Submitted by Gene Howington, Guest Blogger
UPDATED: Newton’s Third Law of Motion is commonly expressed by the phrase “for every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction”. The action in question is the Occupy Wall Street Movement. The reaction in question is fear.
Huffington Post obtained a copy of a memo being sent by high-powered Washington lobbying firm Clark, Lytle, Geduldig, Cranford to one of its major Wall Street clients over Thanksgiving. Previously unnamed, it has been revealed that the major Wall Street client in question is the American Bankers Association. The four page memo was first revealed by MSNBC’s Chris Hayes, host of the show “Up with Chris Hayes“. The first two paragraphs of the memo are indicative of the mood and probably sets the tone for what many in the lobbying industry are having to admit as an inconvenient truth. Namely the truth that the OWS Movement is gaining traction for their cause and doing so in such a way that politicians are eventually going to be forced to put on the appearance of action in bringing the criminals on Wall Street to justice if not actually bring them to justice. The fear on behalf of the lobbyists and their Wall Street clients is palpable.
The first two paragraphs of the Thanksgiving Memo read as follows:
Leading Democratic party strategists have begun to openly discuss the benefits of embracing the growing and increasingly organized Occupy Wall Street (OWS) movement to prevent Republican gains in Congress and the White House next year. We have seen this process of adopting extreme positions and movements to increase base voter turnout, including in the 2005-2006 immigration debate. This would mean more than just short-term discomfort for Wall Street firms. If vilifying the leading companies of this sector is allowed to become an unchallenged centerpiece of a coordinated Democratic campaign, it has the potential to have very long-lasting political, policy and financial impacts on the companies in the center of the bullseye.
It shouldn’t be surprising that the Democratic party or even President Obama’s re-election team would campaign against Wall Street in this cycle. However the bigger concern should be that Republicans will no longer defend Wall Street companies — and might start running against them too.
While phrased in partisan terms, the memo is possibly indicative of not just fear on behalf of Wall Street and their K Street cohorts, but rather recognizes that the problems created by not bringing to justice those who wrecked our domestic economy and nearly wrecked the global economy with their unfettered greed and massive systemic fraud is growing to ultra-partisan proportions. Consider the words of Joshua Stephens, a participant in OWS New York City, who said “The danger is not whether or not politicians will defend these institutions. My fear wouldn’t be that. My fear would be that the politicians that come to their aid will be increasingly irrelevant…That’s the real threat and that’s where things are going.” OWS is serving as a wake-up call for both Wall Street and Washington. A wake-up call that this memo acknowledges presents a real and serious problem for both the corporate bankers and the politicians that have been protecting them from prosecution and doing their political bidding in helping dismantle the regulations around the banking industry. A call for justice that transcends party affiliation and loyalty to the point that the bankers responsible may actually have to face trial with the possibility of prison sentences. A call for justice that may force politicians to take steps to break up the big banks to prevent the myth and the lie of “too big to fail” from being used in the future as an excuse by corporatists to raid our nation’s tax coffers thus making society pay for the risks of their private failures all while the banks reaping massive record private profits in the process. A call for justice that might mean the return of regulation to the banking industry and a return of regulation with teeth.
Perhaps even more telling that the 1% are starting to feel and fear the political pressure is the context of the memo as a sales pitch. What is it that CLGC is offering to sell the ABA? $850,000 worth of spin. In the new MSNBC article by Jonathan Larsen and Ken Olshansky, the deliverable of such a spin project is summarized as ” ‘opposition research’ on Occupy Wall Street in order to construct ‘negative narratives’ about the protests and allied politicians.” If you’d like to read the memo in its entirety, it can be found here in .pdf form. You may feel a bit queasy after reading it.
