Scottish Court Rules Against Biological Males Being Held in Women’s Prisons

There is a major ruling in Scotland where a court declared that it is generally unlawful to house a transgender biological male in a women’s prison. The decision follows the ruling of the top UK court that a woman is defined by her biological gender at birth. The timing is notable as we await a couple of transgender rulings from our own Supreme Court this week. The decisions also highlight the anomaly of police continuing to arrest people who object to transgender policies under the aggressive anti-free speech laws in the United Kingdom.

In her published opinion, Lady Ross declared that “in all the circumstances, the prison’s guidance is unlawful.” The decision came after a controversy involving convicted rapist Isla Bryson – formerly known as Adam Graham. Despite being convicted of raping two women in 2023, Bryson was initially sent to the Cornton Vale women’s prison.

Scotland continues to crack down on free speech through draconian laws.

The Hate Crime and Public Order (Scotland) Act 2021 illustrates how these laws create a slippery slope of speech criminalization as more and more speech is banned. We previously discussed the law when it was first introduced.

The new crime covers “stirring up hatred” relating to age, disability, religion, sexual orientation, transgender identity or being intersex. That crime covers insulting comments and anything “that a reasonable person would consider to be threatening or abusive.”

It is enough that a person is found to have likely understood that the comments would be abusive or insulting as opposed to intending to be abusive or insulting.

Figures such as J.K. Rowling have been threatened with arrest for her public position in opposition to transgender laws.

This creates a curious conflict, as courts support such views when enforcing biological limits on access to prisons and other areas.

In the United States, there is a division on the issue. Some states, like Maine, require correctional housing to match the gender identification of the inmate rather than the biological sex at birth. Faced with lawsuits and legislative inquiries, the Maine Correctional Department continues to defend its policy. Other states have barred such transgender placement.

This coming week, we are awaiting major rulings on transgender controversies in the United States.

In Little v. Hecox,  the Court is considering whether laws that categorically require sports participants to compete based on their biological sex violate the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.

In West Virginia v. B.P.J., the Court is considering two questions: (1) whether Title IX prevents a state from limiting sports teams to biological sex at birth, and (2) whether such a limitation violates the Equal Protection Clause.

 

 

188 thoughts on “Scottish Court Rules Against Biological Males Being Held in Women’s Prisons”

  1. What about the pursuit of happiness?
    What about “live and let live”?
    What about “to each their own”?

  2. to the Pro-Terrorist Anon. at 2:34 pm et al: ‘The US has never looked smaller or weaker’ as I wrote below your post, Being On Time for a meeting is a mark of Professionalism. The Japanese believe one should even arrive EARLY & WAIT for others to be truly Professional. The Fact that the Iralian slugs were Rude & Disrespectul DOES NOT MAKE THE USA look anything but Professional. Please grow up and take your pro-terrorist remarks elsewhere to a Forum sponsored by the Woke Mind Virus… not by Prof Turley, whose Forum to-day is on: Boys & Girls Sports..

  3. Once upon a time, there were “sports”. Schools had sports teams at all appropriate levels. Since they existed in an age where feelings were less important, only the best players made these teams. Naturally, the players were all boys. Girls were not necessarily excluded, they just lacked the attributes to successfully compete with the boys.

    However, girls being girls, they wanted to do the same things that boys were doing. It was uncontroversial that they could not compete with the boys; rather they wanted a “league of their own”. This caught on widely, of course.

    My point is is that the sports were not originally cast as “boy’s” or “men’s” sports. They were just sports without a qualifier. Girl’s sports were designed to be just that: sports teams so the girls could enjoy competing on their own level.

    Nothing prohibits a girl or woman, of unusual gifts, from competing for, and winning, a position on a varsity team made up of males, if she was able to truly excel. I’m not talking about a silly spectacle like the female student at Vanderbilt attempting a field goal while everyone stands by waiting to applaud. I’m talking about true competition, not a performative display where the opposing team condescends to pull their punches for one play. If a woman is capable of putting a 100 mph fastball over the plate, she will make the team. Because they are not “boy’s” sports. They are just sports. But the pressure is never in that direction, is it?

