Gallup: Republicans Rank “Patriotism” and Democrats Rank “Equality” as Top Needed Value

Gallup released another poll showing just how divided the nation remains on core values. When asked, “which values the country most needs today?,” Republicans ranked “patriotism” as number one while Democrats ranked “equality.” What is most alarming is that no shared value cracks fifty percent overall. Patriotism is only ranked in the top three shared values by 32 percent. (Freedom tops the list at only 38 percent).

Republicans rank patriotism as the most needed value today, while Democrats rank it lowest at just six percent.

Clearly, the results must be read in context. There are many values offered and ranking some lower does not mean that they have no or little value. It is a relative ranking of what the country most needs.

However, it shows (as found in other polls) how far the two parties are apart on their perspectives of the country at this moment in history.

 

106 thoughts on “Gallup: Republicans Rank “Patriotism” and Democrats Rank “Equality” as Top Needed Value”

  1. Republicans say they crave patriotism while they support Trump to whom dual Israeli citizen Sharon Adelson gave a quarter of a billion dollars. In return at the behest of foreign Israeli citizens trump starts a war with Iran which directly causes our current insane inflation especially for food and fuel. There are no known words capable of describing this rate of idiocy and hypocrisy.

  2. I’ve tried twice now to post polling results showing that voters of all political stripes are very concerned about government corruption, the cost of gas, groceries, energy and everything else–all of which reflect on Trump because of his tariffs and the war he started, but my posts, as is often the case, never get published. As to corruption–just last night, Trump bragged about how “rich” he’s getting–since taking office Trump has traded $8.1 million in petroleum stocks. Notice that he’s not in any hurry to end the war he started based on a lie? Why can’t he end the war today? Trump also lies about the cost of everything going down, which it isn’t true, but diehard MAGAs believe it–I saw an interview with a man in Texas this morning who said prices are coming down, and claimed that he wasn’t going to allow the Muslim Brotherhood and Communists to take over. Trump has awarded no bid contracts to businesses in which his sons have financial interests, and accepted a gift of a flying palace from Qatar, all while falsely calling El Sayed a “jihidast”–so I guess that Muslims who give him gilded presents are OK, but not Muslims who are American citizens. Kushner also accepted a bailout from the Saudis for one of his failing businesses, while purporting to represent the United States in negotiations. Since Trump took down the Office of Consumer Protection, airlines which have heavily contributed to Trump are getting consumer protections rolled back, so we’re all paying more.

    Gee, the Hunter Biden art sales “scandal” seems quaint by comparison. Republicans even held hearings about it, and that’s part of what Trump is so worried about–the investigations that Democrats will conduct if and when they get the power to do so, which includes the Epstein files. The oligarchs are afraid that they’ll lose all of the tax breaks and rolling back and unenforcement of environmental and consumer protections, which is why they are investing so heavily in the midterms. Elon Musk alone has spent at least $277 million. So far, the largest oligarch contributors have ponied up $2.77 billion to buy this election, which is why the attack ads are so vicious.

  3. I get frustrated with polls such as this for not clearly defining terms. The term “equality” is more than a bit ambiguous. Are we to interpret this to mean equality before the law, that is equal opportunity? Or are we to interpret this to mean equality in all aspects of life, that is equal capabilities and wealth? The later interpretation, more akin to the concept of equity assumes that any performance differences between individuals is evidence of discrimination. Whereas the former interpretation recognizes that humans, although having different temperaments and capabilities and so perform differently, should still be equal before the law. Biology tells us in no uncertain terms that humans have innate differences and thus our founders got is right that equality should be equality before the law, people with equal societal value, and not people as equal performance, that is akin to interchangeable parts.

  4. OT, not better,

    California Gov. Newsom says Democratic Socialists of America will be ‘dominant’ and ‘mainstream’

    “So the DSA, the energy and the desire and demand for bold change, not incremental change, is very much going to be dominant. I mean, that’s going to be a mainstream democratic movement. Absolutely,” Newsom said.

    https://justthenews.com/politics-policy/elections/california-gov-newsom-says-democratic-socialists-america-will-be-dominant?utm_source=justthenews.com&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=external-news-aggregators

    1. UF, you’ve noticed the talent has pulled out of politics and moved into free market capitalism? Congress is dead. The judiciary, dead. To rob you the dsa will need little army cartels in the future.

      Equality references royalty as in Kingdoms. Wasn’t it Magna Carta?

      A physicist and a ditch digger don’t have interchangeable talents

  5. “All Men Are Created Equal”

    It asserts a moral and political principle: every person has the same fundamental worth and equal natural rights (not that everyone is identical in abilities or status).

    Historically, it declares that political authority derives from consent and that no one is born with an inherent right to rule over others—so laws and government should treat individuals as equals before the law and protect their basic rights.

    1. Anon, I’ll agree with equality as being a universal principle in terms of resources.

      I’m not sure of mixing the value with the word principle from the article. Presumably patriotism means loyalty. I don’t know what other principle iples and values were on the list.

      Condolences to all Republicans in what must be h€££.

      Have a joyful day

    2. Blah blah anon, no one is going to listen to Alex Cortez and Myra Lopez etc for much longer. Congress is dump for females. Talent is in econ.

  6. Republicans are patriotic. Democrats have no interest in equality. Democrats favor ever increasing shares of productive capacity be distributed by Democratic operatives and have a set of social stratum in their heads which determines your share of the swag and determines who has to be deferential to whom.

    1. Democrats believe in policy and Republicans believe in party.

      Unity for Republicans means supporting the leader, the strong man, the bully. Someone who will hurt those who are not part of the tribe, those who do not conform to their narrow worldview.

