Baltimore Ravens cornerback Marlon Humphrey will not be playing this Sunday against the Carolina Panthers. He is not on the IL list, but on the FS list. Humphrey was flagged for a free speech; uttering four words about the crime problem in Baltimore. The cornerback quipped that the city is “best at making criminals.” While Ravens players were allowed to protest the United States at a London game, a player is not allowed to make a political comment on his personal podcast about the crime epidemic in his city. The day Humphrey was suspended, a 30-year-old woman was shot and killed near the M&T Bank Stadium. Players would be wise not to acknowledge the crime. However, they could presumably condemn the country.
Head Coach Jesse Minter announced that Humphrey had been suspended after the 10-year veteran spoke about crime in the city on his podcast, The Marlon Humphrey Show. He was asked what Baltimore is best at making. Notably, Humphrey first offered The Star-Spangled Banner and National Bohemian beer. He then added as a joke that the city is also “best at making criminals.”
Crime in Baltimore makes the city one of the most dangerous cities in the United States. Despite a drop in crime levels, it remains in the top five cities for violent crime.
Notably, Humphrey’s comment was not only tongue-in-cheek, but was not racist or prejudiced toward any group. It was not encouraging violence or other bad conduct. On the contrary, it implied criticism of those who continue to endanger others in the city.
Yet, Minter went public with the virtue-signaling suspension.
One can only wonder whether the suspension would have happened if the Ravens were not on a dismal five-game losing streak, ranked fourth in the AFC North, and 11th in the AFC playoff rankings.
We have previously discussed how players are not entitled to protest on the field in relation to the kneeling demonstrations. The same rule applies to other employees from Starbucks to Whole Foods. Employers are allowed to limit political expression and protests in the workplace.
Companies also may contractually subject employees to discipline for public comments or actions that bring controversy or disrepute to the company.
However, that does not make this right. I was critical of kneeling demonstrations during games, but I fully supported players’ right to voice their views outside the game.
The NFL is notorious for hypocrisy and inconsistency in punishing free speech. The Humphrey controversy is reminiscent of the Commanders hammering a coach for expressing a different view of January 6th.
The NFL has spent years virtue-signaling with statements on helmets and in the end zones. However, when players or coaches express opposing views, they are silenced or suspended.
The NBA is little better. LeBron James can show disrespect to the National Anthem, but Jaden Ivy was fired for expressing his opposition to Pride Month. Players are expected to engage in mandatory speech while remaining silent on their own views.
Nevertheless, Baltimore Mayor Brandon Scott rejected an apology by Humphrey: “While we acknowledge Marlon’s apology, a verbal apology is not enough.” He added that Baltimore is “a city full of young Black boys who look to the Ravens as a beacon of light in their lives.”
That is a curious objection since Humphrey was highlighting the failure of Scott to make the city safe to protect those lives given its top-five ranking on criminal violence.
The message is clear. Players are expected to wear and repeat approved views of the team. For the NFL, speech codes reflect whatever values are popular or approved by NFL commissioner Roger Goodell and team owners.
Now players are on notice that they cannot comment on blue cities being breeding grounds for crime. It is a curious sensitivity for a sport that often sounds like a gangbanger’s delight from shotgun and pistol formations.
The NFL and teams should get out of the speech regulation business and focus on football. While they are private companies and not directly subject to First Amendment limits, that does not mean that there are no free speech values at issue in these controversies.
The First Amendment is not the full or exclusive embodiment of free speech. It addresses just one of the dangers to free speech posed by government regulation. Many of us view free speech as a human right. Corporate censorship of social media clearly impacts free speech, and replacing Big Brother with a cadre of Little Brothers actually allows for far greater control of free expression.
Humphrey has now issued the perfunctory apology and is publicly covering himself with sackcloth and ashes. While Baltimore can no longer be called “best at making criminals,” the NFL certainly remains the best in coercing silence.
It is fitting that the team was named in reference to Edgar Allan Poe’s poem “The Raven.” Any effort by a player to express himself freely in Baltimore will be met by the same answer from Humphrey’s attempt at free speech: “Quoth the Raven[s], ‘Nevermore.’”
Jonathan Turley is a law professor and the New York Times best-selling author of “Rage and the Republic: The Unfinished Story of the American Revolution.
Jonathan’s point makes us think outside the box. The Indispensable Right is a human right broader than its application to the government in the First Amendment. How do we uphold that right among each of us in private life, one on one? Specific to today’s topic, the domain of contract law. At the bargaing table that puts the team owner’s goodwill interest in ticket sales up against the fair market sale value of the player’s human right of speech. Enter public policy into the bargaining. Are there norms that inform the speech right to be a nonbargainable issue? Maybe. Imagine a clause that gives an individual team owner the rite of jus primae noctis- a lord’s priviedge of “first night with the bride”. One answer is a consensus that the human right of free speech is more than lip service, and not subject to utility analysis at the bargaining table. There is not a consensus presently on speech in a player contract. Today’s topic bids us not lose sight of the human right itself.
It is unfortunate that the 1A doesn’t apply to private parties. I guess you would have to put that into contracts and employment agreements.
Enjoy the Holiday Marlon !
Marlon Humphrey Baltimore Ravens current contract value:
https://www.spotrac.com/nfl/player/_/id/21757/marlon-humphrey
https://overthecap.com/player/marlon-humphrey/5600
Excellent article by Professor Turley.
Agreed….excellent article by Turley.
Boy, so many mouths so little heart, I for one used to be a fan of professional football and to a small degree still in my heart root for my favorite team but I do not watch anymore. It started with cappernick and the kneeling BS I want to watch football not spoiled brats expressing ( which they are allowed to do) their political opinions you do you & I will in turn not watch.
Humphrey failed to adhere to the Party line: “There is no crime in Baltimore.” The same as Boris Pasternak’s Nobel Prize winning novel Dr. Zhivago: “There is no typhus in Moscow.”
More recently: “The border is secure”.
No, Humphrey realized he insulted his town. A town he represents as a team member. He’s under contract to conduct himself as such. He knew his remark went over the line.
His remark went out in public and we know how easy it is to put things out of context that the team will have to deal with and its tarnishing of its reputation.
That’s why he got suspended. His remark was not just a ‘joke’ it was also a reflection on the team.