During the campaign, many people expressed outrage over Mitt Romney’s statement concerning the fact that almost fifty percent of the public do not pay pay income taxes. I well understood the anger, but I am a bit surprised that a video by the California Federation of Teachers has not produced the same outrage over its unfairness and frankly crudeness. The video shows a wealthy person urinating on the poor as part of a “Tax the Rich: An Animated Fairy Tale.” I readily admit that I am in the minority on our blog in opposing some of the tax increase proposals in this country and abroad as economically unwise. However, the demonization of the wealthy in this country has gone a bit far when a video of this kind is released by a major organization.
Real Clear Politics and a few sites ran a story on the urination scene, but the video below has the sound but not the image of actual urination. It is not clear if someone added the yellow image to the video or the producers removed the image. When you now hit on various sites that showed what they said was the image of the urination, a sign pops up that this is now a “private video.” I am unsure of what that means since the union reportedly put the video out to the public. However, there is no mention of the controversy that I could find on the union site.
The eight-minute video was written and directed by California Federation of Teachers’ communications director Fred Glass with voice over by Ed Asner. The mythical land describes rich evading taxes by investing in “Wall Street” — not quite mythical. “Don’t worry. This is good for you, too. Because it will trickle down from us to you.” You can still hear the sound of the rich man “trickling down” on the poor.
Viewers are urged to email their elected representatives to tell them to raise taxes on the wealthy in order to fund public services.
I happen to agree with the premise of raising revenues (though I oppose some of the tax proposals in this country and abroad). I am a long and vocal supporter for increasing funding for schools and teachers. However, I view this video as unfair and hyperbolic even without the yellow stream. The wealthy do pay considerable taxes and many support public programs and public causes. They also do pay the vast majority of taxes. Should they pay more in this economy. Yes, but it is grossly unfair to engage in this type of vilification. The video for example states that after the housing market crash the government printed money for “rich people” but they didn’t give any to “ordinary people whose houses and jobs were broken by the crash.” The video also states that after the collapse that rich people “love their money more than anything in the world.” That is simply outrageous. What would be the reaction to a business group releasing a video stating poor people do not care for other people and do not want to work? There would be justified anger and outrage, but the reaction to this video seems to be muted from the left. It is not enough to simply shrug and again blame the other side triggering such responses. Whatever the excesses of the other side of this debate, it does not relieve adults of being the obligations of accuracy and decency. As an educator myself, I am embarrassed to see any teacher’s organization engage in such attacks.
I am interested in whether the union did include the even more offensive image and removed it or whether it is claiming that conservative groups hacked their video. If it is the former, I do not believe that they have served the interests of teachers who generally strive to engage in reasoned and respectful debate. If it is the latter, I would love to know who added the yellow image and left the appearance that it was in the original video. The union itself has thus far said little on the controversy. [UPDATE: the original video is posted here and shows the yellow image. It would appear that the union has altered its own video though I cannot find any statement from it on this controversy].
The current video is shown below.
Elaine:
all Romney and other rich people are going to do is to take less income and leave it invested [which isnt necessarily a bad thing]. You wont raise any additional revenue.
And the rich just wont buy a new car or plane or boat/yacht or another vacation home. That just cost the economy jobs and tax revenue.
“LANSING, Mich. — Republicans slammed right-to-work legislation through the Michigan House and Senate Thursday, drawing raucous protests from throngs of stunned union supporters, whose outnumbered Democratic allies were powerless to stop it.
Just hours after they were introduced, both chambers approved measures prohibiting private unions from requiring that nonunion employees pay fees. The Senate quickly followed by voting to impose the same requirement on most public unions.
Although rumors had circulated for weeks that right-to-work measures might surface during the session’s waning days, the speed with which the GOP-dominated Legislature acted Thursday caught many onlookers by surprise. Details of the bills weren’t made publicly available until they were read aloud on both floors as debate began.
The chaos drew raucous protests from hundreds of union supporters, some of whom were pepper-sprayed by police when they tried to storm the Senate chamber.” Chicago Tribune 2014 is going to be an interesting election year.
The rich are now 288 times richer than middle-class households
September 11, 2012|By David Lazarus
http://articles.latimes.com/2012/sep/11/business/la-fi-mo-wealth-gap-20120911
The rich aren’t just getting richer. They’re getting a lot richer.
