? He is the third richest man in the world.
          His worth is larger than the entire budget of DOJ/FBI

    3. Mary,
      They were in mental health facilities seeing a whole team of psychiatrists, medication, kept sharp objects from them and the occasional shock therapy. We would refer to them as “special.”

  3. I can’t believe the ignorance and stupidity of the commenters here, adolescent nonsense from people who think they’re smart. Pathetic clowns.

  4. Jonathan: I have a better case than the Young/CNN defamation lawsuit. This one makes the CNN dispute look like chump change.

    As you know this week DJT suffered three straight losses before the SC. For obvious reasons, you haven’t discussed any of them. So permit me to discuss the latest defeat, and it’s much bigger than the CNN case. It’s Sunoco, LP, et.al. vs City and County of Honolulu, Hawaii. In 2020 Hawaii sued big oil under state consumer protection laws for lying about the toxicity of their products. The case wound its way up to Hawaii’s SC court that upheld Hawaii’s consumer laws. In January of this year big oil file for a writ of certiorari before the SC alleging the Hawaii case was preempted by federal law. This week the SC denied the writ. At the time of it’s request for a writ big oil and right-wing groups, like Leonard Leo and the Federalist Society, launched a media blitz to try to convince the right-wing of the SC to should oil companies from the Hawaii lawsuit. Justice Alito recused himself from the case because he is heavily invested in oil stocks.

    Defending it’s lawsuit against big oil Hawaii stated: “Defendants have known for more than 50 years that greenhouse gas pollution from their fossil fuel products would have a significant adverse impact on the Earth’s climate and sea levels”. It’s like the consumer lawsuits against big tobacco years ago when the tobacco companies finally had to admit it’s products were dangerous to human health and they were forced to pay billions in damages. Hawaii pointed out that heat waves linked to climate change gave stressed Honolulu’s electric grid, and that a waste water treatment plant would need to be retrofitted against sea level rise at a cost of hundreds of millions of dollars. Hawaii wants big oil to pay for those retrofits.

    So the dam has been broken. Local communities and states can now bring lawsuits against big oil to make them accountable–to force them to compensate for the toxic environment they have created. Eleven state AGs and about 86 municipalities have filled similar lawsuits, like Hawaii, against big oil over the past few years. Now those lawsuits can proceed. That’s big oil’s biggest nightmare! I’m quite sure CA Gov. Newsom is preparing lawsuits against big oil to make them pay for the cleaning up and rebuilding due to the wildfires in SoCal which will cost hundreds of billions of dollars. Most climate scientists say these wildfires were exacerbated by fossil fuel induced climate change.

    The SC court’s ruling is a big blow to DJT’s “Drill, baby, drill” agenda. His campaign last year was “fueled” by millions in campaign contributions by big oil that thought it was buying protection from lawsuits like the one in Hawaii. Will big oil be asking DJT for a refund?

    1. OH, I hope the dam has been broken, and that “Big Oil” pulls completely out of Hawaii as a result! My guess is, within a week, Hawaii would dismiss its lawsuit.

    2. Thank you for posting your stupidity on a device that would not exist without fossil fuels you hypocrite.

    3. Jonathan: I have a better case than the Young/CNN defamation lawsuit. This one makes the CNN dispute look like chump change.

      Jonathan, my short Coles Notes version for your DJT MAGA audience: BBBBUUUTTTT… MUH TRUMP!!! BBBBBUUUUTTTT… MUH TRUMP!!!!! BBBBBUUUTTTTT… MUH TRUMP!!!!

    4. “Big Oil” from Dennis. I guess we will be hearing that one a lot more now.
      Now that the radical left can’t easily extort any more money and favors from Big Pharma, Big Insurance, Big Media, Big Tobacco (now Big Food and Beverage) for at least the next four years, listen to how the left’s rhetoric will change. Watch to see if all of the “BIGS” keeping pouring money into the MSM advertising to keeping them singing the left’s song and to keep them afloat. We should watch to see if PBS and the AD Council change their tune.

      Now that we probably won’t being buying as much solar and wind from China, will China keep funneling (laundering) money to the left. Hunter won’t being flying off to China anymore now that his pardon has time limitations.

      1. You know what bothers me about the Hawaiian lawsuit? It is racist, and by driving up the price of gas, it will have a disparate impact on minority communities. It looks like Dennis McIntyre does not want black people and brown people driving to, and around, his white enclave.

