Submitted by Elaine Magliaro, Guest Blogger
I’m sure most Americans are aware that former Alaska governor Sarah Palin has been on a bus tour along the east coast of the United States. What is the purpose of her tour?
Only Palin knows for sure. She did, however, provide people with her reason for taking this tour of historical places on her Sarah PAC website.
It’s interesting when (for the 100th time) reporters shout out, “Why are you traveling to historical sites? What are you trying to accomplish?” I repeat my answer, “It’s so important for Americans to learn about our past so we can clearly see our way forward in challenging times; so, we’re bringing attention to our great nation’s foundation.” When that answer isn’t what the reporters want to hear, we’ve asked them if they’ve ever visited these sites like the National Archives, Gettysburg, etc. When they confirm that they haven’t, it’s good to say, “Well, there you go. You’ll learn a lot about America today.” (They usually don’t want to hear that either!)
Last Thursday, Palin stopped in Boston for a tour of three Revolutionary War sites. She said she was “getting goose bumps’’ from all the history she was glimpsing in Boston. She added, “You’ve got to know a lot about our past in order to know how to proceed successfully into the future.’’ And thanks to Palin we’re learning history anew as she provides reporters with her version of American historical events when she speaks to them on stops along her way.
After visiting the Old North Church in Boston’s North End, she hailed Paul Revere and what he did on his “famous ride.” Here is how Palin described that event: …he who warned the British that they weren’t gonna be takin’ away our arms, uh, by ringin’ those bells and, um, makin’ sure as he’s ridin’ his horse through town to send those warning shots and bells that we’re gonna be secure and we were gonna be free. And we we’re gonna be armed.
Got that? Revere warned the British! That’s news to me. And to think that I thought for decades that Paul Revere had been riding around on his horse warning certain American colonists about the British. The archivist at the Cambridge Public Library doesn’t know what really happened that fateful night either. The archivist wrote the following in a blog post: “Paul Revere and his famous midnight ride is so much a part of the collective memory of the American Revolution that it is often forgotten that Revere was just one of several men and one woman who alerted the Minutemen of the impending British advancement.”
I guess the History Channel got it wrong too. Following is what I found on the channel’s website. It includes no mention of bells.
By 1775, tensions between the American colonies and the British government had approached the breaking point, especially in Massachusetts, where Patriot leaders formed a shadow revolutionary government and trained militias to prepare for armed conflict with the British troops occupying Boston. In the spring of 1775, General Thomas Gage, the British governor of Massachusetts, received instructions from Great Britain to seize all stores of weapons and gunpowder accessible to the American insurgents. On April 18, he ordered British troops to march against Concord and Lexington.
The Boston Patriots had been preparing for such a British military action for some time, and, upon learning of the British plan, Revere and Dawes set off across the Massachusetts countryside. They took separate routes in case one of them was captured: Dawes left the city via the Boston Neck peninsula and Revere crossed the Charles River to Charlestown by boat. As the two couriers made their way, Patriots in Charlestown waited for a signal from Boston informing them of the British troop movement. As previously agreed, one lantern would be hung in the steeple of Boston’s Old North Church, the highest point in the city, if the British were marching out of the city by Boston Neck, and two lanterns would be hung if they were crossing the Charles River to Cambridge. Two lanterns were hung, and the armed Patriots set out for Lexington and Concord accordingly. Along the way, Revere and Dawes roused hundreds of Minutemen, who armed themselves and set out to oppose the British.
Tim Murphy—snarking little fellow—wrote this in an article at Mother Jones: “We don’t mean to nitpick—we just think that if you launch a major publicity tour on the subject of great moments in American history, it might make sense to brush up on the details first. We can only imagine how Palin might try to spin this: ‘Listen my children and you shall hear, of the midnight ride of Paul Revere. If the story doesn’t sound like what you read on Wikipedia, you know who to blame: the elite liberal media.’”
It’s just not fair! Tim Murphy and other members of the “lamestream media” love to make fun of Palin. I don’t understand why. She’s only trying to give us the scoop on what really happened in our country’s past—just like Representative Michelle Bachmann of Minnesota. Thank heavens we have women so well versed in American history that they can enlighten us today with their knowledge.