      1. What Democrat policies would that be?

        Open borders? Sanctuary city/states for criminal illegals? No cash bail? Biological males in women’s sports and spaces? Green energy that drives up utilities costs? A weak, woke military? Pornography in elementary school libraries? Anti-secure elections? Passing laws to ensure Democrats never lose an election again and then packing the SC to ensure those laws are not overturned thereby establishing a one party rule?

        Republican voters got sick of the old establishment Republicans abusing their loyalty and voted for Trump. Those establishment Republicans tired to block Trump’s first admin. Voters told those establishment Republicans to pound sand. As is their right. When a party no longer represents the voters wishes or concerns, it is the right of the voters to vote for someone else or even another party. That is what a democrat republic looks like.

        Not a party pushing for one party rule.

        1. Trump’s party is ignoring the desires of his own base for peace, for economic prosperity. Instead he’s allowed inflation to persist, hes ignored genocide in Gaza, he’s stoked inflation with the needless war in Iran to please his Israeli paymasters, let’s drill down on that a little, his corrupt son Jared pulls his strings for the pleasure of his Israeli friends and their Saudi collaborators, the maniacal bald headed Steve Miller has run amuck cancelling laws of Congress that the executive has not place pretending to veto through administrative fiat long after the laws were written on the books– yes I am talking about asylum, which his own Jewish grandparents benefitted from when they fled the Nazis and came to the USA– it is a repulsive group of scoundrels. I thought the first term was ok but this one is just awful. Voted for the Democrats and you should too!

          1. x mentioned 2 important errors in the post by Anonymous. I’ll bet one can find a dozen errors when one includes overgeneralization, factual errors, and logical errors. The ignorance of Anonymous is astounding.

            Will Anonymous correct his mistakes? No, not when he can run away.

      2. Democrats are nothing great. Most of my life I have disliked the party not locally but at its national leadership level. But at this moment in history they are the lesser evil and deserve our vote. Trump’s broken promises especially not to start another big war like he did in Iran, the sucking up to Israel, the failure on inflation, the corruption, the excesses of ICE like shooting Americans, deporting them (yes this happened in actual fact at least once) cancelling green cards and citizenships willy nilly, this is all way past what anybody bargained for and even diehard Republicans and former Trump fans MUST NOW VOTE DEMOCRAT.

    2. Based on their anti-American speech, many Democrats do not see the difference between patriotism and nationalism.

      Also based on their anti-American speech, many Democrats do not see the difference between leftism and fascism but they call it saving democracy.

  7. Unfortunately, the modern left’s definition of ‘equality’ is do what I say and what I want, or else. Pathetically hilarious. ‘Freedom’ doesn’t appear as a value for either, and that’s sad.

    1. Freedom does appear as a value for all three, and is ranked about equally. The problem is that “freedom” doesn’t mean the the same thing to all.

      1. @mistress

        Sorry, my bad, allow me to clarify: freedom does not appear as the *number one* value. Without freedom first, you can’t have quite literally any of the others, and anyone that thinks collectivism rather than autonomy is freedom has had their brain rinsed pretty thoroughly. Do we really have to do all of this again in the 21st century?

        1. James

          Actually, I think you have it the wrong way around.

          Without equality first, no one can have freedom.

          It is no coincidence that the first sentence of the Declaration of Independence contains the word “equal”.

          And the second sentence reads, “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal”.

          The word “equal” appears twice in the first two sentences, but the word “freedom” does not appear anywhere in the entire Declaration.

          Clearly the Founders valued “equality” as the most important value, as do the majority of Democrats.

          1. The difference is how you get to equality. Do you treat people equally, the golden rule, or do you force it down via DEI?

            I vote for the golden rule.

            1. Equality is not something “you get to”.

              Equality is not something that you earn.

              Equality is not something that is conferred by other higher authorities or individuals.

              As the Founders explicitly stated, “all men are created equal”. Equality is something that you inherently possess simply by being born. Equality is not something that depends on how you are viewed by others, and not something that is given out by governments or groups of citizens.

              Apparently you do not approve of the Founders views of equality, and instead prefer the views of Napoleon, the dictator pig of Animal Farm, who stated ““All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others”.

              And we all know what the Golden Rule really is. “He who has the gold makes the rules”.

              So you make it plainly obvious that you have no understanding of the meaning of “equality” as intended by the Founders. Like all MAGA morons, you apparently believe that YOU and your cult are the keepers of equality, and you have the ability and right to confer that equality only upon those who agree with you.

          2. “Clearly the Founders valued “equality” as the most important value, as do the majority of Democrats.”

            Typical Leftist bait-and-switch. It equivocates on the word “equality.” What the Declaration and Founders mean is equality under the law. What the D’s mean is equality of results, i.e., mass redistribution of wealth.

            The former is a pillar of freedom. The latter is a pillar of socialism.

          3. Respectfully, I agree with James, above.

            I think you are confusing purpose with means to that end. Please note the Preamble, i.e., Purpose/Objective/Goal:

            “We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.”

            Au contraire, “equality” is not even mentioned as the primary motivator; liberty and freedom are more aptly projected and closely related.

            The concept of equality is a tool in achieving that/those purpose(s) and objective(s).

            P.S. we celebrate with the “Liberty Bell,” (symbol of Independence/Freedom) -not the “Equality Bell.”

            1. (I realize you were referring to the Declaration; you must also acknowledge that the Declaration states that we are all created equal as to inalienable[unalienable] rights.

              I was referring to the end result (the Constitution) which embodied and cemented the tools to achieve those ideals, i.e., “In Order to form a more perfect Union..[we must value the following…., of which equality is one]”

              I find it very telling that the largest gap between Democrats and Republicans pertains to Equality, Fairness, and Patriotism.

          4. “All men are created equal”

            It asserts a moral and political principle: every person has the same fundamental worth and equal natural rights (not that everyone is identical in abilities or status).

