Sacked: Raven’s Cornerback Suspended for Four Words on Baltimore’s Crime Problem

Baltimore Ravens cornerback Marlon Humphrey will not be playing this Sunday against the Carolina Panthers. He is not on the IL list, but on the FS list. Humphrey was flagged for a free speech; uttering four words about the crime problem in Baltimore. The cornerback quipped that the city is “best at making criminals.” While Ravens players were allowed to protest the United States at a London game, a player is not allowed to make a political comment on his personal podcast about the crime epidemic in his city. The day Humphrey was suspended, a 30-year-old woman was shot and killed near the M&T Bank Stadium. Players would be wise not to acknowledge the crime. However, they could presumably condemn the country.

Head Coach Jesse Minter announced that Humphrey had been suspended after the 10-year veteran spoke about crime in the city on his podcast, The Marlon Humphrey Show. He was asked what Baltimore is best at making. Notably, Humphrey first offered The Star-Spangled Banner and National Bohemian beer. He then added as a joke that the city is also “best at making criminals.”

Crime in Baltimore makes the city one of the most dangerous cities in the United States. Despite a drop in crime levels, it remains in the top five cities for violent crime.

Notably, Humphrey’s comment was not only tongue-in-cheek, but was not racist or prejudiced toward any group. It was not encouraging violence or other bad conduct. On the contrary, it implied criticism of those who continue to endanger others in the city.

Yet, Minter went public with the virtue-signaling suspension.

One can only wonder whether the suspension would have happened if the Ravens were not on a dismal five-game losing streak, ranked fourth in the AFC North, and 11th in the AFC playoff rankings.

We have previously discussed how players are not entitled to protest on the field in relation to the kneeling demonstrations. The same rule applies to other employees from Starbucks to Whole Foods. Employers are allowed to limit political expression and protests in the workplace.

Companies also may contractually subject employees to discipline for public comments or actions that bring controversy or disrepute to the company.

However, that does not make this right. I was critical of kneeling demonstrations during games, but I fully supported players’ right to voice their views outside the game. Conversely, many who supported the right of players to protest in during an actual game are now supporting the disciplinary action of a player for making a quip about crime on his own podcast.

The NFL is notorious for hypocrisy and inconsistency in punishing free speech. The Humphrey controversy is reminiscent of the Commanders hammering a coach for expressing a different view of January 6th.

The NFL has spent years virtue-signaling with statements on helmets and in the end zones. However, when players or coaches express opposing views, they are silenced or suspended.

The NBA is little better. LeBron James can show disrespect to the National Anthem, but Jaden Ivy was fired for expressing his opposition to Pride Month. Players are expected to engage in mandatory speech while remaining silent on their own views.

Nevertheless, Baltimore Mayor Brandon Scott rejected an apology by Humphrey: “While we acknowledge Marlon’s apology, a verbal apology is not enough.” He added that Baltimore is “a city full of young Black boys who look to the Ravens as a beacon of light in their lives.”

That is a curious objection since Humphrey was highlighting the failure of Scott to make the city safe to protect those lives given its top-five ranking on criminal violence.

The message is clear. Players are expected to wear and repeat approved views of the team. For the NFL, speech codes reflect whatever values are popular or approved by NFL commissioner Roger Goodell and team owners.

Now players are on notice that they cannot comment on blue cities being breeding grounds for crime. It is a curious sensitivity for a sport that often sounds like a gangbanger’s delight from shotgun and pistol formations.

The NFL and teams should get out of the speech regulation business and focus on football. While they are private companies and not directly subject to First Amendment limits, that does not mean that there are no free speech values at issue in these controversies.

The First Amendment is not the full or exclusive embodiment of free speech. It addresses just one of the dangers to free speech posed by government regulation. Many of us view free speech as a human right. Corporate censorship of social media clearly impacts free speech, and replacing Big Brother with a cadre of Little Brothers actually allows for far greater control of free expression.

Humphrey has now issued the perfunctory apology and is publicly covering himself with sackcloth and ashes. While Baltimore can no longer be called “best at making criminals,” the NFL certainly remains the best in coercing silence.

It is fitting that the team was named in reference to Edgar Allan Poe’s poem “The Raven.” Any effort by a player to express himself freely in Baltimore will be met by the same answer from Humphrey’s attempt at free speech: “Quoth the Raven[s], ‘Nevermore.’”

Jonathan Turley is a law professor and the New York Times best-selling author of “Rage and the Republic: The Unfinished Story of the American Revolution.

