by Gene Howington, Guest Blogger
“Silence is argument carried out by other means.” – Che Guevara
“Hello darkness, my old friend,
I’ve come to talk with you again,
Because a vision softly creeping,
Left its seeds while I was sleeping,
And the vision that was planted in my brain
Still remains
Within the sound of silence.”
– “The Sound of Silence”, by Simon & Garfunkel, lyrics by Paul Simon
“Darkness isn’t the opposite of light, it is simply its absence.” – Terry Pratchett
“In human intercourse the tragedy begins, not when there is misunderstanding about words, but when silence is not understood.” – Henry David Thoreau
Just as darkness is the absence of light, silence is an absence. We’ve considered the word and the image as propaganda up to this point, so let us pause to consider their antithesis as a form of propaganda. The phrase “[t]he only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing” is often attributed to 18th Century Irish born English statesman and philosopher Edmund Burke, although what he actually wrote in Thoughts on the Cause of the Present Discontents was that “when bad men combine, the good must associate; else they will fall, one by one, an unpitied sacrifice in a contemptible struggle.” Regardless of the apocryphal attribution, the quote goes right to the heart of the issue of silence being a form of propaganda. Like most tactics of propaganda, silence has multiple forms and uses. Let us examine some of these variations on a theme.
What is “silence”? According to Webster’s it is:
silence \ˈsī-lən(t)s\, n.,
1: forbearance from speech or noise : muteness —often used interjectionally
2: absence of sound or noise : stillness
These are the common meanings of silence that automatically leap to mind when one reads the word, but more to the point in discussing propaganda, we need to consider the full definition of the word and even enhance it a little bit. Consider the third meaning of the word “silence” . . .
3: absence of mention: a : oblivion, obscurity b : secrecy
With this fuller definition, it becomes clear that silence is more than the absence of sound or stillness. For discussion of propaganda, let us use an expanded specialized definition to have silence mean not just the absence of sound, but rather the absence of information. All propaganda is aimed at shaping the flow and content of information. With this expanded definition, we can see the broader scope of silence as a propaganda tactic. As you will see, this can lead to an interesting contradiction.
The first use of silence as a tactic is what you’d expect and the traditional definition of silence: the “No Comment” maneuver. You see this all the time coming from Hollywood and the entertainment industry as well as in the political arena. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn’t and this is dependent upon a variety of factors. The public’s perception of the speaker, the relative severity and the public or private nature of the topic not being discussed, any associated value loading that can go with a scandal, how amenable to obscuration or obviation is the topic in general and are there any related topics currently drawing the public’s attention that may either attract or detract attention are some of the mitigating factors that influence how well playing the “No Comment” card will work out. Let us consider a couple of examples from both the entertainment and political realms and why or why not they succeeded.
Movie stars are well known (or not) for their scandals (real or imagined) popping up from time to time in the tabloid press. Very often, attempts to mitigate the damage of an embarrassing disclosure do more harm than good. An example of this is the current Kristen Stewart/Robert Pattinson/Rupert Sanders story. After photos of Stewart and Sanders (a married man with children) surfaced, naturally her relationship with her Twilight co-star Pattinson became somewhat complicated. In an effort to mitigate the damage, Stewart made a very public apology to Pattinson. This effort backfired as she caught criticism for everything ranging from the public nature of what most would consider a private message to the content for not being apologetic enough concerning the impact on Sander’s marriage and children to the impact the negative press would have on the forthcoming installment of the Twilight series. This in turn led to speculation that the studio might be reconsidering her for future roles as well as much distress among the Twilight fans. To complete this study in contrasts, consider the recent development in this story where Stewart (possibly after taking advice from her former co-star and actress/director well acquainted with the silence strategy, Jodie Foster) is now refusing to answer questions about her and Pattinson’s relationship.
