A Manhattan Canned Hunt: The Trump Jury is Out But is the Case in the Bag?

Below is my column in The Hill on the ongoing deliberations in the Trump trial. The instructions in the case raised concerns that the deliberations could become a legal version of a canned hunt, where the prey is trapped in a cage or fenced in areas to be dispatched. Elements of the instructions are disturbing in reducing what is required to convict the former president.

Here is the column:

Today the jury began its deliberations in the trial of former president Donald Trump. Before jurors left, however, Judge Juan Merchan framed their deliberations in a way that seemed less like a jury deliberation than a canned hunt.

For many of us, the Trump trial has seemed otherworldly, a vaguely familiar proceeding where common elements of a trial seem to have been flipped.

Even before the jury instructions, the trial was controversial for both liberal and conservative commentators. At the start of closing arguments, most honest observers were still wondering what the prosecutors were alleging as to the crime that Trump was allegedly concealing with the falsification of business records.

Then came the closing arguments. Around the country, it is standard for the government to go first with a closing to allow the defense to respond. The government is then given the privilege of a rebuttal after the defense rests. In New York, the defense must go first, giving the government free rein over its closing with no risk of contradiction from the defense. With the exception of objections, any abusive or improper arguments are left to the judge to address.

In the case of Judge Merchan, that protection was all but absent as the prosecution engaged in flagrant violations from offering testimony on unestablished facts to directly contradicting prior instructions. In one of the most egregious moments, Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass told the jury that it is an established fact that former Trump counsel Michael Cohen committed a federal election law violation on the direct orders of Donald Trump. Merchan had repeatedly said that Cohen’s earlier plea could not be used to imply the guilt of Trump. Merchan overruled an objection and Steinglass proceeded, as he did earlier in trial, to repeat the false statement.

Merchan did nothing as Steinglass told the jury that Hope Hicks cried in court because she knew that she had destroyed Trump’s defense (Hicks has never explained why she cried). Merchan did nothing as Steinglass falsely told the jury that the media and political campaigns do not do what Trump did in seeking to kill and plant stories. (This ignored, for example, that the Clinton campaign did precisely that repeatedly in the very same election, including with the false Russian collusion allegations).

It was only when Steinglass repeatedly instructed the jury on the law that Merchan finally sustained objections, at the end of his closing arguments.

So going into the deliberations, the court allowed the jury to be told repeatedly that there were federal campaign violations committed by Trump. That is not true. Putting aside that the federal government found no basis to impose a civil fine, let alone bring a criminal charge, the court barred a legal expert who could have shown that no such violation occurred. The jury does not know that. Instead, the judge allowed them to be repeatedly told a false fact that could make it difficult for anyone to acquit.

However, the instructions then went in for the kill and turned the jury deliberations into a canned hunt.

Consider just a few highlights from the curious aspects of these deliberations.

First, the judge has ruled that the jury does not have to agree on what actually occurred in the case. Merchan ruled that the government had vaguely referenced three possible crimes that constitute the “unlawful means” used to influence the election: a federal election violation, the falsification of business records, and a tax violation. The jurors were told that they could split on what occurred, with four jurors accepting each of the three possible crimes in a 4-4-4 split. The court would still consider that a unanimous verdict so long as they agree that it was in furtherance of some crime.

Second, the judge said that he would instruct the jury on the law but then omitted the key elements that established there was no federal campaign violation. Indeed, the blocked legal expert, Brad Smith, the former chair of the Federal Election Commission, was going to testify that this could not have been a federal election violation. Moreover, even if Trump’s legal settlement money could be viewed as a federal campaign contribution, it could not have been part of a conspiracy to influence the election since any reporting of a contribution would have had to occur after the election.

Third, not only can the jury disagree as to what occurred, but one of the three crimes is so circular as to produce vertigo in the jury room. The prosecutors zapped a dead misdemeanor back into life by claiming a violation under New York’s election law 17-152. The argument is that the crime was committed to further another crime as an unlawful means to influence the election. However, that other crime can be the falsification of business records. So the jury (or some jurors, at least) could find that some documents were falsified as an unlawful means of falsifying other documents.

Finally, Merchan is allowing conviction based on a  “general intent” to defraud “any person or entity,” a dangerously vague concept in this novel criminal case. Merchan has largely stuck to the standard jury instructions but this case is anything but standard. With an ambiguous claim of “influencing” an election, a general intent instruction without better definition to this case can be an invitation for bias.

Given the instructions and the errors in this trial, it would seem that an acquittal is almost beyond the realm of possibility. That leaves either a hung jury or a conviction. However, the framing of this case and failure to protect the rights of the defendant have undermined the perceived legitimacy of the proceedings and any possible verdict.

