The Bells Are Ringing: Sarah Palin and the Revised Story of Paul Revere’s Ride

Submitted by Elaine Magliaro, Guest Blogger

I’m sure most Americans are aware that former Alaska governor Sarah Palin has been on a bus tour along the east coast of the United States. What is the purpose of her tour? Only Palin knows for sure. She did, however, provide people with her reason for taking this tour of historical places on her Sarah PAC website.

It’s interesting when (for the 100th time) reporters shout out, “Why are you traveling to historical sites? What are you trying to accomplish?” I repeat my answer, “It’s so important for Americans to learn about our past so we can clearly see our way forward in challenging times; so, we’re bringing attention to our great nation’s foundation.” When that answer isn’t what the reporters want to hear, we’ve asked them if they’ve ever visited these sites like the National Archives, Gettysburg, etc. When they confirm that they haven’t, it’s good to say, “Well, there you go. You’ll learn a lot about America today.” (They usually don’t want to hear that either!)

Last Thursday, Palin stopped in Boston for a tour of three Revolutionary War sites. She said she was “getting goose bumps’’ from all the history she was glimpsing in Boston. She added, “You’ve got to know a lot about our past in order to know how to proceed successfully into the future.’’ And thanks to Palin we’re learning history anew as she provides reporters with her version of American historical events when she speaks to them on stops along her way.

After visiting the Old North Church in Boston’s North End, she hailed Paul Revere and what he did on his “famous ride.” Here is how Palin described that event: …he who warned the British that they weren’t gonna be takin’ away our arms, uh, by ringin’ those bells and, um, makin’ sure as he’s ridin’ his horse through town to send those warning shots and bells that we’re gonna be secure and we were gonna be free. And we we’re gonna be armed.

Got that? Revere warned the British! That’s news to me. And to think that I thought for decades that Paul Revere had been riding around on his horse warning certain American colonists about the British. The archivist at the Cambridge Public Library doesn’t know what really happened that fateful night either. The archivist wrote the following in a blog post: “Paul Revere and his famous midnight ride is so much a part of the collective memory of the American Revolution that it is often forgotten that Revere was just one of several men and one woman who alerted the Minutemen of the impending British advancement.”

I guess the History Channel got it wrong too. Following is what I found on the channel’s website. It includes no mention of bells.

By 1775, tensions between the American colonies and the British government had approached the breaking point, especially in Massachusetts, where Patriot leaders formed a shadow revolutionary government and trained militias to prepare for armed conflict with the British troops occupying Boston. In the spring of 1775, General Thomas Gage, the British governor of Massachusetts, received instructions from Great Britain to seize all stores of weapons and gunpowder accessible to the American insurgents. On April 18, he ordered British troops to march against Concord and Lexington.

The Boston Patriots had been preparing for such a British military action for some time, and, upon learning of the British plan, Revere and Dawes set off across the Massachusetts countryside. They took separate routes in case one of them was captured: Dawes left the city via the Boston Neck peninsula and Revere crossed the Charles River to Charlestown by boat. As the two couriers made their way, Patriots in Charlestown waited for a signal from Boston informing them of the British troop movement. As previously agreed, one lantern would be hung in the steeple of Boston’s Old North Church, the highest point in the city, if the British were marching out of the city by Boston Neck, and two lanterns would be hung if they were crossing the Charles River to Cambridge. Two lanterns were hung, and the armed Patriots set out for Lexington and Concord accordingly. Along the way, Revere and Dawes roused hundreds of Minutemen, who armed themselves and set out to oppose the British.

Tim Murphy—snarking little fellow—wrote this in an article at Mother Jones: “We don’t mean to nitpick—we just think that if you launch a major publicity tour on the subject of great moments in American history, it might make sense to brush up on the details first. We can only imagine how Palin might try to spin this: ‘Listen my children and you shall hear, of the midnight ride of Paul Revere. If the story doesn’t sound like what you read on Wikipedia, you know who to blame: the elite liberal media.’”

It’s just not fair! Tim Murphy and other members of the “lamestream media” love to make fun of Palin. I don’t understand why. She’s only trying to give us the scoop on what really happened in our country’s past—just like Representative Michelle Bachmann of Minnesota. Thank heavens we have women so well versed in American history that they can enlighten us today with their knowledge.

