I’ve Got Georgia on My Mind

Respectfully submitted by Lawrence Rafferty (rafflaw)-Guest Blogger

With apologies to the famous song of the same title, the State of Georgia has produced some interesting legislation and proposed legislation these days.  The latest in that long list of specious legislation is the proposal pushed by five Georgia State Senators that would set up a commission to review Federal laws.  Any laws not approved by that commission would be nullified and would not be upheld in their state.  If I understand the proposed legislation correctly, the State of Georgia, if this law is passed, would claim supremacy over Federal law. I realize that in some Tea Party view of the Constitution this makes sense, but not in the real world where the Constitution and court precedent makes it very clear that Federal law supersedes any and all conflicting State laws.

“The Constitution provides that acts of Congress “shall be the supreme law of the land” which is why states do not have the power to ignore federal law. Nevertheless, five Georgia state senators — including Majority Leader Chip Rogers (R) and senate President Pro Tempore Tommie Williams (R) — apparently do not believe that the Constitution applies to them. All five lawmakers introduced a wildly unconstitutional plan to have Georgia and its citizens simply ignore laws that its conservative leadership doesn’t want to follow:

(1) There is created the Joint Commission on Recommendation, which shall be charged with recommending and proposing for a vote by a constitutional majority the nullification in its entirety of a specific federal law or regulation which is deemed to be outside the scope of the powers delegated by the people to the federal government in the United States Constitution or at odds with the Georgia Constitution . . .

(4) Upon recommendation for nullification, the General Assembly may vote to nullify following such recommendation. The appropriate documentation reflecting the vote shall be documented in legislative journals of the House and Senate. In the event the General Assembly votes by a constitutional majority to nullify any federal statute, mandate, or executive order on the grounds of constitutionality, neither the state nor its citizens shall recognize or be obligated to live under such statute, mandate, or executive order.”  Truthout

Our friends in Georgia are taking the same path as Gov. Rick Perry chose in Texas when he pushed through a bill that would nullify a Federal law concerning light bulbs.  Light Bulb  It is amazing to me that in the year 2012, we are even having this discussion.  The Supremacy Clause of the Constitution, Article 6, Clause 2, makes it very clear that Federal law is the “law of the land”.

“This Constitution, and the laws of the United States which shall be made in pursuance thereof; and all treaties made, or which shall be made, under the authority of the United States, shall be the supreme law of the land; and the judges in every state shall be bound thereby, anything in the Constitution or laws of any State to the contrary notwithstanding.” U.S. Constitution  The Supreme Court has upheld and confirmed the supremacy of Federal law over conflicting State legislation. But this idea of States nullifying Federal legislation continues to fester.

I question whether these State attempts to nullify Federal law is actually an attempt to discredit the current administration in the eyes of the supporters of these State officials rather than an effort to stop what they consider to be unjust laws. Are politics involved in these decisions to attempt to nullify Federal law?

Are these Georgia legislators trying to re-fight the Civil War with these claims of States superiority over Federal law?  Are these nullification efforts related to the Tenther movement?  Even our old friend, Ron Paul has come out as a supporter of this alleged power of States nullification of Federal law.  Ron Paul   Does it surprise you that a sitting U.S. Congressman would have these views?

Finally, while the attempts by States to nullify Federal laws isn’t new, the calls for nullification seem to have increased since President Obama came into office.  Will the nullification movement die out if Obama is not re-elected?  Let’s hear what you think!

Additional Sources:

McClatchy

James Madison letter to Edward Everett

Crosby v. National Foreign Trade Council

Cooper v. Aaron

219 thoughts on “I’ve Got Georgia on My Mind”

  1. Truth be told, use of nullification, states’ rights, and tentherism are nothing but ploys to abuse minorities or take advantage of other states. Period.

  2. Prior to the present federal republic form of government, the United States’ prior form of government was confederatism. The constitution replaced the articles of confederation. Nullification is nothing more than ex post confederatism. Been there, done it, replaced it.

    1. Totally agree! Perfect video from the only candidate who actually believes in and stands UP FOR the US Constitution! Which by the way does NOT force people to PURCHASE health insurance! And racism my behind! I fail to see where race possibly fits into this conversation. And by the way, I have been screaming for YEARS about unconstitutionality! Wars are to be declared by Congress. Any other way is a travesty! And the US Congress should have ALL THE SAME LAWS apply to them that apply to us. None of this is racist or Democrat or Republican. It’s about law and Constitution. Everyone who voted in the NDAA committed treason. No matter what race they be, nor what party they be. These problems transcend race and party as far as I’m concerned.

  3. James Madison writing to Edward Everett in 1830 —

    “That to have left a final decision in such cases to each of the States, then 13 & already 24, could not fail to make the Constn. & laws of the U. S. different in different States was obvious; and not less obvious, that this diversity of independent decisions, must altogether distract the Govt. of the Union & speedily put an end to the Union itself. A uniform authority of the laws, is in itself a vital principle. Some of the most important laws could not be partially executed. They must be executed in all the States or they could be duly executed in none. An impost or an excise, for example, if not in force in some States, would be defeated in others. It is well known that this was among the lessons of experience wch. had a primary influence in bringing about the existing Constitution. A loss of its general authy. would moreover revive the exasperating questions between the States holding ports for foreign commerce and the adjoining States without them, to which are now added all the inland States necessarily carrying on their foreign commerce through other States.”

    The complete letter at
    http://www.constitution.org/jm/18300828_everett.htm

  4. “nullification was used against slavery, as when northern states did everything in their power to obstruct the enforcement of the fugitive-slave laws, with the Supreme Court of Wisconsin going so far as to declare the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850 unconstitutional and void. In Ableman v. Booth (1859), the U.S. Supreme Court scolded it for doing so. In other words, modern anti-nullification jurisprudence has its roots in the Supreme Court’s declarations in support of the Fugitive Slave Act. Who’s defending slavery here?”

