Italian Court Convicts Three Google Executives For The Posting of a School Beating Video

We have been following the growing threat to free speech in the West through blasphemy and hate crime prosecutions, here. Now, Italian prosecutors in Milan have criminally charged four Google employees after a video was posted by students showing the bullying of an autistic child in late 2006.

Ultimately, the police identified the student responsible for uploading the video and she was sentenced to 10 months community service. However, they proceeded to go after Google for the fact that the video appeared on Google Video.

The defendants are David Drummond, Arvind Desikan, Peter Fleischer and George Reyes who were charged with criminal defamation and a failure to comply with the Italian privacy code. In an outrageous breach of free speech rights, a judge in Milan convicted David Drummond, Peter Fleischer and George Reyes for failure to comply with the Italian privacy code.

It is another example of how the West is steadily criminalizing speech with as little as a whimper of objection. Countries like Italy are allowing defamation, privacy, and blasphemy claims to chip away at a core foundation of Western Civilization. This Court showed precious little concern over the implications of its ruling for the Internet specifically and free speech in general. The ruling is another wake-up call for civil libertarians that we need an international campaign in support of free speech to address these insidious trends.

For the full story, click here.

25 Responses to “Italian Court Convicts Three Google Executives For The Posting of a School Beating Video”


  1. 1 Anonymously Yours 1, February 28, 2010 at 8:14 am

    Isn’t there something that if you sue them it has to be in the location of the corporation. Contract of adhesion or some such nonsense.

  2. 2 nobama 1, February 28, 2010 at 9:16 am

    Obama Signs One-Year Extension of Patriot Act – on a Saturday Night Of Course

    With no debate – or media attention – President Barack Obama has signed an extension for what many considered the most controversial aspects of the USA PATRIOT Act. The provisions, set to expire Sunday without the signature of Obama, include extensions to allow:

    -1) “roving” wiretaps, permitting surveillance on multiple phones and e-mail addresses.

    -2) court-approved seizures of records and property in anti-terrorism operations.

    -3) surveillance on “lone-wolf” foreign nationals, who may not be part of a recognized terrorist group.

  3. 3 Canadian Eh 1, February 28, 2010 at 9:57 am

    It seems odd to me that the Italian courts chose to convict Google employess, who played no part in the crime that was committed, yet there is no mention of what happened to the students who were causing pain & suffering to the Autistic boy in the video.
    Police were able to identify, and charge the female student who uploaded the video, but again, no mention of the punishment to the bullies. If anything, justice systems everywhere should be looking to these sick videos as evidence to convict actual criminals.

  4. 5 Bdaman 1, February 28, 2010 at 11:06 am

    “If you have something that you don’t want anyone to know, maybe you shouldn’t be doing it in the first place,” Schmidt said. “But if you really need that kind of privacy, the reality is that search engines, including Google, do retain this information for some time. And it’s important, for example, that we are all subject to the United States Patriot Act. It is possible that information could be made available to the authorities.”

    My jaw hit the floor when I heard that. Now they are just coming right out and telling us that they will turn our data over to the feds. Based on what I know about how much information they have, it’s really some scary stuff.
    In addition to information collected from searches, Google also saves sent and received e-mails, including e-mail drafts, attachments and chat messages through its Gmail system.
    What these big search engines have is the eye in the sky. It’s like the totalitarian dictator’s dream. They know everything and with a couple of mouse clicks, they could find every single person in the country who observes Passover or attends a Catholic or Baptist church or who buys ammo.

    Here is just one example how google is adapting to online searches and working with a government authority.

  5. 7 Bdaman 1, February 28, 2010 at 11:09 am

    Bdaman 1, February 28, 2010 at 11:05 am

    And it’s important, for example, that we are all subject to the United States Patriot Act.

    nobama 1, February 28, 2010 at 9:15 am

    Obama Signs Extension of Patriot Act – on a Saturday Night Of Course

    With no debate – or media attention – President Barack Obama has signed an extension for what many considered the most controversial aspects of the USA PATRIOT Act. The provisions, set to expire Sunday without the signature of Obama, include extensions to allow:

    -1) “roving” wiretaps, permitting surveillance on multiple phones and e-mail addresses.

    -2) court-approved seizures of records and property in anti-terrorism operations.

    -3) surveillance on “lone-wolf” foreign nationals, who may not be part of a recognized terrorist group.

