New Jersey Gov. Mikie Sherrill Criticizes College Students for Inviting Greogry Bovino to Speak on Campus

Pandemonium broke out at Rutgers University after College Republicans held an event to hear former border chief Gregory Bovino’s views on immigration. What followed was the usual cancel campaign: first trying to stop people from hearing Bovino, then disrupting the event. Rather than denouncing the cancel culture and ideological intolerance that still grips higher education, New Jersey Democratic Gov. Mikie Sherrill denounced the conservative students and the university for allowing his views to be heard on campus.

Various groups staged protests outside of the event at Rutgers, which is perfectly fine and part of the exercise of free speech. However, protesters entered the event and prevented Bovino from speaking (He was escorted out of the event and later returned to finish his remarks after police intervened).

This was another opportunity for a civil discussion of immigration practices and policies. There are good-faith objections that could be raised to Bovino’s views and students could engage directly with someone who held an important position in the Administration. That is what higher education should be about in fostering a diversity of viewpoints. However, many in higher education find opposing views intolerable and refuse to allow others to hear from speakers with whom they disagree.

The scene at Rutgers was all too familiar as Bovino was shouted down by activists.

Of course, speakers on the far left routinely speak without interruption or protests on campuses. The events are not denounced by the governor or disrupted by protesters. Indeed, the faculty itself contains radical activists and academics who call for the release of Luigi Mangione after murdering a health-care executive or encourage further assassination attempts on President Trump. Another professor insisted that Trump and conservatives were conspiring to kill black people with Covid-19. Another proclaimed his hatred for white people.

However, conservative students holding an event to hear the other side on the immigration controversy resulted in a condemnation from the governor that such views were allowed to be voiced on campus.

Sherrill declared that she was “deeply disappointed” the school’s student Republican group would invite Bovino. Sherrill encouraged students to challenge Bovino and  “ask him why he chose cruelty over humanity and put Americans’ lives at risk in their own communities.”

185 thoughts on “New Jersey Gov. Mikie Sherrill Criticizes College Students for Inviting Greogry Bovino to Speak on Campus”

  1. Sherrill has her bully pulpit political thumb on the same scale that bears the thumb weight of skewed academics in education. She never says WHY she is disappointed in the Republican students. They are, as Ollie North’s lawyer Brendan Sullivan told Sen. Inouye in the Iran Contra hearing, “not a potted plant”.  All those students, not just Republicans, will have to cope with immigration policy long after we are gone. You’ve got the Agamemnon side, “what have you done for me lately?” The best and brightest, but not at the expense of jobs that U.S. citizens merit. You’ve got humanitarian/asylum/volume/melting pot issues. You’ve got national policy shifts from open borders to mass deportation- and sit in resistance from sanctuary cities. Sherrill’s disappointment is better understood as a wish that only her preferred viewpoint equip students to think “critically”.

    1. Mike Gilmore,

      Claiming Gov. Sherrill “never says WHY she is disappointed” only works if you stop reading halfway through her statement.

      She explained her exact reason in plain English: she wasn’t objecting to a debate over immigration policy, she was disappointed that a student group chose to glorify an official who oversaw operations that killed two U.S. citizens in Minneapolis (Renée Good and Alex Pretti), was found by a federal judge to have lied under oath, and was demoted and forced into retirement over his conduct. Pretending Bovino is just some scholarly policy expert discussing “melting pot issues” is pure sanitization.

      Even worse, twisting Sherrill’s words into “a wish that only her preferred viewpoint equip students to think critically” ignores what she actually told students to do. She didn’t ask Rutgers to cancel the event—she pledged state support to protect the event and everyone’s constitutional rights, and explicitly urged students to attend and ask him tough questions.

      Encouraging students to show up, hear a controversial speaker, and challenge him with hard questions is literally the textbook definition of critical thinking and free speech. Calling that “putting a thumb on the scale” just means you think conservatives should be protected from criticism, not just censorship.

      Those pesky facts always seem to get in the way.

      1. You clown. Watch the gd video. Is that your idea of “Encouraging students to show up, hear a controversial speaker, and challenge him…?

        DO YOU EVEN GET IT? CAN YOU SPELL READING COMPREHENSION BACKWARDS?

        1. LOL!! Anonymous, I did watch the video. Guess what? Students did show up. The few who heckled instead of asking questions were removed by police, while the rest stayed and listened to his entire speech.

          Gov. Sherrill wasn’t addressing only the dozen protesters—she was speaking to all students, including the ones who actually showed up to listen and ask questions. Knowing the difference between “challenging someone with questions” and “screaming over them” is kind of the whole point of reading comprehension, right?

      2. Bovino apparently lied during a deposition. We learned from Billy Jeff that that is no big deal, and you get to keep your job.

      3. Sherrill swore an oath to uphold he constitution when she took office.

        That includes Free speech.

        Yes Two US citizens were killed while interfering with Law Enforcement.

        Do you think the outcome would be different if you interfered with local police doing a drug arrest ?

        If you do not like our immigration laws – CHANGE them.

        If you wish to protest – go to the WhiteHouse or to Congress where it MIGHT do some good.

        I am not a giant fan of Law enforcement – but they are a necescity.

        and those interfering With ICE doing their job enforcing ACTUAL US law, are loathesome people.

        Just as Sherrill is here.

        NO you do not lecture college students seeking to hear views you disagree with.

        YOu Protect the rights of those speakers and you arrest those who shout the speaker down.

        You do that because THAT is the job of Government – not moral pandering for views that most of us do not share.

        “was found by a federal judge to have lied under oath“

        Judges do not find people lie under oath juries do.

        SCOTUS has already said what needs to be said on immigration cases – you have another left wing judge out over his skis.

        It is not even likely this gets to SCOTUS.

        You have lost nearly every immigration related case.

        And the reasons should be obvious – Our Law requires deporting people who came here without a visa or residence permit.

        I know you do not like that law – so change it. Do not pi$$ on those enforcing the law.

        I do not like our Drug laws – If I try to interfere with Law Enforcement enforcing those laws – I will be lucky if the worst that happens to me is I get arrested.

        If you are here without permission – ICE may remove you. You are entitled to due process consistent with the rights that government is infringing on.

        You are not having your property taken,

        You are not having your liberty taken.

        You are not having your life taken

        You are entitled to sufficient due process to determine that you are the person identified in the ICE warrant who is here illegally.

        And then You are being sent home

        If you are a judge – you are to assure that the required due process above – limited to the rights that are actually being infringed on is afforded – nothing more.

        Judges do not make the law – congress does.

        Judges do not enforce the law – the president does.

        Judges determine if the law is constitutinal – that has already being established, whether it is being followed – it is, and whether any actual rights are being infringed without due process – there is no infringement on rights there is very limited do process.

        As a judge your personal views are irrelevant – if you make them relevant – you are lawless, you should be removed.

        “Pretending Bovino is just some scholarly policy expert discussing “melting pot issues” is pure sanitization.”

        What you think is irrelevant – he was invited – and frankly he needed to be invited.

        Idiots actually like you need to HEAR what people who disagree with you say.

        “Even worse, twisting Sherrill’s words”

        Sherrill is governor – he only liegitmate role was protecting the right of the speaker to speak – she failed.

        She has violated her oath of office.

        I do not care what she asked though that was not her business either.

        “She didn’t ask Rutgers to cancel the event—she pledged state support to protect the event and everyone’s constitutional rights,”

        And yet she didn’t did she ?

        Arguably she encouraged those who disrupted the event.

        That is not a crime – but it was misconduct.

        ” and explicitly urged students to attend and ask him tough questions.”

        It is weird that you feel that Rutgers students need the Governor to tell them to ask tough questions.

        You really think students are stupid.

        Regardless her questions are not tough.

        Congress enacted the law, ICE exists to enforce that law – if you do not like it – change the law.

        The enforcement of ANY law will involve FORCE if people resist or interfere.

        Do not resist or interfere if you do not want subject to force.

        “Those pesky facts always seem to get in the way.”

        There are no facts that got in the way – just a governor who came close to inciting violence and failed to live up to her oath.

  2. Another Democratic Party/DSA member in a leadership role tasked with saving democracy for only a few has expressed her contempt for shared freedom of speech.

    1. Ron A. Hoffman, no. Not even close. Did you use to post on Dave Trabert’s blog a few years ago? Your name is very familiar.

      1. It’s closer than you may think. Contempt is what often arises from disappointment; particularly long-standing disappointment.

        Tell me about Dave Trabert. Is he a scholarly freedom of speech expert?

        1. The whole “saving democracy” narrative is entirely professor Turley’s construct. Nothing about it is rooted in reality. It’s just a means of rage-baiting readers into blind criticism of anything “left” of them.

