Today, we filed the complaint below in the challenge to Utah’s criminal polygamy law. I am still in Salt Lake City for the filing. With me today is our local counsel Adam Alba, an outstanding young attorney and one of my former students. As noted earlier, the lawsuit is on behalf of my clients, the Brown family. The Browns are featured in the TLC program Sister Wives as an openly polygamous family.
The Plaintiffs are Kody Brown, Christine Brown, Janelle Brown, Meri Brown, and Robyn Sullivan.
The Defendants are Governor Gary Herbert, Attorney General Mark Shurtleff, and County Attorney Jeffrey R. Buhman.
There are seven claims for relief:
Claim One: Due Process
Claim Two: Equal Protection
Claim Three: Free Exercise
Claim Four: Free Speech
Claim Five: Freedom of Association
Claim Six: Establishment of Religion
Claim Seven: 42 U.S.C. § 1983
As in past cases, I will have to be circumspect in what I say after the filing of this action. However, we are honored to represent the Brown family in this historic challenge,” said Professor Turley. “We believe that this case represents the strongest factual and legal basis for a challenge to the criminalization of polygamy ever filed in the federal courts. We are not demanding the recognition of polygamous marriage. We are only challenging the right of the state to prosecute people for their private relations and demanding equal treatment with other citizens in living their lives according to their own beliefs. This action seeks to protect one of the defining principles of this country, what Justice Louis Brandeis called ‘the right to be left alone.’ In that sense, it is a challenge designed to benefit not just polygamists but all citizens who wish to live their lives according to their own values – even if those values run counter to those of the majority in the state.
The following is the statement from Kody Brown, which will be the only statement at this time on the filing:
Statement of Kody Brown:
“There are tens of thousands of plural families in Utah and other states. We are one of those families. We only wish to live our private lives according to our beliefs. While we understand that this may be a long struggle in court, it has already been a long struggle for my family and other plural families to end the stereotypes and unfair treatment given consensual polygamy. We are indebted to Professor Turley and his team for their work and dedication. Together we hope to secure equal treatment with other families in the United States.”
Here is the complaint filed today: Brown Complaint
Jonathan Turley
So here’s an independent argument about the relationship between monogamy and political equality. Worth reading.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/andrewbrown/2010/jul/26/religion-polygamy-monogamy-psychology-crime
And here’s the paper it is based on, which sets out some of the arguments I’ve described above.
http://www.vancouversun.com/pdf/affidavit.pdf
See page 21 for the meat of it.
Polygny produces
1) increased crime and antisocial behavior among men
2) younger age of marriage for women
3) increased inequality between sexes
4) less paternal investment in offspring
5) reduced GDP due to changes in male economic choices
And that’s just the start of it.
Now all of this is an argument based on reasoning about how societies and people function. You are free to dispute it, but the case is fairly compelling if you are willing to read it seriously.
People are also by nature murderous, but that doesn’t mean that we don’t have laws against murder.
I would consider men who marry multiple women, and women who enter plural marriages to be equally complicit in doing what comes natural, even when it is disruptive of a stable and just social order. For the men, and in many or most cases, for the women too I’m sure it looks like a solution.
I have a different vision, a vision of a society which doesn’t shut men out of marriage, which supports the economic and personal attributes of so called “lower status” men, so that they are in fact attractive marriage partners for women.
You see, an egalitarian society goes hand in hand with monogamy… supports it, and is in turn supported by it.
The “utopia” that you complain about is just the thing that normative Western culture has advocated for hundreds of years. It’s only in the last hundred years (with Mormonism?) that we have renewed polygamist efforts, and just in the last 10 or so years that those efforts have taken up new religious freedom and personal freedom arguments.
So this is the first real challenge that monogamy has seen in modern history on a legal level, and it’s no coincidence that it is occurring as the radical political right is seeing new strength. The love of inequality, and the hatred of community, of regulation and of self government, go hand in hand and are rising on many fronts, economic, interpersonal, cultural.
Free relationship market? I don’t believe even you are really for that. You do oppose incestuous marriages? Child marriages? Of course you do. Markets function best when they are subject to reasonable regulations.
“I’m only interested in the men you don’t see, the ones who will never find a spouse because of those happy families that you do see.”
That certainly explains why you ignore the rights of the women involved. I suggest that if you want to create good law you need to be concerned with everyone concerned, not just a subset.
“The example of “controls” I gave is an example of a sexist male dominated animal society, the kind of thing I oppose our human society becoming.”
I understand you want to perform social engineering. Instead you want to replace it with a sexist government society that limits the choices that women are allowed to make for husbands.
“I prefer a democratic community of equality and equal opportunity.”
It is impossible to have democracy, equality, or opportunity without the most basic of human values: freedom.
“Mildly Illegal and strongly socially unacceptable.”
What shall you do sir? Shall you jail them and separate them from their kids?
How about this? Lets prosecute polygamists on the same day we start prosecuting adulterers and fornicators who have more than one partner with the exact same penalties? Otherwise it sure looks like you have a prejudice against marriage and sanction an unequal access to the law.