  6. 8 Bdaman 1, February 28, 2010 at 11:14 am

    Alan Davidson, the company’s chief lobbyist, stopped by the White House in March. Vint Cerf had an appointment with US CTO Aneesh Chopra in September. Google CEO Eric Schmidt was at the White House four times in 2009, and though he managed two visits with the POTUS, both were in larger groups than the Gates get-together. (Google’s former top policy wonk, Andrew McLaughlin, is now a key player in the executive branch tech team.)

  7. 9 Byron 1, February 28, 2010 at 1:11 pm

    Bdaman:

    the Patriot Act, as I have said from the beginning, is the child to the future American Gestapo. It needs to be done away with and quickly.

    It doesn’t surprise me though that Google would be okay with it, look at the politics of their 3 key people and you will have your answer.

    And speaking of politics, ever wonder why California is broke? Ahnold took economic advice from Warren Buffet. He may be good at making money for himself but he apparently doesn’t know crapola about making money for other people. Take a look at his true economic views. He ain’t no capitalist.

  8. 10 Duh 1, February 28, 2010 at 1:22 pm

    I don’t consider anything that involves third parties to be “private”. I have not established any trust relationship with Google (at least not when searching the internet).

    If I want privacy, I have face-to-face communications in a area that I have a right to control. If I need to do it via the internet, I use a program like X-IM.

  9. 11 Bdaman 1, February 28, 2010 at 5:23 pm

    Google hits back over algorithm dispute

    By Maija Palmer in London, Richard Waters in San Francisco and Nikki Tait in Brussels

    Published: February 25 2010 12:47 | Last updated: February 26 2010 01:20

    http://www.ft.com/cms/s/2/2e16bd92-2209-11df-98dd-00144feab49a.html

  10. 12 Bdaman 1, February 28, 2010 at 5:24 pm

    P.S. try not to depend on Google for all your searches. Put your inquiry into the other ones like Bing, Yahoo, or the latest one IXquick. IXquick offers you more privacy.

    Search Googlegate in google and see the results. Then do it in the other search engines. 47,900 in google,

    47,900 in google,
    75,299,853 matching results in IXquick
    1-10 of 76,900,000 results in Bing

    Climategate

    2,410,000 for climategate in Google
    51,600,000 results in Bing
    53,099,332 matching results in IXquick

    This is just two examples and this is why Google is under fire right now trying to defend. Plus they are in bed with this administration.

  11. 13 Bdaman 1, February 28, 2010 at 5:28 pm

    I will also advise you that if you have Google Toolbar installed it’s best to uninstall it. Just go to Google.com then search, but take Google completely out of your system. It is also wise to delete your history 4 or 5 times a day.

  12. 14 Anonymously Yours 1, February 28, 2010 at 5:31 pm

    Bdaman,

    How can you say that its safe if it also searches google too?

  13. 15 Bdaman 1, February 28, 2010 at 5:32 pm

    Because with the toolbar you have a google product installed in your system.

  14. 16 Bdaman 1, February 28, 2010 at 5:33 pm

    I suggest no toolbars installed from anyone of the providers.

  15. 17 Blouise 1, February 28, 2010 at 11:31 pm

    Based on cultural history, Europe has a much stricter view on the “right” to privacy than we, based on our own cultural history, do. There was an interesting article on this situation in Sunday’s New York Times.

    I suspect Google is learning some cultural lessons as it expands into other nations.

  16. 18 Dave 1, March 1, 2010 at 12:26 pm

    @Byron You ask “ever wonder why California is broke?” No need to wonder; that’s easy; “SATSQ”. It’s called “Proposition 13″ … one part of it has been enabling the minority Republicans to block every single ressponsible budget for the past many years. If it doesn’t cut taxes for the wealthy (including corporations) … they don’t let it happen. If it does anything to address the services which most (non-wealthy) Californians expect the state to provide (good schools and parks being just two examples) … they don’t let it happen.

    Not that Ahnult has been good, but the blame isn’t only his. Remember that the recall election which shoved him into power was triggered by (a) fiscal problems caused by Enron and other Texas “Friends Of W” looting $50 billion or so out of the state, with federal acquiescence (if not assistance); (b) media (and republican) unrest about some minor vehicle taxes that addressed a different segment of the deficit.

  17. 19 Dave 1, March 1, 2010 at 12:46 pm

    @Eh

    You observe: “It seems odd to me that the Italian courts chose to convict Google employess, who played no part in the crime that was committed, yet there is no mention of what happened to the students who were causing pain & suffering to the Autistic boy in the video.”

