If Andrew McCabe Lied, Could He Be Charged Like Michael Flynn?

McCabeBelow is my column in The Hill newspaper on the reported determination of the Inspector General that former Acting FBI Director Andrew McCabe misled investigators about a leak to the media. There may be a question of consistency in criminally charging Michael Flynn for the same alleged act.  People continue to spin this issue by noting (as the piece states) that Flynn agreed to this false statement crime as part of a plea bargain with more serious potential crimes. However, that misses the point. Prosecutors are required to apply the criminal code evenly. They are not allowed the luxury of a criminal charge that can be easily applied to a wide array of people at their discretion.  It makes it very difficult for people to contest a criminal charge when prosecutors can simply criminalize any inaccurate or misleading statement while ignoring the same conduct in others.  It is particularly concerning when the favorable parties are fellow prosecutors or government officials.  My argument is not that we should have more false statement charges. Rather, there has long been a problem in the use of this provision which has been applied in an arbitrary manner.

Here is the column:

Continue reading “If Andrew McCabe Lied, Could He Be Charged Like Michael Flynn?”

Court Throws Out Conviction Of Texas Man Who Was Given Electrical Shocks By A Judge For Failing To “Follow The Rules”

downloadsafety-sign-high-voltageThe Texas Eighth Court of Appeals in El Paso has thrown out the conviction of Terry Lee Morris after Judge George Gallagher ordered him to be shocked with a stun belt to induce him to “follow the rules.”  Gallagher’s actions were a disgrace and constitutes at a minimum assault upon a defendant.  He should be removed from the bench for his actions in the 2014 trial.  It is astonishing that he remains on the bench after such abuse of a criminal defendant. I have been a long critic of stun belts in court.

Continue reading “Court Throws Out Conviction Of Texas Man Who Was Given Electrical Shocks By A Judge For Failing To “Follow The Rules””

Stormy Daniels Sues Trump Over “Hush Money” Agreement

160px-Official_Portrait_of_President_Donald_Trump_(cropped)I previously wrote about how the payments to both a former porn star and a former Playboy bunny could prove a greater threat to President Donald Trump than the still unsubstantiated collusion allegations that led to the appointment of the Special Counsel.  Now, one of those woman is formally in court after Stormy Daniels (AKA Stephanie Clifford) filed an action against President Trump.  I have previously criticized counsel for both Trump and Daniels for bizarre actions in this controversy and this lawsuit is no exception.  The lawsuit introduces new facts including the allegation that President Trump’s lawyer used a fake name for the President, David Dennison, as part of this effort to pay what the complaint calls “hush money.”  After differing accounts by Daniels, she has not only stated that she did have a year long affair (something Trump’s counsel has denied) but stated it in a court filing as opposed to a tabloid newspaper.

Continue reading “Stormy Daniels Sues Trump Over “Hush Money” Agreement”

Conway Found In Violation Of The Hatch Act By Special Counsel

Screen Shot 2017-11-26 at 10.09.44 PM.pngWe previously discussed the complaint filed by Walter Shaub, the former director of the Office of Government Ethics against White House Counselor Kellyanne Conway for violating the Hatch Act.  At the time, I discussed my view that the statements of Conway concerning the special Senate election in Alabama were clear violations of the Act.  The new report by OSC special counsel, Henry Kerner found two violations in Conway’s making highly political statements in her “official capacity” in November and December of last year in supporting Alabama candidate Roy Moore. Kerner, a Trump appointee, in a letter to President Donald Trump, called on President Trump to take “appropriate disciplinary action.”  However, the White House issued an almost immediate dismissal of the findings.  That was a mistake in my view.  The President can justify not firing Conway but, particularly for an Administration fighting what it considers politicized actions in the Executive Branch, the President should reaffirm the need to comply with the Hatch Act, Some have criticized the act, but it remains federal law.

