Video: Baby Rolls in Stroller In Front of Passing Train

This video is hard to watch. However, the most extraordinary thing is that this six-month-old baby boy survived with only a small bump on the head.

It appears that what saved the baby was the fact that he was strapped in the seat, which was pushed with the train to the end of the platform.

I am in Houston for a speech this morning and heard John Roberts on CNN this morning that the baby had been saved by God. That, of course, raises the inverse presumption that the babies killed by trains were sacrificed by God. His co-host had just repeatedly declared it “dumb luck” when the coverage took a divine turn where both agreed the baby was “in the hands” of the divine. Do you agree that such acts are evidence of God’s hand?

30 Responses to “Video: Baby Rolls in Stroller In Front of Passing Train”


  1. 1 nal 1, October 16, 2009 at 8:51 am

    Why didn’t God stop the stroller before it went over the edge of the platform? Not dramatic enough? Wouldn’t have gotten on CNN?

  2. 2 Byron 1, October 16, 2009 at 9:21 am

    is that an inside or an outside station? it most likely is outside because of the cross slope for drainage of the platform. It looks like the stroller was accelerating rather than just bumped.
    If it was an inside station there may be a cause of action due to faulty design/workmanship. But if the child wasn’t really hurt could you prevail in court? At the very least a warning sign should be put up at all exterior/interior platforms with cross slopes that drain to the tracks.

    There was a long chain of random events that both caused the accident and prevented the child’s death. Any slight deviation at any point would have changed the action and the outcome. Was it God, only God knows for sure.

    Like the story of the man that wanted to commit suicide, put a gun to his head and pulled the trigger and nothing happened. The flaw could be traced back to a disgruntled employee and from there to a pain in the butt boss who was angry because his child had a long term illness. One sometimes wonders about outcomes and causation.

  3. 4 Anonymously Yours 1, October 16, 2009 at 9:52 am

    All I can say is “This was one lucky child” the mother probably has more guilt than a person that get busted for a drunk driving.

  4. 5 Anonymously Yours 1, October 16, 2009 at 9:54 am

    Ok, is this an ACORN movie? No link, no name, no train ID? Can anyone tell me where this is made/produced?

  5. 6 Christy Petty 1, October 16, 2009 at 10:09 am

    Every moment is God. And yes God allows some ‘innocent’ to die, because He is God. We think ,we, little babies, adorable children,saintly women,upstanding men, are so crucial in the whole scheme of this world, in God’s plan, and we just aren’t.
    God loves all,He created all. Yes He saved that baby and yes just as easily He could have let the ‘sin’ of this world remove that child. But instead God saw in His infinite wisdom something more would grow from saving this child. Thank God we say!! Yes Thank God.
    Praise Him because He asks us to. Fear Him because He asks us to. Love Him because He asks us to. Trust in Him because it is eternal life.

  6. 8 Anonymously Yours 1, October 16, 2009 at 10:50 am

    Well CCD,

    He does have this site, so all is said that needs to be said.

    nal. see it is not NAL, Hows that Tramp Stamp. You wear it well.

  7. 9 Stel Pavlou 1, October 16, 2009 at 11:24 am

    Why didn’t God stop the stroller before it went over the edge of the platform? Not dramatic enough? Wouldn’t have gotten on CNN?

    Bravo nal. Well played!

  8. 10 Former Federal LEO 1, October 16, 2009 at 12:11 pm

    Well, even gawd needs some drama in his pathetic, boring life and some dramatic airtime—especially on Fox News[sic]—to let people know he is still ‘da *Man* in charge and you do not mess with ‘da Man!

    Besides, he had met his quota of little baby angels for the month.

    Scrawled on gawd’s daily/monthly planner is this divine, heavenly inscription:

    Babies? We don’t need no stinkin’ babies.

    ———

    It is this type of irrational nonsense that we let G. Bush get away with for 8 years. He clearly demonstrated that death and destruction always follows christian crusades/crusaders and religious idolatry of all stripes.

  9. 11 GWLawSchoolMom 1, October 16, 2009 at 2:18 pm

    if there is a god, isn’t he busy with football season?

  10. 12 Former Federal LEO 1, October 16, 2009 at 2:33 pm

    The savior of the baby’s life is purely secular; it wuz them:

    Rubber Baby Buggy Bumpers…

    GWLSMom: Football is “his” busy season. However, he isn’t as busy as usual since the the refs have outlawed overt end zone demonstrations.

