ABC News has been given a photograph that might make the difference between life in prison and a walk. For weeks, we have been discussing the case and the application of the Stand Your Ground law. As discussed earlier, I think the case was over-charged and I remain doubtful of a conviction. This picture will likely be the single most important piece of evidence in the case. It shows Zimmerman with significant blood on the back of his head — an image that supports accounts from the scene and will be used to corroborate Zimmerman’s account of a struggle with Trayvon Martin where he feared serious bodily injury. [UPDATE: Zimmerman granted bond].
Unlike the photos of Zimmerman at the police station, this photo was taken a few minutes after the fight. Zimmerman’s shaved head could prove Godsend for Zimmerman. Had he had longer hair, the injury would have not appeared so stark.
The photo shows both cuts and a contusion — injuries that would normally be defined as serious bodily injury by many courts in torts cases where head injuries are treated as inherently potentially serious. The original police report said that he was bleeding from the nose and head and that his clothes looked like he had been in a fight. Zimmerman claims that it was Martin who jumped him, punched him, and pounded his head on to the concrete sidewalk.
The prosecutors can still argue that they do not contest the fight but that Zimmerman started it. However, with this photo, the charge of second-degree murder appears even more excessive and undermines Special Prosecutor Angela Corey’s claim that she was not affected by the political pressure to charge Zimmerman. I can understand a manslaughter charge, even with the photo, but no reasonable prosecutor would consider the second-degree murder charge as based on this evidence. Corey clearly must have seen this photo and the reports before her charging of Zimmerman.
The photo should also assist Zimmerman in his efforts to get bail.
Zimmerman, 28, is still being held on charges of second-degree murder of Martin, 17. In my view, a denial of bail would be an abuse and unwarranted given the fact that Zimmerman cooperated at the scene and voluntarily turned himself in.
Source: ABC
It is true that the girlfriend’s sworn testimony of a conversation will not be physical evidence.
It is equally true that anything Zimmerman says about the incident is no more evidence than is the girlfriend’s sworn testimony.
Even speculation about their path on the ground by reference to timelines, speed and distance is problematical. Zimmerman said that Martin ran, but we don’t know that Martin ran. The girlfriend reports Martin as saying he would walk fast, and not run.
We don’t know that Zimmerman was following in Martin’s precise steps. It is possible that the ‘cut-through’ Zimmerman mentions is one of those narrow passages between houses to the South. They lead from the roadway to the footpath area. If Zimmerman believed that Martin was headed around the backs of the roadside houses to get away through the back entrance, then running (out of breath) to one of those cut-throughs would allow him to head Martin off. Having made it to the footpath area, he would have no visual cues for the house numbers. He could then head North and intercept Martin coming South to the back entrance.
All speculation, however – even if logical.
So how about something very strange that might be closer to evidence of something?
Apparently Sanford PD told the Martin family that there were two encounters.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/national/tracy-martin-recounts-police-version-of-son-trayvons-death/2012/03/28/gIQA6MKhhS_story.html
“According to Tracy Martin, the Sanford, Fla., detective recounted this sequence of events: Trayvon Martin walked up to Zimmerman’s vehicle and asked why he was following him. Zimmerman denied following the youth and rolled up the car window. Minutes after Trayvon walked away, Zimmerman got out of his vehicle.
Then came the second encounter, according to Tracy Martin’s recollection of the detective’s account. Trayvon Martin appeared from behind a building in Zimmerman’s gated community, approached him and demanded, “What’s your problem, homie?”
This is very strange.
That ‘first encounter’ did not happen during Zimmerman’s call. We would have heard the question and answer.
Assuming the above is what Sanford PD told the Martin family, where did Sanford PD get the story of Martin asking the question, Zimmerman denying and rolling up the window?
If it happened, did it happen before Zimmerman placed the call? He doesn’t mention it in the call. If it did happen before the call, then it would not be surprising if Martin got spooked and felt threatened. The guy who denied following is …eh..following, and comes face to face down that footpath in the dark – which would be a very threatening situation.
If it happened, did it happen after Zimmerman finished the call? For that to happen, Zimmerman would need to get back in the SUV and whether he drove or not, would have Martin approach the SUV and ask the question. Then both of them would have to leave the SUV position and move to where the fight happened.
