ABC News has been given a photograph that might make the difference between life in prison and a walk. For weeks, we have been discussing the case and the application of the Stand Your Ground law. As discussed earlier, I think the case was over-charged and I remain doubtful of a conviction. This picture will likely be the single most important piece of evidence in the case. It shows Zimmerman with significant blood on the back of his head — an image that supports accounts from the scene and will be used to corroborate Zimmerman’s account of a struggle with Trayvon Martin where he feared serious bodily injury. [UPDATE: Zimmerman granted bond].
Unlike the photos of Zimmerman at the police station, this photo was taken a few minutes after the fight. Zimmerman’s shaved head could prove Godsend for Zimmerman. Had he had longer hair, the injury would have not appeared so stark.
The photo shows both cuts and a contusion — injuries that would normally be defined as serious bodily injury by many courts in torts cases where head injuries are treated as inherently potentially serious. The original police report said that he was bleeding from the nose and head and that his clothes looked like he had been in a fight. Zimmerman claims that it was Martin who jumped him, punched him, and pounded his head on to the concrete sidewalk.
The prosecutors can still argue that they do not contest the fight but that Zimmerman started it. However, with this photo, the charge of second-degree murder appears even more excessive and undermines Special Prosecutor Angela Corey’s claim that she was not affected by the political pressure to charge Zimmerman. I can understand a manslaughter charge, even with the photo, but no reasonable prosecutor would consider the second-degree murder charge as based on this evidence. Corey clearly must have seen this photo and the reports before her charging of Zimmerman.
The photo should also assist Zimmerman in his efforts to get bail.
Zimmerman, 28, is still being held on charges of second-degree murder of Martin, 17. In my view, a denial of bail would be an abuse and unwarranted given the fact that Zimmerman cooperated at the scene and voluntarily turned himself in.
Source: ABC
BTW again, the idea that the girlfriend (Dee Dee) would lie so as not to “incriminate” Trayvon Martin — very TELLING!
How could she possibly incriminate a dead man? Can dead men be charged with crimes in Florida? Where did you get the idea that the person who did NOT follow someone, who did NOT carry a gun, who did NOT shoot anybody, would have to be protected from incrimination? Was Trayvon Martin just to be assumed to be criminal, as Zimmerman assumed?
Furthermore, if she wanted to “de-incriminate” her deceased boyfriend and she was inclined to lie, here is what she would have said:
“Then I heard some guy tell Trayvon, ‘See this gun, you Black Bastard? Shut up and put your hands in the air or I’ll blow you away right now,’ and then I heard Trayvon say, ‘Don’t shoot, help help help help!’ and then I heard something that sounded like a slap and Trayvon screamed and the line went dead…”
See, that’s how to de-incriminate a profiled dead boyfriend who’s been killed by an innocent man.
Wow, it just occurred to me why there is all this obsession with Duke and Brawley cases: there is the mistaken idea that INITIAL IMPRESSIONS formed by irrelevant people (that is, neither law enforcement nor potential jurors nor judicial personnel) formed after hearing or reading NEWS REPORTS created some presumptions!
In that case, let me address the real issue here: The Zimmerman case is NOT in its initial stages in the media, in the law enforcement world, or in the courts. It doesn’t MATTER, now, that the initial reaction of the police was that “Zimmerman is innocent and doesn’t need to be charged with a crime.” It does not MATTER, now, that the initial reaction of the African American activists was that “Zimmerman is guilty of killing a young African American man for no reason and yet the police have refused to arrest him for the crime.” It does not MATTER, now, what I believed in March when the news reports began to come out, because almost as soon as they did, I read MORE than the initial reports. I did NOT just read what Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson said about this. I read and watched a video of a white, conservative looking, classy, well spoken woman describing her attempts to give information to the police about the killing that had taken place in her backyard. That was more than I EVER saw about the Duke case, the Brawley case, the OJ Simpson case (where all I ever saw took place within the courtroom itself) or — since you have recently brought up yet another irrelevant issue — the Michael Jackson case.
NOW, more than two months after the killing of Trayvon Martin, we all have a LOT MORE INFORMATION about this crime than we had about the cases you keep focusing on. Opinions I have formed about the Zimmerman case have germinated, developed and solidified after listening to three audio-tapes (one of them about two dozen times), reading about 60 mainstream media articles, following at least three respectable blogs, analyzing and reading analyses of several very informative descriptions of the physical area and timing of the events of 2/26/2012, reading Ayala’s police report, watching Joe Oliver and Frank Taafe on videos, and drawing my own conclusions. Actually having not heard about the Duke and Brawley cases in their early stages (and I don’t know how many weeks or months might have equaled their “early stages”), there is no comparison with what I have formed as opinions in the Zimmerman case.
