Reasonable Doubt? Crime Scene Photos Shows Serious Injury On Zimmerman’s Head

ABC News has been given a photograph that might make the difference between life in prison and a walk. For weeks, we have been discussing the case and the application of the Stand Your Ground law. As discussed earlier, I think the case was over-charged and I remain doubtful of a conviction. This picture will likely be the single most important piece of evidence in the case. It shows Zimmerman with significant blood on the back of his head — an image that supports accounts from the scene and will be used to corroborate Zimmerman’s account of a struggle with Trayvon Martin where he feared serious bodily injury. [UPDATE: Zimmerman granted bond].


Unlike the photos of Zimmerman at the police station, this photo was taken a few minutes after the fight. Zimmerman’s shaved head could prove Godsend for Zimmerman. Had he had longer hair, the injury would have not appeared so stark.

The photo shows both cuts and a contusion — injuries that would normally be defined as serious bodily injury by many courts in torts cases where head injuries are treated as inherently potentially serious. The original police report said that he was bleeding from the nose and head and that his clothes looked like he had been in a fight. Zimmerman claims that it was Martin who jumped him, punched him, and pounded his head on to the concrete sidewalk.

The prosecutors can still argue that they do not contest the fight but that Zimmerman started it. However, with this photo, the charge of second-degree murder appears even more excessive and undermines Special Prosecutor Angela Corey’s claim that she was not affected by the political pressure to charge Zimmerman. I can understand a manslaughter charge, even with the photo, but no reasonable prosecutor would consider the second-degree murder charge as based on this evidence. Corey clearly must have seen this photo and the reports before her charging of Zimmerman.

The photo should also assist Zimmerman in his efforts to get bail.
Zimmerman, 28, is still being held on charges of second-degree murder of Martin, 17. In my view, a denial of bail would be an abuse and unwarranted given the fact that Zimmerman cooperated at the scene and voluntarily turned himself in.

Source: ABC

1,309 thoughts on “Reasonable Doubt? Crime Scene Photos Shows Serious Injury On Zimmerman’s Head”

  1. Matt,

    You appear to have missed the bit above where I said
    “Even if Martin might have initially run, do you know for a fact that he did not change to a fast walk or even a walk or even pause to check if Zimmerman had stopped following – which would allow him to relax and get back to walking slowly while talking to his girlfriend?”

    You say: “he would be a little more out of breathe than he was”
    Do you know this for a fact?

    You say: “Plus, if Zimmerman DID lose sight of Martin, that means that Martin couldn’t see him anymore either. Why didn’t he just continue on home?”
    How do you know for a fact that Martin relaxed when could not see Zimmerman any more? He wanted to talk with his girlfriend.
    How do you know for a fact that Zimmerman did not use the “cut-through” to get ahead of Martin?

    Zimmerman says “He ran”. He didn’t say “He’s (just) started running”. You don’t know at what precise stage Martin might have started running. You are simply assuming. You don’t know if he ran when he saw Zimmerman get out of the SUV, and Zimmerman is telling 911 that Martin ran in order to imply guilty motives on Martin’s part.

    You ask others for facts, and then you create scenarios not based on facts. You don’t know that Martin started running and continued to run. You don’t know what Martin was thinking. You don’t know how he would react. You don’t know for fact the routes that both took before they came face to face.
    You are assuming the routes and you are assuming the relative speeds. You are assuming how Martin might have been reacting to a situation for which you don’t have facts.

  2. Sling…. – I’m sorry but I don’t see anybody mistaking “walking a little faster” with “running.” This isn’t some “conspiracy” that GZ knew he was going to shoot someone so he made it look better on his behalf from the very beginning. He reported to dispatch that Martin ran. Like I said earlier had he started to “chase” after Martin while on foot, while on the phone with 911, he would be a little more out of breathe than he was (as heard on the 911 tape).

    I still hold to the FACT that a 5’9″ 200 pound Hispanic man cannot OUTRUN a 6’2″ 150-160 pound Black *MAN* (See what I did there TonyC., that was for your benefit LOL)

    Plus, if Zimmerman DID lose sight of Martin, that means that Martin couldn’t see him anymore either. Why didn’t he just continue on home? If he was TRULY lost and/or afraid, why didn’t he ask someone else how to get to his address inside the gated community other than going NEAR Zimmerman?