In the political arena, silence is playing a larger part than usual in the Presidential campaign. The Romney campaign is trying silence as a tactic on his business dealings, his tax returns and the more extremist views of his choice in Vice Presidential running mate Paul Ryan. So far this application of the tactic has generally backfired miserably. For his business dealings, silence makes him look like a liar and a fraud considering it is his past business dealings that make up the bulk of his alleged experience and skill set to lead a nation. With his taxes, silence simply makes him look like he has something to hide in addition to the arrogance he has displayed on the issue showing him to be massively out of touch with the American people and an elitist with remarks about “you people” and “trust me”. With silence about the points of view of his running mate, Paul Ryan? It is early in the use of that strategy to see how well it will work, but early indications are it is going to only serve to highlight Ryan’s extremist views as the media and the public start asking questions. Another spectacular backfire as Ryan’s stance come under greater scrutiny including his budget proposals (even attacked by Conservative King of Trickle Down Economics – David Stockman), the privatization of Social Security, replacing Medicare with a voucher system (also a form of privatization), cutting funding and participation in Medicaid, his dubious and manifestly politically expedient disavowal of his nearly life long love for Ayn Rand and all things Randian, his hypocritical support for economic stimulus when Bush was for it but attacks on it when it is Obama for economic stimulus, and reports of general dissatisfaction among voters of all persuasions about his selection.
There is a second variation on silence as a tactic and that limited silence or partial disclosure. A fine example of this is the career of Michael J. Fox in its post-Parkinson’s phase. Since his diagnosis, he was careful with the media but remained largely silent. After announcing his condition, he carefully controlled his media presence until the scope and effect of his condition and the effectiveness of his treatment could be assessed. What started with silence became partial disclosure of his progress, using his celebrity to draw attention to the condition and support for research, and eventually a slow and partial reintroduction into promoting active acting projects. This illustrates that in the process of information management, what you don’t say and when you don’t say it can be as important to image management as what you do say and when you say it, and that balance in tactics can be crucial.
The third use of silence is a close variant to the “no comment” form of silence and that is the tactic of externally enforced silence. Oddly enough, this tactic can arise from tactical missteps as well as situational elements and there is a perfect example of this going on in the current Presidential campaign. Consider Mitt Romney’s camp and their inability to mention one of his (few) great successes in political leadership without having it blow up in their face and that is the so-called Romneycare he shepherded to life while Governor of Massachusetts. Their silence on this issue is externally enforced because of the similarities to Obama’s ACA plan. Romney cannot attack Obama for actions incredibly similar to actions he took as governor and then tout his actions as governor without tactically shooting himself in the foot with his target audience.
The fourth use of silence is where silence as the absence of information comes to the forefront as well as the previously mentioned interesting contradiction. Sometimes silence can be noisy. Another way to create silence in the sense of an absence of information are the strategies of obfuscation and distraction (which can employ many tactics from white noise to straw men to simple misdirection). In this regard, when evaluating information it is just as critical to ask “what does this speaker not want me to think about or discuss” as it is to look at the explicit content of what they are saying.
Consider in a broader media sense the contrast between the television news coverage of World War II, Vietnam, the first Gulf War, and Iraq/Afghanistan. The media kept silent about a great many details of World War II and in those days of analog media dominance, it was possible to maintain such silence. To the credit of those in government who controlled the flow of information during World War II, the bulk of what was kept silent was validly done so in the name of operational security and once Allied troops were out of danger fuller disclosure was usually forthcoming. Contrast this with the media coverage of Vietnam and the then relatively new medium of television. The collapse of public support at the end of the Vietnam war was due in part to the inability of the government to exert control over television. Once the images of what was really going on over there and the cost it was taking on our citizen draft military with daily visions of caskets being broadcast into a majority of American homes, it was only a matter of time before any public support for that war evaporated.
Fast forward to the first Gulf War. The war mongers in government had learned their lesson from Vietnam and the Draft was not a concern with a volunteer force – removing some of the direct impact into American homes from a war abroad. True, many civilians were against conscription, but getting rid of it came with a hidden cost to civic duty and a hidden opportunity for the unscrupulous to make war easier because of less public challenge. Add to this a high level of embedded journalists, a whole new bag of technology that made showing night actions possible and a theater conducive to night actions and relatively low casualties and you get the first war sold to the American public as essentially a video game. This war as an exercise in modern media control can only be termed a success from the point of view of policy hawks. Silence was kept where needed to keep public support flowing and the flow of information out was carefully controlled. The effectiveness of pro-war propaganda was back to WWII levels.
