A Manhattan Canned Hunt: The Trump Jury is Out But is the Case in the Bag?

Below is my column in The Hill on the ongoing deliberations in the Trump trial. The instructions in the case raised concerns that the deliberations could become a legal version of a canned hunt, where the prey is trapped in a cage or fenced in areas to be dispatched. Elements of the instructions are disturbing in reducing what is required to convict the former president.

Here is the column:

Today the jury began its deliberations in the trial of former president Donald Trump. Before jurors left, however, Judge Juan Merchan framed their deliberations in a way that seemed less like a jury deliberation than a canned hunt.

For many of us, the Trump trial has seemed otherworldly, a vaguely familiar proceeding where common elements of a trial seem to have been flipped.

Even before the jury instructions, the trial was controversial for both liberal and conservative commentators. At the start of closing arguments, most honest observers were still wondering what the prosecutors were alleging as to the crime that Trump was allegedly concealing with the falsification of business records.

Then came the closing arguments. Around the country, it is standard for the government to go first with a closing to allow the defense to respond. The government is then given the privilege of a rebuttal after the defense rests. In New York, the defense must go first, giving the government free rein over its closing with no risk of contradiction from the defense. With the exception of objections, any abusive or improper arguments are left to the judge to address.

In the case of Judge Merchan, that protection was all but absent as the prosecution engaged in flagrant violations from offering testimony on unestablished facts to directly contradicting prior instructions. In one of the most egregious moments, Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass told the jury that it is an established fact that former Trump counsel Michael Cohen committed a federal election law violation on the direct orders of Donald Trump. Merchan had repeatedly said that Cohen’s earlier plea could not be used to imply the guilt of Trump. Merchan overruled an objection and Steinglass proceeded, as he did earlier in trial, to repeat the false statement.

Merchan did nothing as Steinglass told the jury that Hope Hicks cried in court because she knew that she had destroyed Trump’s defense (Hicks has never explained why she cried). Merchan did nothing as Steinglass falsely told the jury that the media and political campaigns do not do what Trump did in seeking to kill and plant stories. (This ignored, for example, that the Clinton campaign did precisely that repeatedly in the very same election, including with the false Russian collusion allegations).

It was only when Steinglass repeatedly instructed the jury on the law that Merchan finally sustained objections, at the end of his closing arguments.

So going into the deliberations, the court allowed the jury to be told repeatedly that there were federal campaign violations committed by Trump. That is not true. Putting aside that the federal government found no basis to impose a civil fine, let alone bring a criminal charge, the court barred a legal expert who could have shown that no such violation occurred. The jury does not know that. Instead, the judge allowed them to be repeatedly told a false fact that could make it difficult for anyone to acquit.

However, the instructions then went in for the kill and turned the jury deliberations into a canned hunt.

Consider just a few highlights from the curious aspects of these deliberations.

First, the judge has ruled that the jury does not have to agree on what actually occurred in the case. Merchan ruled that the government had vaguely referenced three possible crimes that constitute the “unlawful means” used to influence the election: a federal election violation, the falsification of business records, and a tax violation. The jurors were told that they could split on what occurred, with four jurors accepting each of the three possible crimes in a 4-4-4 split. The court would still consider that a unanimous verdict so long as they agree that it was in furtherance of some crime.

Second, the judge said that he would instruct the jury on the law but then omitted the key elements that established there was no federal campaign violation. Indeed, the blocked legal expert, Brad Smith, the former chair of the Federal Election Commission, was going to testify that this could not have been a federal election violation. Moreover, even if Trump’s legal settlement money could be viewed as a federal campaign contribution, it could not have been part of a conspiracy to influence the election since any reporting of a contribution would have had to occur after the election.

Third, not only can the jury disagree as to what occurred, but one of the three crimes is so circular as to produce vertigo in the jury room. The prosecutors zapped a dead misdemeanor back into life by claiming a violation under New York’s election law 17-152. The argument is that the crime was committed to further another crime as an unlawful means to influence the election. However, that other crime can be the falsification of business records. So the jury (or some jurors, at least) could find that some documents were falsified as an unlawful means of falsifying other documents.

Finally, Merchan is allowing conviction based on a  “general intent” to defraud “any person or entity,” a dangerously vague concept in this novel criminal case. Merchan has largely stuck to the standard jury instructions but this case is anything but standard. With an ambiguous claim of “influencing” an election, a general intent instruction without better definition to this case can be an invitation for bias.