BTW, here’s what I thought in the early stages of the OJ Simpson case: “Who is OJ SImpson?”
Here is what I thought in the early stages of the Michael Jackson case: “Ugh! People voluntarily brought their kids to him and left them there? IDIOTS!”
And when I FIRST heard about the Zimmerman case, before I heard the details, read the articles, and started to study it, here is — very unfortunately — what I thought: “OH GOD I hope Zimmerman is not a Jew!”
Well I think Zimmerman told a bunch of lies to the cops and to his father and that is going to be his downfall.
But I do not have any faith in the justice system to do what is right these days, particularly in Florida. I posted a case of a woman who obviously qualified for SYG, did not kill anyone by only firing a warning shot and is looking at a mandatory 10 year sentence. She is black.
The justice system is not blind, it is cruelly insane these days.
Lacks all common sense because our laws have been perverted by ALEC & right wing orgs like NRA. Shootings and killing goes up? Its good for the gun manufacturers, the more ammunition sold and USED the better for their bottom line. How perverted is that?
TonyC. – And see Tony, you have a pre-concieved notion that I know nothing about psychology. How do you know that for a FACT? I ACTUALLY know a LOT about psychology. Especially the FACT that MOST teens feel they are invincible
TonyC. – “DeeDee’s testimony is going to be, and it will hold up because she is not some mastermind with balls of steel ”
And you really think Zimmerman does and was capable of making this all up on the fly?
@Bosco: y stance has always been to NOT RUSH TO JUDGEMENT until we get ALL the facts.
There is no such thing as ALL the facts, and you have already rushed to judgment: You think Zimmerman acted in self defense and should go unpunished; you think Zimmerman was right to be suspect somebody of a crime for walking down the street. And you seem to think this has something to do with race; you cannot let that go, you seem to think Al Sharpton being involved automatically poison’s our minds. It doesn’t, I do not care what Sharpton’s involvement is. Zimmerman’s guilt is evident on the evidence we already have, Sharpton has nothing to do with it. I am not RUSHING to judgment. I don’t do that. As I said before: based on the evidence that stands before us right now, what I conclude most probably happened is enough to convict Zimmerman of manslaughter, and I have no reason to believe that the evidence I use to reach that conclusion will be proven false. If it is, I will re-evaluate, but I doubt that will be necessary. I believe Zimmerman is a threat to society and should be separated from it.
@Matt: I do not think a teenage girl is going to be deposed for hours by a professional prosecutor and lie about what she heard. That is an intimidating process, the prosecutor will make sure the girl knows the consequences of lying, and I believe she told the truth. This isn’t playing monopoly at the kitchen table; it is most likely her first and most lengthy serious contact with the machinery of justice. You simply do not know what you are talking about, Matt, when it comes to psychology. I think she told the truth, and I think the prosecutor pushed her, and vetted her, and made sure the story had no holes in it, and that is why it took hours. Then I think the prosecutor filed charges against Zimmerman based on what DeeDee’s testimony is going to be, and it will hold up because she is not some mastermind with balls of steel lying to prosecutors in order to exact revenge against Zimmerman, she is just a teenage girl telling the truth about what she heard.
Shano – “The way the NRA and the wing nuts have been taking over, simple justice seems to be lacking everywhere.”
1.) “The way the NRA and the wing nuts have been taking over.”
Really? The NRA has absolutely nothing to do with it. Read up about the second amendment, “The right to bear arms.” You want to change the constitution? I, along with EVERY SINGLE AMERICAN, have the RIGHT to carry a weapon. Like I have said multiple times, there are EXTENSIVE background checks done to ensure that the person receiving a CCW permit are LEGALLY allowed to do so. If that makes me a “wing nut” then so be it, that just makes YOU one less person that I have to “protect” if some shit goes down.
2.) “Simple justice seems to be lacking everywhere.”
Are we actually talking about JUSTICE or PRESSURED JUSTICE? Obviously, in this instance, the police in Seminole County saw that there was not enough evidence to CHARGE, and furthermore CONVICT, Zimmerman of any crime. Zimmerman said he shot in self defense, he presented with wounds that were congruent with his story of how the events unfolded that night. The gun shot was close range, something you would see with a person on top of another and the top person getting shot, which is CONGRUENT WITH HIS ACCOUNT OF WHAT HAPPENED. Then there is a witness that states he “SAW TRAYVON ON TOP OF ZIMMERMAN BEATING HIM.”
