Australian Public Schools Teaching Humans and Dinosaurs Co-Existed

Australia is facing a controversy that is all too familiar to Americans. Fundamentalists in state schools are teaching children that humans and dinosaurs lived together and Noah brought dinosaur eggs on to the Ark.


Children are also taught that Adam and Eve were not eaten by dinosaurs “because they were under a protective spell.”

This is consistent with Palintology — the new science advanced by Sarah Palin — which insists that man and dinosaur must have co-existed despite carbon dating and simple logic.
Source: News

452 thoughts on “Australian Public Schools Teaching Humans and Dinosaurs Co-Existed”

  1. Blouise: “the point is not the personal attack … it’s the passive-aggressive mode of presentation.”

    Point of order. Slarti made a wholly personal attack against me and I simply ‘reminded him where we left off.’ No retaliation whatsoever.

    Slarti’s next reply wasn’t substantive; it was simply another personal attack against me.

    My reply in full: “And I could say the same about your inane & inapplicable examples and analogies; e.g. your meteor impact and paper clip analogies. However, rather than attack you personally, I simply reminded you where we left off.”

    In one paragraph I both defended myself and reminded him that I turned the other cheek the first time around. That’s far from passive aggressive. Attack me once; shame on you. Attack me twice…

  2. Gyges,

    I think the dogs are up and hunting – but as I said, I’ll take my reply back to the original thread…

    Anyway, it’s hot and I’m going to spend the rest of the afternoon out on the lake…

  3. TraderB–

    “It biodegrades quickly…”

    What, exactly, is the “it” you refer to. Can you be more specific? What are the products of “its” biodegredation?
    Do you know the exact amount of the substance you refer to as “it” that was dispersed in the Gulf? How quickly will “it” biodegrade? Will any of “it” be ingested by animal life before “it” biodegrades? Will any of “it” or the products of “its” biodegradation cause any environmental problems?

    Tell me, are you are marine toxicologist? a chemist? an environmental scientist?

  4. Elaine M
    “Oh, it was only used for a few days…so no harm done??? Is that what you’re trying to tell me.”

    It biodegrades quickly, so it is unlikely to be present. The EPA said that using it was a trade-off. If they had the A-Whale in the beginning, they might have been able to skim the oil.

  5. Bob,Esq.
    1, August 3, 2010 at 2:54 pm
    “I will not stoop to personally attacking you by saying you’re a son-of-a-#@^* for that would be beneath me …. blah, blah …” … once I read that sort of intro, I’m highly skeptical of any material that follows.”

    Slarti attacked me personally twice, I defended myself once. Yet you’re not skeptical of Slarti’s ‘material that follows?’
    ===============================================================

    Nope … (but I admit to paraphrasing your actual comments) … because he never claimed to be “not” personally attacking you … the point is not the personal attack … it’s the passive-aggressive mode of presentation.

    You know the “Now, I’m not saying the Prosecutor is lying to you, ladies and gentlemen members of the jury, … I’m suggesting he’s not giving you the whole truth.” Turn off …

  6. Slartibartfast,

    “BP has no credibility to say that the COREXIT is harmless and no one should take their word on anything – they’ve already broken trust, so at this point we need to verify everything.”

    It is the EPA saying that. They released a report showing that a mixture of Corexit 9500A and Louisiana sweet crude is no more toxic than LSC alone. Corexit itself is less toxic than LSC and the mixture, presumably because of the absence of benzene and other aromatics in the petroleum distillates. They do not even bother to test the other two ingredients, since they are so common.

  7. “I will not stoop to personally attacking you by saying you’re a son-of-a-#@^* for that would be beneath me …. blah, blah …” … once I read that sort of intro, I’m highly skeptical of any material that follows.”

    Slarti attacked me personally twice, I defended myself once. Yet you’re not skeptical of Slarti’s ‘material that follows?’

  8. From Williamsburg Yorktown Daily (7/29/2010)

    VIMS Prof. Warns Congress of Potential Tradeoffs in Gulf Oil Dispersant Strategy
    By Dave Malmquist, of the Virginia Institute of Marine Science Thursday, July 29, 2010
    http://www.wydaily.com/local-news/4792-vims-prof-warns-congress-of-potential-tradeoffs-in-gulf-oil-dispersant-strategy.html

    Excerpt:
    Oil dispersants work like dishwashing detergent, breaking oil into droplets that mix more easily with the surrounding water. They are designed to break up surface oil slicks, thereby reducing damage to the shoreline; protecting animals such as sea turtles that spend extensive time at the ocean surface; and increasing the rate at which microbes can consume the hydrocarbons. To date, BP has released approximately two million gallons of dispersants into the Gulf.

