Alaska’s Decoy Scandal Brings Back the Usual Suspects for Shady Election Tactics

(MSNBC/via YouTube)

Below is my column on the return of Marc Elias in another campaign controversy with the Alaskan decoy scandal. The Elias Law Group and other lawyers were tied to the effort to confuse Alaskan voters by The New York Times in its recent investigative report. These lawyers presumably have a growing conflict of interest as dozens of subpoenas shower down on Alaska. What is clear is that this scandal will not end on Tuesday and, if the results are close in favor of Democrat Mary Peltola, there could be a major fight over her taking her seat in the Senate.

Here is the column:

Marc Elias is back. The notorious Democratic lawyer who played a critical role in the 2016 Russia hoax is again in the news. His law firm has been identified by the New York Times as part of the expanding scandal involving Democratic effort to confuse voters in Alaska with a decoy candidate named Daniel J. Sullivan.

For those familiar with Elias’s checkered history, this is a case of rounding up the usual suspects.

The scandal involving Democratic candidate Mary Peltola has quickly snowballed this week. A New York Times blockbuster investigative report quotes former staff who claim she knew of a cynical effort by her own campaign and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee to confuse voters by recruiting and fielding a decoy “Dan Sullivan” candidate in the race against incumbent Sen. Daniel S. Sullivan (R-Alaska). State and federal investigations are now unfolding, with dozens of federal subpoenas raining down on Alaska.

The effort to get voters to cast mistaken ballots is grossly unethical and, even in these rage-filled times, a uniquely disgraceful scheme. Peltola and the Democratic Party had long denied any involvement in the other Sullivan’s candidacy. So when the Times produced evidence that she allegedly knew, and that Democratic staffers and lawyers had been deeply involved from the beginning, many of us were surprised — that is, until the name “Marc Elias” emerged. Then it made more sense.

The Elias Law Group was already in the news this election cycle for threatening reporters with defamation lawsuits if they kept asking questions about the health of former Gov. Roy Cooper, the Democratic nominee for Senate in North Carolina. Earlier, Elias caused a stir during an unsuccessful Democratic gerrymandering effort, raising the idea that Democratic leaders could abolish the entire Virginia government after courts blocked their attempted radical redistricting plan.

The fact that figures such as Peltola and Cooper wanted to be associated with any law firm headed by Elias is itself an indictment of their judgment and standards.

Despite his losses in cases such as National Republican Senatorial Committee v. Federal Election Commission, Elias is still a favorite of many on the left thanks to his aggression and partisan fervor. The controversies that make him notorious to many make him popular with others.

Elias was the general counsel to the Clinton presidential campaign when it secretly funded the infamous Steele Dossier and pushed the false Alfa Bank conspiracy theory. (His fellow Perkins Coie partner, Michael Sussmann, was later indicted but acquitted for making a false statement to the FBI.)

Clinton campaign officials lied to reporters during the 2016 campaign, denying any involvement in the Steele Dossier. Journalists discovered the truth after the election — that the Clinton campaign had hidden payments for the dossier as “legal fees” among the $5.6 million paid to Perkins Coie. New York Times reporter Ken Vogel said that when he tried to report the story, Elias “pushed back vigorously, saying ‘You (or your sources) are wrong.’”

Times reporter Maggie Haberman later observed that “Folks involved in funding this lied about it, and with sanctimony, for a year.” The Federal Election Commission ultimately sanctioned the Clinton campaign for the subterfuge.

While raising money as the self-proclaimed defenders of democracy, Elias’s group has been involved in gerrymandering and efforts criticized as seeking to invalidate Republican votes, including unsuccessful efforts to challenge Democratic electoral losses.

In Maryland, Elias’s team supported another abusive gerrymandering scheme that a court found not only violated Maryland law but the state constitution’s equal protection, free speech and free elections clauses. The court found that the proposed map “subverts the will of those governed.”

One media site accused Elias and his group of “making millions off gerrymandering efforts” while publicly denouncing Republican gerrymandering.

In 2024, Elias’s legal team was also accused of pushing “to bar third-party presidential candidates — including Cornel West — from swing state ballots where they might siphon votes” from Democratic nominee Kamala Harris.

Likewise, the New York Times reported that the Elias firm’s work “on behalf of a Soros-funded PAC in Texas … was opposed by a left-leaning election watchdog as undermining laws intended to limit the influence of major donors.”

His group’s work for New York’s redistricting effort was ridiculed as not only ignoring the express will of the voters and also effectively negating Republicans’ votes.

In 2024, the Chief Judge of the Western District of Wisconsin criticized the Elias Law Group for one of its challenges. Judge James Peterson (an Obama appointee) said that the argument “simply does not make any sense.”

Now, Elias’s group is linked to the decoy scandal in Alaska, which allegedly aimed to make voters cast mistaken ballots. What distinguishes lawyers involved in this type of voter disruption is less their talent as their willingness. There are simply some things that most lawyers will not do.

There is also a difference in how lawyers are treated in such controversies. It often seems that election controversies involving Republican lawyers are more likely to end with bar charges and disbarments. Take John Eastman, the former Trump lawyer disbarred in California after a state bar panel found that he had pushed unfounded legal theories and conspired to obstruct the electoral vote count on Jan. 6, 2021.

Although I publicly disagreed with Eastman’s theories, I opposed the effort to disbar him as setting a dangerous precedent for lawyers seeking to advance novel or unpopular theories of recovery or liability. After all, lawyers on the left routinely advance dubious theories, including some that are more ideologically than legally driven. Such controversies rarely rise to the level of disbarment, especially when more appropriate sanctions are available, ranging from reprimands to fines.

Eastman is currently asking the Supreme Court to overturn his disbarment. It is unlikely that Elias Law Group or Peltola’s lawyers will face similar disbarment efforts — nor should they, in my view, unless they were involved in criminal conduct. But the disparate treatment afforded to counsel in this country by party remains a growing concern. What draws a shower of bar complaints for Republican lawyers brings a windfall of clients for Democratic lawyers.

The New York Times has produced sources alleging that lawyers for Peltola’s campaign were involved in this effort, even though they previously told a federal court that they “lack knowledge or information” and “deny any allegation about those purposes.” Such filings and statements could raise ethical or even criminal questions in investigations at both the state and federal levels.

Meanwhile, though, tens of thousands of voters in Alaska have already cast ballots that included the decoy Sullivan candidate. This could result in a nasty fight in Congress if Peltola prevails in the vote count. And when it happens, that is where we will find Marc Elias in his element.

Jonathan Turley is a law professor and the New York Times best-selling author of “Rage and the Republic: The Unfinished Story of the American Revolution.”

 

254 thoughts on “Alaska’s Decoy Scandal Brings Back the Usual Suspects for Shady Election Tactics”

  1. I get it, dirty politics and I doubt it breaks any laws. Part of me even wants to laugh because I thought it was an onion piece when I first read it. Yet the chutzpah this one takes is really amazing. It might even work.

    Just remember Democrats, the sauce good for the goose is good for the gander. So when the chickens come home to roost, do not complain if you are not complaining now. Because you know this will happen to you too in the future.

    It may not be illegal, but it is certainly unethical. Politicians and ethics seem to be mutually exclusive nowadays and that is a sad state of affairs.

  2. Interesting October ratings for cable news channels

    Fox down 28%

    CNN up 19%

    MS NOW up 13%

    Tomorrow will be an extinction level event for Trump and the GOP.

    1. ROFL

      How so ?

      Trump will be president for the next 2 years.

      Assuming the BEST possible outcome for Dems on Tuesday they will control the house and Senate, but not able to get past a filibuster or veto.

      Democrats will NOT be able to accomplish anything but “investigate” – and that has gone badly for them every time they have done so in the past.

      1. Trump will be a limited president. Plus, it’s uncertain Trump will last two years with his poor health.

        1. Contra wing nuts there is no evidence of Poor health.

          But he is old enough that sudden changes in his health are possible – but the odds are very good he survives and thrives over the next 32 years.

          Clinton Biombeed the crap out of the Balkans as a lame duck. He tried to negotiate a peace deal with Arafat.

          He behave more freely as a lame duck with the other party in power than he did in the prior 6 years.

          His approval went from 37% to 69%.

          Obama bombed the Crap out of Libya, massively increased his Drone program killing thousands of civilians. Negotiate JCPOA – which is a treaty and requires senate confimation which it never got, Gave the Iranians billions, and went from 39% approval to 60%

          This is only a small part of what each did in their last two years after losing a midterms badly.

          The Big issue regarding Trump’s power as a “lame duck” is the extent to which those in the current administration stay and stay committed,

          The huge problem lame duck presidents face is that their staff – from the top to the bottom start looking towards 2028.

          The moment this election is over – the 2028 election cycle starts. While Trump is pretty much a king maker in that,

          everyone in both parties is going to start campaigning for whatever their next job is. Democrats and Republicans start jocking for PResident and VP slots and Senate Challenges and open seats and Represenative challenges and open seats.

          Specifically related to Trump:

          Vance is not going anywhere – he is in this to the end – VP’s always are – he is the heir aparent for President.

          Rubio is almost certain to be in this to the end – he is waiting in the wings to be president if there is any issue with Vance and VP if there is not.

          Aside from Rubio Trump’s foreign policy team is people like Kushner and Whitkopf – they are not that high a profile and not going anywhere.

          I doubt that Hegseth is going anywhere. My guess is he is looking for Sec State under President Vance.

          RFK Jr. has nowhere else to go.

          While This Trump term has had MORE significant roles by people outside of the WH – Trump proved in his first term that he could run the entire country with little support from his administration from inside the WH.

          Trump can afford people leaving to seek future jobs.

          You are correct that Trump could have a stroke or some other health problems – but that is not likely – and contra the wet fever dreams of democrats – there is no current evidence of that.

          Further on Jan 22, 2027 anything that happens to Trump would result in a President Vance having the opportunity to serve for nearly 10 years.

          I would not count your chickens until they are hatched. But even if this election goes badly – it is not the end of Trump.

          It is Trump unleashed and looking to accomplish what ever he can with as Obama said “the pen and the phone”.

          You already impeached him twice – he has no reason to care if you are stupid enough to do it again.

          There are 535 members of congress – there are 10,000 FBI agents, massive numbers in DHS and DOJ.

          If the next two years are going to be about investigations – let the subpeonas fly.

          Further Fixating on Trump is counter productive. Trump will be gone in 2028, no matter what.

          Democrats need to kill MAGA – and MAGA is not Trump. Frankly Dems may be in WORSE shape without Trump, Because while there is definitely an issue of Trumps appeal and charisma, Every successor to Trump starts with far less negatives.

  3. Senate Republicans will be willing to remove Trump after impeachment, as a way to punish him for causing the Blue Wave.

    1. It is unlikely for that to happen as the Senate Republicans are beholden to the same dark-money forces that Trump is. The only one who will come out against Trump are ones retiring from politics entirely.

      1. This is the first election ever in which republicans have raised more money than democrats.

        Absolutely there is “dark money” in politics – and most of it goes to democrats.

        Are those of you on the left SANE ?

        As always you are clueless about what you post.

        Regardless – lets presume for a minute that Democrats have a blowout Tuesday – that will PROVE once again that money does not determine outcomes. Trump was outspent in 2016 and 2024 and won both times.

        If Democrats win big on Tuesday they will have been outspent and won.

        All that does is refute your claim that money controls politics.

        Regardless rich and poor people donate to candidates that reflect their values.

      2. James Talarico’s campaign has spent 8x as much as his opponent. Where do you fancy that $136 million came from?

        1. Talarico’s opponent is toxic. No one wants to donate or support that bottle of poison. That it’s only 8X is a sign there are Republicans who will back the human version of an ammonia gas cloud.

          1. And yet the election is a dead heat and in pretty much all elections in the past 20 years undecided break heavily Republican as election day approaches.

    2. In your dreams, I am NOT MAGA and NOT REPUBLICAN – but MAGA is the future of the Republican party.

      It has created a new reliable base for the GOP and it has massively increased GOP support among minorities.

      And what Idiot thinks that Democrats want “President Vance” for the next two years would would then be able to run two more times ?

      1. “It has created a new reliable base for the GOP and it has massively increased GOP support among minorities.”

        ROFL!!

        MAGA will cease to exist the moment Trump is no longer in the picture. Just like the Tea Party republicans. Republicans will end up having to reinvent themselves once again after Trump goes.

        1. X the Tea Party became MAGA – just a rebranding excercise.

          If you think MAGA is going away you are brain dead.

          While Europe is a mess and I am not predicting specific election – the trend accross Europe is slow gains on the right and increasing desparation on the left.

          Many of the issues that drive MAGA in the US – working class, immigration. …. are the same in Europe.

          We are seeing the Same in Canada – Conservatives just unexpectedly swept BC – did WAY better than polls – first time BC has had a conservative govenrment in 100 years.

          Canada is splitting in similar ways to the US – Canadian elections are weird Carney just called a snap election – Dev. 7 but only in 7 districts – all but one currently an NDP seat (candaian far left) that Carney thinks he can pick up. He dare not run a general election or he is gone.

          England can not run a general election or labor is gone.

          Netanyahu was supposed to lose in Israel – Lakud apears to have held on – though it is messy – Israeli politics is.

          No matter what – there is no likely Israeli government that is headed in a different direction.

          Despite the likely Fraudulent win of Lulu in Brazil – it is only a matter of time before the Brazillian left fails – they suck at governing and imprisioning your oposition only works for a while.

          The rest of South America is headed right – though the issues are different than in the US.

          The POINT is that there is nowhere in the world where the right is fading.

          MAGA does not need to change – whether you like it or not most of their issues are supermajority issues.

          Democrats made the current election about Trump – not MAGA. They made it about the economy – oddly persuading the far left that a far better economy than Bidens was bad. Regardless polling over all – still says that Democrats are 10pts less favorable than republicans and that Republican issues are at the top of everyone agenda and has super majority support.

          Assuming Democrats gain atleast one chamber of congress they will NOT be able to blame Republicans for anything in 2028.

          At the same time – as most everything will likely be significantly improved – they also will not be able to take credit for any of it either.

          I do not doubt Democrats will fixate on investigations – it is all they will be able to do.

          So we will get lots of loony Democrats spewing nonsense until the election cycle starts again.