You ALL continue to throw your BLATANTLY IGNORANT statements around that Zimmerman CONTINUED to follow Trayvon even after being told not to and YOU CAN’T PROVE that he did just that! I still hold on to the FACT that, even IF he HAD continued to follow Trayvon, he has NO LEGAL…LEGAL OBLIGATION to stop. Can you call it STALKING if he had? No, you cannot. Then comes the “word exchanged” between the two of them (Z and M) that was heard through the phone. How do you KNOW FOR A FACT that TM didn’t turn back after Zimmerman lost sight of him, and confront Zimmerman himself? How do you know FOR A FACT that he didn’t tell his girlfriend (DeeDee) that he was going to go back and CONFRONT GZ?
TonyC. – You OBVIOUSLY are a MAJOR hypocrite. You state that you “believe the girlfriend (DeeDee) is stating 100% truth and Zimmerman is lying. You also state that Zimmerman was “angry” during the 911 call. I agree with SouthernBelle, to me, he sounded quite CALM and COLLECTED on the phone. I didn’t hear ANY “anger” coming from his mouth during that ENTIRE phone call. So unless you were THERE THAT NIGHT, please stop pushing your OWN agenda to try and justify how you FEEL GZ is in the wrong. Please stop putting your IGNORANT STATEMENTS about what you THINK transpired that night WITHOUT ALL OF THE FACTS.
Like I have said before, do you REALLY think that the girlfriend is going to put out ANY statement that is going to make her boyfriend out to be the aggressor? Absolutely not, if ANYTHING she COULD be the biggest liar of them all.
Strategies To Keep Anger At Bay
Breathe deeply, from your diaphragm; breathing from your chest won’t relax you. Picture your breath coming up from your “gut.”
Being out of breath from running or walking fast does not count.
Slowly repeat a calm word or phrase such as “relax,” “take it easy.” Repeat it to yourself while breathing deeply.
“F**king ****s !! ” Oh crap!” are not calming phrases
Cognitive Restructuring
Be careful of words like “never” or “always” when talking about yourself or someone else. “This !&*%@ machine never works,” or “you’re always forgetting things” are not just inaccurate, they also serve to make you feel that your anger is justified and that there’s no way to solve the problem.
“These assholes. They always get away” is not good.
Tony C,,What a WEAK response you’ve given.
“Not everything that is true has to be explicit, Bosco. When you make unqualified descriptions about what happened that treat Zimmerman’s reports about what happened as if they were facts, we are allowed to infer that you presume Zimmerman is telling the truth…YADDA YADDA YADDA”
Lets break this PATHETIC response down,,,
* “..Bosco. When you make unqualified descriptions about what happened that treat Zimmerman’s reports about what happened as if they were facts..”
Ill say again, BACK UP what you just accused me of with proof Tony..otherwise you are just as pathetic as this statement you made.
Its all still here on this thread …WHEN did i ever make
“unqualified descriptions about what (that had) happened “?
Sounds more like something you have been doing here since the beginning..making unqualified descriptions. I’m sure others here would back me up on this one AND we could cut and paste each and every ‘unqualified description’ YOU ,Tony, have made here thus far.
My stance has always been to NOT RUSH TO JUDGEMENT until we get ALL the facts. You have already convicted this guy Z since the very beginning. What was your position on the Brawley case,,and the Duke Lacrosse case??
As you have said ,”Not everything that is true has to be explicit,” Tony..its very obvious now what your stance was then too.
Tony, I do like the occasional rant, I do not necessarily consider you prejudiced. But I think it’s very easy to oversimplify matters in this case. Why should he lie when he called 911, at that point he had no reason to do so. He obviously convinced the dispatcher to not only send one but several officers. …
I want to understand what happened and why exactly it happened just as much as I want to understand the American debate, as an outsider. If I read German articles about the case they respond in ways similar to my own One Spiegel author wrote, Zimmerman reminds him of a good “Blockwart”. Blockwart was a Nazi informer for a specific block.
Maybe I mentioned somewhere that one of my constant preoccupations from 16 to now 61 has been prejudice. And one of the things I have to avoid as a non-American, is to respond to the American constitutionally guaranteed right –I understand–to bear arms with my own German experience. It doesn’t really give me the necessary understanding.
But: Your rant brings this to mind:
Richard H. King, Race, Culture and the Intellectuals 1940 – 1970
My instinct tells me Zimmerman struggles with identity issues. He may well try to stabilize his own fragile identity by trying to be a super-vigilant-good-American on the the post 911 US home-front.