    Seconded!! And in fact, it was those students who falsely claimed that they had the rights to post the video, and caused all the trouble (because they didn’t).

    Why should they be getting off with less punishment than the folk who just removed the video when asked to do so?

    It seems like a small town letting off “the locals” (despite them being guilty), while punishing the folk from “out of town” (despite them being innocent). Also, it seems if being from the US is a negative which outweighs most other factors. That also seemed to be true in the case of the American student convicted of murdering Meredith Kercher.

    One must also observe the media filter/bias in effect in such cases. (Some from Itailian press, and perhaps Berlosconi; Some from US coverage; some from others.) It’s possible that coverage of the real miscreants has been censored for various reasons. Even if they were minors though, I would have expected any competent journalist would have mentioned what happened to them (if not their names). Perhaps I date myself by expecting competent journalism, though it’s a huge concession to accept that “good” journalism is rare…

  18. 20 PeterMyakky 1, May 5, 2010 at 10:02 pm

    Alas, fair-haired boy, you’ve managed to induce your (best) friend who is a maiden conquered in delight with you.
    Too bad, you’re either not keen or you not in a million years really intended to. Here are a index of things you should NOT do to your consociate because you wouldn’t thirst for her to tumble in love.
    No person of the more evident things like bringing her flowers or singing her a serenade. No. Lease out me contain the more underhanded thoughts.
    Don’t refresh the hair of her face. Not that you haven’t watched too myriad saccharine comedies already! Not representing the love of entire lot in the creation, brambles the mane of her face. Or take out a snowflake. After crying out loud, keep your hands crazy her effrontery!
    Because the confronting is effing sensitive, the tenderness of your deliver will-power evaporate her heart! And for crying in piercing! This is an direct instructions: girl stands surface on a voluble lifetime, young man talks to damsel, brushes a wisp of her fraction crazy her grasp the nettle, filly feels *kilig* and then they kiss. Your fianc‚e most artistically confidante has memorized this rules in her precede already. Don’t womanize the component! Don’t sell to curb her script while crossing the street. Not that holding hands is icy for the benefit of couples, but when you start holding to your aid after your alternative other when she crosses the circle, she strength engage used to it! Additional, afternoon teen dramas overdo this party, when two people start to hold hands when they cross the lane, that’s when they start to comprise feelings toward each other. I don’t know the really of that. BUT to be on the out of harm’s way side, just don’t do it!
    Don’t denote her in the mesial of the night.

  19. 21 yandeks-771 1, May 9, 2010 at 1:58 pm

    Just switched the movie “Mist”. A rare cloudy shit. Make no mistake – young recruits through the fog came in 1941. Slang, Ponte, cheeky Bazaar, light hazing. In general, our realities. Been caught guys in trouble, fired at them, the commander was killed. Then he killed a couple of them, until they began to understand what is happening.
    OK, I sit at the screen and talk – “Yes SHOOT YOU, CHE in this complex,” of course not have to. I did not shoot at people, the war was not, therefore, to give advice to others in such a case would be foolish.

    BUT I am a computer http://ngadla.ru/ – games about the war I know that NOT ENEMY unleashes, the prisoner must not talk, the more believe in him and believed the enemy is not that war is BAD.
    And in the movie at least two have already died because of these errors. Well, nonsense, unacceptable. if boys yard, you should know that, if home is on computer games should understand it. And show us some hybrids incomprehensible.

    In general, turbidity and shit, especially when the reasoning went, not so easy to kill a man. ” Any fool could understand that is not easy, especially deep philosophy here is no.
    PS. The Germans behaved in a village almost disguised NKVD-Schnick.

  20. 22 Sammy 1, January 5, 2011 at 3:50 am

    To sponsor a child to participate in the Will County Boxing Afterschool Program call 877-806-4611

    Boxing and martial arts have a purpose beyond winning fights, students at Lincoln School in Joliet learned recently.

    Dr. Jennifer Bertino-Tarrant, Will County Regional Superintendent of Schools, said the Will County Boxing Association, which runs a gym in Joliet, “offers a positive after-school program for students. I would eventually like to see all our students involved in some after- or before-school program. I believe it is important for children to have some connection with outside community organizations,” Bertino-Tarrant said.

    Physical skills can translate into a way of life as practice helps develop character and focus, members of the Boxing Association told sixth- through 12th-graders at Lincoln, the Regional Safe School for students facing expulsion or multiple suspensions.

