“A Difficult Decision”: Cooperative Closes Outside Chicago Despite Federal and State Funding

 

8 thoughts on ““A Difficult Decision”: Cooperative Closes Outside Chicago Despite Federal and State Funding”

  1. Oh brother. Turley sure loves misleading narratives.

    Turley’s column compares apples to lug nuts (yeah it’s that bad) while misstating both New York City’s budget numbers and basic grocery economics.

    To start, Prairie Food Co-op in Lombard, Illinois, was NOT a government-run grocery store—it was a private, member-owned boutique co-op in an affluent suburb saturated with major grocery chains that stocked high-priced specialty organic items instead of conventional everyday staples. Even its own board admitted shoppers left because it didn’t carry basic conventional groceries at competitive prices. Apparently Turley didn’t notice that particular issue.

    Beyond that, Turley’s claim that a 30% discount violates the “1% to 3% grocery profit margin” ignores how store overhead actually works. Private supermarkets in New York City pay crushing commercial rent, property taxes, and investor returns—all of which disappear (a key distinction) when a store operates on city-owned property with zero rent, zero property taxes, and zero profit extraction. Even more importantly, Mayor Mamdani’s 30% discount applies only to a core basket of produce, meat, dairy, and staples, while all other items are sold at standard market prices—the exact “loss-leader” pricing model private chains like Walmart and Costco use every single day. Turley also double-counts the East Harlem capital budget: the $25 million site renovation allocation is part of the $30 million capital build-out (out of $70 million across all five boroughs), not an extra hidden slush fund.

    Best of all, Turley ignores that publicly owned grocery stores work across America right now. In St. Paul, Kansas, after private grocers abandoned the town, the city took over St. Paul Supermarket in 2013—and 13 years later, it is still thriving because it operates on a break-even public-utility model without commercial rent or shareholder extraction. Meanwhile, the federal government runs over 235 military commissaries that save families 25% to 30% every day using the exact same rent-free, at-cost model. Treating food access like basic public infrastructure isn’t a “myth”—it’s already working.

  2. No mention of the fact that thousands of small businesses go under every year. Cause: Inadequate cash-flow management. Not socialist agendas.

    Data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics in 2024 shows that 20.4% of businesses fail in their first year after opening, 49.4% fail in their first five years, and 65.3% fail in their first 10 years. However, the failure rate varies by region and industry. The sector with the lowest failure rate is agriculture, forestry, fishing, and hunting.

  3. Obviously all of the source farms and industries need to be nationalized along with all of the transportation services used to bring the groceries to Market. Only by limiting the unfair profits of all entities along the food chain can this Noble venture be allowed to succeed.

  4. Socialist promises are free, and given out like candy. Reality and results never match the promises made, however. In fact, far from it. When Mayor Zohran Mamdani spoke in front of shelves chock full of fresh and colorful produce. Every last lemon and apple were produced and sold by private merchants, not a public cooperative. Democrats have no hesitancy about taking money at gunpoint from taxpayers and using it to fund their Socialist dreams, and when they inevitably fail, Democrat politicians simply move on to other promises, all in exchange for votes and power.

    1. There was socialist promise mentioned din the article. As far as we know, they were just incompetent 1st timers.

      Donald Trump has had at least 10 prominent business failures, including ventures that closed, such as Trump Mortgage and Trump Steaks. Separately, four Trump-linked casino and hotel businesses filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy reorganization; these were corporate bankruptcies, not personal bankruptcies. Geez… even devout capitalists fail.

  5. Great and necessary piece, spread it far and wide. If the left gets to enact everything on its agenda this will *be* everything, autonomy and sustainability gone. Our country will likely collapse.

    Don’t believe their bullishness about data centers either – they simply want to be the ones in control of that, too. AI programming that does not fit the narrative will be deemed disinformation and eradicated, and utilizing AI tools, it will be child’s play to do it.

    1. PS – an alternate scenario re AI: the might also seem it simply too dangerous for us plebes and make themselves the only ones with full access to it, just as with the supply chain in their warm and fuzzy grocery stores.

Leave a Reply