Given the instructions and the errors in this trial, it would seem that an acquittal is almost beyond the realm of possibility. That leaves either a hung jury or a conviction. However, the framing of this case and failure to protect the rights of the defendant have undermined the perceived legitimacy of the proceedings and any possible verdict.

With Trump in a tight cage, Merchan just left it for the jury to deliver the coup de grace. We will see. I remain hopeful that a couple jurors will balk at this manufactured criminal theory. Canned hunts are great for trophies, not so much for trials.

Jonathan Turley is the J.B. and Maurice C. Shapiro Professor of Public Interest Law at the George Washington University Law School.

579 thoughts on “A Manhattan Canned Hunt: The Trump Jury is Out But is the Case in the Bag?”

  1. Jury at lunch after requesting Pecker and Mike’s testimony to compare side by side. Not good for trump because they were aligned in what they testified to…

    My guess is they’re addressing whether to convict on all 34 counts, or convict on a lesser #. Either way: conviction.

    What’s funny to me, and what really should be viewed by history post conviction is the press’ desire to declare Pecker More trustworthy than Mike. Pecker ran a tabloid that was entirely willing to help trump cheat to win an election, after all.

  2. Since 2015, the Blob and their Democratic party minions have actually done everything they’ve accused Trump of doing. Their ultimate act of hypocrisy is to indict and prosecute Trump for a conspiracy to interfere in a presidential election. Their actions ARE a massive conspiracy to influence the 2024 election.

    1. The 2024 presidential election will be a referendum on lawfare.

      1. Every election is a referendum on “free stuff” and “free status.”  

        Actual Americans want nothing more than the severely limited and restricted government and the maximal freedom for individuals that the Constitution and Bill of Rights establish and provide.

        The communists (liberals, progressives, socialists, democrats, RINOs, AINOs) demand unconstitutional benefits and entitlements—unconstitutional “free stuff” and “free status.” 

      2. True that. Hell, I can imagine this jury having to consider the possibility they too could be indicted for conspiring to influence an election if they vote to convict Trump.

  3. There was a time in the history of America’s representative democracy when the nation’s electors were sidelined and replaced by a mere twelve New York State citizens. Whether they realized it or not the twelve were kept deceived in a judicial setting masterminded and controlled by members of a highly partisan corps who were blind, passionate, and unreasonable in their effort to upend a national presidential election. Would any of the twelve, even if they were so blind, passionate, and unreasonable themselves, come to appreciate the gravity of their few brief moments in American history deciding the fate of the onetime an election and its votes should lie directly in the hands of all the people? I guess we are soon to see.
    https://www.pennlive.com/resizer/jmNyc2P8q3njniM6lWXn0rRmoDw=/1280×0/smart/advancelocal-adapter-image-uploads.s3.amazonaws.com/image.pennlive.com/home/penn-media/width2048/img/opinion/photo/shutterstock-votejpg-814fef9aaf07aeecjpg-0b46375f90d1fd63.jpg

  4. Jonathan: Todd Blanche made a huge tactical blunder in his closing argument by trying to convince the jury that his client did not have sex with Stormy Daniels. Blanche took that approach under orders from his client. No one on the jury thinks DJT did not have sex with the porn star.

    Belatedly, there is now confirmation from a “celebrity athlete” who was at the 2006 American Center Championship celebrity golf tournament in Nevada. The Beast is reporting (5/29) the athlete, who wanted to remain anonymous because of fear of harassment, says he was close to DJT and Daniels during the tournament. The Beast interviewed the athlete who says DJT boasted about having sex with a “porn star” at the tournament: “It was clear to me and everyone who heard him that he was talking about Stormy…He’d say all these things like, ‘You’ve got to bang a porn star, it’s incredible’, and ‘It added 20 yards to my drive today'”. Sounds like DJT doesn’t it?

    The athlete also told the Beast he has not shared the story widely and the prosecutors in the Manhattan trial never interviewed him. That’s probably because the trial was never really about Daniels–it was about falsifying business records to conceal the sex with Daniels so voters would not find out.

    FOOTNOTE: There were 80 celebs who participated in the 2006 golf tournament. The actor and scratch golfer Jack Wagner won the $100,000 grand prize. Where did DJT come in? He was 62nd and got no prize money. Steve Spurier came in 45th and won $3,588, Dan Quale came in 43rd but also won no prize money. It seems the only golf tournaments DJT can actually win are his own. And we know why–he cheats!

