A Manhattan Canned Hunt: The Trump Jury is Out But is the Case in the Bag?

Below is my column in The Hill on the ongoing deliberations in the Trump trial. The instructions in the case raised concerns that the deliberations could become a legal version of a canned hunt, where the prey is trapped in a cage or fenced in areas to be dispatched. Elements of the instructions are disturbing in reducing what is required to convict the former president.

Here is the column:

Today the jury began its deliberations in the trial of former president Donald Trump. Before jurors left, however, Judge Juan Merchan framed their deliberations in a way that seemed less like a jury deliberation than a canned hunt.

For many of us, the Trump trial has seemed otherworldly, a vaguely familiar proceeding where common elements of a trial seem to have been flipped.

Even before the jury instructions, the trial was controversial for both liberal and conservative commentators. At the start of closing arguments, most honest observers were still wondering what the prosecutors were alleging as to the crime that Trump was allegedly concealing with the falsification of business records.

Then came the closing arguments. Around the country, it is standard for the government to go first with a closing to allow the defense to respond. The government is then given the privilege of a rebuttal after the defense rests. In New York, the defense must go first, giving the government free rein over its closing with no risk of contradiction from the defense. With the exception of objections, any abusive or improper arguments are left to the judge to address.

In the case of Judge Merchan, that protection was all but absent as the prosecution engaged in flagrant violations from offering testimony on unestablished facts to directly contradicting prior instructions. In one of the most egregious moments, Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass told the jury that it is an established fact that former Trump counsel Michael Cohen committed a federal election law violation on the direct orders of Donald Trump. Merchan had repeatedly said that Cohen’s earlier plea could not be used to imply the guilt of Trump. Merchan overruled an objection and Steinglass proceeded, as he did earlier in trial, to repeat the false statement.

Merchan did nothing as Steinglass told the jury that Hope Hicks cried in court because she knew that she had destroyed Trump’s defense (Hicks has never explained why she cried). Merchan did nothing as Steinglass falsely told the jury that the media and political campaigns do not do what Trump did in seeking to kill and plant stories. (This ignored, for example, that the Clinton campaign did precisely that repeatedly in the very same election, including with the false Russian collusion allegations).

It was only when Steinglass repeatedly instructed the jury on the law that Merchan finally sustained objections, at the end of his closing arguments.

So going into the deliberations, the court allowed the jury to be told repeatedly that there were federal campaign violations committed by Trump. That is not true. Putting aside that the federal government found no basis to impose a civil fine, let alone bring a criminal charge, the court barred a legal expert who could have shown that no such violation occurred. The jury does not know that. Instead, the judge allowed them to be repeatedly told a false fact that could make it difficult for anyone to acquit.

However, the instructions then went in for the kill and turned the jury deliberations into a canned hunt.

Consider just a few highlights from the curious aspects of these deliberations.

First, the judge has ruled that the jury does not have to agree on what actually occurred in the case. Merchan ruled that the government had vaguely referenced three possible crimes that constitute the “unlawful means” used to influence the election: a federal election violation, the falsification of business records, and a tax violation. The jurors were told that they could split on what occurred, with four jurors accepting each of the three possible crimes in a 4-4-4 split. The court would still consider that a unanimous verdict so long as they agree that it was in furtherance of some crime.

Second, the judge said that he would instruct the jury on the law but then omitted the key elements that established there was no federal campaign violation. Indeed, the blocked legal expert, Brad Smith, the former chair of the Federal Election Commission, was going to testify that this could not have been a federal election violation. Moreover, even if Trump’s legal settlement money could be viewed as a federal campaign contribution, it could not have been part of a conspiracy to influence the election since any reporting of a contribution would have had to occur after the election.

Third, not only can the jury disagree as to what occurred, but one of the three crimes is so circular as to produce vertigo in the jury room. The prosecutors zapped a dead misdemeanor back into life by claiming a violation under New York’s election law 17-152. The argument is that the crime was committed to further another crime as an unlawful means to influence the election. However, that other crime can be the falsification of business records. So the jury (or some jurors, at least) could find that some documents were falsified as an unlawful means of falsifying other documents.

