Federal Judge Hits CDC Over Withholding Data on Adverse Vaccine Reports

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) continues to resist disclosing information on claimed side effects and problems with its COVID-19 vaccines, including from healthcare workers. Due to a January order by U.S. District Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk in a Freedom of Information Act case, the CDC is being forced to turn over hundreds of thousands of “free text” entries from V-safe. The court has scolded the CDC for its continuing efforts to withhold information on these complaints.

As the CDC and the Biden White House gear up for another possible pandemic, the case reminds us that we still need to address the conduct of the government — and the reporting of the media — from the last pandemic. Once agency officials were told that they could censor those with opposing views, a culture of speech controls took hold at the CDC and the government narrative was then amplified by the media.

To question such mandates was declared a public health threat. The head of the World Health Organization even supported censorship to combat what he called an “infodemic.”

A lawsuit was filed by Missouri and Louisiana and joined by leading experts, including Drs. Jayanta Bhattacharya (Stanford University) and Martin Kulldorff (Harvard University). Bhattacharya previously objected to the suspension of Dr. Clare Craig after she raised concerns about Pfizer trial documents. Those doctors were the co-authors of the Great Barrington Declaration, which advocated for a more focused Covid response that targeted the most vulnerable population rather than widespread lockdowns and mandates. Many are now questioning the efficacy and cost of the massive lockdown as well as the real value of masks or the rejection of natural immunities as an alternative to vaccination.  Yet, these experts and others were attacked for such views just a year ago. Some found themselves censored on social media for challenging claims of Dr. Fauci and others.

The media has quietly acknowledged the science questioning mask efficacy and school closures without addressing its own role in attacking those who raised these objections. Even raising the lab theory on the origin of Covid 19 (a theory now treated as plausible) was denounced as a conspiracy theory. The science and health reporter for the New York Times, Apoorva Mandavilli,  even denounced the theory as “racist.” In the meantime, California moved to potentially strip doctors of their licenses for spreading dissenting views on Covid.

It is clear that much still has to be done to create a culture of transparency at the CDC. Judge Kacsmaryk has slammed the agency for withholding the data on the health complaints on spurious grounds. There still appears a culture at CDC in withholding data that could be used to question its decisions or conclusions.

For a year, the CDC has been fighting these efforts. The lawsuit by the Informed Consent Action Network, revealed “nearly 8% of V-safe users said they required medical care, another 12% couldn’t perform normal daily activities and yet another 13% said they missed work or school.” With limited “boxes” supplied by the CDC, people had to write in their complications. The CDC then failed to disclose those reports.

The free-text entries reportedly support one of the most controversial moves by the CDC to downplay heart complications. Litigants say that the new disclosures show a frequency of symptoms associated with myocarditis – inflammation of the the heart muscle myocardium. 

Experts raising these concerns were labeled “anti-vaxxers” and conspiracists.

As I have previously testified in Congress, the surest way to combat this culture of censorship is to pass legislation barring a single dime of taxpayer funds from being used to fund censorship efforts, including third-party groups on removing “misinformation, disinformation, and malinformation.”

The government can always speak in its own voice, but we should get the government out of the business of controlling the speech of citizens and groups. It can rebut critics on its ample platforms without using third parties to silence them as surrogates.

Additionally, Congress should demand answers on the failure of the CDC to discuss opposing views and to withhold countervailing data during the last pandemic. The loss of public confidence in both the CDC and the media could prove disastrous if we face another pandemic. The years of barring and throttling opposing views (including many later vindicated by the science) has left many Americans deeply distrustful of both the government and the media. That is a real potential health danger. If we want to prepare for the next pandemic, we need to repair that trust.

203 thoughts on “Federal Judge Hits CDC Over Withholding Data on Adverse Vaccine Reports”

  1. Give me a break. Covid was the prefect storm for the fascist left 9read: globalist left). They had an opportunity, and they seized it, and the almost destroyed *global* society as a result. Some, ignorant people will never stop wearing masks alone in their cars. Avian flu? Spare us. I grew up in a place where there are still a couple of incidences of bubonic plague very year (and I doubt the trolls that haunt here even know what Hantavirus is; it doe not exist in the cities these laptop idiots inhabit. It is lethal, and exactly zero populations have been wiped out by it in spite of ZERO interventions). This is bullsh*t. Straight up bullsh*t. The ass-backward interpretation and purpose for science that has been foisted upon us ain’t going to fly. Sorry, too much precedent. I have absolutely given up on trying to find sanity in the modern dem party. I can’t decide which is worse: the ignorance the left pushes in hopes that their ignorant and submissive base will believe it, or the base that believe it in spite of their living through much worse? I did not used to feel this way, but destroy the modern left. They are the aristocracy, they are the puppet masters, and there is no room fr them in a fair and peaceful world. Does no one on the left notice they are still alive and fine?

    The time for polite indulgence has ended. Speak your mind proudly and with confidence. Modern dems are cowards, and that is all there is to it.

    1. And I’m posting at work (yes, some of us actually work), sorry for the typos. Don’t mean to bloviate.

    2. Well said. I support the DEMS rights to take as many Covid vaccines as they want. Load up people. Just do it before November.

  2. There still appears a culture at CDC in withholding data that could be used to question its decisions or conclusions.

    Bad news for Pfizer / Biden’s White House COVID Team / CDC / FDA. Really bad. Embarrassingly bad.

    Paxlovid (combination of nirmatrelvir and ritonavir) is no better than placebo.

    Recall the Biden apparatchiks pushing Paxlovid with their non-stop panic pοrη and bludgeoning Americans, even using Biden as a guinea pig in giving him Paxlovid post COVID infection.