      2. Well i did, js, until my error was corrected. 2/3 senate vote and not simple majority.

        I’m fatigued by what I view as terrorism.

    3. Again assuming that D’s win big on Tuesday – which does not appear likely,

      I highly doubt the Senate will waste much time on trying to remove Trump.

      It is politically counter productive.

      It did not work before, it just makes democrats look stupid and vindictive.

      Further it empowers Trump’s DOJ Investigations of democrats.

      There is a giant difference between Congressional investigations and those of DOJ – DOJ can send people to jail.

      1. I agree it will be pointless to go after Trump after the election. But they can still go after Trumps inner circle. Like Hegseth and a few others. Trump is useless without them.

        1. No Trump is not useless without them – his entire First term was accomplished almost completely from inside the WH.

          Regardless – Have fun – Go after Hegseth Do you really think you are getting anywhere ?

          Further I gave you my rough analysis of what will happen within the administration after this election.

          Much of what will happen is unrelated to the outcome of this election.

          Hegseth, Rubio and Vance are going nowhere.

          Maybe Mullin will go after a Senate Seat again – but DHS will continue as it is. Deportations will continue.

          Blanche was confirmed as AG – and he is not going anywhere.

          No one is leaving because of “investigations” – I fully expect that the administration will be as obstructive as h311 – fighting subpeona for ever – possibly forcing contempt votes, and then failing to prosecute. You keep forgetting that Trump controls the DOJ.

          There will be no Special Counsels. Democrat investigations will be long slogs. bitter and acrimonious.

          Democrats treated Republicans in the house like $hit last time they were in the majority – that is likely to be worse this time – and that will result in big time vengance in 2029. Fool me once – shame on you – fool me twice shame on me.

          Regardless Democrats with power behave abysmally.

          You are your own worst enemy.

          1. John, Trump’s first term was mess and a sh!tshow. It failed miserably. That is why on his second term he did slightly better.

            Hegseth is not going to last the term. Vance is the VP all he has to do to last the full two years is literally nothing. Rubio, can sit pretty and pretend to be doing something meaningful as SOC while Kushner and Lutnick do all the heavy lifting and make a tidy profit while at it.

            Trump’s administration can be as obstructive as they can be, sure. But…that won’t help them with the next election if they want to retake the senate or the house or even keep the presidency.

            Once Trump is neutered by a new Democratic majority in Congress Republicans will find they actually have a spine and maybe, just maybe start compromising and making deals Trump can’t deny.

            Democrats with power can show there is something better than Trump just sitting on his desk with a veto pen on everything. Republicans right now are actively distancing themselves from Trump, his base is shrinking because of the fact he’s not delivering on his promises.

            This election will be a referendum on Trump’s policies and essentially they will be firing him without removing him from office. He will be a true lame duck president.

            Trump will not be the issue in the last two years of his term. It is highly likely he will not even survive the next two years due to his poor health.

            It will be a fun night to watch Republican sweat and worry about what the future holds for them after tonight and the next few days.

        2. X – rather than Make things up – actually THINK.

          Do you honestly beleive Rubio, Vance, or Hegseth are leaving ? There futures rest with the success of the next two years.

          RFK Jr. has no future outside of the GOP and he has a job that he actually wants.

          AG Blanche is not a politician and this is the pinacle of his carreer.

          Trump’s negotiating team is Whitkopf and Kushner – do you really think they are leaving ?

          Post mid terms – NO MATTER WHAT

          Trump will be free to do as he wishes regarding Iran, and Tariffs – he has no more elections to win.

          He will Absolutely be looking at his legacy.

          That means getting a peace deal in Ukraine – right now is the best chance of that.

          He needs to end the Iran conflict – before leaving office.

          But once the election is over there is no need to try to rush.

          He can rain h311 on Iran or wait for them to collapse.

          Carney’s best chance for a Deal was just before the election and he blew it.

          Canada is suffering 10 times as much as the US.

          Trump can afford to pi$$ off americans effected by Trade with Canada after the election – so long as things improve before he leaves.

          Which with certainty they will. One of Canada’s huge problems is there is NOTHING we get from Canada we need.

          We used to make the car parts we get from Canada – we can do that again. That takes time – but once it happens – Canada is screwed permanently – or we can get them from Mexico. Again takes time, but once suplly chains shift – they will not come back.

          We produce our own lumber, We produce more oil than we consume. It is convenient to get it from Canada, but not necesxcary.

          Further Western Canada has said Screw you to Carney regarding oil to the US.

          Much the same is true of ALL Trump tariffs – if they last long enough – production moves to the US.

          It has been moving slowly anyway – Tariffs just speed it up.

          Trump has massively disrupted the global economy in this term.

          He has done so in a way that has short term negative consequences for everyone.

          But deal or no deal the long term benefits are to the US.

          We have the capacity to produce everything we need – in time.

          The rest of the world can give Trump what he wants or get screwed.

          Regardless Democrats can do nothing about that – even if they have a huge blue wave.

          Again What is it that you think is changing ?

          Most everything that Democrats have tried to weaponize in this election is far better than you claim and is improving.

          1. John Say, you’re focusing on the wrong individual. Trump is useless without the rest of his inner circle. He can’t function effectively.

            After the midterms Trump may be free to do more of what he wants. But….Republicans in Congress won’t. Not if you don’t want a Democrat like AOC or maybe El-Sayed to run for president in 28’.

            Hegseth won’t last two more years. Rubio is just a placeholder as Secretary of State. He’s useless. Vance is still well disliked by the majority of republicans and he’s definitely not Trump. He can’t carry the MAGA base as well as Trump does.

            “We have the capacity to produce everything we need – in time.”

            LOL! No we don’t. That’s the problem. It takes decades to achieve that and that depends on the simple fact that we cannot compete against China on manufacturing and distribution. We can’t even compete in the automotive market without serious tariffs in place.

            “We produce our own lumber, We produce more oil than we consume. It is convenient to get it from Canada, but not necesxcary.”

            ROFL!

            We get almost all of our lumber from Canada. We import 60% of “our” oil from Canada. If we were to cut off Canada completely prices would sky rocket and new home construction would be hugely expensive.

            We get the majority of our aluminum from Canada. We don’t have the capacity to produce the amount of aluminum we need by ourselves without investing in huge new energy sources to power aluminum smelters. Not when we are building gigantic energy gobbling and resources hungry data centers many oppose.

            Yeah, supply chains can shift, but they take a LONG TIME and we cannot compete with cheaper sources like Mexico and China. Canada can sell their aluminum to china, they can sell their oil to china, they can sell their lumber to China and we get stuck trying to build out our on sources while they continue to progress far ahead of us instead of cooperating and keeping a lead.

            This is why Trump is an idiot when it comes to tariffs and his animosity against Canada. Even your libertarian free market sense knows we cannot compete against China and its gargantuan supply chains and manufacturing hubs that are literally cities dedicated to one product and supply chain. Plus…they can mass produce much faster and…cheaper than we can.

            We screwed up a long time ago when we let our own greed and quarterly profit estimates dominate our thinking. It was our ‘free market’ that led to offshoring the majority of our manufacturing and skilled labor to cheaper countries so our corporate boards and shareholders could get….more profits and offer consumers cheaper products.

            Ragging on Canada won’t solve our problems nor will our “decoupling” of our supply chains from theirs. Trump is too stupid to realize what he’s doing and by the time he’s done it will be a LONG time before we can even think about competing against the likes of China or other countries with better supply chains and cheaper labor.

  4. Today’s topic is allegedly about honesty. Turley begins by repeating the MAGA phrase “Russian hoax”–there was NO “Russian hoax”–even a Republican-led Senate Intelligence Committee report found that Russian hackers were directed by Trump’s campaign where to spread misinformation about her where they believed support for her was soft enough to make a difference–because they were afraid of her. Trump’s representative, OTOH, called murderous dictator Putin “a humanitarian” for releasing an American teacher. There are reports that Putin has the goods on Trump from the Epstein files, which we know were hacked by some foreigner.

    Let’s talk about scandals. Susan Collins went after Graham Platner for allegations of domestic violence, but her own skirts are very dirty. Her husband is Thomas Daffron, the CEO of Jefferson Consulting, which got a $76 million government contract for acquisition and improvement consulting after Collins wrote a bill requiring such consulting. Collins wrote a bill establishing the Federal Acquitision Institute–for strategic planning, which required the services of a company such as Jefferson Consulting.

    Collins’s defense–her husband never “really lobbied” her. Collins, despite constantly being allegedly “concerned” about Trump, the Epstein files and other scandals, almost always votes in lockstep with Trump, so she is enabling Trump to acquire $1.4 Billion from the sales of his worthless crypto, much of which was purchased by foreign governments, as well as his lenient attitude toward regulation of crypto.

    What do Turley and MAGA media have to say about all of this–nothing. The “big scandal” is Mary Peltola allegedly “knowing” about some plot to confuse Alaska voters. Any Alaskan with average reading comprehension would not be confused, as the Republican incumbent is clearly identified.

    1. Dems fight Gabbard’s disclosure with faulty Senate report that claimed Steele Dossier wasn’t in ICA

      https://justthenews.com/government/federal-agencies/dems-combat-gabbard-declass-pointing-senate-report-which-wrongly?utm_source=referral&utm_medium=offthepress&utm_campaign=home

      Newly declassified evidence suggests FBI conspired with Clinton to legitimize Russiagate allegations

      https://justthenews.com/government/federal-agencies/damning-classified-annex-durham-clinton-plan-intel-released

    2. Declassified intel ties Soros to Clinton’s Russiagate plan for FBI to ‘put more oil into the fire’

      https://justthenews.com/government/federal-agencies/clinton-plan-tying-trump-russia-had-hope-fbi-will-put-more-oil-fire

      After alleged Clinton Russia ruse was intercepted by US intel, Biden took first shot smearing Trump

      https://justthenews.com/government/white-house/biden-took-lead-tying-trump-putin-following-alleged-approval-clintons

    3. Of course there was a “Russia hoax”

      No the senate did NOT find what you claim, nor did the senate results hold up.

      Hillary Clinton paid Perkins Coi – Marc Alias hire Fusion GPS to hire Steele who hired Danchenko a possible russian spy to manufacture the Steele Dossier which was then shilled to the FBI and the only reason that no one went to jail is that even though the FBI and Mueller used it as the basis of a 2 year investigation that found nothing, They persuaded a DC jury that the FBI never beleived the Steele Dosier and therefore they was no material lie to a federal agent.

      No no one find any ty between the Trump campaign and Russian hackers.

      Nor did anyone find any tie between Russain hackers and the DNC emails

      The breach of the DNC was almost certainly an inside job. Probably a Bernie supported angry that the DNC had cheated Sanders out of a shot at the election.

      God not more of the Putin B$ – Trumps conflict with Iran has cost Putin 40% of his munitions supply – it is a major factor in the momemntum in the war tipping towards Ukraine.

      If Putin had the goods on Trump the US never would have attacked Iran.

      Regardless you left wing nuts seem to think that Putin is some super powerful villian.

      Russia which si 5 times Ukraines size is loosing a war with Ukraine.

      Putin has had his pants pulled down in public – He and Russia are impotent.

      I would further note that it is Democrats – Obama, Biden and Clinton that have the serious links to Russia.

      It is Obama that fell over himself to try to reset the US relationship with Russia after Hillary Pissed off Putin with the Orange revolution.

      It is Hillary and Obama that greenlit the Uranium One Deal. It is Biden who was paid by Russian Oligarchs to protect them from a Russian prosecutor.

      No Collins is not dirty. This is old crap. Collins did not award a contract to her husband. She did not write letters for him, She did not trade stocks based on Senate information. Your still shilling this nonsense that anyone Republican that makes money in anyway is crooked and any democrat who does so is a hero.

      And you left wing nuts are still shilling the Epstain files ?

      We already know – that for over 20 years Trump and Spstain were essentially at War with each other.

      From the moment Trump threw him out of MAL and reported him to FL Law enforcement which resulted in his First Trafficking conviction.

      It is NOT Trump that gave him the sweet heart deal – it was the Bush administration, then the Obama administration left Epstain alone and the Trump administration investigated and arrested Epstain.

      If Epstain had dirt on Trump he would not have died in Jail.

      With respect to your Trump nonsense.

      If you think Trump Crypto is worthless DON’T BUY IT – no one is holding a gun to your head.

      No one is forced to stay in a Trump hotel, play golf at a Trump golf course, Buy Trump sneakers, ….

      Crypto does not need regulation. Its purpose is to replace money. It is not owned or controlled by anyone.

      1. “And you left wing nuts are still shilling the Epstain files ?”

        MAGA was demanding the Epstein files. They were the ones promised by Trump he would release them. All they’ve gotten is obfuscations and excuses.

        1. And millions of pages of documents.

          Regardless, if you want all the epstain dirt – get his victims to sue the estate and subpeona everything that is the legal and constitutional way to do so.

          Some of us still beleive in the constitution.

          I want everyone participating in Epstains garbage to get exposed – constitutionally.

          But that is not happening – very very few victims have gone to court.

          Further my guess is that Epstains ties to foreign intelligence are incredibly strong – and to the CIA.

          It is not Trump that is really stalling this – it is the “deep state” – but one of the differences between Trump 45 and Trump 47 – is Trump now MOSTLY owns the deep state.

          I am not personally all that happy with Trump’s accomidation with the Deep State.

          But it has taken place. It brings many NeoCons back to the GOP and the detente is still advancingt Trump’s global policy – not the Deep States.

          I would prefer to see the deep state castrated – I am libertarian. Regardless, Those knifing Trump in the back are gone and the rest are playing ball. If I were to guess Trump is protecting US and foreign intelligence services.

          Not because they were involved in Epstains sexcapades. But because they were otherwise heaily involved with Epstain.

          Do you think he got a sweetheart del in the Bush admin magically ?

          1. Millions of useless documents. Trump is still avoiding the important documents linking him to Epstein. He’s gotten to the point where once again he’s violating the law. Blanche is trying mighty hard to avoid releasing everything and that is after Congress specifically passed a law demanding its release. Talk about lawless.

            FYI, Trump IS the deep state. He’s being lawless and you’re there twiddling your thumbs and wringing your hands over the fact that you cannot bring yourself to admit Trump is indeed the most corrupt president in our lifetimes.