SOURCES

Palin hits town to pick her spots, take her shots (Boston Globe)

Just passing through (Boston Globe)

Reminding Reporters, too, of America’s Foundations (Sarah PAC)

Sarah Palin’s Reasons for Bus Tour Misguided (Yahoo)

Paul Revere’s Ride, Reimagined by Sarah Palin (Mother Jones)

The Other Paul Revere: William Dawes’ Midnight Ride through Cambridge (The Cambridge Room)

Revere and Dawes warn of British attack (History.com)

831 thoughts on “The Bells Are Ringing: Sarah Palin and the Revised Story of Paul Revere’s Ride”

  1. @buddha “I’m an anti-propagandist” because I say I am even though I happen to be using propagandist techniques according to my own definitions, because when I use those techniques they aren’t propagandist techniques because I am not a propagandist because I say I’m not.

    And around and around we go.

    I’m getting dizzy from all this repeated circular reasoning of yours.

  2. Mike Spindell’s Guide to Argument

    Rule 1: Never make sense.

    Rule 2: Use convoluted sports analogies to make irrelevant points, especially if you want to back-handedly concede a point to your opponent.

    Rule 3: Always agree with Buddha. Cheerlead Buddha as much as possible because looking like Buddha’s sycophant is highly desirable.

    Rule 4: If you mistakenly stumble upon a point that turns out to be relevant to the debate, immediate’y retreat and go back to taking irrelevant potshots and making lame sports analogies.

    Rule 5. Copy your opponent’s ridicule and use it in unoriginal attempt to ridicule him back in a similar, though lamer, manner. Bonus If you can sneak in a convoluted sports analogy.

    Rule 6: Never worry if following Rules 1-5 make you look stupid. Always act as though you’ve made the most profound point in the world even though this makes you look more stupid.

  3. I’m an anti-propagandist. That has been an explicit part of role here for a very long time. If you had been familiar with this forum instead of jumping in blindly, you would have known that in advance. Being an anti-propagandist is part of what I’m known for in these parts. That you’re upset because I can use your own tools against you is not exactly a surprise either. I’ve done it here before and I’ll do it again. I’ve even had professional propagandists publicly offer me jobs here in an effort to silence me. It’s all part of giving people the necessary skills required to recognize and defuse your brand of nonsense whenever and wherever they see it.

    But please, continue to focus on me and blame me for your failures.

    Repeating the same action over and over in the face of failure is considered by most people to be a sign of insanity and in the case of failing propagandists it is simply funnier than Hell.

  4. Buddha’s Guide to Using the Propagandist/Big Lie Ad Hominem in the Way that Propagandist Would (While Being Oblivious to the Irony of Accusing Someone Else of Being a Propagandist While Using Propandist Techniques Yourself)

    Rule 1: Buddha is always right no matter what.

    Rule 2: Anyone who disagrees with Buddha must be wrong because only one person can be right and Buddha is always right. All evidence or proof presented by Buddha’s opponents is invalid evidence and can be dismissed out of hand by Buddha because Bussha never believes it. If Buddha believed this evidence or proof, he might be wrong, but Buddha is always right. See Rule 1.

    Rule 3: Buddha’s opponent is not only wrong, but also a liar because Buddha’s opponent knew or should have known that he was wrong because it is always wrong to disagree with Buddha who is always right. See Rule 1.

    Rule 4: Since Buddha’s opponent is a liar, everything Buddha’s opponent claims is a lie, even demonstrable accurate claims. This is important for Rule 11 below.

    Rule 5: Buddha and his half-dozen cohorts (lol) are the public and they never cool off when engaged in an argument with one of their hated opponents. Therefore, anyone who argues with Buddha “never allows the public to cool off.”

    Rule 6: Since Buddha is always right, his opponents are always wrong and/or at fault. But, Buddha’s opponents “never admit a fault or wrong.” Even when Buddha’s opponents do admit fault it is merely a careless error on their part.

    Rule 7: It is good to be right. Buddha is always right, so Buddha is also good. But, Buddha’s opponents “never concede that there may be some good in” Buddha even though Buddha is clearly good.

    Rule 8: Since Buddha is always right, Buddha’s viewpoint is always a valid alternate viewpoint with which his opponents must always agree. But, Buddha’s opponents never agree with Buddha, and so Buddha’s opponents “never leave room for alternatives.”

    Rule 9: Since Buddha is always right, he is never convinced by his opponent’s arguments. And Buddha’s opponents “never accept blame” for failing to convince Buddha.