    5. Just because the liberal Hawaii courts ruled against oil companies means very little to the national landscape and has no impact on DJT’s winning agenda for the American people. As the liberal left continues to draw a kindergartener like cause-effect from the use of fossil toward climate change, the rest of the world is already past realizing the climate change hoax that the left has carried out, as SoCal burns. Geologists have also been demonstrating that global climate changes are hardly affected by the carbon dioxide emissions from fossil fuel use. They are proving that we are in a slight warming period from one of the coldest periods in the last 5000 years and it’s not bad for our climate. But the left continues to lie about climate change to scare Americans in order to line their own pockets. Gavin Newsome knew that the dams he removed had already built salmon accessible ladder runs but he had the dams destroyed for political gain and SoCal is suffering from his decisions and the failed policies of the Democrats. Wise citizens are figuring it out.

    6. The denial of cert is disappointing but expected, and ultimately not significant. SCOTUS rarely grants cert at such an early stage of a case. The outgoing solicitor general advised the court to let the case play out in state court, and then let any appeal make its way up the chain through the usual channels, and the court seems to have accepted that advice. That is all.

      The underlying case is completely frivolous, to the point where an honest court would sanction the plaintiffs’ lawyers for wasting the court’s time and burdening the defendants with the cost of preparing a defense. But there is no need at this stage for federal intervention; the defendants will have to waste millions defending themselves against this frivolous action, probably lose in a corrupt state court system, and then appeal to federal court and win.

    7. DM SCOTUS denied cert on an effort to keep the case from proceeding.

      There still is no actual decision. It is extremely rare for SCOTUS to stop any case no matter how meritless prior to a final decision in the lower courts.

      Despite conservative attacks on Roberts and Barret SCOTUS also refused to block Merchan’s sentencing.

      That was the correct decision. SCOTUS should not intervene unless and until all the lower courts get this wrong.
      It is not SCOTUS’s job to intervene in every bad lower court decision.
      We have appellate courts for that.

      There is no doubt that Merchan’s case will be thrown out.
      It is highly unlikely that SCOTUS will do so – because it is not likely to get that far.

      If it does THEN they will toss it.

      CO2 is an extremely minor Greenhouse Gas., The odds of Human CO2 having any effect on global temps is near zero.
      The odds of that effect being harmful rather than beneficial are even lower.

      3 times as many people die from extreme cold each year as extreme heat.

      Increased CO2 is a significant factor in increased food production.

    8. Nothing could wipe left wing nuts off the face of the earth faster than actually winning this nonsense.

      Lets just all stop using oil now.

      While your Global warming garbage is nonsense, even if it were not – everything in existance is both harmful and helpful depending.

      Lets stop oil now – and watch as hospitals shutdown, businesses shutdown and people starve.

      Right now it is 22F outside at my place – come by and you can spend the night in my yard. Oh and you have to give up your cloths because oil is used in their manufacture one way or another.

  5. Hmmmmm…
    The Associated Press reported that Trump officials had been grilling career civil servants in the National Security Council over their political leanings and donations.

    1. “The Associated Press reported that Trump officials had been grilling career civil servants in the National Security Council over their political leanings and donations.”

      Hmmmmm… why would Trump think American voters are both outraged and concerned that public employees working in the National Security Council could be leaking classified information to CNN in exchange for “gratuities” exactly like CNN paid as bribes to the 37 FBI agents hunting Trump in the fraudulent FBI Operation Crossfire Hurricane?

      Presented as our credible source commenting on their felony leakers working in the NSC, has the Associated Press apologized yet for the years they assured us the Russia Dossier was 100% verified US intelligence agency evidence?

      The Associated Press has apologized for assuring us the Biden laptop was nothing but a fraud, a Putin election campaign disinformation campaign?

      Anonymous Democrats who are honest want to know!

    2. Lol. Your “bigger case” will be laughed out of court. A frivolous lawsuit and waste of taxpayer money. The drilling will begin Jan 21st and once again, we will have affordable gas. Thanks, DJT, for making gas prices great again!

  6. If CNN acted as an honest institution and focused on honest journalism, I honestly don’t think that they would find their honesty questioned in such a devastating manner.

    Instead, here they are, paying the price, in ratings and in court, for their full-on mockingbird participation.

    F’em.

  7. With the cowardly Democrats here desperately deflecting to past presidents because CNN, the Hero Of Trump-Russia Dossier reporting, is YET AGAIN facing financial penalties for lying, I had what you would normally consider to be a bizarre thought.