    Diaz, an ecologist with expertise in bottom-dwelling communities and low-oxygen marine “dead zones,” briefed members of the Congress and their staff on the ecological trade-offs inherent in dispersant use.

    “Applying dispersants represents a decision to increase the hydrocarbon load on one part of the ecosystem while reducing the load on another,” said Diaz. “It decreases risk at the surface and shoreline while increasing potential risk to organisms in the water column and on the seafloor.”

    Diaz stressed that assessing the long-term risks and impact of dispersant use will require study of the Gulf ecosystem as a whole. He says “We now have small drops of oil dissolved throughout the water column in large areas of the Gulf, so resident organisms can encounter oil during different stages of their life cycle, and throughout the food chain.”

    As an example, Diaz noted that white, pink, and brown shrimp ¬ important targets of the Gulf fishing industry ¬ all spawn offshore, with juveniles subsequently moving into coastal nursery areas. He said that crab larvae ¬ important food for many other species ¬ have already been found with droplets of oil under their shell.

    Diaz said migratory animals, including Atlantic bluefin tuna, enter Gulf waters during sensitive parts of their life cycle. “The Gulf of Mexico is an important spawning and nursery habitat for these fish,” said Diaz. “They’re drawn by the Gulf’s warm waters, abundant prey, and Sargassum¬a type of floating seaweed that harbors an ecosystem of its own.”

    Diaz also noted that scientists’ understanding of the environmental effects of dispersants decreases with depth. “We’ve done toxicity testing on shallow-water species that are easily grown or kept,” said Diaz, “so the risks that dispersants pose to surface species are pretty well understood. But as we move from marshes to the deep-sea, our knowledge declines sharply.”

    He cautioned that dispersed oil could reach the bottom along with sinking sediment, potentially affecting the coldwater coral ecosystems of the deep Gulf. These unique habitats, in depths exceeding 1,000 feet, feature a diverse community that includes coldwater corals such as Lophelia pertusa and Madrepora oculata.

  9. Blouise,

    Shhh, or you will be the one getting 9/11 in my science thread again. They argued this for months, it’s best to just let sleeping dogs lie.

  10. Slartibartfast
    1, August 3, 2010 at 2:33 pm
    Blouise,

    Yes, there should be a ‘Mr. Burns’ emoticon…

    As far as the cut and paste goes, TraderB isn’t so bad – he’s just using misdirection to give the appearance of support for a conclusion – that’s pretty easy to sort out. And as far as knowledge in my field goes, I generally have the facts at hand to refute any BS. But when it comes to general science, the odds are stacked heavily towards the cut/paster – Bob posted a link to a scientific paper on another thread and now I’ve got to read through a 25 page paper which is not in my field and debunk it… It’s a lot easier to spread misinformation than it is to correct it. I would guess that I spend at a minimum 5 to 10 times as long researching and responding to those types of comments as the people take to write them.

    ==========================================================

    I highlighted your one sentence as support for this: “Just ask Mrs. Sherrod.”

    I read Bob’s post last evening … I can’t comment at all on the science and stay out of all discussions for I know zilch about the subject however I did notice a certain style of attack that begins with: “I will not stoop to personally attacking you by saying you’re a son-of-a-#@^* for that would be beneath me …. blah, blah …” … once I read that sort of intro, I’m highly skeptical of any material that follows.

  11. Gyges,

    Eye em bat ate spilling, to. God think eye hive ay spill chick…

  12. TraderB–

    “Corexit 9527A does contain it, but they used it for only a few days after the spill.”

    Oh, it was only used for a few days…so no harm done??? Is that what you’re trying to tell me.

    Gotta watch out for them marine toxicologists. They’re always trying to mislead people!

