Bad Finish: Parents Arrested In Washington After Leaving Toddlers In Unheated Car . . . To Attend Wine Tasting

120px-Red_Wine_Glas120px-White_Wine_GlasWe have repeatedly dealt with stories of parents who leave their children in cars while they gamble or party (here) or even commit criminal acts(here). This week, another such arrest was made near our school but this one involves clearly affluent parents who left their two toddlers — a 22-month-old boy and a slightly older girl — in a gray Volvo wagon while they went to a wine tasting at the upscale restaurant Ris. I hope the wine bouquet was satisfying because “the finish” was rough. They were both arrested and now face two counts of attempted second-degree cruelty to children, which carries a maximum 10-year prison sentence.


Christopher (“Christophe”) Daniel Lucas told police that he left an iPhone in the car with an open connection to the children’s mother, Jennie Teresa Chang. However, police say that the girl was crying hysterically and that the temperature was 35 degrees in a car that was turned off with no heat.

The car was left around a corner from the restaurant and around 400 feet from the door in a major traffic area. The manager said that the couple had been wine tasting for about an hour when police arrived.

Lucas, 41, and Chang, 46, own a $1 million rowhouse near Dupont Circle. They actually live 10 minutes from the restaurant and insisted that they were going out to check on the kids.

The court released the couple but they are being denied access to their children.

Notably, Washington seems to be on a theme regarding parenting and the criminal code. We just discussed a question of whether parents should be charged for allowing their children to walk home alone.

The question is what should the punishment be in such a case. Incarceration or a permanent loss of the children seem unduly harsh even though their actions were clearly outrageous and dangerous. However, forcing the children into foster homes would not necessarily be in their best interests if there are no other indications of endangerment or any abuse. That would leave probation and forced counseling or classes. That might seem too light for some people or the court.

What do you think?

Source: FOX DC

173 thoughts on “Bad Finish: Parents Arrested In Washington After Leaving Toddlers In Unheated Car . . . To Attend Wine Tasting”

  1. Well, these truly aren’t helicopter parents, are they? Based on the facts as presented, and assuming the parents aren’t always this negligent, I would say leave the kids in the home, put the parents on probation, and require classes and counseling. If the parents continue to put wine-tasting above their children, then consider removing them.

    I’m the mother of preschoolers, and I just can’t imagine doing this. I’ve missed out on quite a number of activities I would have enjoyed, including wine tastings. These people were clearly not thinking of their children.

  2. DBQ, Interesting anecdote. I would say you hung out in some seedy bars, but as we see, it could have been a swank restaurant like, Ris.

  3. Darren

    A good scolding or perhaps a good shooting. Officer Malloy, swinging his billy club, polishing an apple, saying hello to all the folks on the street, has not been around for a while. C’mon Darren, you are usually better than that. This is a social versus private issue and when the private fails to protect their kids then the social steps in. That is just common sense.

  4. Paul

    When I was growing up North of the border, up Canada way, we routinely played outside in sub zero weather, sometimes 40 below in Edmonton, but it’s a dry cold….

    However, we were moving, skating on frozen backyards, and very well clothed. There was no abandonment there. Also, and perhaps most importantly, we were not out there at two years old. We were ten, eleven and up and could go inside if we were uncomfortable. What goes on in the mind of a two year old child when they start to get cold and miserable, left in a car, while their folks don’t come back for an hour. If I understand the story correctly, after an hour, they were notified. How long would these parents have left their kids if they weren’t notified?

    Your tough guy routine doesn’t cut it here. They should be hung up by their thumbs, until they come around.

    1. issac – I lived a little south of you in Montana and my parents would send us to the car if we misbehaved, regardless of the temperature. Nobody locked their cars so it was always open, but we could not turn it on to get heat. If one of the younger ones got in trouble, as the oldest I was assigned to sit with them. 😉

  5. At first I was confused how it could be 35 degrees in Washington until someone clarified Washington DC I didn’t read the link until afterward to see that it was also late and was dark outside. Terrible parents.

    I agree with those who think counseling for the parents and some frequent surprise health and wellness checkups to make sure that they are paying attention to their children’s needs would be better than putting them into foster care. The foster care system can be very good….or very very awful.

    I would give them a big fine and some humiliating publicity so that all of their high toned friends know what scumballs they are. I would also give them some sort of community service work with small abused children so they can see what might have happened to their children should someone break into the car and steal their babies.

    It isn’t as if they couldn’t afford a babysitter. They sound like self absorbed twits who had a sudden urge to attend a wine tasting and thought of nothing but themselves.