    Democrat deflections to past presidents by George and others makes me marvel that Bribery Biden leads many of us to prefer the days when Bolshevik Barack was the president.

    The puppeteers serving as president for the Oval Office house plant formerly known as VP Biden still have a few more days to carry out actions intended to further wound this country before Trump replaces those puppeteers who have wreaked four years of the Reign Of Error And Terror.

    Old Airborne Dog

  8. Let the ass kissing begin.

    “Jeff Bezos — the second-richest person in America — owns Amazon. His Prime Video just announced it will spend a whopping $40 million for a documentary about Melania Trump, for which she is an executive producer, and stream it on Amazon Prime.”

    I can’t wait! Melania Melania Melania Melania Melania Melania Melania Melania Melania Melania Melania Melania Melania Melania Melania

    1. Let the ass kissing begin.

      Days Out Of Office, The Obamas Ink A $100 Million Deal With Netflix
      https://www.elitedaily.com/p/what-are-the-obamas-doing-with-netflix-they-have-a-multiyear-agreement-9157507

      You’re four years late, tens of millions of dollars short, and handicapped by the lack of at least a double digit IQ, Democrat commie.

      The ass kissing began four years ago with the instant multi-millionaire status Netflix awarded Bolshevik Barack and her husband Moochelle.

      1. Perhaps you missed the fine print…

        “Days Out Of Office”

        How much influence does Obama have when he’s out of office?
        trump will be president when Amazon hires his wife.

        Kind of a difference But hey, facts are hard to deal with, its way easier to ignore them.

        1. How much influence does Obama have when he’s out of office?

          Enough that Democrats had him pimping first for Biden in 2020, then again in 2024. That was before Democrats had him desperately switch to pimping for Harris by lecturing “the brothers” that they were deceived by their misogyny and absorbing GOP racism .

          But you missed all of that in your desperation to deflect off-topic.

          Fun fact: Melania Trump was NEVER in office.

          Other fun fact: Melania Trump was never feted and her thoughts and beliefs pushed by the mainstream media – the complete opposite of President Obama’s husband Moochelle.

          But hey, facts are hard to deal with, its way easier to ignore them.

          Well, you tried commie, you tried. Go pick up your also-ran participation medal.

          1. In 5 days Melania will be the wife of the President. I thought you were all angry because maybe, kinda, possibly Hunter Biden might have given money to his dad? Now the Wife of the President will be a paid producer for an amazon piece that about 5 people want to watch. But hey, facts are hard, BS is easy.

            1. Hunter Biden was nothing but his father’s bag man, collecting his bribes for him, in return for a 50% cut. Mrs Trump is not collecting anything on her husband’s behalf; she has an interesting story that many people will willingly pay to see. if Amazon has decided to make this show it’s because it honestly believes it will make a profit.

            2. Yes, she is being paid for the rights to her story and assistance in producing it.

              Not to get Ukraine to fire a prosecutor investigating Netflix.

  9. Meanwhile, outside the courthouse, other miscreants are facing armed citizens. An excerpt:

    With police forces overwhelmed by the enormous scope of devastation in Los Angeles County, residents are starting to take matters into their own hands, defying mandatory evacuation orders to instead guard their homes and their neighbor’s property with firearms.

    As we reported yesterday, losses from the wildfires in Los Angeles county are poised to reach $250 billion or more. Property isn’t only being destroyed — it’s also being stolen by brazen looters. The neighbor of one LA county resident gave a disturbing description of what was going on on their street: “There were like a hundred people that came up on scooters and were trying to get into any and all houses on this street.”

    https://www.zerohedge.com/weather/armed-la-residents-patrol-neighborhoods-violation-evacuation-orders

    1. Undocumented Democrats are setting the fires so they can clear out the neighborhoods and steal from unoccupied homes. That’s some of the explanation. Governor Nuisance is the rest of the explanation.

      1. Somebody here directed me to this video, which is TERRIFIC! It discusses a lot of the problems behind the fire. Shellenberger, at one point, discusses a focus group he conducted before the mayoral race. Latinos tended to ask sensible questions about the candidates. OTOH, as soon as the white folks found out that Bass was black, that was all they needed to hear, to vote for her. So, its hard to feel sorry fr

          1. The fire department is funded to effect miracles; the fire department cannot effect miracles.  

            The fire department was woefully and understandably ineffective against, and overwhelmed by, an “Act of God.,” the Santa Ana winds. 