With Trump in a tight cage, Merchan just left it for the jury to deliver the coup de grace. We will see. I remain hopeful that a couple jurors will balk at this manufactured criminal theory. Canned hunts are great for trophies, not so much for trials.

Jonathan Turley is the J.B. and Maurice C. Shapiro Professor of Public Interest Law at the George Washington University Law School.

579 thoughts on “A Manhattan Canned Hunt: The Trump Jury is Out But is the Case in the Bag?”

  1. I am not an attorney as most people who read this column know. I’m a physician and I thought that, for the most part, we and attorneys were part of 2 professions which have had reputations of fairness and minimal bias in the practice of our professions. Just as I gave the best effort I could give to save my patients, irrespective of whether they disgusted me, I thought attorneys did the same. That has certainly been my experience over the decades even as I treated many physicians, attorneys, judges, some university presidents and such. I could not even get angry with attorneys suing me for patients I once treated because the attorneys were all such consummate professionals. I must give the edge, however, to one attorney, who represented me, because she did it with such flair and humor but was otherwise a deadly opponent (on my side luckily).
    I have seen incompetent Doctors and even removed some or started and aided in the proceedings to remove others for incompetence or serious impairments.
    I have never seen attorneys, in my presence, actually proceed in such a way as I have seen in this trial or Trump’s previous trials, or judges act in such a manor and do it with a straight face. This is not incompetence but sheer malevolence and hate given free reign.
    From a medical point of view, it would be like Michael Debakey or Denton Cooley deliberately putting a prosthetic mitral valve in backwards and then telling the world that there was a compelling reason to do it but they just could not put it into words or down on paper. It was all for the greater good and the outcome on flow dynamics on the treated patient was regrettable but necessary.
    The J6 rioters stormed the wrong building. Maybe they should have aimed for a building a little further north where there is this huge Statue in the harbor commemorating the best of our nation. I think her left hand is now covering her eyes and the tablets lie broken on the ground.
    This is an abomination that could undo most of what our nation stands for.

    1. This is not incompetence but sheer malevolence and hate given free reign.

      GEB, excellent comment. This blatant abuse of judicial power should alarm everyone across the political spectrum. Of course it won’t withstand appeal, but not everyone has the resources to even get to that point. Sir Thomas More stood a better chance of acquittal than Donald Trump.

    2. “They” would love for us to storm a government building. “They” are hoping for their Reichstag moment so they can crack down on us.

  2. “Judge Juan Merchan framed their deliberations in a way that seemed less like a jury deliberation than a canned hunt.” (JT)

    Merchan tells us that that mysterious blob on the prosecution’s canvas is a violation of NY Election Law 17-152. That is the formerly unnamed “another crime,” the one that somehow revived dead misdemeanors and elevated them to felonies.

    That “crime” was not named in the indictment. Was not adjudicated during the trial. The defendant, in violation of his due process rights, was not given the opportunity to defend himself from that government claim.

    That amounts to: “Surprise. Here’s your crime” — sprung on a defendant *after* the trial, by the judge, during jury instructions. That is not the American system of jurisprudence. And that is not the rule of law.

    Further, that (now) alleged “crime” is a misdemeanor, also with an expired SOL, that is inapplicable to a federal election.

    Then, to fully politicize his courtroom, Merchan tells the jury: You may or may not deliberate about that state crime. You may or may not reach a conclusion about whether the defendant is guilty of committing that crime. And you don’t have to agree unanimously that Trump is guilty of that crime.

    In a *criminal* trial. (?!)

    If you need an explanation of why that is utterly corrupt, you are beyond hope.

    1. @Sam,

      The “other crime” was indeed mentioned. Here’s an excerpt of what Judge Merchan said.

      “ The “other crime,” Merchan said, is NY Election Law 17-152, which prohibits a conspiracy to promote or prevent the election of a person to public office by unlawful means.

      The defendant must intend that the conduct be performed to prevent or promote the election of a person through unlawful means.

      “You need not be unanimous as to what those unlawful means were … you may consider: violations of FECA, falsification of other business records, violation of tax laws,” he said.”

      1. Law 17-152, which prohibits a conspiracy to promote or prevent the election of a person to public office by unlawful means.

        A business record that could not have influenced an election that already happened?

        1. @iowan2,

          Filing a FALSIFIED business record is the unlawful act. Conspiracy to PROMOTE or to prevent the election of a person. The intent to defraud occurred before the election. The conspiracy to prevent the stormy Daniels story from getting out started before the election. The conspiracy involved the intent to file the falsified documents to cover up the nature of the payments after the election. When they chose to falsify the documents everything else before the election became a crime. It was the intent to conceal the purpose of the reimbursements as “legal expenses” They wanted to cover up the act of hiding the story to keep trump’s chances (promote) of getting elected.