    1. Many boys and young men will be mediocre athletes when competing in boys’ sports. That’s fine if they realize what counts is their personal efforts at improvement, playing honestly by the rules, and doing they can to avoid serious injury to themselves and others. If they are sane, well-adjusted human beings, they will be able to live with that state of affairs. It’s really not so bad.

      If, on the other hand, they are sickos, then winning will be all they care about and they will pretend to be girls as a means to that end – e.g., “Lia” Thomas. In that way, they can steal prizes from actual girls, beat the crap out of girls in sports such as volleyball, and take scholarship opportunities away from actual female athletes that have trained practically their whole lives for such opportunities.

      But that could never happen if the adults in charge behaved like actual adults and protected the girls from such usurpations. The problem arises when you get adults who are sick, twisted, evil people and allow the boys to crush the girls. Such people are the scum of the earth. They willingly fail at the only task they are charged with: protecting the sheep from the wolves. Today we call them “woke.”

      1. I agree with you, to a point. I would put it a bit differently. A sports as a cultural entity is typically defined by two sets of rules: written and unwritten (“sportsmanship”, if you will). The point is to win while complying with both sets of rules, but within that context, winning is clearly the objective. In that sense, I believe that an analogy to a correctly functioning society is sought, although frequently not achieved.

        1. Don – how about this edit:

          That’s fine if they realize what counts is their personal efforts at improvement, trying to win while playing honestly by the rules, and doing what they can to avoid serious injury to themselves and others.

      2. oldman, If you mean trans athletes crushing women, that hasn’t been the case. Not only is it rare, they often do poorly in spite of their biological structure, often because the best women are already far up the testosterone path.

        It does pose a problem of how to account for those at the extreme ends of the bell curve. There aren’t enough trans athletes to form a league of their own and they occupy a place that overlaps both traditional male and female distributions in sports. and they aren’t at the extreme ends of either curve.

        It used to be athletes competed against themselves, to be the best at what they could do. Now, oldman, you are against exactly what you just wrote you were for.

    2. Yet the Boston Marathon specifically excluded women from participating solely for being women. While the fastest women are not faster than the fastest men, it is clear that the majority of the women are faster than the slowest men.

      Also – sports in school are a learning experience. Learning how to be a gracious winner as well as a gracious loser. Those making a big deal of it are low-lifes who never grew up. 99.9999% of the school athletes have no future in athletics even though they can consume considerable portions of the school budget. What a waste.

      1. School sports are a thing because most schools suck at teaching so their sports program which relies on mostly on inherent not learned talents is the only thing taxpayers like about them.

  4. A department of corrections policy of housing inmates based on gender identity rather than biological sex? That is the definition of complete and total lunacy, of mental illness in government. Woke government leaders who adopt such idiotic, insane policies should themselves be confined in an insane asylum.

    In New Jersey, they adopted that policy and sent a biological male, Demi Minor, into a female prison. Surprise! Minor impregnated two female inmates. Gee, who could’ve ever seen that one coming?

    If you had told anyone in a saner era that this would happen . . . they would have laughed out loud and called you delisional. Yet, here we are.

    1. He must have been a lesbian trans woman. LOL!
      But then why the working penis? Why the working testes? That’s the definition of a male. If he’s not willing to get those two things cut off then he is nothing more than a cross dresser.

      1. You’re appealing to facts. The policy is based on self-identity. If he identifies as a female, even though factually he’s a cross-dressing male, New Jersey treats him as if he were a female. That’s what I mean by full-on governmental lunacy.

      2. Lack of funds to support surgery. Not like the sex affirming surgery of getting breast implants or hair plugs or the use of so called boner-pills when the equipment has biologically and naturally failed, rendering the penis equipped as no longer a man.

    2. AND guess who’s now financially responsible for HIM impregnating two female inmates? Us taxpayers. Win-win for criminals and therefore dumbocrats.