  3. TonyC. – “I think it is possible Trayvon did what he told DeeDee he would do, and was walking faster, and Zimmerman either lied about him running, or Trayvon turned a corner or left the sidewalk and Zimmerman thought he ran”

    You really think that you couldn’t see a difference between someone “walking around a corner” and “running?” I HIGHLY doubt that this is the “beginning of a conspiracy” that Zimmerman would lie about what he saw. I also put out there that, if Martin was REALLY afraid, why would he tell DeeDee that he was going to “walk faster” rather than “run?” Personally, if I think someone is following me and going to harm me I’m going to run like hell, not calmly walk a little faster! That shows me that he WASN’T afraid, and I PERSONALLY BELIEVE that he would then be looking for Zimmerman to confront him so that Martin COULD get into an altercation.

    “Trayvon was not a “grown man.””

    “Normally men stop growing by 18 years of age but can have spurts as late as 25.”

    http://www.askmedicaldoctor.com/medical/doctor/index.php?xq=72041

    I’m sorry, but he was as close to full grown as possible. Martin was a GROWN MAN.

    “Seventeen year olds do NOT think they are invincible, either, they have plenty of experience with pain, falls, and most of them will avoid fights in order to avoid the pain.”

    That is absurd. 99.99% (my own statistic and feeling) male teens feel they are invincible.

    “Most teens this age still feel invincible and that nothing bad could possibly happen to them. This will cause them to engage in high risk behaviors. Experimentation with alcohol, cigarettes, marijuana, and sexual intercourse increases sharply during this stage.”

    http://www.kidsgrowth.com/resources/articledetail.cfm?id=1140

  4. Matt: “SlingTrebuchet – “How do you know for a fact that Martin was running?”

    Listen to the 911 call again and you’ll get your answer. I’ll even pinpoint the part in the tape. Zimmerman states “He ran” at 02:07.”

    Excellent! I knew you’d say that 🙂

    You don’t know for a fact that Martin was running.

    If Zimmerman saying something makes it a fact, then equally the girlfriend saying something makes it a fact.
    Therefore : (1) Martin told her that he was not going to run, but walk fast. Do you know for a fact that Zimmerman did not interpret a change from walk to fast walk as a run? Even if Martin might have initially run, do you know for a fact that he did not change to a fast walk or even a walk or even pause to check if Zimmerman had stopped following – which would allow him to relax and get back to walking slowly while talking to his girlfriend?
    Therefore : (2) The first words spoken when the came to face were Martin asking Zimmerman why he was following, Zimmerman not explaining but asking what Martin was doing around there – and then the scuffle.

    Zimmerman’s ‘facts’ conflict with the girlfriend’s ‘facts’. This is because they are assertions that they saw or heard something. They are not independently confirm-able

    Your problem is that you demand to know if someone knows something for a fact, but at the same time you assert as fact things that you don’t know for a fact.

    Getting back to where this particular exchange started, it is possible for a complete lard-ass to outrun and overtake professional sprinter who is walking.
    We also don’t know for a fact what route Zimmerman took to get to the pathway. He could have run one of the cut-throughs to the South and got ahead of Martin. We don’t know for a fact.

    Nothing that Zimmerman says can be accepted as fact simply because he says it.

  5. @Matt: I think it is possible Trayvon did what he told DeeDee he would do, and was walking faster, and Zimmerman either lied about him running, or Trayvon turned a corner or left the sidewalk and Zimmerman thought he ran. I think it is possible Trayvon stopped while talking to his girlfriend, and Zimmerman caught up to him. I think it is possible that Trayvon, who was in an UNFAMILIAR neighborhood in the dark, may have tried to lose Zimmerman, got lost, and in doubling back encountered Zimmerman coming after him.

    Trayvon was not a “grown man.” A 6’2″ male weighing 150 lb is extremely thin, I know a 6’2″ teen weighing 170 lb and I think HE is extremely thin.

    Zimmerman does not just say he lost sight of Trayvon, he says “he ran.” I believe that if the jurors believe that line, they will also conclude there was no plausible reason for Trayvon to run except that he was afraid of Zimmerman. I believe the jurors will accept DeeDee’s account as well, which will indicate Trayvon knew he was being followed and by agreeing to “walk faster” proved he was alarmed by being followed.

    Seventeen year olds do NOT think they are invincible, either, they have plenty of experience with pain, falls, and most of them will avoid fights in order to avoid the pain. The modern seventeen year old is also fully aware that other people carry guns, knives and razors, and may be high to boot, and you do not know WHAT you will encounter. When I was in high school, I could be sure that in a fight nobody was going to cut me or try to literally blind me. That is no longer true; and the modern teen knows it. Trayvon was not a grown man, but I think we can assume he was paying attention to the world as it is.

  6. SlingTrebuchet – “How do you know for a fact that Martin was running?”

    Listen to the 911 call again and you’ll get your answer. I’ll even pinpoint the part in the tape. Zimmerman states “He ran” at 02:07.