 

 

325 thoughts on “Sacked: Raven’s Cornerback Suspended for Four Words on Baltimore’s Crime Problem”

  1. Perhaps Baltimore isn’t truly one of the most dangerous cities. It’s pointed out that Baltimore is one of only a few “independent cities” in the entire country that isn’t a part of a county and can’t grow beyond its current established boundaries. As a result, unlike most other cities, it cannot dilute the per-capita crime rate with surrounding county populations. Saint Louis and East Saint Louis have similar problem with restricted geography,

    Mind too that most statistics on violent crime exclude the small, nearly rural cities. Apparently Gary, Indiana would be in the top 10, but it’s considered too small.

  2. He should ask to be traded immediately to a safer city!

    Likewise, I’ve avoided Baltimore since the drug-fueled “window washers” confront me at every red light starting about 10 years ago.

    In fact, I do my best to avoid Maryland altogether.

  3. The story in this article is an investigation into the financing of the stadium. It appears to be RICO. Baltimore city is a place unto itself. PT, imho. What is Baltimore known for? Criminals.

  4. Ain’t what goes into the mouth that defiles people. What comes out of their hearts shows who they are. Like wok not commiserating with the mom of Laken Riley. Not nothing. Putrid death is in there.

    1. I agree!!

      It takes a village.

      I recall hearing that somewhere before, but I can’t quite remember where, but I am glad you agree with the sentiment.

  5. The Democrats have started hiring investigators for their Oversight and Judiciary Committees. They have been inundated with hundreds of applications from people who were fired from Trump’s DOJ. These people know where the bodies are buried, and also know exactly what questions to ask of exactly which Trump lackeys.

    This will be so much fun. They should put the hearings on pay-per-view. The revenue would substantially reduce the national debt.

    Get your popcorn ready !!!!

      1. Exactly. Amazing how deeply rooted is Trump derangement syndrome such that people take pleasure in seeing the country go down the tubes.

      2. Merrick Garland didn’t “bury the bodies”. He created an entire structure from himself down to Timothy Thibaut-like agents who attacked and doxed political adversaries or those they said were insufficiently “Hate Trump”. They represented what we should know was a gestapo-like “justice” system.

        It was a cadre system, so no one knows where all the bodies were buried, and those who did are re-arming to make night of the long knifes look like a hollywood gala event.

      1. Big talker, anon. USA doesn’t exist anymore. Not even its name. It’s now America. At least the border states joined Mexico and have food. America produces nada. Plant a garden if possible and cut wood until its gone. Those gigantias are pretty big. Thank god there won’t be petrol. Good luck with the safe nuclear reactors, east coast.

        thanks for the fun

          1. Of course you fail to realize that the US imports more food that it exports. In 2025 food exports were $171 billion while imports were $212 billion.

            By comparison, in 2025 Brazil exported food worth $169.2 billion, and imported only $20.2 billion. So Brazil exports about the same amount of food, but imports only 10% of the amount imported by the US.

            The US does not produce enough food to sustain its population. It is completely dependent on imports to feed Americans.

            Brazil can produce enough food for its own people, and has a huge surplus to export and feed the American people.

            1. In fact, the US ranks as the third largest net importer of food behind China and Japan. The US is completely dependent on other countries to feed its people.

              Another interesting comparison would be New Zealand, a country of 5 million people that produces enough food to feed 40 million people. New Zealand exports over 80% of the food it produces.

                1. Actually, I think you are the one who needs to learn.

                  China: net food deficit $137.2 billion

                  Japan: net food deficit $48.6 billion

                  USA: net food deficit $41 billion

                  UK: net food deficit $35.4 billion

                  1. Yes the US imports more food than it exports – despite being the 3rd largest exporter of food in the world.

                    We import alot of food because we are a wealthy nation and americans like fresh fruit and vegatables in the winter.

                    My sons birthday is in February and he loves strawberries – so we get hm Strawberries in February.

                    Try doing that anywhere else in the world.

                    Americans produce more food than we need. We do not import more food than we export – because we are starving or because we do not produce enough.

                    We do so because other parts of the world produce what we want cheaper – or because we want foods that we do not produce – often exotic foods, or because we want strawberries in February.

                    Emporor Nero sent runners into the mountains for snow which was then flavored to make Snow Cones in the first century AD.

                    Romans were not starving.

                    Typical left wing nut unable to understand data or economics.