            Historically, it declares that political authority derives from consent and that no one is born with an inherent right to rule over others—so laws and government should treat individuals as equals before the law and protect their basic rights.

    2. James, the dems mean everyone must come down to the lowest common denominator. That’s the only way to be equal in their mind. The physicist must eat beans with the ditch digger. Are these jobs equally interchangeable?

  8. Democrats seeking ‘equality’ might examine carefully those communities which are succeeding, those which are not, and then take a good look at themselves in the mirror.

  9. Thes polls are rubbish. The real poll, “The Westbrook Institute”, shows that “Intelligence” is the top-rated trait characterisitic sought by Republicans with 82% favoring it, whereas “Stupidity” is the top-rated characteristic sought by Democrats with 96% favoring it.

    You can tell that the “gallup” poll is rubbish because Democrats have long abolished “equality” as a worthy standard. No self-respecting Democrat uses “equality” anymore as a yardstick because they hate equality. What Democrats love is ‘EQUITY’, not ‘equality’. Of course, what Democrats really mean by “equity” is that they agree with the Orwellian concept that “Some animals are more equal than others”.

  10. The problem is that too many Democrats believe in “Animal House” democracy where all animals are created equal but some are more equal than others. Do the Democrats believe in equality of opportunity or equality of results. Seems to me that they want equality of results in spite of the lack of work to achieve those self same results.

    Most individuals would likely see that their work and productivity would achieve some equality of results especially when totaled up through a lifetime of work. Others never even start the journey. The world flings tragedy, despair, bad luck, and missteps in your path and you have to respond. In the United States you have no excuses. You can hover in your hole and never emerge or you get out of the hole, wrestle with the tempest, and achieve something. But if you wait to have it all handed to you, I think you are going to have a long wait.

    We all get flattened. It helps to learn that so that you can avoid or ride the next wave. It’s up to you.

    1. “Democrats believe in “Animal House” democracy where all animals are created equal…” Wrong GEB, its from the book Animal Farm by Orwell.

      1. Yeah, but since most leftists live in an “Animal House” world, the comparison is still apt.

    2. GEB,

      Great comment.

      I would add, what you are describing is “character.” Something I would of added to the poll.

    3. GEB, you must be a really nice person, seriously. The predators are overwhelming. The predators without conscience and with entitlement are present.

  11. A closer look at the Gallup data reveals an interesting fact. Normally, you might expect the independent voter data to correlate well with the average of the Democratic and Republican averages. And it does, with a correlation coefficient of about r = 0.85. However, the correlation is far higher (r = ~0.95) between the independent data and the geometric average between the Dem and Rep data. This is extraordinarily high. This implies that changes from Dem to Rep data occur in percentages in the Independent data rather than in jumps.

    Action item: It could be that pollsters should incorporate geometric averages into their predictions rather than using arithmetic averages.

    This pattern appears across the Dow, Nasdaq, and S&P data, where the geometric average of the Dow and Nasdaq is highly correlated with the S&P – also about r = .95. Here, I used moving averages. This observation is not in the literature. I noted it some time back, but did not publish it.

    1. Turley: “However, it shows (as found in other polls) how far the two parties are apart on their perspectives of the country at this moment in history.”

    2. It would be interesting to see more information about the independent voters. They are not a monolithic group sitting in the middle between Democrats and Republicans, or even close to it, but most polls seem to imply that they are. They are spread across the entire spectrum, often identifying as independent because they don’t like some aspect of the Democrats or Republicans and so don’t want to be associated with the one or the other. But they often still hold beliefs mostly associated with one or the other, if not some other third party that the pollster did not offer as a choice. So it would be interesting to see more specific breakdowns about the beliefs of independents and why they choose to call themselves that, plus where along the spectrum they actually would appear and in what percentages.

  12. Pretty much says it all. Dems hold fast to “all animals are equal, but some are more equal than others.”

  13. I think we’re missing an important distinction here. Gallup asked what values Americans believe the country needs most, not what values they personally hold. Choosing equality over patriotism doesn’t mean someone isn’t patriotic.

    But here’s what I found more interesting. Gallup also found that 79% of Americans believe respecting different values is more important than sharing the same values.

    Now look at this comment section. If there’s nothing to fight about, somebody will find something.

    Knowing a value, professing a value, and actually practicing it are three different things. We seem pretty good at the first two. It’s the third that ought to concern us, especially in a republic that depends on citizens capable of governing themselves.

      1. No, Olly is right on this. The ‘values’ issue is more nuanced than the black and white process the poll seems to make it out to be. Olly’s is on point about the general state of the nation’s perspectives on what values are important. Focusing on just the extreme obscures the bigger consensus of those in the middle.

        He’s not wrong here.

        1. Thanks X. I think there’s considerably more common ground among Americans than our political arguments would suggest.

          1. I agree Olly, it’s the extremism that makes it difficult to see it and that is the point I believe that most extremists on both sides won’t see because they’ve been so entrenched in their extreme views for so long.

            It will take a long time to correct itself and I do believe that can only start when Trump leaves office. Too much damage has been done to be able to correct with just one administration or highly divided Congress. When compromise is no longer seen as a dirty word or action then the real progress can occur.

            1. “both sides won’t see because they’ve been so entrenched in their extreme views for so long.”

              Well said George, you and Olly are so extreme (self professed intellectuals) that you can’t see reality.

            2. X, here’s where I part company with you. I think you’re giving far too much power to one man and not nearly enough responsibility to the citizens themselves. Our current divide didn’t start with Trump and it won’t end with him leaving office.

              We have agency. We don’t have to wait for Trump to leave office to stop treating political disagreement as an invitation to fight. We can choose to find common ground right now.

              Look at this exchange. You and I rarely agree, yet here we are, finding something we agree on. Neither of us needed a change in administration to make that happen.