OWS could be, should be and might be even bigger than this one set of issues though. It should be a notice to Washington and the graft merchants of K Street that the United States Constitution says in plain language where the true political power rests in this country and who is really the boss of Washington when push comes to shove: “We the People of the United States”. Not “We the Corporations” or “We the Biggest Campaign Contributors” or “We the K Street Lobbying and Revolving Capital Hill Door Conflict of Interest Machine”, but “We the People”. Washington would be wise to take heed to call to substantively start addressing the needs and demands for justice of the 99% instead of catering to the greedy desires of the 1% and their own over-inflated egos. Our nation was founded in reaction to the tyranny of oppression and non-responsive government of King George. Just so, it can be reshaped in reaction to the tyranny of oppression and non-responsive government of as exemplified by the incestuous nexus of today’s Wall Street and Washington. We didn’t throw off the yoke of a mad, capricious and economically exploitative king in the 18th Century just to have it replaced by the yoke of venal and corrupt plutocrats and their political lackeys in the 21st.
Are Wall Street and their lobbyists starting to fear Main Street? Is the government? Is this a sign of the beginning of the end of OWS? Or is this a sign of the beginning of the beginning of OWS and the effort to reclaim the government for “We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity”?
What do you think?
Source: Huffington Post, MSNBC, CLGC Memo
~Submitted by Gene Howington, Guest Blogger
“The US turned right in 2010, and we could do it again with Gingrich in 2012. Remember the tea party thinks Obama is a socialist even though we know it is far from the truth.”
SwM,
In the last 6 days I received 1 robo call each day with the same recorded campaign message from Newt. He is well funded and can appeal to the entire party, but then there is that hubris factor. Newt drips with it.
http://www.universityofcalifornia.edu/news/article/26702 President Yudof is appalled by the pepper spraying and plans to take steps. Mark Yudof had a good reputation at UT and UMN.
Mike S.,
I think you are right. The 1per cent have over played their hand.
The destruction of private property in Zuccotti Park is going to cost the city a couple hundred thousand dollars, our tax dollars.
The NYPD stated that the private property should have been confiscated and stored, not destroyed. The contempt is showing in the act of destruction.
OWS is claiming damages totaling over $250,000. The destruction of the last personal effects of some of the more poverty stricken protesters is obscene.
They destroyed everything, indiscriminately. From industrial kitchen equipment, to 5,000 books to personal computers, a wireless tower, medical supplies, et al. Total loss and destruction in violation of NYPD rules.
They will pay, meaning WE will pay with our tax dollars. to say nothing of the hundreds of legal cases resulting from police brutality.
AN,
Hubris, an old concept, but one that always runs true.
http://www.canada.com/business/Spanish+voters+throw+Socialists/5738823/story.html The US turned right in 2010, and we could do it again with Gingrich in 2012. Remember the tea party thinks Obama is a socialist even though we know it is far from the truth.
“Why are the powers that be being so stupid as to use violently repressive means towards the OWS protests and their offshoots? What occurs to me is that they are really trying to frighten the movement in the same way that the Kent State Murders sent a message to the Anti-War Movement. It really is dumb given that they control the MSM, but in truth many of the 1% are dumb, it’s just their ruthlessness that carries them forward.” -Mike S. to raff and shano
Again, “in truth many of the 1% are dumb, it’s just their ruthlessness that carries them forward.” (Well said, Mike.)
Hopefully, their hubris will bring them down.
“As Rosa Luxemburg so perfectly put it: “Those who do not move, do not notice their chains.”” -from Greenwald’s article
Sunday, Nov 20, 2011
The roots of the UC-Davis pepper-spraying
By Glenn Greenwald
http://www.salon.com/2011/11/20/the_roots_of_the_uc_davis_pepper_spraying/singleton/
Excerpt:
If a population becomes bullied or intimidated out of exercising rights offered on paper, those rights effectively cease to exist. Every time the citizenry watches peaceful protesters getting pepper-sprayed — or hears that an Occupy protester suffered brain damage and almost died after being shot in the skull with a rubber bullet — many become increasingly fearful of participating in this citizen movement, and also become fearful in general of exercising their rights in a way that is bothersome or threatening to those in power. That’s a natural response, and it’s exactly what the climate of fear imposed by all abusive police state actions is intended to achieve: to coerce citizens to “decide” on their own to be passive and compliant — to refrain from exercising their rights — out of fear of what will happen if they don’t.