    October 2022, NYT:

    The Power of Paxlovid: The underuse of Covid treatments is leading to many needless deaths

    “A large chunk of deaths are preventable right now with Paxlovid alone,” Dr. Ashish Jha, the White House Covid response coordinator, told me. He predicted that if every American 50 and above with Covid received a course of either Paxlovid or a treatment known as monoclonal antibodies, daily deaths might fall to about 50 per day, from about 400 per day in recent months. Dr. Rebecca Wang, an infectious disease specialist at Dartmouth Hitchcock Medical Center, has said: “Never really in recent history for a respiratory virus can I think of an anti-viral medication being as effective, demonstrated in scientific literature, as what Paxlovid has shown.” Dr. Robert Wachter, the chair of the medicine department at the University of California, San Francisco, told me that he thought the underuse of Paxlovid was already associated with thousands of preventable deaths in the U.S. “The public doesn’t seem to understand that the evidence around hospitalization and deaths is really powerful,” Wachter said.

    https://www.nytimes.com/2022/10/07/briefing/covid-treatment-paxlovid.html

    The evidence:

    Nirmatrelvir for Vaccinated or Unvaccinated Adult Outpatients with Covid-19
    – New England Journal of Medicine

    The time to sustained alleviation of all signs and symptoms of Covid-19 did not differ significantly between participants who received nirmatrelvir–ritonavir and those who received placebo.

    Published April 3, 2024
    N Engl J Med 2024;390:1186-1195
    DOI: 10.1056/NEJMoa2309003

    It may well be that the Feds are hiding scientific data from Americans regarding all things COVID. Meanwhile Pfizer, maker of Paxlovid, made billions of dollars in selling a fake antiviral drug with Biden’s blessing.
    It seems anyone in Biden’s orbit makes lots of money….except average Americans.

    1. “Bad news for Pfizer”

      It looks like it is time for the government to spend more time investigating Ivermectin and HCQ.

  3. Just wait until we’re forced to be vaccinated again for tuberculosis.

    I saw an article saying that TB is now breaking out in the USA in migrant centers, and that over 20% of the migrants have latent TB.

    1. “Once agency officials were told that they could censor those with opposing views…”
      Who told these agency officials that they could violate American’s Constitutional rights?
      Perhaps, once conservatives regain control of Congress, we will finally get to the bottom of what really happened with the Plandemic.

    2. Don’t 4get leprosy. It’s a TB of the skin. Some TB is incurable. Unaware of any TB vax. Yep, a real disease soup. Yum

    3. “Judge Kacsmaryk has slammed the agency for withholding the data…” And, yet, the judge has put no one in the slammer over it. CDC won’t be able to print the docs fast enough for the court once they start going to jail.

  4. What are they hiding? I pity the fools that have been unable to connect the dots…

    1. If the CDC didn’t already know what’s causing the hokey pokey, they would be investigating it. Ergo, they know and are doing everything in their power to cover it up.

  5. Jonathan: Fast breaking news! It now appears that KSIC, the bonding company owned by the king of sub-prime king Don Hankey, may not be what it purports to be re the $175 million bond it gave DJT. It may be overleveraged!

    KSIC reports revenue of about $500 million. That means they are posting a bond that amounts to about 34% of their revenues. Pretty unusual. Yesterday, DJT’s lawyers posted paperwork listing the finances of two Hankey owned companies–KSIC and another company called “Knight Insurance Co., LTD”–which together claim assets of $2.6 billion. Only one problem. Only KSIC has agreed to front the DJT bond so you can’t combine the assets of two different companies to justify the bond.

    Then there are other problems with the bond. Under NY law it limits how much money a state regulated surety can post on a single bond to 10% of a bond company’s total “capital and surplus”. KSIC has only $138 million in “surplus”. That means KSIC is posting a bond that is 127% of the company’s dedicated reserves! A big red flag!

    In a bizarre move the president of KSIC, Amit Shah, went on CBS yesterday and made the claim that his company does not have to comply with NY’s capital requirements: “Knight Specialty Insurance Company is not a New York domestic insurer, and New York surplus lines insurance laws do not regulate the solvency of non-New York excess lines insurers”. Sorry, Shah, but if you want to do business in NY and with its courts you have to comply with all the laws of the state.

    See a pattern here? DJT flouts the law and KSIC is trying to do the same thing. Some how they both think they are above the law. No doubt Judge Engoron will sort out this mess at the hearing on April 22. Bottom line: If Judge Engoron finds the KSIC bond invalid, and DJT can’t find some else to post a bond for him, AG James will restart her engine and start seizing DJT’s assets. This is what happens when you get in bed with a used car salesman who specializes in bilking defrauding his customers!

    1. The case is on Appeal – Judge EnMoron no longer has jurisdiction
      And will not agin until the case is no longer before the appeals court.

      As to the rest of your nonsense.

      Revenue is NOT relevant to anything.

      Assets are.
      And yet related companies CAN combine assets – all that requires is a binding legal agreement to do so.

      You are ranting and raving because James is AGAIN engaged in the same LAWLESS conduct she was in the original case.

      You have been wrong by the numbers on this and other Trump cases from the start.
      As has James.

      How many times do you need biden slapped before you grasp that.

      I doubt any of James’s idiotic claims will hold up.

      I know this is difficult for you but Commercial mortgages are NOT subject to consumer protection laws.
      Judge EnMoron is NOT authorized to even here consumer protection cases – NY has a different set of courts for that.
      And the judicial decision that such cases could be heard without a jury was EXPLICITLY predicated on the fact that the awards would be deminimus. otherwise the constitution REQUIRES a jury trail

      You JAmes and EnMoron have been making things up as you go.

      You expect that others should Trust YOU or James regarding what laws actually apply to companies in specific industries, rather then the heads of those companies ? Who had to know these things LONG before Trump.

      You and james are just throwing anbother Hissy fit – and demonstrating exactly why it was so Hard For Trump to get a bond – because everyone KNEW James and EnMoron would attack them – in exactly the same stupid ways as they went after Trump for made up nonsense in the first place.

      There are 10,000 ways this case may die, and none that it will survive.