    1. Having followed the Trial, I beleive it is LESS likely that Trump had sex with Daniels today than 6 weeks ago.

      No, this is not a tactical blunder.

      As has been noted here – and elsewhere – it is the PROSECUTIONS burden to produce the witnesses to support their claims.

      I beleive Trump actually got a jury instruction to that effect.

      We have Several instances in this case – the alleged sex with Daniels being one of those where there ARE 3rd parties that can either bolster or undermine prosecution witnesses testimoney. Trump’s body guard at the 2006 Golf Tournament according to Daniels obesrved her enter Trump’s penthouse. Yet he was not called by the prosecution to testify.

      Cohen testified about a phone call to Shiller that was than passed to Trump.
      Bragg did not call Shiller to testify.

      Cohen testified to meetings with Trump and Weiselberg.
      Bragg did not call Wieselberg to testify.

      I have noted that there is zero possibility in h311 that Weiselberg will ever testify in a court with Judge Merchan ever again in his life – and who can blame him. But that is a Problem of Bragg and Merchan’s making – Not Trump’s.

      If I were to guess Weiselberg would refuse to testify even if given 100% immunity.
      Again who would blame him – Weiselberg has ZERO reason to Trust Bragg or Merchan.

      You like to rant about prosecuting Weiselberg for non-perjuries. But in fact what MErchan specifically and Bragg more generally have done is instead of flipping Weiselberg they have made him unavailable as a witness.

      A jury is required to conclude that if the prosecution did not call a witness that could corroborate an element of the case and they did not,
      that witnesses testimony would not have corrobroated.

    2. A significant part of the defense case is to make the case for reversal so airtight that they can get a quick reversal if they get a conviction.

      While I am not sure that is possible, this is still one of the best cases ever for immediate reversal.
      Worse Still – Merchan/Bragg by improperly dragging FECA law into the case have assured an expedited FEDERAL appeal.
      Normally a defendant must exhaust all state appeals before getting into the federal courts.

      But by making uncharged allegations of federal crimes – tax fraud and FECA violations – Trump can probably get into Federal courts immediately.

      There is a reasonable chance that a federal court will say – NYS courts can not prosecute Federal crimes. PERIOD
      Start over.

    3. With respect to your “confirmation” – as noted before – the burden of proof is on the PROSECUTION.

      The failure to present this alleged witness at trial is a PROSECUTION failure.

      As to the allegation itself.

      Sorry
      First – I do not believe YOU.
      I believe pretty much nothing you say that you do not provide other sources for. And you only rarely produce these.

      Whether Trump had sex with Daniels or not is unimportant to this case.
      EXCEPT that if that did not happen – Daniels perjured herself.

      There are other problems – because the evidence is that DANIELS approached Cohen/Trump – not the other way arround.
      Daniels testified that to HER the election was critical – because otherwise she would not get paid.
      That said nothing about Trump’s motives, but everything about hers.

      Because Daniels approached Trump – Her actions are extortion.

      Finally – not only have witness that based on Daniels story COULD have corroborated it been brought to testify, but even Daniels openly admitted financial motive undermines her claim.

      If Daniels story was True – it would be worth far more and far more people would have been willing to pay for it.

      130K is a nuisance payment for a false but annoying claim.

    4. The Beast reporting hunted gossip. The Beast never sought coroborating evidence.

      Dennis the lawyer is oblivious to the obvious lie.

    5. So Trump did not win a celebrity Golf match in 2006 ?

      So What ?

      We have more evidence of cheating today – but Not by Trump.

      It appears the entire democratic party from the President on down won’t even try to win a fiar contest.

      First we have Hillary with the Russian Collusion Hoax, Then Joe Biden using his campaign to bury the Hunter Biden Laptop – didn’t ajury just decide that was criminal election fraud ? Is is it only Republicans that can be guilty of fraud ?
      Then we have massive ballot harvesting in 2020.

      And now we have lawfare, and corrupt judges and clueless juries.

      So much for ever going to New York again.

      Just too dangerous.

  5. The “blocked legal expert” would actually be (former FEC chair) Bradley Smith, not Ben Smith.

    1. Bradley A. Smith

      Bradley A. Smith was nominated to the Federal Election Commission by President William Clinton on February 9, 2000, and confirmed by the U.S. Senate on May 24, 2000.
      ______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

      Judge limits scope of testimony from Trump’s planned expert witness. Trump’s team wanted the expert to testify about details of campaign finance law.

