
Below is my column in the Hill on recent disclosure that the Biden Administration may have withheld evidence contradicting the Chinese on the origins of COVID. Millions of Americans lost loved ones and would like to know who was responsible. It appears that our government and many experts were less motivated to find that answer.
Here is the column:
Imagine a world war that left more than seven million dead, hundreds of millions became ill, wrecked the global economy, and left a generation with lasting psychological and developmental injuries.
We have seen such wars in history. What is different in this circumstance, however, is that all of that happened, and yet, years later, we still have no agreement on the original cause or possible culprits behind a pandemic that ravaged the world.
Worse yet, many politicians, experts and journalists do not seem inclined to find the answers.
This is like fighting World War II and then shrugging off the question of what actually started it.
New questions are being raised over long-withheld evidence on the origins of COVID, information that contradicted the accounts of not just the Biden administration but also allies in academia and the media.
The Chinese first reported the outbreak in December 2019 and insisted that it came from a wet market in Wuhan — a natural or “zoonotic” transfer from bats sold at the market. Others were skeptical and pointed to the nearby Wuhan government virus lab, known to have conducted coronavirus studies with bats. This lab had a history of safety and contamination concerns.
The “lab-leak theory,” which was always the most obvious explanation, was further reinforced by scientists who saw evidence of possible manipulation of the virus’s genetic code, particularly the “spike protein” that enables the virus to enter the human body in a “gain of function” operation.
There was (and still is) a serious controversy over the origins of the virus, but any debate was quickly scuttled in favor of the natural theory.
The Chinese immediately moved to crush any speculation of a lab-leak. Wuhan scientists were gagged and the Chinese refused to allow international investigators access to them or the lab in question. The Chinese also used their considerable influence over the World Health Organization and other groups to dismiss or downplay the lab theory..
Now, a long-withheld military report has finally been released by the Trump administration. It appears to confirm what was once denied by the Biden administration: U.S. military service members contracted COVID-19-like symptoms after participating in the World Military Games in October 2019 in Wuhan.
That contradicts China’s timeline. It suggests a longer cover-up in that country, which allowed the virus to spread not only to the U.S. but to countries around the world. Other nations also reported that their military personnel had fallen ill after attending the same games, suggesting that the virus was not only spreading but already raging in the area at that time.
The most disturbing aspect of this report is not the alleged conduct of the Chinese government, but that of our own.
Rumors of U.S. military personnel coming down with the virus had long been out there. Republicans in Congress repeatedly asked the Biden administration about any report on the outbreak.
Then-Pentagon spokesperson John Kirby told The Washington Post in June 2021 that the military had “no knowledge” of COVID-19 infections among the troops participating in those games.
Even as the illness associated with the games became known, the Biden administration repeatedly refused to confirm the U.S. cases, and a 2022 report was withheld from both Congress and the public.
If true, the level of duplicity and dishonesty is shocking. In the U.S. alone, more than 1.2 million died and more than 111 million were made sick by this virus. Yet the Biden administration is accused of withholding this information from the world. Why?
This disclosure follows an equally troubling disclosure that scientists in the Biden administration actually found support for the lab theory but were silenced by their superiors.
Last December, the Wall Street Journal released an alarming report on how these scientists supported the lab theory on the origin of the COVID-19 virus. Not only were the FBI and its top experts excluded from a critical briefing of Biden, but government scientists were reportedly warned that they were “off the reservation” in supporting the lab theory.
As scientists were being attacked publicly and blacklisted for supporting the lab theory, experts at both the FBI and the Energy Department found the lab theory credible. Although no theory could be proven conclusively, it was deemed a more likely scenario than the natural-origin theory. The CIA also found the lab theory credible.
What the public was hearing was entirely different. They were hearing the same narrative laid out by the Chinese government in December 2019.
The Chinese relied upon western scientists to form a mob against anyone raising the lab-leak theory as a possible explanation. Many were enlisted to sign letters or publish statements denouncing the idea. It became an article of faith — a required virtue signal among university scientists.
The western media were equally primed to quash the theory.
After President Trump embraced the lab theory, the Chinese had the perfect setup. The media was on a hair-trigger in opposition and denounced his comments as not only unfounded but also racist. MSNBC’s Nicolle Wallace mocked Trump and others for spreading “conspiracy theories.” MSNBC’s Kasie Hunt insisted that “we know it’s been debunked that this virus was manmade or modified.”