              That’s where recovery starts. With us, not Washington.

              1. Agency? Common ground? Agree? Wait, wait, wait. Huh! Olly is saying, now that he’s talking with George, previously vociferous opponents, they have, today, here and now, set in motion the reunification of the nation. Honestly, what a delusion.

              2. OLLY,

                Well said.

                This divide started long before Trump rode the escalator down. MAGA was an idea before Trump turned it into a niffty campaign slogan. Will be around long after he is gone.

                Some have commented they saw it starting in the 60s.

                1. Upstate, exactly. And there’s plenty of evidence to support that.

                  In June 2014, more than two years before Trump was elected, Pew Research Center published a study on political polarization. In 1994, 17% of Republicans had a very unfavorable view of Democrats. By 2014, that had risen to 43%. Among Democrats, the number went from 16% to 38%.

                  Pew concluded that partisan hostility had more than doubled over those twenty years.

                  Here’s the study: <i>https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2014/06/12/political-polarization-in-the-american-public/</i&gt;

                  Trump didn’t create this divide, although we can certainly debate his contribution to it. And his departure won’t magically fix it either.

                  My point remains that we have agency. We don’t need permission from Washington to stop treating our fellow citizens as enemies. That’s a choice we can make ourselves. And in a self-governing republic, we damn well ought to.

                  1. OLLY,

                    Agreed.

                    Sure. There are extremes and wackadoodles on both sides in the past. As of the past ten or so years, seems to have gone mainstream, as the good professor points out. As I have had to point out to the various annonys, pointing out people saying wackadoodle things is not “rage.” It is us saying,

                    “What is wrong with you?”

                2. This guy can’t understand that the Turley opinion is about a poll. Its shows that basic values are apparent in all 3 groups, but he thinks MAGA is what the poll is about. This guy also knows that POTUS Jimmy Crater wrote the “Magna Carter”. Not kidding. Gotta love intelelctuals.

              3. Olly,

                I’m not saying Trump is the sole source of this problem. I agree that the extremism started before him. He simply grabbed onto it and took advantage of it by listening to the voters the Democrats were ignoring. That proved to be a huge mistake for the Democrats. However, that does not change the fact that Republicans are now openly embracing their political extremists, giving them credence and amplifying the polarization we see today.

                A recovery won’t be possible as long as Trump remains the leader of the party. He acts as a barrier that prevents us from seeking compromise. Trump is a narcissist who will never allow anything that diminishes his perceived power and influence. In his eyes, compromising with Democrats is a sign of weakness. It takes away the attention he wants as the sole person with the answers to our nation’s problems, leading him to take credit for things he never did.

                We can find common ground, but that won’t stop commenters like “anonymous” from sabotaging it with the personal attacks and partisan extremism that derail honest debate. Our current divide is rooted in the long-running problem of religious zealotry and extremists who want to drag us back to the social ideas of the 1950s and 1960s.

                Fixing this will take far more than just individual effort. It will require consistent, high-volume voting from true moderates. That won’t be possible as long as Trump and his allies manipulate the rules and constantly gaslight the opposition.

                Elections are just a starting point, and these issues won’t be resolved until Trump’s influence is gone. He is the lifeline for these extremists, making them feel like their conduct is permissible. This is just like the Tea Party wave and the Koch brothers; once their influence waned, the movement faded into the background. Trump’s influence on MAGA is the same. It is what sustains them, but you can already see it fading through low rally attendance and growing bitterness over his handling of the economy.

                Ultimately, it will take a lot of courage for MAGA supporters to accept the idea of compromise. The left is going to have to accept the fact that even they will have to compromise with MAGA too. For years, MAGA supporters have been told by Trump and his inner circle that compromise means complete surrender and weakness. The left have been told compromise with Trump is also a sign of weakness and surrender. Until Trump is out of office and new, less toxic leadership on both sides make efforts to seek compromise the rest will follow.

                1. X, think about what you’re saying. Pew documented a widening political divide from 1994 to 2014. Twenty years, three presidents, and multiple changes in congressional leadership. The divide kept growing. It continued through Trump and Biden.

                  What’s the common denominator? The American people.

                  I’m not suggesting leadership doesn’t matter. Of course it does. But we’ve changed leadership repeatedly, and the problem persists.

                  We have agency, X. We can choose how we treat one another, whether we engage in honest disagreement or partisan warfare, and whether we’re willing to find common ground.

                  Waiting for the right person to occupy the White House before exercising that agency is a cop-out. We’re supposed to be a self-governing people, not spectators waiting for someone in Washington to tell us how to behave.

                  1. Olly,

                    While I appreciate your focus on self-governance, your argument misses a crucial reality: individual agency cannot solve a systemic crisis without leadership to direct it. People do not exercise their agency in a vacuum. They react to the incentives, rules, and examples set by those in power. I’m sure you would agree.

                    The reason polarization grew from 1994 to 2014 isn’t because ordinary Americans suddenly chose to hate their neighbors. Political science research shows that the public is far less divided than the politicians who represent them. The divide grew because elites, both on the right and the left, changed the rules [1]—using gerrymandering, hyper-partisan primaries, and left and right media echoes to reward conflict over consensus. When our entire political system punishes compromise, expecting millions of individual citizens to spontaneously fix the divide on their own is an impossible standard.

                    After the Revolution, the American people were deeply divided and the nation was fracturing under the Articles of Confederation. The public did not fix this through grassroots goodwill. Leaders like Madison and Hamilton had to step in, rewrite the rules, and build a structure that forced cooperation.

                    • Individual citizens had the agency to end segregation for a century, but true change required top-down legislative leadership. It took the Civil Rights Act and transformational moral leaders to establish a new legal and social standard for the country to follow.