The genius of this approach is how insidious its effects are: because the rights continue to be offered on paper, the citizenry continues to believe it is free. They believe that they are free to do everything they choose to do, because they have been “persuaded” — through fear and intimidation — to passively accept the status quo. As Rosa Luxemburg so perfectly put it: “Those who do not move, do not notice their chains.” Someone who sits at home and never protests or effectively challenges power factions will not realize that their rights of speech and assembly have been effectively eroded because they never seek to exercise those rights; it’s only when we see steadfast, courageous resistance from the likes of these UC-Davis students is this erosion of rights manifest. (end of excerpts)
“All of this seems coordinated to me, not just in the US but around the world. The 08 banking crisis was known to the US and European govts, along with the corporations who own them, well before it collapsed everyone’s economies. Not one of these govts. took the legal or regulatory measures to reign in what the corporations were doing.”
Jill,
I agree with you this is coordinated world wide. The power plays aimed at Greece, Italy and Spain all were done with the intent of foisting “austerity” measures on them. In this context “austerity” means screw everyone but the 1%.
Bron,
I’d like to see you send your 21 year old daughter to some burgeoning oil town in North Dakota. Have you the slightest notion of what a town whose population rose 400% in a few years, due to an oil boom, is like? It would have been unsafe for me in my 20’s and i’m a 6 footer that can handle himself. It’s the Wild West Bron. North Dakota is beautiful and the people are great, I’ve been there, but all boom towns share the same characteristics of hard living. As for
working any job I was completely on my own at 18 and I worked my way through college in a variety of crappy jobs also. However, you and I grew up in times of economic growth, back when America still led the world in making things. It isn’t the same now and the law of shipping jobs overseas to be taken by low wage workers is too tempting to those who you would free from government regulation and control. For a smart man, at times you can be downright immature, colored by your political/economic outlook.
“shano,
It is amazing that cities somehow think that repressing free speech is the way to “control” the masses. They have not learned anything from recent history.”
Raff/Shano,
This morning during my daily ablutions I was pondering just this question. Why are the powers that be being so stupid as to use violently repressive means towards the OWS protests and their offshoots? What occurs to me is that they are really trying to frighten the movement in the same way that the Kent State Murders sent a message to the Anti-War Movement. It really is dumb given that they control the MSM, but in truth many of the 1% are dumb, it’s just their ruthlessness that carries them forward.
OS,
I forgot to mention that the video reminded me of the Kent State Days. The police with their riot gear and the pepper spray hasn’t changed much.
OS,
That was an amazing video. What kind of guns are those campus cops brandishing? Are those gas guns or guns for rubber bullets? Since when do campus cops need that kind of riot gear?
Their actions were more than shameful, they violated the free speech rights of those students and the officers in charge and the administrators who coordinated that affront to justice should be pounding the pavement for a new job.
From video of confrontation with police at UC Davis. Numbers are time stamps. The transcript is not mine.
6:12 “Mic check! Mic check!” (hoarse, urgent) “Shame on you!” Shouting.
6:15 Three weapons raised horizontal [by police].
6:20 “Mic check! Mic check! We are willing…”
Occupiers: “WE ARE WILLING…”
MC: “to give you a brief moment…”
Occupiers: “TO GIVE YOU A BRIEF MOMENT…”
MC: “of peace…”
Occupiers; “OF PEACE…”
MC: “so you may take your weapons…”
Occupiers: “SO YOU MAY TAKE YOUR WEAPONS…”
MC: “and your friends…”
Occupiers: “AND YOUR FRIENDS…”
MC: “and go.”
Occupiers: “AND GO.”
6:35 Policeman in front of line of weapons, now, holding two red cans, presumably pepper spray. Police faces behind visors puzzled.
MC: “Please do not return!”
Occupiers: “PLEASE DO NOT RETURN!”
MC: “We are giving you a moment of peace.”
Occupiers: “WE ARE GIVING YOU A MOMENT OF PEACE.”
MC: “You can go! We will not follow you!”
Occupiers: “WE WILL NOT FOLLOW YOU!” “You can go!” [confused shouting]
7:04 Occupiers: Chants, shouts, “You can go!”, “You can go!”, “You can go!” (repeated)
7:11 And the police begin to back down the path. “You can go!”, “You can go!” “None of you is getting a pension!”
7:14 Now for the first time, the camera pans left to show who the police were facing: A loose crowd of students in hoodies and student gear, many of them holding cameras, chanting and shouting. No violent body language, no visible weapons.
