Category: Supreme Court

No Kings, No Votes: Democrats Move to Save Democracy From Itself

Below is a column in The Hill on the move by many in the “save democracy” movement to negate some of the results of the last election while moving to change our constitutional system without any actual amendments. It is a familiar pattern. Throughout history, popular movements have been usurped by small elites who have shown nothing but contempt for actual popular government from the French to the Russian Revolution.

Here is the column:

 

Continue reading “No Kings, No Votes: Democrats Move to Save Democracy From Itself” →

Seattle Mayor and School Board Support Legal Action to Block State Referendum on Transgender Athletes

Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson announced that she and the city would back the Seattle School Board’s unanimous vote to begin legal action to block enforcement of Initiative 638, which requires separating boys and girls in K-12 sports in Washington state. Voters overwhelmingly approved the initiative in 36 of the state’s 39 counties. Critics have charged that Wilson and other Seattle Democrats are seeking to negate the popular vote after campaigning on “saving democracy.” The greater challenge, however, is the legal basis for such an action in light of recent Supreme Court rulings. Continue reading “Seattle Mayor and School Board Support Legal Action to Block State Referendum on Transgender Athletes” →

Mullin’ Over the Separation of Powers: Justice Jackson Again Stands Alone

In Mullin v. Friends of Ruidosa Church, the Supreme Court just lifted the injunction on the Administration’s effort to go forward with the completion of a border wall through the Big Bend region of West Texas. The issue should not be the policy merits. There are good-faith arguments against the wall in such areas. Indeed, outgoing Sen. John Cornyn (R-TX) wrote an op-ed against the project. However, the sole question before the Court was the authority of a president to order the construction and use of statutory waivers to do so. Eight out of nine justices voted that “the Government is exceedingly likely to prevail on its argument that the District Court lacked jurisdiction.” Once again, the sole holdout was Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, who did not explain her position. Continue reading “Mullin’ Over the Separation of Powers: Justice Jackson Again Stands Alone” →

“Crazy Things”: Sotomayor Declares that She Hopes to Overturn the Presidential Immunity Decision

After telling an audience at Mount Vernon that “we saw the outpouring of voters in on Tuesday,” Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor told them that she hoped to see the reversal of various conservative opinions starting with the presidential immunity decision in Trump v. United States. Continue reading ““Crazy Things”: Sotomayor Declares that She Hopes to Overturn the Presidential Immunity Decision” →

The Reverse Ginsburg Scenario: Democrats May Only Need to Wait Rather than Pack the Court

Below is my column in the Hill on one possible impact of the midterm elections: the possible shift of the Court to a liberal majority by simple attrition rather than packing. The decision of Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito to remain on the Court will make the election in 2028 an existential fight for the Court and other core institutions in this country.

Here is the column: Continue reading “The Reverse Ginsburg Scenario: Democrats May Only Need to Wait Rather than Pack the Court” →

Backfire: Cook County State’s Attorney Seeks Dismissal of Key Gun Case Before Oral Argument

I have previously written how Chicago and New York have been the gifts that keep giving for the gun rights community in supplying a line of flagrantly unconstitutional gun laws that have resulted in major wins before the Supreme Court. On December 2, 2026, the Supreme Court is poised to hear oral arguments in Viramontes et al. v. Cook County, Illinois, et al., on the constitutionality of another gun ban involving semi-automatic rifles. Cook County State’s Attorney Eileen O’Neill Burke has filed a last-minute effort to dismiss the case that may actually backfire in emphasizing the very aspect of the case with the greatest potential vulnerability for Chicago and gun control advocates. Continue reading “Backfire: Cook County State’s Attorney Seeks Dismissal of Key Gun Case Before Oral Argument” →

The Justice Department Moves Forward with Grand Jury Investigation into Dobbs Leak

The Administration is reportedly moving forward with a grand jury investigation into the leak of the Dobbs decision on May 2, 2022. The timing is critical given the default statute of limitations of five years. The grand jury has issued subpoenas in an investigation led by U.S. Attorney for the District of Columbia Jeanine Pirro. It is welcome news for many of us who continue to worry about this leak’s impact on the institution and its unique culture. Continue reading “The Justice Department Moves Forward with Grand Jury Investigation into Dobbs Leak” →

No, CNN Did Not Defame Cenk Uygur by Trashing his Anti-Israel Ad Supporting Abdul El-Sayed

A new ad running to support Democrat senatorial candidate Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan has been widely denounced as anti-Semitic for suggesting that Jews are taking food from Americans. The ad is the work of Rebellion PAC, a political action committee co-founded by The Young Turks host Cenk Uygur. Uygur has now struck out at CNN over a panel discussion that trashed the segment and called it clearly defamatory. For a torts teacher, the claim popped this story to the top of my pile, and I thought it was worthy of addressing. The CNN segment is manifestly not defamatory. Whatever grievance that he may have with the network, it is not a legal one.