MSNBC’s Joy Reid called the lab leak theory “debunked bunkum.” Over at CNN, reporter Drew Griffin criticized the “widely debunked” theory and host Fareed Zakaria told viewers that “the far right has now found its own virus conspiracy theory” in the lab leak.
The Washington Post was particularly dogmatic. After Sen. Tom Cotton (R-Ark.) raised the lab-leak theory, he was chastised for “repeat[ing] a fringe theory suggesting that the ongoing spread of a coronavirus is connected to research in the disease-ravaged epicenter of Wuhan, China.”
The Post’s “fact checker” Glenn Kessler mocked Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas) for entertaining the theory. “I fear @tedcruz missed the scientific animation in the video that shows how it is virtually impossible for this virus to jump from the lab,” he posted. “Or the many interviews with actual scientists. We deal in facts, and viewers can judge for themselves.”
Even in 2021 when countervailing evidence was surfacing, the unrelenting attacks continued. New York Times science and health reporter Apoorva Mandavilli urged journalists not to mention the “racist” lab theory.
Social media companies also enforced the narrative and, with the coordination of the Biden Administration, experts raising the lab theory were targeted, censored, and blacklisted.
It now appears that the COVID outbreak may have occurred months before the alleged wet market release — months that could have been used to contain the virus. Instead, China is accused of suppressing the news and allowing the virus to spread worldwide. Our military personnel alone went home from the Wuhan games to 25 states, potentially carrying it with them.
When information on these infections connected to the games was reported around the world, China even suggested that the U.S. used the games to release the weaponized virus.
In 2020, I wrote a column on why China seemed poised to avoid any liability for what might be the greatest act of negligence in history. The sheer size of the disaster somehow seemed to insulate China. As Joseph Stalin had once said, “a single death is a tragedy” and “a million deaths is a statistic.”
Try more than seven million, and you have a statistic that was not worth confronting the Chinese over. What was done was done.
Jonathan Turley is the Shapiro Professor of Public Interest Law at George Washington University and the author of “The Indispensable Right: Free Speech in an Age of Rage.”
Dennis is not commenting today because of being apprehended for throwing a Molotov cocktail and burning down the PA Governor Mansion
Developing
“Suspected arsonist Cody Balmer accused of firebombing Gov. Shapiro’s home pictured — as his disturbing online photos are revealed”
https://nypost.com/2025/04/14/us-news/cody-balmer-suspected-josh-shapiro-arsonist-pictured/
He already passed his knowledge onto this article, before it got taken down and brought back up with a clean comment slate
The deep state assessments are ‘low confidence’ for a virus lab origin.
Could be, but all this noise has no relevance for what public health measures to take. Me, I take a Covid-19 booster shot yearly.
So, you’re saying that your proud to have been duped, and that the only logical theory for the virus’s origin is wrong and you know this because of your personal connections in the “deep state” which is always right? With your enthusiastic embrace for injecting experimental poison into your body, you will be lucky to live to next year.
Diogenes wrote: “Honestly, I despise scientists.”
That is understandable. But we’re stuck tolerating them because, in my book, there is a triad of reasoned judgment: experts, logic, and common sense, ideally, all enveloped in a cloud of morality.
I ask myself what separates good people from the Georges of the world. The most apparent difference is morality and their acceptance of a false God. They pick apart the triad and cling to experts spouting false evidence, never considering the logic of the situation or even basic common sense.
Absolutely agree!
I hope we find out who hacked this site, but the list of suspects isn’t long.
What a total dimwit.
Typical cult member who sees conspiracies everywhere.
There is no hacking.
It is a software update.
See my comment at 2:25pm
What a moron !!!!!
@Anonymous
Sure. Because you are the admin for this site in personal possession of the passwords and logs. You trolls are not amusing, clever, or funny – just annoying. So very, very annoying. Were it possible to give you the spankings your parents failed to through the ethers, we would.
Did you even bother to look at this???
https://make.wordpress.org/core/6-8/
There is a major software update in progress starting today with a scheduled dry run, and full release tomorrow.
It is obvious what is going on.
Darren is trying to do the update live, on the fly, without taking down the site.
Transient glitches and anomalies are inevitable.