Finally, Merchan is allowing conviction based on a  “general intent” to defraud “any person or entity,” a dangerously vague concept in this novel criminal case. Merchan has largely stuck to the standard jury instructions but this case is anything but standard. With an ambiguous claim of “influencing” an election, a general intent instruction without better definition to this case can be an invitation for bias.

Given the instructions and the errors in this trial, it would seem that an acquittal is almost beyond the realm of possibility. That leaves either a hung jury or a conviction. However, the framing of this case and failure to protect the rights of the defendant have undermined the perceived legitimacy of the proceedings and any possible verdict.

With Trump in a tight cage, Merchan just left it for the jury to deliver the coup de grace. We will see. I remain hopeful that a couple jurors will balk at this manufactured criminal theory. Canned hunts are great for trophies, not so much for trials.

Jonathan Turley is the J.B. and Maurice C. Shapiro Professor of Public Interest Law at the George Washington University Law School.

579 thoughts on “A Manhattan Canned Hunt: The Trump Jury is Out But is the Case in the Bag?”

  1. When the German NSDAP party became unhappy with acquittals of their political opponents in their court system they established The People’s Court (Volksgerichtshof) to insure the correct outcome. The Democratic party and this particular administration are so openly contemputous of us all that they use our justice system, make up law on the fly, restrict the defense, and use a venue in the most bigoted of jurisdictions.

    I wouldn’t be surprised to read about such a court and proceedings in the Old South under Jim Crow and the bad old Democrat party, but I am ashamed that such has gone so mainstream in this country that the press can barely stir except to praise it.

      1. No, in the “old” South, they used registered voters but getting to be registered was the trick. In Georgia you had to know the preamble to the State Constitution as part of the test for voters. That guaranteed white juries and virtually no civil rights for Black Americans. No white man was convicted on a Black Man’s testimony until post WW2. Read “Murder In Coweta County” which was a non fiction account of the murder and trial . I am pretty sure that is the accurate title. No special courts were required, just a perversion of the constitution and the law.

        1. Just FWIW, which political party ran things in the Old South, where they had these crooked juries??? DEMOCRATS!

    1. Mind you, it took only 6 and a half years from taking over to mass murders, courtesy of their version of Merchan.

      1. That’s an equally scary part, isn’t it? What’s coming?

  2. If Trump had not been a candidate would he or Cohen have paid the extortion? Is there evidence he would have?

    Yes, the jury will convict but the question is on how many counts. All charges, no doubt.

    1. Is there evidence he would have?

      Yes Pecker provided that evidence of Working with Trump before he sought office. Along with a list of other people having public notoriety.

      1. @Iowan2,

        Testimony read back to the jury about Pecker,

        “ The prosecutor had asked him, “The purpose of that part was to benefit the campaign; am I understanding it right?” “That’s right,” Pecker said.”

        That’s essentially a violation of election law in NY.

        1. That is mind reading from Pecker. EVIDENCE proves Trump was protecting his Reputation long before he ran for office.
          IF there can be other motivating factors FEC law instructs there is NO FEC violation.

  3. The trouble began by taking the oath:

    Oath: I swear that the evidence that I shall give shall be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help me God. Affirmation: I solemnly affirm that the evidence that I shall give shall be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.

  4. The other crime explained in detail for those who still doubt its existence.

    “ “Section 17-152 of the New York Election Law provides that any two or more persons who conspire to promote or prevent the election of any person to a public office by unlawful means and which conspiracy is acted upon by one or more of the parties thereto, shall be guilty of conspiracy to promote or prevent an election,” the instructions read.

    “Under our law, a person is guilty of such a conspiracy when, with intent that conduct be performed that would promote or prevent the election of a person to public office by unlawful means, he or she agrees with one or more persons to engage in or cause the performance of such conduct.”

    As Merchan explains that the jury needs to unanimously find that the conspiracy was to promote Trump’s election by “unlawful means,” but that they do not have to agree on what those means are, Juror 10 appears to nod.”

    This Jury seems to be really paying attention and wanting details explained further. That should be good news for Trump. It means they will likely get into the nitty gritty technicalities of determining a verdict without a reasonable doubt. These re-readings of instructions may be rebutting Turley’s claims that reversible errors are present.

    1. New York law applies to New York elections. Trump was running for a federal office.

      1. @EdwardMahl,

        No, it applies to election to “a” public office. The law does not say it only applies only to NY elections.