Now comes the invasion of Iraq. America was reeling in the aftermath of 9/11, but anyone who focuses on intelligence in looking at foreign policy issues knew that Iraq didn’t have a damn thing to do with those heinous terrorist attacks. The general public was in a state of fear and the Bush Administration seizing upon that opportunity forced through Congress the purposefully vague Authorization for the Use of Military Force (AUMF) as well as the arguably prime facie unconstitutional Patriot Act. Using their media savvy sharpened by the Gulf War, little if any media mention was made of the pure irrationality of attacking Iraq was mentioned during the lead up to that action and once again the television was ablaze with video game warfare images. However, that silence about the cost and irrationality of this invasion had to deal with a change in technology analogous to what transpired in Vietnam with television: the Internet. Although it had technically been around for a while, the World Wide Web hadn’t reached maturity until roughly the same time the war in Iraq started. Due to the very nature of the medium, government found it difficult to control the message and enforce silence, but also due to the massively increased number of media outlets, the impact of negative reporting of the true costs of invading Iraq were somewhat diluted compared to the impact of television on Vietnam. Combined with the lack of impact created by a conscription military, a situation ensued where dissent against the invasion slowly built though the alternative information channels the World Wide Web provided, but instead of ending the war in 13 years (1962-1975) in Vietnam, the pressure to end the invasion of Iraq took 8 years (2003-2011) to “officially” end – seemingly an improvement. But is it? We still have troop presence there so anyone paying attention knows that it is not over. A lesson learned in Vietnam is the euphemistic language of calling a war something other than what it really is, like “police action”, “liberation”, and “nation building”.
This is not to mention that we are still in Afghanistan, a country well known to military history buffs both professional and amateur to be a place practically impossible to occupy due to both terrain and a fractured culture in part created by that terrain. So here we are, still involved in two wars, one an invasion of questionable legality and unquestionably bad tactics (unless you’re in the oil business) and the other an attempt at occupation against a legitimate target but a target that historically has been shown highly resistant to occupation strategies. Unlike Vietnam though, the propaganda masters in government rapidly adapted to the World Wide Web. If you look only at MSM Web sources for news, you might be minimally aware of some sanitized facts of what is going on in Iraq and Afghanistan. If you only watch television, you might be hard pressed to even realize there are two wars going on at all. In either case, you can hear the media’s politically driven drumbeat starting already for war with Iran.
The propaganda masters have learned their lessons and put them into application. Where they could not directly silence, they sowed confusion. Where they could not sow confusion, they manufactured false support with tactics like hiring propaganda trolls and astroturfing. Where they could not manufacture support, they outright lied. And when their lies where exposed by whistle blowers like Bradley Manning and Wikileaks, they resorted to that old standby of fascists and totalitarian regimes to enforce silence about their misdeeds and malfeasance in representing the best interests of the general citizenry: threats and intimidation.
In being or seeking to become a critical thinker and a responsible citizen in the age of modern media and propaganda techniques, silence as an absence of information is your enemy. It can be overcome by diligent research, practiced evaluation, supporting whistle blowers who bring the public evidence of institutional and personal wrong doings by government, industry and its members and to practice through and proper analysis (in context) of as many sources of information as your mind can handle. But is it enough to overcome the silence of information to make your decisions about such matters? As George Orwell so famously noted, “Speaking the truth in times of universal deceit is a revolutionary act.” Is it enough to find the truth behind the silence? Or is it your civic duty to speak truth to power?
I think the answer is quite clear if you are following the sage advice of Marcus Aurelius and “seek the truth, by which no one was ever truly harmed.”
What do you think?
________________
Source(s): E!, The Daily Beast, Times Live, Huffington Post (1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6), Politico, New York Times, League of Women Voters, CNN (1, 2), Slate, Vanity Fair, The Raw Story
~submitted by Gene Howington, Guest Blogger
The Propaganda Series;
Propaganda 105: How to Spot a Liar
Propaganda 104 Supplemental: The Streisand Effect and the Political Question
Propaganda 104: Magica Verba Est Scientia Et Ars Es
Propaganda 103: The Word Changes, The Word Remains The Same
Propaganda 102 Supplemental: Holly Would “Zero Dark Thirty”
Propaganda 102: Holly Would and the Power of Images
Propaganda 101 Supplemental: Child’s Play
Propaganda 101 Supplemental: Build It And They Will Come (Around)
Propaganda 101: What You Need to Know and Why or . . .
Related articles of interest;
Mythology and the New Feudalism by Mike Spindell
How about Some Government Propaganda for the People Paid for by the People Being Propagandized? by Elaine Magliaro
I sure hope you are right…..
if not…. there will be a news clip from Sweden….