            1. No Trump is not avoiding documnets that will link him to Epstain.

              Plenty has come out – All of it is Epstain saying how much he hates Trump and that Trump is dirty.

              Duh, Epstain hated Trump because he spent time in Jail in FL because of Trump.

              As to your claims – your nuts.

              Obama could have investigated Epstain – HE DID NOT.

              Biden could have investigated Epstain – HE DID NOT.

              People in the Biden or Obma administration could have leaked anything damaging to Trump – THEY DID NOT.

              They leaked all kinds of collusion delusion nonsense.

              They leaked things that proved FALSE.

              The leaked Epstain stuff that implicated everyone from Mick Jagger to Bill Gates – but NOTHING regarding Trump.

              Please tell me when your “wet dreams” of “Getting Trump” have Ever proven true ?

              What you dream is being hidden DOES NOT EXIST.

              MAGA wanted everything – because they beleived it implicated Dems.

              Millions of docs have unconstitutionally been release – again some of us actually beleive in the constitution.

              In this case the 4th amendment – The govenrment goes after people through THE COURTS – through prosections.

              The government may not constitutionally release the product of investigations without prosecuting, and then only what is deemed admissable in court.

              DOJ can not be used for fishing expeditions. And if Prosecutors are not willing to take cases to court – they are done.

              Regardless Prosecutors do not hold the only evidence of anything.

              You beleive Trump didled underage girls – So where are those people ?

              Virginia Guffrie cam out and exposed Prince Andrew – Implicating Trump would get you a massive book deal and incredble settlement.

              All you have is EJC – who is not credible, was not underage, did not actually claim rape or sexual assult and can not even tell anyont the year her alleged encounter with Trump took place – much less the Date. The claim was manufactured to precule Trump being able to defend against it. Trump has beaten all prior such idiotic nonsense – even in NYC because sane courts followed the law and REquired those bringing claims to provide sufficient information that the defendant had a reasonable oportunity to defend against.

              You pulled the same nonsense with Kavanaugh – and then tried to assassinate him.

              Aside from the FACT that alleged victims could come forward if they existed and win the lottery.

              Thge Press has been all over this and the collusion delusion nonese – and we had years of Mueller and 2 Years of Jack Smith. Meuller even investigated the alleged Pee Tape. – Read the testimony from Danchenko – The pee tape does not exist, it was a made up claim that he added to the Dossier.

              Trump is by far the most investigated person in the world.

              If anything existed – it would be found.

              There is absolutely nothing that DOJ has that some other person in this world – likely MANY other people in this world do not also have.

              NYT was able to ferret out the Peltola fraud – that required getting insiders to provide information – and they got LOTS of information.

              You do not need to be the FBI to dig up dirt.

              This is one of the huge reasons I do not beleive Stormy Daniels.

              Trump has cheated on his wife TWICE – and we KNOW that. He married the women he cheated with.

              No sane person beleives that Trump has never cheated on his wives.

              I do not know if he cheated on Melania – but I have no problem beleiving he did.

              But the actual Claim is that Trump paid Daniels 80K to hush up an unexciting daliance a decade+ earlier to hide it from the public during an election.

              Hillary paid 1.6M for the steele Dossier – Do you honestly think theHRC campaign or its dark money Billionaires could not pony up far more than 80K for Daniels story ?

              Almost always the value of dirt – particularly political dirt is FAR higher with the persons oponent.

              Daniels is a quite smart person. She knew that – yet she came to Trump – not Clinton.

              The reason that you come to the alleged actor rather than their political enemies is because the story is FALSE.

              Selling a false story to an oponent makes you liable for defamation.

              Selling it to the person it is about is perfectly legal.

              And we KNOW Trump has paid to silence FALSE stories.

              He paid off a doorman for a false story about a love child with a hispanic maid.

              He paid little, and the story did ultimately come out and was proven false.

              Again – even the false stories about Trump have ultimately come out.

              You beleive things that are litterally impossible.

              This is an example – the collusion delusion is another.

              You beleive the Trump campaign managed to collude with Russia without leaving any traces ?

              That Trump’s operatives – people like Stone and Manafort and Pappadoulis and Cohen were so good at tradecraft that they managed this without leaving a single thread. That the best intelligence agencies in the world have been unable to get Anything – or are hiding it to protect Trump ? This would be the same people who got him impeached the first time ?

              You beleive that every news agency in the world has been unable to find a shred of evidence of anything ?

              Every single Trump scandal that you have ever come up with is for things that Trump has done PUBLICLY.

              His golden bibles, his golden sneakers, his crypto, His College, Various busness deals.

              Every one has been done publicly and openly.

              No there is no secret trove of damning Trump material that only DOJ has.

              That is absurd.

              Biden was brought down by information that was ferreted out because there is no crime in the world that does not involve other people.

              We KNOW that the Biden WH was directly involved in the “Get Trump” efforts leading up to the 2024 election – do ou honestly beleive that Biden would not leak damaging information on Trump ?

              This is the problem with EVERYTHING about YOU – you are NOT rational about anything.

              You beleive all kinds of end of the world nonsense.

              You beleive all kinds of absurd conspiracy theories.

              You were fooled by collusion delusion nonsense.

              By the Bidens, by myriads of things on Covid,

              You get fooled again and again.

              And having been played as a fool – you double down and decide that Trump “the all powerful Oz” is somehow paying people off are leveraging power he does not have over people who hate him to keep them silent,

              and that all this occurs without a single crack.

    4. The scandal is Democrats engaged in Election Fraud.

      The extent to which Peltola herself is involved is not well established THUS FAR.

      But her campaign was HEAVILY involved, a SuperPAC supporting her was HEAVILY involved, Marc Elias was HEAVILY Involved. the DSCC was Heavily involved.

      If you attempt to murder someone and fail because you are too stupid or your victim is smart enough to survive that does not prevent you from being charged and convicted of attempted murder.

      You are not innocent of a crime purely because your attempt is unsuccessful.

      1. “You are not innocent of a crime purely because your attempt is unsuccessful.”

        Weird. Because that’s what has happened to Trump. Clearly he’s not innocent either. He’s still a convicted felon.

        1. Yes, you convicted Trump of a non-crime.

          Nobody bought it

          Get over yourself.

          You have NEVER successfully persuaded the american people – not just the left wing nuts, that Trump is guilty of anything.

          You lost, Get over it.

          When you go back to the same nonsense – you will lose again.

          So PLease – bring on the investigations.

          We can have congress and DOJ dueling.

          My bet is on DOJ.

          Why ? Because they are going after REAL CRIMES, and they have the power to put you in jail.

          Congress does not even have the power to enforce its own subpeonas.

          1. John Say, Trump did commit a crime, multiple crimes to be exact (34).

            It’s on the record and he is still a convicted felon. Pretending he wasn’t is pure denial.

            You’re betting on the DOJ? Are you sure? Because they have an awful record in court. Failed case after failed case including a record for no bill findings from grand juries. Jeanine Pirro has had an no luck convincing grand juries to convict.

            The only ones who “didn’t buy it” were the MAGA nut cases. They will never be convinced of the fact Trump is a convicted felon and a thoroughly corrupt president.

            1. Of course more than 80M people were not convinced – most of whom are NOT MAGA – because People (outside the left) are NOT stupid,

              If I am having an affair with the neighbor and I write checks to cover the motel bills and call them Lodging expenses – is that a crime ?

              My wife will have a field day and pummel me over the infidelity, the checks will be evidence of that in court.

              But no one is going to try this idiot Nonsense of claiming writing Lodging on my personal private records that are NOT required and can not legally and constitutionally be required to be accurate is somehow a felony.

              I know this is hard for you left wing nuts – but what is and is not a crime is NOT arbitrary.

              ALL Crimes require violations of their rights to life liberty or property of others.

              If your actions do not do that – they are NOT a crime.

        2. Trump is innocent because you failed to prove your allegations to the largest jury in the world.

          Is he technically a convicted Felon – sure. Has anyone come close to actually proving that ? Not even close.

          All you are doing is demonstrating the depth of your own delusions.

          Further your analogy is garbage – Trump Successfuly paid Daniels to keep a false claim quiet.

          While technically Trump did not hold a press confernce anouncing his payments to Daniels – as Jared Kushner did with his management deals with the Qataris – he made the payments – sometimes from the Oval, involving a number of other people. And Contra left wing nuts those payments were legal and the records of those payments are only legally admissible as evidence of OTHER frauds – like failure to pay your taxes.

          A persons own business records or the records of a non-public company are NOT public records, They are private records and you can not defraud yourself. The entire basis of the Bragg/Merchan nonsense was that Trump lied on records he never had any obligation to disclose to prevent people from learning something that might have effected the election AFTER the election.

          Only a left wing nut can beleive that nonsense.

          in 2024 the american people did not elect a convited Felon – because they are smarter than you credit them for and did not beleive this idiotic claim.

    5. Wasnt the double Dan already litigated and corrected before the primary? Double Dan got 1% of the vote? Voters were not confused. The remaining interest is in the rank voting. I couldnt find a comparison showing Real Dan as number 1 choice v Peltola as number 1. Imo

      1. Wasnt the double Dan already litigated and corrected before the primary?

        No.

        The remaining interest is in the rank voting. I couldnt find a comparison showing Real Dan as number 1 choice v Peltola as number 1.

        The ranked-choice election hasn’t happened yet, so of course you can’t find any results. Expect them on Wednesday.

      2. DEcoy Dan was allowed on the ballot because months ago alaska was unable to prove to the courts that he was on the ballot fraudulently rather than legitimately. Decoy Dan lied to the court and the court beleived him. Lying to courts is a crime in and of itself.

        Regardless months ago the Evidence of fraud was not available – now it is.

        Voting data is irrelevant. The core question is whether Decoy Dan – and more importantly the Peltola campaign, the DSCC the involved SuperPAC

        and Marx Elias were trying to decieve voters into wasting their right to vote.

        It is a crime whether they succeed or not. If you try to murder someone and you mis – it is still attempted murder.

        1. No, it wasn’t because the state couldn’t prove he was not running in good faith. It was because the statutory language the secretary was relying on to exclude him for bad faith simply did not say what she claimed it did. The state supreme court found that it doesn’t matter whether a candidate is running in good faith or in bad. If he’s qualified and has properly filed his candidacy he must be placed on the primary ballot, and if he’s in the top four then he must be placed on the November ballot. There simply isn’t any language in the statute that allows him to be excluded, even if he were to openly admit that he’s a Democrat shill.

  5. -I should clarify that my earlier comment specifically related to the Professor’s sentence about votes already cast while litigation continues. I agree with the state’s initial resolution of printing ballots showing that the “decoy” Sullivan appears without a party designation next to his name, vis a vis incumbent Senator Sullivan being expressly listed as the Republican incumbent. I was referring to the sequelae (and unknown revelations) occurring after those votes were cast.

    1. Lin, on another topic, what do you think of El-Sayed’s explanation that parents shouldn’t be concerned about men in their daughters’ competitive sports, locker rooms, and showers because there is already pornography on the internet?

      1. OldManFromKS,

        Not speaking for Lin here, but if I may interject . . . that is just plain stupid.

        Big difference between one by their own choice to go to a pornography site on the internet vs women being forced to have to share a locker room, shower with a biological male.

        There is a reason why some women choose to change in a janitorial closet vs. in a locker room with a biological male.

        Recently Haley Stevens endorsed GOP candidate Mike Rogers, earning the ire of many far leftist illiberals. She said in an interview,

        “I’m with a lot of other Democrats, and we’re all going to want to come back home.”

        i.e. to come back to a sane and normal party and not the illiberal leftist that have embraced the stupid and crazy.

        Interview here: https://www.thefp.com/p/exclusive-haley-stevens-says-i-wasnt-honest-with-myself-michigan-election-midterms-democrats-republicans?utm_campaign=260347&utm_source=cross-post&r=b4a3o&utm_medium=email

        1. Upstate – yeah that was kinda what I was thinking: a middle school or high school girl having to disrobe and shower next to a male has nothing at all to do with internet porn. Nor does sacrificing scholarships, awards, and other opportunities for which the girl has trained her whole life, all because a mediocre male athlete wants to compete against people he has a biological advantage over.

          1. OldManFromKS,

            And that is what the far leftist illiberals are defending . . . as Haley said,

            “I’m with a lot of other Democrats, and we’re all going to want to come back home.”

            1. It seems to me Haley’s “lot of other Democrats” is a minority. The majority of Dems these days appear to be clinically insane. Mainly among white suburban liberal women who all seem to have gone bonkers.

        2. Yup. Force trans-men back into the women’s locker room and shower where they belong.

          Also, try not to think of what gay men are considering when they see you bend to pick up the soap in the clubhouse shower. (probably revulsion.)

      2. OMFK – we get idiotic explanations like that all the time.

        Right here and now myriads of posters are claiming that Decoy Dan is not election fraud because only stupid voters would be fooled.

        So what.

        1. 1% were fooled. It doesn’t make a difference because the gap was 9 points or so?

          Disclaimer: I could be delusional

          1. It is irrelevant whether it makes a difference.

            If you attempt to murder someone – you are not innocent because you only wounded them.

      3. This type of argument is typical of the absurd nonsense we see from the left.

        First – if you are exposed to something on the internet – YOU chose to be exposed – if that is not the case – the website will be shutdown and those involved likely jailed.

        Next – nothing you encounter on the internet is going to jump off the screen and come after you.

        We have serveral cases of MTF trans people raping women – in bathrooms, lockerooms, prisons.

        El Sayed is making the same stupid apples to oranges argument the left makes all the time – X and Nutascha do that here constantly

        Such catagory errors are the bread and butter of the left.

        Worse still these are usually stacked catagory errors.

        It is likely impossible to prevent your children from being exposed to sexuality today.

        That is why parents should address things in an age appropriate way.

        But the inevitability of exposure does not mean we jump straight to subject pre-schoolers to people having anal sex in shopping malls

        You do not have to be a rocket scientist to grasp that the right to privacy is not the right to force onto children in public your private life.

  6. In Texas we have an ethical rule that would permit disbarment for bringing disrepute to lawyers. I disagree with Prof. Turley on this one, Elias and some of the lawyers in his firm should be disbarred. Turley, himself, listed the litany of conduct that would justify the sanction.

