ABC News has been given a photograph that might make the difference between life in prison and a walk. For weeks, we have been discussing the case and the application of the Stand Your Ground law. As discussed earlier, I think the case was over-charged and I remain doubtful of a conviction. This picture will likely be the single most important piece of evidence in the case. It shows Zimmerman with significant blood on the back of his head — an image that supports accounts from the scene and will be used to corroborate Zimmerman’s account of a struggle with Trayvon Martin where he feared serious bodily injury. [UPDATE: Zimmerman granted bond].
Unlike the photos of Zimmerman at the police station, this photo was taken a few minutes after the fight. Zimmerman’s shaved head could prove Godsend for Zimmerman. Had he had longer hair, the injury would have not appeared so stark.
The photo shows both cuts and a contusion — injuries that would normally be defined as serious bodily injury by many courts in torts cases where head injuries are treated as inherently potentially serious. The original police report said that he was bleeding from the nose and head and that his clothes looked like he had been in a fight. Zimmerman claims that it was Martin who jumped him, punched him, and pounded his head on to the concrete sidewalk.
The prosecutors can still argue that they do not contest the fight but that Zimmerman started it. However, with this photo, the charge of second-degree murder appears even more excessive and undermines Special Prosecutor Angela Corey’s claim that she was not affected by the political pressure to charge Zimmerman. I can understand a manslaughter charge, even with the photo, but no reasonable prosecutor would consider the second-degree murder charge as based on this evidence. Corey clearly must have seen this photo and the reports before her charging of Zimmerman.
The photo should also assist Zimmerman in his efforts to get bail.
Zimmerman, 28, is still being held on charges of second-degree murder of Martin, 17. In my view, a denial of bail would be an abuse and unwarranted given the fact that Zimmerman cooperated at the scene and voluntarily turned himself in.
Source: ABC
leander writes: ”
Trayvon we have a self-appointed neighborhood watchman who occasionally patrols the community, if you met him, his name is George Zimmerman, try to be very, very polite, some people think he is aggressive.
” wow, this would open up the HO to such liability. Imagine having to say that about any neighborhood- we have an aggressive guy with a concealed weapon here, so be nice!
http://articles.orlandosentinel.com/2012-05-08/news/os-george-zimmerman-arraignment-motions-20120508_1_speedy-trial-motions-arraignment-today
TonyC. – She COULD have a reason to lie, she COULD be TRYING to not incriminate her boyfriend by making it LOOK LIKE he was the victim. You are the biggest damn hypocrite if I’ve ever seen one! You only try and make things fit YOUR agenda i.e. Zimmerman side of the story is all lies and Martin was in the right. It’s people like you that are “stirring the pot” and trying to make everything one-sided.
Leander – I actually read your entire comment (don’t do that with a whole lot of one siders here). I must say it was a pretty well thought out and written piece. There are a lot of questions, questions that will hopefully be answered here shortly during the trial. It is nice to see someone that isn’t all, “HANG HIM” and “HE BELONGS IN PRISION FOR THE REST OF HIS LIFE” and “HE WAS IN THE WRONG.”
@Matt: As for Officer Roach, he was a uniformed policeman that had the authority to shoot a suspect running from the police that disobeyed a command. Zimmerman was a citizen, no citizen, whether on Neighborhood watch or not, has the authority to give commands to anybody and expect them to be obeyed, and certainly does not have the authority to shoot, and Trayvon was NOT a suspect running from police.
But if we understand something differently than some means, it doesn’t mean he lies.
I don’t check the rest,
But if we understand something differently than someone intends it to be understood, it does not mean he lies.
Maybe I need an external preview option, to deal with this problem.
Zimmerman was an over-zealous, aggressive, frustrated paranoid, and I do not presume Zimmerman was telling the truth to the dispatcher, I think he was spinning it all with deniable lies.
Actually I would like to know much more about him than I do. Over-zealous, yes maybe. I wonder how that could be connected to his earlier encounters with the authorities, which I do not consider as significant as Shano does. He obviously even handles privat problems like with a former housemate with police, that’s a trait that is very, very unfamiliar to me.
Neither do I believe as long as there is no further evidence–and I think there is none–that his father somehow infered in the process, besides quite possibly advising his son on his rights, or how to handle the situation. Although I would be interested in the specific father son relations. He self-defines as Hispanic, if reports are correct, thus with his mother. But what do his racial slurs about Hispanics on his 2005 my space website signify in this context? Self-hating Hispanic? Besides what does it mean that two of his brothers (how many brothers and sisters altogether) joined the army, like his father. Why didn’t he. Does this tell us about his relation to his father?
