Texas Police Officer Suspended After Reportedly Firing 41 Shots and Killing Unarmed Suspect

In Texas, Garland Officer Patrick Tuter reportedly fired 41 rounds at an unarmed man last month after a collision with the truck of Michael Vincent Allen (shown left). Now it appears that a dash-cam video contradicts what the police department first said in the case. Moreover, a witness has charged that police officers confiscated his phone and erased a video and pictures of the scene.

The confrontation occurred around midnight on August 31st after Tuter identified the white GMC pickup as the one involved in a prior chase with police. Joined by Dallas County sheriff’s deputies, Tuter pursued the truck for 30 minutes at speeds up to 100 mph and finally caught up to Allen in a cul-de-sac. Police claimed Allen collided with Tuter but the opposite appears true. Allen died with gunshot wounds and dog bites from a police dog.

Yet, Tuter’s attorney, John Snider, insists that the new information does not change the justification for force: “At some point, while trying to prevent the suspect from making an escape, Officer Tuter did feel in fear for his life and was justified in firing his weapon.”

Tuter’s 41 rounds, however, means that he had to reload and resume firing. No gun was found on Allen.

Allen was no angel to be sure, He had a long criminal record of arrests. However, the justification of not just the use of lethal force but the number of bullets has raised questions over the police response. There has long been a controversy over the use of semi-automatic weapons with large clips of ammunition. Critics charge that officers now fire more rounds and sometimes endanger both bystanders and fellow officers — as suggested in the recent shooting of pedestrians by police in New York.

One witness says that he took cellphone pictures and video of the scene but police confiscated the phone and deleted the video and pictures. The phone was returned four days later without the photos.
We have been discussing the trend of officers arresting citizens who film them in public. The alleged destruction of these photos raises obviously serious concerns over the destruction of evidence to protect a fellow officer. There also remains the question if it was Tuter who gave the false account of Allen hitting his car.

Tuter is reportedly on suspension. Yet, these allegations raise questions about his fellow officers, particularly with the destruction of the witness’ photos.

Source: Dallas News

40 thoughts on “Texas Police Officer Suspended After Reportedly Firing 41 Shots and Killing Unarmed Suspect”

  1. What the hell is taking so long? Ask yourself, if you shot someone 41 times would it take this long before they decided to arrest you or not? And, what about the photos that the cop deleted of the CRIME SEAN that were illegally taken from a person who lives there and was in there own yard? TALK ABOUT A COVER UP! Are you people blind? Do you not see what is going on? The only reason it is taking this long is so their team of lawyers can get their stories straight and find a way to white wash this and save this cop from what should be murder charges.

    1. Even with Texas law that allows one to shoot in defense of property, I would not shoot any crook that number of times because a grand jury would probably return an indictment against a homeowner for doing something like that. So I think that a cop doing that has to be given less leeway in such an action since he is supposed to be trained and his job is to apprehend and deliver for trial such crooks.

  2. A real hard look needed to be taken a long time ago. This is nothing new for the Garland police department. You have to get in line to sue them. As for the officer not being a good shot he fired all those shots into the cab of a pickup never once hitting the passenger sitting beside him.

  3. Paul, interesting question.

    It has been posited that violence against wives was a way for the culture to allow brutal, angry, over-controlling men a “safety valve” so they would not use their violence against others in the street, on the job, etc. A frustrated angry guy could always go home and beat the missus instead, without fear of punishment from either her OR the society. When that began to change in the 70s, it appeared that there might have been an increase in public violence. I don’t know if this theory has been tested; I’m not a social scientist. But it’s worth a check-it-out.

    Anyway, the answer to “how does a wife go to bed with such a man?” is a very easy question to ask, very difficult to answer. A lot of it has to do with whether or not there are viable alternatives, resources, support, avenues of escape — it’s not as easy as it may sound. Like charity, violence begins at home.

  4. I live in Garland and have to say the cops here have their own aganda. My son was assulted at school, requiring him to have stapes in his head for minding his own business. I was told by the cop at the school.well you can press charges but I don’t our would do any good. Even even I had a bad wreck, the cop didn’t make sure we were okay, they just started talking to each other. I have to say they are not all this way but this city is all about money money money!

