We have been discussing the myth promoted by socialist politicians like Zohran Mamdani that state-sponsored stores can sell produce at a huge discount and still break even. I discuss these efforts in Rage and the Republic and the record of such failures for decades in state-subsidized stores. The latest example is the closure of the Prairie Food Co-op grocery, which remained operational for only a little over a year after burning through $1.5 million in taxpayer dollars. As always, the politicians and bureaucrats who funded the effort with great fanfare have just shrugged while the media has offered little coverage of the predictable aftermath.
When it opened, the store in Lombard, outside Chicago, proclaimed it would offer “sustainable, ethically produced foods that were locally or regionally sourced.”
Unlike Mom and Pop stores, which have to find their own funding, the woke store was showered with public money, including a $750,000 federal grant in 2023 from the Biden Administration and an $807,000 state grant in 2022 from the Pritzker Administration.
Politicians such as U.S. Rep. Sean Casten (D., Ill.) heralded the store. In an April 28, 2022, letter to House Appropriations Chair Rosa DeLauro, Casten wrote, “I am requesting funding for Prairie Food Co-op in fiscal year 2023.” The funding, he said, “would be used to revitalize downtown Lombard IL, support the growth of local microbusinesses, and create $1.5 million in revenues for local agriculture and local food businesses.”
The money was quickly spent, and the store then closed roughly 16 months later. It was based on an idea that the community would own the store with customers owning shares: “The cooperative had about 2,700 owners, who paid $200 apiece for their shares. But minutes of a board meeting indicated that about 600 of those owners had stopped shopping at the store.”
So their own shareowners eventually abandoned the store as customers because they could get better deals at competitive, private stores nearby. The store reportedly projected $80,000 in weekly sales as the bare minimum needed to sustain the operation. It was clearing only around half of that and estimated it would need another $500,000 to keep operating.
In its statement, titled “A Difficult Decision,” the store admitted that “Our survey also made clear that the store was not meeting many shoppers’ needs, particularly around produce selection, pricing, and the availability of conventional grocery options alongside natural and organic offerings.”
Notably, this was a small, modest operation. Yet the community ownership model could not sustain the operation for much over a year of full operations in an industry with less than a 3% profit margin. Without the infusion of public funds from the Biden and Pritzker Administrations, it is doubtful that it could have opened and lasted a month.
Nevertheless, the left and the media continue to foster the myth that these stores can operate as anything other than a state-sponsored food bank. The result is burning tax dollars on feel-good projects which then quietly die when the public attention (and profits) fade.
As previously discussed, the losses for other cities will make the Prairie Food Co-op grocery look like a blue-chip stock investment.
Mayor Mamdani is selling New Yorkers a bill of goods that will cost them millions. Standing in front of blackboards saying “REDUCED 30%,” Mamdani promised that “Once a month, our five city-run grocery stores will set prices for this core set of goods at 30% below typical retail prices. No exceptions, no gimmicks”
Not only that, but Mamdani assured the public that “The savings will last for the entire month. That means no weekly fluctuations or sticker shock at the checkout line — not for our seniors living on fixed incomes, nor for the parents who rely on a regular supply of apple slices to keep toddler tantrums at bay.”
The math simply does not add up for Mamdani. Most groceries have an average profit margin between 1% and 3%, one of the smallest margins of any industry.
Promising a 30% discount below market rate that cannot be adjusted for monthly market fluctuations is economically absurd.
It is not a description of a competitive grocery but a quasi-food bank where taxpayers subsidize the cost.
Nevertheless, the media ate up the pitch as Mamdani declared, “May the most affordable grocery store win.”
Of course, as Illinois shows, the test is not which grocery is the most affordable, but which is the most sustainable. As discussed in Rage and the Republic, such stores previously failed in Chicago, Milwaukee, and other cities. Mamdani will use the New York budget to cover and hide the real costs.
The average bodega owner must cover the fixed costs of renting a space, building the store, and complying with inspectors. Those fixed costs must be internalized into the cost of produce to break even.
Real stores are competing in one of the tightest markets in the world and are grappling with a 33% nationwide increase in costs since 2019. Mamdani wants to use the stores to prove that socialism works as part of his effort to introduce New York to the “warmth of socialism.” We may never know the real costs of the Mamdani markets.
According to the New York Post, the city plans to open an East Harlem location as its first store, at a reported cost of $30 million.
However, that is not the full cost. The Post also reported that the city had already appropriated $25 million to improve the first site. The city will lose millions that could have been acquired through a sale of the land or through rents to private companies.
This fuzzy math allows Mamdani to promise New Yorkers “$90 a month, or roughly $1,000 a year.” He is using the city to subsidize food under the guise of selling at low, but still profitable prices.
In comparison, the Prairie Food Co-op grocery was a relatively cheap gimmick for the Biden and Pritzker Administrations. It is privately owned, but a significant part of its $4 million start-up costs came from the public. Yet even that public infusion of money for a relatively small operation was not enough to make it sustainable.
The first city-run grocery, in East Harlem, will cost $30 million to build — and perhaps more. It will never need to pay this money back nor factor it into its prices. The public will cover the true costs, as Mamdani falsely claims that it is only the latest benefit from the “warmth of collectivism.”
The failure of stores like the Prairie Food Co-op is not a cause for glee or celebration for free marketers. State subsidies can hurt actual Mom and Pop stores, which are struggling in an industry with a razor-thin profit margin. This is also money burned that could have gone to failing schools and infrastructure around Chicago. These are real costs to the public, which has been left largely uninformed by the coverage.
Ironically, these public tax dollars may have hastened the demise of projects like the Prairie Food Co-op. Most grocery stores exist because owners put together the tough financing and resources needed to sustain a store. The Biden and Pritzker Administrations helped allay much of that work with public dollars, but there was still an unsustainable business plan. Ultimately, when public funds ran out, the store could not meet even half of the bare-minimum sales and was half a million dollars short of the further investments needed to sustain its operations.
While the closure of the Prairie Food Co-op was understandably a “difficult decision” for its management (which had only the best motivations and interests in pursuing this store), it was not a difficult decision economically. It is based on the same flawed economics used on a much larger scale in New York and other blue cities.
Howard Lutnick upstaged Donald J. Trump’s trilateral summit on Thursday by becoming the first US Commerce Secretary to be named Employee of the Month by the Chinese Communist Party.
Lutnick beat out a competitive field of candidates in November including former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang and Trump himself.
“I hope this silences my critics,” a beaming Lutnick said as he accepted the plaque from Chinese President Xi Jinping. “Scott Bessent can bite me.”
For his part, Trump admitted he was “envious as hell” that Lutnick had bested him for November’s honor, but noted, “By the end of this summit, I’ll be a lock for December.”