“Outside of the American Embassy in Stockholm, there is a strange woman, who looks to be burning her passport..”
justagurl…
I would have replied sooner, but was cleaning up the coffee spew on my screen.
I am going to have to share that with my friend.
Otteray… the above post and link is for you… 🙂
http://www.giftsforageek.com/marketplace-section/politicsisfun/7800406/137_physics_joke_
@Slarti: I still believe the progressive backlash is coming, certainly since Romney has over-stepped. I try to read Nate Silver pretty regularly, btw. It is one of the reasons I think Obama will win; both Intrade and Nate put Obama as about a 2:1 favorite. Congress has a 78% disapproval rating.
My unsupported take is that Paul Ryan was picked for funding purposes, not winning purposes; and they are not the same thing at all. As a result, I think Paul Ryan will have negative coat-tails; he will drive progressives to the polls (and independents to Democrats) in order to protect the social safety net, and that will not only elect Obama, but Democrats in the House and Senate.
As always, I could be wrong, I am stating what I think. If I am wrong, then much of the social safety net will be effectively destroyed. The pain (and death and desperation) that is going to cause will be the just desserts of the complacent, and perhaps that will wake up the 76% of voters that oppose ANY cuts in Social Security or Medicare, for 2014 or 2016. If it hasn’t happened by then, well, I was wrong, and the majority says they want the safety net but is lying, they cannot break themselves away from the TV long enough to vote. I think I would have to accept that, and try for social justice by organizational means other than politics.
Still, I think it happens now, in 2012. We are immersed in the information age. I imagine Romney/Ryan will get their standard 30% to 40% of die hard ideologues, but I am betting that the 76% that want SS / Medicare kept intact as-is will realize the threat posed by RR with a possibly Republican Congress and Senate, and come out to vote for Democrats.
We shall soon see, I suppose.
Nick,
I never worked with rape victims. I was an elementary school teacher–remember? I am also a mother. I was busy teaching and tending to my family responsibilities–including helping out with elderly grandparents. I never worked as a private investigator like you. I did work with children who were neglected, had severe special needs, who came from troubled homes. I tried to make sure that my classroom was a warm and safe and encouraging environment for them.
What does my not having worked with rape victims got to do with my position in support of choice for women and the belief that women should have the right to control what happens to their bodies?
There…I answered your question–now you answer mine.
Slarti, you can just mention 137 to my friend and she breaks into peals of laughter. The constant that isn’t. Physicists are strange creatures by and large. I only had a minor, so was not completely contaminated.
OS,
Thanks.
I can’t quite make out the name of the operator (left hand side of the first line), but if it is a definition that was used in the second or third line it would be okay. The doubling of indexes is bad—and fixing it in the third line just makes things more confusing… The missing minus sign is minor (and can be fixed by any tattoo artist) and since this looks to be quantum mechanics (yuck!), we can assume that c=h-bar=pi=1 is in effect*. All around, you’re right, it’s pretty sloppy—just what mathematicians have come to expect from physicists 😉
* this is an old physics joke—not quite as bad as the math joke about the integral of d(cabin)/(cabin)…
justagurlinseattle,
The reason the right wing wont admit it is because their stated position is just a fig leaf to cover their naked greed. That’s what I think, anyway…
You never answered my question about what you have done to help rape victims after condescendingly pontificating. I have an aunt who taught 2nd grade for 40 years. Once in awhile she’ll start speaking like she’s talking to second graders. Of course, I’ll call her on it and she’ll laugh and say, “Professional hazard.” I have no expectation you could ever see this in yourself..but it’s there. I apologize for thinking you’re a paisan, too bad you’re not. I didn’t think feminist took “slave names” as I’ve heard them call it.
So, ElaineM who is not an Italian, answer my question that you have avoided like the plaque[truth can be a mofo!] and I’ll answer your silly one.
First line is an operator while the second two are numeric valued. Terms in the first line should be acting on some field (like the Psi in the third line.)
Second row, as a whole: indexes i and alpha are doubly used, once as a sum index, and once as an absolute index. The indices should be distinct. (They fixed that on the third line, but it can’t be repaired on the second.)
Second row, second term, denominator: there is a missing minus sign.
Units are inconsistent (the terms in the first line go 1/distance^2, 1/(mass*distance^2), charge/distance, 1/distance, charge^2/distance)—it may be that they chose some “everything=1” system of units so we can let that slide.
Slarti, I must confess that it went by me too, but got some free help from a physicist friend.