        “ Section 17-152 of the New York Election Law provides that any two or more persons who conspire to promote or prevent the election of any person *to a public office* by unlawful means…”

        Trump has to get elected in NY to qualify for federal office. He has to get elected several states.

        1. George – New York State does not have jurisdiction to make laws governing federal elections, regardless of the phrasing of the statute. Can you cite any case where this law has been used to prosecute anyone for conduct involving a federal election?

  5. Trump going falling asleep again. This seems to be an issue. It seems he wants to out sleep sleepy joe. Yeesh. I suspect Trump suffers from sleep apnea.

  6. This is what will presumably apply to Cohen’s testimony.

    “ You may consider whether a witness had, or did not have, a motive to lie. If a witness had a motive to lie, you may consider whether and to what extent, if any, that motive affected the truthfulness of that witness’s testimony. If a witness did not have a motive to lie, you may consider that as well in evaluating the witness’s truthfulness.”

    Oh, of anyone wants to follow the proceedings,

    https://www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/live-blog/rcna154607

  7. Thank you professor for pointing out all the flaws in this case, the obvious bias by a corrupt judge.

    1. The corruption of the judge is so blatant, obvious and egregious it is undeniable. And yet here it is being done so starkly in front of the whole world, with a straight face.
      The bias is so obvious, the errors so frequent and huge, ye cannot believe this judge doesn’t know exactly what he is doing, and knows what he is doing is obvious wrong to everyone watching.
      I guess a person with Trump Derangement Syndrome can be that mentally unhinged so as to think what they are doing is legitimate when it is violating all norms of procedure.
      But, alternately this judge may have been told to do this, and/or he has told someone else this is what he is going to do. In that case, he has broken criminal law. If there were any communications of this nature with this judge, then it may be discoverable.

      1. Gee Trieste,
        Well said.
        There are communist countries, dictatorships taking notes of how to have sham trails and get away with it.

      2. Yeah, Trump could have gotten Alito to hear the case, then it would be fair, right?

  8. For those who keep saying “where’’s the crime?”

    Judge Merchan telling the jury,

    “ I will now instruct you on the law applicable to the charged offenses. That offense is Falsifying Business Records in the First Degree — 34 Counts.”

    THAT is the crime Trump is being charged with.

    1. Got it George, Paying a lawyer’s invioce, and calling it a legal expense is hiding a crime.

      Except the action would not be public until AFTER the election.

    2. George, Hunter Biden goes on trial next week. Will you be as worked up about that one, too?
      Will you breathlessly post countless comments about his lies and crimes? Or not, because he’s a (D)?
      Since you’re so concerned with ‘no one being above the law’, you’re probably looking forward to it.

      1. @anonymous,

        Oh you bet, that’s a trial worthy of following. I’m sure professor Turley will follow it as diligently as I.

    3. No, THAT is not the crime, you are missing elements of the crime charged.
      Trump is being charged with Falsifying Business Records in the First Degree in furtherance of another crime.
      If all he did was falsify business records, then he is acquitted.

      1. If all he did was falsify business records, then he is acquitted.

        Thats the only stated crime in the indictment.

        I agree. ALL the prosecution witnesses provided evidence the DJT never interacted with his accounting group, as they did their job, aided by their experience and accounting software.

        1. @Iowan2,

          “ Thats the only stated crime in the indictment”

          I thought there was no crime according to Turley and many others here. Now there is? Curious.

          DJT interacted with Pecker and Cohen who are co-conspirators in their intent to defraud. Conspiracy is what applies in determining if Trump committed a crime. Which involved falsifying business records in furtherance of benefitting his election to public office. That’s what made it a felony.

          1. DJT interacted with Pecker and Cohen who are co-conspirators in their intent to defraud

            Stay on topic George. Falsifying business record. Pecker has no relevance.

          2. There is no crime.
            There is a partially stated crime that is missing the element of the “in furtherance of” crime.
            So, there is no crime, and there is no fully stated crime, only a partially stated crime — which is not a stated crime.
            The part of the partially stated crime could be a crime in of itself if it had not expired from statute of limitations, but it has and requires a second crime to make it viable.
            The second crime had not been stated.