    Rule 10: Since Buddha is always right and never convinced by his opponents, Buddha’s opponents’ attempts at convincing Buddha always blow up in their faces. And since Buddha is only one enemy, his opponents always “concentrate on one enemy at a time and blame him for everything that goes wrong” with their arguments that always fail to convince Buddha, even when they have never explicitly blamed Buddha for anything.

    Rule 11: Buddha’s opponent’s lies are always failed Big Lies because Buddha says they are. They cannot be “Big Lies” because “people will believe a big lie sooner than a little one” and Buddha, who is a smart person, never believes his opponent’s lies. This puts Buddha in a tight logical spot because his opponent’s lies are not BIG Lies becasue Buddha, a public person, hasn’t believed them and they cannot be LITTLE lies because then Buddha’s opponents would not be propagandists. Therefore, Buddha’s opponent’s lies are always failed Big Lies according to Buddha (See Rule 1 again). Buddha is now out of his logical tight spot. Yay for Budda.

    Rule 12: Buddha’s opponents always repeat things because “if you repeat it frequently enough people will sooner or later believe it.” Except for Buddha who never believes it because Buddha and his like-minded cohorts (lol again) are smarter than the public. But, that must mean that Buddha’s opponents haven’t argued to the public (per Rule 5) becasue they have only argued to Buddha and his buddies who are smarter than the public. Buddha is now very confused. But wait, Buddha is always right, so Buddha says he and his buddies are both the public and not the public. Buddha is again out of his tight logical spot by simply ignoring the rules of logic and declaring a fact to be both true and not rue at the same time. Therefore, Buddha’s opponent’s always satisfy the requirements of Rule 12.

    Rule 13: Because Buddha’s oppononents satisfy Rules 1-12, Buddha’s opponents are always Propagandists who engage in the Big Lie.

    Rule 14: Buddha can now tar his opponents with this epithet just like a real propagandist.

    Rule 15: Buddha should repeat the propagandist epithet as many times as possible in lieu of senselessly and wastefully engaging in the merits of his opponents’ arguments. (Remember Rule 1) That is hard work and Buddha is very intellectually lazy. Being intellectually lazy must be good because Buddha is good. See Rule 7.

    Rule 16: Buddha should never think too hard about what he is doing (See Rule 15) because then he might notice the irony that he is engaging in the exact same propaganda-like behavior that he is accusing his opponents of engaging in. Oops. Being intellectually lazy is fun and holds many advantages for Buddha.

  5. Oh…one other point on my post above: If kderosa were the Coach he would be pondering whether to now perform an onside kick.

  6. “@Roco, those are random latin phrases I inserted so I can sound like Buddha.”

    Picture this: The last 34 seconds of a football game. The Tight End scores on a three yard pass from the Quarterback, that he fumbles and almost drops, but at the last second holds on. He proceeds to do a dance in the end zone and then runs back to the bench, arms outstretched, yelling with glee and pumping his chest. Oh….one last point, the other team had 53 points before the touchdown and the Tight End’s team had three.

  7. kderosa:

    I thought so. But just wanted to make sure so they dont give you stuff about it.

    wouldnt “veni, vidi, blahterit” be better?

  8. @Roco, those are random latin phrases I inserted so I can sound like Buddha.

  9. kderosa:

    Buddha won and so did Elaine and Otteray Scribe, they say it is so, so it must be true.

    but what the hell does after death, time flies, all powers ultra (vocabulary lacking) mean?

  10. @Buddha, you’re so smart. You really showed me how to argue like a pro. Let me adopt some of your techniques.

    “don’t [you] accuse others of fallacies you don’t understand in the future. It makes you look even more ridiculous. Again, your failure in tactics is your failure, not mine.”

    Clearly it is you who don’t understand that it is you who have commited a logical fallacy. It makes you look ridiculous. And it is your failure, not mine. Ad infinitum. Ante Meridiem!!!

    That was easy. I didn’t have to prove anything or make much sense. All I had to do was hurl accusations. Let’s try some more.

    “Also, repetition is not the only component to the Big Lie.”

    You keep repeating this accusation, Buddha, and you’ve met all the other components of the bIg Lie that I copied from Wikipedia. Therefore YOU are a propagandist engaging in the Big Lie. And everything you say must be a lie because you are a propagandist. Pro bono. Ad nauseam.

    “that you cannot process the idea of multiple criteria is not terribly surprising.”