David Stockman on the Folly of Anti-Tax Crusades
February 10, 2012
In this web clip, exclusively on BillMoyers.com, David Stockman, former Budget Director under President Ronald Reagan and chief architect of Reagan’s supply-side, or “trickle-down,” economic policies, says today’s Republicans have taken their anti-tax campaign too far.
“Taxes are the price we pay for civilization,” Stockman says, borrowing a quotation from Supreme Court Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes. “What they’re saying today is foolish, it’s irresponsible. How can anyone believe with the kind of deficit that we have — a trillion dollars, year after year after year — that we can keep taxes as low as they are?”
Watch Bill’s full interview with Stockman.
http://billmoyers.com/content/david-stockman-on-the-folly-of-anti-tax-crusades/
Blouise,
That’s okay—just ask yourself where Gene will be when my plans for world domination come to fruition…
Since you asked (and because Tony C probably deserves more than my naked appeal to my own authority), I’ll try and get a post up before I go to bed tonight outlining the mathematical basis for what I’m trying to say. Please make sure that raff is sedated and has a comfortable padded room with a huggy-huggy jacket he can use if he needs it.
gbk,
I love that cartoon—although I prefer proof by decree (it’s true because I say it’s true 😛 ).
OS,
Maybe I’m looking too hard, but I don’t get it… (I know I’m just setting myself up to feel stupid when you tell me, but I guess humility [or humiliation] is good for the soul 🙁 ).
raff,
Before you try to read what I post next, you need to go to your happy place…
Nick,
There you go assuming that I’m a member of a particular ethnic group when I’m not. That’s par for the course–because you assume a lot of things that aren’t based in fact. I took my husband’s name when I got married.
I wasn’t being petulant–just merely informing you about my background–since you make a lot of assumptions and snap judgments about people.
BTW, did you answer the questions that I posed to you about trophy wives?
what I would like to know… WHY is it when Regans, policy adviser has ADMITTED that low taxes do not spur job growth…. and we have tried the low taxes and all it has done is screw things up… why is it that the Right wing wants to keep trying this failed and proven failure, over and over again????
some of the strongest economies in the world have higher taxes, and do quite well… these same economies also have a bit of socialism, and this has proved OVER and OVER to be a winning equation….
WHY does the right wing not accept this?????
conservative economist Bruce Bartlett, who wrote “the bible” for the Reagan Revolution, worked on domestic policy for the Reagan White House, and served as a top treasury official under the first President Bush. Now he’s a heretic in the conservative circles where he once was a star.
Bartlett argues that right-wing tax policies — pushed in part by Grover Norquist and Tea Party activists — are destroying the country’s economic foundation. When he called George W. Bush out as “a pretend conservative” in his book Impostor: Why George W. Bush Bankrupted America and Betrayed the Reagan Legacy, Bartlett was fired from his position as a senior fellow at a conservative think tank. His new book is The Benefit and the Burden: Tax Reform — Why We Need It and What It Will Take.
http://billmoyers.com/segment/bruce-bartlett-on-where-the-right-went-wrong/
N ic k ,
Are you really A paid troll trying to sell your wares here? Maybe that representative has an entry level position for you.
Blouise,
Yeah, it’s pretty good. Tried to find another I saw some years back but no luck. Gotta get back to work.
gbk,
That was a hilarious cartoon! I hope lotta sees it.
Gene,
I spun in “can be” since Slarti failed to do so … I am always cleaning up after him.
This has always been one of my favorite equations:
http://star.psy.ohio-state.edu/coglab/Miracle.html
and then of course my all time favorite:
i = me^2
Slarti, here is a math fail for you. And an exemplary lesson in why you should be very, very careful about the text from which your tattooist is working. The sad thing is, the people who can read this are the ones who will catch it immediately.
Raff, trigger warning. Do not, I repeat, DO NOT click the link.
http://i617.photobucket.com/albums/tt256/otteraylens/6dc3fc32.jpg
“Can be” and “are” are not equivalent, Blouise. 😀
(I know, I know, now I’m just be ornery. That’s what too much coffee will get ya.)
Blouise, You were apparently involved in an inside “joke” for which I had no context, being a newcomer. And you’re projecting vis a vis victimhood. I am a rugged individualist and comments I’ve made here, loathing pc and victimhood, bear that out. You’ve explained, and as far as I’m concerned it’s over.