      2. @Gee Trieste,

        “ If all he did was falsify business records, then he is acquitted.”

        In NY falsifying business records IS a crime. If all he did was falsify records then he is guilty of the crime.

          1. No, first degree felony. Trump’’s lawyers are not disputing that at all.

        1. Not in this case. If all he did was falsify records, then he could not be found guilty because that crime is beyond statute of limitations.

    4. “That offense is Falsifying Business Records in the First Degree — 34 Counts.”
      THAT is the crime Trump is being charged with.”

      According to New George, the Speech Moron, the falsified business record is a check. It’s impossible to argue with a dummy who gets everything wrong. One first has to correct him so that the discussion can continue. But each step of the way he provides additional erroneous statements thinking he is smart.

      Already today he has made over a dozen errors, so to prevent such errors he copies and pastes. That doesn’t answer the legal questions asked and only provides a statement which itself is frequently wrong.

      We need to ask this dummy to define his words and explain how they are being used. We need to hold his responses to the questions asked. Actually we need do nothing because I think most people recognize him as an idiot.

  9. WE live our lives in a “Canned Hunt”.
    Held in; Financial, Social, and Psychological Cages waiting for the final slaughter by; Politicians, Judges, Hedge-fund Managers, Media Moguls, The Police State… that’s life inside the boarders of the United States, a Canned Hunt.

  10. Jury getting re-reading of instructions from Merchan. Looks like another tense filled day for Trump supporters. This will be either a short day or a very long day.

  11. “ Merchan has largely stuck to the standard jury instructions but this case is anything but standard. With an ambiguous claim of “influencing” an election, a general intent instruction without better definition to this case can be an invitation for bias.”

    Merchan is running proceedings according to NY law, not federal law which seems to be the basis of Turley’s arguments. Every state has their own peculiar criminal laws. The Supreme Court made this point in 2020,

    “ In a 2020 opinion, the Justices explained that due to their narrow construction of the federal criminal statutes, “federal fraud law leaves much public corruption to the States (or their electorates) to rectify.” Kelly v. United States, 140 S. Ct. 1565, 1571-73 (2020).”

    This is why claims that fraud is strictly defined by the constitution or by SCOTUS are grossly flawed. SCOTUS talks about federal law, not state law which the constitution leaves it to the states to define for themselves based on their legislature’s views for state laws.

    1. All they want, come hell or high water, a hail Mary pass, Anything to just get a conviction here and now, no matter how flimsy and inevitable the reversal on appeal. Makes no difference what comes later, their reputations and mockery that will come later. Nothing matters now, except to eke out a conviction.
      The timing here for them is everything. Get Trump to have the moniker “Convicted Felon” for next few months, so they can use, overuse, jabber it all day long. And hope that will affect the election.

      1. Gee Trieste,
        The fun part about this sham trial is how it puts on gross display of what a sham trial it is. The good professor and other real lawyers, non-DNC hack MSM lawyers, are pointing it out. And more and more people are seeing it.
        Have to wonder if their betting on “Convicted Felon” might backfire on them.

  12. Stefanik Complaint: Judge Merchan Was ‘Intentionally Selected’ To Ensure Trump Is Convicted
    “One cannot help but suspect that the ‘random selection’ at work in the assignment of Acting Justice Merchan, a Democrat Party donor, to these cases involving prominent Republicans, is in fact not random at all.”
    By: Monroe Harless – The Federalist ~ May 29, 2024
    https://thefederalist.com/2024/05/29/stefanik-complaint-judge-merchan-was-intentionally-selected-to-ensure-trump-is-convicted/

  13. “@Liz_Wheeler

    I generally avoid predictions…

    But here’s my prediction of what will happen in this Trump trial…

    Trump will be convicted.

    This is due to a biased jury & radical leftist judge. In reality he’s innocent, which is obvious from the facts of the case. But… nonetheless, he’ll be convicted.

    Trump will then be the “convicted felon” that Democrats want for campaign ads.

    Will Trump go to prison?

    Not right away. The Democrats will use the “convicted felon” “criminal” “facing prison time” language in the lead up to the election, but they won’t dare send him to prison before Election Day because it would energize Trump’s base ten times more than the epic Trump mugshot.