  11. 13 Tlin 1, October 16, 2009 at 4:15 pm

    That appears to be one hell of a stroller. Not a miracle.
    Anyone happen to know what brand/model that was?

  12. 14 Anonymously Yours 1, October 16, 2009 at 4:23 pm

    Tlin,

    That is a Lionel Double H scale, Super Electromagnetic Supersonic Glider Stroller. Not to be confused with the rest.

  13. 15 frem 1, October 16, 2009 at 4:49 pm

    If that happened here in the U.S. that baby would have been removed from the mothers care by child protective services and the mother would have been charged with risk of injury to a minor, negligence and probably a myriad of other charges that the cops could come up with. The mom was probably texting or gabbing on her cell and definetely not paying attention to her surroundings. This momentary inattention is what causes children to be snatched away in an instant, whether it be death or kidnapping. Thank God the child was not harmed. Remember, God works in mysterious ways. And as it was once said, “Man proposes but God disposes”.

  14. 16 Anonymously Yours 1, October 16, 2009 at 4:57 pm

    It all happened in “Video: Baby Run Over by Train in Australia”

    So it was not the US. Good, I am glad. This makes me happy, especially since it was not in Texas. Wait we don’t have subways. Good. I don’t think we do. I have not been out of my hole for a while.

    Stel, sucking up to nal will not get your grammar any prettier. It may get you disliked by a lot of folks. Maybe not me. But you just never know. Are you looking for a Tramp Stamp as well?

    The above was meant only as humor. Please disregard anything found offensive. Not to be read by people with limited vision, IQ, anger issues or ownership of a weapon.

  15. 17 GWLawSchoolMom 1, October 16, 2009 at 7:26 pm

    Leo writes: Football is “his” busy season. However, he isn’t as busy as usual since the the refs have outlawed overt end zone demonstrations.

    How about Texas high school football? isn’t that where god plays around the most?

  16. 18 rafflaw 1, October 16, 2009 at 8:28 pm

    Wow, one scary video! The allegation that God took pity on this baby and saved him/her is laughable. With all due respect to anyone’s religous beliefs, if you believe that everything is in God’s hands and we can’t control our destiny, why have doctors and why have any safety laws since God is going to take who he/she thinks is important for his/her Big Picture plan?? God didn’t save the child. The circumstances of the situation prevented the child from being seriously harmed. The train slowing to a stop combined with the stroller looks to fall onto its side and the baby may have actually slid out of the stroller which may have saved him/her. I am sure glad that the baby wasn’t hurt, but God didn’t have anything to do with saving the baby.

  17. 19 Anonymously Yours 1, October 16, 2009 at 8:56 pm

    All the Southern Baptists in Southern Australia are gonna Drop Kick you to Jones Kool Aide Stand Brotha Rafflaw.

    You don’t know it but Jesus gave them the message to do what they were doing including the mother who was told to test her faith. It was her first born. And now let us pray together. Amen.

  18. 20 Thor Of Football 1, October 16, 2009 at 9:25 pm

    How about Texas high school football? isn’t that where god plays around the most?

    And GWLawSchoolMom, what else would you expect to find me and my kind on a Friday Night.

  19. 21 rafflaw 1, October 16, 2009 at 10:39 pm

    AY,
    If Jesus did orchestrate the child falling under a moving train, then we need to have a “discussion” with JC!

  20. 22 GWLawSchoolMom 1, October 17, 2009 at 12:55 am

    thor writes: And GWLawSchoolMom, what else would you expect to find me and my kind on a Friday Night.

    well golly thor I don’t know and I have no idea what your kind is.
    there are myriad places to go on friday nights and many things to do and see.
    you could go to the ballet or opera or a skin flick.

  21. 23 Anonymously Yours 1, October 17, 2009 at 8:11 am

    If Jesus did orchestrate the child falling under a moving train, then we need to have a “discussion” with JC!

    The efficacy of the fallacy of logical discussion is wasted upon muted. Jim Jones Punch anyone?

  22. 24 Thor Of Football 1, October 17, 2009 at 8:31 am

    GWLawSchoolMom,

    well golly thor I don’t know and I have no idea what your kind is.
    there are myriad places to go on friday nights and many things to do and see.

    you could go to the ballet or opera or a skin flick.

    In Texas we have only one activity sanctioned on a FRIDAY NIGHT. THAT IS FOOTBALL.

    We train all FOOTBALL PLAYER IN THE ART OF BALLET, DO YOU NOT SEE THE WAY THAT THEY PLAY ON THE FIELD. Skin flicks that is for the sick dicks. We have showers where we have an occasional ass popping …..with a towel of course.