“Compassion. Justice for all. A vision of a human society in which the maximum number of people’s needs are met and their humanity recognized.”
Except, of course for the wives, who are preventing from marrying the man that they love, which seems to me to me fundamental human right.
“I’d prefer that we organize society along monogamous lines for exactly that purpose, to create a just society in which everyone (more or less) gets taken care of, or has the opportunity to get taken care of, in terms of reproductive opportunity, relationship opportunity, sexual opportunity and intimacy/love opportunity.”
That is not the world we live in, and to use the state to achieve your utopia would be a terrible thing. You seem to be wanting to do with human relationships what socialists want to do with money.
Further your utopia seems to think monogamy meets everyone’s needs, but as you said earlier, by nature humans are polygamous. It is therefore not a great stretch to believe that polygamous relationships meet some peoples needs, too, but in your utopia they would be frustrated by the very government that is to serve them and protect their rights.
No, I think the free relationship market is a much better solution
The logical fallacy I see perpetuated above is the fallacy of small numbers versus large numbers. The number of families that will opt for a poly family group is a very small number compared with the total number of people. We see polygamy as a common lifestyle in the middle east, for example, but the actual number of people available is so large that it does not even make a ripple when we consider statistical probabilities.
Chris, As I already stated the problem with polygamy is that it IS quite “natural” and common in human history.
Yes, it is society’s job, acting through its institutions (aka government) to control human nature, preventing all sorts of natural preferences like murder, robbery, rape, incest, and the taking of many wives. This is ethics 101. It’s what communities do to create just stable societies.
To repeat myself, I have no interest in the preferences of the women and men involved in plural marriages. Some of them, and certainly those featured on a TV show, are no doubt quite happy. I’m only interested in the men you don’t see, the ones who will never find a spouse because of those happy families that you do see.
The example of “controls” I gave is an example of a sexist male dominated animal society, the kind of thing I oppose our human society becoming. I prefer a democratic community of equality and equal opportunity.
Gyges,
Reasonable question:
“Miles,
“It should not be legal to maintain a relationship with multiple women (whether they are called girlfriends or wives), with whom a man repeatedly sires children.”
And you think that any system set up to enforce this wouldn’t favor the connected and wealthy?”
To the extent that it did favor the powerful, that would be a bug… and not a feature.
“or would we rather be a baboon or gorilla society in which an uber male controls large number of females?”
Do you even watched the show in question? Are the women involved “controlled” or volunteers? Have they chosen the man that they want to be with?
So you are saying that the state should deny the wives the opportunity to be with the man that they love so as to satisfy your own sense of fair play? So ultimately it is the job of the state to make some people unhappy (wives) so that other people can be happy (single men). And that is your definition of justice?
No. I think the free relationship market much more just and fair than your government controlled relationship market.
“There’s nothing sexist about my arguments at all.”
Yes it is. Very much so. See above and the use of the word “controls”.
“Nothing in our animal or human pasts suggests that it would. Polygamy remains a case of one man, many women, across species and across most of human history.”
So you are saying that polygamy is perfectly natural and you believe that it is the government’s job to fight human nature?
You never answered if you want to use the state to go after Hugh Hefner and Charlie Sheen, too?
Chris
“Should we make what Hugh Hefner and Charlie Sheen are doing illegal, too?”
Mildly Illegal and strongly socially unacceptable.
“To protect the poor men who are left out with no women?”
Now you’re getting it. Compassion. Justice for all. A vision of a human society in which the maximum number of people’s needs are met and their humanity recognized.
“Or would you prefer the state just assign every man a women to make sure everyone is taken care of?”
I’d prefer that we organize society along monogamous lines for exactly that purpose, to create a just society in which everyone (more or less) gets taken care of, or has the opportunity to get taken care of, in terms of reproductive opportunity, relationship opportunity, sexual opportunity and intimacy/love opportunity.
Chris,
You say:
“If two men married each other, then there are two women out there who now have no chance of having a husband. Polygamy balances out homosexuality.”
While statistics in this area are variable, most studies suggest that yes, there are very slightly more gay men than gay women, and so there might be a slight imbalance. But the big picture is that gay men don’t create a significant deficit in the market of available men for marriage because they are balanced by lesbian women who also remove themselves from the heterosexual marriage “market”.
—
“We gave up state control of this task when adultery laws went out the window.” In a sense you are right. That was preliminary to legalizing polygamy. We’ve been moving in this direction, growing economic inequality, legitimization of serial monogamy, glorification of men who bed lots of women, and now “naturally”, polygamy too. A society has to make choices. Will it be one in which men have an equality of opportunity for marriage, love, sex and reproduction, or would we rather be a baboon or gorilla society in which an uber male controls large number of females? http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2011/07/110714142137.htm
—
There’s nothing sexist about my arguments at all. Indeed, if there was any reason to think that women would choose to gather multiple husbands, and so do in the same numbers as men chose to gather multiple women, then I don’t think I would have any objection to polygamy at all. But the burden of evidence that this would ever happen is on those who say that it might. Nothing in our animal or human pasts suggests that it would. Polygamy remains a case of one man, many women, across species and across most of human history.
