First Circuit Refuses to Remove Judge Gertner For Alleged Bias

gertnerThe United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit has refused to disqualify US District Judge Nancy Gertner from a lawsuit against the Boston Police Department for a wrongful conviction in three rapes. Counsel for the department charged with her showing “deep-seated favoritism and antagonism” in comments made in court.

In an Oct. 8th hearing, Gertner questioned whether plans to deport the plaintiff, Ulysses Rodriguez Charles, to his native Trinidad soon were “somehow related” to his lawsuit. The government was trying to deport him before his scheduled trial in April. That seems to be a perfectly legitimate question under the circumstances, but the city’s attorney, John P. Roache, cried foul at the judge voicing “wholly unfounded suspicions” that there might be collusion. He demanded her recusal and she refused.

For the full story, click here.

4 thoughts on “First Circuit Refuses to Remove Judge Gertner For Alleged Bias”

  1. Patty C:

    Good for Judge Nancy. I like her already. Thanks for the excellent research–as always.

  2. Reminds me of the 60s song “My momma told me! you better shop around”

    In this case the defense is tryin’ to follow mamma’s advice to “shop around” for the best judge…

  3. That’s the way to get on the Judge’s good side. A specious motion to recuse because she asked what I’m sure everybody in the courtroom was thinking. I offer my prediction now–behind every immense plaintiff’s verdict is a dumb or arrogant (or both, they seemingly go hand in hand) defense lawyer. This verdict looks to be a doozie.

Comments are closed.