Folks, please, don’t click on they/them’s link above. Could be legit; could be trollware. Not worth the risk.
Unbelievable !!!!!
Nothing but conspiracy theories, paranoia and irrational delusions of persecution.
WordPress 6.8 is scheduled for full release tomorrow.
There have been several preparatory releases in the last week.
Today was scheduled as a dry run for the update.
That is why you have been seeing transient glitches and quirks.
If you afraid to click on the link, then just Google WordPress 6.8 and see for yourself.
Unbelievabele!!!!!
You people are just plain crazy.
Hardcore cultists.
S. Meyer
Word salad of gibberish, completely devoid of meaning.
Are you having a stroke ??
Or perhaps you are just trying to emulate your orange cult leader, similar to his recent comments when he invited the LA Dodgers to the White House.
His comment:
“When you ran out the healthy arms, you ran out of really healthy, they had great arms, but they ran out, it’s called sports, it’s called baseball in particular, and pitchers I guess you could say in really particular.”
A person of interest returns to the scene of the crime.
That must be you informing us that you don’t know what morality, common sense, and logic are. You don’t have to tell us. Everyone already knows.
I’ve been saying for quite a while now…
This applies to any narrative that the political left has forcibly promoted with their cancellation tactics; COVID, Russia/Ukraine, Trump’s a racist, Trump is a fascist, Trump is a Putin puppet, Trump Russian Collusion, Hunter Biden laptop, January 6th was an Insurrection, Trump is a rapist, Trump is a traitor, Trump is a white supremacist, Musk is running the government, Trump is cutting Medicare-Medicaid-Social Security-Veterans Benefits, Trump is a threat to democracy, the list is dang near endless. The political left is full of lying propagandists that think that the ends justifies the means and they will lie, lie, lie to achieve their demonization goals; they’re LIARS!
@whimsicalmama
Yep. Could be a DDoS attack or similar. Something definitely going on server-side, one way or the other.
“This is like fighting World War II and then shrugging off the question of what actually started it.”
They wouldn’t want to answer that sort of question because it might cause us to figure out a way to keep it from being gaslighted again. They can’t have the great, unwashed, deplorables having independent thoughts, now can they?
This was one of the most egregious crimes against humanity in modern history, and oh no, we will never forget. And here in the States, the left’s actions were the most totalitarian we have likely *ever* seen, – no mean feat.
I’m not surprised it was loose earlier than stated, my wife and I had it in January of 2020, a full two months before the lock down. We were both over it and immune by the time everything unraveled, and long before the ‘jab’. It was madness, and it cannot be allowed to happen ever again.
The modern left is insane, pure and simple, and between covid, the Biden years, and what the globalists are perpetrating in countries that lack our protections, it is crystal clear how they would ‘govern’ if ever in power again as they are currently constituted. No. Just, no. And the globalists and their minions can go to h*ll. They very nearly succeeded in destroying the fabric of our societies and seizing absolute power.
Even if America stands alone – henceforth America will stand, not kneel.
In May of 2016 Johns Hopkins researchers announced medical error to be the third leading cause of death in the US. As a senior lay American male I was investigating official US disease and mortality numbers in late 2019, with 2017 being the most recent year completed. Back then the average daily count of all cause deaths was 7,703 (CDC/NCHS/NVSS). When public officials began announcing an alleged “pandemic” in March of 2020 (Trump era) I knew almost immediately the numbers were being greatly exaggerated. What I also knew then that most others still don’t now was that there is a (my) kind of nearly subclinical non-IgE-mediated food (minimally) allergy reactions which, since the early 1930s (Dr. Arthur F. Coca) mainstream medicine still fails to recognize, research, practice and/or teach as true allergies. Consequently, about 75% of all cause US death is now cheaply and easily prevented chronic illnesses foisted on America since the late 1960s, primarily through the toxic FDA approved food additives soy, cooking oil preservative TBHQ (1972) and added artificially cultured “free” (can cross the blood brain barrier) monosodium glutamate (MSG; 1980). I know from experience that my kind of allergies alone can lower my resistance to upper respiratory infection and FDA approved food poisoning can aggravate that. So, in conclusion, the total US deaths attributed to Covid-19 were mostly preexisting conditions, comorbidities, and inherently frail victims and never exceeded what we could expect of medical errors alone in the same time frame; no pandemic, but with about a $7 Trillion dollar ‘scamdemic’ price tag, instigated prior to Biden, who picked up the ‘medicine’ ball and ran with it. The problems with undiagnosed food allergies and FDA approved food poisoning still exist.