SOURCES
Palin hits town to pick her spots, take her shots (Boston Globe)
Just passing through (Boston Globe)
Reminding Reporters, too, of America’s Foundations (Sarah PAC)
Sarah Palin’s Reasons for Bus Tour Misguided (Yahoo)
Paul Revere’s Ride, Reimagined by Sarah Palin (Mother Jones)
The Other Paul Revere: William Dawes’ Midnight Ride through Cambridge (The Cambridge Room)
Revere and Dawes warn of British attack (History.com)
@Buddha,
“And the Rove card is played . . . again.”
This is an attempt to counter my calling you out on your foolish playing of the Hitler card. An Ad hominem Tu Quoque logical fallacy.
“Combined with “an appeal to reason” when defending arguments – based in proven lies and distortions – it is particularly funny because you are using an appeal to reason to defend a manifestly unreasonable position, namely that Palin’s Imaginary History of the United States is factual when it is demonstrably not.”
This also fails the Otteray Scribe standard of this forum.
No, I say it is so because Elaine provided actual evidence from professional historians that shows you’re full of crap. As to your evaluation of my comments, I really don’t care about the evaluations of someone who learns history from the back of sugar packets at Denny’s and has the language and argumentation skills of a baboon on acid.
And the Rove card is played . . . again.
Combined with “an appeal to reason” when defending arguments – based in proven lies and distortions – it is particularly funny because you are using an appeal to reason to defend a manifestly unreasonable position, namely that Palin’s Imaginary History of the United States is factual when it is demonstrably not.
@Buddha, “Do you mean other than your blatant attempts to rewrite the demonstrated facts of history in support of a woman you then claim not to care about? ”
According to your pal Otteray Scribe, the only evidence you provide to prove this proposition is “because you say it is so.” Therefore, it is not so.
The rest of your comment fails the same standard.
Troll: In Internet slang, a troll is someone who posts inflammatory, extraneous, or off-topic messages in an online community, such as an online discussion forum, chat room, or blog, with the primary intent of provoking readers into an emotional response or of otherwise disrupting normal on-topic discussion.
I’m not sure that works here. My posts have definitely inflamed the delicate sensibilities of the commenters in this forum. However, my primary intent is not to provoke readers into an emotional response or of otherwise disrupting normal on-topic discussion.
Almost every response has been an emotional response, even though I’ve been trying to provoke dispassionate well-reasoned responses. Sadly, I haven’t gotten any. And, none of the discussion has been “on-topic” so there is nothing to disrupt. If anything, I’ve been trying to get the discussion back on-topic, i.e., away from emotional and/or irrelevant responses.
Actually, by this definition, you all appear to be trolling your own forum. Good luck with that.
What the Great Green One said.
“I bet you cannot point to any evidence that I have ‘demonstrated disingenuousness’ or ‘demonstrated a lack of logical coherence'”.
Do you mean other than your blatant attempts to rewrite the demonstrated facts of history in support of a woman you then claim not to care about? Because those acts alone show disingenuousness and a lack of logical coherence. Only the disingenuous would lie about history and only the logically incoherent would spend so much time defending a woman they do not care about looking ignorant when said woman is demonstrably ignorant of the facts. The very same facts that you attempted to rewrite in her defense, by the way. Argumentum ad ignorantiam compounded by ignoratio elenchi and a distinct argumentum ad populum directed at the ignorant that further boosts the initial fallacy of argumentum ad ignorantiam.
Nescirem vobis logica seu verum si paulum tibi.
OS, “kderosa, because you say it is so, does not make it so.”
And by the same token, just because you say it is so, does not not make it so.
Let’s apply your own standard to the rest of your comment.
This whole thread is about Sarah Palin and her outlandish account of Paul Revere and his famous ride.
The only evidence you provide to prove this proposition is “because you say it is so.” Therefore, it is not so.
Your continuing comments mostly fall into the “begging the question” category of non-debate.
The only evidence you provide to prove this proposition is “because you say it is so.” Therefore, it is not so.
So far, you have failed to argue any logical points. None. Nada. Talking points, snide comments and evasions interspersed with outright untruths which you seem to be convinced are true.
The only evidence you provide to prove this proposition is “because you say it is so.”T herefore, it is not so.
And arguing with you is like trying to argue with a fence post for all the good it does.