    **********

    From New York Times (6/9/2010)
    Ingredients of Controversial Dispersants Used on Gulf Spill Are Secrets No More

    By ELANA SCHOR
    http://www.nytimes.com/gwire/2010/06/09/09greenwire-ingredients-of-controversial-dispersants-used-42891.html

    Excerpts:
    Three ingredients of the two Corexit formulas were already available on material safety data sheets that outline the human health risks of using the dispersants in the workplace. Corexit 9527, used in lesser quantities during the earlier days of the spill response, is designated a chronic and acute health hazard by EPA. The 9527 formula contains 2-butoxyethanol, pinpointed as the cause of lingering health problems experienced by cleanup workers after the 1989 Exxon Valdez oil spill, and propylene glycol, a commonly used solvent.

    Corexit 9500, described by Pajor as the “sole product” Nalco has manufactured for the Gulf since late April, contains propylene glycol and light petroleum distillates, a type of chemical refined from crude oil. Nalco had previously declined to identify the third hazardous substance in the 9500 formula, but EPA’s website reveals it to be dioctyl sodium sulfosuccinate, a detergent and common ingredient in laxatives.

    *****

    In fact, one potentially significant detail for advocates seeking to perform independent dispersant tests was left out of the EPA’s online disclosure: the proportions in which the chemical ingredients are mixed to produce Corexit. “Having the full ingredients out there is only part of the information that someone wanting to copy the product would need,” said Pajor, of Nalco.

    This afternoon Nalco added a release to its website that matched up the chemical components of Corexit with the common household substances that it had named last month as sharing common ingredients with the dispersant. According to Nalco, ioctyl sodium sulfosuccinate is also used as a “wetting agent in cosmetic products, gelatin, [and] beverages”; sorbitan, tri-(9Z)-9-octadecenoate, poly(oxy-1,2-ethanediyl) derivs is found in body and face lotion; sorbitan, mono-(9Z)-9-octadecenoate, poly(oxy-1,2-ethanediyl) derivs is used in mouthwash and baby bath products; and sorbitan, mono-(9Z)-9-octadecenoate is found in body shampoo and juice.

  13. Blouise,

    Yes, there should be a ‘Mr. Burns’ emoticon…

    As far as the cut and paste goes, TraderB isn’t so bad – he’s just using misdirection to give the appearance of support for a conclusion – that’s pretty easy to sort out. And as far as knowledge in my field goes, I generally have the facts at hand to refute any BS. But when it comes to general science, the odds are stacked heavily towards the cut/paster – Bob posted a link to a scientific paper on another thread and now I’ve got to read through a 25 page paper which is not in my field and debunk it… It’s a lot easier to spread misinformation than it is to correct it. I would guess that I spend at a minimum 5 to 10 times as long researching and responding to those types of comments as the people take to write them.

  14. Slart,

    I’ve always been really bad at spelling. That’s why I never converted to Wicca. Puns are another issue entirely.

  15. The methodology of the application needs to be taken into consideration also. What guarantee is there that the dispersant applied at the well head actually dispersed and didn’t linger or migrate as a separate, concentrated toxin. From the very start that was a method of use characterized as unique.

    From article written in May:

    “Tjeerdema (Ronald Tjeerdema, chair of the Department of Environmental Toxicology at UC Davis’ College of Agricultural & Environmental Sciences, who has been studying dispersants since the ’90s) explained that the tactic of applying dispersant underwater at the base of leak is a “unique situation” because dispersants are normally applied at the surface. “The hope is that the dispersants and oil mix as they rise and lessen the amount of oil that reaches the surface,” he said. Mixing is key to achieving that goal, he continued, and mixing occurs best at warm temperatures. “At 5,000 feet below the surface, the temperature is a lot colder and there’s a lot more pressure, and both the dispersant and the oil are thicker and more viscous,” he said. “My guess is that the mixing down low isn’t happening very readily … I would be concerned that they’re not very mixable because of the temperature.”

    If they don’t mix well, of course, BP was until recently dumping toxic chemicals into the Gulf without gaining any advantage in limiting damage from the spill. According to a report on Wednesday, a “brown slime” appeared on the shore of a barrier island off Louisiana. “The slime, which is not as thick as oil, is thought to be the chemical dispersant that had been pumped down to the site of the leak to break up the oil before it reached the surface,” ABC reported.”

    http://www.sott.net/articles/show/208366-Chemical-Dispersants-Being-Used-in-Gulf-Clean-up-are-Potentially-Toxic

Comments are closed.