The Bells Are Ringing: Sarah Palin and the Revised Story of Paul Revere’s Ride

Submitted by Elaine Magliaro, Guest Blogger

I’m sure most Americans are aware that former Alaska governor Sarah Palin has been on a bus tour along the east coast of the United States. What is the purpose of her tour? Only Palin knows for sure. She did, however, provide people with her reason for taking this tour of historical places on her Sarah PAC website.

It’s interesting when (for the 100th time) reporters shout out, “Why are you traveling to historical sites? What are you trying to accomplish?” I repeat my answer, “It’s so important for Americans to learn about our past so we can clearly see our way forward in challenging times; so, we’re bringing attention to our great nation’s foundation.” When that answer isn’t what the reporters want to hear, we’ve asked them if they’ve ever visited these sites like the National Archives, Gettysburg, etc. When they confirm that they haven’t, it’s good to say, “Well, there you go. You’ll learn a lot about America today.” (They usually don’t want to hear that either!)

Last Thursday, Palin stopped in Boston for a tour of three Revolutionary War sites. She said she was “getting goose bumps’’ from all the history she was glimpsing in Boston. She added, “You’ve got to know a lot about our past in order to know how to proceed successfully into the future.’’ And thanks to Palin we’re learning history anew as she provides reporters with her version of American historical events when she speaks to them on stops along her way.

After visiting the Old North Church in Boston’s North End, she hailed Paul Revere and what he did on his “famous ride.” Here is how Palin described that event: …he who warned the British that they weren’t gonna be takin’ away our arms, uh, by ringin’ those bells and, um, makin’ sure as he’s ridin’ his horse through town to send those warning shots and bells that we’re gonna be secure and we were gonna be free. And we we’re gonna be armed.

Got that? Revere warned the British! That’s news to me. And to think that I thought for decades that Paul Revere had been riding around on his horse warning certain American colonists about the British. The archivist at the Cambridge Public Library doesn’t know what really happened that fateful night either. The archivist wrote the following in a blog post: “Paul Revere and his famous midnight ride is so much a part of the collective memory of the American Revolution that it is often forgotten that Revere was just one of several men and one woman who alerted the Minutemen of the impending British advancement.”

I guess the History Channel got it wrong too. Following is what I found on the channel’s website. It includes no mention of bells.

By 1775, tensions between the American colonies and the British government had approached the breaking point, especially in Massachusetts, where Patriot leaders formed a shadow revolutionary government and trained militias to prepare for armed conflict with the British troops occupying Boston. In the spring of 1775, General Thomas Gage, the British governor of Massachusetts, received instructions from Great Britain to seize all stores of weapons and gunpowder accessible to the American insurgents. On April 18, he ordered British troops to march against Concord and Lexington.

The Boston Patriots had been preparing for such a British military action for some time, and, upon learning of the British plan, Revere and Dawes set off across the Massachusetts countryside. They took separate routes in case one of them was captured: Dawes left the city via the Boston Neck peninsula and Revere crossed the Charles River to Charlestown by boat. As the two couriers made their way, Patriots in Charlestown waited for a signal from Boston informing them of the British troop movement. As previously agreed, one lantern would be hung in the steeple of Boston’s Old North Church, the highest point in the city, if the British were marching out of the city by Boston Neck, and two lanterns would be hung if they were crossing the Charles River to Cambridge. Two lanterns were hung, and the armed Patriots set out for Lexington and Concord accordingly. Along the way, Revere and Dawes roused hundreds of Minutemen, who armed themselves and set out to oppose the British.

Tim Murphy—snarking little fellow—wrote this in an article at Mother Jones: “We don’t mean to nitpick—we just think that if you launch a major publicity tour on the subject of great moments in American history, it might make sense to brush up on the details first. We can only imagine how Palin might try to spin this: ‘Listen my children and you shall hear, of the midnight ride of Paul Revere. If the story doesn’t sound like what you read on Wikipedia, you know who to blame: the elite liberal media.’”

It’s just not fair! Tim Murphy and other members of the “lamestream media” love to make fun of Palin. I don’t understand why. She’s only trying to give us the scoop on what really happened in our country’s past—just like Representative Michelle Bachmann of Minnesota. Thank heavens we have women so well versed in American history that they can enlighten us today with their knowledge.