      What will not be fixed is the damage James and EnMoron have caused in the process.

      James claimed to be protecting the profits of the companies that Deal with Trump.
      What she is actually doing is HARMING those profits.

    2. Absolutely someone Forbes assesses as worth 6.4B (as of 3/25/2024). Who is being backed by Don Hanky – according to Forbes worth 7.4B (as of 4/5/2024) aregoing to default on a 175M bond and allow James to start confiscating their property ?

      Are you NUTS ?

      There is litterally no reason at all Trump should have to post ANY bond. If Trump were to lose and even attempt to default on judgement – neither of which will happen, James now has nearly $15B in assests – 100 times the amount of the bond that she can go after.

      This is moronic stupidity from James and just efforts to waste more time and money.

      BTW Hanky claims that Trump secured the bond with CASH. In other words Trump turned over control of $175M in bank acounts to Hankey.

      The bond is fully secured. A 100 times over.

    3. Yes, we see a pattern here. What most people WITH A BRAIN see is that these partisan, unethical, corrupt judges, prosecutors and DAs are undermining the integrity of the entire justice system. And they DO NOT CARE.

      These malicious prosecutions are ONLY about interfering in the election, stopping Trump from being reelected, damaging candidate Trump by hanging the words “convicted felon” around his neck. Period. None of these cases are about administering “justice.” They are bogus. All of them should be thrown out.

      Then this lunatic judge Engoron, corrupt DA Tish James, and all the rest of the nut jobs, including moron Bragg, corrupt Willis, deranged Jack Smith should be investigated, disbarred and tossed in prison. That’s a fact.

      Our entire system of justice and government depends on consent of the governed, and on public faith in the integrity and legitimacy of the “system.’

      Thanks to this outrageous cast of corrupt partisans, a critical mass of the public can now smell the odor of mendacity, and see all of this for what it is: outrageous political law fare and election interference!

      When the “system” no longer has credibility, the system breaks down, it becomes illegitimate, unable to function, and it is replaced by Rule of Man. Rule By Force. Tyranny.

      This is exactly what is happening here. And again, the Democrats DO NOT CARE.
      They are willing to burn it all down. Just to hold onto power and stop Trump.
      And it is WRONG. What they are doing is WRONG.

      1. When the “system” no longer has credibility, the system breaks down.
        It becomes illegitimate, and it is replaced by Rule of Man. Rule By Force. Tyranny.
        We clearly no longer have a functioning justice system — if we ever did.
        Joe Biden and his corrupt and lawless DOJ are trying to throw his political opponent in prison and bankrupt him. And also prosecute, disbar, bankrupt and destroy everyone in Trump’s orbit — guilty by association.
        This is where we are, America. Our republic is teetering on the edge of collapse.
        Thanks Joe Biden.

  6. Let’s be real. FOIA rules do nothing but allow the government to hide information from the public. ALL GOVERNMENT WORK, including emails, data, text, etc…. ANYTHING GENERATED BY GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES should be IMMEDIATELY PUBLICLY AVAILABLE. Of course, defense, intelligence sources & methods info would be exempt.

    1. Anonymous said: “Of course, defense, intelligence sources & methods info would be exempt.”

      Sorry, that’s naive, at best (trying to be generous). If that requirement became law, along with your postulated exceptions, you would quickly find that anything that could possibly cause a public official embarrassment (or worse) would magically become part of one of your exempt classes.

  7. April 5, 2024 A Turbo Cancer “Dual Diagnosis” Phenomenon in the COVID-19 Vaccinated Ten couples who both got cancer

    Feb. 2024 – Grapevine, TX – Tiffany Branum was diagnosed with brain cancer. Months later her husband Scott Branum was diagnosed with brain cancer. On October 4 2023, Tiffany started feeling bad.

    https://www.globalresearch.ca/turbo-cancer-dual-diagnosis-phenomenon-covid-19-vaccinated/5854004

    https://www.globalresearch.ca/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/turbo-cancer-couple.jpeg

  8. Professor Turley notes that “Litigants say that the new disclosures show a frequency of symptoms associated with myocarditis – inflammation of the the heart muscle myocardium.”
    When I went for the last of the COVID booster vaccines (Oct ’22), I mentioned to the pharmacist that I had (for the first time in my life) experienced cardiac arrythmias (skipped beats/PVCs/heart palpitations) and asked if there were any association with the vaccines? He said he knew of none.
    I am a healthy, fit person with no Hx of cardiac issues. A few weeks later, I asked a second pharmacist at a different location; she likewise said she had heard of none. —This, despite apparently “internal” recorded and reported incidence of same to CDC…
    I did not want to visit a medical facility (at the height of the pandemic) and chose to not seek Tx but instead “stay on top of the symptoms” in case they worsened.
    All symptoms ceased/resolved without further ado or sequelae. In my heart of hearts, I know they were related to the vaccines.
    Bottom line: loss of trust.

    1. The CDC is covering up their negligent homicide. They had overwhelming evidence of harms as above and hid that information from the public so they could keep their masters in the biosecurity blob happy. They killed people through failure to act. They conspired with other facets of government to censor truthful information that could have saved lives. Every decision-maker needs to go to jail for a long time, and every enabler needs to go to jail for a lesser sentence but a severe sentence. These are murderous thugs in bureaucrat suits.

      1. oldschoolcounselor said: “Every decision-maker needs to go to jail for a long time”

        From what I have read of Fauci’s conduct in RFK Jr’s book, I wouldn’t at all mind watching him be drawn and quartered in public, in spite of the 8th A. There are very, very few people I would say that about, but he was,and is, a truly revolting and reprehensible little shit.

    2. Many pharmacists and doctors knew too. Some may have been in denial, and some were ideologically driven. Some loved the extra money that was rolling in. Some relied on the government to be honest, which we know now was a tragic mistake.