    The Democrats will try to cheat (again) & rig the election (again), to prevent Trump from getting to the White House. They’ll probably be successful in their cheating, due to the fact that Republicans have done nothing to counter the Democrat electioneering of 2020.

    Subsequently, if Joe Biden “wins” the election, Trump most likely won’t go to prison because Democrats will be wide-eyed innocent liars when they claim “We don’t want it to appear that we’re targeting political enemies.”

    But, if Trump wins because Republican voter turnout is so enormous it overcomes Democrat cheating, then Trump will be sent to prison.

    When? When the radical leftist Marxist Democrats who hate our country—and us—are ready for revolution.

    Because, if Trump is sent to prison—even as POTUS—it will spawn political violence. The left knows this and it’s what they want.

    The Democrats will try to blame Trump supporters for the violence. But ultimately remember, it’s NOT conservatives who want violence. It’s the bloodthirsty communist left who want a “civil war.” They want unrest, riots, anarchy & violence because it will allow them to usurp our rights in the name of “safety” and “democracy” & to overthrow our system of republican government and instead impose the tyranny they admit they want.

    2025 isn’t going to be pretty.

    We have Islamist terrorists hidden in our cities.

    We have sympathizers of genocidal terrorists marching on our college campuses (and in Congress!).

    We have drug cartels operating in all 50 states whose business is the killing of our citizens with fentanyl.

    Our institutions—from healthcare to education—are captured by Marxists.

    Our financial system has been primed to be weaponized against us with ESG.

    The value of our dollar is so fragile thanks to deliberate overspending by Biden that all of our wealth & prosperity is hanging by a thread.

    And one half of the American public—who probably hate being called American—has been conditioned to hate anyone who is white, Christian, conservative, or believes in free speech. This hateful mob have proved themselves willing to burn businesses, assault law enforcement, target Trump supporters, persecute Christians, censor conservatives, and establish anarchy at the slightest emotional impetus.

    This brainwashed mob now just awaits word from the Democrats to unleash violence against us—again. And this time, as recorded conversations from inside radical orgs have shown, the violence they plan will be worse than the Summer of Rage 2020.

    Trump’s impending, bogus conviction is a key part of this plot. Nothing but extreme, repeated wrong deliberately inflicted by the left on the right all but ensures that some righteously angry but imprudent idiot acts out in violence if Trump is sent to prison, thereby setting the stage for the revolution the left wants.”
    6:51 PM · May 29, 2024

    1. I agree that Trump is most likely to be convicted, because of the bias in the jury pool and in the way the trial was conducted, but I do not think Trump will go to prison. Even if he is sentenced to a prison term I suspect its commencement will be deferred pending appeal (so long as this is permitted by NY law), which could take years and ultimately may be resolved by the Supreme Court. I don’t think a conviction will survive appeal in the end.

      It’s hard to know how a conviction will affect Trump’s chances in the election.

  14. Imagine being a soldier put in harm’s way
    to protect such things back home as
    kangaroo courts.

  15. What typically happens is the left so muddys the waters with their despicable actions that the nation doesn’t want more of it to punish the left as they must be to deter them in the future.
    I wonder if attacking Trump and his staff is insulation.

  16. Q. If the President is found guilty what’s the odds Merscum puts a leg monitor on him and confines him to home until he decides the degree of penalty?

    1. The “President” is not on trial here.
      The criminal defendant in this case is private citizen Donald Trump.

      He will be remanded in custody to await sentencing, because he is an extreme flight risk.

      1. “The criminal defendant in this case is private citizen Donald Trump.”

        The defendant in this case is the Republican Presidential candidate. If he were a private citizen, none of this would happen. It is a blatant action of election interference. The left used organized cheating in the last election and now is wrongly using the judiciary to impair the candidate’s ability to run.

        Any conviction will eventually be found to be improper. Anyone wishing a free America to survive needs to vote for Donald Trump and not vote for any Democrats. The Democrat Party needs to disappear, permitting honest Americans to form a new party or parties.