    Through traing and practice, “you find a way to fix yourself,” said Joseph Awinongya, a professional boxer who trains youth boxers. “Be a champion in school,” he said. “Stay in school because life is not easy. You guys may think life is easy, but life is very, very hard,” he said.

    “We’re here to talk to you all about character,” said Derek Drey, 21, who plans to attend Joliet Junior College. “Boxing shapes your body,” Drey said. “You guys can change your life.”

    The Boxing Association is performing a service for the young people of Joliet’s East Side, said Tony Pena, a member of the Joliet Elementary District 86 School Board.

    Pena said Awinongya “has done something nobody else has done. Life is like boxing,” he said. “It’s a one-on-one situation/ Boxing will help you look in the mirror, build your self-esteem,” he said. “We’re trying to give you the opportunity to change, to do something good for yourself.”

    “The gym is a great place to vent,” said coach Delwin C. Fields, adding that physical activity is an “outlet to turn my energy positive.” Positive energy can overcome the mistakes of the past, Fields said. “All I see is winners out here.”

    Octavius Webb, 20, said he is turning his life around after going off-track as a college student on a football scholarship. “Boxing keeps me focused on making a better life. It helps me with my anger,” said Webb, who attends Joliet Junior College.

    Sixteen-year-old Adrian Palacios is successfully blending sports and study, Awinongya said. Palacios, a student at Joliet Catholic Academy, expects to attend college on a wrestling scholarship. He doesn’t neglect his schoolwork, Awinongya said. “Adrian has to get A’s and B’s.”

    But boxing isn’t a boys-only sport, as Fields demonstrated by sparring with Jaecee Burkart, 17. Fields said Jaecee, who is home-schooled, is one of the best. “A woman can be a boxer,” he said.

    The gym also offers a martial arts program, which emphasizes mental strength as much as physical prowess, instructor Quinton McCottrell said. He said martial arts originated among Chinese monks, who, for a while, were the only ones allowed to practice those skills because they could be trusted not to use them for personal gain.

    “It builds character, but it’s also a culture,” McCottrell said. “Martial arts build discipline, character and focus.”

  21. 23 CellPhones 1, March 6, 2011 at 9:40 am

    Review Of The Latest Nokia T5000

    It appears to be Nokia’s response to all the other smartphones as they issued Nokia T5000 by other wireless telephone companies. Though Nokia T5000 is the biggest constructor of wireless cell telephones round the world, it has let the smartphone market fall to its competitors for example Apple, HTC and RIM. It has thus assessed a renewal inside the smartphone market by issuing the Nokia N8 Mini, which is mighty but accessible and directed at the mean client, much like Nokia N8 Mini competition. It furthermore permits buyers for full world broad web browsing of genuine world broad web sheets under feel control. The Nokia N8 Mini GPS amenities that are connected with A-GPS receivers are conceived to lead buyers under a pinpoint accuracy.

    The Nokia N8 Mini is bearing arms with a Symbian running method that jogs in the assortment of an ARM 11 680 MHz processor which basically has turned more heads to it. Furthermore, its gigantic inside recollection of Nokia N8 Mini. All the chatting liked in time spans of storage. This is labeled in supplement as a greatest Mail device which contains with an exact toiling environment. Call worth was in supplement good, if not somewhat up to Nokia’s own high benchmarks, with a very small muffling of the user’s voice. And if you perform sense the want to perceive to tunes, the furnished earphones are somewhat good, but if you have a 2.5mm headset adaptor you could likely use your own headphones.

    Providing a subtle film the N8?s camera negotiations with a film worth of 12MP, Nokia Copy has become the fearsome characteristic for more digital camera dealers and manufacturers throughout the world. When equipped with a Xenon wink with automated red-eye deletion, face tracking/detection, autofocus and a Focal distance of 5.9mm the Nokia N8 negotiations in exact Nokia style. Furthermore, it is studded with the dignified conceived Nokia OVI contestant who has the flawless proficiency to propel its users over the Nokia T5000 demonstration of satisfaction. The Dolby Digital Plus enclose noise are facets that only boost the Nokia Copys performance.

    http://cellphones.abouts.us/review-of-the-latest-nokia-t5000/

  22. 24 savap 1, January 22, 2012 at 3:26 am

    Have you ever wondered how you can watch Man on a Ledge Online movies for free today? Using the technology that any of us have confronted ever day; you’ll be able to watch to find out tips on how to watch movies online. What does this implies in your case? Well this means that you no longer need to panic about buying DVD rentals or buying expensive DVD movies to raise your movie collection. This article will reveal how to watch movies online.

