Reasonable Doubt? Crime Scene Photos Shows Serious Injury On Zimmerman’s Head

ABC News has been given a photograph that might make the difference between life in prison and a walk. For weeks, we have been discussing the case and the application of the Stand Your Ground law. As discussed earlier, I think the case was over-charged and I remain doubtful of a conviction. This picture will likely be the single most important piece of evidence in the case. It shows Zimmerman with significant blood on the back of his head — an image that supports accounts from the scene and will be used to corroborate Zimmerman’s account of a struggle with Trayvon Martin where he feared serious bodily injury. [UPDATE: Zimmerman granted bond].


Unlike the photos of Zimmerman at the police station, this photo was taken a few minutes after the fight. Zimmerman’s shaved head could prove Godsend for Zimmerman. Had he had longer hair, the injury would have not appeared so stark.

The photo shows both cuts and a contusion — injuries that would normally be defined as serious bodily injury by many courts in torts cases where head injuries are treated as inherently potentially serious. The original police report said that he was bleeding from the nose and head and that his clothes looked like he had been in a fight. Zimmerman claims that it was Martin who jumped him, punched him, and pounded his head on to the concrete sidewalk.

The prosecutors can still argue that they do not contest the fight but that Zimmerman started it. However, with this photo, the charge of second-degree murder appears even more excessive and undermines Special Prosecutor Angela Corey’s claim that she was not affected by the political pressure to charge Zimmerman. I can understand a manslaughter charge, even with the photo, but no reasonable prosecutor would consider the second-degree murder charge as based on this evidence. Corey clearly must have seen this photo and the reports before her charging of Zimmerman.

The photo should also assist Zimmerman in his efforts to get bail.
Zimmerman, 28, is still being held on charges of second-degree murder of Martin, 17. In my view, a denial of bail would be an abuse and unwarranted given the fact that Zimmerman cooperated at the scene and voluntarily turned himself in.

Source: ABC

1,309 thoughts on “Reasonable Doubt? Crime Scene Photos Shows Serious Injury On Zimmerman’s Head”

  1. “GZ would not have been given a gun permit if he had not been given special scrubbing & dispensation in the justice system because of his father.” IS a completely unfounded and biased comment made to add more weight to your prejudiced leaning. I never assumed all of you have been listening to Al Sharpton 24/7 365,,,but tell me Shano,,what is your view of Sharpton,,and Jackson. ESPECIALLY considering the Duke Lacrosse case and the Brawley case?????

  2. I might also add that Martin may not have been as “innocent” as you believe. I say this because IF HE DID ATTACK ZIMMERMAN he was guilty, at that point, of assault.

  3. Shano – “GZ would not have been given a gun permit if he had not been given special scrubbing & dispensation in the justice system because of his father.”

    “People will be outraged if Zimmerman gets off completely because of the history of his special privileges giving him a gun permit when he was really not eligible until strings were pulled.”

    You are WAY off base. NO PERSON EVER (and I want to emphasize EVER) get a gun permit because they know/are related to someone (judge, cop, etc.). They are given a gun permit after EXTENSIVE background checks through the FBI, the same background checks that are performed for someone who is enlisting into the military. You WOULD NEVER be allowed to go into the courthouse and apply for a gun permit BASED SOLELY on you “knowing someone.”

    I have no idea where you got your information and I would like you to post where you read that he received his gun permit ONLY because his father is a judge.

  4. Bosco, you assume all of us have been listening to Al Sharpton 24/7 365. No so. You assume way too much.

    I think this case is more about gun rights than race. And it is also about insider privilege- GZ would not have been given a gun permit if he had not been given special scrubbing & dispensation in the justice system because of his father.

    Most Americans know that the scenario where you can shoot anyone to death and have no trial should be VERY RARE. This is NOT one of those cases.
    People will be outraged if Zimmerman gets off completely because of the history of his special privileges giving him a gun permit when he was really not eligible until strings were pulled.
    It is problematic that the NRA pushing these laws has lost ALEC because of this case. This shows me that they know these laws are a problem and that the public is horrified at how they are being used.