What is interesting for me about Zimmerman is that he seems to be the American eveyman, which seems the basis for the identification of many with his narrative. Helping him to walk free, for them means defending their own way of life and freedom. What happened to him, could happen to them.
Initially it didn’t feel to me it was a racial issue either, but it’s obvious that his supporters often refer to the criminal statistics in their support. There seems to be some kind of flyover-America-consensus that the blacks are to a vast majority criminals, and thus there is a big chance that Trayvon wasn’t a harmless child, neither. You can’t ignore this motive on the side of the people defending him, he is “one of us” for them, it’s partly about keeping their worldview intact.
trayvon “killed by stereotype”
America’s Most Wanted
I absolutely don’t agree he lied. That makes no sense to me at all. What he saw to him was real, he perceived Trayvon as suspicious, he fitted into the profile of the offenders observed in his neighbor’s house. What we say, is always interpreted, there is no one to one relation between what we sent and what arrives at the other end. But if we understand something differently than some means, it doesn’t mean he lies. It only means we do not understand.
Frustrated, yes, there are signs for that. He had reported young black males before and they run before the police arrived. This time he wants to make sure this guy does not get the chance. Unfortunately he is really bad in communicating the location of his car, that takes much time. In a way it puzzles me. But as a linguist I am aware this is a widespread problem for people. It also suggests to me this was in fact a chance encounter, otherwise he would be much better prepared. Strange he never thought about that, on other hand if your target moves quickly, isn’t it absurd the dispatcher wants to nail you down on a distinct location?
Trayon: Was one of the problems, that Ms Martin and Ms Fulton did not perfectly teach him to not under any circumstances run, as we now hear black parents teach their children, or did they in fact, and that is why he told Dee Dee, no, I am not running, but I can walk slightly faster?
It obviously was a very tragic chance encounter, in which Trayvon had no chance to understand what was happening to him. Had he been aware of it, he may have remained much more calm, hard as it is to be confronted with such loaded prejudice, even more as a 17 year old.
Imagine if Brandy Green had told him. Trayvon we have a self-appointed neighborhood watchman who occasionally patrols the community, if you met him, his name is George Zimmerman, try to be very, very polite, some people think he is aggressive. And some of the buglaries committed here recently were black and about your age.
But on the other hand, did she have time to get into community politics? Was she aware of it at all, or had even moved there only recently, and didn’t even know?
Questions, questions, questions ….
@Matt: You really think he was lying and reporting false things? That was his “job,” to report suspicious activity. Like I said earlier, this isn’t some conspiracy, and I highly doubt that he had ANY INTENTION to shoot and kill TM.
No, it was his hobby, he wasn’t paid for it, he wasn’t trained for it, he wasn’t certified for it. I also doubt (but do not rule out) that he had any explicit intent to shoot and kill Trayvon, but I think he DID have the intent to confront him and bully him, because his neighbors have said aggressive confrontation was his style; they have complained about that, both personally and on behalf of their kids, at the neighborhood watch meetings. (According to emails to MSNBC they have verified as coming from Zimmerman’s neighbors).
So when that confrontation did not turn out the way he expected (something like cowering submission to his assumed authority) and he got knocked down, he did shoot and kill Trayvon, but it wasn’t in self defense because you cannot intimidate someone, confront them, bully them, frighten them, and THEN claim because they swung at you or pushed you down that you were acting in self defense.
I think Zimmerman instigated the whole thing by following Trayvon in the first place, and from the INSTANT he left his car with a gun to follow Trayvon, he was the aggressor, with no right to claim “self defense.”
I do NOT assume DeeDee is lying, she has nothing to gain from lying. Zimmerman DID have a motive for lying, he wanted the police to have a reason to stop Trayvon, search him, and possibly arrest him, or scare him into staying indoors, because Zimmerman was clearly paranoid about teens “up to no good” and being “assholes” that were “always getting away” on what he falsely assumed were “HIS” streets, not just to patrol, but to CONTROL.
Those are Zimmerman’s motives for lying, and nothing he said about Trayvon in his call can be verified. DeeDee has no motive to lie about what she heard, and certainly some of what she has said IS verified by other sources, Trayvon WAS being followed by a man in a car.
After the murder, Zimmerman has every reason to lie, his entire life is on the line. After the murder, tell me what motive a high school girl has to get on the stand in court, take an oath and then outright lie. Revenge?
At 16 I did not know what the penalties for slander, libel or perjury might be, or even the difference between them, but I was smart enough to figure that if a lie could convict somebody of murder then that lie would be a pretty damn serious crime itself. Would you do that at 16? Get on the stand and tell a lie to put somebody you didn’t like in prison for life?