In the process of reading about the Martin – Zimmerman case, I came across an article by a black woman, who gave three short examples of the discrimination she experienced. One story was about her son;
He was a good student in mathematics and had fulfilled the requirements for an (excuse me if I do not use the correct terms here) advanced course in mathematics. When the teacher entered the class he looked at him, the only black student in the room, asking him, if he had lost his bearings. He could now leave again immediately. Her son did not move. So the teacher or prof asked him to write down his grades for the necessary courses. Her son did and handed it over to him. The teacher/prof looked at what he had written in apparent unbelief and asked if he knew what the punishment for fraudulent statements was.
I found this story really painful to read, maybe since I loved mathematics too, but maybe since I vividly remember that prejudice hurts and angers much more when you are young. Later you learn to register it and move on, you’ve grown a thick skin.
southernbelle; yes, interesting that GZ defenders always want to talk about black violence statistics. I submit that this, too, has very little to do with ‘race’ and more to do with POVERTY.
You see the same sorts of violence on Native American reservations, which are some of the worst pockets of poverty in the nation along with majority black inner city communities.
Regardless, Trayvon was not in poverty, he was not in a gang, both his parents work, he got good grades.
He was middle class or a bit lower, but not in the kind of poverty that causes crime like the poor white meth producers in rural areas. Their crime rate is also caused by poverty, not the color or culture or race of the people..
““Noone knows how they come to be there””
In fairness, it has to be considered that Zimmerman did not get there because of following Martin. He could have a perfectly reasonable reason for being there in the dark.
Zimmerman was apparently on his way to the store when he spotted Martin. He might have become confused and formed an opinion that the store was located on the pathway between the two rows of houses.
“Noone knows how they come to be there”
Zimmerman got to be there because he had been following Martin. We know this from his own words.
‘There’ is at least 200 feet from the road – in the night.
“And who did you expect him to call after calling the police? His proctologist?”
I think calling his Anger Management counsellor would have been a great idea.
and he passed right on without any problems. as far as the maps, they can’t tell me what transpired at all. That’s what the case is for me, not where they were but how they got there.. Noone knows how they come to be there, Just trying to form alternate/different scenarios. That’s all. Both had the right so SYG, I understand the call Z made completely and it’s the same one that’s been argued about on this page. This case is nothing special, it happens every day and several times a day. Young african american teens, some in there early 20s are killing each other at an alarming rate. You can look up the stats on that one if you want the truth. Seldom is it white/black killings. You can go to y.tube and hear eye witness stating that Z. was asking him for help. I think that will be a big issue in court. Good Lord, he was right there talking to Z.
And who did you expect him to call after calling the police? His proctologist?
Bosco: “posted by someone here-
“Zimmerman was at the very least reckless and provoked the entire situation.”
(based on what solid information?)”
I’ve already explained, but to save you the trouble, here we go again:
Zimmerman was following Martin.
He followed him off the road and down that path between the houses in the night.
He was carrying a gun.
Neighborhood Watch have clear rules/guidelines.
1) Report only, do not engage
2) Do not carry a gun.
These rules are sensible. They are not sensible because of being NW rules. They are based on common sense. They are sensible in themselves.
Zimmerman purported to be a NW Watch Captain.
Zimmerman was engaged in studies, so he was of a mind that would read up.
It is reasonable to assume that he would be aware of the NW rules.
Even if he was not aware, that is no excuse for behaving in a way that was counter to common sense.
It is clear from the 911 recording that Zimmerman was emotionally involved in the chase. “They always get away”.
When he says “F**cking ****s”, it signifies anger.
Perhaps his shoes were not a good fit, and the chase was huring his feet. “F**cking shoes!”. Whatever he was f**king, he was angry.
He followed a suspect, while carrying a gun and while being angry.
The moment he lost sight of Martin and continued to regain contact, he had no idea whether or not he would come face to face with him.
His comment about Martin having his hand on his waistband means that he considered that martin might be armed – or he was just talking up a situation.
Non-reckless NW rules mean that following suspects (whether possibly armed or not) in the dark is best left to the police.
That is the situation without reference to anyone’s history. It stands by itself. Zimmerman was reckless. We have it all in the few minutes that covered the events.
This is independent of race and of the histories and background of both Zimmerman and Martin.
Got that?
Just from the tape and where the fight and shooting happened, down there in the dark, Zimmerman was reckless. No reference to anything or anyone outside of those few minutes.
What if we look at their histories?
Does either or both have a history that might indicate they would throw a punch?
Martin does not seem to have such a history.
Zimmerman does. He was charged with assaulting an officer. It’s not on his record because he agreed to attend Anger Management classes rather than go through with a full prosecution.
You might not be familiar with the concept of Anger Management classes, so I’ll explain.