  7. Prediction: dems take the House. The dems take the Senate or it splits 50/50. In the latter, Vance will cast the tie vote after impeachment. Prediction: dems take the Senate.

    Enjoy the lovely autumn one and all. Each day is precious imo.

    1. Civics lesson for the day. There is no such thing as a tie vote after impeachment that the Veep can break. Conviction by the Senate after impeachment by the House requires a 2/3 vote.

      1. Really. 2/3 by Sentate. Then DJT will not be impeached. My error. I had this scenario of war crimes trial etc.

        My delusion. Thanks

        1. He might be impeached since that only requires a simple majority vote in the House. But he won’t be removed from office (convicted) by the Senate.

        1. Its all racism isnt it. El(ick) Said Jewish lives aren’t worth the price of bananas was some of the lowest.

          Liberty to speak?

    2. Impeachment requires a 2/3 vote in the Senate to remove – that is 67 senators – that is just not happening.

  8. Attaining power unethically is but a means to the end of having and exercising power that will inevitably become arbitrary. What has become of the Democratic Party suggests strongly it is one that will gladly exercise absolute power at worst or misuse their discretionary powers at best. In either event the Constitution is rendered inactive and the Republic nonexistent.

  9. “Although I publicly disagreed with Eastman’s theories, I opposed the effort to disbar him as setting a dangerous precedent for lawyers seeking to advance novel or unpopular theories of recovery or liability.”

    Eastman was not disbarred because of his “novel” legal theories or because they were unpopular. He was disbarred because he was presenting false claims in court. The State Bar Court found that Eastman repeatedly made false, misleading, and factually unsupported claims about widespread voter fraud in public statements and court filings without conducting any meaningful investigation or verification.

    1. 3x former Trump voter, I just voted straight Dem, and I still abhor the California bar’s attack on Eastman’s license. Also the states that dinged Giuliani. Lawyers are not investigators, they can be but we are not requiored to be, we are entitled to take plaintiff claims as just that- unverified claims

      1. Every “3x Trump voter” in the comments is a lifelong Dem who has never voted for Trump. Don’t be fooled by the liars.

        1. Ex-f*cking-actly. Transparent liars with delusions of credibility. Or merely a juvenile and idiotic compulsion to see their comment on-line…

    2. “false, misleading, and factually unsupported claims” are the bread and butter of Republican leadership.

      1. Then you would be able to demonstrate that.

        BTW False and misleading claims are the norm in politics.

        El Sayed in MI is claiming that Jews are responsible for high prices.

        Way to channel Hitler.

          1. X Please – ignoring the Add made by relatives, Chenk Ugur and Hassan Piker which says exactly that and which Sayed refused to distance himself from – as Haley stevens said the deciding factor in endorsing Rogers over Sayed was that Sayed himself throughout his campaign had said much the same things.

            I am not a huge Rogers fan – he is a NeoCon and I have problems with that. Though I am NOT an isolationist.

            I think what Stevens has done is a profile in courage. She has no political future. The is permanently PNG in the Democratic party,

            and while Trump and Johnson invited her to join the GOP – she is just not a republican – she is not even as close to Republican as Fetterman.

            She is not going to join the GOP and that means her political career is over.

            But she did the right thing. Rogers is the lessor evil.

            Further we do not have some black and white choice between islamophobia and antisemetism.

            In the pantheon of religions Islam is the most dangerous on its face. But all muslims – not even most muslims are violent terrorists.

            Though the evidence is that most muslims are antisemetic.

            Regardless it is not islamophobia to note that you apply conditions to Israel’s right to exist that you do not regarding Palestinians.

            That you are incapable of grasping that AT WORST Israel will over rspond to terror attacks, while Iran will foster Terror attacks and would nuke anyone who gets in their way if they could.

            Israel with near certainty has nukes though they do not admit it. They have likely had nukes most of my lifetime.

            They almost certainly have fusion bombs. They have never used on, never threatened to they do not even talk about their nuclear capability.

            In fact they never threaten ANYTHING with respect to other countries beyond RETALIATING if attacked.

            There is no moral parity – not in the mideast – not in the US.

            There are about 3-4 times as many muslims in the US as jews. There may be more muslims in the US that jews in the world.

            Yet in the US 60% of all hate crimes target Jews. Not muslims, not gays,. not trans – Jews.

            Throughout history EVERYWHERE in the world – jews have been exterminated at the drop of a hat.

            The Holocaust is merely the worst of many genocides against the jews.

            There are almost no jews in Europe today.

            There are almost no jews in the UK today.

            90% of the jews in the world live in two place – Israel and the US. Those are the only places in the world Jews are safe.

            And they are not really safe in either Israel or the US.

            No there is no parity between islamophobia and antisemitism.

    3. X

      ROFL

      this is all nonsense.

      Eastman has won all challenges against him – except that in CA – where it is still being appealed and he is likely to win.

      It was docketed with the Supreme court just a month ago.

      ACLJ is representing Eastman and they have an excellent Supreme court track record

      Left wing nuts disbarred or threatend to disbarr myriads of lawyers in their efforts to disrupt investigations into 2020 election fraud.

      They have lost pretty much every single one of those that has been challenged.

      All you are doing is defending more idiotic left wing nut lawfare.

      Outside of CA the courts have affirmed that “eastmans theories” – are actual US constitutional law.

      The process that he outlined for challenging an election in congress is EXACTLY how you challenge an election in Congress.

      Every aspect of it has actualy occured at one time or another before.

      The “fake electors” are not “fake” they are alternate and and them MUST exist to challenge an election in congress because Congress has three choices:

      Count the state certified electors,

      Count the alternate electors,

      or do not count the state at all.

      The latter disenfranchises millions of voters.

      You are literally shilling for Marc Elias and Democrat idiot law-fare that has harmed this nation for the past 2 decades.

      You are also echoing the idiocy from Sen Sloctkin – that it is irrelevant whether people are guilty of anything – they should be made to suffer so no one will take those jobs again.

      That is totally completely vile.

      Should DOJ go after the attorneys who represent terrorists – so that no terrorists get decent attorney’s ?

      Trump has myriads of enemies – people who plotted against him. The people DOJ has gone after committed crimes. They were not merely enemies.

      No one Targeted Marc Elias – but he is about to be a target in criminal investigations because HE chose to engage in ACTUAL election fraud.

      BTW Eastman is 10 times the lawyer Elias is.

      And 1000 times more honest.

      1. John Say,

        No American court has ever validated Eastman’s 2020 election theories.

        Mainstream conservative and progressive legal scholars, federal judges, and the U.S. Supreme Court have roundly rejected his theories. In the landmark 2023 case Moore v. Harper, the Supreme Court decisively rejected the “Independent State Legislature” theory that underpins the idea that state legislatures can unilaterally override election results. Judges overseeing 2020 election challenges repeatedly dismissed cases brought under these premises for a complete lack of evidence.

        The unilateral process Eastman outlined was unprecedented and openly illegal.Eastman’s internal memos proposed that Vice President Mike Pence could unilaterally reject certified electoral votes or stall the joint session. That’s why he didn’t “win” any challenges.

        In 2020, the executive branch of every single contested state certified only one slate of electors: Joe Biden’s. Eastman himself admitted in front of Donald Trump on January 4, 2021, that his proposed path explicitly violated the federal Electoral Count Act of 1887.

        The self-appointed pro-Trump individuals were legally fraudulent, not legitimate alternate electors. For an alternate slate to have legal standing, they must be transmitted or recognized by an official state governing body while a recount or litigation is actively unresolved.

        In 2020, these individuals met in secret, signed certificates falsely claiming they were the “duly elected and qualified” electors, and sent them to the National Archives. Because they lacked any official state certification or court orders authorizing their status.

        Marc Elias has faced numerous civil legal battles and sanctions motions from political opponents over the last two decades, but he has never been indicted or made the target of a federal criminal investigation regarding the 2020 election. Conflating aggressive partisan litigation with actual, documented criminal election subversion—for which Eastman and others face real felony charges—is a false equivalence.

        As usual John Say is wrong.

        1. “No American court has ever validated Eastman’s 2020 election theories.“

          First ISL is not Eastmans theory and has next to nothing to do with the issues regarding 2020.

          To the extent the extremely wide version of ISL was rejected by the courts – that occured in 2023 and was decided 5-1-3

          A bare majority. It is the law of the land, it is NOT what you claim. It is NOT relevant to Eastman,

          And you can not legitimately be disbarred even today for arguing for ISL

          Just as Left wing Lunatics can not be disbarred because they are constantly losing cases – often 9-0 with SCOTUS

          Regardless “Estmans Theories” are entirely about what the powers of CONGRESS – not the states are with respect to contested elections.

          What you call “eastmans’s theories” are just they actual way a en election contest in Congress proceeds.

          In every single election in my lifetime – Democratic represenatives have risen to challenge counting the vote of states that republicans have won.

          That is how the process works. You can find the Eastman Memo – it is really nothing more than his restatement of the SAME memo that Prof. Lawrence Tribe provided to Hillary Clinton in 2016 as an option to challenge the 2016 election in Congress.

          Over US history we have RARELY seen election contests decided by Congress – but it has happened before.

          Jefferson’s election took something like 74 voted by congress. After which we made slight changes to the constitution.

          The 1876 Hayes/Tilden is pretty much EXACTLY what Eastman and Trump hoped for.

          In 1960 VP Nixon gave the HI Vote to JFK – rejecting the prior state certified electors and acceptng the vote of the Alternate electors.

          The left has NEVER won a single case regarding alternate electors – because that is litterally the constitutionally accepted way to challenge an election in congress. That is NOT ISL and it was not rejected in Moore.

          I am not going to debate your completely botched understanding of Moore or you idiotic application of it to cases and issues that it does not apply to and which SCOTUS had repeatedly ruled AGAINST YOU

          As absolutely none of this is relevant to Eastman, or to IS you are as you always do reading things MASSIVELY into decisions that have nothing to do with those decisions.

          “Mainstream conservative and progressive legal scholars, federal judges, and the U.S. Supreme Court have roundly rejected his theories.”

          First – no one cared what progressives who make up the constitution as they go claim.

          Nor is this argument relevant – SCOTUS has been rejecting lunatic left theories over and over – we are not disbarring the attornies who advocated for them or in many cases STILL advocate for them. We are not impeaching and removing Judges who continue to ignore supreme court preceident.

          The FACT is that what you have attacked regarding Eastman is EXACTLY what Congress did in 1876 – it is not a theory it is a historical fact and it is established US law and constitution.

          “The unilateral process Eastman outlined was unprecedented and openly illegal.“

          Your off in lala land – All the left lawfare regarding Eastman is specific to the process by which CONGRESS decides Federal elections – that has absolutely NOTHING to do with Moore vs. Harper or ISL.

          “Eastman’s internal memos proposed that Vice President Mike Pence could unilaterally reject certified electoral votes or stall the joint session. That’s why he didn’t “win” any challenges.”

          False. Eastman’s argument is that the VP could do as Nixon did in 1961 and place the votes of alternate electors before Congress.

          Constitutionally the VP is the Chair in what is a joint session of Congress – he controls the PROCESS of the secesion.

          But unlike when he presides over the Senate he does not have a vote. The VP has ZERO power to decide whether congress accepts the votes of one state panel of electors or another – only the order in which he presents them. There are a number of matters he gets to rule on – but his decisionss on those matters are fixed. A challenge to a slate of electors if I recall correctly requires One representative and one senator to put it forward – there may be some other requirements. Absent meeting those requirements the challenge is rejected – and congress does not even vote on the objection. It is the VP that decides that – but he decides it based on rules that he must follow.

          Further ANY actions the VP takes can be objected to by the members of congress and the VP can be overrule.

          While I have noted the rules congress follows – that the VP must follow – that Eastman was proposing to follow,

          what is ALSO True is that no matter what “the rules” are – Congress can ultimately do whatever it wants. Congress is the final certification of elections. They are not obligated to accept anything from any state. Congress has passed election laws that establish the process that Congress must follow – which is what Eastman was following in his memo, but even those laws are completely non-binding.

          The constitution says that the houses of congress get to make their own rules. Except by constitutional amendment no congress can create a rule or law that is binding on another congress. Congress changes the rules or laws that govern its operations all the time – these are rarely major changes. The Fillibuster is ONE example. The rule that allows the minority party to choose its own committeee assignments is another.

          The POINT is that you can not bid congress with respect to the rules it must follow in anything it has the power to do, without amending the constitution.

          Eastman was advocating following rules that are rarely needed.

          “The self-appointed pro-Trump individuals were legally fraudulent, not legitimate alternate electors.“

          Not a single state or court has actually ruled that – Every single challnge to the alternate electors has ultimately been dismissed.

          They are NOT fraudulent – they are REQUIRED by federal law and indirectly by the constitution to comply with the process of challenging an election.

          And only a moron would not understand why.

          You beleive there was no fraud in 2020 – Fine.

          But lets presume we have an election – and there is OBVIOUS fraud, for the sake of argument lets assume that Fraud is alleged but not proven until after all state and court remedies are exhasted.

          So here we are Jan. 6, 20XX Congress is presented with an election that almost no one has any doubt was fraudulent.

          Or we do not even need fraud. LEts presume that some Honest error flipped the election.

          Lets look at the 2000 election. LEts assume that AFTER SCOTUS ruled that FL had to move forward with certification – 1000 legitimate Gore Ballots were found to have somehow be honestly missed.

          By YOUR idiotic nonsense – there is NOTHING congress can do. No matter how great the fraud or how egregious the error – Come Jan. 6th even if the entire country agrees that the person about to be certified is not the correct winner – YOUR argument is congresses role is PURELY ceremonial and they can do nothing.

          Obviously that is FALSE – Fraud was alleged in 1876 and Congress reversed the outcome of the election – unlike my scenarious above the fraud was not even obvious – or more acurately there was significant fraud on both sides and it was not aparent who legitimately won the contested states. Congress appointed a commission, a backroom deal was struck, and Hayes was named president and Union soldiers were withdrawn from the former confederacy.

          In 1876 Congress essentially did as it pleased – because its role is OBVIOUSLY not cerimonial – there are NO provisions of the constitution that are merely cerimonial.