    No one wants to be in favor of innocent people being shot and killed for no good reason.

  5. TonyC. – “Funny how you totally discount the possibility that Zimmerman is actually guilty and the jury might find that fairly.”

    I never said that I discount the possibility that he might FAIRLY get a guilty verdict, I’m just stating that, either way, I think he will receive that verdict based on public pressure. I LEAN more towards his innocence, however, I am not coming to a CONCLUSION because I DON’T HAVE ALL FACTS. I just FEEL, personally, that either way that the court system will “succumb” to public pressure like they did in the OJ trial.

  6. Tony your words-
    “As for Duke and Brawley, are you seriously telling us that you are judging THIS case based on unrelated cases that may have involved fraud?”

    Do you lack reading comprehension ,are you trying to manipulate my meaning or or are you just plain stupid ?
    Im NOT judging this case with those cases ,,I’m judging YOU and your prejudiced counterparts who are >RUSHING TO JUDGEMENT< on this case,

    I see what your doing though,,avoiding the question by attacking my character.

  7. Tony
    funny how YOU have already decided that Zimmerman is actually guilty.

    Even though you have also agreed in other comments that we do not have all the facts as yet.
    This is called BIAS mentality on your part.
    Matt is making a point about the after effects of what could be in re to EITHER verdict.

    To get back to basics,,My objective here is NOT to DEFEND Zimmerman.
    but to defend EQUAL JUSTICE for all.
    People like you who are obviously very prejudiced and respond like lemmings to the black activists who misguide you. They stink just as badly as the Jim Crow laws of the past did. Misguiding the ignorant.

  8. @Matt: Funny how you totally discount the possibility that Zimmerman is actually guilty and the jury might find that fairly. The fact that you leave that out proves you have pre-judged the case.

  9. @Bosco: Tony,,thanks for the BLAH BLAH BLAH,,, didnt waste my time with it,,sorry

    No apology needed, your admission is just further evidence of your own hypocritical careless rush to judgment. It tells us you cannot be bothered reading anything you disagree with; you hypocritically employ confirmation bias because you will only read something if you think it will confirm what you have already decided is true. So, seriously, thank you for the ammunition, it was fun.

    As for Duke and Brawley, are you seriously telling us that you are judging THIS case based on unrelated cases that may have involved fraud?

    I can only infer from your statements that you believe media-storm attention is somehow inherently evidence of fraudulent testimony by witnesses for the prosecution and innocence on the part of the defendant. Pardon me while I laugh my frikkin’ ass off.

  10. “So what would a fair outcome look like? To my mind, the government offers Zimmerman a plea deal that has him back on the street within this decade, and he accepts it quietly. That seems like a conclusion most reasonable Americans could live with. Of course, no matter how long or short any sentence may be, there will be those who disagree, some vehemently.”

    “If O’Mara were successful in brokering such a resolution, he should be viewed as nothing less than a savior. A protracted murder trial of George Zimmerman is the last thing this country needs right now. America can only dodge so many racial bullets, and a not-guilty verdict in this case could very easily turn the racial cold war into a very hot one.”

    http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2012/04/18/trial-of-george-zimmerman-could-trigger-another-rodney-king.html

    This is what I’m “afraid” of and what I have been saying about “pressure from the public” all along. I still stand in my belief that the court system will go AGAINST George Zimmerman (GUILTY VERDICT) just because of public PRESSURE, but in the off chance that the verdict comes back IN FAVOR (NOT GUILTY VERDICT) of George Zimmerman, what are we as Americans in store for?

    Honestly, in my opinion I believe that the court system WILL in fact give a guilty verdict just to keep from having another “Rodney King” incident. I still believe that they will “hang” George Zimmerman just to “quiet the public.”

  11. Bosco is placing all his bets on ‘media bias’ and the fact that some OTHER cases may turn out entirely differently than initial public opinion would suggest.