  5. I think that judges, legislatures, prosecutors, and police would all benefit from having a legal system that is based, within the limits of the English language, on objectively defined terms. Vague or subjective terms will certainly promote endless litigation and debate. So having the justice system be put in the position to take on faith the declared gender of a convicted criminal (someone demonstrated to violate laws) is shear madness. That it took a ruling from the highest court in the land (Scotland) to declare the obvious is a unflattering commentary of our current society as reflected in our legal system.

    I hope that our US Supreme Court will likewise promote rationality.

    1. Rewriting history and changing the meaning of words has always been a communist tactic. They know exactly what the words mean but want to confuse the people so they can seize power.

      1. So true. They brand it “interpretation”—modification, transformation, and amendment by “interpretation.”

        They are as corrupt as —-!

        They are vested with only the power to JUDGE, or ensure that actions comport with statutory and fundamental law.

        They have no power to rewrite the law in every case they try.

        1. See if you can understand this:

          All persons born or naturalized in the United States and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.

          The judicial branch just can’t come to grips with the fact that illegal aliens and the babies they bear in America are subject ONLY to the jurisdiction (i.e. the full, unqualified jurisdiction as it is written in the 14th) of their country of origin and that they are only subject to partial, or territorial, jurisdiction of the U.S.

          The judicial branch just can’t grasp this.

          1. The judicial branch doesn’t want to grasp this as they are good at ignoring words they don’t like and creating new ones they do like.
            like they don’t know what jurisdiction means.

      2. AND… this is where their useful idiots come into the picture, the ones that spread the marxist virus with their stupidity infecting anyone dumber than themselves. AND… here they are, posting on Turley’s blog, AND running for office.
        There are actually some dumbocrats out there that are not aware of the party’s takeover by marxists.
        It’s the useful idiots who are at the heart of the problem but are usually easy to deal with.

  6. “But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security.”

    – Declaration of Independence, 1776

  7. The Confederate States of America lost.

    Does that mean that actual Americans cannot take their country back?

    1. Most of the Confederacy was comprised of the descendants of founding fathers and citizens.

      1. Comprised is used as The descendants of founding fathers and citizens comprised most of the Confederacy.

        Comprise is used to indicate the parts comprise a whole; composed indicates a whole is composed of parts.

        1. Don’t listen to this fool. Presenting the fact that the Confederate States of America were comprised of the descendants of the Founding Fathers and citizens is perfectly acceptable. Certainly, anyone who followed the Constitution and opposed “Crazy Abe” Lincoln’s nullification and destruction of the Constitution was a true patriot and was comprised of loyalty and devotion to the Constitution and America.

  8. The ongoing peace talks in Switzerland between American and Iranian officials got off Sunday to a rocky start, according to one Emirati political analyst who went on to describe the spectacle as nothing short of “humiliation” for Vice President JD Vance, who’s leading the U.S. delegation.

    Several key details from the meeting between the two delegations made it easy for the world to draw its own conclusions on who looked confident and who looked desperate. Chief among them was the U.S. delegation entering the venue well before the Iranians.
    “This was humiliation. No one in modern history has made America wait and beg for negotiations. This was the moment JD Vance should have returned to Washington. The Islamic regime did this on purpose,” argued Emirati political analyst and author Amjad Taha in an analysis published on social media.
    “In diplomacy, the side with leverage doesn’t wait in the room,” Taha wrote. “You claim to be leading and winning, yet you arrived first. First mistake.”

    Taha also flagged a telling moment from Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghci, who Taha claimed “entered last and refused to shake hands,” a claim supported by reporting from the Iranian news outlet Tasnim News Agency.

    The US has never looked smaller or weaker on the world stage.

    1. And the Iranian talks have just ended prematurely.
      The Iranians walked out, saying they are frustrated by Trump’s latest threats.

      Total clown show !!!!

      1. Trump keeps claiming that Iran is totally defeated.
        If that is true, how can Iran be calling the shots.

        When a country is “totally defeated”, there is no negotiation about anything. The defeated country has no leverage. If they are totally defeated they simply surrender and accept what follows. This is not happening. Iran is calling the shots and they appear to be in total control of the situation.