    3. Lin, I have always exercised and do so now 4-5 days a week either biking or the elliptical, but about 2 years ago, maybe less, I developed AFIB??? Has anyone heard about AFIB coming from the vaccine? I got the shot and maybe 4 boosters.

      1. hullbobby: Hey, fellow cyclist, good for you! I dunno about your question, but after I learned of associative findings in medical journals, I did conclude that there were more reports of ventricular arrhythmias than atrial fib. Notwithstanding, the majority of findings simply lump all together as general “heart rhythm disorders.” (see attached link as example)
        My Hx went on for about a year, coinciding with my two Moderna mRNA vaccines as well as the boosters.
        Since they never worsened but were simply noteworthy, –and no one I talked to was familiar with any connection to vaccine, I dismissed them as electrolyte imbalances and reverted back to drinking Gatorade, etc. ( I have both a medical and legal background. But I know when to seek information from those who are more knowledgeable than I).
        Even though incidents (with NO correlation to physical activity) would recur and subside over the months, I made no mental connection to the vaccines, –as such association had been dismissed by those I asked.
        Notice that this is dated June 2023:
        https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10299473/

        Did you take mRNA vaccines? Those are more associated in findings of heart rhythm disorders, especially electrical conductivity.
        Thinking of you, lin.

          1. lin and HULLBOBBY……thank you for all of the information! This message is for you two:
            When I was a teenager in the early 1960’s, during the summers, I volunteered in a big hospital in downtown Houston as a “Candy Striper” (a volunteer nurse’s helper with a red and white striped uniform and cap) I loved it, loved pretending to be a nurse, and loved the big hospital environment (I think because of my love for the old Dr. Gillespie movies in the 40’s!!) One extremely important thing we girls were told was “NEVER give ice ( in water or tea, etc) to a heart patient!! Period”. There was a sign on the door of each heart patient in the hospital that read: “NO ICE”!!! We were told the consequences for heart patients were extremely serious.
            I am now a heart patient (A-Fib, and CHF) and have NEVER been told anything about ice; however, I recently stumbled upon an article online about heart problems and read this: (From CK Birla hospitals in India) “……..drinking cold water is considered to be one of the major triggering factors for life-threatening cardiac arrhythmia in patients who already have a heart problem. It is not only drinking cold water that you should be avoiding but also swimming in such water.”
            I know nothing about Birla hospitals and their research, but think it’s very very interesting to hear about this again, after 60 years of not thinking about it. I’ll talk to my cardiologist this week, as I have always put tons of ice in my water glass, all day long…(and having A Fib problems again, I have now stopped with the ice!)

            1. Cindy, as someone who has a mother (94) who is a retired nurse and whose only 2 nieces are both nurse I have great admiration for the profession.

              As for the AFIB, sorry that you have it too. I developed it about 2 years ago and I had a cardio version (shock) that stabilized me for about 9 months, but since then I am in AFIB all the time. My pulse is slow due to Atenolol and I take Xarelto for blood thinning ( I have a history of blood clots as well) and my heart doc said that I will be fine due to the slow pulse and the blood thinner.

              The rest of the story is that last week my pulse was 42 and I cut the Atenolol in half and I am now on a monitor for a week and if it is still too low I will be getting a pacemaker. I always thought the low pulse was good since I exercise a ton, but we shall see.

              Thanks for your comments and I wish you well with our common malady. I still wonder if the shots put me in AFIB???

              1. hullbobby……Thank you for your reply! I am so sorry to hear about your problems.
                I take eliquis and a lot of other “stuff”! I had the cardio shock a couple of years ago…and was fine and in rhythm until 6 weeks ago…One nurse told me she thought a tooth infection that I had 6 weeks ago might have caused the AFib to act up! (They now want to do an ablation) I wouldn’t be surprised to find the vaccine caused your AFib. . BTW, although I took a biology course for student nurses in college, I couldn’t grasp chemistry, etc, so I became a public school music teacher….but I, too, have a great admiration for nurses. Stay well and good luck to you!!

              2. hullbobby P.S. I think it’s wonderful you still have your mother, and at age 94!

        1. Lin, so nice to hear that you enjoy the bike too. I played hockey until I was 40 (just high school and pick up leagues afterwards and when I got a bit too old for that I ran for about 10 years…until I needed hip replacement!!! For me the bike is a godsend because I can do it as much as I want without killing my now 2 fake hips. Biking, and the elliptical to a lesser degree, are wonderful for people that want to exercise without damaging their bones. I am not a swimmer, sadly.

          I did get the Moderna shot, so who knows if it cause the AFIB. I do know that it is a hassle whenever you need any kind of procedure.

          BTW, I have a legal background as well…and I also am back on Gatorade!

          Thanks for your super kinds words (always) and best of luck to you as well.

      2. hullbobby…….I have a combined response ( a little down the thread) for you and lin. Hope it helps.

  9. Sharyl Attkisson stays up with this well and her podcasts and articles are well footnoted. Long covid/long vax is a thing. My husband (81yo) is proof. I am devastated that I encouraged the booster just so I could take a cruise!

  10. Oh, Now, the jackboot of oppression is naughty and deserves a slapped wrist.
    What about the entire range of govermental failures to protect civil rights?
    Money and power greed displaced and killed millions and this is recompense?

  11. Do you want to read/listen to something that will keep you up at nights, in fear? If so: J H Kunstler, last week, an essay titled, This Is Not an April Fool’s Gag –

    “I had the honor of interviewing the Belgian virologist Geert Vanden Bossche on Friday for my podcast, and he had quite a sobering message. “What I am predicting,” he said, “is a massive, massive tsunami” of illness and death among highly-vaccinated populations with dysregulated immune systems.