“Anger is a completely normal, usually healthy, human emotion. But when it gets out of control and turns destructive, it can lead to problems—problems at work, in your personal relationships, and in the overall quality of your life. And it can make you feel as though you’re at the mercy of an unpredictable and powerful emotion”
Anger Management is not aimed at normal inoffensive folk who want to get really good at Anger or managing the Anger of others.
Anger Management is intended for those emotionally crippled folks who have difficulty with controlling themselves.
Zimmerman was reckless.
He ignored sensible ideas.
He ignored whatever benefit his Anger Management classes might have given him
@Bosco: Please find in any of my comments that I said that state Zimmerman is telling the truth.
Not everything that is true has to be explicit, Bosco. When you make unqualified descriptions about what happened that treat Zimmerman’s reports about what happened as if they were facts, we are allowed to infer that you presume Zimmerman is telling the truth, otherwise you would qualify your statements, you would not use only his claims to describe what happened.
Did Trayvon run? Only according to Zimmerman. I think it is at least plausible that Zimmerman lost sight of Trayvon and exaggerated that into “he ran” so the dispatcher would think Trayvon was running to escape a crime, which is what Zimmerman clearly thought, which we can infer from his statement about assholes always getting away.
“Getting away” from what? There is only one plausible meaning of “getting away,” and that is getting away from a CRIME. Zimmerman wanted the dispatcher to believe Trayvon was a criminal escaping from a crime, when he had witnessed no crime and knew of no crime.
I am just thankful we are getting a trial. The way the NRA and the wing nuts have been taking over, simple justice seems to be lacking everywhere. Do we really want Americans to accept the option of letting the police decide who to charge with any crime? Do we really want anyone to be able to shoot people if they feel threatened in the slightest degree?
Not after seeing what can happen, people will end up being afraid to take a walk ! The ‘conservatives’ talk about ‘freedom’, yet they want a society where it is everyone for themselves, no community, everyone packing guns to confront the threats they create by their own ignorance and closed mindedness.
Tony C, your words-“The problem is you assume Zimmerman is telling the truth, on the tape and afterward. Zimmerman clearly wanted the police to come out and harass Trayvon. He could be lying on the 911 tape, and all the things he says are practically designed for deniability.”
>>Tony ,are you prepared to back up your assertions/accusations here?
If you cant then you LACK credibility and would prove to be BIASED and prejudiced in your mindset.
(Holy cow,,where does one start first)
1) “The problem is you assume Zimmerman is telling the truth..”
Please find in any of my comments that I said that state Zimmerman is telling the truth.
Address this question instead of conveniently bypassing it just as you and others have been doing.
Ive always stated that we cannot rush to judgement,,regardless of who it is. Tony ,,here is a link that you NEED to review it applies to ALL Americans- http://www.aclu.org/
2) “Zimmerman clearly wanted the police to come out and harass Trayvon”
Wanted the cops to HARASS Martin? Maybe in YOUR MIND.
A great example of ASSUMING .,,once AGAIN.
(making an ASS out of you…and no one else)
(Maybe you have ESP Tony ,,you’re this threads Uri Geller).
3) “all the things he says are practically designed for deniability.”
That biased ‘logic’ can be applied to Martin’s girlfriend too, cant it??
Oh no, not her, she is above human frailties,,right?
I thought about reading the rest of this banter after Matts comment but,,whats the point?
Its all the same prejudicial blah blah blah goings on.
Oh right, I don’t have credibility because I wont read all of the ‘same old,same old’. Sorry for not reading twisted garbage oops i meant ‘logic’…
Tony, go and find those comments to back up your words. Your a ‘man of your words’ arent you? Prove it.
One more thing,,everyone….
1)What was YOUR HONEST take on the ‘Duke Lacrosse’ charge when you first heard and saw it in the news?????
2)What was your take and HONEST VIEW of the ‘Tawana Brawley’ case when it was unfolding in the news and Sharpton was doing the very same media manipulation as he has been on this case?
@leander22: if you [meet] him, his name is George Zimmerman, try to be very, very polite, some people think he is aggressive. And some of the buglaries committed here recently were [by] black and about your age.
Right. Just imagine if all the responsibility to be deferential to white authority, at the risk of their life, was on the shoulders of blacks; just imagine if all blacks were just told by their parents that when confronted by white men they should not make eye contact, but should stare at the ground and be very, very polite, because son, you are black, and the white man has more rights than you, and might kill you for mouthing off.
Actually, he did have the authority to shoot, at the exact moment that he was getting his head pounded into the concrete and he feared for his LIFE and SERIOUS BODILY INJURY.