The only evidence you provide to prove this proposition is “because you say it is so.” Therefore, it is not so.
If you were one of my students or supervisees, you would either straighten up or flunk.
This is just your opinion. And God help us if you teach logic to these unfortunates.
@ Mike Spindell “However, I reserve those responses for people who have demonstrated capability to discuss issues with wit and sincerity.”
Since A logical fallacy is, roughly speaking, an error of reasoning., you somehow think it is wise to have your public ritings demonstrate your faulty reasoning. You’re a smart one, Mike.
“You have only demonstrated disingenuousness and lack of logical coher[e]nce.”
I bet you cannot point to any evidence that I have “demonstrated disingenuousness” or “demonstrated a lack of logical coherence” without relying on one or more logical fallacies or otherwise display faulty reasoning skills.
“In that case my only rational response to your nonsense is ridicule, when it amuses me.”
You’ve just contradicted yourself or are still laboring under the common misconception that ridicule is always a logical fallacy.
Let me spell it out for you so you don’t miss the point. You just stated that you reserve responses that aren’t logical fallacies for people “people who have demonstrated capability to discuss issues with wit and sincerity” which you then go on to claim I haven’t done. For me, you only respond with ridicule. But proper ridicule is not a logical fallacy. so responding with ridicule to me is something you claim to reserve for other people — smart people like yourself, apaprently.
You meant to say that your only rational response to my “nonsense” would be ad hominems in order to be consistent. Though spouting ad hominems is hardly rational or smart.
I wonder if there is a kid’s version of identifying and understanding logical fallacies that you might understand better than the grown-up versions.
kderosa, because you say it is so, does not make it so. This whole thread is about Sarah Palin and her outlandish account of Paul Revere and his famous ride. Your continuing comments mostly fall into the “begging the question” category of non-debate. So far, you have failed to argue any logical points. None. Nada. Talking points, snide comments and evasions interspersed with outright untruths which you seem to be convinced are true. And arguing with you is like trying to argue with a fence post for all the good it does. If you were one of my students or supervisees, you would either straighten up or flunk.
“@Mike Spindell, That is a very good example of an Ad hominem Tu Quoque logical fallacy. Are you capable of expressing anything that isn’t a logical fallacy?”
Quite capable, thank you. However, I reserve those responses for people who have demonstrated capability to discuss issues with wit and sincerity. You have only demonstrated disingenuousness and lack of logical coherance. In that case my only rational response to your nonsense is ridicule, when it amuses me.
@Mike Spindell, That is a very good example of an Ad hominem Tu Quoque logical fallacy. Are you capable of expressing anything that isn’t a logical fallacy?
“It is rare to find such concentrated blend of stupdity, obliviousness, and irony anywhere else.”
Very good. It’s refreshing to see that you have obviously delved into yourself and come up with an honest appraisal of who you are.
Now the hard part of change begins. Are you up to it?
@OS, I couldn’t care less about Sarah Palin and whether she gets elected. But what I do enjoy is skewering nitwits like you who attack her with ad hominems for being supposedly dumb and yet through their own words and debating skills clearly demonstrate that they are at least as dumb as she is. It is rare to find such concentrated blend of stupdity, obliviousness, and irony anywhere else.
kderosa, keep being an apologist for this woman who is the poster girl for the dull normal crowd. What does that say about those who would revise history to create an alternate reality so as to excuse her verbal gaffes?
mespo: No, Basil is like that all the time. He is the genuine article. I am not even sure if he drinks. There are a number of YouTube videos of him campaigning and being interviewed, but since we may run out of brain bleach, I will not post any more.
@OS, and I am also waiting for your simple acknowledgment that you are.someone who is way in over his head in this debate.
I suspect we both won’t get that ackowledgement for the exact same reason.
OS:
Basil Marceaux looks drunk to me.
I am waiting for a simple acknowledgment that Sarah P. is a woman who is way in over her head politically, and could not even exist on the national stage were it not for blind (and apparently deaf) followers. She is a dummy who cannot speak in coherent English, ad lib. I am beginning to wonder if she gets all that media attention just because of the entertainment value of her Mad Libs. Not just once in a while, but every time she opens her mouth.
But she is attractive, so that makes it all OK.