            Private property development must be restricted to areas cleared of combustible foliage, which must be compelled by insurance company mandates. 

            Insurance coverage and development conducted in the free markets of the private sector must also compel “area fire sprinklers” as they have “home fire sprinklers.”

            Government has no power over private property; property is either private or public.

            Parties suffering damages enjoy the redress of litigation.

            Buffer areas cleared of foliage, and area sprinkler fire suppression systems, must be compelled by insurance company mandates.

      1. Yup, but they hurt their own cause. This disaster will set gun control efforts back 30 years. Before that, during the 1992 LA riots, the Korean grocery store owners set gun control back 20 years by showing the world how property is actually defended from looting, lawless mobs.

        The other way Dems hurt their cause is by passing unconstitutional gun control legislation at the state level. The challenges make their way up to Scotus which issues a pro-2A opinion binding on the whole country. But we’ve discussed that before on this blog.

    2. “Mandatory evacuation orders,” so-called “emergency” proclamations, and martial law are unconstitutional.

      It is unconstitutional to deny citizens their constitutional rights and freedoms. 

      Certainly Americans enjoy the freedom of movement and the right to peaceable assembly.  

      Violent assembly is unconstitutional and illegal, as is trespass. 

      Strict enforcement and prosecution would deter trespassing and theft. 

      The government may not arbitrarily declare dictatorship. 

      The suspension of habeas corpus would allow the government to exercise full control by way of indefinitely incarcerating opponents; that hasn’t happened. 

  10. “I’m troubled by all of this. I’m overly concerned with the level of professionalism, or lack thereof,” Judge Henry said, adding that both sides were at fault.”
    *****************************
    Well, the judge shouldn’t be surpised by Axelrod’s questionable tactics. He was trained at DOJ and the SEC, after all. Another litigation “rising star” hitting the supernova status and then fading quietly down to Earth. My money is on the Plaintif with an over-under of $15 million.

    1. What Turley isn’t mentioning is that the judge’s frustration is directed not only at CNN’s lawyers but at both sides for playing these games in his courtroom. Interestingly, it hasn’t been reported whether the judge has instructed the jury to leave the courtroom whenever he admonishes either side.

      Tapper’s deposition also addressed Fox News’ own defamation case, but Turley conveniently omitted the fact that Fox News is still liable for defaming Smartmatic. They face a $2.7 billion claim, and it appears this case will proceed to trial. I expect Turley will eventually discuss this case since it will be tried in New York, where he may claim favoritism from the judge and jury. However, he overlooks the potential issues arising from CNN’s defamation case being tried in heavily Republican Florida. Will the Republican judge and jury be impartial? Unlikely. How many jury members might be Fox News supporters? Probably all of them. Can you say bias to the extreme? Very likely.

      1. @George: How many jury members might be Fox News supporters? Probably all of them. Can you say bias to the extreme?

        Like Democrat bias in the extreme from New York and Washington DC Grand Juries and trial juries in all those Trump cases you always reference George? And deny exists!

        That’s one of your better self-owns, revealing you as the serial pathological Democrat liar and demagogue that you are, George.

        All to get in another BBBBUUUTTTTTT…. MUH FOX!!!!! deflection!

        WELL DONE GEORGE!!!! Nobody needs to expose you for what you are when you do such a good job of that yourself.

        Old Airborne Dog

      2. “Interestingly, it hasn’t been reported whether the judge has instructed the jury to leave the courtroom whenever he admonishes either side.”
        Because a failure to remove the jury would be reversible error.

        This is SOP. It is done in EVERY case.

  11. “I apologize if you feel…” is no apology at all, and the judge should have said so. The judge’s feelings have nothing to do with the duplicitous actions of the defense.

  12. The real CNN is being exposed in a courtroom. It is the National Enquirer of video network. Has nothing to do with “News”.

  13. I am watching Adam Levine testify. He is senior vice president of CNN. He comes off as ethical as a used car salesman; like he sold a car with a serious problem he knew about, but for which the price of the vehicle was not accordingly adjusted. It is as if he believes that lying about people is good for them, like paying top dollar for a junk car is good for a person’s character. Watching CNN leaves a person in need of a shower.

  14. Turls, trying to rattle the defamation cage as a distraction from, well, Fox’s defamation situation. The whole ‘look! Squirrel’ of it all?

    What I really wanna know is how long before Spanky sexually abuses Bondi in his office and will Elon be invited to watch???