          Years ago I followed a blog from a libertarian think tank. I think he was president. For some reason your name is strangely familiar. I might be wrong.

          1. It’s hopeful that those who cry for “saving democracy” do not really believe it needs saving and are not using it as a criticism of anything “right” of them.

            Do you have libertarian leanings?

            1. Ron, X is one of our resident far left wing nuts.

              He has a long reputation for dishonesty.

              He is a classic exmple of those who accuse others of what they are doing.

              He has a massive case of TDS.

              As bad as he is – and that is pretty bad – he is close to the intellectual best the left has to offer on this blog – it gets much worse past him.

              While he rarely can complete a sentence without more errors than words – he does try albeit badly to make an argument.

              I really wish someone actually intelligent on the left would join, But X appears to be the best the left has.

  3. These schools no longer have admission standards nor standards of any kind. This is expected. Bovino is extremely controversial, as well.

    shocking!

  4. “…Maybe the only question to ask of Bovino is what part of his oath to the Constitution did he miss.”

    Maybe the only question to ask the Governor is why she’s lied about her honor violation while at the Naval Academy? That tells you all you need to know about her integrity. Honorable? No way in he**.

  5. Free speech is NOT harrassing. block, attacking people…those are CRIMES

    Free Speech is giving a speech in a park or hall or writing your point of view!

    Democrats are the FASCISTS school of Anti-Free Speech!

  6. Go South Young Children(college & Jobs)

    The Democrats are Fascists who will destroy you!

    The Mason Dixon Line has reversed!

    1. Go south? Are you sure? The South pretty much turned blue after the election remember? Texas turned blue, Arizona, New Mexico. Georgia, Mississippi.

      1. Parts of the south are turning blue as democrats move south – that is not new.

        New Mexico ha been blue for some time. Frankly I can not remember when NM had a republican in state wide office.

        AZ will flip back, as will TX – though it is an open question as to how long TX can keep accepting refugees from CA who want to turn TX into the state they just fled.

        Georgia, and NC will also flip permanently – again people are comming from the North.

        SC is an anomaly as is Mississippi.

        Conversely the Rust belt will flip red – that too is just a matter of time.

        PA, OH, MI, MN, evenually IL. OR will also flip red eventually, as will NY eventually.

        Given enough time WA may flip red.

        Collins was likely that Last Republican senator from New England.

      2. and now you have to govern.

        You have ranted here about the Various states ballot initiatives to protect womens sports.

        You do not seem to grasp that they passed – by 10pts even in purported Blue state.

        You can fight those measures – and maybe win. You shouldn’t win, but democrat judges make up constitutions to suit.

        Regardless we DO expet courts to protect individuals rights from infringement by the people.

        There just is no right for a bio male to pummel a women in girls sports.

        But the more important point is that even in a very blue state – you are on the wrong side of a large number of issues.

        The people may be with you on some things – but obviously not everything.

        I do not beleive in direct democracy.

        But I do beleive that our elected officials should take heed of what Voters tell them

        Regardless – you keep claiming a sweeping mandate – that is obviously false.

        You may have the power tokneecap ballot initiatives you do not like – but you do not have a mandate to do so – that should be obvious.

        What will matter in the future is whether the issues where you steam roll voters are important enough for them to vote ou out of office.

        YOU beleive that Trump was voted down for pi$$ing off voters.

        YOU should take heed of that.

        \

  7. Democrats are fighting THEIR 2nd Civil War! They want power, they want slaves on their plantations, they are against a Free America and its Constitution!

    I want every Democrat helping their illegal invader army jailed for Treason!

    1. Thank you for saying what all of us who love our constitutional republic have also been trying to say. However, we face censorship for speaking this truth!

      1. Concentration camps they were free to leave at any time?

        Like the bartender used to tell us at 1:45 AM: While you don’t have to go home, you can’t stay here.

  8. Time to End all Federal Aid to cities, states, non-profits and colleges.

    Ban all Public Unions, the political army of the democrats!

    Let’s see how democrats actually operate

  9. Democrats are Fascists…who are against Freedom!

    They want total government, power, censorship, propaganda, destruction!

  10. The governor of a state has no business interfering in the right of students to invite a speaker to their college. She has used the office of governor to provoke the usual useful idiots to protest and disrupt a talk instead of keeping her mouth shut and allowing the students to have virtually any speaker they desire. Instead she uses the weight and power of the Governor’s position to interfere and lend support to those who would disrupt the talk. She, in essence, pre-approved the demonstration and disruption.

    She should be removed from office for her blatant impingement of the 1st amendment rights of the students and speaker. Where does this governor think she has this power. She is in New Jersey where blood was spilled on several fields to attain those rights. This not the European Union of the UK, after all.

    1. GEB, the governor did no such thing. As I said below,

      “Sherrill explicitly pledged state support to Rutgers “to protect the safety of everyone and the rights enshrined in our Constitution” and urged students to attend and ask him tough questions. Saying “I disagree with this speaker, but I will protect their constitutional right to speak and encourage you to question them” is the textbook definition of free speech—not “joining the mob.”

      Turley likes to leave out important facts to produce a rage-baiting narrative for the gullible.

      1. She did not send law enforcement to remove people trying to shutdown the event

        That is her actual job.

        Bad moral lectures are not.

  11. Little Nazis like Gov. Sherrill can’t bear freedom of speech or the free exchange of ideas. Nazis like her only survive with total control over messaging and by not allowing any competing ideas to be heard.

  12. Ah Commissar Sherrill joins Commissar Spanberger in whipping up the frenzy in her Gulag known as New Jerky! Nonconformists must be DEALT WITH in the old Soviet Style – taken out back and educated? Typical scumbag DEMS!!

    1. What is really disturbing is that neither Sherrill nor spanberger are on the far left of the party.

      They would have been for nearly all my life.

      Today – both are insane and they are the “moderates”.

  13. Here we go again for another round of DEI, Hate, and mostly peaceful demonstrations. What have the voters done to our country this time?

  14. Sigh….Jonathan Turley’s narrative only works because he leaves out what Rutgers University and Gov. Mikie Sherrill actually said and did.

    First, Rutgers did the exact opposite of canceling anyone. Despite petitions demanding the event be shut down, the university explicitly affirmed that student groups have the right to invite controversial speakers, deployed Rutgers Police to remove the handful of hecklers who disrupted the room, and made sure Gregory Bovino returned to the stage to finish his entire speech—as confirmed by The New York Times and CBS News New York.

    Second, Turley selectively edits Gov. Mikie Sherrill’s statement to make her sound like a censor. In the exact same post where she criticized inviting Bovino, Sherrill explicitly pledged state support to Rutgers “to protect the safety of everyone and the rights enshrined in our Constitution” and urged students to attend and ask him tough questions. Saying “I disagree with this speaker, but I will protect their constitutional right to speak and encourage you to question them” is the textbook definition of free speech—not “joining the mob.” Both university leaders and elected officials have the First Amendment right to criticize a speaker while protecting that speaker’s right to take the stage.

    Finally, Turley sanitizes why people protested in the first place. According to The New York Times and federal court records, Bovino wasn’t some ordinary policy wonk—he was demoted and retired earlier this year after overseeing the Minneapolis crackdown in which federal agents fatally shot two U.S. citizens (Renée Good and Alex Pretti), after a federal judge found he lied under oath about deploying tear gas in Chicago, and after a CBP investigation into reports he mocked a federal prosecutor’s Jewish faith. Even at Rutgers, The Philadelphia Inquirer noted he falsely claimed 100 million undocumented immigrants live in the United States.

    Rutgers protected free speech, police removed the disruptors, and the governor defended everyone’s constitutional rights while voicing her own opinion. Leaving out half the governor’s quote and all of the university’s actions to invent another “campus cancel culture” story isn’t journalism—it’s spin.

    1. And Trump asked his followers to protest at the Capitol peacefully. Law enforcement cleared the Capitol of offenders within hours. Most of the protesters at the Capitol who were prosecuted were in fact acting peacefully.

      1. Ummm…no. First, on January 6, rioters didn’t “leave when ordered by police.” They smashed through windows, beat officers with flagpoles, fire extinguishers, and bear spray, forced the evacuation of Congress, and halted the constitutional certification of a presidential election for hours. Over 140 police officers were injured, and multiple people died in connection with the attack.

        Second, saying “most of the protesters who were prosecuted were acting peacefully” is pure fiction. Nobody was prosecuted for standing peacefully outside on the National Mall. According to the U.S. Department of Justice, over 1,500 defendants were charged because they breached restricted Capitol grounds or broke inside the building—and over 600 of them were charged with assaulting, resisting, or impeding law enforcement, including more than 170 charged with using a deadly or dangerous weapon against police.

        Third, Trump told the crowd to “fight like hell,” sat in the White House watching the violence on TV for 187 minutes before telling them to go home, and then pardoned even the rioters convicted of violently beating police officers.