If Zimmerman actually remembered that question, and recounted it to Sanford PD as part of a confused self-serving story, could it be that the girlfriend’s account of what she heard is accurate?
It would be extremely interesting to see sworn evidence from Sanford PD on this. Did they say that Martin approached Zimmerman in his SUV and asked why he was following? If they did, who told them that?
The girlfriend recounts the question being asked seconds before the scuffle.
It isn’t incendiary to tell the truth, blacks are targeted, arrested and convicted much more often than whites in the same situations. Statistics bear him out.
http://bronx.ny1.com/content/top_stories/160622/ny1-exclusive–video-may-back-claims-bronx-teen-s-arrest-was-unfounded
Tony’s words-
“Nor does she need to be there physically to testify as to what she personally heard over the phone. That is perfectly valid sworn testimony, it is called “ear-witness” testimony and is just as valid regarding what was heard as “eyewitness” testimony..”
Tony is correct about that.
The alleged FACT is that all she heard said on the phone was..
“why are you following me?” and “What are you doing here?”
Which is a far cry from knowing what happened physically since she was NOT THERE to witness any of it. She can SPECULATE like a lot of people here have been doing but speculation is NOT evidence.
To repeat Matt’s words..
“Does she know for a FACT, along with everyone else that Martin didn’t double back and confront Zimmerman?”
The answer is NO. None of us know at this point exactly how the confrontation started.
“Jackson said that Martin’s death shows how
“BLACKS ARE UNDER ATTACK” and “targeting, arresting, convicting blacks and ultimately killing us is big business.” Apart from the obvious incendiary nature of such comments, what in heaven’s name could Jackson mean?”<<<<<<Especially since he DOESN'T HAVE ALL THE FACTS IN FRONT OF HIM .
People BLINDLY followed that illogical comment.
Matt: YOU DON’T KNOW WHAT PHYSICALLY HAPPENED BETWEEN THE TWO, AND THAT INCLUDES THE GIRLFRIEND. All that anyone can do is SPECULATE what happened. The ONLY two people that know EXACTLY what happened that night are Zimmerman and Trayvon.
Yes, and luckily one is dead, right?
Let’s assume for a moment George Zimmerman had been on the phone with 911 at this point in time. Now, if his phone call would have been disconnected, what would you assume? Would you assume too, he threw his phone away to attack Trayvon Martin?
Matt: Unless the POSSIBILITY that M went to attack Z and threw the phone on the ground causing it to shut off or the battery falling out. But I actually state that I am SPECULATING not stating “facts.”
Your speculations always work in support of Zimmerman. Why should TM interrupt his phone call for an encounter he didn’t seek? Besides the most easy way to let her know about the strange man following him would have been to let her listen. Surely almost everone with a best friend on the other end would have done. He could have asked him for his name, and than hold the phone in his direction. It clearly can’t have been in TM’s interest to throw his phone on the ground, quite the opposite it would have been in his interest to stay connected.
Matt: Z followed M until dispatcher said “we don’t need you to do that” and Z said “OK.” That’s all anyone knows for a FACT, you all can SPECULATE but you don’t know for a FACT!
Let me repeat what others already said here: Zimmerman wasn’t attacked in or close to his car. If he was only looking for the exact adress, as his father suggested, would he have found the adress where the encounter happened?
I am admittedly a bit puzzled by daddy Zimmerman’s statement, since it can’t be very hard to seize the pattern or distribution of the numbers of the houses inside the gated community. He lived there for several years and regularly went with his dog on patrol according to Taaffe, and he didn’t know streets and numbers roughly? I find that hard to believe.
The shot happened slightly over three minutes after he ended the 911 call. How long did he follow Martin, 3o seconds? So it should have taken him not longer than a minute to return to his car. That would have been still two minutes before the encounter, besides the clash starting with shouts, continuing with screams, ending with a shot happened somewhere else. No?
Also remember, he already gave to the dispatcher the location of his car, but in the end asked the dispatcher, could the officers call him apon arrival? would he have needed to say that, if he had the intention to return to his car and stay there?
Generally, nothing wrong with taking sides, you do a lot better than our Don Quijote fighting phantoms. We all follow our instinct in this case, and that has to do with who we are.