        1. Then, there’s Trump insisting that the Italian PM was “begging” to be photographed with him. She denied it. He insulted her. According to posts on “X”:

          “On X, formerly Twitter, The Hill’s Julia Manchester reports, “Italy’s foreign minister cancels his trip to the U.S. after President Trump reportedly say Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni ‘begged’ him for a photo at the G7 Summit.”

          It is the “begged” part, according to Manchester, that Italian officials found offensive.
          One of them is Italian Deputy Prime Minister Antonio Tajani, who also serves as Italy’s minister of foreign affairs.

          On X, Tajani posted, “The serious and offensive words of President Trump towards Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni offend all of Italy. For this reason, I have decided to cancel my visit to the United States scheduled for the next 21 and 22 June.””

          Trump just can’t control his narcissism or his mouth, which caused the Iranians to walk out of peace talks and now, the cancellation of the visit of the Italian deputy PM.

          1. Trump’s confidence and his mouth is the sole reason we are winning on all fronts worldwide, you just have TDS so you can’t see how awesome he has made everything. Italy didn’t act like our ally and let us use their air base and this is the payback for THAT offense but of course you didn’t know Italy started the feud because of the TDS that clouds your judgement. Next time we’ll just take the airbase.

            1. We are “winning”? Only in MAGA world. The war Trump started and that we are losing, was based on a lie. The reasons kept changing— regime change, Iran poised to nuke us within 2 weeks—but the truth is that Netanyahu suckered Trump into believing the lie about Iran poised to strike. That was a cover for Israel’s plan to start bombing Lebanon and steal some of its land, like it did in Palestine. Netanyahu tried that with Obama, Bush and Biden, but they didn’t bite. Trump has come off looking like a fool.

              Now, Trump is desperate to get out of the problems he created with his stupid war— gas prices much higher, cost of groceries and other things, including the cost of fuel and fertilizer for farmers going up, billions wasted, 14 service members killed, along with thousands of Iranians and the Strait of Hormuz closed. Our weapons stockpile is depleted, but Iran still has many of its ballistic missiles and its nuclear facilities were not destroyed. It has taken control of the Strait of Hormuz.

              Trump’s arrogance was on display— he strolled into the G-7 and announced that he was “the boss”. He insulted the Italian PM by claiming she was “begging “ for a photo op. How is any of this “winning “?

              There’s all the difference in the world between confidence and narcissistic arrogance— Trump is the poster boy for the latter. MAGA media have to spin all of Trump’s failures as successes, but the lies aren’t working, based on opinion polls and the reaction of other world leaders who think Trump is a joke.

            2. Explain WHY Italy should get involved in the Trump war he started with Iran. The NATO alliance agreement provides that Italy would help the US if another non NATO country attacked us—not if our stupid President, without any provocation, decided to start bombing another country that was not part of the NATO alliance. And what does that issue have to do with Trump insulting Meroni, the Italian PM, by portraying her as desperate to get a picture with him by “begging”? Are childish insults called for?

              Another example of Trump’s disrespectful behavior— he made the comment that one of the G7 members “shot his wad”-which literally stunned those who heard him say it. Earlier, Trump claimed that Iranians said President Obama was a “stupid SOB”—only he used the actual words.

              Trump is an embarrassment to the United States.

              1. Trump’s insults are not childish and it is childish to think of them as such. They move the world. They are an instrument of America’s immense power and Trumps not afraid to use it. Meroni’s ego bruising is no reason for the rest of italy to suffer from a poor relationship with the USA. It’s simple: “We’re the USA, B**ch” and we are tired of tinpot eurotrash telling us they know better as the world falls apart. I would love to see Trump exit us from the failed NATO and declare europe lost to marxism which was the intent of NATO to preserve western democracy.

        2. Trump is giving them a chance to save face. A totally defeated enemy becomes desperate. Let them stay in their naughty corner a little longer and they will come around.
          Exactly what cards do you think they are holding? Trump has shown them nothing but restraint, but we are damn well winning this quite nicely. There is no evidence of any other conclusion.

