“The Pope Doesn’t Take Sides”: Should a Foreign Head of State Be Able to Vote in United States Elections?

Official State Department photo by Freddie Everett

“So, the Pope doesn’t take sides. Prevost has another opinion, but we won’t do that now.”

That funny quip from Pope Leo XIV (born Robert Prevost) referred to the historic game in Rome when the Villanova and Notre Dame basketball teams play each other.

However, a story this week raised a different question of when the Pope, as opposed to Prevost, can “take sides.”

This month, American-born Pope Leo XIV became the first pope ever to vote in a U.S. election.

A longtime Chicago native, the Pope mailed an absentee ballot to Will County, and the clerk’s office confirmed to Fox News Digital that “Robert Prevost is on the list of individuals who requested a Vote by Mail ballot.” There is no question that the Pope can vote in the Holy See. Indeed, he is the ultimate and final vote in the Vatican, but can he actually vote in Illinois races (including the governor’s race involving incumbent Democrat J.B. Pritzker)?  The answer appears to be yes, but it raises some novel questions.

Now, as a threshold matter, I want to shed some bias. I was raised Catholic in Chicago. No, that is not the bias. There is that lingering conflict with the Pope coming out as a White Sox fan. Many of us on the North Side hoped for a conversion to restore our faith in papal infallibility. However, he has remained entrenched in his South Side allegiance.

This column rises above that historic rivalry and does not suggest that White Sox fans can be challenged at the polls. (Besides, I previously explained that the Pope is a Cubs fan without knowing it.)

Rather, what surprised me was that the head of a foreign state could vote in U.S. elections. The Vatican is a distinct nation with a diplomatic corps, a court system, a local government, and even a military in the form of the legendary Swiss Guards.

The Holy See Press Office declared, “Pope Leo XIV has exercised his right to vote as a United States citizen whenever he was eligible to do so. The Holy See Press Office confirms that, in keeping with this long-standing practice of civic participation, he has submitted his mail-in ballot in Chicago.”

The Holy See maintains that Pope Leo retains his status as a U.S. citizen while serving as the head of a foreign nation. There is support for this position.

The State Department has maintained that dual citizens do not have to choose between their countries, though it does not expect them to serve as the head of another country.

“U.S. dual nationals owe allegiance to both the United States and the foreign country (or countries, if they are nationals of more than one). They are required to obey the laws of both countries, and either country has the right to enforce its laws.  Claims of other countries upon U.S. dual-nationals may result in conflicting obligations under the laws of each country.  U.S. dual nationals may also face restrictions in the U.S. consular protections available to U.S. nationals abroad, particularly in the country of their other nationality.”

Notably, the State Department requires dual citizens to use a U.S. passport to enter the country. Does that mean that, when traveling as head of state, Pope Leo has to use a U.S. passport? Unlikely, but intriguing.

It strikes me as odd that a person can lead another country and still vote in U.S. elections. With all of those worried about Russian interference in elections, imagine if Putin could actually vote in U.S. elections. Obviously, Pope Leo is greatly loved and represents someone whose values are aligned with this country. Yet, he is also the head of state of a foreign nation.

Under the Uniformed and Overseas Citizens Absentee Voting Act (UOCAVA), military personnel and citizens abroad are allowed to vote in U.S. elections. It is no longer considered an absentee vote requiring an excuse but simply a mail-in ballot.

The question is whether this right should be suspended when you assume a position in a foreign nation, let alone the head of such a nation. Dual citizenship has long been debated over the difficult questions raised by nations with opposing values and interests. However, being the head of a foreign government with potentially opposing interests and actions to the United States creates a curious status.

It turns out that when Gov. Pritzker met with the Pope last year, he was actually meeting with a constituent and voter.

I am most surprised that the Vatican does not have a policy against such voting, though this is admittedly unprecedented. I would think that the head of the Catholic faith and the head of a foreign government would have a single national citizenship for the Holy See. All popes are selected from the global faithful by the College of Cardinals and thus have national citizenship with other countries.

In assuming their positions, the cardinals “pledge and swear, as individuals and as a group, to observe faithfully and scrupulously the prescriptions contained in the Apostolic Constitution.” They also reaffirm that they are not subject to countervailing allegiances or pressures from outside of the College: “And never to lend support or favour to any interference, opposition or any other form of intervention, whereby secular authorities of whatever order and degree or any group of people or individuals might wish to intervene in the election of the Roman Pontiff.”

