Family Sues Frostburg University Coaches And NCAA Over Death Of College Student

football_6As most football fans know, the NFL has been struggling with rules changes to address the danger of concussions and Chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) in players in the wake of expanding medical research on injuries. Colleges and High Schools have implemented strict new guidelines, particularly in preventing helmet to helmet hits. None of that seems to have sunk into Frostburg University, which is accused of a shocking display of ignorance and negligence in the death of Derek Sheely, a 22 year old fullback. According to a lawsuit, Sheely was bleeding and complaining that he did not feel right, but the coach told him “Stop your bitching and moaning and quit acting like a pussy and get back out there.” Sheely collapsed a short time later and never regained consciousness.

The lawsuit says that the football team was doing helmet to helmet hits. The family is suing not just the coaches, but the NCAA and the helmet manufacturer. Named are Frostburg running backs coach Jamie Schumacher, assistant athletic trainer Michael Sweitzer Jr. and helmet manufacturer Schutt Sports.

Schumacher allegedly told players to “lead with your head” and use your “hat first” and ridiculed them if they did not hit with their heads. It was Schumacher who allegedly told him to “stop your bitching.”

Notably, the university is not named as a defendant, though I am not sure why. These coaches are employees of the university and their actions would be presumably covered under respondeat superior. Unless there is a settlement, it is surprising to see the school excluded from the lawsuit. That is particularly the case given the allegations of open and gross negligence. The lawsuit states “One of Derek’s teammates described the demeanor of the practices leading up to Derek’s fatal injury as completely ‘out of control’ . . . What is more, the word ‘concussion’ is not stated a single time in Frostburg’s team policies. Thus, the coaches treated all injuries — brain injuries and ankle sprains — the same: You were expected to play through them.” Sheely had had his head bandaged for several days and was seen bleeding repeatedly over the course of four days. Yet, the family says that he was still expected to play.

The NCAA is facing a massive class action lawsuit over such injuries.

A foundation and facebook site has been established in Derek’s name to bring greater awareness to this danger for athletes.

The dangers of CTE are now documented in various studies and documentaries, including the one below:

Source: CBS

28 thoughts on “Family Sues Frostburg University Coaches And NCAA Over Death Of College Student”

  1. Here’s an update on the case from the Washington Times. If you think the NCAA gives one hoot about concussions read this excerpt from the deposition of the NCAA’s man on concussion policy, David Klossner:

    Q: Are member institutions required to submit their concussion management plans to the NCAA?
    A: No.
    Q: Have any member schools been disciplined regarding concussion management plans?
    A: Not to my knowledge.
    Q: Has the NCAA considered disciplining any member institutions regarding concussion management plans?
    A: No, not to my knowledge.

    Plus coaches a free pass to force kids into games after an injury to the head:

    “It would not be appropriate,” Chris Strobel, NCAA director of enforcement, wrote Mr. Klossner 11 months before Derek died, “for enforcement to suspend or otherwise penalize a coach pursuant to the current legislation even if the student-athlete was required to participate after having been diagnosed with a concussion.”
    The note added that the point of the rule wasn’t to make sure universities adhered to the plan unless “systemic or blatant violations” existed.”

  2. Write more, thats all I have to say. Literally, it seems as though you relied on the video to make your point.
    You clearly know what youre talking about, why throw
    away your intelligence on just posting videos to your blog when you
    could be giving us something informative to read?

  3. Gene & Nick,

    I would love to see how they arrived at the figure of $765 million. Does anyone have a copy of the actual settlement? After reading pre-settlement report from, the settlement prevents the NFL from admitting any wrong doing, and uncovering their 10 year study on concussions.

    I didn’t know that filing bankruptcy is living like a prince? Or maybe we should ask Donald Trump (Mr. Bankruptcy)?

  4. I just heard that on the radio, Gene. ESPN did a doc recently. About 70% of all retired NFL players file for bankruptcy within 5 years of retirement. A financial advisor tells his clients, “You can live like a king for a few years, or like a prince the rest of your life.” Most choose the former. Hopefully, they invest this settlement wisely.

Comments are closed.