    As a propogandist engaing in the Big Lie, this is clearly a lie, no matter what Wikipedia says. Also, if you look at my last comment you’ll see that multiple criteria – blah blah blah, you Hitler-like propagandist.

    “That’s another logical fallacy scored for you though. It’s called a false equivalence. Repeatedly exposing the Big Lie is a tactically and strategically valid to counter the tactic . A method of dilution.”

    I read on my favorite site Wikipedia, that Hitler said things like this all the time. Saying things like that Hitler said, conclusively proves you are a propagandist engagiing in dilution. And false equivalence. Caveat Emptor. Carpe Diem. In loco parentis.

    Elaine met the burden of proof of showing it was historical revisionism. You did not meet the burden of proof for showing that it wasn’t. You keep flailing away though.

    Elaine didn’t meet the burden of proof of showing it was historical revisionism. You did not meet the burden of proof for showing that it was. You keep flailing away though.

    Post Mortem. tempus fugit, ultra vires omnibus

    Vae victis

  11. OS,

    It is indeed a new high in low. And that’s saying something around here. We have Tootie to serve as a baseline.

  12. BiL, the depths of the troll’s ignorance of analytical reasoning plumbs new depths I did not even know existed.

  13. Here’s a hint: don’t use accuse others of fallacies you don’t understand in the future. It makes you look even more ridiculous. Again, your failure in tactics is your failure, not mine.

    Also, repetition is not the only component to the Big Lie. Being that you’re proving to be hard of understanding, that you cannot process the idea of multiple criteria is not terribly surprising. In addition, repeatedly exposing the Big Lie the equivalent of the Big Lie. That’s another logical fallacy scored for you though. It’s called a false equivalence. Repeatedly exposing the Big Lie is a tactically and strategically valid to counter the tactic . A method of dilution. I could go into details, but you’ll have to do get your continuing education on the mechanics of propaganda from someone interested in improving your pitiful skill set as opposed to someone exposing you and merely laughing at your pitiful skill set.

    Elaine met the burden of proof of showing it was historical revisionism. You did not meet the burden of proof for showing that it wasn’t. You keep flailing away though.

    It really is funny.

    Why don’t you try blaming your inability to properly execute tactics on me again?

    That’s equally funny.

    Meus opus est etiam perfectus,

    Ceterus est risus.

  14. @Buddha

    “which is rightly upon you as the claimant that Palin’s historical revisionism is not historical revisionism”

    The burden of proof is actually on the person who claimed that Palin’s statement was historical revisionism in the first place, knucklehead.

    And, as I pointed out, that claim was based on nothing more than an opinion. Thus, the burden of proof was never satisfied since opinion is not factual evidence.

    My rebuttal, to the extent it went past pointing this out, was unnecessary.

    Overkill if you will.

  15. @Buddha

    “Yes, I imagine an impossible task would be low on your list of priorities.”

    Impossible? Hardly.

    Let’s do one for giggles.

    1. All propagandists repeat things and blah, blah, blah.
    2. you repeat things, and blah, blah, blah.
    3. Therefore, you are a propagandist.

    Undistributed middle: The middle is: Everyone who repeat things, and blah, blah, blah is a propagandist.

    By the way, you have repeated the Big Lie and propogandist claims about 50 times in this tread. Just sayin’.

  16. Yes, I imagine an impossible task would be low on your list of priorities.

    I’ve actually had courses in logic and symbolic logic both in high school and in college. Not only that, I learned something in them – a claim which you cannot make based on your demonstrably pitiful showing here. If Wikipedia happens to contain some of the information that is in my head, well, that just saves me from having to make an entry now, doesn’t it?

    So unless you can meet your still unmet burden of proof regarded the facts of the matter (and that above semantic argument fails miserably), let me explain it to you, child:

    You are discredited; both factually and in form.

    The reasons you are discredited are your failure to meet the burden of proof (which is rightly upon you as the claimant that Palin’s historical revisionism is not historical revisionism) and your poor choice and execution in propaganda tactics.

    So let’s assume you’re going to continue to apply the failed tactic.

    Since, apparently, you are continuing to apply the failed tactic.

    Munus meum ibi fiat.

  17. @Buddha “I do notice that you have not substantively rebutted the proof you are a propagandist [engaging in the Big Lie], because you can’t. Please do try though.”

    I promised you I would, but it was low on my list of things to do.

    I’ll take the easy way out. I can tell that explaining to why your claims of being propagandist and engaging in the Big Lie are logical fallacies is going to be like teaching a monkey to talk based on your wikipedia cut and paste job.