Continue reading “Conway Found In Violation Of The Hatch Act By Special Counsel”

Nashville Mayor Resigns And Pleads Guilty To Felony Theft

1520360894350Nashville mayor Megan Barry has resigned and pleaded guilty to felony theft as part of her affair with her police bodyguard.  We often debate whether a politician should give a smiling mugshot (and risk looking non-contrite) or a frowning mugshot (and risk looking guilty).  Barry went with the smiling option.  She will now face three years probation and a criminal fine.

Continue reading “Nashville Mayor Resigns And Pleads Guilty To Felony Theft”

Spiked Gummy Bears: Three Women Arrested For Giving Sleeping Aids To Day Care Children

Daycare ArrestIn Illinois, the Des Plaines Police Department has arrested three employees of the Kiddie Junction day care facility after allegedly discovering that the women gave children gummy bears laced with the sleep aid melatonin without parental consent.  Ashley Helfenbein, 25,  Jessica Heyse, 19, and Kristen Lauletta, 32, were charged with endangering children and battery.  The battery charge is clear since the parents thought that they were paying for Kiddie Junction, not Kiddie Junkies.  The endangerment charge could result in some challenges.

Continue reading “Spiked Gummy Bears: Three Women Arrested For Giving Sleeping Aids To Day Care Children”

Sam Nunberg and Last Night’s NASCAR Press Pileup [Updated]

YouTube screengrab

It was another breathless bombshell evening last night as media proclaimed that a “Former Trump Aide” said that he believed Trump “may very well have done something during the election with the Russians.” CNN carried a series of bizarre interviews with Sam Nunberg who was refusing to comply with a subpoena from Special Counsel Robert Mueller to produce documents and appear before a grand jury. Nunberg spouted off a series of accusations against Carter Page and others that were immediately picked up as potential confirmation of collusion. However, each CNN interviews made it more and more clear that the network had a virtual freak on a leash. Soon Nunberg denounced Sarah Huckabee Sanders as a “fat slob” and telling her to shut her “big fat mouth.” Nunberg was clearly neither credible nor under control but he drove the coverage for hours as a former aide supporting Russian collusion theories. It was part of our new media: NASCAR journalism where media rushes figures like Nunberg in front of cameras and viewers watch for the inevitable crash. Update: Nunberg now is saying that he will cooperate after all.

Continue reading “Sam Nunberg and Last Night’s NASCAR Press Pileup [Updated]”

Prime Directive: MIT Librarian Declares Star Trek Posters To Be Male

downloadChris Bourg, director of libraries at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, has issued a prime directive that “Star Trek” posters and nerdy cultural images should be removed to create a more welcoming workplace for women:  “Replace the Star Trek posters with travel posters, don’t name your projects or your printers or your domains after only male figures from Greek mythology, and just generally avoid geek references and inside nerd jokes. Those kinds of things reinforce the stereotypes about who does tech; and that stereotype is the male nerd stereotype.” It is not clear if the MIT seal is also problematic as a male dominated (and fairly geeky) cultural icon.

Continue reading “Prime Directive: MIT Librarian Declares Star Trek Posters To Be Male”

Turley To Speak At National Archives

democracys-messengers-image.pngOn Tuesday, March 6, at noon, I will have the pleasure of speaking as part of the screening of Democracy’s Messengers: The Never-Before-Told Story of Young Americans on Capitol Hill at the National Archives.   Narrated by Cokie Roberts, the film Democracy’s Messengers tells the story our page system.  I was a House page in 1978-79 and eventually served as a House Leadership Page.  I will be part of a panel discussing our experiences ij the program.  Register to attend online. You can also watch the program live streamed on the National Archives YouTube channel.

Continue reading “Turley To Speak At National Archives”

Beware Of Politicians Promising An “Honest” Internet: New Bills Targeting Russians May Bag Free Speech

800px-Capitol_Building_Full_ViewBelow is my column in USA Today on the legislation proposed to combat Russian trolling and Internet campaigns.  There is a serious threat to free speech in these measures, which mirror efforts from (ironically) countries like Russia and China.  The serious threat is not a handful of Russians playing on our deep divisions, but rather the hacking operations and attempt to interfere with voting systems.