    1. And Turls… don’t even dare accuse me of deflecting to Fox from CNN with a “BBBBBUUUTTTT…. MUH FOX!” left over from Senator Harry Reid, back when Mitt Romney was running for president.

      Your a traitor to our side, Turls, and I will be here every day to remind your readers of that.

      1. The good professor is not a traitor. He is a normal and sane traditional Democrat. He is just calling out the stupid and insanity of the woke leftists that have taken over his party. Just like Bill Maher has been for years now. Democrat strategist James Carville has called the woke leftists stupid. After the election, more than a few long time DNC members call that part of their party toxic. They want you to get off their side. The rest of us, Republicans, Independents, traditional Democrats are all cheering the good professor on. You prove the good professor correct with all your inane comments.
        How marvelous!

        1. Upstate: Turley cannot be a Democrat and work for Faux News, shovel the BS he shovels every single day, and promoting the endless culture wars nonsense that hooks the gullibles like you. Turley is not viewed as a “good professor” anywhere other than MAGAworld–but, that’s the idea–Turley is a “good professor”, so when he attacks Justice Jackson, Judge Chutkan and Judge Merchan, as well as mainstream and non-MAGA media, his one-sided and unfair rhetoric are supposed to be more credible. Ditto for defending Alito, Gorsuch, Kavanaugh and Barrett for overturning a Constitutional right that stood for 50 years and which they claimed they would honor. A big part of the ongoing MAGA movement is to undercut traditional media via MAGA media pounding out the message that traditional media cannot be trusted. MAGA media was established for the purpose of pushing back against the manifest unfitness of DJT, his endless lying, his Project 2025 agenda, all for those huge tax breaks and elimination of consumer protections and environmental regulations. MAGA media made up “wokeness” and “TDS”, to accuse people who comment about the absurd unfitness of Trump of being mentally ill. Now Trump has gotten social media to stop fact-checking, so the liess can spread like wildfire, and he also got major corporations to end DEI programs.

          You want to speak of toxicity? What could be more toxic to American values than Trump, a convicted felon, getting away with starting an insurrection that left Capitol Police Officers seriously injured with fractures, one missing an eye, several fingers lost, many with PTSD, concussions and some committed suicide, all because he refused to accept the will of the American people? No one who calls himself “Democrat” could conscience this conduct, much less try to spin the facts to defend it. How about getting away with stealing classified documents, lying about returning them, hiding them and lying about “mentally declassifying” the documents–something that is not real? How about falsifying business records to cover up liaisons with a nude model and porn actress, all while he “holds hands” with his former nude model wife who pretends that all of this is OK–an act to entertain the gullibles–to pretend that he and his former nude model wife legitimately belong in the White House? How about Bondi and Hegseth, who just parrot lines their attorneys told them to spout during their confirmation hearings instead of answering serious questions bearing on their qualification to be head of DOJ and DOD? Turley sold his soul, and that’s too bad because after Trump screws up royally, and those who voted for him finally figure out that he lied about bringing down the cost of groceries “immediately”, and who knows what other disasters await us because he has nominated conflicted, drunken unqualified people to run our most important government agencies based solely on their willingness to ignore their oath to the Constitution and to do whatever a stupid, malignant, vindictive narcissist demands, and whose failures even MAGA media won’t be able to explain away, Republicans will be voted out of office. However the stench of Turley’s advocacy for MAGA will remain. We won’t forget.

          1. @Gigi: Upstate: Turley cannot be a Democrat and work for Faux News, shovel the BS he shovels every single day

            For those who find entertainment in seeing and reading filth from CNN and Gigi, an alternate to Gigi is the much more comprehensive and coherent online presentation of the contents of the Bribery Biden laptop (that Gigi denies exists).

            All the filthy pictures and comments you could ask for, one click away: (remember to bring your eye bleach)

            Hunter Biden Laptop Online
            https://bidenreport.com/#p=231
            Given the explicit nature of the text and pictures of the Biden Laptop, this online publication of the laptop contents is for an adult readership only.
            ISBN: 978-1-7371866-3-2
            @2022 by ICU, LLC

            Gigi hates that, because the Biden Bribery Laptop is where she modeled for Hunter Biden following his promises he would make her famous.