However, it is fascinating that, once elected, Popes do not shed that status upon assuming the head of the Holy See.

It is an uncomfortable question since it also raises whether the head of a foreign government should have dual citizenship. Most people were legitimately thrilled (including myself) by the first American Pope and can view this as an unlikely “one-off.” However, it could just as easily happen with another nation and a dual citizen.

At the risk of my own excommunication, it seems a worthy question for discussion, even though I doubt any politicians would relish such a debate. For his part, Pope Leo stated before the Villanova-Notre Dame game that the Pope will not take sides in the U.S. elections, but Robert Prevost will.

Jonathan Turley is a law professor and the New York Times best-selling author of “Rage and the Republic: The Unfinished Story of the American Revolution.”

The column appeared on Fox.com

153 thoughts on ““The Pope Doesn’t Take Sides”: Should a Foreign Head of State Be Able to Vote in United States Elections?”

  1. Illegal aliens, since January 1, 1863, have been “allowed” to vote through the actions of anti-American communists. The communists effectively used the equivalent of “jury nullification” to disregard the Naturalization Act of 1802, which remained in full force and effect. They have continued to do so for 163 years.

    Americans have consequently lost their absolute right to private property, much of their freedom of speech and of the press, the comprehensive restrictions on government enumerated in Article I, Section 8, and vast quantities of liberty secured by the Constitution and Bill of Rights—all surrendered to the communists.

    The singular American failure is the judicial branch, with emphasis on the Supreme Court.

    1. “In this sense, the theory of the Communists may be summed up in the single sentence: Abolition of private property.”

      – Karl Marx, Communist Manifesto, Chapter 2

      1. 13th Amendment — persons can no longer be considered property owned by other persons.
        Passed 2/3 in Congress, and ratified by majorities in 3/4 of states by December 1865. It’s a stretch to call that “abolition of private property”. The freed slaves were given greatly expanded property ownership rights, including the right to pass property in a Last Will and Testament. Hardly a “communist” action — get a grip on history and language.

        1. The entire Lincoln “Reign of Terror” was unconstitutional, starting with Lincoln’s wholly unconstitutional denial of secession and proceeding to martial law, suspension of habeas corpus, nullification of freedom of speech, jailing of political opponents, smashing of opposition printing presses, invasion of a sovereign foreign nation, nullification of legislation, nullification of the 5th Amendment, confiscation of private property, prosecution of an undeclared unconstitutional war against American states, etc. The “Reconstruction Amendments” are just as corrupt and unconstitutional as Roe v. Wade; they await being struck down.

  2. The official Church teaching is that eligible voters in a democracy have a moral duty to vote. Therefore, the Pope performed his religious obligation as an example to all

    Whether the US should allow it is another question, and I strongly oppose it for the Pope, and for all people in a position of nominally non-partisan authority. Judges, prosecutors, military men should not vote, for it betrays their non-neutrality. Nor should non-residents citizens vote since the vote does not affect them (nor should they pay taxess)

    Anyway, I hope he voted in blank, or scribbled “you are all crooks!”

    1. Anon 12:36 PM-I disagree. Soldiers should always have the vote because they pay the biggest price for our country. That was the whole argument during the Viet Nam war. Most states required age 21 to vote. 2 states allowed voting at age 18 and 1 or 2 others allowed voting at 19 or 20. The point was that draftees at age 18 could be sent to Viet Nam and never had the chance to vote on the policy until the 26th amendment lowered the national voting age to 18. All citizens generally should have the right to vote. Judges should neither wage election campaigns nor comment on politics.

      GEB

  3. Prevost is not at liberty to choose his place of residence. When he was in Peru, it was not because he went on sabbatical there. It was because he was assigned there, becoming a resident of Peru. Later, he was assigned to Chicago. He had no choice in that matter either, and because he was assigned to Chicago he was a resident of Chicago. Now he is assigned to the Vatican City, and he is a resident of the Vatican City, not Chicago. And it is also his choice to be a resident of the Vatican City as he could very well have told the College of Cardinals: don’t make me Pope, keep me in Chicago. Popes, once selected, remain popes in the Vatican City until they die. As such, I say that regardless of technical citizenship, he does not satisfy the Illinois requirements for being a resident able to vote in any Illinois election.