          Absolutely no rational person thinks that Congress does not have the power to refuse to certify an erroneous or fraudulent election.

          And Democrats have tried to do so in every election that republicans have won in my lifetime.

          The only difference is that the objections of past democratic congressmen to the certification of Republican presidential candidates did not stand a snowballs chance of succeeding – though No on has criminally prosecuted or attempted to disbarr those who objected to certification.

          What was different about 2020 – was that there was a very small possibility that Objections to the 2020 election would prevail.

          That said regardless of whether you like such challenges – they are perfectly legal.

          And only a moron would think that Congress must throw up their hands and certify a fraudulent or erroneous election result.

          This is NOT ISL – it has NOTHING to do with ISL – it is merely the OBVIOUS fact that Congress has the final decision on Federal elections – per the US constitution.

          You can rant and rave about what re essentiallly irrelevant procedural objections – While Eastman was actually following accepted procedure – that is irrelevant – Congress is still free to do whatever it damn well pleases regarding certifying an election.

          And there is no other rational choice about how to deal with that.

        2. “Marc Elias has faced numerous civil legal battles and sanctions motions from political opponents over the last two decades,”

          Correct and he has won some cases and lost some cases. Unlike Eastman – no one has attempted to disbarr him because a court later rejected his arguments.

          “but he has never been indicted”

          I beleive that is correct.

          “or made the target of a federal criminal investigation regarding the 2020 election”

          Probably true – we do not KNOW who the target of ciminal investigations is – DOJ is barred from confirming targets until they indict – that is required by the 4th and 5th amendments and is relevant to why the Epstain docs never should have been released.

          We do not subordinate the outcome we want to the constitution, or to individuals rights.

          .”Conflating aggressive partisan litigation with actual, documented criminal election subversion—for which Eastman and others face real felony charges—is a false equivalence”

          What a mess – yes – people can not be prosecuted for agressive partisan litigation – or disbarred – and yet YOU DID EXACTLY THAT.

          The fact that people were charged is merely proof of YOUR malfeasance.

          I do not know if Elias will be charge in Alaska, That depends on what he actually did. What he knew, when he knew it and what he told courts.

          And whether he transitioned from “agressive partisan advocacy” to violating the law.

          With near certainty he did regarding the Steele Dossier,
          But he has in the past been protected by DC courts.

          To be clear – so long as he confines himself as Eastmen did to legal and constitutional advice or advocacy – he SHOULD be protected – no matter how absurd his claims are.

          There are numerous people here who want to charge left wing nut judges with Treason for willfully bogus decisions.

          While there does need to be consequences for a pattern of unquestionably unconstitutional acts by left wing judges – they do not constitute Treason. If SCOTUS fails to act eventually Congress is obligated to. But the correct answer is for SCOTUS to disipline those judges.

          To bad them from some types of cases or whatever other powers the Chief justice has to reign in lunatic judges.

          But we should not be threatening them with treason or criminal prosecution or even impeachment except as a very last resort.

          Turley is railing against Elias – Elias is not 1/100th the constitutional scholar that Eastman is – but he is absolutely a DC power broker.

          Much of what he does is NOT law or only vaguely related to law. And no one in their right mind should put much weight on Eliases legal views.

          But that does not mean we disbarr him.

          That said – his conduct as a power broker while bound to the ethics of a lawyer does open some possibility of disbarrment.

          Though still should have nothing to do with partisanship and everything to do with established unethical acts.

          Nor should he be criminally prosecuted just because he legal advice is garbage.

          I strongly suspect he is or will be a “target” in Alaska and whether that translates into indictment and prosecution depends on what actions he took that are criminal that can be proven.

          Lawyers are supposed to gt the benefit of the doubt there – but those of you on the left seek to criminalize any disagreement with your ideology.

  10. Dear Mr. Turley, Mr. Elias is the “scummiest” of all scum bags. He was involved with Mrs. Clinton and the phony Russia scandal, and his fingerprints are all over this one too. His ego is so terribly huge, that he is of the belief that he is able to control all of our election processes. I am thankful this was found out before election day.

  11. “A New York Times blockbuster investigative report…” NYT accidently – make that begrudgingly – doing real journalism months after a story breaks in May is now considered “blockbuster”? Who knew?

  12. Democrats have an alibi. They were driven crazy by mosquitos.

    Alaska has about 35 mosquito species, and peak mosquito season typically runs from late May through July, with the worst swarms occurring in the Interior, tundra regions, and areas north of the Yukon River.

  13. So, Professor, what’s the takeaway? That lawyers are scum? That lawyers lie and cheat and manipulate, using the law as a weapon and never risking accountability? Tell us! Look at the litany of egregious things that this man has done! Yet he is still actively subverting our system, our laws and the very principles that underpin everything we hold dear. Where is the ABA? Where are the judges? Where is the honor of the profession. I’m beginning to think that Shakespeare may have been right.

    1. The famous quote “The first thing we do, let’s kill all the lawyers” comes from William Shakespeare’s play Henry VI, Part 2 (Act IV, Scene II).
      -Who said it: It is spoken by Dick the Butcher, a follower of the rebel leader Jack Cade.
      -The context: Cade and his men are plotting a violent overthrow of the government and social order.
      -What it means: The line is uttered by a villainous rebel who realizes that to establish tyranny and break the rule of law, they must first get rid of the people who uphold and defend the law

  14. Unless and until some miracle occurs that drastically enhances the cognitive abilities of US voters, this kind of nefarious deception will only continue. In fact, it will almost certainly worsen, as each side escalates these kinds of practices in response to resulting wins by their opponents. The only solution requires massive reform of the public education system (or its dissolution) and a subsequent multi-decade wait for the resulting unpropagandized students to reach the age of majority. That almost certainly ain’t gonna happen. If you are a boomer like me, we, and our parents before us, and even our grandparents, are/were guilty of blindly ignoring what was openly going on in public education for a very long period of time, while we were pursuing our own successes. To some extent, I’m convinced that phenomenon was deliberately engineered by hidden interests opposed to our Liberty and general prosperity, but, no matter: we did clearly have opportunities to forestall the current situation, and we blew it. There may be a dim and distant light at the end of this particular tunnel, but if so, there is a huge, dangerous swamp replete with ferocious denizens that will need to be navigated before there is any chance of reaching it.

      1. “what kinda moron votes for the wrong sullivan,”

        The kind that stumbles into a voting booth bleary-eyed either just before or after work, and quickly flicks tabs for candidates whose names he or she believes are recognizable, after having done no better research than watching a few minutes of CNN or MSNBC, before pulling the lever and rushing off? Or even better, the kind who fills out his or her ballot at home while being besieged by kids, and distracted by loud TV and video games, after the same abysmally inadequate “research”? Would you like to make a wager on what fraction of voters I have aptly described?

      2. Was Double Dan , decoy listed before Real Dan on the primary ballot? That’s your idiot 1%. It matters and some states arrange the order by names in hat schema.

    1. Tens of millions of ignorant people voted for the guy who claimed:

      -He would end the war in Ukraine in a single day

      -Never enter a new war

      -Lower fuel prices

      -Lower grocery prices

      -Focus on removing the violent murdering and rapist undocumented immigrants (and not Uber drivers)

      Anyone with a functioning neuron would have realized he was lying with all of those and many other claims.

      Mind that the demand for a better education system is being actively thwarted, in part, by a Dept. of Education head who usually manages over-muscled entertainers smashing each other with metal folding chairs.

  15. Worthy of old soap opera coverage on As the World Turns, we have this lone story from The Alaska Story about Peltola’s former campaign manager Elisa Rios attempting to recant her story printed in the NYT and why she might have wanted to: https://thealaskastory.com/hush-money-why-did-peltolas-former-campaign-manager-try-to-retract-her-new-york-time-story/

    (I looked up the credentials for The Alaska Story; it appears to be a worthy and reputable publication.)

    How this is related to today’s post: it appears the circle of usual suspects is widening, or at least is becoming more convoluted…..

    1. Couldn’t this be about withholding severance payments because she violated a nondisparagement provision in the severance agreement?

      1. Of course, Daniel, that is pretty standard fare. I take note of Alaska Public Media’s interview with NYT’s Kellen Browning, with a vague reference to the silence surrounding the Rios departure: https://alaskapublic.org/news/politics/elections/2026-10-29/how-the-new-york-times-broke-the-story-on-secret-candidate-recruiting-in-alaskas-senate-race

        About two-thirds down, see paragraph starting with “I did want to ask you, you mentioned Elisa Rios,…”

        1. Lin,

          It is rather interesting how Elisa Rios changed her mind and wanted to retract all the information, evidence, her statements. I have to wonder if that is when Elias got involved?

          Also, be interesting to see if investigations find money transfers to both Rios and the decoy Dan.

          Be funny if the Peltola campaign listed them as “legal fees.”

      2. It mentions right in the publication linked: “The Alaska Story previously received information alleging that Rios faced a threatened action from Peltola’s campaign to withhold her final compensation if she didn’t keep quiet.”

  16. Turley still in this? This is no “scandal”. It’s a distraction at best. What is relevant is the vote is tomorrow and this will very likely be moot the day after tomorrow or by the end of the week.

    This is nothing but the same tactic Republicans used in 2024. Trump’s DOJ will not go beyond ‘investigating’ things they can’t prove. Voter fraud? LOL! Nope. Ironically real voter fraud was committed by Republican Sean O’Keefe, of former project veritas fame. He got caught committing felony voter fraud. Sullivan applied for candidacy legally and the Alaska Supreme Court agreed he did nothing wrong.

    Heck, looks like Texas Ken Paxton is not going to win based on his poor performance and even poorer views among his own party. I suspect Republicans will lose the Senate and perhaps the House as well. I mean really, what did the Republicans run on besides scare mongering about socialism and communism?

    1. NO C

      This is not moot.

      Numerous legal analysts -= including Turley and Derschowitz have pointed out this is a Crime.

      NYT provided sufficient evidence to prove a crime and a criminal conspiracy to commit that crime involving people from Petola through the DSCC and Minority leader Schumer.

      Absent later finding that the NYT evidence is itself fraudulent – AI generated or in some other way false, Many people are at serious risk of criminal prosecution and conviction.

      Daniel J. Sulivan who has been in hiding for weeks appears to have disappeared – he is in hiding and may have fled the country.

      That is what Criminals do.

      Additional evidence will with near certainty and additional conspirators be unearthed by the evidence gathered by subpeonas that have been issued and the ongoing investigations.

      No this is not “the same tactic” – please cite any instance ever where this has been done before.

      This is NOT an effort to crowd the ballot to give voters alternate choices. This is a deliberate effort to deceive voters – that is called FRAUD.

      The evidence so far is that this ORIGINATED with the Peltola Campaign.

      Daniel J. Sulivan did not decide to run and then solicit assistance from Peltola – Peltola directed her campaign to go out and look for other Sulivans to put on the ballot and Found a Willing Daniel J. Sulivan.

      You keep aluding to other elections – Likely Hafner – you do not seem to be willing to actually those anymore.

      Because they ARE DIFFERENT.

      The Alaska Supreme court ruled in favor of Daniel J. Sullivan earlier – BECAUSE he and his lawyers told the court he was a legitimate candidate, that he had been thinking about running for Senate for over a decade and that no one solicited him.

      He LIED.

      In addition to the Obvious election fraud – there are also multiple violations of campaign finance law. We have evidence of communications between the DSCC, a Democrat SuperPAC, The Elias Group, Daniel J. Sullivan and the Peltola Campaign.

      By law Superpacs can not coordinate with candidates or campaigns.

      If Peltola actually manages to win on Tuesday – there will likely be essentially a constitutional crisis that likely will take months and end up before the supreme court.

      I do not beleive it is likely that she wins. I do not beleive it was likely before. But the Polls could actually be right for once.

      Even if she loses – this was a crime and there is an investigation and there will be subpeonas warrants. likely prosecutions lots of people taking the fifth, Plea Deals …. There are many many people involved in this – the very fact that NYT was able to get this story means that SOME of them are willing to speak and grasped this was a crime.

      No OKeefe was not caught committing voter fraud – that is a radically different case and the Minnesota AG is way over her skis.

      Okeefes people were given detailed vetted legal instructions and that process was Videoed – because OKeefe KNOWS that idiot democrats will come after him for exposing their fraud. They were very careful NOT to commit Fraud – They were engaged in undercover investigative reporting.

      They did NOT vote. They did NOT touch a ballot. They did NOT sign anything, and they did NOT use a false identity.

      The MN AG will lose this case badly – what is unfortunate is that she will not be sanctioned for filing it.

      OKeefe has been the victim of this kind of lawfare before and has won all attempts by Left wing nuts to prosecute him for exposing THEIR Fraud.

      Fox which oddly is one of the more left leaning polls has TX tied right now.

      Republicans are not running on scaremongering about communism and socialism – Myriads of Democrats are litterally running as communists and socialists. The Democratic party is nuts.

      SOME of those candidates are backtracking – or more accurately refusing to talk about their own remarks – even remarks made during the current campaign that embraced socialism or communism or antisemitism.

      Republicans have done a bad job of messaging in this cycle – Contra the left – they have a strong economy, growing jobs, tax breaks for the working class, and a long list of accomplishments that they have done a poor job of selling.

      They have some problems because – some things are not fully accomplished yet – Iran has not yet capitulated. There is not yet a peace deal in Ukraine. Hezbolah is not yet exterminated, Canada has not yet agreed to a trade deal. Gas Prices – though NOT outside historic norms – lower than under Biden and in real dollars lower than the entire Obama administration are still high because of the Iran conflict – but that will end – likely soon.

      Inflation is far lower than under Biden – but still too high. But REAL Growth though below projections is good and rising. It is more than double the average growth under Obama and infinitely greater that the zero growth under Biden.

      Regardless have Republicans done a poor job of selling their accomplishments – absolutely.

      But Democrats have done even worse. ICE and Deportations are a supermajority republican issue, But in deep blue cities with a small minority of voters in a low turnout election they are an advantage for Democrats – though they have to be very careful not to wake the sleeping giant.

      Idiotic and false Trump nonsense also plays well on the far left – and if Democrats can get the far left to show up in a low turnout election – the can win.

      You rant that Republicans have been shilling a socialist and communist boogey man – But nuerous high profile Democrats have Run on EXACTLY that.