****************************************
Jeckyll and Hyde: some of his earlier 911 calls. During earlier calls he occasionally doesn’t observe his suspects closely, since they may notice him. As he knows “they” usually run away fastly. This is interesting–2 of 6–he doesn’t want the parents to know he reports their children to the police for playing in the street.
Oh, Mam, sorry, obviously since I live in the neighborhood, I would like to keep it anonymous … about 2:10
Yeah, well, yes.
Here are some facts
Zimmerman said in a 911 call that he followed Martin, having decided that Martin was up to no good.
Zimmernam said in the same 911 call that Martin ran, and that he lost him.
The only fact is that Zimmerman is recorded as saying these things. We do not know for a fact that anything Zimmerman said is true. What Zimmerman describes in the call are not facts. Only the existence of the call is a fact.
There were calls between Martin and his girlfriend at the time. Times and durations are known. The girlfriend reported that Martin said that someone was following him.The girlfriend reports a verbal exchange between Martin and someone unknown. We do not know for a fact that anything she reports is true. The existence of the calls is fact.
Sometime after Zimmerman’s 911 call ended, people in nearby houses heard a disturbance and at least one shot.
Zimmerman and Martin ended up a distance of at least 200 feet from the roadway where Zimmerman’s SUV was parked.
That location is on a reasonable route between the 7-11 and Martin’s home.
Martin had been shot dead.
Police have a body of other facts, such as forensics, ballistics, medical and crime scene analysis.
Neighborhood Watch rules tell members not to carry guns
Neighborhood Watch rules tell members to report only and not engage
It is a fact that Zimmerman reported Martin
It is a fact that he was told that a patrol car was on the way
It is reasonable to accept that Zimmerman was indeed following Martin.
It is a fact that he was carrying a gun.
It is reasonable to accept that Zimmerman was frustrated and angry about break-ins, and that he considered Martin to be the kind of person who “always gets away”.
Court decisions often revolve around the question what “a reasonable person” would think or do.
The Neighborhood Watch rules are reasonable.
Zimmerman’s behaviour was not reasonable.
Zimmerman’s unreasonable behaviour resulted in a death by shooting.
We don’t know for a fact who struck the first blow or gave the first push. We never will.
We do know that the fight and shooting arose solely due to Zimmerman’s unreasonable behaviour.
It is not reasonable to say that Zimmerman’s unreasonable behaviour was actually reasonable because there was no law against him following or approaching Martin.
It is not reasonable to disregard all the surrounding circumstances and simply say that Zimmerman was entitled to shoot because he had injuries or because he claimed to be in fear of serious injury or death.
@WithoutMalice: you are just as guilty as Zimmerman.
I am not Malisha, but I will point out Zimmerman killed somebody, that is a high bar to jump to be “just as guilty.”
I will also point out, speaking for myself, I voted in every Presidential election since Carter and voted for the Democrat every single time, including for Obama, and I switched my support to Ron Paul as soon as Obama proved himself to be an Orwellian liar doing the opposite of about 90% of his campaign promises, and EVERY campaign promise on our civil rights, the rule of law, reigning in the military or wars or Wall Street.
There is an overlap between Progressivism and Libertarianism that is independent of taxation and business regulation, and that is the realm of Constitutional authority, the Bill of Rights, and the legal declaration and definition of war and Presidential Powers. I thought Obama was on my side for that, after his claims to be a Constitutional scholar, but I was wrong, Obama is totally not on my side. And neither would be the reigning King of FlipFlopistan, Mitt Romney.
Malisha,
You just do not get it, you are just as guilty as Zimmerman. You have decided based upon the information you have read, that he is guilty. I bet you think Bush was the best president that we have ever known. You are more likely a Ron Paul supporter. Shame on you, you know He does not stand a chance in winning. You should switch your support to at least Rommney.
@Matt: Your kidding me right? So your telling me that they give a license to drive to a 16 year old (Martin was 17) and think that they can “think fast enough” for that but not a situation such as this?
No, I am not kidding you, I am informing you of a medically proven FACT. We give children a succession of rights as they age, including driving and voting and having sex and drinking alcohol. Those are socially determined, not scientifically determined.