  7. Adding to my last comment, Malisha. Do you ALSO think that he was CAPABLE of “continuing to follow Martin” an CATCH UP to him….ALL while being on the phone with dispatch?

  8. Matt: “I ask again, do you REALLY think that a 5’9″ 200 pound Hispanic man was CAPABLE of OUTRUNNING and CATCHING UP TO a 6’2″ 150-160 pound Black man?”

    How do you know for a fact that Martin was running?

  9. Malisha – Your attempt at a “good analogy” is pitiful.

    “Picture a six-year-old girl in the playground approached by someone she doesn’t know, and she tries to run and he catches up with her, and she turns and kicks him HARD in the shins. Guilty of asssault? What if the kick doesn’t stop the guy and he grabs her and carries her off and she “goes missing.” Is he ultimately innocent if, when they find her body, he says, “she kicked me first”?”

    Are you trying to say that Martin was a little boy? Come on. You have two grown MEN. Zimmerman states that he “lost sight of Martin.” You have the girlfriend who states that she heard, “Why are you following me?” and “What are you doing here?” and then the scuffle. How do you know for a FACT that Martin didn’t double back and confront Zimmerman while he was walking back to his car (like he states)? I’m sorry, but from what I have heard thus far you cannot say that Martin was “frightened.” Like most 17 year olds (including myself at that age), they think they are invincible. You really think that Martin, a 6’2″ 150-160 pound Black man is “AFRAID” of a 5’9″ 200 pound Hispanic man? I ask again, do you REALLY think that a 5’9″ 200 pound Hispanic man was CAPABLE of OUTRUNNING and CATCHING UP TO a 6’2″ 150-160 pound Black man?

  10. The idea that Martin would be “guilty of assault” if he physically touched Zimmerman before being shot to death is absurd.

    Picture a six-year-old girl in the playground approached by someone she doesn’t know, and she tries to run and he catches up with her, and she turns and kicks him HARD in the shins. Guilty of asssault? What if the kick doesn’t stop the guy and he grabs her and carries her off and she “goes missing.” Is he ultimately innocent if, when they find her body, he says, “she kicked me first”?

    The person being targeted and followed, who has reason to fear the stranger who is accosting them, is not committing assault to try to physically gain his or her freedom from the person and to escape WHATEVER IT IS that the person may want to subject them to, whether that is interrogation, kidnapping, killing, or anything else — UNLESS THE PERSON STOPPING AND QUESTIONING THE PERSON IS A UNIFORMED POLICE OFFICER WHO PROVES THAT HE IS OFFICIAL.

    Zimmerman does not equal POLICE,
    therefore,
    Physical confrontation with the goal of escaping Zimmerman does not equal ASSAULT.

  11. @Matt: I think he will receive that verdict based on public pressure.

    Tony, actually that’s a pretty clever way to make sure he is right. 😉

    outcome one: GZ is aquitted – I told you so.
    outcome two: GZ is sentenced – I told you so, they can’t judge differently due to public pressure.

  12. A volunteer community watch captain who shot an unarmed Florida teenager to death last month had been the subject of complaints by neighbors in his gated community for aggressive tactics, a homeowner said.

    George Zimmerman has not been charged in the Feb. 26 shooting of Trayvon Martin, 17, who was walking home from a convenience store in Sanford, Fla., near Orlando. Zimmerman, who patrolled the Retreat at Twin Lakes development in his own car, had been called aggressive in earlier complaints to the local police and the homeowner’s association, according to a homeowner who spoke on the condition of anonymity.

    At an emergency homeowner’s association meeting on March 1, “one man was escorted out because he openly expressed his frustration because he had previously contacted the Sanford Police Department about Zimmerman approaching him and even coming to his home,” the resident wrote in an email to HuffPost. “It was also made known that there had been several complaints about George Zimmerman and his tactics” in his neighborhood watch captain role.

    http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/03/12/george-zimmerman-trayvon-martin_n_1340358.html

  13. “Another disturbing aspect of this case is the fact that Zimmerman was issued a permit to carry a concealed handgun by the state of Florida in the first place. Zimmerman, of course, was arrested in 2005 for resisting arrest with violence and battery on a police officer. The case was dismissed, and Zimmerman’s record expunged after he agreed to attend a pre-trial diversion program. He was also the subject of a restraining order in 2005 after his ex-fiancee accused him of physically abusing her. In addition, police have fielded complaints from members of Zimmerman’s gated community about his aggressive conduct in the neighborhood.