        1. Trump at the rally: “I know that everyone here will soon be marching over to the Capitol building to peacefully and patriotically make your voices heard.” X leaves out anything that doesn’t comport his trolling.

          For the record, I wasn’t happy with Trump’s performance that day, and I’m never happy with how you always justify liberals no matter what. You’re doing that now. Disorderly conduct with the intention of violating free-speech rights at Rutgers is a crime.

          One might add charges like physical threats, brandishing weapons, and trespassing, but we’ll never know because guys like you are sweeping it under the rug.

          1. Cherry-picking the single time Trump said “peacefully” while ignoring the 20 times he told the crowd to “fight”—including “fight like hell” right after Rudy Giuliani demanded “trial by combat”—is classic selective memory. When the crowd beat over 140 police officers and smashed into the Capitol, Trump sat watching on TV for 187 minutes before telling them to go home, and later pardoned even the rioters convicted of violently assaulting cops.

            Brandishing weapons”? Nobody—not Rutgers Police, not Gregory Bovino, not College Republicans, and not even Jonathan Turley—reported a single weapon or violent assault inside that room. You just invented fake weapon charges because without them, your comparison between a dozen yelling college kids and the January 6 riot collapses completely.

            Under New Jersey law, when disruptive protesters comply with a police order to leave an event, removing them resolves the disturbance—which is why Rutgers Police cleared the room in minutes and Bovino delivered his entire two-hour speech. I never justified the hecklers; I pointed out that getting removed was the lawful consequence, and no amount of imaginary weapon charges makes yelling at a campus speaker equal to beating 140 cops at the U.S. Capitol.

            Diogenes, clearly you’re a bit nuts.

            1. “You just invented fake weapon charges”

              I explicitly suggested they were possible charges, not factual charges. For those who believe X, read my comment, again, please. I do believe disorderly conduct was likely the case. We don’t know what else could be charged because your guys didn’t want to know.

              Besides misreading our comments, you also neglect relevant facts and give irrelevant facts cosmic significance. This is conscious trolling, not good-faith argumentation.

              1. Diogenes, speculating about “brandishing weapons” at a filmed campus event where police, reporters, and even Jonathan Turley reported zero weapons isn’t “good-faith argumentation”—it is making things up out of thin air.

                More importantly, under New Jersey law, disrupting an event and criminal disorderly conduct are two completely different things. Disrupting a campus event violates university conduct rules, meaning organizers and campus police can revoke your permission to be in the room and order you out—which happened immediately. Criminal disorderly conduct (N.J.S.A. 2C:33-2), by contrast, requires fighting, physical threats, violent or tumultuous behavior, creating a physically dangerous hazard, or unprotected “fighting words” meant to provoke an immediate brawl. New Jersey courts strictly apply the First Amendment so that shouting political slogans at a government official—without violence, threats, or refusing a police order to leave—does not meet the criminal threshold for disorderly conduct.

                Because the hecklers left the second Rutgers Police ordered them out, there was no violence, no physical hazard, and no defiant trespass. You keep insisting there must have been hidden crimes only because you want the law to say something it doesn’t. You want retribution for their actions despite what the actual consequences are under the law.

                1. AGAIN almost certainly lying about the law.

                  The law has 4 sections – you can be charged if you meet the elements of one of them.

                  I think you can credibly charge under a(1).

                  Regardless the requirements of B are obviously met – b is “petty disorderly conduct and is almost certainly subject to less consequential punishment.

                  It is possible some present met c – that is more serious.

                  And D is absolutely met.

                  As usual when dealing with the law you cut and paste only the portions you want.

                  NJ has a diversion for first time offenders where you get probation and if you complete it charges are dismissed.

                  That is perfectly appropriate here.

                  2C:33-2. Disorderly conduct.

                  2C:33-2. Disorderly Conduct.

                  a. Improper behavior. Except as otherwise provided in subsection c. of this section, a person is guilty of a petty disorderly persons offense, if with purpose to cause public inconvenience, annoyance or alarm, or recklessly creating a risk thereof, the person:

                  (1) Engages in fighting or threatening, or in violent or tumultuous behavior; or

                  (2) Creates a hazardous or physically dangerous condition by any act which serves no legitimate purpose of the actor.

                  b. Offensive language. A person is guilty of a petty disorderly persons offense if, in a public place, and with purpose to offend the sensibilities of a hearer or in reckless disregard of the probability of so doing, he addresses unreasonably loud and offensively coarse or abusive language, given the circumstances of the person present and the setting of the utterance, to any person present.

                  c. Concealing identity. A person who attempts to conceal or conceals the person’s identity by wearing a mask or disguise while engaging in a course of disorderly conduct, as defined in subsection a. of this section, with purpose to instill fear, hinder prosecution, or avoid apprehension is guilty of a disorderly persons offense.

                  d Disturbance at a public gathering. A person who acts with purpose to disrupt or cause a disturbance at a public gathering or event or who engages in behavior knowing that it will disrupt or cause a disturbance at a public gathering or event is guilty of a disorderly persons offense. For purposes of this subsection, a person who wears a mask or disguise solely for medical, religious, or expressive purposes shall not be deemed to have acted with purpose to instill fear, hinder prosecution, or avoid apprehension.

                  “Public” means affecting or likely to affect persons in a place to which the public or a substantial group has access; among the places included are highways, transport facilities, schools, prisons, apartment houses, places of business or amusement, or any neighborhood.

                  1. Thank you for pasting the actual text, (finally for once you cite a source LOL!) though, because it confirms every single subsection of N.J.S.A. 2C:33-2 is a non-criminal “petty disorderly persons” or “disorderly persons” offense—quietly burying your hilarious claim from further down thread that defiant trespass is a “felony.” It just goes to show you just make up stuff on the fly.

                    Even better, declaring “the requirements of B are obviously met” proves you didn’t bother checking case law: New Jersey courts struck down N.J.S.A. 2C:33-2(b) as unconstitutional under the First Amendment decades ago (State in the Interest of H.D.; State v. Rosenfeld) because the government cannot criminalize “offensive” speech unless it meets narrow Chaplinsky fighting words. Citing a dead, unconstitutional subsection as your slam dunk is peak armchair lawyering.

                    Beyond that, under New Jersey precedent (State v. Stampone; State v. Kane), “tumultuous behavior” in (a)(1) is strictly limited to violent, threatening, or physically dangerous conduct—which is why Rutgers Police standing right there filed zero charges—and guessing “it is possible some present met c” without any evidence of masking to instill fear or evade arrest is pure BS. Even under subsection (d), First Amendment narrowing principles and standard campus policing distinguish brief chanting followed by immediate, peaceful compliance when escorted out from an unlawful refusal to leave—which is why Rutgers removed the disruptors, Bovino finished his full two-hour speech, and even FIRE praised how Rutgers handled it.

                    Facts are not your friend in this argument John.

                2. Yes in NJ there are usually local violations in addition to state law violaitions – and a perfectly legitimate legal strategy is for lawyers to make a deal to plead to the local violation

                  Rutgers can also expell or suspend students in addition to or in leiu of the state prosecuting.

                  “New Jersey courts strictly apply the First Amendment”

                  I find it interesting – you practice in New Jersey ? Aparently courts apply the first amendment STRICTLY everwhere when left wing nuts protest.

                  But if you are conservative – all bets are off.

                  BTW – they engaged in Tresspass when as they were disruptive event organizers asked them to leave.

                  Further the standards for disorderly conduct are different when “in public” – as in on a street, and when attempting to disrupt an event.

                  If you are disrupting an event, rather than annoying people on the streets – fighting words are generally not necessary. Regardless calling someone a nazi or fascist AND physically confronting them is “fighting words”.

                  The words in the very first “fighting words” case were – “a fascist and a GD racketeer” Fascist was considered fighing words and the conviction upheld.

                  More recently just calling someone a fascist without confronting them is insufficient. but aggressively moving towards them while ranting, disrupting and calling them a fascist or Nazi is sufficient.

                  It is also defamation to call someone a nazi or fascist. Bovino is retired, While he probably under the circumstances is still a limited public figure,

                  there is still a case for defamation.

                  Personally I disagree with defamation law entirely – But I also believe in enforcing the laws we have – until they are changed.

                  “so that shouting political slogans at a government official”

                  Bovino is retired – he is not a government official. “without violence” Moving aggressively towards somone while moving wildly and insulting them is a threat of violence.

                  “refusing a police order to leave”

                  The evbent organizer asked them to leave. “

                  Mischaracterize all the conduc and you can make murder not meet the threshold for a crime.

                  “does not meet the criminal threshold for disorderly conduct.