The human brain reorganizes three times on the way to adulthood; the last re-org, from about 13 to 23, is a dramatic pruning of more than half of all neural connections and a sheathing of the remaining connections with a fatty substance called myelin. This sheathing boosts signal distance and speed by a factor of two or three, it actually makes people think faster. The last area of the brain to undergo this remodelling is the frontal cortex; which is, in all people, responsible for self-control and the processing of consequences to actions, and the judgment that allows people to repress their impulses due to negative consequences.
So yes, we let kids drive when they shouldn’t, we let them join the military when we shouldn’t, in many states we give them the right to sexual consent when we shouldn’t, we let them take out loans when we shouldn’t, we let them buy guns, smoke, and drink when we shouldn’t, because they are not mature enough to properly weight consequences over immediate emotional gratification.
The main reason we do that has nothing to do with science, it has to do with social history and fighting wars. The military wants soldiers at 18, not 24. In order to justify either drafting or recruiting 18 year olds, politicians caved in to pressures to give 18 year olds full fledged legal adult status.
That has nothing to do with whether they are developmentally adults or not. In fact our all-volunteer military depends very heavily upon the immature development of teens, that is why their ads are emotionally centered on pride, patriotism, camaraderie, respect and elitism, all strong emotional triggers. They push recruits to join impulsively, they count on emotion trumping reason and the full-adult status of 18 year olds binding developmentally immature kids to contracts.
As for driving: Reflexes are not an issue at 16-24, but judgment clearly is. Reckless speeding is one of the major causes of death among teens, and death-by-reckless-speeding is much higher in that age group than in, say, the 36-44 age group. If anything, that proves my point; teens are developmentally immature, impulsive and reckless.
@Matt: She, too, was not THERE TO SEE WHAT HAPPENED.
Nor does she need to be there physically to testify as to what she personally heard over the phone. That is perfectly valid sworn testimony, it is called “earwitness” testimony and is just as valid regarding what was heard as “eyewitness” testimony is valid regarding what somebody saw.
There is no plausible reason to exclude that testimony or believe what she heard was fabricated or falsified. There is no plausible reason for her to lie about what she heard. I have no doubt, if this goes to trial, the jury will hear her tell her first hand account of what she heard, and will believe her.
@Matt: You know for a fact M was frightened?
Nobody will ever know for a fact what was in Trayvon’s mind, or what was in Zimmerman’s mind. Surely you understand that. The jury will be composed of people like me (and I have served on a jury in the past, and as the foreman of a jury). Juries cannot deal in the FACTS of what was in the minds of dead people, or the FACTS of what happened between two people without any witnesses.
So your criterion of what I know as FACT is unreasonable, applying that criterion to whether or not we find guilt would let anybody that wanted to murder somebody get off scot free by simply making sure they committed the murder without witnesses, then admitting to the murder to render moot any forensic evidence and claiming their victim attacked them and they had no choice but to kill the victim in self-defense.
That is the standard you are implicitly demanding I apply, and it is an unreasonable standard.
The standard that actually applies is the legal standard, which is “beyond a reasonable doubt.”
Under that standard, I have no plausible reason to doubt that Trayvon Martin was frightened, and I know beyond a reasonable doubt (and far beyond it) that Trayvon Martin was frightened by Zimmerman.
You know for a FACT that M didn’t just attack him after Z asked him “what are you doing here?”
I do not think that distinction makes any difference in Zimmerman’s guilt. I know beyond a reasonable doubt that Trayvon Martin was frightened and threatened by Zimmerman. Under the Stand Your Ground law of Florida, Trayvon was within his rights to KILL Zimmerman because he was (rightfully) frightened for his life. So certainly Trayvon was equally righteous in swinging first, or trying to push past Zimmerman, or taking any other physical action against Zimmerman, and that does not exonerate Zimmerman in any way.
Zimmerman, on the other hand, as the aggressor and intimidator, which in my mind is also beyond any reasonable doubt, should not enjoy the cover of the Stand Your Ground law, he does not get to claim he was frightened by Trayvon but chose to make an armed pursuit of him anyway. If the language of this confrontation becomes testimony, Zimmerman does not get to claim he was frightened of Trayvon when he confronted Trayvon with these questions. That is what I believe 12 out of 12 jurors will conclude, and then the FACT will be that Zimmerman is found guilty.