                    Relying purely on individual agency to solve a structural problem lets failed leadership off the hook. We are a self-governing people, but self-governance requires leaders who build bridges rather than walls. Until leadership stops rewarding tribalism, the public cannot easily choose a different path.

                    Whether we like it or not leadership plays a crucial role.

                    1. X, you’re arguing against something I never said. Of course leadership matters. So do laws and institutions.

                      But look at your own examples. The Civil Rights Act didn’t happen because Washington suddenly woke up one morning and decided to fix segregation. People organized, marched, boycotted, and demanded change. They didn’t wait for Washington. They pushed Washington to act.

                      Same thing with the Constitution. Madison and the others didn’t just show up and decide to create a new government. The people had already been exercising self-government. They sent representatives to work out the problems, and ultimately the Constitution had to be ratified.

                      That’s my point. Individual agency becomes collective agency when enough people exercise it. And that collective agency can change leadership, laws, and institutions.

                      I’m not letting leadership off the hook. I’m saying we shouldn’t let the citizens off the hook either.

                      We’re supposed to be governing ourselves, X. Waiting for the right person in Washington to make us behave differently is missing the whole point.

                    2. Why did American’s suddenly “choose” to hate their neighbors starting in 1994 and continue since? Two probable reasons. First, the change of US House control from 40-years of continuous Democrat leadership to Republician. Two: Legacy Media thought the American public were bonkers to vote in some real political power to the Party of Pachyderms. Canadian Peter Jennings says as much while anchoring ABC News election coverage : “It’s clear that anger controls the child and not the other way around. The voters had a temper tantrum. . . . The nation can’t be run by an angry 2-year-old.” That night Americans finally understood legacy media was cheerleading for one political party to win and the other fail. Most media, television, print, and radio had been that way since shortly after WW2 and continues to this day.

                      Not long after, two new cable news channels launched: Fox News and MSNBC. Each chose to cater their news coverage to different political demographics.

                      Following that, the explosion of social media and the ability attack other Americans anonomously.

                      I dare say we’d all be getting along better had Gore not invented the Internet.

                  2. Olly,

                    I appreciate you clarifying your position, and I completely agree that grassroots pressure is essential for driving major historic shifts. However, your argument still misses the core of my point by conflating the spark for political change with the structural framework required to sustain it.

                    When you look at the Civil Rights Movement, the people did not organize simply to practice “collective agency” in their daily lives; they organized specifically to demand that Washington use top-down state power to change the rules of society. Before the Civil Rights Act, millions of Americans exercised their individual agency to fight for equality, yet segregation persisted because the legal structures permitted it. It ultimately took federal laws, court orders, and government enforcement to change public behavior on a mass scale.

                    The same applies to the Constitution. The 1787 Convention was not a bottom-up, grassroots initiative. It was an elite-driven effort by leaders who realized the Articles of Confederation were structurally broken. They did not ask the public to simply “behave better” under a failing system; they designed an entirely new political machine that forced cooperation.

                    This is where the distinction lies between our arguments. You are treating polarization as a moral failing of individual citizens who just need to choose to treat each other better. I am viewing polarization as a structural failure of our political system.

                    Today, the rules of the game—such as gerrymandered districts, hyper-partisan primary systems, and media algorithms—actively reward conflict and punish compromise. Telling citizens to simply choose common ground while the system is actively engineered to divide them is an impossible standard. We are indeed a self-governing people, but we cannot fix a broken machine while the people operating it are still running it at maximum speed. True agency requires leaders who are willing to change the rules of the game so that cooperation can actually succeed.

                    1. X, you keep coming back to the machinery, but who built it, who keeps it running, and who has the power to change it?

                      Look at your own example of the founding. The Articles weren’t working, so the states sent delegates to Philadelphia. Those delegates worked out a new Constitution, but they couldn’t just impose it on everyone. They had to make their case, and it had to be ratified through state conventions. That took debate, persuasion, and people willing to act.

                      The system didn’t fix itself, and the leaders didn’t accomplish it on their own.

                      You keep telling me we need leaders willing to change the system. Fine. But where do those leaders come from? Who chooses them? Who holds them accountable?

                      I’m not denying that institutions influence behavior. I’m saying citizens have a responsibility for the institutions they create and maintain.

                      And here’s what bothers me about your argument. You keep finding reasons why citizens can’t exercise their agency until somebody in government changes the rules.

                      I think you’ve got that backwards. Citizens exercising their agency is how we get the rules changed in the first place.

                      That’s self-government, X. It starts with the people.

                  3. OLLY,

                    You are correct.

                    As I mentioned the other day, I think the failure is/was in parenting, public and higher education, a captured/biased MSM and the willingness for people to insert their political bias in just about anything.

                    That existed long before Trump. I can recall an entitlement mentality and “not my responsibility” in the 80s, which my parents quickly squashed any notion of that in us kids. I think that mentality is what got us to where we are today. It sure did not just pop up after the election of Trump. For that matter, I recall some were saying Trump’s election was not the cause but a symptom of something else. Something bigger.

                  4. Olly,

                    You ask a fair question: Where do these leaders come from, and who chooses them? In a healthy democracy, the voters do. But in our current hyper-polarized system, the machinery has been rigged to block the very accountability you are calling for. Is that a fair observation?

                    Consider how the rules currently suppress the “collective agency” of the moderate majority or the ability to self govern:

                    • Gerrymandering: Districts are drawn so precisely that most general elections are uncompetitive. The only election that matters is the party primary, where a tiny, highly ideological minority of voters decides the nominee. A candidate who wants to compromise is punished by their own party, while extremists are rewarded.
                    • The Financial Incentives: Modern campaign finance and media algorithms are engineered to reward outrage. Leaders who stoke anger raise millions of dollars overnight, while those who seek common ground are starved of funding and attention.

