Submitted by Elaine Magliaro, Guest Blogger
I’m sure most Americans are aware that former Alaska governor Sarah Palin has been on a bus tour along the east coast of the United States. What is the purpose of her tour?
Only Palin knows for sure. She did, however, provide people with her reason for taking this tour of historical places on her Sarah PAC website.
It’s interesting when (for the 100th time) reporters shout out, “Why are you traveling to historical sites? What are you trying to accomplish?” I repeat my answer, “It’s so important for Americans to learn about our past so we can clearly see our way forward in challenging times; so, we’re bringing attention to our great nation’s foundation.” When that answer isn’t what the reporters want to hear, we’ve asked them if they’ve ever visited these sites like the National Archives, Gettysburg, etc. When they confirm that they haven’t, it’s good to say, “Well, there you go. You’ll learn a lot about America today.” (They usually don’t want to hear that either!)
Last Thursday, Palin stopped in Boston for a tour of three Revolutionary War sites. She said she was “getting goose bumps’’ from all the history she was glimpsing in Boston. She added, “You’ve got to know a lot about our past in order to know how to proceed successfully into the future.’’ And thanks to Palin we’re learning history anew as she provides reporters with her version of American historical events when she speaks to them on stops along her way.
After visiting the Old North Church in Boston’s North End, she hailed Paul Revere and what he did on his “famous ride.” Here is how Palin described that event: …he who warned the British that they weren’t gonna be takin’ away our arms, uh, by ringin’ those bells and, um, makin’ sure as he’s ridin’ his horse through town to send those warning shots and bells that we’re gonna be secure and we were gonna be free. And we we’re gonna be armed.
Got that? Revere warned the British! That’s news to me. And to think that I thought for decades that Paul Revere had been riding around on his horse warning certain American colonists about the British. The archivist at the Cambridge Public Library doesn’t know what really happened that fateful night either. The archivist wrote the following in a blog post: “Paul Revere and his famous midnight ride is so much a part of the collective memory of the American Revolution that it is often forgotten that Revere was just one of several men and one woman who alerted the Minutemen of the impending British advancement.”
I guess the History Channel got it wrong too. Following is what I found on the channel’s website. It includes no mention of bells.
By 1775, tensions between the American colonies and the British government had approached the breaking point, especially in Massachusetts, where Patriot leaders formed a shadow revolutionary government and trained militias to prepare for armed conflict with the British troops occupying Boston. In the spring of 1775, General Thomas Gage, the British governor of Massachusetts, received instructions from Great Britain to seize all stores of weapons and gunpowder accessible to the American insurgents. On April 18, he ordered British troops to march against Concord and Lexington.
The Boston Patriots had been preparing for such a British military action for some time, and, upon learning of the British plan, Revere and Dawes set off across the Massachusetts countryside. They took separate routes in case one of them was captured: Dawes left the city via the Boston Neck peninsula and Revere crossed the Charles River to Charlestown by boat. As the two couriers made their way, Patriots in Charlestown waited for a signal from Boston informing them of the British troop movement. As previously agreed, one lantern would be hung in the steeple of Boston’s Old North Church, the highest point in the city, if the British were marching out of the city by Boston Neck, and two lanterns would be hung if they were crossing the Charles River to Cambridge. Two lanterns were hung, and the armed Patriots set out for Lexington and Concord accordingly. Along the way, Revere and Dawes roused hundreds of Minutemen, who armed themselves and set out to oppose the British.
Tim Murphy—snarking little fellow—wrote this in an article at Mother Jones: “We don’t mean to nitpick—we just think that if you launch a major publicity tour on the subject of great moments in American history, it might make sense to brush up on the details first. We can only imagine how Palin might try to spin this: ‘Listen my children and you shall hear, of the midnight ride of Paul Revere. If the story doesn’t sound like what you read on Wikipedia, you know who to blame: the elite liberal media.’”
It’s just not fair! Tim Murphy and other members of the “lamestream media” love to make fun of Palin. I don’t understand why. She’s only trying to give us the scoop on what really happened in our country’s past—just like Representative Michelle Bachmann of Minnesota. Thank heavens we have women so well versed in American history that they can enlighten us today with their knowledge.
SOURCES
Palin hits town to pick her spots, take her shots (Boston Globe)
Just passing through (Boston Globe)
Reminding Reporters, too, of America’s Foundations (Sarah PAC)
Sarah Palin’s Reasons for Bus Tour Misguided (Yahoo)
Paul Revere’s Ride, Reimagined by Sarah Palin (Mother Jones)
The Other Paul Revere: William Dawes’ Midnight Ride through Cambridge (The Cambridge Room)
Revere and Dawes warn of British attack (History.com)
@Elaine, sorry that was legalese. What I mean by that is that your interpretations are not the only reasonable interpretations of Palin’s spoken words. If they were, then she would have made clear mistakes. There are other interpretations of Palin’s words that are both reasonably plausible and also result in an historically true statement. The existence of these alternate interpretations means that Palin cannot be said to be wrong as a matter of fact. She can only be “wrong” as a matter of opinion and then the reasonableness of that opinion becomes an issue and a function of how plausible your interpretations of her words are. In any event, it is bad form to hurl acccusations of mistake or lies on a matter of personal opinion, especially a shaky opinion.