It’s still hilarious that the source of COVID is still an issue for Turley. It’s certainly a welcome distraction from the current parade of mismanagement and incompetence that is the Trump administration.
As I said before, this is nothing but a means for MAGAs to gripe about while ignoring more important issues like Trump attacking free speech and putting the US economy at a disadvantage against the Chinese. Turley wants to portary the Chinese in a bad light so it’s easier to make them the bad guys in Trump’s tariff fiasco. Trump is doing China a big favor by making the whole world look at it as the better alternative than the USA, and it’s working. Truly astonishing.
Removes article, revamps some stuff, reuploads because his site directors didn’t like how the convo was going, and won’t even have the journalistic integrity to offer a correction.
Yep, seems like, as Denny and Goergie would say, a far-right magstreeeeemist trumpologist to us! (/s)
The Covid pandemic saga has been like putting together a 100 piece jigsaw puzzle, with the picture on the box showing the Wuhan lab and a lineup of bad actors. It starts out with the bad actors claiming that’s a picture of the Wuhan wet market. Then as the pieces get put in, and as the picture becomes clearer, those same bad actors attack anyone pointing out the obvious, massive gaslighting being perpetrated on the world. This cannot go unpunished.
>In the U.S. alone, more than 1.2 million died
No.
Come on Jonathan, you’re years late and still echoing bogus statistics?
I have been posting since 2020 that this was a deliberate ACT OF WAR by the chi-coms in retaliation for the Trump tariffs. No we know that the chi-coms deliberately infected the military members during the games in order to spread the virus world wide. The Biden regime, every single on of them is guilt of high treason and deserve to be tried and if convicted executed by firing squad.
The big picture is that the Dems are in the pocket of the CCP. It’s not only the origins of COVID, its:
+ Allowing the Chinese spy balloon to float across the entire US
+ Biden selling much of the strategic petroleum reserve to China
+ Hunter’s many deals with China (including Joe’s 10%)
+ Gavin Newsom’s pilgrimage to Xi
+ Continued emphasis on the the mortal threat of Russia, Russia, Russia but crickets about the even bigger threat about China
+ Continued purchase of Chinese “green” energy equipment while crushing US manufacturing
+ Allowing China’s takeover of Hong Kong in violation of the “Basic Law”
+ Blocking transfer of advances weapons to Taiwan that Taiwan has already purchased
reminder the Bidens got Millions from China…bought their loyality!
The original gain of function work was done in chapel.Hill north carolina. Obama said to stop gain of function work. Fauci continued it for months, but ultimately transferred it to Wuhan, along with the bat lady who had been working on it in Chapel Hill. The rest is history.
Your comment corresponds with my memories of of late Dec. 2019-early Jan. 2020. I remember reading something about a (Chinese?) woman scientist working at a university in NC suddenly, and somewhat mysteriously, departing the US. About the same time there were stories on either FOX or CNN about some scientists in China falling ill, some fatally, with a disease they possibly contracted in their lab. What I remember quite well is that by the second or third week inJanuary 2020, while waiting outdoors on an unusually warm and sunny Saturday, I not only removed my coat, but pushed up my sleeves to expose my arms to the vitamin D from the sun, because by then I knew what a corona virus was, and that this new virus was particularly dangerous for the sick, elderly, and overweight—and I was elderly and overweight (fortunately, I’m still elderly!).
Here are two of the unprincipled principals suspects… “Phauci” and Pfizer!
Others
Paid propangandiving pressitutes.
Ghoulish Globalists
When was last time you had a meal at a Chinese restaurant?
There is a Chinese restaurant where a few diners have died.
Someone actually had a heart attack and slumped over face first into the egg fried rice dish.
Just a some from a US-supporting Cantonese restaurant – yummy!
Yep, defintely DOGE. Who else could be messing up the blog like this but DOGE. LOL!!
LOL!! What the heck is Turley doing? his column titles keep changing and comments are getting deleted. Is DOGE running the show now?
I would imagine it is George’s partners in crime trying to eliminate all the truthful analyses of his propaganda tirades.