          1. The intent to defraud occurred before the election

            The fraud was to win an election. But the voting was over before the information was public

          2. George, you also lack evidence. No evidence is presented showing DJT’s Intent. Merchans jury instructions specifically bar the jury from inferring intent. They must have evidence. In fact Pecker provided evidence DJT was intent on protecting his image long before he ran for office.

          3. “Filing a FALSIFIED business record is the unlawful act. “

            Of course, the Speech Moron, George, recently identified the falsified business record as a check made out to Michael Cohen. Does he know what he is talking about? Of course not. He is a moron and proves it daily.

            “The intent to defraud occurred before the election. “ _ New George

            How can anything be considered an “intent to defraud” since, in this case, such an action happens after the fact when it has no value? New George copies and pastes statements and ideas without any critical thinking skills.

            “When they chose to falsify the documents everything else before the election became a crime.”

            Everything else? Ignorant people are unable to state and link those things. Like New George, they depend on rhetoric, which is stupid when analyzed. We still don’t know what was illegal, and according to New George, the falsified business record is a check signed by Donald Trump. That check was a legal everyday check.

            If New George doesn’t know the falsified document, how can he state everything else is a crime? Everything else includes going to the bathroom. Was that a crime as well? Judge Merchan is hoping for ignorant jurors, not permitted to hear from experts or all the evidence, to find Trump guilty without ever figuring out what the crime was. He enables them to guess the crime and finds that they need not agree to the nature of the crime. That is not justice,. That is finding a person to target and convicting him of a non-existent crime to get him out of the way. With Judge Merchan, NY has become the Soviet Union’s judicial state, as seen under Stalin.

            The fool continues, ” It was the intent to conceal the purpose of the reimbursements as “legal expenses” and thinks that everyday legal business practices are a crime. The jurors haven’t been permitted to hear experts on the law so they can understand what is legal or illegal.

            I pray for at least one juror to see through the fog and recognize the indecency of what is happening. If that doesn’t occur, no matter who wins or loses the election, a giant hole will seep through the judiciary system and destroy the rule of law.

    2. Sam,
      Oh, but they do.
      This is a kangaroo court, with a biased, corrupt judge and a jury who had already made up their minds before even walking into the court building.

  3. Trump will still win. The worse and more unjust the verdict, the greater will be his margin of victory.

  4. President Trump has a problem of his own making but his problem is not criminal

  5. On Tueday, the US Treasury had what we call in the industry a failed auction of 7 year US Treasury Notes. The main reason is because foreign buyers of our debt did not show up. I believe that happen because of lost of faith in our legal system brought on by this trial. Yesterday the US market tanked as people pull their money out of this country. The implications of this corrupt judge and trial will be felt for decades in a lower living standard for everyone except the very ultra rich.

    1. Epstein, I did not delve into that part of the news, but what you say is something we should be concerned about. America’s reputation has been compromised. The only solution is for every law-abiding citizen to vote for Trump and to keep vigilant, as the left is not concerned with the law. No Democrat, even if a good person, should get anyone’s vote. The Democrat Party must be destroyed and replaced.

    2. Epstein did not kill himself said: “The main reason is because foreign buyers of our debt did not show up. I believe that happen because of lost of faith in our legal system brought on by this trial.”

      As terrible as the conduct of this trial has been, can you seriously be suggesting that it has more to do with the Treasury auction failure than the abysmal condition of the Federal financial empire, including the national debt and the interest thereupon, and the desire of the BRICS nations to capitalize on the incompetence and corruption of those responsible for running that empire to displace the USD as the default international reserve currency? If so, I thank my stars that I don’t depend on you for investment advice.

  6. The mission goals and objectives of this farce is to convict, no matter what. No matter how bizarre. They know it will be overturned on appeal. There is no case. But that does not matter to them.

    All they want is to call the former President “a convicted felon” during the campaign. They are desperate.

    They have no platform or accomplishments to stand on. The diminished Joe does nothing unless he is told to read something. Otherwise he spends his days in his beach home. The world is without a leader and it is heading for the cliff.

    What a surreal, destructive display of rage and hatred.