And you’re getting poorer.
The wealth gap between the richest Americans and the typical family more than doubled over the past 50 years, according to the Economic Policy Institute.
It found that the top 1% had 125 times the net worth of the median household as of 1962. But by 2010, the disparity reached 288 times.
The institute cited two trends: More wealth finding its way to the high end of the demographic spectrum, while people in the middle class were seeing their cash grow more scarce.
The median household saw its net worth drop to $57,000 in 2010, down from $73,000 in 1983. It would have been closer to $119,000 had wealth grown equally across households.
The top 1%, meanwhile, saw their average wealth grow to $16.4 million, up from $9.6 million in 1983.
What’s to be done? Well, we could leave things as they are and watch as the middle class continues to dwindle while more wealth accumulates among the 1%.
Or we can look at tax reform that would attempt to level the playing field and tax all income levels fairly.
Man, tough call.
Rich get a lot richer, outpace middle class
By ANDREW TAYLOR, Associated Press
10/27/11
http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/money/economy/story/2011-10-27/income-gap/50952720/1
Excerpt:
WASHINGTON – Yet another study shows how the richest 1% of Americans have been getting far richer over the last three decades while the middle class and poor have seen their after-tax household income only inch up by comparison.
This report is from the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office.
Average after-tax income for the top 1% of U.S. households almost quadrupled, up 275%, from 1979 to 2007, the CBO found. For people in the middle of the economic scale, after-tax income grew by just 40%. Those at the bottom experienced an 18% increase.
The report, based on IRS and Census Bureau data, comes as the Occupy Wall Street movement protests corporate bailouts and the gap between the haves and have-nots. Demonstrators call themselves “the 99%.”
“The distribution of after-tax income in the United States was substantially more unequal in 2007 than in 1979,” CBO Director Doug Elmendorf said in a blog post. “The share of income accruing to higher-income households increased, whereas the share accruing to other households declined.”
The top 1% made $165,000 or more in 1979; that jumped to $347,000 or more in 2007, the study said. The income for the top fifth started at $51,289 in 1979 and rose to $70,578 in 2007. On the other end of the spectrum, those in the 20th percentile went from $12,823 in 1979 to $14,851 in 2007.
The report also found:
—The top 20% of the population earned 53% of after-tax income in 2007, as opposed to 43% in 1979.
—The top 1% reaped a 17% share of all income, up from 8% in 1979.
—The bottom 20% reaped just 5% of after-tax income, versus 7% in 1979.
The Rich Get Even Richer
By STEVEN RATTNER
Published: March 25, 2012
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/26/opinion/the-rich-get-even-richer.html
Excerpt:
Government has also played a role, particularly the George W. Bush tax cuts, which, among other things, gave the wealthy a 15 percent tax on capital gains and dividends. That’s the provision that caused Warren E. Buffett’s secretary to have a higher tax rate than he does.
As a result, the top 1 percent has done progressively better in each economic recovery of the past two decades. In the Clinton era expansion, 45 percent of the total income gains went to the top 1 percent; in the Bush recovery, the figure was 65 percent; now it is 93 percent.
Ah, the old public/private, motivated/mediocre, hard worker/slacker debate has kicked in full force.
First I’d like to share a thought abrewing for decades: the very rich don’t necessarily work much harder than I do. And they can’t manufacture more than 24 hours in a day. Much of this is moot anyway since the obscenely rich don’t really ‘work’ commensurate with their reward; their money does.
Second, on the question of being mediocre. By the inverse law of Lake Woebegone, most of us are potentially mediocre I think. I believe things would move along quite nicely if the average worker were at least mediocre. And how can one possibly blame a teacher for being mediocre when that is the nature of things?
Side question: where do the very rich, and particularly those holding levers of power, public or private, get the sheer chutzpah to make decisions affecting millions of people? My guess, like anything, it’s habit.
Anyway, this thread seems to have diverged to dumping on teachers when it should be about the question of whether the obscenely wealthy manipulators of our economy should be vilified and demonized. I see that Mespo has returned us to this theme with a hearty defense of those hard working, cuddly creatures who brought our economy to it’s knees.
For the record, I certainly don’t begrudge the hard working, self made individual. I don’t think that’s what we’re talking about. We are in a new era of financial cum social disequilibrium. It can, or should be brought under control in a nation that holds itself out, not just as a beacon of capitalism, but one of fairness.