SOURCES

Palin hits town to pick her spots, take her shots (Boston Globe)

Just passing through (Boston Globe)

Reminding Reporters, too, of America’s Foundations (Sarah PAC)

Sarah Palin’s Reasons for Bus Tour Misguided (Yahoo)

Paul Revere’s Ride, Reimagined by Sarah Palin (Mother Jones)

The Other Paul Revere: William Dawes’ Midnight Ride through Cambridge (The Cambridge Room)

Revere and Dawes warn of British attack (History.com)

831 thoughts on “The Bells Are Ringing: Sarah Palin and the Revised Story of Paul Revere’s Ride”

  1. @Buddha, I’ll respond to your increasingly tangential “arguments” as time permits.

    @Bob Esq. “What the hell was that?” That was my comments going over your head. Nice Simpsons reference, though.

  2. @Bob, Esq

    “There is little to no agreement between Palin’s representation of said event and the event as recorded in history books and Revere’s own writings on the event.”

    Here is my reply.

    Just because you say there is little to no agreement between palin’s representation of said event and the event as recorded: does not make it so.

    You need to establish that there is no agreement through historical factual evidence and argument based on that evidence.

    Right now, your statement is merely an opinion, a conclusory opinion at that.

  3. kderosa:

    @Bob

    You must not be Elaine’s friend, Bob. Friends always stick up for their friends against enemies. I am an enemy, Bob. You should be defending your friend, Elaine, against a mean enemy like me. It should be easy because I am very dumb and you are very smart. I am sure you are very brave, Bob. So, you must not be afraid to argue with me, especially since I am so dumb and arguing with me would be so easy for someone who is so smart like you. Perhaps, you are unable to defend the statements Elaine has made. Is that what it is, Bob? Please tell me, I won’t tell anyone. It will be our little secret. Hopefully, Elaine will also make her own arguments. But she appears to be hiding right now.

    Also, you lied to me, Bob. You said you were going to be polite. And, here you are trying to fool me into arguing your point first. I may be dumb, but I am not that dumb, Bob. Plus, you are being very mean by trying to fool me. Bad, Bob.

    Thank you gain for your invitation to argue about your chosen topic. I have accepted that invitation already. However, I offered you an invitation before you offered me yours. And, you accepted my invitation first. It sounds like you are very scared to go first, Bob. I thought you were brave, Bob. And, fair, Bob. Bit now you are being neither brave nor fair and trying to weasel your way out of defending your friend, Elaine.

    Default is a big word, Bob. I don’t want to default. Will I lose, if I default, Bob? Are you trying to warn me, Bob? That’s another new word I learned this week, I can’t wait to tell you what it means. Did you know that there is more than one definition for that word, Bob? Sometimes, people use warn, like when your mommy or daddy warns you to eat your vegetables so you will go grow up to be big and strong. Other times people use warn to make a threat, like when the bully warns you that he is going to take your lunch money or he will punch you in the nose. Ouch, Bob.

    Which way are you trying to warn me, Bob?”

    =================

    What the hell was that?

    Not for nothing, but the foregoing does not constitute an argument; and here I am taking seriously your claim about being an argumentation maven.

    Again:

    Palin: “he who warned the British that they weren’t gonna be takin’ away our arms, uh, by ringin’ those bells and, um, makin’ sure as he’s ridin’ his horse through town to send those warning shots and bells that we’re gonna be secure and we were gonna be free. And we we’re gonna be armed.”

    Given: Truth is the agreement between knowledge and its object.

    Arguing is reason giving.
    1. Reasons are justifications or support for claims.
    2. Rationality is the ability to engage in reason giving.
    3. The alternative to reason giving is to accept or reject claims on whim or command.

    Claim: Palin’s representation of Paul Revere’s ride is not only muddled but bereft of truth.

    Reason: There is little to no agreement between Palin’s representation of said event and the event as recorded in history books and Revere’s own writings on the event.

    Your reply sir?

    And do refrain from using the term Tu quoque; seeing you have little idea of what it means and when to raise the objection.

  4. Keep clanging that bell.

    “‘No. I admitted you failed in your attempt at rebuttal.’

    Once again, just because you say it’s so, doesn’t make it so.

    The attempt still stands, lacking your rebuttal.”