          1. You are utterly demented and living in a fantasy world of your own creation.
            A “totally defeated” enemy has no leverage, no bargaining power, nothing.
            All a “totally defeated” enemy can do is surrender and accept whatever terms the winner imposes upon them. There is no negotiation of ANYTHING.

            Iran is dictating the terms of negotiations that should not even be taking place.
            Thus Iran can in no way be considered to be defeated.

            The only conclusion to be drawn here is that Iran is in no way shape or form defeated in any conceivable way.

            1. Please smarty-pants, tell me what leverage they have that Trump! cannot easily defeat?
              TIME alone is taking it’s toll on them. Trump is literally getting everything with just an ‘understanding’ that the IR must follow through to benefit anything at all: an end to immediate hostilities, opening the Strait (meaning an end to their hostilities as this is all they are able to conjure), and an undefined release of frozen Iranian assets. There’s no deal if they don’t ‘understand’. all performance-based. Meanwhile the Iranian citizens are getting restless and the IR knows it. Trump! has shown nothing but restraint at this point. Your viewpoint is skewed by TDS. Tick tock.

        3. I hope those lunatics force President Trump into a corner he can’t get out of. I can’t wait.

          1. Well your anti-american hopes are dashed because we have already won this war and Trump has already won the midterms.

    2. Article 3, Section 3

      Treason against the United States, shall consist only in levying War against them, or in adhering to their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort.

    3. We have Iran right where we want them and you know it. Time is on our side and the midterms will be the IR’s nightmare.
      This murderous regime has finally met it’s match, and they have no way to stop the coming revolution.
      The only delay is that they are still in the stages of grief, but soon will face reality that their world is over.

      1. You are clearly living in the alternate universe of a MAGA fantasy-land, completely and utterly disconnected from reality.

        1. You wish, IR supporter. Everything I said is true and you cannot dispute it or you would have.
          So what does the MoU achieve? It settles the oil markets, it fuels the stock market, and arguably it enhances the chances of the Republicans to win the midterm elections. Thank you IR capitulators as we look to the future prospects of the free Iranian people.

    4. ,,actually.. Being on Time like the USA is simply a Professional attribute.. The Japanese believe you should even be early for all meetings and wait for the others to arrive to be truly Professional… THIS is not ‘humiliating and inded it is ridiculous to suggest that the Rude and Disrespectful Iranian Doofuses had the upper hand. The more they act this way, the closer they get to negating the MOU and inviting us to find wipe their ass off the Global Forum once and for all and install the rightful Iranian Govt… 47 years is already a long time to put up with their disrespect & terrorism… perhaps they are simply asking to be FIRED once and for all.

      1. eighteenhole
        Your comment is completely irrational.
        The ability of the MAGA cult to rationalize the completely irrational and demented behavior of Trump is absolutely astounding.

        You and the rest of the MAGA constantly harp on this theme of Iran being a villain for 47 years. Despite many attempts to stop them, they have remained undefeated for 47 years. They continue to do what they have done for 47 years. They are not now, and never have been defeated.

        This nonsense by the Trump administration is nothing but a charade, smoke and mirrors.

  9. Today for Father’s Day I received a T-Shirt to wear around our small Texas town as an invitation to troubled souls to visit our ranch. Printed on the shirt is:
    “If Genders Confuse You, Come Milk Our Bull” That should clarify the confusion.

    1. Cattle don’t have gender. I can see why you are confused.

      Bulls also have sex with their offspring – something you might want to avoid if you have children.

      If you cannot tell the difference between cattle and people, then stay away from people.

  10. Well, it must be a similar problem to send a male to a male prison when the male was convicted of killing a male.

    That is the reasoning about sending a trans woman to a woman’s prison on the charge of raping a woman, is it not?

    Maybe the real concern is to send a trans woman to a male prison so she can be murdered.

    After all, being trans, for conservatives, is punishable by death.