Because if you would I will assume you have no moral compass whatsoever, and that will change the character of this discussion.
TonyC. – Also, I can only ASSUME that if you believe GZ was lying during the 911 call, then YOU must also ASSUME that DeeDee (the girlfriend) is lying about what she heard through the phone the night of the encounter?
TonyC. – “He could be lying on the 911 tape, and all the things he says are practically designed for deniability.”
You really think he was lying and reporting false things? That was his “job,” to report suspicious activity. Like I said earlier, this isn’t some conspiracy, and I highly doubt that he had ANY INTENTION to shoot and kill TM.
“Zimmerman says, “He has his hand in is waistband,” and in normal human behavior, that is taken as reaching for a gun.”
That’s normal behavior seen as a POSSIBILITY that he MIGHT have a gun, knife, etc. On a dark, rainy night are you really going to WAIT to see what he MIGHT have in his waistband? Are you really going to wait and find out what he is carrying in his hands? That’s how cops get killed, they give the benefit of the doubt and wind up getting shot. Perfect example, and we had riots for WEEKS…
“Officer Roach shoots Timothy Thomas
While the city was embroiled in emotional discussions about racial tensions and police conduct regarding those incidents, Timothy Thomas ran from police down a dark alley, and was killed at 2:20 a.m. on April 7, 2001.
Thomas had been pulled over by police 11 times from February to May 2000, and then was charged later in July and August with obstructing official business after running from police on-sight. All 11 times Thomas was charged with driving without a license, and usually had accompanying tickets such as illegal window tinting, not wearing a seat belt, loud sound (music) or in one occasion driving with a child not in a safety restraint (car seat). While Thomas had both appeared in court and spent time in the Hamilton County jail for these violations they were not all cleared up, which Thomas believed they were at one point, and he was pursued because he had an outstanding 14 arrest warrants and court capiases demanding his arrest.[7]
Thomas initially was approached by two off-duty policemen who were familiar to him in the Over-the-Rhine neighborhood. The chase was joined by several police who were in the area when Officer Roach joined in the pursuit.
According to Roach’s statements, Thomas unexpectedly came around a corner; according to Roach’s court testimony, he reacted with deadly force as he thought Thomas was reaching for a weapon. He explained his reaction as follows:
* He was made aware that Thomas had 14 open warrants; however, police cruiser technology did not reveal the nature of outstanding warrants, so he was unaware that most of them were traffic violations and two were based on obstruction.
* He gave the verbal command to stop, but Thomas did not comply before making the gesture of lowering his arms.
* Thomas was probably reaching to pull up his pants, which were quite large and sagged below his waist (as was the current style of many young men at the time), so when he lowered his arms without instruction, the intent was unclear in that moment of heightened tension.
* It was a dark alley and visibility was limited.”
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cincinnati_riots_of_2001
“Zimmerman was an over-zealous, aggressive, frustrated paranoid, and I do not presume Zimmerman was telling the truth to the dispatcher, I think he was spinning it all with deniable lies.”
Wow…you must me his personal psychologist with they way you throw around your “diagnosis” of GZ. How many meetings did you have with him before you came to this conclusion? I think it is you who is a frustrated paranoid. Do you also think that everyone lies to everyone to make their story look good? If so, wow, you lived in a messed up world.
In order to formulate a FAIR opinion on any issue or case, one must have ALL of the facts / evidence in front of him/her.
When a person does have ALL of those items mentioned then he/she may unbiasedly ponder different possible scenarios.
Its imperative to consider all the differing hypotheses and possibilities before one can form a FAIR opinion and conclusion especially if it effects someone elses fate and the long term effects on our country.
You must do that with nothing but unbiased COMMONSENSE and LOGIC.
I don’t see that used here in this playground because we are NOT PRIVY TO ALL OF THE FACTS AND EVIDENCE yet.
. I do see emotions running amuck. I do see people here going out of their way to state that their views are not prejudice . (a rose by any other name…)
People here have no problem in questioning the character of Zimmerman, which is something we all must do,
BUT those same people wont allow for the character of Martin to be questioned. Why? Because he was the one killed and after all he was only a ‘child’.
To use this this BLATANTLY uninformed statement as a small example of an unfair rush to judgement.
posted by someone here-
“Zimmerman was at the very least reckless and provoked the entire situation.”
(based on what solid information?)
Coming here to express my point of view is comparative to stopping in at a ‘JIm Crow’ rally in the early 1900s to speak against the ‘separate but equal’ laws.
Enjoy your playground while its here.
@Matt, Bosco, southernbelle: The problem is you assume Zimmerman is telling the truth, on the tape and afterward. Zimmerman clearly wanted the police to come out and harass Trayvon. He could be lying on the 911 tape, and all the things he says are practically designed for deniability.