      Justice Juan Merchan has sharply limited what Trump’s planned expert witness can testify about.

      Trump’s defense team wants to call election law expert Brad Smith to testify about federal campaign finance law. But the judge ruled this morning that allowing Smith to testify expansively on that topic would supplant the judge’s role to determine what the law is.

      – Politico

  6. It seems Trump was so bored they provided him with a TV in the holding room. He must be kept awake with a…TV. Something needs to keep him animated. Perhaps a glimpse of his dozen or so supporters outside the courtroom will cheer him up.

    1. So ? What is he supposed to do, watch the paint peel ?

      Of course this is boring as hell.

      And as is typical NY has process anomolous of the rest of the country and Trump must be physically present in court for deliberations.

      It is not like if he was not in the holding room, he could not be found and brought to court at a moments notice.
      It is not alike dozens of secret service agents as well as the world press do not know exactly where he is at any time.

      1. It’s not boring to the rest of those hoping Trump will finally be held accountable for something. He won’t find it boring if he ends up getting convicted.

        1. “It’s not boring to the rest of those hoping Trump will finally be held accountable for something. “

          The above quote tells us everything! Convict Trump of something, even if you don’t know what for.

          1. S. Meyer,
            Well said.
            That has been the Democrats playbook this entire time, “Get Trump, by any means necessary! Even if it means corrupting our judicial system! Even if it means election interference! Even if it means we have to destroy democracy, to save democracy! Just get Trump for . . . something!”
            Trying to imagine if Trump gets convicted in this sham trial, then wins the election. How will the TDS leftists, Democrats react? More calls for “resistance,” from her holiness, Clinton?

  7. Judge Juan Merchan’s Jury instructions were made syllogistic so the Jury could find the ‘Crime’ that did not exist.
    Thus getting Merchan and Bragg off the hook and pinning Trump’s Criminality (The Crime Sought) on the Jury.

    Slick move on the part of the Bench, someone had to be ‘The Greater Fool’, and there you have it! – The Jury.

  8. A headline on The Hill today, where this article originally was featured:
    ‘Most say Donald Trump verdict would make no difference to their vote’.
    So, conviction or not, he’ll still be in the lead compared to Biden.

    1. I have no idea how people will respond.

      There have been lots of predictions in the past regarding how people would respond to warrants, indictment, mug shots, actual trials.
      So far all of these have proven wrong.

      Unlike most of us here – most people are not paying attention to this.

      There is significant evidence they have decided it is all political and they do not care.
      But it is possible that a conviction might have an effect on the election.

      It is also likely that an acquittal of a hung jury will have an effect on the election.

  9. Dear Mr. Turley, the verdict has been in the bag from the get-go. Democrats are very clever in twisting the law to say anything they want it to. They have used the court system for years to get their way. This time it is no different. So to make sure the Democrats kept Mr. Trump out of the White House, a concerted effort was established among 4 different DA’s . the White House was also involved in counseling these DA’s on what to do. In spite of all of the democratic wrangling to upset another Trump White House, it is my hope that he will beat these charges.

    1. It does not matter whether we are dealing with a political trial such as this one or a real criminal trial – this type of conduct by the prosecutor and judge is WRONG – it is also unethical illegal and unconstitutional.

      Is this how you would want to be tried ? or your children or friends ?

      Analysing this mess is incredibly complicated – because there is error on top of error.

      Turley notes Steinglass testified in closing – which is not allowed, stating that Cohen said something he did not – also not allowed.
      but in the end it was about Federal election law which has absolutely no place in this court at all.

      This is a state court. Absent a federal conviction federal election law should not even be mentioned in this court.
      The court has no jurisdiction over it, there are no violations charged, and you may not even allege crimes not charged.

      And finally Merchan grossly misstated federal election law in the jury charge.

      What a judge says regarding the law in a court to the jury is sacred – The jury is required to assume the judges statement of the law is correct, and if the judges statement of the law is found incorrect by other courts – the case gets tossed on appeal.

      The standard for FED violations – most of which are NOT crimes, is And expense is SOLELY a campaign expense.
      Merchan stated the standard as “But for” the campaign that is the incorrect standard and it is a large error.

      But it does not end there, Merchan entirely ommitted the fact that FECA allows – because constitutionally it must, any candidate to spend as much as they please of their own money on an election, and does not even require reporting.