                  Tresspass and disorderly conduct do not require the police to ask you to leave. They require those controlling the space to ask you to leave.

                  “Because the hecklers left the second Rutgers Police ordered them out,”

                  Not really, and not releivant – they did not leave when asked by the organizers.

                  “there was no violence”

                  Charging towards someone while load ranting and defamatory is the threat of violence and meets the threshold for fighting words.

                  ” no physical hazard” – of course there was,

                  This is not a capital offense – they are not being charged with assault – and that alone should make clear that you do not have to hit someone to be considered violent. You just have to appear to be a credible threat. Again this is a minor offense – one that firs time offenders can have struck from their records if they complete probation.

                  “and no defiant trespass.”

                  Defiant tresspass is a felony and hey arguably commited it – the police do not have to ask you to leave – those controling the space are sufficient.

                  Regadless there is also misdemeanor tresspass – which is a more serious offense than disorderly conduct.

                  ” You keep insisting there must have been hidden crimes”

                  Nope – right in plain sight.

                  Again this is not a serious offiense – but it is an offense. These protestors were behaving worse than 99% of J6 protestors.

                  1. John, seriously? You have the worst track record for getting things wrong. You just called defiant trespass a “felony” in New Jersey—a state that doesn’t even use the terms “felony” or “misdemeanor,” and where N.J.S.A. 2C:18-3(b) explicitly classifies defiant trespass as a petty disorderly persons offense, the lowest non-criminal infraction on the books. Maybe look up the actual statute before inventing imaginary felonies. I’m citing the actual law. You’re just making sh!t up.

                    Every other legal claim in your post is just as wrong. First, calling a political speaker a “fascist” or “Nazi” is not defamation—under settled Supreme Court precedent (Milkovich, Sullivan), political epithets are constitutionally protected rhetorical hyperbole, not provably false statements of fact. Second, citing Chaplinsky from 1942 ignores 80 years of Supreme Court rulings (Cohen v. California, Snyder v. Phelps) narrowing “fighting words” strictly to face-to-face insults provoking an immediate fistfight—which is why the Court hasn’t upheld a single fighting-words conviction since 1942.

                    Your reading comprehension also failed on the facts right in front of you. Nobody claimed Bovino is still on payroll—he was invited to speak on federal immigration policy because of his role as Border Patrol chief, and Rutgers Police (the actual legal authority on a state university campus) immediately escorted the disruptors out without filing a single assault, threat, or trespass charge because there was no physical threat. Shouting is not a crime John. It’s painfully clear you have absolutely no idea how the law works. Just shouting and being disruptive is NOT trespassing. The only time you can be trespassed is if the owner of the facility tells police the people causing the ruckus are no longer welcome or no longer have permission to remain.

                    Finally, claiming college students who chanted for two minutes and walked out peacefully “were behaving worse than 99% of J6 protestors”—when January 6 left over 140 police officers beaten and produced 1,500+ federal criminal convictions—shows you’ve completely lost touch with reality.

                3. Again you have no critical thinking skill.

                  We make illegal conduct we wish to prevent.

                  Your twisted interpretation of the NJ statute is essentially that disorderly conduct comes with a free pass grace period.

                  You say the police have to ask them to leave – and if the police never come ? Or do not ask ?

                  Can Republicans slip a hundred people into the gallery in congress and one at a time shout and disrupt democrats until they are asked to leave and then the next starts ?

                  A crime does not become a crime when you are asked to stop – though it may become more serious.

                  1. Notice that once again, John, you cite zero statutes, zero court rulings, and zero legal authority—just your personal gut feelings about how you wish the law worked.

                    Nobody invented a “free pass grace period.” Under actual New Jersey law (N.J.S.A. 2C:33-2), disorderly conduct requires fighting, threatening, violent, or tumultuous behavior, or creating a hazardous or physically dangerous condition—and under New Jersey Supreme Court and Appellate Division precedent (State v. Kane), courts strictly narrow speech-related arrests so brief political chanting in a public forum is not turned into a criminal prosecution.

                    In a public university hall open to the public, attendees start with lawful permission to be there. Under New Jersey’s defiant trespass statute (N.J.S.A. 2C:18-3(b)), it is refusing to leave after an authorized official revokes that permission that triggers an arrest—which is why Rutgers Police escorted the disruptors out immediately, they complied without resistance, and Bovino delivered his entire two-hour address.

                    Even your congressional gallery example proves my point: Capitol Police routinely escort shouting gallery protesters out of the chamber without criminal trials unless they resist or refuse to leave, whereas a coordinated 100-person relay designed to permanently shut down a session is a completely different scenario from a two-minute chant that didn’t even stop the event. Try reading the actual statute before lecturing anyone else on “critical thinking.”

                    It’s so obvious that you want the law to be what YOU want it to be instead of reading what it ACTUALLY says.

            2. You do not protect rigths with words, You do so with actions – There was no reason for Sherril to say ANYTHING – except DON’T or you will be punished.

              If the question is who uses more violent rhetoric – Democrats win hands down.

              This is a common prank of the left – pi$$ on other for doing the same thing as you are.

              While the No Kings and ICE protests were astroturf, they also had more violence than J6.

              Pretti can to ICE trying to arrest someone with a gun. No one came to the Capital with a gun – except under cover FBI agents.

              Food came at a police officer with a vehicle – no on tried to drive an SUV into the capital.

              Left wing nuts show up at protests with balistic sheilds or helmets or even have them delivered.

              Left wing nuts bring lasers to blind the police and forzen water bottles to throw at them – as well as bricks sometimes.

              They do not get tear gassed and then flee into waiting CP offers who go at them with bight sticks,

              Left wing nuts PLAN to be violent.

              The bring fireworks, they engage in arson. How many times have you tried to assassinate Trump ? Kavanaugh ?

              You assassinated Charlie Kirk for free speech. Bovino should have showed up at Rutgers with a Phanlanx of agents – Because those of you on the left are actually dangerous.

              Here you completely down play more than a dozen left wing nuts engaged in disruption.

              While this is not murder – it is an offense that MUST be punished.

              I am NOT a big fan of police or prosecutorial discretion – When it is not possible to prosecute a case because the evidence in just no there – fine. Though courts in My county are way to good at convicting people without evidence – I will tell those of you on the left – DO NOT TRY THING HERE.

              We had about 50 BLM protestors go down the street in front of the police station, the broke windows at the police station and lit a dumpster on fire. Not only the perpatrators but the leaders went to jail – for a long time.

              I do actually have a problem with the latter.

              Regardless dont come here.

              And they dont. 5 people showed up for the no kings protest – and we are the 200th largest city in the country.

              While my community overdoes it – if you want peaceful protests – arrest those who are not peaceful.

              First offenders spend the night in jail and get a fine and a slap on the wrist – We absolutely should minimize charges when the first amendment is involved – even when people have gone beyond what is allowed. We do not want to chill speech. We also want free speech to be peaceful.

              You rant that Trump said “fight” a bunch of times. – honestly I do not beleive you – you lie about these kinds of things so much.

              Regardless – you were OK with Chuck Schumer threating the Supreme court – or Maxine waters – or prety much every democrat there ever was.

              How long do you think we haave to listen to ANY democrat before hearing violent words – like Fight ?

              Biden talked about taking Trump behind the Gym and beating him up.

              As usual – when you say it – its not serious – except too often what follows is violence. But when those you dislike say something – the same words are incitement – evil.

              H311 Biden even told weird stories about going after people with Tire chains. The RIGHT answer was not to attack him for violent rhetoric – it was to send him to a memory care unit. Strange sureal badly distorted stories about the past are a huge red flag for demintia – Biden was doing that in 2015.

              Regardless – with you it is always – violence for me, but not for the – whether it is actual violence or just words.

              1. Every single factual claim in your rant is completely false, John. Still haven’t learned your lesson it seems.

                Claiming “no one came to the Capitol with a gun – except undercover FBI agents” is pure conspiracy fiction. Federal court convictions prove dozens of January 6 rioters carried firearms onto Capitol grounds (with over 3,000 rounds of ammunition and 11 Molotov cocktails seized), and a DOJ Inspector General report confirmed zero undercover FBI agents took part in the attack. Meanwhile, 140+ police officers were beaten with flagpoles, stun guns, and bear spray on January 6—whereas millions marched in No Kings protests across all 50 states with virtually zero violence.

                You also lied about Alex Pretti in Minneapolis. Multi-angle video verified by Reuters, BBC, CNN, and The New York Times proved Pretti—a VA ICU nurse with a legal carry permit—was holding a cell phone, not a gun, when Border Patrol agents tackled him, pulled his holstered gun from his waistband, and shot him ten times while he lay unarmed on the ground. Even the NRA and Gun Owners of America condemned that killing.