7:20 Police still in a block formation, backing away.
7:45 Finally the police turn their backs on the Occupiers and walk down the path. Cheers. “Yeah!” (Somewhere military historian John Keegan says that in a rout, the first troops to flee are not at the front, but at the back of the column, instancing the collapse of the Old Guard at Waterloo. Notice that here, the first police to turn their backs and walk away are indeed those at the back of the column, and not those, weapons still partially raised, at the front.)
“Shame on you!” “Shame on you!” “Our university!” “Whose university?” “Our university!”
“Whose quad?” “Our quad!” “Whose quad?” “Our quad!”
“Meanwhile DHS is working hard with a wonderful private company to coordinate the crackdowns. The Guardian has this story. Those are the people who most need jail time. They won’t get that because they’re too high up in the fascist food chain.” -Jill
Jill,
Do you have a link for the Guardian article?
shano,
It is amazing that cities somehow think that repressing free speech is the way to “control” the masses. They have not learned anything from recent history.
The fight is engaged:
“Sunday, Anonymous hacktivists assaulted PERF because of their alleged involvement in coordinating police crackdowns on Occupy protests across the country.
Anonymous hacktivists assaulted PERF, the Police Executive Research Forum, by taking down their website and releasing the private information of Sherwin B. “Chuck” Wexler – Executive Director at PERF.
PERF is a private but extremely influential national, non-governmental organization with close ties to law enforcement agencies across the country, as well as the U.S. Department of Homeland Security. The group allegedly orchestrated and coordinated the sometimes brutal police crack down on Occupy Wall Street, and other Occupy movements across the country.
After several news organizations identified PERF as being responsible for advising and coordinating the police crackdowns resulting in Occupy evictions and other brutalities, the hivemind of the nebulous and notorious international Internet collective known as Anonymous began to swarm, and sting.”
This is going to cost our government millions of dollars. The bigger the resistance grows, the more costly it will become. And that is a good thing. We tried the carrot, now the stick is in play.
Just voting for people, and then having them try to work in a system that is thoroughly corrupted has not worked. We all know it. This will continue until the system is radically changed to one where money does not influence politics and they do the bidding of the 99%, not the 1%
Middle-Class Jobs Disappearing As Workforce Shifts To High-Skill, Low-Skill: Study
http://ibnlive.in.com/news/ows-pepper-incident-officers-placed-on-leave/204178-2.html President of the UC system, Mark Yudof, says he appalled at the pepper spraying and orders a review of procedures.
http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/world-wide-mind/201111/the-turning-point-the-moral-example-uc-davis-students
Concerning the pepper spraying incident at UCD:
This event is powerfully symbolic. It is about contempt from those in power and the wanton use of force against the powerless.
We have seen similar things over and over again in the past few years. We have seen it in banks lobbying for public handouts and then denying relief to millions of exploited homeowners. We have seen it in tax breaks and bonuses for the rich while millions of Americans are out of work. We have seen it in church and university officers abusing children and then covering it up. We have seen it in the censorship of climate science performed in the public interest. We have seen it in the absurd declaration that corporations are “people” and entitled to spend billions of dollars to elect representatives that they will then own. We have seen it everywhere we turn.
The police officer is Congress. Our banks. Our clerics.
The students are us.
If I had to sum up the attitude of America’s governing classes in one word, I would say: contempt.
We are seeing the beginning of a worldwide movement to fight for dignity and intelligent, collective governance. It is remarkable, the parallels between what we see in Tunisia, in Cairo, in Rome, in Zucotti Park, in Oakland, California, and now at UC Davis.
On November 17, PERF Executive Director Chuck Wexler acknowledged PERF’s coordination of a series of conference-call strategy sessions with big-city police chiefs. These calls were distinct from the widely reported national conference calls of major metropolitan mayors.
This is the same man: Chuck Wexler, head of group that coordinated police crackdown on #Occupy serves on Dept of Homeland Security council http://is.gd/FByuu2
http://2012.talkingpointsmemo.com/2011/11/gingrich-says-child-labor-laws-should-be-rolled-back-so-kids-can-be-janitors.php?ref=fpb_beta Newt’s solution to high unemployment among the young.