      And this is just one Tiny portion of this case.

      There are other huge issues. Normally a criminal case must be appealed to local/state courts before going to federal appeals courts, and then ONLY on federal constitutional grounds – though there are several of those already.

      However by trying a federal crime in a state court, Merchan has likely directly involved the Federal appeals courts.

      It is likely that Trump can go directly to the federal courts and have any negative outcome dismissed on federal supremacy grounds.

      1. @John Say,

        This is not a federal case. Your point relies heavily on the wrong interpretation of law. NY law is not the same as federal law. Conflating the two to make an argument is pretty stupid. Professor Turley fell into the same problem arguing from the perspective of federal law instead of NY State law. He’s wrong and so are you.

  10. Much is made about the fact that Trump fell asleep. Various people read too much into this.
    For one he keeps a vigorous schedule that tires out many younger people. Preparing for depositions and testimony is nerve wracking and exhausting just by the expenditure of pumping out epinephrine as a stress reaction. Eventually you crash. Also even with his short sleep cycle he has to sleep and despite the expressed confidence I am sure his sleep is disturbed and incomplete.
    If you have been working enough hours without sleep and you are fatigued from the physical demands of your schedule, movement helps keep you awake but then having to sit and listen to a judge drone on can be a soporific and easy to fall asleep.
    I fell asleep, standing up, in surgery as a medical student. Up all night, then went to surgery with my patient who was being operated on by the chief of surgery. In an operation such as that, the only people doing anything fun or interesting are the surgeon, assistant surgeon, the anesthesiologist to some degree (depending on the operation) and the instrument nurse. The medical student is basically a pair of extra hands that hold retractors. Your hands belong to the surgeon as he positions your hands and the retractors exactly where he wants them. The medical students body is positioned behind the chief surgeon and you get to look at his back through the whole operation. I briefly fell asleep and nodded my head and slightly jostled the surgeon. The malignant stare I received kept me awake for the rest of the surgery. So falling asleep has to be in context, just like everything else.

    1. @GEB,

      Trump often mocks Biden for his age related flaws. Here we have Trump falling asleep during a very important trial and then griping he didn’t hear or see the judge say or do things. One could assume that Trump’s mental health is spiraling out of control. All that is missing is some drool while he “naps” in court.

      Should we be considering electing Trump and expect him to remain alert and awake during important foreign affairs meetings, intelligence meetings, etc? Trump is demonstrating that he’s no different than Biden when it comes to health at old age.

      1. But this is NOT a very important trial. It is a lawless bit a nonsense and political theatre that appearently most people are not paying attention to.

        It is so unimportant that Trump did not want to be there – which is perfectly understandable. There was never any reason to require him to be there from the start.

        The US Supreme court is considering presidential immunity – and her in NYC is Bragg and Merchan giving the country an object less in why that is required.

        Though it is worse than that – lets presume as those ont he left like to claim that what is occuring in this trial is NOT a biased political witch hunt.

        All that does is condemn the NYC criminal justice system even further.

        Is this the kind of nonsense that people must face in NYC ?

        That may actually be so.

        We have seen numerous NYC cases where the DA goes after people trying to STOP crimes,
        While ignoring those that actually commit violent crimes.

        1. John Say,
          “But this is NOT a very important trial. It is a lawless bit a nonsense and political theatre that appearently most people are not paying attention to.”
          That right there!
          It is a sham trial.
          With sham charges.
          A sham judge.
          Sham prosecution.
          And everyone knows it too.
          Everyone knows the sham jurors will find Trump guilty. That is why they are not paying attention. It is Democrat lawfare.

        2. @John Say,

          It is an important trial. It’s the first criminal trial of a former president. A LOT of people are paying attention to it including Turley and members of congress.

          “ It is so unimportant that Trump did not want to be there – which is perfectly understandable. There was never any reason to require him to be there from the start.”

          NY law requires him to be there. If it was so unimportant why is he there? He can get up and leave and leave it to his lawyers to deal with it. Trump did not want to be there because no defendant really wants to be there.

          “ Though it is worse than that – lets presume as those ont he left like to claim that what is occuring in this trial is NOT a biased political witch hunt.

          All that does is condemn the NYC criminal justice system even further.”

          How? All the griping and whining is due to the fact that people don’t understand that this is NY state law. It’s their law and it’s what every state has. Each has their own peculiar quirks and ‘unfair’ penal codes. That’s why we have the 10th amendment.