                    The US is the wealthiest country in the world.

                    There is not a nation with more than 20M people with a higher standard of living and very few with less people with a higher standard of living.

              1. Do you think Americans would starve if we didn’t import food?

                Only non-thinking people can believe that. We can feed the entire American population while we export food. We import not for calories, but for variety and to get seasonal foods all year round.

                1. I didn’t say anything at all about whether Americans would starve without importing food.

                  You are just playing your stupid games of drawing an inappropriate conclusion, setting up a straw man and then attacking the straw man about something that was never said. This is your typical tactic of argumentation. You never try to argue about what was said. You try to argue about something that was never said.

                  America may be able to feed its population at a basic level and still export food, but do you think that the American people would be happy if there was no coffee, no cocoa, no bananas, no sugar, no avocados, among many other things.

                  Only a non-thinking person would believe that.

                  1. “You are just playing your stupid games of drawing an inappropriate conclusion”

                    No that would be you.

                    The US is also a net importer of diamonds. Does that mean we are poor ?

                    You have produced data that means what the rest of us claim – not what you do – unless you are claiming it means nothing and just lobbed it out there for no reason.

                  2. The logic and stupidity of your reply are similar to GSX’s in your comment. I will quote from your previous posting.

                    “The US is completely dependent on other countries to feed its people.”

                    You infer that the US is **completely** dependent. Don’t you think that was a stupid statement, as the US agricultural industry produces more than enough calories to maintain a healthy population?

                    1. Obviously you have no understanding of basic economics. As Trump has repeatedly said, when we import more from other countries than we export, then we are being ripped off by those countries.

                      Only a non-thinker would believe otherwise.

                      You are obviously a commie, leftist antisemite.

                    2. You treat economics like a swap, and it makes you sound more like a GSX promo than a serious thinker. What is actually wrong with trading surplus corn for gold when we have plenty of one and a shortage of the other? Before you make another comment on trade, learn some basic monetary theory.

                    3. What a load of nonsensical lies.

                      What makes you think we are trading surplus corn for gold?

                      We are trading high quality surplus corn for poor, low quality food from third world countries that is often contaminated and carrying diseases. More often than not the imported food is contaminated with raw sewage. Mexico, and large parts of Central and South America do not have sewage treatment plants. They simply pump raw sewage onto millions of acres of farm land as irrigation. That is why we constantly hear about food contaminated with E. coli and hepatitis and cyclospora. Much of the imported food is contaminated with chemicals such as heavy metals, dioxin, pesticides, antibiotics and formaldehyde. In Asia, formaldehyde is routinely used to preserve food because they lack refrigeration. Seafood from China and Vietnam is often contaminated with formaldehyde.

                      In no way can it be said that we trade surplus corn for gold.

                      You are a simply lying. You are well known here as liar. Nothing you say can ever be believed. You have proven time and time again to be an unmitigated liar.

                      You are an unserious, non-thinking, inveterate and incorrigible LIAR !!!!!

                2. The deficit he refers to is entirely accounted for by wine, beer, distilled spirits, coffee, cocoa, and fish.

                  1. What exactly is your point??

                    The US imports more food than it exports by a significant margin. It is dependent on other countries to supply food that cannot be produced here, and that is demanded by the American people.

                    The US is not self-sufficient in the foods that Americans demand, and John Say’s assertion that the US is the world’s largest exporter of food is pointless and irrelevant, as are almost all of his comments here.

                    1. No wonder I’m so hungry all the time. I’m moving to the mountains of Tehran. The Marshall Plane didn’t help no body. Neither Truman doctrine. Wish I could get all the billions back, like stealing candy from a laughing baby’s mouth. And our hundreds of billions in foreign aid. 48.3 billion in foreign aid across 169 countries JUST THIS YEAR. i COULD EAT A LOT OF BEURGERS WITH A FEW HUNDRED BILLION. i KNOW iran IS PROVIDING FREE MEALS TO THE THE RELATIVES WHO DON’T EAT AT ALL no more FROM gaza.

                  2. x, thank you for hitting the key causes, but I think fresh fruits and vegetables need to be included as they represent one of the higher-dollar edible imports.

              2. “The US is completely dependent on other countries to feed its people.”

                False – we are dependent on other countries for strawberries in February.

                We are a very very wealthy country and even middle class american families can afford fruits and vegetables from elsewhere in the world out of season.