In the one polyandry case that I know of (Tibet), the men who share a wife are almost always brothers (or cousins), so that they share a genetic interest in the woman’s child, regardless of actual paternity. However this, again, is a very rare case, in a human cross cultural context.
“I think the Brown children should be able to attend public schools and be open about their family situation without the fear that something bad could happen to their father. I think the state should do what is best for the Brown children. Putting Kody in prison would serve no good purpose.”
So what do you suggest, if anything, be done?
“Sure, it is possible to imagine that new things can happen in this world.”
Miles,
In your 4:15 comment that begins with the above line don’t you realize that you could substitute homosexuality for polygamy and come up with the type of argument a homophobe would use to argue for banning homosexuality.
“Why not do away with the pretense of divorce?”
That is the only line that wouldn’t fit. however, talking to that question your statement:
“I’m really not interested in criminalizing sex. On the other hand, the state may have a role to play in defining the terms of social order and household formation, through a combination of education, advocacy, intervention and criminal penalties.”
Miles, please of course you are as shown by your “On the other hand” and what follows.
“Societies that allow men (and again, the polyandry argument is simply not realistic) to accumulate multiple wives, are creating a gradient that will profoundly reward some men, and punish others.”
Finally, though I’m sure you don’t intend it, your arguments continue to border on being sexist. You give all the power to men in getting these relationships and none to women for either avoiding or partaking. Do you really think so little of a woman’s ability to choose.
Your arguments are beginning to border on the territory of the anti-abortion movement. Women must be protected because they can’t choose for themselves. Society must be protected in order to ensure procreation. Same lines of reasoning being used.
Yeah, what could possibly go wrong by throwing out hundreds of years of social mores willy nilly?
“The point is the shut out men.”
This is absurd. Should we make what Hugh Hefner and Charlie Sheen are doing illegal, too? To protect the poor men who are left out with no women? Or would you prefer the state just assign every man a women to make sure everyone is taken care of?
The truth is we currently already have a free relationship market and men can and do take care of themselves. This lawsuit is simply about what we are allowed to call it.
Chris,
“If two men married each other, then there are two women out there who now have no chance of having a husband. Polygamy balances out homosexuality.”
What about lesbians getting married? Did you consider that? It isn’t just gay men who believe in same-sex marriage. I don’t see how polygamy balances out homosexuality.
Miles,
Well, at this point we’re just talking in circles. Personally, I don’t see that you’ve provided any evidence that the U.S. is drastically different then all those other European countries (and itself in the past), that had huge amounts of inequality and didn’t revert to the polygamist hell you describe. On the other hand, I’ve given key differences (most importantly, the status of women) that it IS different than the polygamist societies you use for models.
We’re both just making educated guesses. Personally I’d rather err on the side of individual freedom than puritanical ideas.
“Not sure how that would work. Can you explain?”
If two men married each other, then there are two women out there who now have no chance of having a husband. Polygamy balances out homosexuality.
Actually, I find the whole “control the marriage market” argument absurd. In our free relationship market adults can, and do, connect up with who they want to connect up with. We gave up state control of this task when adultery laws went out the window.
This lawsuit is about what we can legally call what is already happening. Absurdly the law is on the side of less responsibility (“girlfriend”), and against more responsibility (“wife”).
Mike
“So are you contending that the difference between felony polygyny and the act of infidelity with a mistress is that your wife doesn’t know so it’s not illegal?”
Shall we debate how many angels can dance on the head of a pin?
I’m really not interested in criminalizing sex. On the other hand, the state may have a role to play in defining the terms of social order and household formation, through a combination of education, advocacy, intervention and criminal penalties.
Chris,
I’ve thought of that possibility too. I think the Brown children should be able to attend public schools and be open about their family situation without the fear that something bad could happen to their father. I think the state should do what is best for the Brown children. Putting Kody in prison would serve no good purpose.
Chris,
“That does not make sense on several levels.
1. Why is homosexuality gender neutral but not polygamy? Your position seems inherently sexist.”
Please be serious. Polygny (which most Polygamy in most cultures is and due to human evolutionary history is likely to remain ) shuts men out of marriage. I say polygamy when I mean polygyny, because that’s what human polygamy is in practice and historical reality.
“2. In a free relationship market maybe polygamy would soak up some of the demand created by same sex marriages?”
There is NO evidence or reason to think that heterosexual men seeking wives would have any interest in gay relationships. Your suggestion is part of the general hostility to the interests of men in that situation.
“3. Maybe some people would prefer and be fulfilled in an other than traditional marriage where they would not be in a traditional marriage. In fact the complaint lists one of the sister wives (Robyn Sullivan) who was in a monogamous marriage, but preferred polygamist marriage.”
The happiness of women and men in polygamous marriages doesn’t interest me much. I believe that such marriages can be happy for some people. It’s just not the point. The point is the shut out men.