    Let me explain it simply so that even a child might understand.

    Let’s assume that I am a notorious propagandist engaging in the Big Lie. The Big Lie propaganda I am spreading is that Buddha is a crazy loon to discredit Buddha. During my “Buddha is loony” research I discover from many reliable sources that Buddha is a compulsive bedwetter. So in the course of my propaganda campaign is spread around the fact that you are a compulsive bedwetter to further discredit you. Tell me, is that fact now untrue because I am a propagandist engaging in the Big Lie?

  18. Thanks for the offer, Mike, but really, it’s not much effort at all.

    Mike concludes that Elaine’s response to 2 of my 4 arguments “succinctly disproves them by correctly stating how Palin’s statement was ignorant of the facts.” Mike’s argument is simply that Elaine’s statement of the facts was “correct.” Or even more simply: Elaine is correct because Mike thinks so. Not much of an argument really and Mike isn’t a qualified expert in American colonial history or an expert linguist in the English language. As such, Mike’s opinion is not a fact that is capable of providing factual support for Elaine’s statement. Nor did Mike provide any other evidence or logical argument that could be relied upon. Therefore, Mike’s opinion adds nothing to the debate except that we now know he is Elaine’s cheerleader.

    Note also that Mike never argues that the remaining two arguments I made were inaccurate or wrong. So, until Mike corrects his oversight, It’s safe to assume he has no credible argument for them.

    So let’s get back to Elaine’s statement to see why she isn’t correct in her layman judgment.

    “Are you trying to tell me that Paul Revere went around ringing bells and shooting off warning shots to warn the British regulars “that they weren’t gonna be takin’ away our arms…and that we’re gonna be secure and we were gonna be free. And we we’re gonna be armed” when the purpose of his ride was to warn colonists about the British regulars?”

    One problem with Elaine’s logic is that her entire case rests on three definition fallacies. Elaine has purposely used overly-narrow definitions for “ring,” “shoot,” and “warn.” \

    First, Elaine has defined “ring” and “shoot” to mean “personally ring” and “personally shoot” The plain meaning of those words and the context surrounding those words compells no such narrow definitions. So even though Revere caused bells to ring and caused shots to be fired by others as part of the alarm system that he personally designed and help implement during his ride, Elaine can claim that Revere didn’t accomplish either effects. No, he only gave the commands for others to do so. And, according to the most relevant dictionary definition of “ring,” which is “to cause (a bell, for example) to ring,” Revere did in fact cause bells to ring. Similarly, the releveant dictionary definition of shoot (“To fire or let fly (a missile) from a weapon”) is also not limited to the personal or direct firing from a weapon.

    More egregiously, Elaine insists that the word “warn” be read to include only warnings whose intended purpose was known from the outset of the endeavor.” The definition of “warn” and the context in which the word was spoken compell no such overly narrow meaning. In this way, Elaine attempts to eliminate the three actual warnings that Revere delivered or caused to deliver that night that we know from history.Moreover, historian David Hackett Fischer who wrote the book The Ride of Paul Revere explicity states that Revere issued warnings to the British (the quote has been provided). Fischer is an expert on Paul Revere and his account agrees with the extant primary sources.

    So let’s weigh the evidence. Elaine’s interpretation is supported only by her own layman opinion. No sources of external evidence were relied upon or cited. My interpretation is consistent with the plain meaning of the words based on the relevant dictionary definitions and in the context in which they were spoken and the opinion of the expert on Revere with respect to the word “warn.” And, the plain meaning of each of these words, as Palin used them, is consistent with the historic record (No one disputes the historical events that I have cited). Thus, for Palin to be mistaken, you’d have to deny that the plain meaning of each of these words was a reasonable interpretation and instead, substitute, as Elaine has attempted, a contrived, overly-narrow interpretation which is hardly compelled from the context in which the words are spoken in order to wind up with an ahistoric result. Talk about twisting words to achieve a desired result.

    (None of the articles Elaine has linked to changes this result. If anyone disagrees, they can explain why and a specific analysis will be provided)

    And note that this debate is not a debate about historic details (those are not in dispute, now that Elaine has been apprised of them). This is merely a linguistic debate as to whether Palin used three words according to the plain meaning of those words in extemporaneous speech.

  19. Mike,

    I’m going to go read some Walter Mosley and take a nap. I’ll check back in later.

Comments are closed.