  4. Of course the American citizen who is the head of his church gets to vote in US elections!

    That person is guaranteed the freedom to practice his religion & voting rights as a citizen of the US.

    If dual citizenship is a block to the right to vote then all Jews must not be allowed to cast their ballots in America, along with all others with dual status.

  5. Watch out I think there’s a few guy’s in Alaska voting in the name of Leo Pope, those pesky democrats.

  6. Do not forget: Pope John Paul II abstained from voting in Poland’s first democratic elections in a generation in 1989. Karol Wotjyla’s role in bringing Poland to that moment was not a small one, and he probably could have voted if he had the chance, but he did not pursue it and stayed neutral in the elections.

    Pope Leo voting for Will County Board and for the First Congressional District just doesn’t feel right.

    But don’t forget: in Cook County Michelle and Barack Obama still vote. They are almost never here.

  7. I remember when Boris Johnson was the Prime Minister of Great Britain (hereafter known as Lesser Britain), he assumed the post while still a United States Citizen. There was even the issue of him owing US income taxes during those years. So this was not the first time the head of a foreign state was also a US Citizen.

    I don’t recall whether Prime Minister Johnson exercised his right to vote in a United States election during his time as Prime Minister, but this is an interesting issue.

  8. I was raised in a family where Mom was a hard shell Southern Baptist and a Dad that was a Moravian thus my exposure to Catholicism came during my Army Days when I accompanied a Catholic friend to a Mass. Half way down the aisle he dropped to a knee without signaling the stop…and I wound up in a far lower posture to the amusement of all who witnessed my being struck down with what they they thought was a strong case of supplication….when all it was a mere traffic violation.

    It is good the Pope is an American.

    Why is it a surprise he might be what we call a Liberal Leftie and who probably is a party line Democrat Voter?

    This citizenship thing where certain obligations, responsibilities, and liabilities come with privilege offers some interesting questions at times.

    Of course an American Pope can vote in American Elections unless and until he denounces that citizenship or is convicted of Felonies in Court. That the Pope could swing an election by putting his Holy Oar into the water…no doubt whatsoever. One would hope he (as there has never been a Female Pope…to my knowledge) would do so based upon the values of the Catholic faith…..you know like on topics like abortion for instance.

    The notion that we should keep Church and State separate does not mean people of faith should not take use of their particular faith’s teachings as they decide upon the issues, problems, and threats we face and which Party (political and individuals) offer views we can embrace.

    Easy example today is the jerk up in Michigan El Sayed or some Baptist Minister down in Alabama who are running for an office….I am going to stick with the Baptist over an Islamist because I see a clear difference in the views and beliefs each present.

    Would I take a Mamdani who is a Communist over anyone else who is not a Communist…..absolutely.

    Faith informs us as we go through Life….we benefit when we partake of it.

    Mine informs me to love others….honor and respect Women for the role they play in family and in life itself.

    History reminds us the Capitol Building was used for church services for many decades….how does that remind us of the notion that separation does not mean exclusion when it comes to religion?

    Being not a Catholic I see the Pope for what he is….the head of a Church, a human being, and living proof that we are all Sinners if he backs the wrong ball teams and votes Democrat. I hope he seeks counsel for those sins when he goes to a Confession and finds redemption as result. Plus, Republicans need some divine intervention in Illinois and Chicago considering what goes on there.

    1. There is not party registration in Illinois. He is in databases as an observed independent, meaning he hasn’t voted in a primary in 10 years. In fact, he voted in 2016 in the Republican primary as well as in 2014 (Rauner-Brady-Dillard-Rutherford), and 2012. But he voted in the 2010 and 2008 Dem primaries.

  9. I hope that, to be consistent, the Pope is also going to file tax returns, both Federal and State. Will he report the Vatican’s income as his own since he controls it? There appear to be a lot of unanswered questions here. In any event, for a Pope to vote in an American election seems unwise. I say that as a lifelong Catholic.

    1. @Ralph

      No doubt. This is a double whammy, too: ‘See, flock, you plebes? Mail in ballots are the greatest! The pope loves them! Also, vote for his leftist agenda! The pope is infallible! It’s the same as God telling you to!.