    “You commit errors or even crimes at the very small scale, you can hide them,” he said (at around 47:00 minutes into the hour-long discussion). “I have seen this happen with the Ebola vaccination with Africa a number of years ago. . . . However, if you do this at the very large scale, like what has happened with this mass [Covid] vaccination campaign, the truth will surface. And those who have committed these crimes who have been lying to the people, who have not been taking care of the health and safety of the people, will be severely, severely punished. . . . If these people would now go out and say, ‘Yeah, wait a minute, we have been making some mistakes, it wasn’t all right, we have to correct them, we have to revise our opinion,’ these people will be stoned in the streets. . . . They can only hope that something will happen that will distract from this issue, but it won’t. . . . The truth will surface: this has been a large-scale experiment of gain-of-function on the very human population. This will be something that will be reported in history for many many generations to come.”

    A bit further on (around 55:20 minutes) he says, “You will see what will happen, for example, in the next coming weeks. . . is more and more cases of more serious long Covid. . . . They will start to replace the surge of the cancers. . . now we have a more chronic phase. It will end with a hyper-acute phase, a huge, huge wave. . . I’ve been studying this now for four years. I know what I’m talking about. I’m probably the only person, in all modesty, who understands the immunology behind this. . . . (At 1:00:12) The thing I want your audience to understand, what we will be facing in the hyper-acute Covid crisis that is imminent, is that we will have to build a completely new world. . . . It is very very clear that when this starts, our hospitals will collapse. And that means the chaos in all kinds of layers of society — financial, economic, social, you name it — will be complete. And that is what I’m very clearly predicting. . . . It’s very strange for me to make such statements, but I’m not hiding it because I’m two hundred percent convinced that it will happen.”

    Now that you’ve had an ice-cold shower, consider some further implications of this scenario. One is that the government and its public health officials may try to attribute the blame for this to the “Disease X” story they’ve been peddling for about a year, the “next pandemic,” something entirely new. That will not be true. They will be trying to cover their asses.

    —————
    There is hope! Same article”

    What, if anything, can you do to prepare for this? Dr. Vanden Bossche is also very clear: “What I can advise. . . to all these vaccinated people: they need to avoid reinfection. It is the reinfection of vaccinated people that is responsible for this situation. . . . Well, the only thing they can do — it’s very simple — is take anti-virals, of course. The only difference is, you will not be able to wait to take anti-virals until you have symptoms. . . . As soon as people see that in one of the other countries, or one of the other states in the United States, when this starts with hospitalizations going up very rapidly, they need to take anti-virals prophylactically, not wait until they have any symptoms. I’m in Belgium. If it starts in the US, or starts in Israel, or starts in the UK, I bet you that within a few days, you will see the same scenario in many of the highly-vaccinated countries.”

    By “anti-virals,” Dr. Vanden Bossche means specifically Ivermectin, the Nobel Prize-winning drug that the FDA and the CDC demonized brutally in order to distract the public from knowing that there was a safe and effective treatment for Covid. To acknowledge that would have vacated Pfizer’s and Moderna’s Emergency Use Authorization, which allowed them to make tens of billions of dollars on a very poorly tested pharma product while enjoying blanket protection against lawsuits.

    “I have been predicting already a half a year ago, that the public health authorities are finally going to have mandates for ivermectin.” Dr. Vanden Bossche said. “The results with ivermectin are fabulous. It is very safe. It is the only anti-viral that is cost-effective, that is widely available, that can be supplemented in sufficient quantities. . . . There is simply no alternative.”
    ————
    On the bright side, maybe since the Democrat/Left/Woke folks vaxxed like there was no tomorrow, their ranks will be decimated. Kinda reminds me of that thing in Africa – in 1856. You should read this, for fun, and for possible insight:

    https://digitalscholarship.unlv.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1006&context=psi_sigma_siren

    1. Floyd: (although Vanden Bossche is a DVM I believe), take a look at his “The emergence of cryptic lineages.”
      A most fascinating view, especially regarding viral mutations/immune escape.

      1. Yes, he said that he was trained in veterinarian medicine during the podcast. I will look up your suggestion! Thx!

  12. Jonathan: This is your intrepid reporter back with an update on the $175 million bond posted by Knight Specialty Insurance Co, a little known California bonding company owned by Don Hankey, the king of subprime car loans. In my comment (4/04/24@2:10pm) I pointed out that the NY Appellate Division Clerk rejected the bond as defective and required KSIC to submit a financial statement.

    This came to the attention of AG James who filed a motion with Judge Engoron yesterday. She pointed out that KSIC is not recognized in NY under the state’s insurance law as a legitimate bonding company. In her motion James “takes exception to the sufficiency of the surety to the undertaking” and asks Judge to order KSIC “to file a motion to justify the surety bond” and to provide further information about the collateral provided by DJT. Judge Engoron has ordered a hearing for 4/22 on James’s motion. That should be interesting.

    Why is this important? It shows DJT could not get a bond from any other legitimate bonding company in NY–maybe because he has been adjudged someone who engages in persistent business fraud and his CFO is going to jail for fraud and perjury? So he had to turn to a used car dealer to bail him out.

    Why would Don Hankey agree to post a bond for someone who is such a poor credit risk? It’s Hankey’s business model–he loans to people who have little or no credit. What’s in it for Hankey? He will get his pound of flesh. He will charge DJT huge fees–maybe up to $10 or $15 million. Beyond that Hankey will want something else from his client. As a political backer of DJT and a contributor to his campaign, Hankey probably wants something else. If DJT gets back in office Hankey expects a quid pro quo–maybe relief from frequent DOJ lawsuits over his unlawful lending practices?

    The bottom line is that in the 270 yr. history of the country we have the first candidate for President who is up for sale–every bit of him. Do we want a Presidential candidate who is financially compromised, judged a rapist, has gone bankrupt and is beginning his first criminal trial in 10 days?

    1. Dennis, have you ever responded with anything even close to the subject of the piece you’re commenting on?

    2. Dennis – you are telling us we should be worried about a future President who MIGHT be beholden to an American businessman, while ignoring the fact that we have a President now who IS beholden to the most dangerous opponent of America in the world.