  5. more from Madison:

    ““However true, therefore, it may be, that the judicial department, is, in all questions submitted to it by the forms of the Constitution, to decide in the last resort, this resort must necessarily be deemed the last in relation to the authorities of the other departments of the government; not in relation to the rights of the parties to the constitutional compact, from which the judicial as well as the other departments hold their delegated trusts. On any other hypothesis, the delegation of judicial power would annul the authority delegating it; and the concurrence of this department with the others in usurped powers, might subvert for ever, and beyond the possible reach of any rightful remedy, the very Constitution which all were instituted to preserve.””

  6. “3) Since the peoples of the states are the sovereigns, then when the federal government exercises a power of dubious constitutionality on a matter of great importance, it is they themselves who are the proper disputants, as they review whether their agent was intended to hold such a power. No other arrangement makes sense. No one asks his agent whether the agent has or should have such-and-such power. In other words, the very nature of sovereignty, and of the American system itself, is such that the sovereigns must retain the power to restrain the agent they themselves created. James Madison explains this clearly in the famous Virginia Report of 1800:

    The resolution [of 1798] of the General Assembly [of Virginia] relates to those great and extraordinary cases, in which all the forms of the Constitution may prove ineffectual against infractions dangerous to the essential right of the parties to it. The resolution supposes that dangerous powers not delegated, may not only be usurped and executed by the other departments, but that the Judicial Department also may exercise or sanction dangerous powers beyond the grant of the Constitution; and consequently that the ultimate right of the parties to the Constitution, to judge whether the compact has been dangerously violated, must extend to violations by one delegated authority, as well as by another, by the judiciary, as well as by the executive, or the legislature.”

  7. I think several of the posters may have forgotten that the Supreme Court is the deciding arm of the government which determines if legislation is constitutional or not. The States have the right to file suit against the Feds if they think a law is unconstitutional, but not to nullify it on their own.

    1. The Supreme Court does not always do what is right either. What happens when all the checks and balances fail? Oh yes. A POLICE STATE!

      I find it EXTREMELY strange that all of a sudden the states are finding fault with all kinds of federal laws (many of which are unconstitutional) and trying to nullify them. I don’t remember this happening like this a few decades back. I think this is oppressive. And if state legislature’s try to stop this, it’s a GOOD thing!

      If I remember correctly, in civics class (which I took in 1970 or so), we learned that the purpose of the federal government was to 1) coin money and 2) defend the country. I may have forgotten one (that was a long time ago). We also learned that people actually have due process. This whole government and what they’re trying to do is turning the Constitution on its ear. The president does not have the right to require all citizens to buy health insurance. Nor to be arrested and never heard from again without due process. And this is not party related. It’s a continuation of what has previously gone before.

  8. more from Nullification – Answering the Objections:

    “What the Supremacy Clause actually says is: “This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in pursuance thereof…shall be the supreme law of the land.”

    In other words, the standard law-school response deletes the most significant words of the whole clause. Thomas Jefferson was not unaware of, and did not deny, the Supremacy Clause. His point was that only the Constitution and laws which shall be made in pursuance thereof shall be the supreme law of the land. Citing the Supremacy Clause merely begs the question. A nullifying state maintains that a given law is not “in pursuance thereof” and therefore that the Supremacy Clause does not apply in the first place.

    Such critics are expecting us to believe that the states would have ratified a Constitution with a Supremacy Clause that said, in effect, “This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in pursuance thereof, plus any old laws we may choose to pass, whether constitutional or not, shall be the supreme law of the land.””

  9. http://www.tomwoods.com/nullification-answering-the-objections/

    ““Nullification” dates back to 1798, when James Madison and Thomas Jefferson drafted the Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions, respectively.”

    “Today, political decentralization is gathering steam in all parts of the country, for all sorts of reasons. I fail to see the usefulness of the term “neo-Confederate” – whatever this Orwellian neologism is supposed to mean – in describing a movement that includes California’s proposal to decriminalize marijuana, two dozen states’ refusal to abide by the REAL ID Act, and a growing laundry list of resistance movements to federal government intrusion.”

    “the Principles of ’98 – as these decentralist ideas came to be known – were in fact resorted to more often by northern states than by southern, and from 1798 through the second half of the nineteenth century were used in support of free speech and free trade, and against the fugitive-slave laws, unconstitutional searches and seizures, and the prospect of military conscription, among other examples. And nullification was employed not in support of slavery but against it.”

  10. The constitution itself provides the means for challenging an unconstitutional law — extra-constitutional effortsby a state constitutes REBELLION.

  11. THIS IS REBELLION!

    Forget all the mamby-pamby stuff about resorting to court seeking an injunction or mandamus. The only question is whether the United States should wait until the General Assembly actually nullifies a federal law before imposing a reconstruction government or do so on the effective date of the act.

  12. an interesting speech on nullification by states. The main premise is that nullification is legal and right if the federal government is imposing unconstitutional laws on the states.

  13. Exactly what I say. The law must be ”constitutional.” And they have the specific clause which you quoted

    which is deemed to be outside the scope of the powers delegated by the people to the federal government in the United States Constitution . . .

    the feds have taken powers that they do not have the POWER to take by the Constitution. GO GEORGIA!!!! I wish all states would do this!

  14. Actually, I understood Federal law had supremacy only when constitutional. Of course, if you accept the commerce clause as being all encompassing…..

  15. Raff,

    I don’t think that this passes even the rational basis test….. I think the doctrine of preemption applies……

Comments are closed.