      That is how much they respect people’s intelligence.

    2. The Vatican’s income is certainly not his, and is not taxable by the USA. His own income is taxable in the USA, but is offset by a large deduction for living abroad, as well as by double-taxation treaties. Most US citizens living abroad end up not owing any taxes to the USA, but they do have to file.

  10. The Pope was born more than three miles south of Chicago’s Madison Street, making him a Southsider by birth. Further, he grew up in the southern suburb of Dolton, 15 miles due South of his birthplace.

    Said birthplace, Mercy Hospital, was less than two miles from Comiskey Park. But over nine miles from Wrigley Field.

    As such, the Pope was born a White Sox fan. He has acknowledged his affiliation as an adult, as one acknowledges his childhood faith via the Sacrament of Confirmation.

  11. This is an interesting question Can the head of a foreign state vote in our elections if he or she maintains dual citizenship. I’m surprised that the Vatican allows for its head of state (AKA, the Pope) to hold dual citizenship. I’m not aware of other countries allowing their head of state to hold dual citizenship. As long as Robert Prevost holds his US citizenship, he can vote. I wonder if he gets out of jury duty? Does he have to go back to Illinois to renew his drivers license?

    1. Jury duty depends on residence, not just citizenship. And drivers’ licenses depend entirely on residence and not at all on citizenship. A foreign citizen living in Illinois needs an IL driver’s license in order to drive there. A US citizen living in Italy needs an Italian license, not one from anywhere in the USA. And someone with diplomatic or sovereign immunity probably doesn’t need a license at all.

  12. “U.S. dual nationals owe allegiance to both the United States and the foreign country.” And just how does one do this?

    1. Unless the two countries are at war, one does it very easily. Millions of US citizens are foreign citizens as well, and there’s nothing the USA can do to prevent it. The constitution says anyone born or naturalized in the USA is a citizen, and that means Congress cannot make a law depriving such a person of their citizenship involuntarily. Back in the 1930s Congress tried to legislate that if you take up foreign citizenship you lose your US citizenship; the Supreme Court struck it down as clearly unconstitutional.

      1. The pope has left his residency within the US.

        Alito, dissent, 1st paragraph, Barbara.

        The pope controls 20 million votes and he says he holds the keys. Quite a terrorist threat but moslem women say they love wearing the burka.

      2. Congress can certainly pass a law defining someone who has undertaken certain acts abroad as having constructively renounced their citizenship. It can also strip the courts of jurisdiction as the courts have been a source of abuses.

  13. The three point hitch on Pope Leo’s tractor has the plow raised up. If he retires, what result for Vatican citizenship? Second, a birthright U.S. citizen returns to China and becomes head of state with dual citizenship. That tractor has its plow down working. Article V?

  14. There is no question that this Pope is a left-wing liberal and as such, doesn’t seem to understand the long standing Dem axiom, “the separation of church & state.” Vatican City is an independent country in and of itself. Pope Leo is the elected leader of this country, much in the same way a dictator is elected. He is also the leader of all Catholics. By voting in our election, he is indeed blending ‘church & state’ more so than any American ever has. It is repulsive to know that a foreign leader who also represents a major religion will actually be cancelling someone’s vote, here in America!

    1. @Freddy

      I tend to agree. This smacks of another dirty attempt at voter manipulation by the global left. Not being Catholic, I don’t know if Catholics will be so easily swayed, but the compulsion to announce this days become the election stinks to high heaven. These people are soulless.

    2. Aren’t all Roman Catholics citizens of VC? Weren’t they originally citizens of Rome no matter the birthright citizenship? I could Google it…

    3. The Pope wss elected by a representative body, in much the same way that Senators were elected by state legislatures. No dictator is so selected.

    4. This is ridiculous, for a number of reasons, but the first reason is that there is not one word in the constitution about a “separation of church and state”. What the constitution says is that the state can’t adopt a religion as its own. The courts have interpreted this as meaning it can’t interfere with religion, or discriminate for or against any specific religion, or against religion in general. It can encourage religion in general, and grant it privileges not available to equivalent non-religious movements. None of which has anything to do with religious people exercising their right to vote.