    I don’t have to rebut your arguments. Elaine already did. With facts and evidence I might add. The burden of proof is still yours to make. You saying Elaine’s evidence is insufficient without proof it is insufficient absent persuasive factual counter-proof, counter-proof you failed to provide.You can’t make your argument against Elaine or else you would have, so by all means, keep bloviating. It just further proves that you are executing the Big Lie tactic.

    “My rebuttal quoted from acknowledged historical sources. Those are facts, not merely my opinion or belief. Those facts are substantive proof. My facts trump Elaine’s and your opinion.”

    When facts are distorted, they are not substantive proof. They are lies based upon half truths. Your “rebuttal” was, again, nothing of the sort. It was repetition and insufficient evidence. Evidence insufficient because you tried to twist it to mean what you wanted it to mean instead of what it actually meant. Lies are lies. That’s how that works whether you like it or not, propagandist. Repetition does not make them true. Elaine’s evidence was supported by better proof than yours and you saying “uh uh” is not an opinion, but rather a fact. Tell me that’s an opinion again though. That never ceases to be funny when someone says lies trump facts.

    “Godwin’s law didn’t make your quote into a logical fallacy. Godwin’s law just made you look silly. Your argument was a logical fallacy for another reason.”

    Really. And what was that other reason? That is was accurate in describing your tactic? Awwwwww. That’s not a fallacy. That’s just you being busted. That you can’t believe you got busted using the tactic of choice for the Nazi regime is your problem and your denial. But it wasn’t a fallacy of any sort. If it was? Prove it. You can’t, but you are welcome to try.

    By the way, “irregardless” is indeed a word although it is non-standard and colloquial to 20th Century American English. See Websters if you disagree. When I use non-standard English, unlike you, I know I am using non-standard English, Mr. Doesn’t Know What A Possessive Adjective Is. Change the word to the standard “regardless” and the meaning is still the same, propagandist. Unlike you, I’m not working off a script.

    Now about the dissection of your tactic . . . it still stands.

    But please, keep coming back to beat your dead horse and further cement that you are engaging in propaganda about a woman you don’t care about and whose being wrong is irrelevant. If you truly don’t care about her and her being wrong is irrelevant? Why bother? Hmmm? As Mike S. says, you are simply a sad case involved in mental masturbation if you are not paid to make yourself look like a fool. If you are being paid to be a propagandist, you are only succeeding in making yourself look like a fool and taking money from an employer who is not getting their value for their dollar. Propaganda to be effective must not be recognized as propaganda. You simply lack the skills to accomplish that end in this forum.

    Run along now, Goebbels Jr.

    Your jig is up.

  5. @ Mike Spindell

    “I would have to say that this is giving you some modicum of pleasure and if so that is only a further indictment of your temperament.”

    I am enjoying this immensely. And, I am doing it for the pure enjoyment of making you look as foolish as possible.

    No doubt that is a character flaw of mine. I’ll get over it.

    I must say, reading back over this thread just now, the arguments were quite sane prior to me and a few other posters started apprising you of the historical facts that had been overlooked. (I even almost agreed with Bob Esq. arguments re the propriety of governmental discrimination for seemingly beneficial desires, like affirmative action.) But, then the crazy really started shining through and teh quality of the arguments plummeted. It’s amazing how some people get so unhinged when their world view gets questioned.

    Note: Fourth invokement of Godwin’s law. Nice job, Mike.

  6. @Buddha,

    “No. I admitted you failed in your attempt at rebuttal.”

    Once again, just because you say it’s so, doesn’t make it so.

    The attempt still stands, lacking your rebuttal.

    “Elaine’s evidence was found valid and persuasive. Yours was not. The burden of proof to persuade the audience otherwise is yours to make.”

    These are merely statements of opinion. And, you are entitled to your opinion as to what was persuasive, no matter how ill-informed.

    But, your opinion is not a fact. And you are claiming that Palin lied, was dishonest amd wrong as a matter of fact.

    You don’t get to say that based solely on your opinion.

    My evidence contradicts Elaine’s statements which are unsupported by evidence. So at this point you are basically just agreeing with Elaine’s opinion. Opinion based on opinion. Like anyone cares about that.

    “Just so, your belief – which is what you stated since your “rebuttal” was absent any substantive proof – does not constitute a valid rebuttal.”

    My rebuttal quoted from acknowledged historical sources. Those are facts, not merely my opinion or belief. Those facts are substantive proof. My facts trump Elaine’s and your opinion.