                On top of that, blaming millions of Democratic voters for the lone shooter who killed Charlie Kirk while erasing the right-wing extremists who assassinated Minnesota Democratic lawmakers and firebombed Gov. Josh Shapiro’s home is pure partisan blindness. Every major extremism study—including DOJ-funded research—shows right-wing violence accounts for the vast majority of deadly political attacks in America, and Donald Trump literally pardoned rioters convicted of violently beating police officers on January 6—after telling his crowd to “fight like hell” 20 times on the Ellipse.

                Don’t lecture anyone about “violent rhetoric” while defending pardons for cop-beaters and repeating debunked FBI conspiracy theories.

        2. Ummm….yes. Coverage of Jan 6 was documented from different sides of the building and behaviors differed. What the media chose to emphasize were the more outrageous and violent. It suited their bias and purpose. There were no arrests, charges, prosecutions, or convictions for the crime of insurrection.

        3. ” First, on January 6, rioters didn’t “leave when ordered by police.”

          Actually they did – watch the video – they were NOT ordered to leave until very late.

          They were ordered to stop while the areas ahead were cleared – and they did.

          With extremely few exceptions they peacefully did exactly what the CP directed them to do.

          “They smashed through windows” a few.

          Why was the pre-eminent free speech forumn in the world, why was “the peoples house” closed to the people ?

          Why were protestors denied he right to petition government ?

          None of the little violence on J6 would have occurred had Pelosxi accepted Trumps offer of the guard.

          But even less was needed. If the CP has setup a chute going into the Capital, and searched people or precluded them from taking bags in,

          Aloowed them in 40 – 50 at a time, allowed them to peacefully proced through and voice their concerns and leave.

          All violence would have been avoided.

          ” beat officers with flagpoles, fire extinguishers,”

          Officers who Tear gassed them first and then went at them with Bean Bag Cannons and blilly clubs –

          Watch the actual video – not only was the violence initiated by the CP – but as protestors fled the Tear gas, CP officers tarted attacking The protestors – not the other way arround.

          “forced the evacuation of Congress”

          Only in your head.

          All they wanted was to be heard – and they had that right and You left wing nuts thwarted it.

          You think it is OK to try to run down a law enforcement officer with your car, because you oppose the law they are enforcing.

          But you want to deny others the right to protest the actions of congress AT CONGRESS – the actual legitimate place to do so.

          “halted the constitutional certification of a presidential election for hours.”

          So what ? There is not actually a time limit on this. It took weeks to confirm Jefferson.

          ” Over 140 police officers were injured,”

          ROFL

          Of the 6 officers that actually claimed disabilities – atleast two are on video after they were purportedly injured beating unarmed people.

          Basically they lied about their injuries under oath.

          Nor does anyone care what idiots like you who had no problem with throwing fireworks at Law enforement during BBLM marches or at the Portland Courthouse.

          No one came to the capital with Frozen Water Bottles. With Guns, With lasers to blind police, with balistic sheilds – with molotov cocktails.

          All the things that we find Whenever the left engages in “peaceful protest”.

          ” and multiple people died in connection with the attack.”

          Yes, Two protestors – Alishi Babbit and Rose Boylan were murdered by the Capital p[olice.

          That is not your best argument

          “Second, saying “most of the protesters who were prosecuted were acting peacefully” is pure fiction.”

          Nope, it is absolutely true. I do not beleive there were more than 6 people prosecuted for acts of violence.

          Regardless it was few.

          “Nobody was prosecuted for standing peacefully outside on the National Mall.”

          Correct – and they were just as free to protest inside the peoples house.

          ” According to the U.S. Department of Justice, over 1,500 defendants were charged because they breached restricted Capitol grounds or broke inside the building—and over 600 of them were charged with assaulting, resisting, or impeding law enforcement, including more than 170 charged with using a deadly or dangerous weapon against police.”

          ROFL you can not breach space that is constitutionally required to be open to public.

          Congress may NOT hide from the public. The right to protest, to petition government REQUIRES that those we elected to government can not hide from people excercising Multiple first amendment rights.

          You are free to search people entering the capital

          You are free to impose reasonable time limits and limit numbers –
          Things that Congress has NEVER done to left wing protestors at the capital.

          You are not free to prevent them. Just as Republicans did not deny Kavanaugh protestors access to the Capital.

          “Third, Trump told the crowd to “fight like hell,””

          So waht – you say more incindiary things all the time.

          Schumer said much worse as people tried to break in to the supreme court.

          “sat in the White House watching the violence on TV for 187 minutes before telling them to go home”

          Not relevant – Trump provided the NG – Pelosi waited forever to allow them.

          The securit of the Capital is the job of Congress – the speaker of the house. Not the president.

          Trump has absolutely no authority over the capital.

          Regardless I do not recall any democrats telling Kavanaguh protestors to go home ?

          Is there ONE democrat that told the violent protestors at the Portland courthouse for 100 strait nights to Go Home

          Sorry X democrats have absolutely no problem with violence – unless it is by republicans.

          “then pardoned even the rioters convicted of violently beating police officers.”

          If you had followed the law instead of running a kangaroo court there would have been no pardons.

          There was more violence by protestors at the Kavanaugh protests. Very few were arrested – ultimately all charges were dropped.

          The same with those who Burned down St. Johns and busted down the WH security fence.

          Lots of violence, a few arrests, and no prosecutions.

          In fact in many cases these people got settlements from DC

          NYC has seen many violent protests in the past few years – protestors burned police cars, Asaulted police,

          And what is Mamdani doing – disbanding the riot police and replacing them with unarmed first amendment responders with no weapons, no power.

          If you are merely excercising your first amendment rights – there is no need for any police at all.

          Honestly I am surprised – there has been some pretty rough protests of Mamdani by left wing nuts.

          The next two years are going to be fun.

    2. BTW, could you address how many arrests were made of people who deliberately disrupted Bovino’s event? Violations of human rights should have legal consequences, right?

      If you don’t respond, I can respond for you.

      1. Diogenes, no arrests were needed because the disruptors complied with police dispersal orders. Some were removed.

        More importantly, calling college kids shouting at a guest speaker a “violation of human rights” completely cheapens what human rights actually are. The First Amendment protects Gregory Bovino from government censorship—not from citizens booing or yelling at him. Rutgers Police removed the disruptors, protected his right to speak, and Bovino returned to finish his entire two-hour event. The system worked exactly as it is supposed to.

        1. No arrests were made because we live in a world of liberals without consequences. That’s why these violations keep happening.

          Folks, X claims conservatives are always wrong and liberals are always right. If you follow his comments long enough, you’ll see the pattern. There is no nuance there, only sophistry. Consider that when you read his posts. He leaves out anything that doesn’t comport with the liberal narrative.

          1. Consider that when you read his posts.

            I don’t read his posts any more because he has proven over and over that every word out of his mouth is a lie, and in his commentary he makes no effort to comment in good faith. He is a robot programmed to say the opposite of Professor Turley no matter how ridiculous his position becomes under that stringent mandate.

                1. Disrupting a speaking engagement to the point that the speaker is removed for his own safety probably requires at least disorderly conduct charges and yet no arrests were made–as usual.

                  Look, dude, I’m not trying to convince you. I’m trying to keep you from deceiving others.

                  1. Diogenes,

                    Under N.J.S.A. 2C:33-2, disorderly conduct requires fighting, threats, violent or tumultuous behavior, creating a physically dangerous hazard, or unprotected “fighting words” meant to provoke an immediate brawl. Political chanting and heckling—however rude and disruptive—do not meet that criminal threshold, and New Jersey courts strictly enforce First Amendment limits on that statute.

                    Even more importantly, the second Rutgers Police ordered the disruptors to leave the room, they complied immediately. When people obey a lawful police order to exit, there is no defiant trespass and no refusal to disperse. Briefly stepping a speaker behind a curtain for two minutes while police clear a room is standard de-escalation protocol—which is why Bovino walked right back onstage and finished his entire two-hour event without a single person being harmed.

                    Tell me how am I being deceiving?

                    1. X needs a dictionary to understand what “tumultuous” means. “The adjective tumultuous means disruptive, troubled, or disorderly — like the tumultuous state of an unruly classroom after the teacher has stepped out for a few minutes.” https://www.vocabulary.com/dictionary/tumultuous

                      He also fails to comprehend that under the statute that he posted, “A person who acts with purpose to disrupt or cause a disturbance at a public gathering or event or who engages in behavior knowing that it will disrupt or cause a disturbance at a public gathering or event is guilty of a disorderly persons offense.”