      You want to “have your cake and eat it too” – You can not concurrently get away with claiming to be a socialist and denying you are a socialist.

      You can not claim to be a communist and deny you are a communist.

      No All democrats are not card carrying communists and socialists. Many are not even “social democrats”.

      But many are openly communist, openly socialist, openly “social democrat”. As well as openly racist, openly antisemetic.

      Many Democratic candidates are repugnant to other Democrats.

      Haley Stevens did her best to toe the party line to support the democrat party even though El Sayed was running a vile and nasty antisemetic campaign.

      I would further note that many of the Republican attacks – are just circuitous efforts to expose the REAL Democrat they are running against.

      Wl Sayed is NOT Hassan Piker – but he has embraced Hassan Piker.

      I do not care that El Sayed is egyption – I do not care that his family has strong past ties to the Muslim Brotherhood – which is ACTUALLY Fascist, The Muslim brotherhood recruited the most brutal members of the Waffen SS. What people care about – What Haley Stevens cares about is that El Sayed can not even call scapegoating Jews Wrong

      It is a small thing – but El Sayed did a recent interview where he avoided actual issues entirely and talked about Basketball and how Pete Hegseth was just a mediocre white boy white boy whose parents told him that he was exceptional While El Sayed – who reportedly loves basketball and is possibly good at it, did not have parents who came to his games and told him he was great. El Sayed showed video of himself wiffing free throws repeatedly – all fine, I can’t hit a free throw either, and I loved playing basketball. But I have not claimed to be good at it, only to enjoy it.

      Hegseth responded by posting video of hitting 9 of Ten shots from outside the 3pt circle, and his parents posted his awards for All State Champion in basketball.

      The above is NOT about basketball. It is about STUPID lying and getting caught. El Sayed made stupid assumptions about Hegseth – as he does about everyone and everything – as those of you on the left do about everyone and everything.

      Assumptions he EASILY could have checked before hand. El Sayed talking about his own interest in basketball is fine and an attempt to humanize him. But he stupidly compared himself to someone he did not know and made idiotically false assumptions that proved to be terribly wrong.

      Further he turned talking about his love of basketball into whining about others.

      No one in their right mind wants as Senator someone who stupidly fires from the hip and is Wrong. No one wants as senator someone who is still whining about his childhood. While trying to paint himself otherwise – El Sayed grew up wealthy and privileged. He is trying to run as a poor disadvantaged black guy.

      1. John Say,

        “This is not moot.

        Numerous legal analysts -= including Turley and Derschowitz have pointed out this is a Crime.”

        And what crime is that?

        Funny you don’t mention it.

        ”This is NOT an effort to crowd the ballot to give voters alternate choices. This is a deliberate effort to deceive voters – that is called FRAUD.”

        So thought you said fraud as only about property. Deceiving voters is not fraud. It’s typical dirty campaign tricks that have been legal for some time. Republicans did this back in 2024 with Hafner. Despite your measly protestations they did the same thing Democrats are doing now. The ONLY difference is Hafner was in jail in NY at the time he filed already a criminal for extortion and threatening elected officials, police, etc. quite a list.

        The Alaska Supreme Court already ruled Sullivan did nothing wrong and his candidacy is legitimate.

        “In addition to the Obvious election fraud – there are also multiple violations of campaign finance law. We have evidence of communications between the DSCC, a Democrat SuperPAC, The Elias Group, Daniel J. Sullivan and the Peltola Campaign.

        By law Superpacs can not coordinate with candidates or campaigns.”

        LOL! Nope.

        The DSCC is NOT a superpac. The DSCC (Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee) is not a super PAC. It is an official national political party committee.

        The Supreme Court’s landmark ruling on June 30, 2026 (National Republican Senatorial Committee v. FEC), official political party committees like the DSCC are now explicitly allowed to coordinate unlimited spending directly with candidates. Communicating or coordinating strategy between the DSCC and a campaign is entirely legal under the First Amendment. How did you miss that?

        1. “And what crime is that?”

          I menttttioned several – there are state and federal election crimes.

          Election fraud, conspiracy to commit election fraud Violations of campagn finances laws and coordination between campaigns candidates and superPACs

          Some of the easily provable allegations are civil rather than criminal – such as the campaign finance violations – but those can rise to crimes when they are part of a larger conspiracy.

          Various Crim in Falsi violations (perjury)

          If you have ever had anything to do with a court proceeding you know that filings have to be sworn and separately verified by the lawyers.

          You cited the Alaska Law – please actually read it – Decoy Dan with near certainty provided false information to The State when he registered as a candadate and to the court when he appealed the States efforts to remove him.

          YOUI cite the Alaska Supreme court decision which SPECIFICALLY notes that they decided in Favor of Decoy Dan because he swore to them he was a legitimate candatate and the state did not provide evidence to disprove that.

          They NOW how that evidence. Further they have the evidence to PROVE that Decoy Dan’s statements to the court were knowingly false at the time he made them – again “crim in Falsi”

          For your edification “crim-in-falsi” is shorthand for a long long list of Crimes of Falsification – usually lying under oath or on sworn statements.

          In Most state Perjury is ONE of those – But Perjury is usually specific to oral testimony under oath – False statements on Sworn forms are not perjury, but they re crimes much like perjury.

          Under SOME circumstnces unsworn lies can also be crime – kiting a check is a crime forgery is a crime.

          Decoy Dan attempted to register as Dan S. Sulivan – that is identity theft – his name is Daniel J Sulivan Jr.

          If he was advised to register falsely – those people are guilty of conspiracy.

          You want a single crime – but there are MYRIADS of them.

          There are federal and State crimes. Pretty much everything federal election related is both a federal and state crime.

          “So thought you said fraud as only about property. “

          Correct – when you are prosecuting using normal fraud statutes – as the left was trying to do with respect to Trump.

          We call putting false ballots into ballot boxes Election fraud.

          That is not a property crime.

          “Deceiving voters is not fraud. “

          Correct. But using deception to actually infringe on their rights is a crime.

          Forging another persons name – on a check, on a mailin ballot on a voter registration – those are all crimes,

          We generally call them Fraud – often election fraud – I used Crim-in-falsi above – specifically because all lies that are crimes are not the same.

          NY tried to use a standard fraud statute – a PROPERTY crime statute – falsification of business records, that results in other people being deprived of their property is standard fraud – it falls under the statute that Trump was prosecuted under.

          Forgery, Election fraud and other crimes in falsification do not.

          “It’s typical dirty campaign tricks that have been legal for some time.”

          False generalization – can we cut the crappy fallacies.

          Many political dirty tricks are legal.

          All are not.

          “Republicans did this back in 2024 with Hafner.”

          No they did not the Hafner’s were real candidates who had run for election many times before – and and did so again in 2024.

          They ran under their own name in elections where no other candidate had their name.

          They were free to receive political donations from whoever they pleased.

          Further YOU use the language – “Republicans did the same thing ” – No republicans did not do the same thing.

          Not only was it not the same thing it was SPECIFIC people – both in this instance and in the Hafner case.

          In this instance – the Petola campaign went looking for a potential candidate with the same name to confuse voters.

          In the Hafner case – Hafner got on the ballot and some random republicans donated to his campaign.

          If that was the case here – Petola would not be in trouble.

          While all of us here speak broadly of the misdeeds of democrats or republicans – and that matters when we are talking about things such as the broad morally bankrupt efforts of those like you to try to excuse this criminal conduct, Crimes are committed by specific individuals – not entire ideologies. And exactly who did exactly what matters.

          If Decoy Dan solicited donations from “Democrats” and received them – that would not be a crime.

          There is a crime here – because it it the Peltola Campaign that initiated this and because THEY coordinated with THEIR super PAC to solicit Decoy Dan to run and to funnel money to him. Elias and the DSCC face criminal liability because they were aware of and facilitated illegal acts.

          If the DSCC had itself funnelled money to Decoy Dan with no coordination with the Peltola campaign or her super PAC they would not be part of the conspiracy nor facing possible criminal prosecution.

          “The Alaska Supreme Court already ruled Sullivan did nothing wrong and his candidacy is legitimate.”

          No they rules that Alaska had not met the burden of proof to prove he was not a legitimate candidate.

          Please read the ruling – you do this all the time – You make idiotic claims about court decisions based on Your understanding of the outcome never having read them – or you read them get mired in dicta and fail to grasp that the actual ruling is at odds with your claims.

          “The DSCC is NOT a superpac.”

          Correct – nor is the DSCC the source of the money to do Decoy Dan’s campaign. As usual you are confused about who did what.

          The DSCC’s problem is that they are a co-conspirator.

          With respect to NRSC vs FEC – absolutely correct – political party committees can coordinate with Campaigns.

          Of course that does NOT mean they can coordinate to commit a crime.

          Again you are massively overly broadly interpretting a court decision.

          If the NRSC “coordinated” with a candidate to murder someone – they would be guilty of conspiracy to commit murder.

          Do you actually think about what you write before you write it ?

          The DSCC’s criminal liability is limited to their knowlege and participation in a criminal conspiracy – if there is no predicate crime – they are off the hook. They are perfectly free to coordinate with the Peltola campaign over legal activities to their hearts content.

          Regardless I did not miss anything – the DSCC did not fund Decoy Dan. A Peltola affiliated superPAC did.

          If they coordinated with the Peltola campaign which is alleged and evidenced by the NYT article – that is illegal. If the DSCC was part of that coordination – they too are part of that illegal coordination. If there is a crime involved – then this is a conspiracy involving all of them – atleast to the extent they are aware of an contributed in the smallest way towards that crime.

        2. This is a legal blog. Posters here are presumed not to be toddlers.

          Your comment wastes time and space on arguments that are irrelevant and no one has made.

          Cooridianting with a SuperPAC is a federal election law violation – it is probably not a crime, though under some circumstances it could be.

          But it is illegal. The DSCC is NOT a superPAC nor is Marc Elias. But read the NYT article a SuperPAC was involved, did coordinate with the Peltola campaign and the Elias Group and DSCC were part of that, and the SuperPAC was the source of the money involved and I beleive was directly soliciting Decoy Dan to run.

          Illegal activity, combined with a conspiracy to perform that activity is a CRIME.

          You play these stupid word games all the time.

          If this was solely a superPAC acting on its own it likely would just be a political dirty trick or if a crime a small one that did not implicate the Peltola campaign.

          UNLESS they coordinate campaigns have no responsibility for the actions of SuperPACs

          But when you coordinate to commit an illegal act – you have a criminal conspiracy.

          To a SMALL extent you are correct – sorting out exactly WHO involved in this knew what when could be a massive task – though the NYT article evidence seems to indicate early and full coordination between all parties.

          Regardless those in the DSCC are not culpable for what they did not know.

          Marc Elias is not culpable for what he did not know.

          The evidence is this initiated with the Peltola campaign – and that is going to be a crime.

          There is no legitimate reason for a political campaign to work to put another candidate with the same name as a competitor on the ballot.

          As this is reported – the Peltola campaign did NOT solicit Decoy Dan directly – the SuperPAC did – that is coordination with the superPAC – which is illegal. You now have a crime, a violation of the law and a conspiracy to do both. Whether Elias and the DSCC are part of the conspiracy depends on their knowledge and actions.

        3. Trump was prosecuted in NYC – civilly under Ordinary Business Fraud statutes – Those require the use of deceipt to deprive someone of their property.

          This case is going to hinge first on other crimes in falsification – identity theft, forgery, perjury.

          We often CALL these Fraud, but they are Not Fraud laws.

          All deception is not a crime.

          All fraud is deception – but all fraud is not a crime.

          All deception is not fraud, and all deception is not a crime.

          But some deception is a crime but not fraud.

          People call almost anything that is deceptive fraud – whether it is fraud or not.

          Election fraud is not usually actual fraud – it is usually deception that violates specific rights of others.

          Elections do not typically involve property rights – but they do involve rights and deception to violate those rights under SOME circumstances is a crime.

          The very fact that you keep arguing that no one would be confused by this is DAMNING – it is very close to an admission that this was a BAD attempt to deceive people into wasting their vote.

          1. The old registration of decoy Dan lacjs transparency and imposes a knowledge a voter may not have. Dems have objected to voter ID and may think candidate ID irrelevant? It’s a crime.

      2. John Say,

        “You rant that Republicans have been shilling a socialist and communist boogey man – But nuerous high profile Democrats have Run on EXACTLY that.”

        LOL! Who? Bernie Sanders has always identified himself as a Democratic socialist. Who has claimed to be a communist? A couple? The number is so minuscule that it makes Republicans look like hyperventilating nincompoops. Come on. NYC’s mayor is the same type of Socialist as Bernie Sanders and he’s hugely successful. Which seems to be an annoying thing for those on the right.

        ”Republicans have done a bad job of messaging in this cycle – Contra the left – they have a strong economy, growing jobs, tax breaks for the working class, and a long list of accomplishments that they have done a poor job of selling.”

        Selling the message is not the problem. It’s the fact their policies have failed or have not produced the results they promised. If it’s such a strong economy why haven’t Republicans focused on it? Because it’s actually worse and people are NOT seeing the economic benefits Republicans are claiming. Those choosing to blame Biden can no longer use that excuse. Growing jobs? It’s growing so slowly, barely make it into Obama era levels. Inflation is still high and it hasn’t gotten down and won’t go down if Trump continues to wage war in Iran.

        “Haley Stevens did her best to toe the party line to support the democrat party even though El Sayed was running a vile and nasty antisemetic campaign.”

        Antisemitic? LOL! How? Being critical of Israel is not anti-Semitic. Haley Stevens made a serious mistake and she’s paying for it dearly. In fact her conduct may have made things a lot worse for Rogers.

        1. “Bernie Sanders has always identified himself as a Democratic socialist.”

          Correct – so calling him one is not scaremongering.

          “Who has claimed to be a communist? A couple?”

          So ? How many Nazi’ does a paty have to support before it is ok to call them out ?

          I would suggest you actually listen to Haley Stevens – she withdrew her endorsement of El Sayed and endorsed Mike Rogers not because his Brother put out an antisemitic add. or even because he refused to call it out,. but because she decided after thinking about his own campaign rhetoric that it was anti-semetic. Scapegoating a race is vile – whether they are jews or blacks or whites. Crimes are committed by people. Individuals are responsible for their individual actions.