Continue reading “No, CNN Did Not Defame Cenk Uygur by Trashing his Anti-Israel Ad Supporting Abdul El-Sayed” →

Mississippi Lawyer Charged with Criminal Threat Against ICE Officers

Jeremy Bentham once said that “lawyers are the only persons in whom ignorance of the law is not punished.” We will see, apparently, in a case in Mississippi. At age 70, Lisa White is looking at a possible stint in prison after allegedly threatening to shoot Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents.

Continue reading “Mississippi Lawyer Charged with Criminal Threat Against ICE Officers” →

A Game of Chicken? Whitehouse Taunts Biden and Other Democrats For Being Too “Chicken” to Pack the Court

Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse, D-R.I., has added schoolyard taunts to his call to pack the Supreme Court with an instant liberal majority. Last week, Whitehouse denounced former President Joe Biden and other Democrats for being “too chicken” to pack the Court and, in the view of many of us, destroy the institution that has been critical to the success of this Republic for 250 years. Continue reading “A Game of Chicken? Whitehouse Taunts Biden and Other Democrats For Being Too “Chicken” to Pack the Court” →

Supreme Showdown: Investigative Reporter and Accused Chinese Operative Face Off in Press Freedom Case

Below is my column in The Hill on an important case currently before the Supreme Court on the free press and the ability to protect confidential sources. The underlying facts may seem like something out of The Onion: an accused Chinese operative and PLA Colonel who was viewed as a national security risk is successfully using the Privacy Act to get a respected journalist to reveal her confidential sources. However, it is very serious and, unless the Court reviews the case, investigative journalism in the United States could suffer a debilitating blow with little more than a shrug from the courts. Continue reading “Supreme Showdown: Investigative Reporter and Accused Chinese Operative Face Off in Press Freedom Case” →

Borked or Just Business? Supreme Court Hears Challenge to the Sharing of Viewing Records on Free Sites

Today the Supreme Court will hear arguments in a major case pitting privacy advocates against media companies. By any measure, Salazar v. Paramount Global is a blockbuster case in the making. At issue is the use of viewing habits by companies offering free subscriptions and material to the public. These companies make money by then using that history for tailored marketing programs. Michael Salazar is arguing that a Blockbuster-era law should prevent such sharing of his viewing history, a ruling that would have a massive impact on media and entertainment companies.

Continue reading “Borked or Just Business? Supreme Court Hears Challenge to the Sharing of Viewing Records on Free Sites” →

“Kayak-tivists” Target the Home of Chief Justice Roberts in Maine in the Latest Protests

There are certain dates that have become a regular feature in American life. In February, the Sandhill Cranes return to the Platte River in Tennessee. In March, the swallows return to San Juan Capistrano…and in October, the protesters have returned to Hupper Island, the summer vacation home of Chief Justice Roberts. Continue reading ““Kayak-tivists” Target the Home of Chief Justice Roberts in Maine in the Latest Protests” →

Justice (and Justices’ Investments) Should Be Blind: The Alito Controversy Raises Persistent Problem on the Court

Yesterday, Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito recused himself from one of the term’s most important cases: Suncor Energy Inc. v. County Commissioners of Boulder County. As I have previously discussed, the case involving the liability of energy companies for nuisance actions tied to climate change could have sweeping implications for the country. Justice Alito should be commended for avoiding even the appearance of a personal interest or a conflict in the case. However, the controversy should prompt the Court to explore a longstanding problem for justices in holding financial interests that can conflict with their duties. The solution is simple: justices need to use blind trusts. Continue reading “Justice (and Justices’ Investments) Should Be Blind: The Alito Controversy Raises Persistent Problem on the Court” →

The October Term: A Preview of the Coming Cases for Another “Big Year” on the Court

Below is my column in The Hill with a preview of the coming October Term at the Supreme Court. It already has the making of another “big year” on the Court.

Here is the column:

Continue reading “The October Term: A Preview of the Coming Cases for Another “Big Year” on the Court” →

Res ipsa loquitur – The thing itself speaks