                    2. You’re citing the wrong New Jersey statute to excuse shutting down a scheduled event, and you’re still dodging the core issue. First, bringing up N.J.S.A. 2C:33-2 (general disorderly conduct) is a complete red herring when N.J.S.A. 2C:33-8 (“Disrupting meetings and processions”) explicitly makes it a disorderly persons offense to intentionally obstruct or interfere with a lawful gathering—not to mention Rutgers’ own campus rules against shouting down speakers. The First Amendment protects counter-protest; it does not give anyone a right to drown out an invited speaker inside a reserved venue. Second, Bovino didn’t casually step “behind a curtain for two minutes”—multiple news reports confirm protesters screamed and cursed him off the stage until he had to leave the Douglass Student Center under police escort for 10 minutes before police cleared the room. Finally, pivoting to whether protesters left once police intervened completely ignores what you’ve left out from the beginning: Gov. Mikie Sherrill used the power of her office to scold college students for inviting Bovino (“giving him a platform is the wrong decision”) while refusing to condemn the mob that forced him offstage.

                  2. Anonymous,

                    “X needs a dictionary to understand what “tumultuous” means. “The adjective tumultuous means disruptive, troubled, or disorderly — like the tumultuous state of an unruly classroom after the teacher has stepped out for a few minutes.” https://www.vocabulary.com/dictionary/tumultuous

                    He also fails to comprehend that under the statute that he posted, “A person who acts with purpose to disrupt or cause a disturbance at a public gathering or event or who engages in behavior knowing that it will disrupt or cause a disturbance at a public gathering or event is guilty of a disorderly persons offense.”

                    LOL! Nope. Clearly you don’t understand. Let me clarify;

                    criminal law, courts interpret statutes using binding legal precedent, not Vocabulary.com—and the statutory quote you just pasted isn’t even from New Jersey law.

                    First, New Jersey’s actual statute for disrupting an event is N.J.S.A. 2C:33-8, which explicitly requires an act “tending to obstruct or interfere with it physically.” Simply shouting political slogans at a government official—without physical obstruction, violence, or property damage—does not satisfy the statute. 

                    Second, New Jersey appellate courts already settled this exact issue in State v. Kane (303 N.J. Super. 167). In Kane, the Appellate Division overturned a conviction under N.J.S.A. 2C:33-8 for a protester who shouted at a public hearing, ruling that under the First Amendment, brief shouting does not constitute “tumultuous” or criminal disruption when it doesn’t physically prevent the event from proceeding.

                    Third, under New Jersey criminal procedure, police do not arrest people for petty disorderly persons offenses when they immediately comply with a lawful order to leave the room. Rutgers Police ordered the hecklers out, they left without incident, and Bovino finished his entire two-hour speech. Copying a definition off Vocabulary.com doesn’t override the New Jersey Appellate Division. 

                    Those are the facts.

                    1. George. George. George. Sigh.

                      (how does it feel to copy cat your “sigh”?) 1.First of all, let’s walk you through your various citations. Did you know, X, that the “A” at the end of your citation means Annotated? Do you know what that means?

                      -Not to worry here, though, George, because in this instance, the annotated version helps your critics.

                      2. Your AI/Google Kane case citation is quite dated. You might want to update yourself with New Jersey’s P.L. 2025,c59 and N.J.S.2C:1-4 for more current information. You also need to understand/distinguish disorderly conduct and disorderly person petty offenses.

                      3; Further, you need to look up the definition of “public place” as applicable here under NJ law

                      You’re welcome, George. Glad I could help.

                2. Across both of your posts, you leave out the exact facts at the center of the dispute. First, while you point to Gov. Mikie Sherrill’s general pledge to protect constitutional rights, you omit her explicit declaration on November 16 that “giving him a platform is the wrong decision”—using the governor’s office to publicly scold a student group for inviting a speaker while saying nothing to condemn the protesters who disrupted the event. Second, you gloss over what actually happened in the room: protesters shouted Bovino down and forced him off the stage under police escort for 10 minutes before he could return. Third, contrary to your first post claiming Turley left out Rutgers’ response, his column explicitly noted that police cleared the room so Bovino could finish speaking, focusing instead on why an official rebuke from a sitting governor combined with an attempted heckler’s veto undermines campus free speech. Finally, regarding the 2025 Chicago litigation before Judge Sara Ellis, court records show that the claim about a fabricated rock-throwing pretext came from plaintiffs’ allegations and the judge’s credibility findings—not an admission by Bovino that he lied to cover up unprovoked tear gas.

                  1. Anonymous,

                    You aren’t even reading what I actually wrote—you’re just repeating the exact same talking points I already refuted.

                    First, I never omitted Gov. Sherrill’s criticism of inviting Bovino; I explicitly addressed it in every single post. Saying “giving him a platform is the wrong decision” while pledging state support to “protect the safety of everyone and the rights enshrined in our Constitution” and urging students to ask him tough questions is textbook counter-speech, not censorship. And notice you quietly dropped your defense of Jonathan Turley falsely claiming Sherrill “denounced… the university for allowing his views to be heard”—because she never did.

                    Second, I never “glossed over” Bovino stepping offstage while police cleared the room; I literally pointed out that Rutgers Police followed standard de-escalation protocol, removed the disruptors, and brought Bovino right back out to finish his full two-hour speech—which is why even FIRE praised Rutgers today for getting free speech right.

                    Third, you are flatly wrong about Judge Sara Ellis’s November 6, 2025 ruling (Chicago Headline Club v. Noem). That did not come merely from “plaintiffs’ allegations.” On Page 100 of her written opinion—and as reported by The New York Times and Associated Press—Judge Ellis explicitly cited Bovino’s sworn deposition testimony after he was confronted with body-camera video showing he launched tear gas beforeany rock was thrown, finding that Bovino admitted he “outright lied” about being struck by a rock prior to deploying tear gas.

                    If you’re going to accuse someone else of ignoring the primary records, try actually reading Page 100 of Judge Ellis’s opinion—and the comments sitting right above yours—first.

                    1. Telling someone to “read the primary records” while getting both the date and the exact wording of the court opinion wrong is a bold move. First, Judge Sara Ellis’s written opinion in Chicago Headline Club v. Noem was issued on November 20, 2025—not November 6—and the actual text quotes Bovino testifying in his November 4 deposition that he was “mistaken” about the sequence of the rock and the tear gas, not that he admitted he “outright lied.” More importantly, dragging in a 2025 Chicago use-of-force injunction still does nothing to excuse protesters shouting down a speaker at Rutgers in 2026. Second, calling a sitting governor’s official rebuke of a student club “textbook counter-speech” misses the entire First Amendment point: when the chief executive of New Jersey uses her office to tell college students that “giving him a platform is the wrong decision”—while saying nothing against the protesters who subsequently drove that speaker off the stage—she is throwing the weight of state authority behind the idea that controversial speakers shouldn’t be hosted in the first place. Finally, the fact that Rutgers Police eventually had to clear the room so Bovino could return only proves that disruptors succeeded in shutting down the event until law enforcement intervened.

            1. Nope. It’s literally speaking facts to the ignorant on the blog. You just don’t like the fact you can’t refute the facts.

          2. So typical. Police are known for their highly liberal bias. One would never see a cop walk to a seated protester and use a pepper spray designed for 20-30 foot standoff from a few inches directly into their eyes and nose and mouth. Those liberal cops would never aim a rubber bullet at the eye socket of a protester, pulping their eyeball and permanently blinding them.

              1. No, Diogenes. Resisting arrest has consequences everywhere. You just don’t like the fact when people do not get the kind of punishment YOU want instead of what the law requires.

          3. Diogenes, no arrests were made because the hecklers left immediately after police told them to clear out. Heckling or protesting at an event isn’t an arrestable offense unless you turn violent or refuse a lawful order to leave.

            The consequence for disrupting a private campus event is getting removed—which is exactly what happened. You just want the punishment to be harsher than the law actually allows.

            And I’ve never claimed conservatives are always wrong or liberals are always right, so don’t start making things up.

              1. To be clear, I have no intention of threatening AOC, but you and she would have no problem with others being threatened if it shut them up.

                1. Diogenes,

                  “To be clear, I have no intention of threatening AOC, but you and she would have no problem with others being threatened if it shut them up”

                  Why are you assuming things not in evidence? I absolutely have a problem with others being threatened if they shut them up. Heckling and threatening are two very different things mind you. Heckling is fine, you heckle and you get removed. That’s how it should be.

                  1. George says, “Why are you assuming things not in evidence?”

                    Stop trying to sound like a lawyer, old man X. You pick up words like “construct” (from someone else yesterday or the day before) or phrases like “not in evidence” and it makes us laugh.

                    No one is at deposition, hearing, or trial here, nor filing any pleading, X..

                    IN other words, X, there is NOTHING here ‘in evidence”

              2. Diogenes, I would be fine with that. Safety is important. Why would it be an issue if AOC were not removed for safety?

        2. If you were a disrupter – then you get arrested.

          Disrupting the peace is a crime.