    You can believe that the earth is flat. But we know for a fact that the earth is round and not flat. You are entitled to your flat-earth opinion, but as a matter of fact you are incorrect. That’s how it works, whether you like it or not.

    “And Godwin’s Law, even if it applied, is not a logical fallacy per se. It is only a logical fallacy when it is untrue by the forms of true formal and informal logical fallacies.”

    Godwin’s law didn’t make your quote into a logical fallacy. Godwin’s law just made you look silly. Your argument was a logical fallacy for another reason.

    The rest of your argument re Godwin’s law and The Big Lie, while facinating, are off point. Your arguments re Gidwin’s law and noe The Big Lie are logical fallacies for another reason. I’ll leave that to you to figure out.

    And by the way, “irregardless” isn’t a word, jerky.

  7. Buddha has analyzed your methods correctly and they directly correllate with your actions here. so you are a NAZI in technique, if not in political sympathy. That explains the question of why after 392 comments and no one agreeing with you, you persist. If you were being paid (by the comment no doubt)then one could see your persistence as chasing a buck, which is probably dear to one having your limited skill set. However, if you are unpaid then you are simply suffering from a pathology of one sort, or another. In either case your performance and you are pathetic in their content.
    I would have to say that this is giving you some modicum of pleasure and if so that is only a further indictment of your temperament.

    Your arguments are fallacious and have been directly rebutted with
    boring frequency. Yet you persist in your written masturbation. Do you realize what a sad case you are? I can find no anger in dealing with you, only pity for how you need to gratify yourself.

  8. “So then you admit there is at least one outstanding rebuttal.”

    No. I admitted you failed in your attempt at rebuttal.

    “You also contend that I “offered insufficient evidence”

    Again, as per the Otteray Standard, just because you say I offered insufficient evidence, doesn’t make it so.

    You need to demonstrate/prove that the evidence is insufficient.”

    No, I don’t. Elaine’s evidence was found valid and persuasive. Yours was not. The burden of proof to persuade the audience otherwise is yours to make.

    “Your “belief” does not constitute a rebuttal. (I believe you are an ignorant jackass, does that make it so?) Just because you say I am “demonstrably and manifestly wrong in your facts” doesn’t make it so. Palin being wrong is irrelevant.”

    Just so, your belief – which is what you stated since your “rebuttal” was absent any substantive proof – does not constitute a valid rebuttal. It constitutes you repeating yourself. As to your belief about me? I could really give a rat’s ass because that’s merely your belief – an opinion. I don’t base by sense of self worth on the opinions of propagandists. I know – and this thread demonstrates – that you are a propagandist. That you say ” Palin being wrong is irrelevant” merely confirms this as it shows you are distributing propaganda in support of a position and a person you find to be irrelevant, yet you persist in your attempt at the Big Lie anyway and compound the matter by using other propagandist techniques (poorly I might add) in your attempts to give yourself an out that saves some sort of credibility for yourself now that you have been busted.

    And Godwin’s Law, even if it applied, is not a logical fallacy per se. It is only a logical fallacy when it is untrue by the forms of true formal and informal logical fallacies.

    “never allow the public to cool off;” – Yep. You keep coming back for more irregardless of the fact that you’ve failed to persuade anyone that you are correct.

    “never admit a fault or wrong;” – Neither yours or Palin’s except when you carelessly admitted that you think Palin being wrong is irrelevant. If someone is paying you to do this, they are not getting their money’s worth.

    “never concede that there may be some good in your enemy;” – Yep. Palin supporters good, people with actual facts bad.

    “never leave room for alternatives;” – That has been your contention from the start – you’re right (absent proof even) and everyone else is wrong . . . except for Palin who is right, but now somehow irrelevant? Pst! Never ever try to defend yourself in court. You lack the logical skills and consistency to do so successfully.

    “never accept blame;” – You don’t accept blame for your failure to convince and this is evidenced by your denials that the burden of proof is yours to make.

    “concentrate on one enemy at a time and blame him for everything that goes wrong;” – Duh. Just like you are trying to blame me for your choice of tactics blowing up in your face.

    “people will believe a big lie sooner than a little one;” – This is where you fail. Your lie isn’t big enough – it was easily debunked and we are not most people when it comes to persuasive speech.

    “and if you repeat it frequently enough people will sooner or later believe it” – And you fail because we don’t believe repeated lies are the truth around these parts. We demand proof of claim and valid evidence to support said claims.