                Conversely we are the largest grain exporter in the world and we have BY FAR the highest agricultural yeilds in the world

                US Farmland has been declining while US agricultural output rises. And NO for the most part farms are not being converted to Suburbs – they are just laying fallow. The US farms only a small portion of the available US farm land. We could massively boost food production if we wanted to.

                While you are correct that the US is a net importer – by dollar value of Food – US Farmers feed just under 1/10th of the world while making up just over 4% of the world.

                “Another interesting comparison would be New Zealand, a country of 5 million people that produces enough food to feed 40 million people.”

                US Farmers feed over 560M people

            2. I think you are on to something here. Never did realize “America produces nada.” 1.7 billion of nada. That is a disgrace. I want me some of that nada, baby. Gladly pay you Tuesday for nada today.

              1. You’re an idiot. You can’t read labels nor do you know the difference between distributed by and produced in. Sheeple.

            3. “Of course you fail to realize that the US imports more food that it exports.”

              So what?

              The US is also a net exporter of countless other products, including some food products. It’s called the Law of Comparative Advantage (see Ricardo).

              Other than a mindless dig at JS, why did you make that completely irrelevant point?

          2. JS, do some legwork and actually look for those fields of food and check the labels on your foods. Distributed is NOT produced. You’re stuck in what once was. Yes, the United States did do that but read carefully. This is nothing but fraud America.

          3. JS, I’m not going to get into it with you but you need to follow the food. Grow and export top follar foods and import low quality, tainted, culls and god know what beef with glue in it, dye and water at the cheapest price and resell it at 25 dollars per pound. good god, we’re eating culls that were once swine food. This is crime central and you live in your own world. Undercover investigation needs doing following food from production, shipping and arrival. Again, Distributed is NOT produced nor manufactured. We basically eating pig food at 1000% mark up. Watermelon for a nickel in Mexico is 15 dollars US.

            I’m done after vomiting for 2 days after eating shrimp from Vietnam grown in a sewer.

            Happy Holidays

        1. Im dyin for a cheeseburger man. Iran, here we come. P.S., please don’t murder me. I’ll be good. I swear

      2. Discontent over an accumulation of measures.

        ==

        The population of British North America in 1763 was about 1.75 million and growing rapidly (that of the British Isles was about 11 million; there were about 300,000 in the British Caribbean). The agrarian order in the colonies was entirely different from that of any part of the British Isles. Yeoman farming was the mode. Perhaps 10% of the households had chattel slaves in residence; more would have had indentured servants in residence.

        ==

        The various colonies from the time they were on a secure footing had been on their own under the authority of their elected assemblies, though a number had Governors appointed by the Crown. You had mercantilist restrictions retarding the development of manufactures, attempts by parliament to impose new taxes on the colonies, restrictions on agricultural settlement to points west, &c. It looked to the colonists that the freedom of the colonists to manage their common affairs would be on a downward trajectory from that point forward.

        1. The main fear was the anti-slavery movement in Britain that threatened the use of slavery in America. The colonists saw their economic future depended on the expansion of slavery.

    1. They do ? Really ?

      You presume there are bodies burried.

      Regardless, you pulled this nonsense for 4 years with Biden as president and got nowhere.

      You have been investigatring Trump for 10 years.

      You can not even make a credible claim of malfeasance.

      They best you have been able to do is “he is rich – he must have done something bad”

      And no – outside the far left – and probably not even many of them, will be watching.

      1. “Bad to be rich” is antithetical, anti-American, wholly unconstitutional, and pure communism.

        It is long past time for the political extirpation of unproductive parasites and for the reimplementation of the “manifest tenor” of the original Constitution and Bill of Rights.

    2. Never did touch that louisky babe.

      I waited in my office for word from Rwanda, just so curious what might be happening over yonder.

  6. I have a suspicion the management is just truckling to Brandon Scott and actually didn’t give a rip about what Marlon Humphrey said.

  7. Please note that Brandon Scott has held patronage positions and elective public office since age 23 and has no background in any profession of any kind. His ‘crime control’ program is the usual social work slop and blame-the-weapons nonsense. He voted to cut the police department’s budget during his time on the city council.

    ==

    What the state legislature needs to arrange for is a joint police department, joint sheriff’s department, and joint social welfare inspectorate for the four counties around Baltimore. It also needs to assign individual schools in Baltimore City to incorporated philanthropies under stakeholder boards and leave to the Baltimore City government the operation of a voucher distribution program and the budget of a dedicated school fund set up to redeem the vouchers when presented by schools. It also needs to provide for the construction of day detention centers for incorrigibles no one else wants and for the state board of regents to hold annual examinations taken aby all youths in the state.