  15. Pope Leo is popular with the MSM media because he spoke out against Trump- a mortal sin in my mind-for his prior publication of personal politics (of course, his actual vote remains private). I posted on national media long ago that he needed to stay in his lane. He is not ignorant of the fact that his opinion affects all Catholics, who represent around 20% of the entire U.S. population (69-70 million), including a large percentage of the Hispanic population, who I believe are generallay more amenable and malleable.

    AS we approach elections, I am reminded of the persistent efforts of MSM to seek out anyone, especially Republican, who is anti-Trump, then interview that person and broadcast it on national news. Interviewing anyone who favors Trump is always an aside, an anecdote–even though he/she represents the overwhelming majority of Republicans. (I have long-time-ago stated that I disliked Trump’s braggadocio but heavily favored his politics.)

    Media knew and knows the effect it has on America’s voters by focusing on the Pope’s personal political views and the manipulative news coverage that has contributed to American sentiment. Commenter whimsicalmama was correct in noting the shame in relying on the gullible American electorate for spreading propaganda. The constant kneading and manipulative influence on public sentiment by the media is inexcusable for me.

    https://uslawexplained.com/electorate

    1. (spelling/grammar correction: should read: “population…which I believe is generally more amenable”)

      (as I am writing this, ABC’s Martha Raddatz is interviewing an anti-Trump Hispanic female in the Rio Grande Valley (a location identified by media as equivocally susceptible), with leading questions and encouragement of disappointment.)

    2. Re: lin at 9:09 AM

      “Media knew and knows the effect it has on America’s voters by focusing on the Pope’s personal political views and the manipulative news coverage that has contributed to American sentiment. …
      The constant kneading and manipulative influence on public sentiment by the media is inexcusable for me.” – Lin

      So is it an implied factor of the ‘Catholic Pope’ and the history of the Catholic Church’s centuries of rein in Central and South America of which roots hold the in the U.S. Hispanic and Latino Populations (As well as the European/Anglo Catholic Populations) as being used/manipulated as the ‘target audience’ of the Democratic’ Party’s campaign strategy?

      Would this effectively explain Bidens Open-Boarder Policy (+NGOs) in the importation of Catholic acculturated Immigrants from Central and South America?

      Would it enplane the Catholic Church’s exploitation via the Democratic’ Party’s subversion (method & means) of the United States?

      Other ‘Religious Proclivities’ also manipulate the U.S. Election system to create advantages. Is it fare to say that this Midterm Election is a battle between these Proclivities?

      Is it fare to say that Immigration is being used as a guise for Religious proliferation and consequential Party affiliation?

      1. Ref.: The power of the Pope (as influencer) – JFK’s Election

        … ” Throughout the primaries and the fall campaign, Kennedy’s religion was a dominant issue. He would become only the second Roman Catholic ever to be nominated for president by a major party (the first was Democratic Gov. Al Smith of New York, who lost to Herbert Hoover in 1928). Some Protestant ministers and prominent laymen expressed fears that a Catholic president would be under the domination of the pope and would not always be free to act in the best interests of the country, charges which Kennedy denied.” …

        https://www.britannica.com/event/United-States-presidential-election-of-1960#ref286000

        https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1960_United_States_presidential_election#Nominations

    3. He’s kind of a rock star isn’t he? People, bow and drool, right? 20 million catholics probably check his recommendations particularly in matters of abortion.

  16. The comments on this issue of Res Ipsa are worth the subscription. I think citizenship, whether single or multiple, carries with it responsibilities and voting is one of them.

    1. Voting is not a responsibility, it is a privilege, one a person can exercise or refuse.

      BTW, the blog is not subscribable.

      1. @Anonymous

        It is; you can subscribe to having posts delivered via email, and it is free. You can also add it to a feedreader’s subscriptions, also free.

      2. Voting is not an privilege to be exercised or refused everywhere.

        It is mandatory by statute to vote in 22 countries. In most of them failure to vote is a misdemeanor that carries a fine.

      1. @Carpe

        My thoughts, too. I can’t go back to NM and vote despite being born there, so, why? Troll logic. And I wish we’d address flaws in national birthright citizenship (kill it, please, unless parents are at least naturalized, not on a temporary status), believe me.

Leave a Reply

Res ipsa loquitur – The thing itself speaks