Justice Delayed; Justice Denied: Man Settles with County After Being Held Seven Months After Molestation Charges Were Disproven

gavel2Grant County in Washington has settled an exceptionally disturbing case involving false allegations of child abuse, allegedly ineffective representation by a public defender (later disbarred), and the holding of an innocent man for seven months after allegations were disproved. The $250,000 with Felipe Vargas seems quite modest given the abuse that he encountered in Grant County, which seems to maintain a criminal justice system on a model from the Thirteenth Century.

On November 5, 2003, Vargas went to dinner with his girlfriend. When they returned they found a note saying that her girls had been taken to the police station. When they arrived, Vargas was arrested for child molestation in first degree, child molestation in the second degree and indecent liberties.

The charges were completely false. The girls soon admitted that they did like Vargas staying at the house and a friend suggested by the allegations to get rid of him.
One of the girls immediately told the true story to her mother and to the police. Nevertheless, the police continued hold Vargas for seven months after the recantation. He was represented by three lawyers, including Thomas Earl, who was later disbarred. Earl never met with Vargas outside of the courtroom. Earl was handling 550 criminal cases a year and reportedly spending 30 minutes with each client. The county knew of the problem but did nothing.

Vargas is continuing his lawsuit against Earl.

Earl collected a huge amount of money by taking so many cases under the public defender system of the county.

According to one article:

During 18 years as a public defender, Earl’s annual pay for court-appointed work climbed from $40,000 to $80,000 to $120,000 to $156,000 to a large slice of $500,000 — the amount of his public-defense contract. How large a slice isn’t public record, but two years ago Earl retained about $255,000 after paying other public defenders, according to financial figures provided by those attorneys.

Earl does not appear to be the only problem here. The County officials clearly did not seem bothered by the arrangement, even after the allegations were raised against Earl. In my view, this settlement is too small by at least half. It was a settlement with the insurance company and will have reduced by attorney fees to offer a fraction of the damage caused to Vargas.

This is not the only such allegation against Earl. Consider the following account:

In the early 1990s, Thomas J. Earl worked as a fixed-fee contract attorney for indigent clients in Grant County. Tom was no paragon of virtue as the case of Patrick Hurley will attest.

In 1993, Hurley was arrested and charged with a sex crime. On the first day of his trial, Hurley sat at the defense table with Tom Earl, his court-appointed public defender.

“There was nothing but a blank piece of paper at the table,” Hurley recalled. When he demanded an explanation for the seeming lack of pre-trial preparation, Tom took Hurley aside and told him he could avoid prison time if he could come up with $10,000.

Outraged, Hurley asked the court to appoint another attorney to defend him. The judge refused. Hurley pleaded not guilty, he was convicted and sentenced to 9-1/2 years in prison.

Three years later, Hurley’s new lawyer appealed. The victim admitted she had fabricated the allegations, the conviction was vacated, and Hurley was released. The high cost of Hurley’s free defense? Three years in prison.

These fixed fee contracts often go to the lowest bidders and can create some perverse incentives. It is the legal version of the recent case of a sheriff being able to pocket any money that he saves from the food allowance of prisoners.

5 thoughts on “Justice Delayed; Justice Denied: Man Settles with County After Being Held Seven Months After Molestation Charges Were Disproven”

  1. A federal jury awarded Felipe Vargas $3,012,500 in compensatory and punitive damages against his former public defender, Tom Earl, for the seven months he spent in the Grant County Jail after the alleged victims recanted within hours of his arrest. Mr. Earl was accused of violating Mr. Vargas’ civil rights by not rendering him effective assistance of counsel. Mr. Vargas was represented by Garth Dano and his partner George Ahren.

    There were points in the trial where individual jury members literally gasped out loud as they heard testimony about the criminal justice system in Grant County. At conclusion of the trial Judge Quackenbush told the panel that their verdict should sent a clear message to the Grant County Commissioners, Judges, and Prosecutors that their criminal justice system is broken.

    The odd thing about is the verdict is that Mr. Vargas only asked for $500,600 in compensatory damages and the jury awarded $762,500. Then in the punitive damages phase of the trial, Mr. Vargas asked for $1,500,000 to “send a message to Grant County.” The jury returned only after 15 minutes of deliberating with a $2,250,000 “message.”

  2. I personally know of two cases where someone spent time in prison for crimes of this type that they never committed. In one case, the defendant was on the verge of a diabetic collapse when the investigator got him to “sign something” that turned out to be a full confession. He agreed to a plea rather than risk a trial. The problem is as much prosecutors who want to win a conviction regardless of the facts as it is incompetent and uncaring defense counsel.

  3. FFLEO,

    That is very well said. I cannot imagine what false imprisonment would do to a person. Further, the idea that any person is willing to let the innocent languish in prison is repugnant.

  4. …and people wonder why our jails and prisons are so overcrowded with the poor people of society who cannot afford their own legal counsel.

    Victims of these types of injustices never receive full compensation and attorneys who are involved deserve much more than financial punishment and disbarment. Society can never repay a victim’s mental and physical suffering resulting from years of false imprisonment.

Comments are closed.