    1. x, you are quite knowledgeable regarding Baltimore city. Are you a resident? I see the reason for the canton language. After poking around in the financing of the M&T Bank stadium it looks inbred and costly to the residents of Baltimore city and taxes. Property taxes soared. Bonds sold with repayment from lottery? I’m not as smart as you are,x, but it does appear to be criminal, Mr. Humphries.

      So much for this…adieu. Tragedy overall.

  8. Professor Turley, since you’re on the subject, you should tell that nosy and presumptuous WordPress to STOP interdicting and censoring speech on this blog.

  9. He added that Baltimore is “a city full of young Black boys who look to the Ravens as a beacon of light in their lives.”

    ==

    Which is not something they should do. Their lodestar should be improving their trade skills. Spectator sports are an avocation to which you might devote a few hours a week. Earning a living is crucial.

  10. September 17, 1787

    _______________________

    “Well, Doctor, what have we got, a republic or a monarchy?”

    – Elizabeth Willing Powel

    _____________________________

    “A republic, if you can keep it.”

    – Ben Franklin

  11. The Kaepernick years were insufferable to the point of painful, and not just the ignorant virtue signaling from a privileged brat – but the capitulating to an ignorant child on the part of people that absolutely knew better. So it goes for modern liberals.

    They reset their brains weekly as though that will save them from what they perceive to be irrelevancy, and it terrifies them. The modern dnc are happy to prey on their insecurity. Adding in the free speech concerns – what does it matter if even now, people will not actually discuss it? And the boomers are some of the worst offenders. If they can’t be what they consider to be rock ‘n roll, they might as well not exist. Sad and pathetic.

    Real wisdom is rapidly becoming a superpower. Pray that they don’t Mao all of us of a different persuasion over the age 45, because they certainly want to.

  12. Some years ago, Fr. Paul Shaughnessy, SJ, penned an article on ‘sociological corruption’, which he defined as an institutional state in which an organization is unable to right itself from its own efforts and requires the imposition of a trusteeship of some sort. He was thinking of religious orders. In his understanding, an organizations active components might be categorized thus: 5% scoundrels, 5% heroes, 90% people keeping their head down trying to do their jobs. In a healthy organization, the heroes set the overall tone and the scoundrels are sanctioned, contained, expelled. In a corrupt organization, the concerns of organizational leadership are about appearances and avoiding publicity which exposes issues. It often seems as if with every retiring cohort, the portion of institutional leadership with integrity is diminished and the portion composed of hollow men (and scoundrels) increases.

    ==

    The black population has a shame culture and this exacerbates the problem. For 32 out of the last 40 years, blacks have held the mayor’s chair in Baltimore (and have been a majority on the city council for much of that time). They’ve held the position of state’s attorney for 36 of the last 44 years. You call attention to the city’s rot over four decades, the issue isn’t that the city is rotting. The issue is that you’ve ‘disrespected’ the black political elite. Improved performance is pretty much impossible with that mentality.

    1. “[Racial separation] [is necessary], and [though difficult] must be effected by colonization… The enterprise is a difficult one, but ‘where there is a will there is a way’; and what colonization needs most is a hearty will… Let us be brought to believe it is morally right, and at the same time [not against] our interest, to transfer the African to his native clime, and we shall find a way to do it.”

      – Abraham Lincoln, Springfield, Illinois, June 26, 1857 (Adapted)

    2. “STUP”Some years ago, Fr. Paul Shaughnessy, SJ, penned an article on ‘sociological corruption’,”

      And you know that verbatim huh? No source, makes you a liar.

    3. The current population uses humiliation, degradation, ridicule, insult, Clinton’s deplorables as example, as a weapon to destroy souls and spirit leaving opponents demoralized. my humble opinion

  13. Quoth the Founders,

    “No person shall be…deprived of…property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.”

    And what they meant was,

    “[Private property is] that dominion which one man claims and exercises over the external things of the world, in exclusion of every other individual.”

    – James Madison

    Only the OWNERS of PRIVATE PROPERTY may CLAIM and EXERCISE DOMINION.

    The “Baltimore Ravens” football team is private property, and only the owners may “claim and exercise” dominion over that football team, including the imposition of a “moral turpitude” clause.

Leave a Reply