    2. Margot;
      A non pedantic answer, is the clear law says yes, Merchan CAN sentence President Trump to Jail.
      Now politics enters. It is a game of soothsaying, to determine what the DNC machine, manipulating Merchan, to provide maximum Political advantage to Joe Biden.
      Home confinement and or Parole is the most relevant. That possibly would limit the President from campaigning at will.
      Much like the Gag order, there are serious constitutional issues, to limiting a candidate running for political office.
      Rational people would allow the convicted candidate to be free during the appeal process. As is done 100’s of times a day, all across the nation.

      1. ***Much like the Gag order, there are serious constitutional issues, to limiting a candidate running for political office.***

        It may be possible to argue there are constitutional issues in gagging a CANDIDATE.

        However there are no constitutional issues whatsoever if a candidate is also an IMPRISONED CONVICTED FELON.

        If that were the case every convicted felon in prison would file for an elected office tomorrow and demand to be released.

        Try to think it through when you make a ridiculous claim !!!!

    3. He could do that. Or sentence him to time served and given him probation with strict conditions. That is also possible. OR he could send trump to prison for 3 months. That’s a light sentence be legal standards.

  17. Is Merchan breaking the law?
    With a corrupt judge like Merchan, there was no need for the prosecution to even show up. He did their job for them.
    Is he on their payroll?
    Is anyone going after Merchan for his in-kind contribution to Biden’s campaign?

  18. Jon, you’re saying today is conviction day, aren’t you? I’m in full agreement with you on that point. A conviction on the crimes of a wildly corrupt ex president is a great day for America. Looking forward to seeing magats spit, snarl and howl over it.

  19. Is Turley really a lawyer?

    “ Merchan did nothing as Steinglass told the jury that Hope Hicks cried in court because she knew that she had destroyed Trump’s defense (Hicks has never explained why she cried). Merchan did nothing as Steinglass falsely told the jury that the media and political campaigns do not do what Trump did in seeking to kill and plant stories.”

    If there was an issue with those comments by Steinglass it was not the job of Merchan to do something about it unless the defense objects to it. Turley doesn’t say the defense objected to those two statements. If the defense doesn’t object it’s on them. This is how courts work. The prosecution objected when the defense made a comment that required judge Merchan to instruct the jury to disregard the comment. The prosecution did objected to multiple comments or claims and were sustained. The defense did not seem to object to a lot of comments from the prosecution.

    “ Finally, Merchan is allowing conviction based on a “general intent” to defraud “any person or entity,” a dangerously vague concept in this novel criminal case.”

    It wasn’t vague. This is according to NY law.

    Merchan tells the jurors that in determining intent, they can ask: What did the person do or say? Was the result the natural or probable outcome?

    The intent to defraud need not be an intent to defraud any particular person or entity and can extend beyond economic concerns.

    There are several definitions of “intent to defraud” in NY law.

    “ Falsifying business records
    This is a misdemeanor or felony offense that includes “intent to defraud” as an element. New York Penal Law § 175.05 defines falsifying business records in the second degree as having “intent to defraud”.

    Offering a false instrument for filing
    New York Penal Law § 175.35 defines “intent to defraud” as an act or behavior that leads someone into error or disadvantage.

    Scheme to defraud
    New York Penal Laws § 190.60 and § 190.65 both include “intent to defraud” as an element:
    Scheme to defraud in the second degree: This offense requires “intent to defraud” along with other elements, such as depriving another party of property or services through false or fraudulent pretenses.”

    “ A long line of New York state court cases supports an expansive conception with respect to § 175.00 crimes – namely, that intent can be established when a defendant acts “for the purpose of frustrating the State’s power” to “faithfully carry out its own law. On this standard, the law does not require prosecutors to show “pecuniary or potential pecuniary loss” to the government or otherwise. Id. Indeed, New York Jurisprudence (Second Edition 2023) in a section titled, “Indictment or information charging falsification of business records,” states: “In an indictment for first degree falsification of business records, the grand jury presentation is not required to establish commercial or property loss.”

    This is why Turley and others argue these definitions from a federal perspective which is wrong. It’s a state law. Not a federal law.

    1. “Is Turley really a lawyer?”

      If [the Left] Only Had a Brain

      “I could while away the hours
      Conferrin’ with the flowers,
      Consulting with the rain;
      And my head I’d be a scratchin’
      While my thoughts are busy hatchin’
      If I only had a brain.”

      But it doesn’t. So it stoops to childish smears.

Comments are closed.