    I do not know about any of those other cases, and I am not going to research them to please you, Bosco. What a ridiculous question.

    This case has nothing to do with those other cases. I agree with Tony C., Zimmerman will be caught in a number of lies and that will cast doubt on his innocence.

  12. Tony,,thanks for the BLAH BLAH BLAH,,, didnt waste my time with it,,sorry

  13. “It’s a very uncomplicated case” — and yet you go out of your way to write out a long winded comment about…what exactly?

    The previous cases mentioned are not related by the in-particular details,,of COURSE.

    Those CASES are brought up to bring attention and FOCUS to how people LIKE YOU are reacting to this current Martin/Zimmerman case.

    That is how it IS RELATED.
    The Brawley case and the Duke Lacrosse case has the SAME biased tone, prejudice and ‘rush to judgement’ quality by activists like Jackson and Sharpton as this one does. People being mislead because of ignorance.
    We all know just how those cases ended. (don’t we?)

    People like you want to avoid that comparison of these cases.

    So,,your wrong ‘Sling,,whatever’ They are very relative.

    Sling–answer these questions for us all..
    1)What was YOUR HONEST take on the ‘Duke Lacrosse’ charge when you first heard and saw it in the news?????

    2)What was your take and HONEST VIEW of the ‘Tawana Brawley’ case when it was unfolding in the news and Sharpton was doing the very same media manipulation as he has been on this case?

  14. @Bosco: I did not say the jury would be biased; I said they will speculate, because they have no choice but to do so. A judge would have to speculate too. The prosecutor must speculate, the defense attorney must speculate, the only actual witness is Zimmerman, and unless you have a 100% reliable truth serum we have to assume he will act only in his own self-interest, and will violate any oath to “tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth” to save his own skin, or will plead the fifth.

    The jury (or a judge) is faced with a dilemma. If they convict they may punish a man that killed in self-defense, if they are hung or acquit, they may set free a man that is a danger to society, that in anger killed a teenager that did nothing wrong.

    Either scenario has drastic consequences, and the only way to arrive at a conclusion is by doing your best to understand what most probably happened, and how likely each outcome is, and choose one.

    That does not prove any bias against Zimmerman or for Trayvon at all, the only bias necessary is for the reality of how humans act and events transpire, and to my ears Zimmerman’s story sounds like very bad fiction full of holes. He was the aggressor and he is trying to hide it. The police could only have gotten their story from Zimmerman or invented it themselves, but I suspect the former, and it is contradicted by the girlfriend’s ear-witness testimony. You can bet on the voice on the neighbor’s 911 tape will be analyzed, and Zimmerman’s voice (already recorded) will not match the structural components used for voice recognition that he cannot fake. When the jury adds up the lies, I am betting Zimmerman is a liar that undoubtedly shot and killed Trayvon Martin. That result will not be due to bias against Zimmerman, that is going to be putting a guilty man in jail because of a bias against murder.

  15. Bosco: “Martin was not the BOY that you see in the only photos available,
    You and many many others want to paint a rosey picture of Martin without knowing him.”

    This case is significantly more simple than the unrelated cases that you want to drag in. It’s a very uncomplicated case. Everything relevant happened in the space of 30 minutes max. Zimmerman and Martin had no dealings with each other before that night. There were no eyeball witnesses to the entire thing. Nobody saw the start of the fight. Nobody seems to have seen the shooting.

    The only third-party evidence on how the two came face to face comes from the girlfriend. All she can relate is the conversation and sounds of a scuffle. We don’t know who pushed who first.
    All we can know from her testimony is that it directly contradicts that of Zimmerman as to who said what.

    Which one pushed/struck first does not really matter as : –

    (a) Zimmerman was not going about his ordinary business on that footpath behind the houses. He was there because he had been following Martin.
    By his own recorded words in the 911 call, he was doing so in an aggressive frame of mind. “They always get away”. “F***ing ****s”.
    Despite claiming to be a Watch Captain in NW, he was ignoring NW rules. His ignoring those sensible rules led directly to the fight and the shooting.