Here is the column:

Continue reading “Beware Of Politicians Promising An “Honest” Internet: New Bills Targeting Russians May Bag Free Speech”

Trump and Netanyahu Meet As Investigations Move Forward In The United States and Israel

trumpnetanyahuwives
White House picture from May 2017 (U.S. Government)

President Donald Trump and Israeli Benjamin Netanyahu meet today in the White House as a critical moment for both leaders. It is not just a common interest in Middle East peace that they have in common in this meeting. Both men now have key aides who have been cooperating witnesses for prosecutions investigating allegations of wrongdoing. While there is still not direct evidence implicating Trump, Netanyahu is facing a serious threat of indictment, particularly after his former key aides, Nir Hefetz and Shlomo Filber have agreed to testify against him. These witnesses are far closer to Netanyahu and are cooperating on criminal cases directly linked to Netanyahu — as opposed to the collateral crimes thus far addressed by the Special Counsel. One other difference is the respective Constitutional issues.  As I discussed recently, Israel has long accepted that a Prime Minister can be indicted in office.  I believe that the same is true for a president, but there is a long and good-faith debate over the question.

Continue reading “Trump and Netanyahu Meet As Investigations Move Forward In The United States and Israel”

Controversial Polish Holocaust Denial Law Takes On Its First Media Target

Child_survivors_of_AuschwitzI recently criticized the new Polish law criminalizing any statements attributing the genocide of Jews to Polish forces or actions. The legislature approved a bill making it a crime to use statements suggesting Poland bears responsibility for crimes against humanity committed by Nazi Germany.  You could receive up to three years in prison for calling Auschwitz-Birkenau a “Polish death camp.”  USNews is reporting that the first target of this abusive law has now been announced: the Argentine Pagina 12 daily.  The newspaper was accused of breaching a new law by suggesting that Poland was complicit in the Holocaust.

Continue reading “Controversial Polish Holocaust Denial Law Takes On Its First Media Target”

Le Pen Faces New Criminal Charges For Sending Pictures of ISIS Abuses On Twitter

libertyWe have been discussing  the rollback of free speech in France where writers and speakers are now routinely prosecuted for what would be protected political or religious speech in the United States, including the recent conviction of Robert Menard, mayor of Beziers and a top adviser to Menard was found guilty of inciting hatred against Muslims for complaining about the increasing numbers of Muslim children in French schools.  Now Le Pen is again being charged herself.  She has been accused of the “distribution of violent images” for sending out  tweets depicting ISIS propaganda and violence. It is again an example of France’s denial of free speech and particularly political speech.  Regardless of how one feels about Le Pen’s views, these were core political expressions.

Continue reading “Le Pen Faces New Criminal Charges For Sending Pictures of ISIS Abuses On Twitter”

South Africa’s New Economic Plan: Expropriation of Land and Printing Money

170px-Coat_of_arms_of_South_Africa.svg.pngWith South Africa’s poor economy showing slight improvement and a major credit decision looming,  the new government of President Cyril Ramaphosa would be expected to chart a careful and conservative approach.  However,  its new leaders are turning to two measures that have historically triggered utter disaster for African nations: land expropriation without compensation and the even more dangerous plan to simply print more money and give it to the poor.  I have long admitted to have a Chicago School bias from my undergraduate days, but this does not seem promising for this struggling country.

Continue reading “South Africa’s New Economic Plan: Expropriation of Land and Printing Money”

Taking The Shot: Julian McGarvey And The Self-Defining Moment

Screen Shot 2018-03-04 at 6.14.01 PM.pngThere are moments in life that are so perfect and magical that one can only sit back and just bask in its glory. That moment came for Ardsley High School basketball player Julian McGarvey who intercepted a pass with only 2.4 seconds left to play and won the championship for his school in an incredible 70 foot throw.

Continue reading “Taking The Shot: Julian McGarvey And The Self-Defining Moment”