(In my opinion, your interpretation of the warning to the British is unreasonable, but your interpretation of the personally ringing/shooting is on firmer ground.)
K, do you have something substantive to say? Perhaps a well-reasoned argument on a position you hold? I know that is a lot to ask, but you might try it–defend your position with something more than irrelevant ad hominem or red herring comments.
kderosa,
“Your favored interpretations are not compelled…”
I can’t say I understand what you mean by that.
“The wolverines would have eaten him by now.”
Mike S.,
That’s a terrible thing to say about wolverines.
Even they have limits in their willingness to scavenge.
They’ve read the studies that show eating Koch puppets (in the literal sense) can lead to stomach cancer. All the extra methane and benzine. Garbage in, garbage out.
@OS, so you’re backing down in favor of playing the race card on a tangential point?
Elaine, the difference between Herman Cain and Sarah Palin is that Cain is highly intelligent. We may disagree with him on political and philosophical matters, but the guy is bright and knows how to use the English language effectively.
If Cain gets the nomination to run for President, there are folks in the deep south who are gong to have some serious cognitive and political dissonance of their own.
@Elaine,
“That is exactly what Sarah Palin should have done.”
If she had made a mistake, she should have. But her statements contain no clear mistakes. Your favored interpretations are not compelled and most likely not the most probable.
In contrast, at least 2 (Revere warned British and bells rung) of your 4 mistakes that I’ve identified are clearly mistakes. And we both now agree that admitting clear mistakse wre mistakes is the right thing to do. And, yet, you haven’t admitted anything.
Elaine, when I read the chin driblets of our trolls, I get ‘cognitive distress.’
kderosa
1, June 14, 2011 at 2:04 pm
“@Elaine, let me show you how it is done. That was a careless mistake on my part. Done and done.”
That is exactly what Sarah Palin should have done. I think she would have earned some respect by doing that. Herman Cain admitted on television that he didn’t know what the Palestinian Right of Return was.
**********
Herman Cain Admits To Hannity He Didn’t Know What ‘Right Of Return’ Meant
http://www.mediaite.com/tv/herman-cain-admits-to-hannity-he-didnt-know-what-right-of-return-meant/
Excerpt:
Herman Cain may have just slyly avoided his own “what newspapers do you read?” moment. After getting caught flat-footed on Fox News Sunday over his position on the Palestinian right of return, Cain returned to the network Monday and got a second chance to answer the question. Cain made no excuses: “I didn’t understand the right of return,” he told Sean Hannity, though sticking by his original answer.
@Elaine, let me show you how it is done. That was a careless mistake on my part. Done and done.
The major industry right now in rural america is meth….kd, must be the top entrepreneurial manufacture……..
Otteray,
Shame on you and your political “cognitive dissidence!” Well, at least kderosa didn’t accuse you of having cognitive dissonance.
😉
@OS, I made that assumption based on your comments, don’t blame me. I am shocked that any kind of scientist, especially a phD level one, can have such cognitive dissidence re politics and still be able to perform their day job competently. But, apparently you are the exception. Good for you.
I won’t bothering quibbling with 1-3. Your understanding of 4 is probably off if you think anything I have stated qualifies as a “lie” or “making stuff up” I have offered up some opinions, but those are not necessarily lies of making stuff up.
Why don’t you use that PhD sized-brain of yours and identify my “lies” and the “stuff that I made up” like most entry-level forensic scientists are more than capable of doing with ease? That seems easier than trying to draft cross-exam questions, but you go ahead and do that as well if you think you can do it as well as you claim you can.
k, the lawyers here understood what I meant by getting you on cross examination, even though you apparently missed the point.
I will try to explain in as simple terms as possible. If you were on cross examination,
1. You would HAVE to answer the questions.
2. You would be required to tell the truth.
3. You would not be allowed to evade or give non-responsive answers to the questions.
4. Did I mention you would not be allowed to lie or make up stuff as you go along as you do here?
k, you lose.
I am a forensic scientist with a Ph.D. and am board certified in my specialty. I am President and CEO of a company that consults with law enforcement. attorneys, judges and government agencies. I have been doing this for four decades. Next dumb question or assumption?
Buddha and AY,
My guess is Boise, or Colorado City. There is a correlation between hunting ability and intelligence. The wolverines would have eaten him by now.
AY, that’s funny ’cause you thought it then you wrote it. High fives.
OS,
Fritz would have spent more than a minute excoriating him, while he blew smoke in his face. Ellis would have simply thrown him out after 30 seconds and then explained his reasons after he was gone. Neither suffered fools gladly, Ellis though, was relatively gentler.
Buddha,
I do not think that even people in rural Michigan are that stupid.
AY,
I’m guessing some place in rural Michigan.