    After you see this article you’ll realize the best way for you and your family to use your entertainment money for other pursuits; like gas or popcorn.

    You’ll find services online that will allow that you watch free movies online.

    the best way to stream movies,may i stream movies, nevertheless you may find it hard to pick one up that delivers you top quality and is also safe for the computer. There are various scams in existence plus you’ve got to be careful everything you upload to your computer; otherwise you will finish up damaging it. You want to make sure that you discover a service that may give you relief, while still lowering costs and supplies the good quality of entertainment that you’ve got grown to like.

    Here i will discuss two solutions to watch movies online…of course one is destined to be superior to the other.

    1. Online Man on a Ledge Online Streaming Video Sites

    You have possibly read about YouTube; well they will be just like it. Nevertheless the only difference is simply because are likely to provide full length movies on them. These movies can vary from very low quality which has been (bootlegged) with a home cam corder. Most likely the excellence of the picture is going to be sketchy and will be hard to watch the full movie and like the process. This should be the last resort to watch movies for free; should you not just enjoy watching an unhealthy quality movie

    2. Legally Watch Man on a Ledge Online And Download Movies Online

    There are sites online that can assist you to stream movies while only paying a smaller one time fee. It is possible to receive use of over one million movies and observe them legally; plus the image quality is going to be great.

    You can also burn the films onto a CD and will have accessibility to music also. The web is now such a popular place and then you can use it to view every one of the movies you want for just a small 1 time price. The purchaser support that you’re going to receive out of this services are great. The most beneficial advantage about this services are that you will not need to purchase any new hardware or spyware; you are able to literally choose the services tonight.

    While you are wanting to watch movies for free; usually do not take a step illegal when you can set out to watch the many movies you wish by simply visiting the site below. One can learn the best way to stream movies today. Looking not really a computer genius you will discover this particular service user friendly. So settle back and get a film tonight!

  23. 25 Teseponge 1, February 9, 2012 at 4:35 am

    The point of a hedge is to make money payment clients regardless of customer base direction. Hedge funds determination buy and hold stocks, they will trade in short, as entirely as swallow and tattle on options. These unusual funds differ from most stock funds, which adhere to the get and hold concept. In these minute funds, an investor wish reward a exhibition rate as well as a administration damages it performs well. These investments, which comprise foundations, college endowments, and put out to pasture funds are merit billions of dollars. Beyond 1 % of economic doctrine assets are comprised of these funds, with thoroughgoing assets roughly $2 trillion. Many strapping funds judge this type of capital because of their possible upside during a bull market.

    These funds can offer some tidy returns dependent on how the they are positioned in the market and how persuasive the sell is performing. If investments of this well-disposed are leveraged easily, the investor resolve realize weight qualified to returns as opposed to other funds. With this in intellect, at one must also be wary of the dormant losses that can be suffered when the reprehensible investment carrier is being leveraged. In short, take your obsolescent and do your analyse when choosing any fount of fund. The boom in 2008 seemed to incite big old-age pension funds into administer hedge subsidize investing. A lot of people were torment by the 2008 blast, lending to more hedge fund investing to recuperate some losses. The rules of hedge reserve investing give birth to evolve into stricter since 2008, limiting participation to accredited investors, weening revealed the humiliated, unofficial investor.

    A hedge stock managers uses the unvaried message at to all investors. Instead of exemplar, you did not essential to be a hedge repository manager to rank some opportunities in Japan after the tsunami. However, the thin size of these ilk of funds lends to consequential research and investment opportunities that an run-of-the-mill investor does not have. Even so, on the having said that note, these burly funds can sometimes decide it difficult to find a pad to inaugurate billions of dollars. When this kindly of reserve takes a disposal in an fair play, it changes the captaincy of the market. An lone investor can profit from studying a hedge stake, being au fait of where the well-heeled is going. A lot of well-to-do investors over high returns by mirroring a successful hedge funds investment strategy. How convenient that word is depends on the party investors savvy. Again, hedge funds move the market.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s




Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Turley Tweets

Click here to follow the blog on Twitter.

SELECTED AS TOP LEGAL OPINION BLOG (2011)

SELECTED AS TOP LEGAL THEORY AND LAW PROFESSOR BLOG (2008)

blawg100_2008_winner9349c7

Winner — Top Opinion Writer By Aspen Institute and The Week Magazine for Best Single-Issue Advocacy (Civil Liberties)

Categories

Archives


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 618 other followers