    3. Dennis is a moron. Adjudged a rapist–let’s take a deeper look, a moonbat, E Jean Carroll concocts some story–can’t even pick the date, and we’re supposed to care about what this says about Trump. It’s an out of control legal system.

      1. “out of control legal system” like a jury, or a Grand Jury. Right? Yeah, their are out of control all right, wait till The Dear Leader terminates the constitution.

        1. Seriously? Have you lost your mind? Do you really think that the E. Jean Carroll suits are at all ok when it comes to the rule of law? She couldn’t even remember the year. And Donald has to fork over millions? Come on. Even you cannot be so partisan as to be ok with it.

    4. LOL Fiction and laughable fiction at that. Put down the koolaid, pal.

    5. What the DOJ (along with the CIA and FBI) and NY ‘justice’ have done and are doing to Trump, for PURELY political reasons, is a terrifying example of what this country once abhorred about the USSR and China. NONE, absolutely ZERO of these cases would have been brought, were he not running for President. HOW could red blooded Americans want to forfeit the Constitution, American sovereignty and freedom, and allow the Globalist/Marxist/Democrat/anti-American/anti-Constitution cabal, foreign and domestic to openly and with glee, smash our Justice system?

      The Russia Hoax was a lie and a fraud cooked up by Hillary and her cadre which includes all if the 3 letter groups, and outside operators. Before the election, you ‘might’ be able to pass it off as a vile campaign action, but after the election, it became an attempted coup, it wrecked the lives of people that had done nothing wrong. Trump is accused of other malfeasance that he did openly, not in secret, and in almost all cases the ‘crime’ is a matter of opinion. Example: The papers Trump took when he left office were his to choose and take, BY LAW. Because of how the left works, I believe the papers ‘the government’ wanted to retrieve, the documented proof of their ILLEGAL and TREASONOUS actions against Trump and members of his administration. We will never know, and NO ONE was really punished or tried for these gross crimes against the American people’s duly elected President, much less be accused, or the crimes given their correct names. Contrast and compare with the treatment of those involved with Jan 6, the Democrats at it again with the Hollywood choreographed show trial commission in which all exonerating information and witnesses were NOT allowed to be heard, and the committee records to that effect, were destroyed!

      And for the record, Biden has sold out this country six ways to Sunday, either at the direction of the Chinese and Globalists, or by default, for profit. (Who could question the quid pro quo of shutting down our oil sales while pumping up Barisma?) I believe a real National Security Treason case could be brought on several fronts. Oil, the border, the Chinese sellout deals, the Ukrainian deals, and more.

  13. The most concerning aspect of medicine today in the US is now a reality in the UK.

    This morning I had a lengthy conversation with a young surgeon while doing cardio on a treadmill. Since we were both exercising side by side, we talked shop. It ended with the theme that Professor Turley raises: politicization of medicine by Biden’s handlers / Leftist apparatchiks and subsequent decline in academic medicine (research and discovery)

    Today’s medical education (meded) pipeline is not encoraging. MD students and trainees are being groomed as Marxist “equity” front line guardians at the expense of scientific acumen. As regular readers on here know, I argued in 2020-2021 that COVID had less to do with a killer virus than an individual’s immune system genetic fitness. Problem is few MD trainees are taught nor encouraged to understand the ever changing paradigms within the field. Time was when the immune system was thought to be little more than a quaint feature that caused allergies and produced antibodies. HIV / AIDS opened the eyes of scientists and academic physicians and showed that they knew next to nothing about the immune system, e.g. T cells.

    We are still stuck in ancient medical paradigms. As I argued on here 3-4 years ago, our immune system is well equipped to handle whatever pathogens are thrown at it. Evolutionary pressures are like that. A minority number of individuals have what is called SNPs – single nucleotide polymorphisms. Receptors are like a keyhole in a door, and viruses are like a key. Receptors can catch the viruses and kill them. However some individuals have jagged keyholes (receptors) where the virus will not fit, and consequently the receptor is nonfunctioning. Innate immune cells like monocytes, macrophages, dendritic cells, and neutrophils are veritable arsenals of explosive munitions that can obliterate just about anything. However, the offending agent (e.g. virus) has to be recognized by the innate immune cells pattern recognition receptors (PRRs). PRRs are made of proteins and proteins are made of amino acids. One single amino acid substitution can alter a protein, esp a PRR, making it a liability. Sickle cell disease is caused by a single amino acid substitution, making the protein Hemoglobin, malfunctioning. If future physicians are more fluid on WOKE, DEI and Marxist language instead of epigenetics, immunology and protein chemistry, everyone suffers just like the current situation in the UK

    It is clear to immigrants who fled authoritarian nations that America is following the same trajectory, and with Professor Turley’s article on the CDC and “Biden’s regime”, to quote OLLY, Americans need to practice preventative medicine and embrace fitness ASAP. This is no time to throw caution to the wind regarding obesity, metabolic disorders, sedentary behaviors, isolation and lack of fitness. Trusting future physicians and public health to be up to date on evidenced based medicine, is not supported by current trends in medicine in America

    Rx:

    Lose weight below a BMI of 25
    Exercise like your life depends on it
    Abandon all addictions including sedentary behaviors
    Strengthen and create personal relationships in your community – you may need them and vice versa

    Also, get current on all recommended vaccines as your physician directs.

    The clinical academic workforce is ageing and without intervention to train and retain a new generation of medical academics, the UK risks its ability to contribute to scientific research, improve patient care and educate an increasing number of medical students as set out in the government’s Long Term Workforce Plan. New data published by the Medical Schools Council continue to show concerning trends within the clinical academic workforce.

    https://www.medschools.ac.uk/news/investment-in-clinical-academia-needed-to-deliver-medical-expansion

    Schröder, N.W. and Schumann, R.R., 2005. Single nucleotide polymorphisms of Toll-like receptors and susceptibility to infectious disease. The Lancet infectious diseases, 5(3), pp.156-164.