    1. All they want is to call the former President “a convicted felon” during the campaign. They are desperate.

      Absolutely, E.M! From the moment he came down that escalator, they’ve (the Blob) salivated over the possibility of calling him anything other than President of the United States. From the Russia collusion hoax, where they wanted to call him a traitor and puppet of Putin. The Ukraine BS QPQ and J6 conspiracy to call him a twice impeached President. To this abomination where they are sounding the alarm that Trump will be a dictator and our democracy will be over. I’ve never purchased any Trump merchandise, but if he is convicted, I will be the one salivating at the opportunity to buy his “Convicted Felon for President” t-shirt and proudly where that in support of his election. I won’t be alone.

  7. If only one honest citizen on that jury stands the tide of prog/left corruption, they will have a place in history as the last honest person in NYC.

        1. “Where is a Nathan Hale when you need one?”

          He’s being hung in a New York courtroom.

          By the same power-lusting ilk who hanged a great patriot.

    1. If only one honest citizen on that jury stands the tide of prog/left corruption, they will be replaced by Merchan on Monday morning. I suspect that is all the time he will give the jury to come up with a “guilty of something” verdict.

  8. Are you up for it, New York?
    New York is the party trial here. We will now see what the citizens are made of….

  9. So who will bring this group (Judge & Prosecutor) to justice? Should Red State prosecutors bring charges against Hillary, Obama, Strozk, Paige, Comey and Mush for Brains for something they make up? This country is in a great deal of trouble brought us by the Democrat party aka Marxist party.

    1. I too seek revenge by mirror tactics.

      The problem is Conservative Judge follow the law.

      So its DOA before it gets launched

  10. NYL 17-152 makes it a misdemeanour to conspire to influence an election by unlawful means. I’m not even sure it applies to Federal elections, but assume it does.

    It is not at all clear how a falsification of business records or a tax violation could have influenced the election, even if unlawful. Yet those are two of the three options the jurors have to consider. So far as I am aware, the prosecution made no arguments on this, there are no facts in evidence about it and the elements of these crimes have not been specified.

    Brad Smith would have said that paying consideration for an NDA in these circumstances was not a campaign contribution. Yet the limitations the judge put on his testimony would not have permitted this, so the defense did not call him. The jury is thus reliant on limited testimony and prosecutorial assertions about Pecker and Cohen’s deals with prosecutors to intuit a violation, even though their conduct is not evidence of Trump’s guilt.

    Finally, the idea that affirmative votes of jurors on the three possibilities may be aggregated to get to twelve, when there is no unanimity, and perhaps even no majority, in favour of any one of them, is almost certainly a violation of the due process clause of the 14th amendment of the US Constitution.

    Trump is right that Merchan has “rigged” this trial.

      1. “Rigged is the key word here.”

        Correct, Upstate. What differentiates America from despotic nations is that the system is not supposed to be rigged. Democrats are intent on rigging elections, whether it be through cheating or arresting the opposition. That sounds bad (lethal to our system) because it is.

    1. Daniel said: “NYL 17-152 makes it a misdemeanour to conspire to influence an election by unlawful means. I’m not even sure it applies to Federal elections, but assume it does.”
      Would a deliberately malicious, false, and frivolous prosecution to achieve that influence count?

      1. Unfortunately I suspect doctrines of immunity for official acts would protect the judge and the prosecutors. Mike Davis has been arguing that they should be indicted under the federal statute against deprivation of rights. That may fail for the same reason.

  11. I would be interested in your opinion on the similarities between this case and the J6 cases. Those too seem like a canned hunt.

  12. so why aren’t the bidens all in jail for taking bribes from China, Ukraine, etc?

  13. will it be another $1/2 Billion Dollar fine? As the Rule of Law, why not $10 Trillion and life in jail with no parole?
    And yet the Republicans CONTINUE to FUND the criminal Fascist Democrats…why?

  14. question…when can a JUDGE and or DA go to jail for their conduct?
    As the RULE OF LAW IS DEAD?

    1. The second crime which has been left a mystery is Extortion, and the victim of this crime was Donald Trump. This case is a malicious prosecution to an extreme degree of Evil.

  15. Merchan didnt bother to tell the jury what “general intent” means. He implied that it means there doesnt have to be a victim or intended victim. Defraud is not arson. Defraud is not DUI. Defraud is not reckless driving. Defraud specifically and generally requires a victim.

    That is a reversible error, and an egregious one.

    1. Defauding the public to win an election undermines the consent of the governed. To obtain that consent through trickery and deceit is vile and despicable. Handing over governing power to the untrustworthy paves the road to tyranny, so it is impossible that the 1st Amendment goes so far as to allow candidates to deliberately dupe the voters to garner their votes.

      That said, prosecution is totally the wrong approach.

      The Constitution only allows civil lawsuits toward keeping the campaign infospace reliable. That’s because dueling was outlawed after the tragic death of A. Hamilton, and defamation lawsuits replaced it as the way to confront those who intentionally lie to sway public opinion.