                    This is why the cycle doesn’t break from the bottom up. When citizens try to exercise their agency to self govern or demand compromise, the rigged rules of the primaries and the financial system by a tiny entrenched minority of extremists filter those efforts out before they ever reach Washington.

                    To use the Constitutional Convention example again, the delegates didn’t just ask the public to “behave better” under the broken Articles of Confederation. They realized that under the old rules, state-level rivalries made voluntary cooperation impossible. They had to use their elite leadership to design an entirely new structure—the Constitution—that mathematically forced competing factions to work together.

                    I am not letting citizens off the hook. I am pointing out that telling voters to simply “choose better leaders” inside a machine constantly producing bad leaders lately is an impossible loop. We do not need to wait for a savior in Washington, I agree, but we do need a focused, structural movement to change the rules of the game and that often requires choosing a leader or a…representative who would change things—like ending gerrymandering or reforming primaries—so that the true agency of the American people can finally break through.

                    Our system is set up so that we can exercise our agency to self govern, but it’s broken and rigged against fixing it by the extremists in the minority currently accumulating wealth and power while keeping everyone else off balance and divided.

              4. “Our current divide didn’t start with Trump and it won’t end with him leaving office.”

                Olly, this statement is clearly about an important issue. When criticism of Democrats turns to policy, policy is forgotten, and Trump’s name is substituted for it. This isn’t new, as we saw in earlier years: ‘Kill Bush,’ though; perhaps this kind of vacuous thinking is just more vociferous. If policy isn’t the problem, what is?

                1. SM, I agree. In fact, I’d challenge anyone here to identify a problem, propose a solution, and defend it without once invoking the name of a politician or a political party. Just talk about the policies, the principles, and the evidence.

                  We’ve become so accustomed to blaming people and parties that we can hardly discuss a problem without turning it into another partisan fight.

                  But there’s something else we keep overlooking. Ourselves.

                  We talk endlessly about what our leaders are doing wrong, as though the citizens have no responsibility for any of this. We have agency. We decide what we’ll tolerate, what we’ll support, and how we’ll treat people who disagree with us.

                  If we want better government, maybe we ought to start by becoming better at governing ourselves.

                  1. OLLY,

                    I agree.

                    But there is a degree of mental laziness for people to become better at governing themselves. For that matter, just being better of themselves.

                    It was, “I saw it on TV! It must be true!” mentality.

                    Then it became “I read/saw it on the internet! It must be true!” Got a friend with a Master’s Degree, got duped by a deep fake video of that Pretti guy and ICE off of Facebook, where she gets all her news from. She was none to thrilled with me when I pointed it out it was a fake.

                    Got another friend who is voting for a guy just because he dresses like a farmer. That was good enough for her.

                    And now it is getting worse. People are using AI instead of thinking for themselves. Recently a student used AI to write to their professor. A mathematics professor says he is no longer going to bother grading his students homework as AI has gotten so good, he cannot tell the difference.

                    These are the kind of people that are being formed. Or should I say, not being formed.

                    1. Oh, certainly, Upstate. But I don’t think people realize there’s no such thing as not being formed.

                      We’re being formed every day by the environments we participate in. Family, neighborhoods, schools, churches, organizations, communities, and yes, even social media.

                      We can consciously practice the habits of self-government in those environments, or we can simply allow those environments to shape us without giving it much thought.

                      And that’s the problem. When we stop questioning what we’re told, stop thinking for ourselves, and start letting others do our thinking for us, we’re still being formed. Just not necessarily into the kind of citizens a self-governing republic needs.

                      The question isn’t whether we’re being formed. It’s how, by whom, and toward what end.

                  2. OLLY, our disagreement with the left is not the end goal, but rather how we get there. Florida, a well-run state, has an interesting story.

                    In 2,000 voters passed a constitutional amendment authorizing a bullet train. Do I have to tell anyone to look at California? It was crazy and recognized by many who paid attention to the costs that this type of expenditure could lead to financial ruin.

                    This led to the 2,004 constituional mandate that made the voters see the financial costs and tax impact on the ballot. That led to the repeal of the bullet train mandate and other rules.

                    I’d like a bullet train but not at the expense of a loss of funding to other programs or raising taxes. I think many Democrat voters would agree to curtail many Democrat programs if they recognized the costs.

        2. Not wrong you say George? You’re a pathological nutjob and liar. So the pseudo interpretation is accurate? Its listed in order of preference dummy, how can you interpret it any anything else?

          ” perspectives on what values are important.” Again, that’s because it’s listed in order of desirability. Any idiot can read it. But you two are extraordinary idiots.

          1. You’re a prime example of what Olly is talking about and what the poll is showing. YOUR extremist view is the problem. It’s like a reflex rather than an actual constructive thought.

            1. LOL! Thanks, been waiting for that George. You’re so childishly predictable.

              Yeah, tell us about constructive thought George, how your lies are constructive.

            2. My “constructive thought”: there’s one problem with your flighty comment George, no one polled me.

    1. Gallup asked what values Americans believe the country needs most and the people responding to the poll expressed their thoughts accordingly. So where’s the problem?

  14. The poll confirms what is already obvious to regular observers: the country is deeply polarized, and hyper-partisanship is at an all-time high. A look at data from sources like the Pew Research Center reveals how far both major parties have drifted from the political center over the last few decades, fundamentally changing the American political landscape.

    The traditional Republican party of Ronald Reagan and George W. Bush has largely been replaced by populist, nationalist, and religious conservative factions. We see this rightward drift in the modern party’s embrace of strict “America First” isolationist trade policies, hardline immigration stances like border walls, and a heavy legislative focus on Christian nationalist values in public education and healthcare. For many on the right, “patriotism” has increasingly taken on a nationalist tone that critics argue feels exclusive rather than unifying.