    The reality is that it is very easy even for people with criminal records to get concealed handgun permits in Florida. The state has a “Shall-Issue” system that forces law enforcement to issue permits to civilians who meet a basic set of criteria and complete a firearms safety training course (no minimum number of hours of training is required). You have to be 21 years of age. You can’t be a convicted felon. You can’t be the subject of a current restraining order related to domestic violence (you also can’t have a past misdemeanor conviction for the crime of domestic violence). You’re disqualified if you’ve been adjudicated as mentally incapacitated or committed to a mental institution. You’re disqualified if you are a “substance abuser” (no blood alcohol or drug tests are conducted on applicants) or have been convicted of a drug crime within the previous three years. You’re disqualified if you have two or more convictions for driving under the influence.

    But beyond that it’s wide open. You can have previous misdemeanor convictions, even for violent offenses or drug-related offenses (as long as the latter was more than three years prior). You can have severe mental health problems, as long as you never came into contact with the court system. You can have multiple previous restraining orders for domestic violence. You can have a DUI on your record. Or you can be someone like George Zimmerman, who committed a violent crime but was able to plea-bargain it down to the point where it served as no obstacle to him obtaining a permit. And permits are good for seven years — so once you are issued one, you may not have your record checked again by the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services (the issuing body) until you renew the permit.”

    http://www.huffingtonpost.com/josh-horwitz/arming-zimmerman_b_1367648.html

  14. Matt; “I might also add that Martin may not have been as “innocent” as you believe. I say this because IF HE DID ATTACK ZIMMERMAN he was guilty, at that point, of assault.”

    I might also add that Zimmerman may not have been as “innocent” as you believe. I say this because IF HE DID ATTACK MARTIN he was guilty, at that point, of assault.

    We will never know who might have been guilty of assault. No on-the-spot witnesses to the beginning of the struggle have come forward. There is one person who overheard the initial meeting and whose testimony as to who said what contradicts that of Zimmerman.

    All we know is that Zimmerman’s reckless and aggressive behaviour resulted in a death.

  15. Shano – by expunged you mean the charges were DROPPED right? The domestic violence and battery on a police officer were DROPPED. This means that the officer and the girlfriend did not have ENOUGH PROOF to make the charges stick. Maybe you need to do a little more research.

  16. @Bosco: Sharpton is irrelevant; as irrelevant as FOX or MSNBC reporting. There is money to be made and exposure to be had in a media-storm, it doesn’t mean anything about the case. I, for one, have not heard or read a WORD about what Sharpton has said about this case, and if I do, I will discount him for what he is; a self-serving media whore trying to get paid for appearing on TV. Just as I would discount any opinion from FOX or MSNBC or CNN.

    Who cares what their opinion of the facts are? I can think about the facts for myself, I do not need anybody telling me what I should think about it. I guess some people like it, because they sell commercials, but personally I do not need any help thinking, and I am not a parrot.

  17. Matt & Bosco, you mean to say you know nothing about GZ getting his felony record (attacking a police officer, domestic violence) expunged?

    GZ lied to the police & his father about that night and that will be his downfall.

  18. @Matt: I think he will receive that verdict based on public pressure.

    Pray tell, how could you possibly distinguish a fair verdict of guilty from a public pressure verdict of guilty? The only way you can claim a guilty verdict is due to public pressure is by assuming Zimmerman is actually innocent.

    @Matt: I say this because IF HE DID ATTACK ZIMMERMAN he was guilty, at that point, of assault.

    This is also absolutely false, if Trayvon attacked Zimmerman he had the right to do it under Florida’s Stand Your Ground law which allows lethal force to be used when one is threatened and in fear of one’s life. There is evidence, even by Zimmerman’s 911 tape account, that Trayvon was alarmed and frightened by Zimmerman. Trayvon attacking Zimmerman would not be assault, under Florida law it would be SYG self-defense.

  19. @Bosco: I am a reality-based professional scientist that is forced to come to conclusions and make decisions all the time in the face of partial knowledge.

    If the reports of DeeDee are admitted into evidence and are TRUE as I have heard them, and if all of what Zimmerman has told the police and others is admitted into evidence, then I do not need further facts to conclude, beyond a reasonable doubt, that Zimmerman has been lying to escape justice and should be found guilty of at least manslaughter.

    If some inescapable FACT appeared that exonerated Zimmerman and proved DeeDee was lying, then as a scientist I would admit I was wrong (as I have before in this forum) and I would reevaluate my belief. But at the moment, I would need strong evidence to conclude beyond a reasonable doubt that Trayvon presented a lethal, unprovoked threat to Zimmerman, and I do not see a shred of it anywhere, I do not see even a “preponderance of evidence” (the lowest legal threshold) for that, and thus I conclude Zimmerman is guilty of at least manslaughter.

    This is a decision that will HAVE to be made without all the facts, with people speculating about what most probably happened, and that does not mean it is biased.

Comments are closed.