    So you see, demonstrably you have deployed the tactic of the Big Lie, that you failed at it is another matter, but it is not a logical fallacy of any sort irregardless of the fact that Hitler perfected the technique you have so miserably failed to deploy. Godwin’s Law? Hardly. More like an accurate assessment of your performance. As it is accurate, it is true, thus making Godwin’s Law inapplicable as there is no other fallacy upon which you can rely to assert that the comparison of your technique to the one perfected by Hitler is flawed logically or factually.

  9. @Buddha

    “You didn’t post rebuttals. You repeated yourself and offered insufficient evidence.”

    So then you admit there is at least one outstanding rebuttal.

    You also contend that I “offered insufficient evidence”

    Again, as per the Otteray Standard, just because you say I offered insufficient evidence, doesn’t make it so.

    You need to demonstrate/prove that the evidence is insufficient. And if you can manage to do that, I will respond by either providing additional evidence, revise my argument, explain to you why you are not correct with supporting evidence, or with withdraw my rebuttal.

    “The problem here is that no one believes you because you’re demonstrably and manifestly wrong in your facts. Just as Palin was wrong.”

    Your “belief” does not constitute a rebuttal. (I believe you are an ignorant jackass, does that make it so?) Just because you say I am “demonstrably and manifestly wrong in your facts” doesn’t make it so. Palin being wrong is irrelevant.

    “And you can attempt to call the Propagandist Card the Hitler Card [blah blah blah …]”

    It’s still a logical fallacy and is therefore irrelevant to any argument you’re trying to make.

  10. You didn’t post rebuttals. You repeated yourself and offered insufficient evidence. That’s not a rebuttal. That’s repeating yourself. As in ““If you tell a lie that’s big enough, and you tell it often enough, people will believe you are telling the truth, even when what you are saying is total crap.” The problem here is that no one believes you because you’re demonstrably and manifestly wrong in your facts. Just as Palin was wrong.

    And you can attempt to call the Propagandist Card the Hitler Card all you want too. It won’t change the fact that you have deployed a propaganda tactic perfected by the man. Like I said, if you have a problem with the exemplar of the tactic, then the fault is entirely yours for deploying his tactic. However it appears that you like whine with your propagandist cheese so you keep on bitching about it. That’s even funnier.

  11. @Buddha, that would be the third playing of the Hitler card.

    I don’t need to comment on your repeated playings of the Hitler card since the playing of that card (and the propogandist card) is a logical fallacy.

    “Also, the burden of proof in refuting Elaine’s presentation of facts lies with you, which you have failed to do.”

    And my burden of proof was satisified when I psoted the rebuttals. Now the burden of prood lies with you to rebut my rebuttal with arguments that don’t rely on logical fallacies and that are supported with evidence. When you accomplish that, I will either agree with you and withdraw my rebuttal or I will rebut your rebuttal. That’s how argument works.

    So until you substantively respond to my rebuttal, it stands as proven with your acquiescence.

  12. Here is Red State Update where Jackie and Dunlap cover stuff that is about as relevant as the troll on this thread. Or Sarah Palin, for that matter.

    And a lot funnier.

  13. Also, the burden of proof in refuting Elaine’s presentation of facts lies with you, which you have failed to do.

  14. If you object to the propagandist in question as the exemplar of your tactic, then perhaps you shouldn’t have chosen a tactic perfected by him. You made your own bed in your tactical selection. It’s not my fault you chose to sleep with Hitler.

    Flail some more.

    It’s funny.

  15. @Buddha,

    “Ex[cep]t I didn’t play the Hitler card, nitwit. I played the propagandist card. Which you’ve done an excellent job in proving was the correct card.”

    You did play the Hitler card, nitwit. The propogandist you chose was Hitler.

  16. @Buddha,

    “No, I say it is so because Elaine provided actual evidence from professional historians that shows you’re full of crap.”

    Actually, she didn’t. I rebutted those supposed displays of evidence and no one has attempted to respond or rebut my rebuttals. So, you’re still at the “because you say it is so” stage.

  17. Expect I didn’t play the Hitler card, nitwit. I played the propagandist card. Which you’ve done an excellent job in proving was the correct card.

    BZZZZZZZZZ! Sorry, but you won’t moving on to the final round.

    Try again though if you like.

    It’s funny.

Comments are closed.