  5. lexmanifesta,

    I don’t know who in the hell pulled your string but i find your post offensive and your whole interpretation to be wrong. I asked some questions concerning the law that I thought some of the lawyers on the site might address. You might want me on your jury as I would, as much as anyone, evaluate evidence without bias, although I would suggest you not testify with your big mouth.

    with no regard,


  6. Taser,

    Most departments use 9mm Glocks, although I do not know what that officer was carrying. Assuming he was using a standard issue Glock with either a 17 or 19 round magazine, he would have to have reloaded twice to fire 41 shots. With practice, it is easy to change magazines in one second or less.

    Cpl. Travis Thomasie, an Army firearms instructor, demonstrates with a standard issue Glock:

  7. The details of this case will be watched carefully by many of us going forward. As a former Police Officer I am concerned with the very aggressive posture nationwide of those who are charged with the responsibility to serve and protect. This could be totally justified but it sounds like a real hard look needs to be taken. Also take a look at a case that is being officially covered up by the Penna. State Police. WorseThanRodneyKing.com

  8. I would be interesting in knowing how many magazines were used to fire 41 shots. There was no initial or return fire by the suspect? Files were deleted from witness phones? Possible false statements by the police? Does not surprise me it is Texas, but it could be anywhere.

  9. Tuter should bee suspended, alright.

    By a rope, in the form of a noose, after being convicted of murder.

    Unfortunately, the Clash were right. Murder is a crime…unless it is done by a policeman. There won’t be any serious punishment, despite the fact that Tuter deserves execution for what he did.

  10. How does a wife sit accross the table let alone get into bed with someone so out of control

  11. As the brother of a unarmed young man shot and killed in Texas this appears to be business as usual in Texas. My brother wasn’t killed by the police but by the nephew of a Texas Ranger. When the trial occurred my mother and sister couldn’t be in the court room because it would be prejucdicial to the jury. Surprising none of the witnesses for the prosecution couldn’t be found although the majority of them lived around the corner from the police station and the defendant’s mother and his Sunday school class could be present. The defendant was acquited, self defense, even though my brother was inside the house and unarmed and no where near the defendant and was shot by the defendant from oustide the house. After being shot in the femora artery my brother died within minutes. His assailant never spent a night in jail.

  12. Leo beo bo beo, banana nanna fo feo, LeeeeO.
    If the first two letters are ever the same,
    Ya drop them both and say the name ,
    Like bob fob etc
    -The Name Game

  13. Captain Ratty is right. Nothing more than “suicide by cop”. Stroke of genius by whatever psychiatrist or psychologist dreamed up the term. Or, maybe it was just a clever officer in the officer’s guild.

    As for Andy, who still believes in “honor and integrity”; yes you are naive. I don’t believe that the cop will ever get charged let alone convicted. Afterall the best evidence was confiscated and destroyed. But if he was charged and I was defense counsel for the cop, I would certainly want Andy and his like minded brethern on the jury.

    Warm regards, Lexmanifesta

  14. “how many clips in a cops 9mm? 7, 10, 14? At minimum it is 2 reloads at maximum 5. It could all be done in about 20 seconds or less if it was only 2 reloads.”

    I grit my teeth and let the normal misuse of “clip” go unanswered (it’s a magazine, not a clip). But this one is twice removed from the actual meaning of the word. The word you were looking for is “rounds” or “cartridges”.

    As for capacity, most semi-autos used by police top out around 17 rounds (+1 in the chamber). I’m not aware of a handgun with a standard size magazine that holds 20 or 21 round magazines (though extended magazines are available in that size, I can’t imagine a police force using them though). Does anyone know of one with that capacity?

    So yeah, this guy reloaded at least once and possibly (probably?) twice.

  15. I’ve driven across Texas at least 4 or 6 times. It’s that monotonous landscape that gets you.

    But I never felt I was in dangerous country.
    Who say angels don’t take care of…..?

Comments are closed.