Zimmerman says, “he is staring at me,” and in normal human behavior staring is a confrontational behavior. (And that is why YOU are noting it as confrontational behavior.) Well, if the cops get there and Trayvon denies staring at him, Zimmerman can say, “it looked like staring to me,” or even, “he is lying, he was staring at me, it made me uncomfortable.”
Zimmerman says, “He has his hand in is waistband,” and in normal human behavior, that is taken as reaching for a gun. Well, if the cops get there and Trayvon says he did no such thing, Zimmerman can say, “He definitely did, maybe he was trying to make me think he had a gun, I definitely felt threatened.”
Zimmerman says, “He was looking at all the buildings,” and in normal human behavior this might be taken as casing them for weaknesses. Well, if the cops get there and Trayvon denies it, Zimmerman can say, “I saw it, it wasn’t idle sight seeing, I think he was looking for a way in, an open door or something.”
Zimmerman says, “he ran,” and normally we would consider that suspicious. Well, if the cops get there and Trayvon says he did NOT run, Zimmerman can say, “I saw him run, I was there.” If Trayvon says “I started walking faster,” Zimmerman can say, “It looked like running to me.”
Everything Zimmerman says that casts suspicion on Trayvon or makes Trayvon look aggressive can devolve to his word against Trayvon’s word.
Unlike most of us, Zimmerman had a lot of experience in getting police to come out without any effect other than harassment of teens. As his neighbors will probably testify, since a few have already been talking about him in the media, Zimmerman was overly aggressive in person (to them personally) and was calling the cops for no good reason just to keep kids from hanging out together or playing on a residential street. (Which is not dangerous, I grew up playing in residential streets, and for twenty-five years I have had kids playing in my residential street, to this day, and not one has ever been hit by a car. In many neighborhoods yards aren’t big enough to play in, or in the cities they are non-existent.)
Zimmerman was an over-zealous, aggressive, frustrated paranoid, and I do not presume Zimmerman was telling the truth to the dispatcher, I think he was spinning it all with deniable lies.
Bosco,
From the first thread in this blog discussing this topic, I have been clear that in my opinion
(1) The situation is that of a wingnut with a gun
(2) This a not racially-motivated incident. Zimmerman (of whatever race) profiled Martin (of whatever race) as the sort of person responsible for local break-ins. The fact that they mainly seemed to be black was incidental.
The rights and wrongs boil down to two main options:
(1) Martin was assaulting Zimmerman and therefore Zimmerman was perfectly entitled to kill him. End of. No need to look at any other circumstances.
OR
(2) Zimmerman was at the very least reckless and provoked the entire situation. Additionally, it is not ascertainable from any known facts who might have got physical first. The only witness to the beginning of the scuffle is Martin’s girlfriend who says that she overheard a conversation. It is a fact that a telephone conversation between Martin and his girlfriend was in progress at the time. That conversation description directly contradicts Zimmerman’s version.
I hope that there is a trial.
If the case should turn out to have been overcharged in order to facilitate the bureaucratic convenience of a plea bargain, then that would be a complete disgrace. It would also be particularly unwise in the light of all the passions raised.
Matt, I only HOPE that if there IS a trial , all of the same people at this biased ‘playground’ will still be here. Once the FACTS and the EVIDENCE are shown, regardless of what they prove or disprove, EVERYONE here will HONESTLY express their opinions on it. (Without the racist attitudes that is)
on enge = on edge.
good night.
I agree Belle, he sounds mild mannered and polite, but is clearly occasionally on enge, and frustrated. You can’t deny that.
For me there are clearly hysterical traces, he almost wails: They always get away. He is irritated that the dispatcher reacts rather cool to his discription. Ok he is just walking around the area. You don’t believe me, let me tell you he is looking at the houses.
Your side has to explain to us what crime TM committed. He clearly would not have touched Zimmerman, had Zimmerman not followed him first. And people could hear shouts, quite possibly: Why are you following me?
Zimmerman’s intention was to prevent a robbery a break-in, that we know. If TM had planned one while being on holiday there, police must have found some tools in his pockets, no? Did they?
After the whole thing happened Zimmerman has no other choice but to criminalize Trayvon Martin to justify his actions. When he did so on the same evening his best hope was that TM did not belong into the community, and no one would ever miss him, unfortunately for him, he did.
Stand your ground is not meant to protect someone that on his own decision targets and follows someone that does not commit a crime, that had no intention to harm him or his possessions, to start with, is that so hard to understand?
GZs background would prejudice me. An assault on an officer and a woman? Now isn’t he the angel son of a magistrate?