          El Sayed has courted the DSA – both as voters and campaign workers and supports MFA and pretty Much Bernies entire Platform.

          El Sayed “says” that his is not “technically” a member of the DSA – but not only does he fully emprace Sanders – but also Hassan Piker who is a vile person and openly marxist.

          It is not fewar mongering to Call El Sayed a Socialist. Further as with MANY things regarding El Sayed he does not deny it.

          All candidates have to find the ways to hold onto voters that often have little in common.

          One of the reasons that the GOP and MAGA are dominant and likely to be for a very long time is they have embraced a long list of supremajority issues. Republicans no longer have to work so hard to placate the religious right – which is fairly socialist, Neo Cons and establishment republicans. Trump has created a new and growing GOP base with working class and minority voters that used to be the Democrats bread and Butter. Republicans have staked out a slightly right of center core that is much harder to alienate.

          For all the lefts rantings – there is no “far right” of consequence today.

          But democrats are trapped between their “far left” and their moderates and independents.

          The far left Biden presidency – which was actually unexpected and disasterous, has actually opened the door to Democrats in some cses to be openly socialist or even communist, and more commonly to do a Wink Wink Nod Nod thing and allow left wing voters to with near certainty correctly assume they will govern on the far left.

          Absolutely Republcans call them out as crypto or even open socialisst or communists.

          No candidate is obligated to explain who they are – But voters are NOT obligated to give you their vote if you do not.

          I do not think El Sayed has been a particularly good candidate he did very poorly in the primary. Barely eaking out a win when it was supposed to be a romp.

          I will be surprised if he does well in the general – but we will see.

          When I say he has not been a good candidate – he has been evasive, whinny, Ranting constantly about non-existant islamophia – while dancing on and often falling over the edge into antisemitism. He has alienate blacks and Jews and in the event he pulls this off will be deeply indebt to Clyburn and Obama and Harris for shoring up support of black voters.

          Candidates are often evasive – though Trump usually is not what is part of his appeal. You know what you are getting with Trump.

          Can you tell me what you are getting with El Sayed ? Petola ? Acton ? Talerico ? Jackson ?

          TDS is not a platform.

        2. No Mamdani is not “hugely successful”
          NYC is a mess, worse he is dragging down NYS democrats.

          There is zero chance Mamdani can run statewide much less nationally.

          And Hochuls governor Campaign has been significantly weakened by constantly bailing out Mamdani.

          But if you really want a picture of the future of “democratic Socialism” – look to Europe RIGHT NOW.

          2+ decades of pathetic growth. deindustiralization – jobs moving elsewhere- including to the US.

          The left rioting against their own failed socialist governments – and the right not far behind.

          You have repeatedly pointed towards Europe as a model – look at your model.

          That is not what Americans want.

          Even Biden was not as bad as Europe – but that is where Socialism, Communism, even democratic Socialism lead.

          Socialist governments fighting against socialist students rioting in the streets and a $hit economy.

          1. There is zero chance Mamdani can run statewide much less nationally.

            Mamdani can’t run nationally, because he was born in Uganda. It wouldn’t matter if he were successful and popular; he’d still need a constitutional amendment to allow him to run for national office.

            1. FALSE – You must be born in the US to run for president.

              You only have to be a citizen to run for Senator or representative. Those federal offices.

              Even New York State is not going rto elect Mamdani – probably not even for Governor which is not a national office.

              1. John, no one said anything about “federal offices”. You’re just making that up to change the subject. The statement was that “There is zero chance Mamdani can run statewide much less nationally“, and the plain undisputable fact is that no matter how popular he might be he can’t run nationally. There are no national races other than for president and vice president, and he can’t run for either of those.

      3. John Say,

        “Wl Sayed is NOT Hassan Piker – but he has embraced Hassan Piker.

        I do not care that El Sayed is egyption – I do not care that his family has strong past ties to the Muslim Brotherhood – which is ACTUALLY Fascist, The Muslim brotherhood recruited the most brutal members of the Waffen SS. What people care about – What Haley Stevens cares about is that El Sayed can not even call scapegoating Jews Wrong”

        ROFL! You think everything is fascist. You’re ranting man.

        Republicans will certainly lose a lot of seats in the house and senate. It’s looking that way and Republicans are desperate. You can see it in the political adds and mass texts sent at the last minute. None are about the issues. All are scare mongering about socialists, and taxes and transgender kids and so on. Trump’s rallies are looking worse for wear. It’s going to be bad for Republicans in the next few days. Really bad.

        1. Nope – but the Muslim Brotherhood is ACTUALL fascist.

          Most socialists are dangerous – most far left socialists in the past were very dangerous but not fascist – but increasingly socialist are fascist.

          “Republicans will certainly lose a lot of seats in the house and senate. “

          We will know in a few hours.

          How close the elections are and how large the turnout is matter. If Democrats win big in a LARGE turnout midterm that is a message.

          We are getting conflicting data. Early turnout was low, Turnout appears to be rising rapidly. Normally late rising turnout favores republicns.

          But we will have to see. I have seen numbers saying that the Generic Ballot is D+8.8 and others based on election returns saying D+1.

          Those are radically different.

          “It’s looking that way and Republicans are desperate.”

          Not this nonsense.

          ” You can see it in the political adds and mass texts sent at the last minute. “

          That is what political parties do – they spend whatever they have left at the last minute.

          Republicaans more so than Democrats – because Republicans DOMINATE Election day – while Democrats lead in early voting.

          “None are about the issues.”

          Not paying attention to anyone’s adds. But Republicans do not need to talk about issues – they are in power – their platform is KNOWN.

          It is nearly always true that the inpower party touts accomplishments and the weaknesses of their opponents.

          While the out of power party usually tries to tear down accomplishments point out failures push its own platform.

          And everyone engages in character assassination – that has been True since Adams and Jefferson – nothing new.

          “All are scare mongering about socialists, and taxes and transgender kids and so on”

          So hit your opponent where they are weak.

          .”Trump’s rallies are looking worse for wear. “

          Not that I have seen. Turnout rose rapidly as the rallies started – we will have to see what that actually means.

          “It’s going to be bad for Republicans in the next few days. Really bad.”

          So you say.

          I have no idea what is going to happen – except that there is lots of conflicting evendence and lots of people are lying.

          Further Republicans are used to being told they have losts.

          2016, 2024, 2022, …..

          Maybe the polls are right this time. That would be a first.

          Not betting on it.

      4. John Say,

        “No OKeefe was not caught committing voter fraud – that is a radically different case and the Minnesota AG is way over her skis.”

        Nope. O’Keefe was indeed caught committing voter fraud and a felony to boot. He used a fake name and presented himself as someone else. In Minnesota that’s a felony. He’s already been charged.

        Republicans are already committing verifiable voter fraud. O’Keefe tried to “catch” election workers letting people with false names to vote, and he got caught. It showed the safety measures worked as intended and he got a felony as a result. Not very smart. Because he recorded his intent. That’s the funniest part.

        1. James (not Sean, as you previously alluded to) O’Keefe did NOT conspire to commit “real voter fraud” for the purpose of what you claim. Notwithstanding that provisions of law were broken, it was journalistic investigation to expose flaws in Minnesota’s voting system– NOT an intent to use voter fraud to advance a particular candidate OR to vote more than once. –More a stunt to prove a point about Minnesota’s lax provisions.

          Indeed, didn’t County Attorney Moriarty expressly state that neither of them actually voted or signed affidavit, and that this was completely different? Look it up, X, I don;t have time.

          1. Lin,

            Yep. That is how I came to understand what O’Keefe was doing.

            I thought him dressing up the way he did kinda made it obvious.

            1. Hello Upstate: Gotta go, but I’ve been reading all your comments lately, good. Yeah, regarding the “garb.”

              “A new video showing conservative provocateur James O’Keefe and people from his team seemingly posing as Muslim Minnesotans and asking election volunteers questions about how the vouching system works is making the rounds on social media. The 11-minute video shows the group, with O’Keefe dressed in a thobe and kufi, going into polling places in Minneapolis.”

              https://www.mprnews.org/story/2026/08/14/project-veritas-founder-posts-video-critical-of-minnesota-election-law

              I guess it was funny until it wasn’t funny

          2. Lin, did look it up. That’s how I know he’s in for some serious charges in Minnesota and he did commit voter fraud AND identity theft.

            Unlawful voting. He he didn’t need to actually cast a vote or sign anything.

            https://www.courthousenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Minnesota-identity-theft-charge-against-James-OKeefe.pdf

            This provision of the Minnesota Election Day Act dictates that “no individual shall intentionally misrepresent the individual’s identity in applying for a ballot, depositing a ballot in a ballot box or attempting to vote by means of a voting machine or electronic voting system.”

            Under Minnesota election rules, the process of “applying for a ballot” legally begins the moment a person approaches a Roster Judge, engages with them, and gives a name and address. Prosecutors contend O’Keefe violated this statute by intentionally giving the names of real, registered Minnesota voters to the judges to initiate the ballot application process.

            Then there’s identify theft. A serious crime in Minnesota when trying to vote.

            O’Keefe crossed the line into felony identity theft because he did not use entirely fictional names; he specifically used the real names, home addresses, and voter registration statuses of actual citizens (including one living voter named William Pomeranz, as well as deceased residents) without their knowledge, consent, or permission.

            Both of those are felonies in Minnesota.

            1. X:

              OK I’m back (had to leave for a bit) Thanks for reading my comments as you always do.

              First, you will note that I said other laws may have been broken. I was right. You glossed right over that. Indeed, you have been carrying on about “voter fraud” and if you read the particular statute, you would see that there would be a legitimate question as to whether the elements therein are met.

              However, in typical manner, you skirted the issue and now for the first time bring up identity theft after researching. I do not believe you knew that until you were challenged.

              Yes I believe that an initial prima facie case of misrepresenting identity can be made. Again, I had already mentioned that in my original post, which you glossed over.

              You will recall that simply stating you are someone else could represent a prima facie charge, but you will also recall that Moriarty admitted that both neither applied for, nor signed the oath needed to confirm their identity. I clarify “applied for” by noting that it appears that the referenced “oath” is part of the application process, and they appeared to not want to go that far. This would be consistent with their stunt to show laxity. HAD THEY SIGNED THAT OATH, I would feel completely differently about what I said.

              You will note that the cited statute they are being charged with expressly states: “(a) misrepresent the individual’s identity in applying for a ballot, depositing a ballot in a ballot box or attempting to vote by means of a voting machine or electronic voting system;

              Likewise, in misrepresented voter identity cases, there generally is an element of intent to deprive the true voter of the right to vote. That is why I believe that Count I applies the general statute of misrepresented identity-not one particularly related to voting.

              The intent of both Higby and O’Keefe is patently clear by the contemporaneous social media postings they made–not something they later manufactured as part of a defense.

              In any event, I do not believe that they will be found guilty of both charges, but may plead to the lesser, especially when there could be expected a large representation of Muslim citizens in the jury pool.

              sorry for the long response.

              1. Yes I believe that an initial prima facie case of misrepresenting identity can be made.

                lin, X will undoubtedly lob back a discombobulated response, given his 99 page CV of myriad personas, careers and skill sets including being a Republican, a Jew, a married heterosexual with 6 children, a conservative, a construction builder supplier, a nurse practitioner with an MSN in pediatric cardiology, a physician, an attorney, a law professor and other CV fluffers I can not bring to mind….emphasis he is a fluffer

                You have the patience of Job in dealing with X / Svelaz / Gigi / Natacha / George / Esquire / Wally / Sally et al

                Have you noticed he does not use those sock puppet names anymore? We won. We beat the fluffer and we all had a happy ending, figuratively speaking!

                1. LOL! Estovir, the reason why I don’t use sock puppets is because I never did. On the other hand….you use them all the time.

                  1. GSX, you are a liar. Remember the Iran issue? When I pointed out your stupidity in what you said and attributed the words to, you said it wasn’t yours until I produced that same written material elsewhere. place.

              2. Lin, this is what you said,

                “James (not Sean, as you previously alluded to) O’Keefe did NOT conspire to commit “real voter fraud” for the purpose of what you claim. Notwithstanding that provisions of law were broken, it was journalistic investigation to expose flaws in Minnesota’s voting system– NOT an intent to use voter fraud to advance a particular candidate OR to vote more than once. –More a stunt to prove a point about Minnesota’s lax provisions.”

                That’s not what you’re claiming you said.

                Under Minnesota law it does not matter if they signed anything or not.

                Under Minnesota election rules, the process of “applying for a ballot” legally begins the moment a person approaches a Roster Judge, engages with them, and gives a name and address.

                Minnesota Statute § 204C.14, Subdivision 1(a)

                Prosecutors contend O’Keefe violated this statute by intentionally giving the names of real, registered Minnesota voters to the judges to initiate the ballot application process.

                1. yup, I repeat what I said and I stand by everything I said. You initially harped on and on about “voter fraud” in your earlier posts, then later brought up the ‘identity thing.’ That’s all; no more, no less. thanks.

            2. Just so we are clear YOUR idea of Republican Voting fraud is a reporter trying to report on how easy Voting Fraud is in the hopes that maybe we can get idiot laws than make fraud trivial changed ?

              If OKeefe had actually signed a ballot request, taken a ballot and voted and destroyed the ballot before it was counted – he would STILL not be guilty.

              The MN law (and all similar law) requires the INTENT to commit a crime – NOT the intent to expose states for fascilitating crimes.

              The MN law states that signing a voter registration form is prima fascia evidence of intent – and that is TRUE.

              But prima fascia is NOT the same as unrebuttable.

              in pretty much every crime in existance you can express the desire to commit the crime take one Act towards committing that crime get caught and be successfully prosecuted.

              BUT if you stop at any point without being caught reverse and do not complete the crime – you can not be prosecuted.

              If OKeefe had entered the Poll with the actual intent of violating the law – gone through EVERY element of the crime but reveresed at the very last moment and left on his own – then no crime has been committed.

              This is fundimental law, it is also good public policy.

              We do not ever want to punish people who do not go through with crimes.

          3. Lin PLEASE – never trust that X or the others on the left get ANY facts correct.

            NO provisions of the law were broken –

            The Attorney is misrepresenting the law – and MILDLY misrepresenting the facts.