    Mockenhaupt, F.P., et al. 2006. Toll-like receptor (TLR) polymorphisms in African children: common TLR-4 variants predispose to severe malaria. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 103(1), pp.177-182.

    El-Bendary, M., et al. 2018. The association of single nucleotide polymorphisms of Toll-like receptor 3, Toll-like receptor 7 and Toll-like receptor 8 genes with the susceptibility to HCV infection. British Journal of Biomedical Science, 75(4), pp.175-181.

    Texereau, J., et al. 2005. The importance of Toll-like receptor 2 polymorphisms in severe infections. Clinical Infectious Diseases, 41(Supplement_7), pp.S408-S415.

    Yucesoy, B., et al. 2009. Influence of cytokine gene variations on immunization to childhood vaccines. Vaccine, 27(50), pp.6991-6997.

    Pan, L., et al. 2014. A genome-wide association study identifies polymorphisms in the HLA-DR region associated with non-response to hepatitis B vaccination in Chinese Han populations. Human molecular genetics, 23(8), pp.2210-2219.

    1. Estovir, Excellent post except for,

      “Also, get current on all recommended vaccines as your physician directs.”

      You missed the part about no longer being able to fully trust what you call ‘recommended vaccines’. Read lin’s informative post above about cardio problems after getting the vaxx and ignorance of pharmacists and other professionals on those already acknowledged problems.

    2. Estovir,
      Great comment!
      Thank you for that reminder or advice.

    3. Estovir said” “Also, get current on all recommended vaccines as your physician directs.”

      How can you possibly make that unqualified recommendation, considering the recent experience with COVID vaccines (the very subject of Turley’s column here)? Nearly all physicians uncritically directed that all of their patients receive those vaccines.

      1. I provided six (6) citations of dated, unbiased, respected medical journals, all highly cites. 6!

        And here you are asking such an asinine question. But of course.

        1. Estovir– I wondered how Pfizer employees were doing with the vaxx and learned that early on they were required to get the jab OR get weekly testing. So I don’t think we know how many people making this Frankenstein drug were willing to have it injected.

          Naturally we would expect Pfizer management to get it as soon as possible so their important work can continue.

          But NO. They didn’t want to jump in line.

          https://www.cnbc.com/2020/12/14/pfizers-ceo-hasnt-gotten-his-covid-vaccine-yet-saying-he-doesnt-want-to-cut-in-line.html

          ” CEO Albert Bourla hasn’t received his company’s Covid-19 vaccine shot yet, saying Monday he and other executives will not “cut the line” as U.S. officials kick off a massive effort to distribute the vaccine across the country.” 2020 article.

          It’s almost as if they didn’t believe their own b.s.

          1. My father never made it past 3rd grade, my mother 6th grade. None of my family in Cuba finished high school. My parents told me they wanted me to be what they were never afforded: educated, intelligent, the use of reason.

            You could have saved me time 2+ years ago when we first disagreed about medical issues, by telling me you believe pigs fly, the moon is made of cheese and you wont believe in any darned facts because youre infinite wisdom runneth over. I would respect you more if you admitted you relish wallowing in ignorance, even if my parents were ashamed they were not educated. In my book they were wise beyond their years. Alas, I can say neither about you

            On a happy note, Alex Jones sells alot of nutraceuticals that supposedly makes him more “manly”, have virility like Superman and his member bigger. I promise I will not present to you in the future any more scientific studies, I will never reference evidenced based data, nor will I stop you from being an ass. Alex Jones seems to do well in spite of these, and he had quite a few suckers believers

            Here is the Alex Jones link for you to buy those products

            https://www.infowarsstore.com/

            You are the face of ignorant conservatives, but you probably wear that like a badge, naturally

            1. Estovir to Young: “You could have saved me time 2+ years ago when we first disagreed about medical issues, by telling me you believe pigs fly, the moon is made of cheese and you wont believe in any darned facts because youre infinite wisdom runneth over. I would respect you more if you admitted you relish wallowing in ignorance,”

              Your reply to Young was non-responsive and insulting to others while revealing your unpleasant side. Young’s response had a fair question, but your knee-jerk reaction is to demean a group because you don’t agree with their politics.

      2. Number 6, You made essentially the same point that I did with the added spice of noting that Estovir missed the very point of Turley’s article.

        I was amused to see that his not very gracious reply to you was that his little pile of citations settled the issues.

        They don’t.

        Like the media and the powerful tech sites, Facebook etc, the journals have disgraced themselves by winnowing information to favor the experimental vaxx and hide or attack successful treatments like Ivermectin. If huge amounts of money are involved they are no longer to be trusted to the extent they once were. A citation to one of those journals convinces me of nothing until it is examined with skepticism.

        We didn’t get the vaxx here and I am still a bit surprised that so many did. It takes only a moment, just an instant, of critical thinking to inspire hesitation.

        A drug company that expects to make billions insists its concoction is ‘safe and effective’ and will back it 0% demanding full immunity from harms it may cause while rushing through abbreviated testing [no details] and peddling it under an Emergency Use Authorization [EUA] while pretending no alternative treatment [Ivermectin] exists.

        Then the Karens who rage that if you are pregnant a half glass of wine or second-hand smoke is extremely dangerous insist that you get injected with this Frankenstein jab.

        And yet, so many people went along with this s**t show and got the jab. Now almost everyone knows at least one person who reports vaxx injuries.

      3. Number 6, there is no problem with your comment. The government and its experts’ attempt to prevent discussion of COVID and force its use made the public suspicious of its mandates and suggestions. This discussion is, in part, a continuation of the disagreement seen about six months ago between Young and Estovir. The evidence is mounting on Young’s side, and maybe Estovir didn’t watch his words carefully enough then.

  14. What excellent, well-written piece Professor Turley! As the English would say: “It is spot-on.”

    Every American should read this, but I most fervently hope that all of all Supreme Court Justices read it before they make their ruling on Murthy v. Missouri.