Whatever you want to say about Travyon Martin, he had no violence whatsoever on his record.
Somehow an OK, got lost here:
Dispatcher: …OK
nothing else missing.
Zimmerman didn’t sound frantic on 911 call to me. Not at all. Nor was his voice aggressive. I don’t know where that’s coming from., that he was freakin’ on this guy. I didn’t hear anything frantic from Z. I was expecting hysterics after reading here, hell, he wasn’t even sure what color M. was. Maybe he jut found him interesting because he was a stranger in a gated comm. That would be reason enough for me. Since my wife and kids were nearby. There’s a hell of a lot of difference in posting opinions on here and a court of law. The jury can choose to discount Z testimony, also discount the girlfriends word of what was said in the phone conversation. I didn’t realize how many ppl were getting fed up with this race thing. If Z. background is allowed in court, so should M. although Martin’s . might predjuice the jury.
Don’t shoot the messenger.
The taped call I heard today was Z. telling dispatch that this guy M was staring at him and then started toward Z with his hands in his waist band. So, who is stalking whom?
There is only one call so you can’t have listened to a different one than everybody else. Besides, why don’t you look at a map, Belle?
If George Zimmerman is where he tells the dispatcher he is, than Trayvon Martin has to pass him to get home to the house were he stays. that’s hardly “starting towards someone”, whatever you are trying to suggest with that phrase. Zimmerman says he is “staring” at him, not “starting” at him.
Now wouldn’t you be curious, who someone is that keeps staring at you, and keeps talking with someone on the phone while carefully watching you and seemingly reporting every one of your movements? Don’t you think, you would look back too?
Dispatcher: Did you see what he was wearing?
Zimmerman: Yeah. A dark hoodie, like a grey hoodie, and either jeans or sweatpants and white tennis shoes. He’s [unintelligible], he was just staring…
Dispatcher: OK, he’s just walking around the area…
Zimmerman: …looking at all the houses.
Dispatcher: …
Zimmerman: Now he’s just staring at me.
Dispatcher: OK–you said it’s 1111 Retreat View? Or 111?
Zimmerman: That’s the clubhouse…
Dispatcher: That’s the clubhouse, do you know what the–he’s near the clubhouse right now?
Zimmerman: Yeah, now he’s coming towards me.
Dispatcher: OK.
Zimmerman: He’s got his hand in his waistband. And he’s a black male.
What I do not understand is WHY Zimmerman is so frantic about this teen. Did he just want a opportunity to ‘pall around’ with the local cops & shoot some small talk about how his schooling is going? A chance to be a ‘hero’, the thrill of the hunt, false courage because he was carrying a concealed gun, whatever—did he really think that from what he saw that anyone would be able to charge Trayvon with any violation whatsoever?
Speculating that even if he detained Trayvon, & they ended up talking to the cops, George would have had egg on his face for yet another ‘false alarm’ …………Or were the people in the neighborhood who complained about George in his overzealous ‘patrolling’ of the neighborhood more right than they knew at the time?
This isn’t some “conspiracy” that GZ knew he was going to shoot someone so he made it look better on his behalf from the very beginning.
Sling doesn’t necessarily suggests “a conspiracy”.
Zimmerman obviously thinks/experienced “these guys” always run away fastly, and he reported that before: Zimmerman: Can you let the officers know they typically run away quickly earlier call, about 1 min into the tape.
So “strictly” any sign of a different, in his eyes deviant behavior like leaving the road or dissappearing between two houses , may trigger this preconception. I had the impression he lost sight of TM at this point, when I heard it the first time, and didn’t have an idea about the location.
Moving between houses is something he reports before, something he considers suspicious behavior.
At this point he is clearly preoccupied with explaining the dispatcher again where exactly he wants to meet the officers, and he is slightly exasperated with the officers at that point too (No, you go straight in). In this context he may well have lost sight of Martin, and he simply translates this fact into he is running, he ran towards the back entrance.
let’s get the whole context:
Dispatcher: Yeah we’ve got someone on the way, just let me know if this guy does anything else.
Zimmerman: Okay. These assholes they always get away. When you come to the clubhouse you come straight in and make a left. Actually you would go past the clubhouse.
Dispatcher: So it’s on the lefthand side from the clubhouse?
Zimmerman: No you go in straight through the entrance and then you make a left…uh you go straight in, don’t turn, and make a left. Shit he’s running.
Dispatcher: He’s running? Which way is he running?
Zimmerman: Down towards the other entrance to the neighborhood. Dispatcher: Which entrance is that that he’s heading towards?
Zimmerman: The back entrance…fucking ****s