          The only reason Trump is facing a criminal trial in NY is because he committed the offenses in NY. It was his decision and that of his co-conspirators to engage in something that is illegal in NY. Their laws are a bit different because NYC is a major financial hub and there are specific criminal laws that apply to what goes on in NY.

          The blame lays square with Trump and his accomplices. Not the DA or the Judge.

      2. In the event there is a conviction – the only question is how quickly will it be tossed on appeal.

        As Criminal cases go this is an entirely unimportant case. Even if Trump was “guilty” it would be inconsequential.

        As several legal experts have noted – Cohen confessed to stealing From Trump in the middle of the trial – a FAR more significant crime.

        There are so many problems with this case including this bizarre legal theory that requires a time machine.

        You can not cover up past actions to influence an election that is over.

        There is no a single crime that is alleged that occurred BEFORE the election.

        Regardless while there is the legal drama fascinating the rest of us over whether Merchan and bragg have wreaked havoc on the rule of law sufficiently to get a a manhattan jury to convict, that does nto make this case important.

        Or more accurately the case is incredibly important POLITICALLY – it is completely meaningless LEGALLY.

        Which is likely why Trump’s polling has improved slightly as the case has proceeded.

        This case is POLITICALLY important to YOU.

        But do you actually have even a small amount of confidence it will not be overturned on appeal ?

        The list of indisputable reasons this will be reversed is in the dozens.
        We are not talking minor errors.

        There must be a dozen criminal allegations that have been made in this trial that have not been charged.
        Worse still – most unlike Daniels introduction of a #metoo rape allegation which should have resulted in a mistrial, most of the uncharged allegations are CENTRAL to the prosecutions case.

        You may not try a criminal defendant for crimes you do not charge them with. That violates the 6th amendment.

        But even worse still – prosecution did not provide the defendant with the ACTUAL crime he is being prosecuted for until jury instructions.

        One of the reasons you can not prosecute uncharged crimes is so that the defendant can defend themselves.

        If the first time you learn the prosecutions actual criminal allegation is in the jury charge – that is massive legal error on the part of the court.

        1. Trying hard to be dismissive about a case that is important and will be the biggest thing in the news cycle for a while. Trump becoming a criminal felon is a big thing to a lot of people.

          Cohen’s confession is irrelevant since he gained immunity from prosecution in exchange for his testimony.

          “ There is no a single crime that is alleged that occurred BEFORE the election.”

          Yes there is. It’s been discussed in court multiple times. Denial is not going to alter reality to avoid accountability.

          “ But even worse still – prosecution did not provide the defendant with the ACTUAL crime he is being prosecuted for until jury instructions.”

          Yes they did, 34 counts of falsifying business records in the first degree. That’s the crime.

      3. So, George, when Trump mocks, it’s bad,
        but when you and Biden do it, it’s OK?

    2. I fell asleep, standing up, in surgery as a medical student. Up all night, then went to surgery with my patient who was being operated on by the chief of surgery

      Yep, I was serving as ground crew, for aerial application season. We were running 3 planes off the air strip. As I was pulling the fill hose for fuel, (they put on just enough fuel to spray off their load), the Pilot waved me off. When I got up on the wing and asked what he wanted, he explained he had dozed off during approach. He was taking a nap for an hour. I have found the very successful, often had unique sleep cycles and most lived on power naps. GI’s on the battle field soon learned you never passed up a nap. Lots of high power ceo’s do these power naps through the day.
      I’m sure this is DJT’s routine.
      Regardless, it has zero to do with the legalities of this case

  11. Why did Pecker come out hard on Trump?
    Prosecution finds it difficult to beat Pecker!

    Enquiring minds want to know!

  12. @Turley,

    Here’s a bit of Irony.

    The best outcome for everyone is for the Jury to come back and find Trump guilty of at least or more count.
    This may be contrarian to the thought, because if Trump is found guilty, he will be handicapped in terms of being able to campaign for president. Yet everyone recognizes that this entire trial is a farce, regardless of being either a Republican independent and even some or more Democrats all see the perversion of this court.