    1. what a dumb comment. So you’re saying that all the other prisoners are conservatives? Don’t think so pal. In fact, quite the opposite.

      1. Conservatives want trans people to be murdered in prison; though I suppose many conservatives are also criminals as you suggested.

    2. Now this is some amazing lefty-logic! Let’s think about this a bit more shall we?
      Is this the trans rights I keep hearing so much about? The right to tell us where we will punish you?
      Here’s my logic: Men, even those that feel dainty, go to men’s prison.

      1. “Here’s my logic: Men, even those that feel dainty, go to men’s prison.”

        With the hope the dainty ones will be killed or raped or worse. Maimed, mangled, tortured. That’s the conservative version of retribution for the crime of being dainty.

        You don’t have to admit it. Your comment confirms it.

  11. OT.

    The windowless tomb aka Obama “campus” needs some examining. Federal taxes will pay for upkeep and employees at the 19 acre complex campus. 8 stories of building space, a branch of the Chicago library with hand selected books, a full size official basketball court indoors, children’s fun park including slopes for winter fun, gardens and walkways are part of the package.

    Are there limits of size, purpose, other for these presidential archival museums ? I certainly hope taxes cover only 2 floors of this monstrosity plus 25 ft surrounding area as planters or concrete, whichever is cheaper. Each foundation must have an endowment before transfer to the federal department. NO GROWTH and there’s a learning kitchen atop the library.

    You better rein in those narcissistic hoaxters.

    Have a good one…

    1. ^^^The Obama Campus is not and will not be part of NARA , national archives. His “prezidency” is not official and not a dime from taxpayers now or ever, all privately funded.

      He didn’t exist. 😂. After the blast , like Tutankaman’s bones, he’ll be found in the tomb. 😂.

      Many Americans died

  12. I’m curious to know how the trans gender believers will react/justify when a trans gender golfer plays for millions of prize money on the LPGA Tour?

  13. A regular mom who cracked the code to recession-proof income without selling a thing!
    I started this online work a few months ago.
    At first, I was confused about where to apply.

    1. Sure. So smart. But no amount of plastic surgery, hormone therapy, wardrobe changes, haircuts, wigs, cosmetics, or method acting classes can make a male into a female. Still a male. Just crazy. Biologically speaking.

  14. Why not,
    Have a separate area for Trans people in a prison so that there are no associated risks.
    Have a separate league for Trans men/women to compete in to allow fairness and less risk of physical harm.
    Just like before when there was only men’s sports and to comply with title IX women’s sports were created and are quite successful.

    1. rcs,
      That makes sense.
      And the left would have you canceled for it!
      IIRC, there was an attempted “trans” bicycle race and no one showed up. Where is the fun in that if you, as a biological male identifying as a female, cannot beat up on biological females?

      1. I presume a trannys wish to become a woman means that they are a bit envious of a real woman that’s making it look so easy when it’s such a difficult path for the trans. I presume some of them might like to beat a woman beacuse they are supremely jealous of them as they could never become ‘real’ which is their extreme desire. Otherwise the word ‘trans’ would have no meaning and would never be used.

    2. (Have a separate area for Trans people) That approach gives these mentally ill people the special privilege that they seek. Separate them out into regular prisons of their assigned sex at birth and put them in a facility within that prison dedicated only to mentally persons.

      1. I had thought, perhaps naively, that the separation from the population that they would prefer or the one that could kill them, would cause them to think about what they did and who they really are. Since the population would be small perhaps only a single cell, the amount of extra resources would be small. This would provide the safety for all involved, which no matter who they are or what they have done, deserve to be in a safe space. We provide so much to other questionable programs that the funding for this could easily be found.

        1. I’m not qualified but…a completely transitioned woman would face incredible abuse in a man’s prison aka brutes. Oth she could earn a lot of commissary goodies.

          😏

          1. Many such people getting along better than most in men’s prisons. They get protected by inmates where others are not. Of course it’s prison, so anything could happen to anybody.