    Conversely, the Democratic party has shifted steadily to the progressive left. This leftward drift is evident in the mainstreaming of policies that were once considered fringe, such as sweeping student loan cancellation, universal healthcare concepts like “Medicare for All,” massive government intervention to fight climate change via the Green New Deal, and an intense institutional focus on identity politics and systemic equity. For the left, “equality” has become the dominant framework, focused on reshaping institutions to protect marginalized groups.

    While both sides have their ideological extremes, the collapse of the political center means that compromise is virtually impossible. Because the goalposts have moved so far to the extremes, any moderate or opposing viewpoint is instantly viewed by the other side as an existential threat.

    Republicans want to exclude and segregate. Democrats want to include and integrate. Which is weird because it’s exactly the opposite of what ‘Democrats’ in the 60’s were for which are today’s Republicans. All that needs to happen for compromise to become the norm once again is for Trump to leave office. He’s been the one figure who has embraced polarization more than anyone. The nation has been hostage to a narcissist for far too long.

    1. If you look at the polarization it began in the late 90s when the Democrats ran left and the GOP moved slightly left. Then the racial identity grievances began in earnest in 2008 (this is easily tracked through multiple polls) which further divided the country and pushed the Dems left. The GOP base revolted against the establishment GOP in 2010, which had been moving left, to push the GOP back to conservative ideals (individual liberty, fiscal responsibility, and safety) which for whatever reason are considered far-right.

      The GOP establishment hated this and gave the base the horsemeat of Mitt Romney in 2012 then tried to push Jeb Bush down the base’s throat in 2016. Obama and the GOP establishment created Trump. They created the desire for America to be the primary focus of the elected American government (what a concept!). From 1988-2016 every elected President was more interested in globalization and offshoring (for the GOP it was argued that it was the ideal economic model that would lower costs, for the Dems it was the idea that the “lesser” jobs are for “lesser” people and Americans should have better jobs–both parties were completely wrong).

      Democrats actively exclude and segregate. They’ve done it their entire existence. Today it is affirmative action, DEI, and minority contracts. Republicans want simply that “the way to end discrimination based on race is to end discrimination based on race.” I do not see how anyone can argue that the GOP wants to segregate and divide when they are ACTIVELY fighting to stop discrimination and division! Discrimination and division are part of the Democrat PLATFORM!

      X – as always, your takes are long and language and tragically short on the application of any critical thinking at all. Although, I guess I can’t expect much from your horsemeat ChatGPT inputs. Garbage in garbage out.

      1. DW,

        First, the Republican party did not “move left” before 2010. Decades of data from sources like the Pew Research Center prove that the Republican party moved much further to the right than Democrats did to the left. The 2010 Tea Party wave wasn’t a return to traditional conservative values. Instead, it was the start of a populist movement. This new movement completely abandoned traditional conservative ideas like free trade, controlling government debt, and respecting the law. You cannot claim Trumpism is about “individual liberty” when its core ideas are built on government-controlled trade and extreme nationalism.

        Second, you try to paint the Republican party as the true champion of civil rights, but that is a massive logical leap. Using the idea of “color-blindness” to destroy voting rights protections and ban diversity programs is not ending discrimination. It is just a deliberate effort to ignore existing inequalities and pretend they do not exist.

        By calling programs that help minorities “segregation,” you are confusing the medicine with the disease. The modern populist right is just as obsessed with identity politics as the left. The only difference is that the right uses cultural anger and white nationalism to fire up its voters.

        Finally, mocking someone else’s critical thinking while repeating simple talk-radio talking points is the real definition of “garbage in, garbage out.” If you are going to accuse others of lacking depth, you need to bring actual facts next time.

        1. “mocking someone else’s critical thinking…” But you earned that distinction, here is the latest example: your “garbage out” (comments) is not “critical thinking” George, its outright delusion.

        2. 1. Flaws in the Argument on Ideological Shifts and “Trumpism”

          • Misapplication of Data (Pew / Voteview): The author cites Pew/political science data to claim Republicans moved far right while Democrats barely moved left. However, ideological distance measures like Voteview (DW-NOMINATE) primarily measure party polarization and voting consistency, not the radicalism of social positions. On major social and cultural issues—such as immigration, criminal justice, transgender rights, free speech, and institutional skepticism—the Democratic party shifted significantly leftward relative to where public consensus and the party stood in the 1990s and 2000s. Framing the polarization shift as entirely one-sided ignores well-documented cultural shifts on the left.

          • Conflating Populism with Moving “Far-Right”: The passage claims Republicans moved “much further to the right,” but then immediately notes that the 2010 Tea Party and Trumpism “abandoned traditional conservative ideas like free trade [and] controlling government debt.” Moving away from traditional right-wing orthodoxy (like free trade, entitlement cuts, and deregulation) toward protectionism, state intervention, and entitlement protection is, by definition, not a move further to the economic right. The argument contradicts itself by calling a populist realignment “far-right” while simultaneously admitting it abandoned core right-wing fiscal policies.

          • False Dichotomy on Liberty and Trade/Nationalism: The claim that “Trumpism cannot be about individual liberty” due to government-controlled trade ignores how populists define liberty. National populists argue that economic sovereignty and protected domestic industries safeguard national independence and workers’ individual agency against un-elected multinational corporations and foreign adversaries. Calling tariffs “extreme nationalism” ignores that tariff protectionism was the historic platform of the early Republican Party (e.g., Abraham Lincoln, William McKinley) and organized labor for generations.