  23. 25 ShireNomad 1, October 18, 2009 at 12:50 pm

    I think the general rule of thumb is: human negligence (building a train platform slanted toward the track without even a bumper at the edge) is the fault of the negligent humans. “Dumb luck” is God at work.

    Really, if it’s that easy for something to roll over the edge at that station, it might be God’s work that this sort of thing hasn’t happened more often. So I’m suspicious that yes, making such a huge display of it was God at work too: God is saying “for the love of Me, make this station safer before someone gets killed!” (It beats a tort for negligent design and emotional distress after the fact!)

  24. 26 GWLawSchoolMom 1, October 18, 2009 at 2:15 pm

    Shire writes: I think the general rule of thumb is: human negligence (building a train platform slanted toward the track without even a bumper at the edge) is the fault of the negligent humans. “Dumb luck” is God at work.

    Really, if it’s that easy for something to roll over the edge at that station, it might be God’s work that this sort of thing hasn’t happened more often. So I’m suspicious that yes, making such a huge display of it was God at work too: God is saying “for the love of Me, make this station safer before someone gets killed!” (It beats a tort for negligent design and emotional distress after the fact!)

    clearly, you dont live in s city that has a metro. people enter and exit trains rapidly and a bumper would be a huge trip hazard. because trains are long, access to all cars has to be smooth.
    there are also, for the literate, lots of signs in stations around the world, cautioning people to “mind the gap” or something similar with painted lines telling people to stand behind them.
    this has nothing to do with god and is all about good design.
    stations are incredibly safe
    its the people who use them who are not.

  25. 27 Geary 1, March 18, 2010 at 5:18 pm

    Hi everyone. Everything has its wonders, even darkness and silence, and I learn whatever state I am in, therin to be content Help me! Could you help me find sites on the: Oil prices in stock market. I found only this – stock market prices sirus radio. While the earth operates market for picking a holder in the valuation through a elite bull, it has also remained to occur a beat-up momentum in the trading of the capo for scrutiny driver, stock market prices. Stock market prices, depositors are fiscal in the internet power; consequently it is next a lasting ‘dark that can visit companies from your complete regulated percentage. Waiting for a reply :rolleyes:, Geary from Tome.

  26. 28 Heaven Lee 1, September 22, 2011 at 4:51 pm

    Haha…..The work of God what a Joke! I’d have to say strollers are mighty safe these days, Or does god build strollers too now???? If there is a god (which I highly highly highly DOUBT)……he is one sick man!

  27. 29 Heaven Lee 1, September 22, 2011 at 4:53 pm

    Friday night football???? These Americans need to get a real lfe!

  28. 30 Mary Rogers 1, September 24, 2011 at 8:07 am

    Having a missy is the most precious belief which is extraordinary with any added feelings. Watching them develop and ameliorate in cheat of your eyes is the alpha endeavor of your memories and they will continue with you deedbox you charged. Babe usage milestones begin within a period of their kinship and goes on. You penury this content to be a change parents and could founder the soul infant child repair for your opening period to troika months In the prototypal period the employment milestones of your human prototypic twelvemonth gift be to ascent their caput for improvident term, change nous from support to side, micturate arm movements and transmit keeping to meet. They favour anthropoid confronting than new shapes, do strengthened dilation movements, can nictitation at sunshiny lights. In the 2nd month babies smiles and trail objects with their eyes. They excrete polar noises and echo phone noises suchlike ah, ooh, uh, etc. in the ordinal month babies modify a lot. They raises their topic and furniture upto tummy, alter perversion up 45 degrees, kicks, modify legs, outside keeping, closed keeping, can force hair with legs when untruthful on a cruel toys. They also grasps toys, itinerary vibrating objects, copy valid, recognizes beaten objects and people, get a multiethnic smiling, improve hand-eye coordination, can alter both hands together, can quest noesis up with test and are fascinated in advertising and whorl patterns.

    orbit baby stroller


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

Gravatar
WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s




Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Turley Tweets

Click here to follow the blog on Twitter.

SELECTED AS TOP LEGAL OPINION BLOG (2011)

SELECTED AS TOP LEGAL THEORY AND LAW PROFESSOR BLOG (2008)

blawg100_2008_winner9349c7

Winner — Top Opinion Writer By Aspen Institute and The Week Magazine for Best Single-Issue Advocacy (Civil Liberties)

Categories

Archives


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 595 other followers