      2. That special privilege is to go unrecognized and unharassed, but conservative are so concerned with the genitals of others they keep getting assaulted and beaten. I think it is the basic insecurity that conservatives feel, unable to be sure of their own sexuality they need a world to be sanitized of any other thoughts that might challenge their beliefs.

        1. ^ Gibberish. Learn to write coherent English sentences, please. You’re making no sense at all ^

        2. “keep getting assaulted and beaten” quite some hyperbole, examples?
          or do you have TDS? I have some examples I’ll drop too, OK?

    3. “Why not,
      Have a separate area for Trans people in a prison ?”
      Because this is a dying fad. And spending limited taxpayer funds on a fad is a waste when those funds could be better spent on getting mental health support for those individuals.

    4. The state is required to make prisons safe for those who are put into prison – fopr the most part beyond that the administration of the prison is the business of the govenrment – not the prisoners.

      1. True and safety issues are gleaned from reported incidents? I know it’s all on camera when they’re working.

    5. I am not looking to rain on your parade – but in a perfect world we would have separate imprisonment for the mentally ill, trans, possibly different races, different crimes, …..

      In the real world we do not have a separate prison for each criminal.

      I am absolutely open to all kinds of reforms to our criminal justice system – both alternatives to incarceration – and supplements to incarceration.
      But we arrived where we are over hundreds of years – what we have has significant problems – but it is better than doing nothing, and better than much of what we have done in the past, and better than many of the idiotic experiments that the left has tried recently.

      Regardless, the MEASURE of any criminal justice changes should be the benefit to society – does it reduce crime ? And separately – what does it cost.

      Many of the systems that the left sees are alternatives to incarceration are actually supplements not alternatives – and they cost us MORE – but when used as a supplement they do reduce recidivism which is a benefit to all.
      We are an affluent society and we can afford to pay more for a criminal justice system that both works better and increases the odds that criminals will not repeat offend.

      1. “We are an affluent society and we can afford to pay more for a criminal justice system that both works better “

        An adaptation of F.A. Hayek

      2. No free market solution? The private sector is getting into the prison business. It’s not working out as expected. It’s worse.

        1. No free market solution? solution to what exactly? Prisons for criminals? we have prisons for criminals at home. Deters crime. solved.

    6. Why not, Have a separate area for Trans people in a prison so that there are no associated risks.?

      Prison is not a publicly funded resort and spa with al la carte services. What right does a convict have to violate the law, victimize someone or something, consume public resources associated with their investigation, arrest, conviction, and incarceration and then demand special accommodations? No taxpayer should have to pay one additional cent because a convict chooses to identifies to identify as something other than what they were at birth. If a convict doesn’t like the risks perhaps they should have complied with the law.?

    7. What happened to equal treatment under the law?
      Accommodating the crazy is no way to deter from it.

    8. Create a separate set of facilities to pander to a convicted criminal’s delusions? Not with my tax dollars, thank you so very f*cking much.

    9. Create a separate set of facilities to pander to a convicted criminal’s delusions? Not with my tax dollars, thank you so very much.

  15. OH Come On! You know you have always fancied the idea of being the Warden of a Women’s Prisons every time you passed one on the Interstate. 😉

    1. I confess, thinking of it every time I passed the Women’s Huron Valley Correctional Facility off Mich. Hwy 23 going on the way to Ann Arbor.
      The Highway signs there say: DON’T PICK UP HITCHHIKERS, which has always intrigued me.

  16. The narcissistic fetishism that underlies the entire transgender narrative is nothing but mental illness. It needs to be viewed as dangerous, especially to children.

    I’m amazed that anyone thinks that puberty blockers and cross sex hormones are in any way beneficial to a child. Just crazy.

    I think every person has a right to keep these nutjobs away from their children. Sorry if that limits some careers but not sorry.

    1. The origin is the Obama hoax syndrome- I want it to be true, I want it to be true. It’s a hoax and a lie. Obama syndrome causes extreme confused thinking. Men no longer know they’re men is an effect. 😏 Someday the OS will morph into a Mandela effect.

      Half /s

Leave a Reply