            Old Airborne Dog

          2. Normal, sane, traditional Democrats want you off their side and out of their party. Bill Maher, who has been savagingly pointing out your stupid and crazy for years now, wants you off his side and out of his party. James Carville, who called you stupd, wants you off his side and out of his party. He thinks you are toxic. So do many other long time DNC members. The good professor, who has just been calling out the stupid and crazy, wants you off his side and out of his party. My own sister, who does not recognize the Democrat party anymore, wants you off her side and out of her party. Has nothing to do with MAGA. They want to get back to their traditional, JFK Democrat roots. We dont blame them! At lest they can define what a woman is and know full well biological males do not belong in women’s sports! The problem MSM has is they have embraced the same stupid and crazy and that is why people are switching them off. They are tired of your TDS. Dont call yourself a Democrat. That is an insult to real Democrats.

        1. Gigi doesn’t have a pussy. She has a gaping Grand Canyon that her crates full of vibrators cannot satisfy.

          1. And, people like you PROVE what critics of MAGAs already know–that Trump and Republicans are able to hook people like you who are not able to articulate anything resembling a cogent response to valid points because you blindly believe the lies that are fed to you daily by MAGA media. You also prove that you are uneducated, that you believe posting pornographic photos, resorting to gutter references to genitalia and other non-substantive responses makes you looke “cool” or proves anything other than the fact that you are ignorant and low-class.

            1. giggles, words like “articulate” and “cogent” are words you learned or at least refreshed from me. Only I had used them against you. Learn to develop your own style and vocabulary. I don’t own those words, but it is very clear that you are inspired by them after I use them.

            2. “able to articulate anything resembling a cogent response to valid points”

              What leads you to lie to yourself that you somehow or other manage to pull that off here once in a while? Articulit and cogent are two things you’ve never been able to get close to even faking.

              “you believe posting pornographic photos”.

              We know, we don’t just believe, the porno pictures of you that are found in the Biden Bribery Laptop were taken by Biden while you were posing for him. Not by somebody here.

              He promised he’d make you famous, he did, and now you don’t like the porn you starred in.

              The laptop content was created by Hunter Biden, not some poster here.

              Explain to everyone why you believe that readers here believe you’re educated, credible, and something other than ignorant and low-class back ally ass.

              You need to do that. Nobody here will do that on your behalf; everybody here thinks you’re the opposite: a vicious lying bytch.

              Old Airborne Dog

      2. Glad to know you’ll have a free second or two, I’d have never known given how much you want to lick my ass everyday.

  15. Thank you for reporting on this. It encapsulates everything about the modern leftist media: the are unapologetic totalitarians willing to destroy anyone who they disapprove. CNN needs to go into the trash can of media history! May Young get a multiple of the $450 million award imposed on Trump by the Stalinist NY AG.

  16. Your Credibility with Me is about None

    Professor Turley, using a metaphor to finally reply to the posts of his dear friend Dennis, Gigi, George, and that cowardly Anonymous Democrat who posts so obsessively here!

    Old Airborne Dog

    1. Says Old Airborne Dog who does exactly the same thing. Go home Democrat communist aparatchik wannabe. Putin has some medals to pin on your chest.

      BTW, when did you become a democrat?

      1. Says Old Airborne Dog who does exactly the same thing.

        I call out feckless, cowardly pathological liars like you George, who have zero credibility here. Yes, exactly the same thing.

        And like you, I can at times criticize some aspects of our host’s comments. But unlike you I can support and add to what he posts here in agreement.

        You NEVER agree with our host: every single column, Professor Turley is wrong and hypocritical, while you are always right and the very picture of standards and credibility.

        Go home Democrat communist aparatchik wannabe.

        Oh my! You’ll have no problem selling that here George!

        You will never be anything other than a Democrat serial lair and cheap fake American.

        Old Airborne Dog

        1. I’ve never been a democrat. Sorry to burst you bubble. You’re more of a democrat than I given how you complain like a woke marxist.

          BTW glad you can at least admit you are a serial poster like the rest of us.

          1. @George: BTW glad you can at least admit you are a serial poster like the rest of us.

            There’s a world of difference between being a “serial liar” and being a serial pathological liar like you are George. You don’t know that????

            I’m happy to confirm I’m a serial poster. But you won’t admit that you’re a pathological serial liar. Just as you won’t admit you have zero credibility as you post your lies here every day.

            What’s next? You’re going to claim in your defense that your abysmal third grade level reading comprehension is the excuse for you not knowing the difference between ‘serial poster’ and serial pathological liar?

            You’re a cheap fake human being on top of being a cheap fake American, George.

            If you could at least lie more convincingly than Biden, Harris, and the rest of the Democrats you defend, you might actually be a threat.

            Old Airborne Dog

Leave a Reply