            But X is blatantly misrepresenting everything.

            I have cited the entire law elsewhere. X cherry pick a part of one requirement and even after selective editing – that still does not apply.

            Further if the law actually was as X claims – it would be unconstitutional.

            This prosecution is “as applied” unconstitutional.

            OKeefe is just waiting to tear this apart in court.

            This is not his first rodeo and he has faced far batter lawyers and won than these.

            If they push this too far – they are going to be sued by OMG – OKeefe Media Group.

            Regardless I posted an OMG video on this incident – that has Excerps – but the full video is available.

            Pretty much NOTHING X hs claimed is true – not the facts he claims, not the law.

            And as you note – even the Prosecutor is not stupid enough to make X’s claims.

            It is kind of nonsense that is why no one trusts the left.

            No Trans boys in Girls lockers is NOT the same as internet Porn.

            One can rape you the other can not.

            What is islamophobia ? Fear of Islam ? I am ok with that – Islam has a horrible track record. Fearing its spread is sanity.

            But initiating violence against people because they are muslim – that is NOT OK.

            Nor is doing so to jews.

            In the US – 60% of hate crimes are against less thn 1% of the population – jews.

            Whatever fear people practicing Islam may legitimately have – that of Jews is 60 times worse.

            You are free to run for the US cenate if you are muslm. Scapegoating jews is still absolutely dispicable and no one should vote for you.

        2. Never mind. Found one for you before I leave. (John Say is correct in his sentence.)

          “;I think it’s pretty clear they did not intend to vote. That’s not the question here,’ Moriarty said Wednesday as she unveiled the charges against O’Keefe and Higby.”

          “”Alright guys, it’s Election Day in Minneapolis. James O’Keefe and I are going to go around the city to different polling stations and we’re going to see if they’re going to allow us to vote without IDs and then we’re going to see if they are going to allow us to vouch for other people who aren’t even registered to vote,”

          https://www.mprnews.org/story/2026/10/28/james-okeefe-and-cam-higby-charged-with-unlawful-voting-for-youtube-videos

          1. He presented himself as someone else. The moment he did that he broke the law. Regardless of whether he voted or not.

            1. um, X, I think there has to be mens rea attaching to intent to fraudulently cast a ballot, –did you notice that Lin said “Notwithstanding that provisions of law were broken,” we’ll check in with you again X when we see what they are convicted of.

              1. Nope.

                In Minnesota the law does not require an intent to successfully cast a ballot or alter an election. Instead, the statute explicitly attaches the intent to the act of misrepresentation itself

                “No individual shall intentionally misrepresent the individual’s identity in applying for a ballot…”

                Because O’Keefe and Higby knowingly and intentionally gave names and addresses that were not their own to poll workers, prosecutors argue the mens rea (the intent to deceive about their identity) was fully achieved the moment they spoke those words. The fact that their ultimate goal was a journalism stunt rather than a fraudulent vote does not legally erase the intent to misrepresent their identity at the roster.

                1. “In Minnesota the law does not require an intent to successfully cast a ballot or alter an election.”

                  That’s not even what was said, clown X, always moving the goal posts.

                2. X they did not represent those addresses as their own.

                  Nor BTW did they APPLY FOR A BALLOT – that is an ACT and an ELEMENT of the crime and Neither the misrepresentation nor the act are present.

                  Next please cite the WHOLE LAW

                  • 204C.14 UNLAWFUL VOTING; PENALTY.

                  §Subdivision 1.Violations; penalty.

                  No individual shall intentionally:

                  (a) misrepresent the individual’s identity in applying for a ballot, depositing a ballot in a ballot box or attempting to vote by means of a voting machine or electronic voting system;

                  (b) vote more than once at the same election;

                  (c) put a ballot in a ballot box for any illegal purpose;

                  (d) give more than one ballot of the same kind to an election judge to be placed in a ballot box;

                  (e) aid, abet, counsel or procure another to go into any precinct for the purpose of voting in that precinct, knowing that the other individual is not eligible to vote in that precinct; or

                  (f) aid, abet, counsel or procure another to do any act in violation of this section.

                  A violation of this section is a felony.Subd.

                  2.Signature on roster as evidence of intent.

                  For purposes of proving a violation of this section, the signature of an individual on a polling place roster or voter signature certificate is prima facie evidence of the intent of the individual to vote at that election.

                  1). You MUST ask for a ballot – no one did.

                  2) in the alternative you MUST sign a roster or voter signature certificate – no one did.

                  Watch the video

                  YOU LOSE

                  One the law, and on the facts.

                3. “In Minnesota the law does not require an intent to successfully cast a ballot or alter an election. Instead, the statute explicitly attaches the intent to the act of misrepresentation itself”

                  Whjat does this KAmala Harris word salad even mean.

                  Yes the law requires intent. Even the tiny slice you excepted demonstrqates that – but the FULL law goes further – it specifies that Signing the Voting book is prima fascia evidence of intent.

                  Again NO ONE asked for a ballot, no one signed anything, no one signed a form, no one signed anything, no one touched a ballot, no one touched anything, no one said “I am mr X”.

                  In the video I linked none other that AG Eric Holder said that Okeefe doing essentially the same thing with Respect to HIS PERSONAL ballot was perfectly legal.

                  We will have to see who lines up behind OKeefe this time – but in identical cases in other states OKeefe has won and had Amicus briefs by the ACLU and major left leaning media groups.

                  OKeefe won in DC in front of a far left DC pannel of appelate judges after being convicted by a DC jury who said This is a farce and reversed.

                  In this case Tjhe MN AG said you must present yourself as a journalist and provide ID before you can report in a polling place – that is complete and total nonsense – and has been addressed before.

                  It is also bizarre that a state that does not require ID to vote requires ID to engage in Journalism.

                  X – this is idiotic lawfare plain and simple, and the only question is how quickly OKeefe will win.

                  OKeefe knows what he is doing – the MN AG does not, she – like you is way out over her skis.

                  Intent is NOT an issue here – there is absolutely ZERO doubt what OKeefe intent was – he documented it over and over.

                  His intent was to demonstrate exactly how corrupt and bogus MN’s voting is without violating the law.

                  That is his EXPRESSED intent.

                  While OKeefe himself made clear BEFORE this

                  We do no t say “my name is” or “I am”, we do not ask for a ballot, we do not touch a ballot, we do not ask to vote we dop not sign anything, We do not identify ourself as ANYONE

                  Again OKeefe KNOWS what he is doing. He has done variations of this is in dozens of states. He KNOWS the law. Stupid prosecutors have Tried this before – he ALWAYS wins.

                  To paraphrase him – “I am going to enjoy raking the MN AG over the coals”

                  It is the MN AG that has violated OKeefe rights.

        3. “Nope. O’Keefe was indeed caught committing voter fraud and a felony to boot. He used a fake name and presented himself as someone else. In Minnesota that’s a felony. He’s already been charged.”

          False it is all on video – because that is what OKeefe does.

          This is just more left wing nut lawfare – the MN AG trying to prevent people from learning how easy election fraud is in MN.

          “Republicans are already committing verifiable voter fraud. O’Keefe tried to “catch” election workers letting people with false names to vote,”

          Again you could know something about what you are writing.

          No Okeefe was NOT trying to catch election workers allowing someone with a false name to vote.

          He was trying to demonstrate how MN’s sysem where ONE voter on the voter rolls can “vouch for” as many as 8 people not on the rolls – and they get to vote.

          Again WATCH THE VIDEO

          Quit spewing left wing nut talking points from people who do not know what they are talking about.

          Nothing OKeefe did is something that 60 minutes did not do all the time decades ago – it is called under cover journalism.

          OKeefe also goes OUT OF HIS WAY to make himself as suspicious as possible. He dresses up as Pimp to solicit Welfare for prostitutes.

          or a Saudi Sheik to get MN election workers to tell him that he can vouch for as many as 8 other unregistered voters.

          Again WATCH THE VIDEO – OKeefe committed no Crime and MN election officals look like FOOLS – because they were trying to defend an absolutely absurdly stupid law.

          ” and he got caught. It showed the safety measures worked as intended and he got a felony as a result.”

          He did not get caught – he left and posted the video embarrassing MN and then they decided to claim Fraud – long after the fact. \

          “Not very smart. Because he recorded his intent. That’s the funniest part.”

          Again you clearly have not watched the videos.

          He absolutely recorded his “intent” – the intent to NOT violate the law.

          He recorded the legal prep before, and the interaction between his people and election workers.

          Legal advice dictating Exactly what could and could not be said was presented, and the video of the appearance at the polls shows he followed that advice.,

          There are TWO laws in play here – the MN election law – which he did not come within 10000 miles of violating that requires actually signing to vote, taking a ballot and starting to vote.

          No one signed anything.

          No one touched a ballot.

          The MN election law violation claim not only dies in flames but could eacily trigger first amendment S1983 challenges for violating OKeefes rights to free speech and a free press.

          The other claim is “identity theft”

          OKeefe and his people were EXTREMELY careful – they NEVER said what THEIR names were. They phrases everything they said never assert Their Names but to provide the election workers with the oportuity to make assumptions.

          When they had Election workers on Absolutely Absurd video that had them advising people who looked like minor Saudi Princes that they could vouch for 8 random people to Vote and that they would be allowed to vote and that their votes would be counted

          Then they left.

          Again WATCH THE VIDEO.

          OKeefe was charged because he embarrassed MN – no one was “caught at the scene”

          In fact wheile he did NOT commit any crime – he could have, and so long as he did not release the video not only would he not have been caught but he could have voted illegally multiple times and gotten away with it.

          BTW this is not the first Time OKeefe has done this – and he wins ALL THE TIME.

          He KNOWS WHAT HE IS DOING – he KNOWS the LAW and he KNOWS how to embarrass left wing nuts – and that is why you hate him and why you try these bogus prosecutions.

        4. “He used a fake name and presented himself as someone else.”

          Nope. – Watch the Video.

          “Republicans are already committing verifiable voter fraud.”

          Nope

          ” O’Keefe tried to “catch” election workers letting people with false names to vote,”

          Very loosly correct – and not a crime – it is called journalism.. Whistleblowing.

          Trying to Catch govenrment doing things that are illegal or stupid is not a crime.

          “and he got caught.”

          Nope he walked away. The Election officials were completely unaware of what was going on. They were unaware that they had been exposed.

          The MN AG was not aware of this until the OKeefe video of the visit to MN polls was released.

          This is all cover my A$$ nonsense by the MN AG

          With the typical left wing nut beleif that if they prosecute the people who expose the flaws in their sacred cows that people will ignore the flaws.

          “It showed the safety measures worked as intended”

          Nope. Had Okeefe wanted to vote illegally he would have been allowed to – the poll workers did not “catch” anything – that is the point of the video. The only reason that OKeefe and his crew did not get away with voting illegally 8 times is because they had no intention of voting.

  17. Marc Elias needs to feel real jeopardy Only then will he stand any chance at remorse for his heinous conduct.

  18. This is about the part of the Indispensable Right that lives in the zipcode lie down with dogs get up with fleas. It tells us that nuts is normal getting a vote. It does not tell us that nuts is normal for giving our vote. That puts it on each one of us in the voting booth. The Alaska Supreme Court affirmed the Superior Court holding that a candidate cannot be kept off the ballot by intent to confuse, because that is not a qualification requirement of the law. It also affirmed that the law itself gives the election authorities tools to shape the ballot to nix confusion. Alaska’s website  tells this writer who the incumbent Sullivan is, and is not. I suggest that the ballot  text block about Ballot Measure 2, ending ranked measure voting is every bit as interesting. If Alaska voters pass that, goodbye to a whole bunch of fleas. They almost did last election. We may look  and see this blaring  dispute had its sights on both of these ballot measures.

    1. Ranked choice voting is salutary. The procedure set up by the Alaska legislature made a mess of it. You benefit from procedural adjustments, not from eliminating ranked choice voting entirely.

      1. I disagree – the central presumption of Ranked Choice voting is false – that is that people put the same thought into 2nd and 3rd choices, and that those choices are unaffected by what actually happens with other candidates.

        You can not fix that procedurally.

        If you want real ranked choice voting – have runnoffs – that operates under the same principle, but requires people to think about what their 2nd choice actually is.

        But you can not fix the problems with Rank Choice procedurally.

        That said – this is not a constitutional issue – Alaska can use the means to vote that they choose.

        They chose ranked choice – they appear to be ready to unchoose it.

        That is normally how choosing ranked choice goes. People like it in the abstract but not in practice.

        1. the central presumption of Ranked Choice voting is false – that is that people put the same thought into 2nd and 3rd choices,

          ==

          That is not the central presumption. Nor is that a valid argument against it.

  19. The good professor notes, “Meanwhile, though, tens of thousands of voters in Alaska have already cast ballots that included the decoy Sullivan candidate.”

    Alaska is not a state in which statutory provision/precision permits a “re-do” election, (wherein judicial ruling voids an entire previous election result and orders a new election). The more common remedy is a judicial order for a recount or a voiding of specific votes for specific candidates.

    Recount does not seem applicable here, but either judicial order voiding votes for the “other” (Dan J Sullivan) might be appropriate; or alternatively, voiding the entire election result and ordering a “re-do” election, see, e.g., “Section 3 New Elections” p. 283 in Remedying Election Results, https://journals.law.harvard.edu/jol/wp-content/uploads/sites/86/2023/02/44HarvJonLegis265.pdf

    1. Lets just hope that Danial S. Sullivan wins and we do not have to sort through this mess.

      If Peltola wins – this will be a mess and I strongly suspect that she will eventually be seated.

      Courts do not want to decide elections – especially conservative courts.

      honestly we should have processes that avoid that.

      We should not want courts to involved in politics. It is very bad for the credibility of the courts.

      1. JohnSay: I should have premised my comment by noting that the “remedies” outlined in the Harvard piece related to a judicial conclusion of wrongdoing or malfunctioning. That is not the case here, at least not yet.

        While I share your hope of a clear winner without legal intervention, the Alaska courts have already been involved and resolved on the immediate question as to appearance on the ballot, but it ain’t over till the fat lady sings and the FBI has just filed a records request with the court on Oct. 29 on a related matter.

Leave a Reply