    So Trump doesn’t really lose because he is still in the mainstream and his eyes. sure Biden gets a chance to say Trump is a convicted felon yet everyone can respond with “sure he was convicted in a kangaroo court that was politically motivated. ”

    The reason this works for Trump’s advantage is that he will immediately file for appeal, and his lawyers will ask that he remain free on bail pending appeal. If the judge denies bail or releasing Trump he will further compound the election interference. This is one of those cases where Trump’s lawyers may file an emergency appeal either just to the appellate court, or also to the Supreme Court. It’s not that the Supreme Court will jump in, however, because of the applications they may want to.

    Note that the judge didn’t rule on the motion to dismiss. I may have missed something and he may have gave a ruling when he sent the trial to jury, but assuming that he could he gave himself an out so that if the jury came back with any guilty charge, he could set it aside. This may be his exit strategy because if he doesn’t do that, and Trump is found guilty when this is overturned on appeal, the judge along with the prosecution team has to be concerned with the blowback. I seriously doubt that the DOJ under Biden would charge anyone involved with election interference, however, if or when Trump is elected, he can appoint a new USAG, who will without Trump’s input or involvement pursue charges. At the same time, Trump could in civil court sue the judge and prosecution for violating his constitutional rights under the law now because he is POTUS, he would have to stay that lawsuit until he’s out of office, just to remove any question of potential bias by the court. That would be icing on the cake because clearly this case is based in politics. Brag and the judge clearly have motive to go after Trump.

    If the jury comes back and it quits Trump as truly and other legal pendants, say justice was served that the system worked that the jury yeah through this ridiculous case. Yet, those who perpetrated this fraud on the court meaning the court and prosecution will walk away Scott free. There will be no reprisals or lessons learned. The judge clearly violated several of his judicial canons. he knows that at most he’ll get a slap on the wrist. All the while his daughter will gain financially from his and his wife’s actions. In a democratic run city, the Democrats will turn a blind eye if it helps the party.

    Even if Trump is acquitted, and wins the election, would there be a case against the prosecution and judge for election interference, considering how the J6 defendants have been treated as they await trial, this could be a precedent on how to treat the judge and the prosecution team if they were to be charged.

    If you were them or a democratic shill like Denise and Giggly all I can say is be careful what you wish for.
    – G

    1. Ian,
      A very interesting analysis.
      Something to think on.
      While the DNC trolls will harp on the conviction part, if Trump plays it right, he could use or work it to his advantage. Even sell t-shirts. I think I would buy one.

      1. @Upstate,
        (Its just Gumby) 🙂

        Yes, exactly.

        Honestly, any attempt of the DNC or Biden to capitalize on this, even if Biden pardon’s Trump (which I doubt he will), it will backfire.

        Suppose they create a T-shirt of Trump’s mugshot and that he’s now a convicted felon…
        Every time you see that shirt, you remember just how badly the DNC framed and went after Trump. Tossing the rule of law to the side.

        My fear is that if Trump is acquitted, liberal pundits that support Trump, will turn a blind eye on what just happened. That the acquittal will just sweep this under the rug and people will look the other way.

        Bragg, his team and the judge all need to face the music. Same for Engoran and James.

        -G

        1. Gumby,
          I was not clear.
          If Trump were to print some kind of t-shirt playing off the conviction, that is a shirt I would buy, and send money to Trump.

    2. Note that the judge didn’t rule on the motion to dismiss. I may have missed something and he may have gave a ruling when he sent the trial to jury, but assuming that he could he gave himself an out so that if the jury came back with any guilty charge

      Turley has repeated his prediction, that he believes the Judge will toss the case for cause. He in fact has saved that last motion to dismiss, and has not ruled on it.
      IF the Jury convicts, Merchan dismisses the case for cause, and Democrats will still get to lie, and say a jury convicted DJT of a felony.
      The Narrative (PHONY) marches on.

  13. Well, the judge is almost always trying to secure a conviction. In that sense this is no different from the usual criminal trial. But what’s different here is that there’s the high profile scrutiny. That acts as a deterrent to this judicial behavior. Sometimes. But of course the media “scrutiny” is completely absent here. Because Trump.

    1. JMRJ. I thought a judge was supposed to try and secure a factual conviction or acquittal. Judges should not root for either outcome. The judge should ensure that the law is fairly applied and the rights of the defendant are upheld.

      1. Yes Jimboct
        I agree the Judge, ideally is only rooting for the rule of law. The Judge should be on the side of innocent (defendant) And Holding the prosecutions feet to the fire by forcing them strict adherence to the law and Constitutional protections

  14. RFK Jr. files FEC complaint.

    Completely on their own, the Biden and Trump campaigns announced they wanted a debate between their candidates with a time and date of their choosing. CNN agreed to cover this Presidential debate arranged entirely by these campaigns. These are not the only two people running for President.