SlingTrebuchet – You are also ASSUMING that every single word that the girlfriend of Martin is saying is 100% accurate. She, too, was not THERE TO SEE WHAT HAPPENED. She supposedly heard two phrases through a telephone call (“why are you following me?” and “What are you doing here?”) and then a scuffle. Does she know for a FACT, along with everyone else (including you) that Martin didn’t double back and confront Zimmerman? Like I have said before also, do you really think that the girlfriend (of anyone) is going to say something that is going to INCRIMINATE their partner? How do you know for a FACT that Martin didn’t say to the girlfriend, “I’m gonna go back and find out what this asshole wants” and went back and confronted Zimmerman? How do you also know for a FACT that Martin didn’t say to the girlfriend, “I’m gonna whoop this asshole for following me”?
YOU DON’T KNOW WHAT PHYSICALLY HAPPENED BETWEEN THE TWO, AND THAT INCLUDES THE GIRLFRIEND. All that anyone can do is SPECULATE what happened. The ONLY two people that know EXACTLY what happened that night are Zimmerman and Trayvon.
But Sling, although I understand your analogy perfectly and it’s a good one, there’s another issue. George doesn’t just have to pass his exams, he has to GET HIRED. As he is chasing down Trayvon Martin, can he be thinking, “If I catch the neighborhood thief, they’ll hire me because I’ll be a hero”? And once he closes the gap and says, “what are you doing here?” can he be thinking, “I’m so close, so close…”?
And then it goes South.
This is not just George having a little egg on his face because he made a fuss over a guy with a candy bar, this is George humiliated. The cops will never hire him and make him their “brother” on the force.
It could be an even bigger boo hoo than a bonk on the head.
It could be, “Hey George, Neighborhood Watch is sick of your antics and you’re an embarrassment to everyone, STEP THE HELL DOWN!”
It could be a grievous injury, not to his head, but to his psyche.
Now you’ve got him kicking down the door to an institution that will not have him, that rejects him, that stands CLOSED to him.
Trayvon Martin was unlucky enough to be standing there…or struggling there…or whatever…there…while that scenario might have played out upon his coincidental life.
Possibly.
George before passing exams:
Plainclothes cop George bangs on door of suspect – who happens to be the innocent man Matt
“Open up!”
Matt inside thinks. “WTF. No Way!”
George breaks through the door.
Matt assumes this stranger is a threat, and attacks him.
George gets knocked down and is at a disadvantage. Fearing his life in danger, he shoots Matt.
George after passing exams:
Bangs on door of suspect – who happens to be the innocent man Matt
“Sanford PD. Open up!”
See the difference?
Would we expect the same outcome in both cases?
Shano’s comment -“He should have waited until he passed his exams before going HUNTING” -is a PERFECT example of the prejudicial comments & opinions going on here at this ‘playground’ .
definition of
prejudice: an unfavorable opinion or feeling formed beforehand or without FULL knowledge, thought, or reasoning.
You and your belly are in that category Malisha (malicious)
George must know that only a cop has a chance to get away with a killing like this.
He should have waited until he passed his exams before going hunting.
Bosco, that’s hilarious! You can be minister of comedy!
But if you can put words in Tony C’s mouth, I can put words in — oh, say, New Gingrich’s mouth, and here goes:
Q: You know for a fact that Zimmerman felt his life was threatened when he shot Martin?
NEWT’s conscience: “Actually NO, I don’t know that for a fact — because it’s just as likely that Zimmerman just thought he could get away with killing this Black throw-away asshole.”
Q: You know for a FACT that Z didn’t just attack M because he didn’t like the kid’s answer to the question “what are you doing here?”
NEWT’s conscience: “Actually Matt, NO I DON’T KNOW for a fact, I’m speculating– because it is just as possible that at that point, Zimmerman drew his gun, said, “back off, coon, ‘fore I blow your ass to Kingdom Come,” and THEN Martin ducked, head-butted Zimmerman in his stomach, bringing him down, and then scrambled around while screaming for help as Zimmerman retrieved his gun in the dark and shot the boy from a distance of three feet. SORRY.”
So as for your comment, “Tony ,Malicious and others,,Id rather be criticized for putting words in Tony’s mouth than be criticized for RUSHING TO JUDGEMENT with a biased thought pattern,”
Well you’ve earned your criticisms and your belly laughs this time.