    (b) Martin was going about his ordinary business. He was on his way home from the 7-11, and talking by phone with his girlfriend. The telephone conversation between the two is proven by service provider records. The conversation with his girlfriend is perfect explanation of why he might not look like someone who was simply walking from A to B.

    It does not matter if Martin was or was not an angel.
    That Zimmerman was reckless is beyond reasonable doubt.
    Martin died as a result of that. It is hard to credit that any fair-minded jury would not judge him guilty of at least manslaughter.
    Martin’s character has nothing to do with it.
    Even if Martin had been a serial killer of the most nightmarish kind, Zimmerman had no way of telling that. It is not relevant.

  16. May ‘Blind’ unbiased JUSTICE WITHOUT prejudice prevail
    so murders like OJ SIMPSON will not walk.

    May the ignorance of many dissipate as well.
    Martin was not the BOY that you see in the only photos available,
    You and many many others want to paint a rosey picture of Martin without knowing him.
    The reason? You want to see a non-black ‘hung’ due to black prejudices which BLINDS you to other possibilities.
    By the way Shano…

    1)What was YOUR HONEST take on the ‘Duke Lacrosse’ charge when you first heard and saw it in the news?????

    2)What was your take and HONEST VIEW of the ‘Tawana Brawley’ case when it was unfolding in the news and Sharpton was doing the very same media manipulation as he has been on this case?

    You have yet to HONESTLY answer any of these questions.

  17. May the current prejuduices against armed men shooting unarmed boys prevail!

  18. Tony C..an excerpt of ‘JURY’ definitions and expansions ..this will mean nothing to YOU though will it.Pay attention to #6 Tony.

    A jury is a sworn body of people convened to render an impartial verdict
    (a finding of fact on a question) officially submitted to them by a court, or to set a penalty or judgment. Modern juries tend to be found in courts to ascertain the guilt, or lack thereof,

    Disadvantages of a jury system

    1)The jury members are with a few exceptions not knowledgeable about the law and are unfamiliar with court procedure, decisions might be based on emotions rather than rationale arguing.[original research?]
    2)Complex cases tend to require special expertise to judge the case which a jury do not have.
    3)The jury members are more susceptible to the rhetoric impressions and mesmerized by the eloquence of a lawyer than a judge, they tend to be over-awed by the whole experience
    (if it doesn’t fit you must acquit)
    4)Since the decision by jury is a group decision, individual members of the jury may not feel that responsible about their duties and therefore neglect it.
    5)Group pressure might be influential on the decision.
    6)Juries may be swayed by the CURRENT PREJUDICES in the society, which are not supported by law.

    This supports what YOU were saying..they can be just as biased as you..i.e. the OJ Simpson Jury.

  19. Your right Tony C
    The jury would be just as unbiased as the OJ Simpson jury was.

  20. @Bosco: Which is a far cry from knowing what happened physically since she was NOT THERE to witness any of it. She can SPECULATE like a lot of people here have been doing but speculation is NOT evidence.

    True, but nobody was there to know, so what is the jury going to do? They are going to hear what she said, and any other facts presented, and then both in the jury box and in the jury room, they are going to SPECULATE as to what actually happened, and they will vote to convict or acquit based on their SPECULATION and what they BELIEVE happened, because that is their job.

    If we want to know what the jury will do, the best route we have to predict the outcome is to predict what their SPECULATIONS will be. You are right, we cannot predict that with any certainty because we do not know every word they will hear, and we do not know their background or thinking process. But that does not mean we cannot know ANYTHING, we can make a pretty accurate guess about their reactions by treating them as average citizens and seeing what the average citizen will think.

    Based on my reading, I think the jury speculation will lean heavily toward finding Zimmerman guilty of at least manslaughter and perhaps Murder 2. I think his attorney will see that, and advise him to plea manslaughter, or face a high probability of serving hard time.

Comments are closed.