          A relatively minor one – though more significant than a traffic ticket.

          Las enforcement exists to ensure consequences for the few who will not naturally follow the law.

          You aresst them charge them prosecute them convict them and likely fine them.

          The purpose is to increase the odds next time they stay inside the law.

          You also do so because if there is a next time – the consequences get worse – some jail time.

          Had you behaveed lawfully on J6 – first there would have been no violence.

          As I said – let protestors un – under more restrictive conditions that applied to Kavanaugh protestors.

          Then if there is violence – Arrest. charge prosecute and fine.

          NORMALLY if you shove a police officer – that is assault.

          But we explicitly do NOT do that at protests. When there is misconduct AND legitimate first amendment activities – we prosecute but we scale down pushing and shoving. We restrict serious charges to those who go far outside protest – either looting which has nothing to do with the first amendment

          Actual property damage, or serious violence to Law Enforcement that is actually doing their job.

          Had DOJ stuck to the same standards they used for left wing protests. A half a dozen people would have spent the night in jail.

          Less that 100 would have had disturbing the peace charges. One or two would have felony convictions.

          And no one would have been pardoned.

          But you overstepped.

          You went beyond reasonable law enforcement – you did that from the begining – you may not close the capital from the public while Congress conducts its business. PERIOD – that is what Tyrants do.

          You can play games with the rules of congress in the direct context of politics – though you should not.

          But when ordinary people become involved – you do not play games. Congress can act to enure its safety – but NOT by denying first amendment rights.

          Tht you do not like what protestors are saying – is irrelevant.

          The issue with the people who disrupted the bovino event is not that they spoke – it is that they disrupted. That is a crime, a minor one with small punishment.

          Had J6 protestors been allowed through congres and acted o disrupt rather than protest and petition govenrment – they too should have been arrested – removed and fined.

          But you did not allow that – that is tyranny.

          The Bovino protestors had the absolute right to protest – just not to disrupt the event.

          There are many legal ways to do that. Chose them.

          1. Comparing a two-minute college chant where the speaker finished his entire speech to a four-hour violent assault on the U.S. Capitol that hospitalized over 140 police officers is pure historical amnesia, John.

            Your claim that “you may not close the Capitol from the public while Congress conducts its business” is completely wrong on basic facts and constitutional law. The Capitol was closed to general public tours for ten months starting in March 2020 due to COVID-19, Joint Sessions counting electoral votes are always restricted to credentialed officials and ticketed guests, and Capitol Police have clear statutory authority (40 U.S.C. § 5104) to maintain security perimeters. Calling Joint Session security “tyranny” is absurd—and Kavanaugh protesters in 2018 didn’t smash through police barricades with riot shields, beat 140 officers with flagpoles and bear spray, or halt the transfer of power.

            On top of that, pretending January 6 defendants were prosecuted for minor “pushing and shoving” erases the over 600 defendants charged with assaulting or impeding officers—including more than 170 who used deadly weapons like metal pipes, stun guns, crutches, and chemical sprays—and ignores that federal prosecutors brought hundreds of felony charges during the 2020 riots as well.

            Best of all, you are still contradicting the exact New Jersey statute you pasted yourself: under N.J.S.A. 2C:1-4(b), disorderly conduct is not even a “crime” in New Jersey, and campus police routinely resolve brief heckling by escorting disruptors out of the hallwhen they comply immediately without violence. Rutgers removed the hecklers, Bovino delivered his full two-hour speech, and even FIRE praised how Rutgers handled it.

            John, you sure make up a lot of stuff.

    3. It’s pretty clear you didn’t actually read Jonathan Turley’s column before rushing to lecture everyone about it, because your entire “fact-check” collapses the second anyone checks the primary sources. First, you accuse Turley of leaving out that Rutgers Police cleared the room so Bovino could finish his speech—except Turley explicitly noted that exact fact in his piece. Second, you completely fabricate Gov. Mikie Sherrill’s remarks by paraphrasing her as saying she would protect Bovino’s right to speak; in reality, she never defended his right to speak, never condemned the mob that drove him offstage four minutes into his remarks, and instead used the governor’s office to publicly scold a student group by declaring that “giving him a platform is the wrong decision”. Even your legal trivia is sloppy: Judge Sara Ellis’s November 2025 perjury remark was about alleged threats and a rock-throwing claim, not “deploying tear gas,” and Rutgers Police cleared the room after protesters had already successfully shouted Bovino offstage. Accusing someone else of “spin” while inventing fake quotes and misreading the very article you’re attacking isn’t journalism; it’s embarrassing.

      1. Anonymous, nope.

        First, Gov. Mikie Sherrill’s quote is verified directly from her November 16, 2026 X post and Fox News, where she promised to protect constitutional rights hours before the event even occurred. She never criticized Rutgers University.

        Second, records from U.S. District Judge Sara Ellis’s ruling, reported by The New York Times and WTTW Chicago, show Bovino admitted he falsely claimed a rock hit him to cover up firing unprovoked tear gas. 

        Third, Turley buried Bovino’s brief removal and return to a single parenthetical while misrepresenting the governor’s position at length is the real spin.

        1. Your three points still misstate the primary records. First, nobody claimed Gov. Mikie Sherrill attacked Rutgers’ administration—her November 16 X post explicitly targeted the Rutgers College Republicans, declaring that “giving him a platform is the wrong decision” while saying nothing against the protesters who subsequently drove Bovino offstage. Second, U.S. District Judge Sara Ellis’s November 2025 ruling found Bovino’s testimony about alleged threats and a rock-throwing incident not credible, which came from plaintiffs’ allegations rather than an admission by Bovino that he fabricated a pretext for unprovoked tear gas. Third, Turley did not “bury” the resumption of the speech; his column explicitly addressed why a sitting governor scolding students over their choice of speaker—combined with protesters successfully halting the event until police cleared the room—matters under First Amendment norms.

          1. Anonymous,

            Your reply still misstates the primary records—and anyone who reads Jonathan Turley’s column and Judge Sara Ellis’s ruling can verify that in seconds.

            First, you claim “nobody claimed Gov. Mikie Sherrill attacked Rutgers’ administration.”Look at the third sentence of Jonathan Turley’s own column: “New Jersey Democratic Gov. Mikie Sherrill denounced the conservative students and the university for allowing his views to be heard on campus.” Turley literally claimed she denounced the university—when in reality her November 16 post pledged state coordination with Rutgers “to protect the safety of everyone and the rights enshrined in our Constitution”hours before any protesters showed up.

            Second, you have Judge Sara Ellis’s November 6, 2025 ruling completely backward. That finding did not come merely from “plaintiffs’ allegations.” In her 233-page written opinion (and as reported by The New York Times, Associated Press, and WTTW Chicago), Judge Ellis cited Bovino’s own sworn deposition admission—after being confronted with body-camera video showing he deployed tear gas in Little Village beforeany rock was thrown—in which Bovino admitted he “outright lied” about being hit by a rock prior to firing the tear gas.

            Third, in journalism and rhetoric, tucking a decisive outcome inside a brief parenthetical aside—rather than stating it in the main narrative—is a classic way of “burying” a factthat undercuts the author’s thesis. By relegating Bovino’s return to a passing seven-word parenthetical while repeatedly claiming in his main sentences that Bovino was “chased from a campus hall” and that higher education refuses “to allow others to hear from speakers with whom they disagree,” Turley structurally minimizes the central outcome of the night: Rutgers protected the event, police removed the disruptors, Bovino finished his full two-hour speech, and Gov. Sherrill exercised her own First Amendment right to criticize a public official while pledging to protect everyone’s constitutional rights

            1. Even when you check the exact documents, you are still dodging the central issue while getting key dates wrong. First, while Turley’s opening summary loosely grouped the university with the student club, Gov. Mikie Sherrill’s actual November 16 statement explicitly used the governor’s office to scold college students—declaring that “giving him a platform is the wrong decision”—while saying nothing against the protesters who subsequently forced Bovino offstage under police escort. Second, Judge Sara Ellis’s 233-page preliminary injunction opinion was filed on November 20, 2025(not November 6), and it centered on enforcing temporary restraining order limits on crowd-control weapons in Chicago—an entirely separate legal proceeding that has zero bearing on whether protesters and a sitting governor violated First Amendment norms at Rutgers. Third, noting in the text that police cleared the room so Bovino could return is not “hiding” the outcome; the entire point of the First Amendment critique is that shouting a speaker offstage and having a governor publicly rebuke student hosts for inviting him is a textbook attempt at a heckler’s veto—whether police eventually restore order afterward or not.

              1. “Judges do note get to decide if witnesses commit perjury – Jurors do.”