  15. The CDC should be put in front of a firing squad, firing, not bullets, but vaccine-filled syringes. Just a thought….a happy thought.

  16. Prof Turley is too kind in saying that there are now questions about the validity of the government’s “suggestions”. It is fairer to say that is clear that the idea of closing down schools and businesses was disastrous, causing damage that is still being felt. American kids have lost learning time that may not be recoverable. Every day businesses are going out of business, blaming the COVID closings for part of their problems. Maybe the first step we can take is to stop worshiping the words “expert” and “scientist”. We are all stupid or even dishonest to some extent whatever our degrees or titles.

  17. For all you Vax guinea pigs.
    Ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine work. They lied to you. Look at the increase in cancer rates since the mRNA experimental vaccine. Good luck.

    1. At least I would know what sodium hypochlorite would do to my body as I swim in it in my pool annually. We drink it in our tap water daily as a disinfectant. Can you tell me exactly what was in the so call mRNA vaccine shot and boosters? Have you read the reports on some of the side effects like turning off T cells, you know the ones that eat cancer cells? Enjoy your poison dipwad.

  18. My fear is that the hateful Democrats will mandate that US Citizens take a drug for the next CRISIS that will also have the “ingredients” in it to solve a number of their so-called highest priorities, like
    Overpopulation (climate change ingredient},
    “White Supremacy” – Men, Christians and Jews.

    Naturally the white male Democrat donors, members of the FBI, DOJ, CIA, Congress, Loyal Media toadies, and families will get the alternate vaccination.
    I just don’t trust anyone that has to rule by executive order and brute force.

    1. Anonymous said: “mandate that US Citizens take a drug for the next CRISIS that will also have the “ingredients” in it to solve a number of their so-called highest priorities”

      Just pray that the Deep State hasn’t perfected an MK-Ultra follow-on, or some equivalent, long term, independent-thought-sapping drug. If they have, I’d give you 70-30 odds that substance will be part of the next mass inoculation.

  19. This is going to be painful. No matter if the CDC is hiding things or not does not really matter. No matter what happens, the conspiracy theorists will scream loud and hard it is not all released. This is not going to get better anytime soon.

    I will not second guess trying to work through the fog of war during the early days. However, it is gas past the time to withhold information. The only way to learn is through lessons learned from mistakes. If those mistakes are hidden, it will happen again. I personally doubt there was nefarious intentions from any medical leaders. I am more than willing to bet that they had nothing but good intentions. Yet, it only harms in the long run by hiding what needs to see the light of day.

    Lance this boil and let the healing begin.

  20. I disagree that we need to repair trust in government agencies; quite the contrary. We need to stop blindly trusting that the government, or the media, or the WHO or NATO or the WEF or the CIA or whatever it is, wants what’s best for us and start to use those inconvenient things that hold up our hair, i.e., our brains.

    I was following the news from France early in the “pandemic” so I knew that hydroxychloroquine worked – in fact, it was described by many as miraculous. I prayed that someone in the US would take notice, but I didn’t expect that someone to be Trump. On March 7, 2020, at a presser, he advocated for the use of HCQ to treat covid. I expected the media to reject anything Trump, but figured that saving lives would outweigh Orange Man Bad. Instead, I saw the media double down, the pharmaceutical industrial complex coming up with fake studies pretending that HCQ was some kind of dangerous experimental drug. In particular one of the claims was that HCQ was damaging to the heart, while the truth was that it was contraindicated for those with a preexisting heart condition.

    I also knew, again from French research, the Covid’s danger to children was statistically nil. They didn’t get the disease, they didn’t spread the disease, they didn’t die of the disease. When the “vaccines” (they had to change the definition of vaccine to be able to call them that) were rolled out, they forced them on adolescents and children despite knowing that their category of risk was nil. All of these things were known and reported on at the time but not by the mainstream media. If people had known, or suspected, that their children’s risk of heart disease from the shots was infinitely greater than their risk of serious disease from Covid, would they still have gotten the shots? If they had known, or been told, that the shots didn’t protect against transmission, would they still have gotten injected?

    It is clear that Professor Turley really wants to trust the government and of course, it would be nice. But it is not realistic. Our problem in this country is not a lack of trust – it is abdicating thought in favor of trust. Critical thinking is not just a right – it is a responsibility. It is a responsibility we have shirked. I hope and pray that trust in government agencies may never be restored – instead, I hope to see watchdog agencies empowered to keep an eye on government shenanigans.

    1. I also did a lot of reading around that time, and I made an informed decision NOT to get vaxxed. I am a medical shut-in, and supposedly one of the vulnerable categories. But, I continued smoking my pipe (a defence against COVID, believe it or not – something to do with nicotine, IIRC), and taking my normal meds, one of which supposedly also protected against COVID, and I never got the stuff, although exposed. I have also never gotten a flu shot, since elementary school, back in the 1960s, and I have not ever gotten the flu. I always figured flu shots made you more likely to get the flu, and now there is actually some research to back that up. I am looking for the article that said that.

    2. Our Government is a captured legislative tool for special interests Can’t resolve the issue if our politicians are fearful of their role being canceled. The Autism crisis would have been eliminated years ago if they had the guts to question the science and stop the myriad of injections our children receive. Trump signaled he wanted RJK Jr. to investigate and it sent shivers up the spine of Big Pharma. Alex Azar made sure RJK Jr never got the job done. My view!

    3. Anonymous said: “I saw the media double down, the pharmaceutical industrial complex coming up with fake studies pretending that HCQ was some kind of dangerous experimental drug. In particular one of the claims was that HCQ was damaging to the heart, while the truth was that it was contraindicated for those with a preexisting heart condition.”

      Problem was, there weren’t trillions of dollars to be made, and entire populations that could be stripped of their free will, using HCQ as a vector.

Comments are closed.