    Short story: When I was in my early 20’s I was at a bar where there was among the crowd drinking and dancing another young woman, who I didn’t know at all, about my age. We were all having a great time and she was flirting her @ss off……as were we all 🙂 However, someone told me that her kids were in the car outside…..at 12am! I went out side to verify and yup….there they were about 2 and 4 yrs old. They had been out there for HOURS. I went back inside (this was before cell phones were even though of) and called the police, who arrived, arrested her and removed her from the bar. I felt bad for doing it in some ways, but I couldn’t stand to see those children left out in the cold all night in a car. I also surmised that this was not the first time and sure wouldn’t be the last.

    There is NO excuse to leave your children in the car while you are partying down. NONE.

  6. Both parents should alternately spend a years worth of weekends in jail. They don’t need counseling, they need to “Get their minds right” as often said in Cool Hand Luke. The one parent not incarcerated will have the kids while the other does time. The parents should be supervised by a probation officer w/ a no alcohol or drug condition of probation, checked by random urine analysis. That’s tough w/ alcohol because traces leave the body quickly, but a smart and dedicated PO, w/ random tests, could do it.

    1. Nick – in Cool Hand Luke, Luke ends up dead. He never did get his mind right. And our jails are over-crowded as it is. We do not need these two idiots taking up space. I do like the idea of parenting classes and spot check though.

  7. Prairie Rose

    Of course, taken to extremes and made obvious to the child this will result in potentially negative results. Also kids need to be left to themselves for at least as much time that they spend in organized events. You want to have a pretty good idea of where and with whom they are left though. When you bring a child into the world, you become more responsible for the child than for your own issues. Even a career should not win out without some exceptional circumstances over the needs of a child. Most can balance the two but when it comes down to it the child’s welfare-not the child’s luxuries- should come first. There are plenty of screwed up kids that grew up in wealthy homes with disinterested parents, too busy looking in the mirror. This choice between sipping wine and leaving the kids freezing in the car for an hour is right off the charts. The parents need attention by society, whether they like it or not.

    There are lots of better ways to make a kid self-reliant and tough than neglect.

    The greatest trick is to focus on the kid and not let them realize it, until they are in their twenties, making big bucks, and then you can hit them up for a Corsair 7.5 trailerable trimaran to cruise the Keys.

  8. This is not a criminal matter in my view. There are times when a good scolding by a police officer is enough to get the message across.

  9. With more and more helicopter parents getting their kids into myriad activities afterschool, finding a baby-sitter gets harder and harder. 35 is cold but it is not killing cold. If it were 15 below in the car I would be more upset. And some toddlers cry every time mom is out of sight, it is a stage they go through.

    Do I think it was a good idea? No. Do I think they should be hung up by their thumbs? No.

  10. Is this what “Affluenza” looks like when left “untreated” in their formative years? I’m trying to imagine how they reasoned this was acceptable at any level. I seriously doubt this was the first time they used extremely poor judgement in parenting.

  11. Different Edward, but without more information, I don’t know if I agree that the kids should be permanently taken away from their parents.

    I am also annoyed that Ris, through no fault of its own, is now associated with these nitwits. For any of you traveling to D.C., it’s truly a great restaurant.

  12. Maximum penalty in an unheated cell while they are monitored occasionally.
    Those children could have. They should never be returned to such neglectful
    people who valued a wine tasting above the safety of their children.

  13. “the parent takes second place to the child”

    Issac,
    This perspective also has risks. Kids need to know they are not the center of all things, and, they need to see their parents have their own interests (parents are people, too). There needs to be a balance. However, those poor kids are neglected, and being spoiled is the least of their worries. I like your idea of a wine tasting post-bedtime. If done on the weekend it could be a slumber party!

  14. I think counseling and classes for this couple. Children are very attached to their parents, good or bad. The estrangement and upheaval in the children’s lives would do more harm to the children than it would the parents.

  15. “That would leave probation and forced counseling or classes.”
    All three seems reasonable to me.

  16. This reminds me of a Conan O’Brien joke I heard yesterday:

    “The creator of the birth control pill passed away. He leaves behind a wife and two kids he never wanted.”

  17. Parents so self absorbed and ignorant of their responsibilities should first be obligated to undergo a screening or analysis by professionals to better understand their potential to raise their kids safely or do harm to their kids. There should also be obligatory counseling and education provided in an attempt to fill in missing parts of what it means to have kids.

    Often times parents are too self absorbed in their own desires or identities to understand that the parent takes second place to the child. Taste wine at home after putting the kids to bed with stories and such. The wine tastes a lot better.

Comments are closed.