    Without any pre-arranged date or other criteria, such as dates selected by the Presidential Commission on Debates, which would have set debates in the fall, CNN agreed to cover this debate. CNN is making an illegal corporate campaign contribution to the Biden and Trump campaigns.

    Under the Bragg doctrine, we have a case of election interference and my vote has been defrauded.

    A trial should commence immediately.

  15. I actually agree with the judge barring the testimony of Ben Smith. That’s because the question of whether Trump’s conduct is a federal election law violation is a question of law not fact. The real failure of the judge is his failure to direct a verdict on that question unless everything I have read on the issue is wrong. I’m a Trump hater, but unlike many that hasn’t blocked my objective evaluation of the evidence.

    1. @Norm,

      An expert witness can testify to the law and to the facts of the case.
      Note that the FEC had heard this complaint and did nothing.
      That is a fact and Smith who is an expert on the law and on this specific matter can explain why the FEC took no action.

      I don’t know what you’ve read, but yes, you’re wrong.
      Trump hater or not… if you had been following pundits like Turley or Dershowitz who are not fans of Trump, you’d understand what is happening and how the court just gave America a black eye.

      O’Leary said it best when he talked about America’s brand.

      -G

    2. The judge could not instruct on this question because he knows that Trump’s NDA is NOT a violation of federal law, and he knows that HE cannot enforce federal campaign laws. If he had so ruled, he would have provided a clear and easy basis for an unanimous reversal. Instead, he wanted, first, to create the impression in the jury’s mind that there had been a campaign violation and then lead the jury to believe that IT could decide in the jury room that there had been a campaign violation by Trump. Thus, he would have gotten his verdict without creating a record of how it was arrived at. Very clever and very sinister. Probably from the DOJ itself.

  16. Turley, we all know that you can never say Trump broke any laws, because you have made it clear Trump is above the law so do what you do best, write a Hunter Biden story.

    1. Do Fish have rectums? If they do, there is hope for you. Rectal Administration is another method of taking benzodiazepines. When benzodiazepines are taken rectally, only about 33% of the benzodiazepines undergo first-pass metabolism. Therefore, rectal administration has an increased effect over oral administration for the same amount of benzodiazepine

  17. One last comment on this criminal justice system, it’s apparent it makes no sense and the higher courts will overturn the conviction for now but the future isn’t so bright. Justice will eventually become just sport. Let’s arrest anyone and hang them just for fun and excitement.

  18. Jonathan: You continue to mischaracterize Justice Merchan’s jury instructions. Merchan told the jury that to convict DJT they will have to find UNANIMOUSLY on each of the 34 felony counts–that he falsified business records and did that with the intent of concealing another crime, violating NY’s state election law. Merchan told the jury that re the “other crime” they could consider three different ways the law may have been broken and only on that issue they do not have to be unanimous. That jury instruction is not a “manufactured criminal theory”!

    1. Dennis, that is exactly what Turley said, so you have misunderstood his essay. It is almost certainly a due process violation to allow conviction without unanimity about which specific unlawful means Trump intended to use. Under this instruction, not even a majority would be required. It would result in a conviction if the votes AGAINST each of the unlawful means was 7-5, 8-4 and 9-3, simply because there were 12 who thought some unlawful means was used.

  19. Off Topic – (for Jonathan)

    Why are professors trying to escape their jobs?
    The Facebook group that offers a look inside the crisis in higher education

    A Facebook group called The Professor Is Out, which has close to 33,000 members, aims to spirit dissatisfied college and university professors in the United States out of the profession and into other pursuits. The scale of the group might come as a surprise to most people, who assume that a combination of competitive salaries and flexible work schedules make academia close to an ideal workplace. Yet many professors are deeply unhappy with their jobs, their compensation and the general direction of higher education policy in the United States, especially in southern states where policymakers are eliminating job protections and imposing new speech restrictions on faculty.

    By: David Faris – The Week | under-the-radar ~ May 27th 2024
    https://theweek.com/education/professors-leaving-academia

    1. I’ll have to see it to believe it.

      Most professors, lack marketable skills. Those is stem have a larger percentage with marketable skills, but honestly, Profs that have skills along with personality traits to work for a living is a rare creature.

Comments are closed.