Matt good questions you’ve asked .. Ill answer for Tony C
“TonyC. – You know for a fact M was frightened?
Tony’s conscious<'Actually NO I don't know that for a fact'
"You know for a FACT that M didn’t just attack him after Z asked him “what are you doing here?"
Tony's conscious< 'Actually Matt, NO I DON'T KNOW for a fact, I'm speculating-sorry'
Tony ,Malicious and others,,Id rather be criticized for putting words in Tony's mouth than be criticized for RUSHING TO JUDGEMENT with a biased thought pattern.
When you’re arguing a point like “Zimmerman is innocent” but you pretend you’re arguing the point, “Zimmerman should not be convicted until his guilt is proven beyond a reasonable doubt,” you are arguing to satisfy yourself of your own rightness, correctness and superiority. When you two (or divisible one) Matt/Without Malice go into these high-adrenaline tirades against someone who clearly holds opposing views, you make yourself sound overly defensive, and that weakens your argument. When you keep challenging: “Answer my question, answer my question!” and you set yourself up as the blog-fuhrer who can require others to answer his pre-qualifying questions before they’re allowed to express their opinions, you actually identify yourself as someone who is not really interested in debate, but in bullying.
As to your comment: “Now I know you need a dictionary. There are ones on line, read up on the definition of hyperbole. So it does not mean a super word slut, but close.”
uh…well…maybe I do need a dictionary. One that translates English to WITHOUTMALICE and WITHOUTMALICE to English. Because other than the fact that you spelled “slut” correctly — I don’t get the rest of it at all.
(By the way, maybe I am a slut, and if so, maybe that’s why I get invited to parties.) (Yeah, and if slut is the feminine form of the word, what is the masculine form, sluttock? I always wanted to know that, ever since reading Nabokov.)
TonyC. – You know for a fact M was frightened? You know for a FACT that M didn’t just attack him after Z asked him “what are you doing here?” Like I have stated plenty of times before, it DOES matter who PHYSICALLY attacked first. A verbal confrontation DOES NOT constitute for an “assault” in the eyes of the law. Once person A puts their hands on person B uninvited it becomes an unlawful assault against person B. Have you ever seen a cop arrest someone for VERBALLY arguing with another person? The answer is NO.
“Trayvon was not a mature adult, and could not think as fast as a mature adult”
Your kidding me right? So your telling me that they give a license to drive to a 16 year old (Martin was 17) and think that they can “think fast enough” for that but not a situation such as this?
“In a jury room, I would claim it makes no sense that Trayvon’s call was disconnected voluntarily by him or without physical contact”
Unless the POSSIBILITY that M went to attack Z and threw the phone on the ground causing it to shut off or the battery falling out. But I actually state that I am SPECULATING not stating “facts.”
@Matt: Its a simple question. “Why are you here?”
No, the question was “What are you doing here?”
Trayvon’s question was simple and asked first: “Why are you following me?”
Which Zimmerman refused to answer. So why couldn’t Zimmerman answer Trayvon’s question?
As to YOUR question, answering a question like Trayvon’s with a demanding question of your own will very likely be interpreted by 12 out of 12 jurors as a dominating and hostile act. And the same source that gave you that question gave you what happened next: Immediate sounds of a scuffle and a call disconnect. It is entirely possible that with that loaded question, “What are you doing here?”, Trayvon was frightened and thinking he was about to be the victim of a hate crime by somebody that didn’t like black people walking around their neighborhood. It is entirely possible that frame of mind left Trayvon speechless and he tried to bolt, or it left Trayvon speechless and Zimmerman struck him and Trayvon fought back. Trayvon was not a mature adult, and could not think as fast as a mature adult, and was more driven by emotional impulse, including fear, than a mature adult. None of which excuses Zimmerman’s acts, because we do not blame non-adults for acting like non-adults.
In a jury room, I would claim it makes no sense that Trayvon’s call was disconnected voluntarily by him or without physical contact, and Zimmerman had the responsibility to identify and answer first, and by not doing so displayed aggression and hostility. Trayvon cannot be blamed for what happened next, whether he initiated the scuffle or Zimmerman did is immaterial, Zimmerman was the hostile aggressor.