      We are dangerously close to being a mendocracy….a country where the most compelling liars rise to power. Restoring honor and trust in the public sphere will require a firm intolerance to dissembling and deceitful opinion-shaping operations. But again, not through prosecutions — through lawsuits brought by citizens.

      1. Defauding the public to win an election undermines the consent of the governed.

        How does an action, that would not become public until after the election, influence an election?

    2. @anonymous,

      No, it’s not a reversible error. It’s based on NY law which defines “Intent to defraud” very broadly and it’s supported by several NY cases. Merchan did not imply it. He defined it according to how NY law has defined it a long time. If you doubt that is the case here’s a good explanation about that issue.

      https://www.justsecurity.org/85831/the-broad-scope-of-intent-to-defraud-in-the-new-york-crime-of-falsifying-business-records/

      “ So, how does New York State law define the “intent to defraud” for the criminal offense of falsifying business records? A long line of New York state court cases supports an expansive conception with respect to § 175.00 crimes – namely, that intent can be established when a defendant acts “for the purpose of frustrating the State’s power” to “faithfully carry out its own law.” People v. Kase, 76 A.D.2d 532, 537–538, 431 N.Y.S.2d 531, 534 (N.Y. App. Div., 1st Dept. 1980), aff’d, 53 N.Y.2d 989, 441 N.Y.S.2d 671, 424 N.E.2d 558 (1981).

      On this standard, the law does not require prosecutors to show “pecuniary or potential pecuniary loss” to the government or otherwise. Id. Indeed, New York Jurisprudence (Second Edition 2023) in a section titled, “Indictment or information charging falsification of business records,” states: “In an indictment for first degree falsification of business records, the grand jury presentation is not required to establish commercial or property loss.”

      Applying this broad concept of “intent to defraud” in false business records cases, New York state courts have found such intent in a wide range of cases including when a defendant: made covert contributions to a political campaign, covered up an alleged rape, misled the relatives of a patient about the individual’s treatment, operated a motor vehicle without a license, obtained credit cards through false documents but with no proof of intention to miss payments, frustrated the regulatory authorities of the New York City Transit Authority, and much more. We detail all these judicial opinions below.

      If as expected the DA charges former President Donald Trump with falsifying business records to conceal hush money payments as campaign finance or election law violations, that will fit the test, with government authorities being frustrated in their ability to regulate elections. Nor is the harm limited to them.

      Falsifying hush money payments as legal services frustrated New York State authorities’ more broadly. New York firms are required to “keep correct and complete books and records of account” for the purposes of state regulators and tax authorities, N.Y. Bus. Corp. Law § 624 (McKinney). Indeed, New York Tax Law allows for tax commissioners “to examine or to cause to have examined…any books, papers, records or memoranda” of a corporation “bearing upon the matters to be required in the return.” N.Y. Tax Law § 1096(b)(1) (McKinney). Thus any book or record kept by a private corporation is subject to public exposure, and New York law requires these books to be accurate.

      In short, the Manhattan DA’s case rests on firm legal footing.”

      1. George – is there a public duty to reveal payments to a blackmailer? I’ll help: no. Therefore the relevant records did not “defraud” anyone in the universe.

      2. Tell us how, according to you, the check was a falsified business record. You can’t, but you keep cutting and pasting, despite all the contradictions.

  16. There will be the usual suspects in these comments who claim everything that happened is totally normal, nothing unusual to see here. They will never imagine themselves or their loved ones in the defendant seat someday, subject to these style of “justice.”

    If you are among these, I pity you. The inability to look at oneself and one’s biases objectively and with humility is a moral defect which surely poisons every meaningful relationship one can have.

  17. Judge Merchan ‘s KANGROO COURT doing what he was told to do by the DEMS, make sure Trump is found Guilty of a Nothing Crime even though it will be overturned in Appeals court or Supreme Court, Bidden has already a schedule Broadcast to Gloat to celebrate etc. That tells you the Fix is in. Only fly in the ointment is a Hung Jury, I am sure the DEMS are doing everything they can to convince the Jurors to find Trump Guilty. Judge Merchan and the DEMS/Biden Admin. has ruined the Legal system. Nobody, especially in Blue States, such as NY and DC will trust the courts, all radical left. Even the BBC has declared this trial a JOKE

    1. Democrats trust the legal system to destroy their opponents….Fascism has its advantages. Especially when the Republican Party does NOTHING TO STOP THEM!

  18. Where is the outage among fellow judges over Freisler’s stunts? Not a single one protesting.

Comments are closed.