                Wrong. Only on very limited circumstances do juries decide. An ordinary jury trial, jurors don’t issue a “perjury verdict” at all—they just decide the underlying case, and perjury is only decided by a jury if a prosecutor later files a separate criminal perjury indictment.

                Under the Supreme Court’s unanimous ruling in United States v. Dunnigan, the sentencing judge—not the jury—makes an independent finding of whether a testifying defendant committed perjury and increases their prison sentence for obstruction of justice.

                Also, there’s Bench trials were judges do determine if someone committed perjury.

            2. Wow! NJow you are demanding control of the way Turley frames his arguments

              Sorry – you are full of Schiff.

              Attacking the way and argument is made rrather addressing the argument itself is a FALACY – it is an attempt to decieve – to avoid the issue.

              The central outcome is that protestors disrupted he event – that is lawless conduct.

              That the disruption merely delayed things is mitigation – it is NOT central.

              If there had been a mass shooting – would the central point be – “Its OK – no one was killed ” ?

              Where in gods name did you learn critical thinking ?

              Do you have to turn everything A$$ backwards and upside down ?

              Can you ever stop trying to spin the stupidest conduct.

              This is NOT the crime of the century – and Turley is not making it so.

              There are TWO significant issues – the rest is most tangential.

              It is irrelevant who the speaker was. It is irrelevant what the topic was.

              All your BS defamation nonsense is irrelevant.

              I do not care if the speaker was Tinker Bell from Trans R us debating the merist of kiddie diddling or Adolf Hitler.

              You allow the invited speaker to speak. If you have a problem – Protest – DO NOT DISRUPT

              You keep refering to J6 – J6’rs were denied their first amendment rights. Hd they reveived them – THEN all your claims might have merrit.

              Here protestors were given their rights and the went rougue – lawless, Not in a huge way, bu in a way that required arrest and removal and a fin – slightly more important than a traffic ticket.

              Regardless tjht is the first issue – protestors attempted to shout down the speaker.

              Not crime of the century. But acts that require consequences in the hope they will learn and not do that again.

              The next issue is Sherrill.

              HEr SOLE role is to say – the Law will be enforce – protest – but stay inside the law.

              Her editorial remarks were wrong, Again not an end of the world wrong. They were also patronizing.

              Sherrill is Governor – not Mommy.

              But then meybe left wing nuts need Gov. Mommy.

              1. John Say, it seems you didn’t learn your lesson. No surprise there. You always have everything backwards.

                Comparing two minutes of college chanting to a mass shooting—and claiming January 6 rioters were the ones denied First Amendment rights—is peak absurdity.

                Pointing out that Gregory Bovino finished his entire two-hour speech isn’t “spin”; it is the central fact that destroys Turley’s entire “censorship” narrative. You cannot claim a speaker was silenced when police promptly removed the hecklers and he delivered every word of his address—which is why even the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) praised Rutgers for handling it properly.

                Your claim that brief heckling “required arrest and removal and a fine” is also flatly wrong under New Jersey law. Under N.J.S.A. 2C:33-2 and State v. Kane, brief verbal chanting without violence, obstruction, or refusing a police order to leave is not a criminal arrest offense—so Rutgers Police escorted the disruptors out, they left peacefully, and the event resumed immediately.

                As for Gov. Sherrill, governors are elected leaders, not mute robots—they express opinions on public controversies every day (just like Donald Trump does hourly) while affirming their duty to protect both free speech and peaceful protest, which Sherrill explicitly did. Defending January 6 rioters who beat 140 police officers while demanding criminal arrests for students who chanted for two minutes and walked out peacefully tells everyone what your “First Amendment principles” are actually worth.

        2. The quote is irrelevant – the only things she had any business saying is keep protests peaceful and do not disrupt the event or you will be arrested.

          1. The quote isn’t “irrelevant”—it directly refutes your claim about what she said.

            Gov. Sherrill explicitly affirmed that New Jersey will protect the constitutional rights of both speakers and peaceful protesters, and Rutgers Police enforced the rules on the ground by immediately escorting the disruptors out so Bovino could finish his entire speech.

        3. OT

          I have done a fair amount of research into Norways GDP.

          There are multiple sources that document Norway’s GDP for the last decade of about 0.5% average.

          But there are more than support your claim that it is 1.% average over the last decade.

          I am still trying to understand the discrepancy – there are also a few that are producing significantly different results.

          I though the explanation might be the difference between Real and Nominal GDP – but though Norways Real and nominal GDP are different because … Inflation.

          Norway did not have the Huge US spike under Biden. I am not sure much of the rest of the world did. That was Unique to Trump spending way to much on Covid Stimulus and then Biden Outdoing him By a factor of almost 2. You can not dump that much money into the economy without a spike in inflation.

          Regardless thus far I have no explanation for the differences. Nor is this normal. I use the Fed for GDP projections – because they are both best at that – it is their job, and because few others do. But my Trust of FED data is only Slightly higher than other Government data.

          I use Trading Economics when I am looking to make comparisons between countries – they are non-partisan, they have not horse in he race, and though they often rely on data from the country there is the slightest hope that methodology across multiple countries is similar. It is one thing to use a contries data to compare to itself – generally even if the data is off – the trends are still correct.

          I am not prepared to “correct” anything I said about Norway. Only to state that your position on Norways past decade GDP is no less likely to be correct than mine.

          Moving to Singapore – While I can defend my claim that Singapore is a monoculture – contra your claim it is 75% Chinese and most of the rest are east asians.

          Still there is more of a narrow range of diversity than I had expected.

          I think you are inarguably wrong claiming it is very diverse – 75% chinese and nearly all east asian is not really diverse. At the same time I made an assumption and that assumption was incorrect, and Singapore is different with respect to diversity than I expected.

          I do not think that error makes the least difference to my argument – I think thre are more shared values of Singapoereans and those shared values belong to a larger portion of the population than Norway. Norway is also somewhat different than other Nordic Countries regarding Immigration. While it has taken in large numbers of immigrants in the 21st century – more than half are from Europe or the west. Norway has also tapered immigration down recently – but unlikely Denmark and Sweden it still has net positive immigration. It also has a lot of emmigration – Norwegians are leaving what you think is a socialist paradise – it isn’t.

          Not in massive numbers but almost as many as are immigrating.

          Norway also appears to have limited mid eastern immigration – pakistan and Iraq, as well as African – probably north africa. At the same time norway has only 3.6% islamic immigrants. Throughout Europe there has been a huge problem integrating islamic immigrants into European nations. Virtually all the rising anti-immigrant backlash in Europe which is more significant than the US is with respect to Muslims.

          Regardless, I am not correcting anything I have said, I do correct myself when I make errors.

          But I will correct with respect to claiming your 1.5% Norwegian GDP error is wrong – it is as plausible as 0.5%.

          1.5% is still not good. But it is better than 0.5% I am still checking on the last 5 years – while More sources support 1.5% as the aveage over the past 10 years, more sources support 0.5% over the past 5. Norway had a good year in 2021 and things have been flat since.

          I am also sticking to my argument that Singapore is a monoculture – it is heavily chinese and very heavily east asian – that is ethnic diversity, but the values of east asians are more strongly shared than values in even Norway – which is close to a monoculture.

          Regardless even though I am not backing away from the assertion that Singapore is a monoculture – because the important aspect of my argument is that nations with super majority near perfectly shared values have better government, less fraud and corruption, and less problems with Government programs even ones that should not be govenrment programs.

          But your view that Singapore is diverse – is defensible if you do not care that that diversity is close ethnic groups and has small impact on shared values.

          I value Diversity – I beleive it is NET positive. But that is NOT the same as All positive.

          One of my major points which you ignore is that what might work less badly than it ought in less diverse countries will likely fail in higher diversity countries like the US.

          Lower diversity REQUIRES a more libertarian approach to government – less shared values means a much narrower scope for law, and that what is done through Government works even worse.

          an excellent example is he recent Somali Fraud exposed in Minnesota.

          Ayaan Hirsi Ali who is somali and was muslim, has spoken on this. What we are seeing in he Somali community is not surprising – The somalis do not even view it as wrong. If Government is giving away money and all you have to do is create a dayccare on paper – they view it as practically a duty to do so.

          I would note that Libertarian values are NOT much different – except that Libertarians will not commit fraud to do so. Another feature of the Somali fraud is that most of the Money is being funneled back to Somalia. Somalis have a strong clan like social structure. Absent the fraud they resemble Jews in that even dispersed they are still tied to their claim wherever it has spread and back to Somalia.

          That social structure is a positive feature (not without negatives) of Somalis – but their lack of moral strictures against Fraud mean that Somali participation in any government benefit program needs highly scrutinized.

  15. Some years ago a man in Newark NJ by the name of Anthony Michael Imperiale Sr would have assured all sides were heard.

Leave a Reply

Res ipsa loquitur – The thing itself speaks