          2. Weaknesses in the Critique of Civil Rights and “Color-Blindness”

          • Redefining Civil Rights and Legal Equality: The author dismisses “color-blindness” as a tool to “destroy voting rights protections.” However, color-blindness was the foundational premise of the 1960s Civil Rights Movement and the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (e.g., evaluating individuals “by the content of their character, not the color of their skin”). Arguing that treating individuals equally regardless of race is “ignoring inequality” conflates equality of opportunity (a core classical liberal/conservative principle) with equality of outcome(equity).

          • Straw-Manning the Opposition to DEI: The passage frames opposition to diversity programs as an effort to “ignore existing inequalities.” This ignores the legitimate legal and ethical critiques of modern DEI and affirmative action: namely, that race-based preferences in hiring, admissions, and government contracting violate the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment and constitute explicit racial discrimination against individuals who played no role in historic injustices.

          3. Logical Fallacies Regarding Identity Politics and Segregation

          • False Equivalence / Question-Begging (“Medicine vs. Disease”): The passage asserts that affirmative action and minority-focused programs are “the medicine” while calling them segregation is “confusing the medicine with the disease.” This is a circular argument that assumes the author’s preferred policies (race-conscious distribution of resources) are undeniably benign and effective. Opponents argue that institutionalizing race-based classification is a form of neo-segregation that inherently divides society along racial lines.

          • Overbroad Characterization / Ad Hominem Attack: Smearing the entire conservative populist electorate by claiming it relies on “white nationalism to fire up its voters” is an oversimplification and a broad-brush ad hominem attack. It overlooks the measurable increases in working-class Black, Hispanic, and Asian voters supporting the modern Republican Party, which undermines the claim that the movement is exclusively driven by racial animus.

          4. Rhetorical Flaws and “Garbage In, Garbage Out”

          • Hypocrisy in Rhetoric: The author closes by accusing the opponent of “repeating simple talk-radio talking points” and lacking critical thinking, yet relies heavily on mainstream partisan tropes, ideological smears (“white nationalism”), and unsupported assertions without citing specific policies or legislative data.

          • Lack of Substantive Evidence: While the paragraph demands “actual facts,” it provides zero specifics—no specific Pew study details, no economic metrics on tariffs, no specific voting rights cases, and no policy breakdowns. It relies entirely on broad assertions while criticizing the other person for doing the same.

          1. The aforementioned instance demonstrates a critical operational and methodological failure on the part of X.

          2. Anonymous @ 9:31: Yours is the best and most thought-provoking comment thus far today, thank you. I took the time to read through it. Although some of it sounds AI-ish, it nonetheless underscores some key points in addressing statements made by our fellow commenter.

            From a personal standpoint, I stopped reading that comment when I read the sentence, “Decades of data from sources like the Pew Research Center prove that the Republican party moved much further to the right than Democrats did to the left” and the proffered explanation thereto. I say no more.

            Your contribution also fits well with the “correlation coefficiency” aspect cleverly raised by commenter gdonaldallen and the agency aspect raised by Olly.

            I also again thank the good Professor Turley for providing this forum for us to engage in such exchanges on the issues and topics he raises.

            1. Lin,

              I would add, MSM also changed the definition of what was far right. If anyone is for immigration, they are “far right.”

              Yet, at one point in time, both Obama and Schumer were for stronger immigration.

              Pointing out “green energy” is not as efficient or reliable is “far right.” Uh, it is also true.

              Pointing out stupid and crazy things like biological males in women’s sports or women’s spaces, pornography in elementary school libraries, tampons in boys/mens bathrooms, Drag Queen story hour, is now “far right.”

              Being against no-cash bail to keep dangerous criminals off the streets is now “far right.”

              You get the idea.

              I think Elon Musk and Bill Maher said it best, they did not leave the party, the party left them.

    2. Republicans want to exclude and segregate. Democrats want to include and integrate. Really? Please George, tell us you don’t ingest mind expanding drugs.

      Then this: “He’s been the one figure who has embraced polarization more than anyone.” And Obama didn’t? It was so bad under the demo-nazis in the USA that for eight years the Republicans controlled congress. Obama wasn’t polarizing?

      Gawd you really are on drugs, aren’t you?

      1. Let’s be honest: Barack Obama was only called “polarizing” because the right panicked over a Black man becoming president. Bigots did everything they could to paint him as a radical because they hated seeing him in the White House. It was that obvious.

        The truth is that the Republican party does want to exclude and divide people, and Donald Trump made it much worse. Far-right extremists and nationalists have spent years crawling into the party. The old leaders let it happen because they wanted the extra votes. Now, white nationalists like Nick Fuentes are openly welcomed, and top Republican leaders refuse to condemn them. These are the exact same kinds of bigots who fought against civil rights in the 1960s. They just wear a different party label today.

        1. I’m being honest, but you can’t write a sentence without lying. Panic? Blackman? Bigots? Hey, what drugs are you using?

        2. An American President who, just out of the gate, travels to the Middle East to offer an apologia to his nation’s adversaries for his nation’s existence, is not exactly a unifying force. The ‘Atlantic’s’ piece, ‘The Obama Doctrine’ is worth the read. A work the ‘Obamaphone folks’ are not likely to, but keeping them down on the plantation is what it’s all about, isn’t it.

      1. Gee, “stealing” from someone is illegal. Voting for politicians to steal for you is called the basis of the Democrat party.

  15. If that poll graphic is even close to accurate, how far down the road to losing the Republic — as Ben Franklin warned — are we?

  16. These choices appear to be carefully crafted to produce the desired result by appealing to known preferences. Honesty is a personal characteristic, but Freedom is not. Some view a country the same way as a person; some do not. This feeds the division rather than seeking to resolve it.

    1. Are you saying there are unknown preferences? If so, what are they?

      Can one can prefer honesty over dishonesty?

      Then, freedom is not a personal preference? Then why are Americans fighting over restricted speech as opposed to unrestricted right i.e., freedom of speech.

Leave a Reply