Mespo’s plea notwithstanding, the American dream does not seem to function well these days except as a soporific to insulate the MOTU from getting sheared. Accuse me of generalizations. Fine. It is unseemly to use the attribution of the many worthy rich to insulate the many rapacious rich from responsibly contributing to society according to their means.
As far as demonizing those who manipulate the livelihood and well being of millions, you bet I do.
U.S. Economy Adds 146,000 Jobs In November; Unemployment At 7.7 Percent
David Taintor 8:34 AM EST, Friday December 7, 2012
“The U.S. economy added 146,000 jobs in November, according to the Labor Department. The unemployment rate fell to 7.7 percent. The Labor Department said that Hurricane Sandy “did not substantively impact the national employment and unemployment estimates for November.”
The Bureau of Labor Statistics revised the September and October jobs numbers as follows:
The change in total nonfarm payroll employment for September was revised from +148,000 to +132,000, and the change for October was revised from +171,000 to +138,000.” TPM
Makes Jack Welch look like the fool he has become.
mespo,
Do you really believe that people like Mitt Romney can’t afford the same income tax rate as someone like me?
*****
What’s your real tax rate?
http://money.msn.com/tax-planning/whats-your-real-tax-rate
Excerpt:
“Ready? Then let’s recap. Warren Buffett kicked up a storm when he noted that his effective federal tax rate in 2010 was less than his secretary’s. (He paid 11% of his AGI in federal taxes that year.) That’s because investment income is taxed at a lower rate than wages and salaries. Buffett questioned the fairness of that situation. The controversy led to the Buffett Rule, a proposal by President Barack Obama that would create a minimum 30% tax rate on people making more than $1 million a year.”
*****
Do you think people making a million dollars or more a year can afford to pay a minimum tax rate of 30%? Do you think people who say they think the income tax rate should be raised on those earning that kind of money are waging economic class warfare?
“We like this new President Barack Obama.”
“Assured and direct, Obama is refusing to yield to Republicans on a core idea he ran — and won — on: increasing the tax rate for America’s top earners. […] Reinvigorated after the vote, Obama is taking a new tack with the Republicans, who get credit for coming around to the notion that any deal will require new tax revenue. Instead of endless negotiations, Obama has drawn his line in the sand and is standing firm on tax rates for top earners. He’s doing the same with Republican attempts to gain leverage by potentially refusing to raise the government’s debt limit next year. Last time that happened, in 2011, Congress brought the U.S. to the brink of default.
After Obama was re-elected, we said our nation desperately needs a grand bargain, one that combines increased tax revenues with bold spending cuts. That is what Obama ran on, and he now has every right and obligation to fight to the end to get it.” Chicago Sun Times editorial board
“So it is sheer hogwash that “tax cuts for the rich” caused the government to lose tax revenues. The government gained tax revenues, not lost them. Moreover, “the rich” paid a larger amount of taxes, and a larger share of all taxes, after the tax rates were cut. ”
http://jewishworldreview.com/cols/sowell120512.php3#.UMHxqa5PJ80
“One of the big advantages that President Obama has, as he plays “chicken” with the Congressional Republicans along the “fiscal cliff,” is that Obama is a master of the plausible lie, which will never be exposed by the mainstream media— nor, apparently, by the Republicans.
A key lie that has been repeated over and over, largely unanswered, is that President Bush’s “tax cuts for the rich” cost the government so much lost tax revenue that this added to the budget deficit— so that the government cannot afford to allow the cost of letting the Bush tax rates continue for “the rich.”
It sounds very plausible, and constant repetition without a challenge may well be enough to convince the voting public that, if the Republican-controlled House of Representatives does not go along with Barack Obama’s demands for more spending and higher tax rates on the top 2 percent, it just shows that they care more for “the rich” than for the other 98 percent.
What is remarkable is how easy it is to show how completely false Obama’s argument is. That also makes it completely inexplicable why the Republicans have not done so.
The official statistics which show plainly how wrong Barack Obama is can be found in his own “Economic Report of the President” for 2012, on page 411. You can look it up.
You may be able to find a copy of the “Economic Report of the President” for 2012 at your local public library. Or you can buy a hard copy from the Government Printing Office or download an electronic version from the Internet. ”
“For those who find that “a picture is worth a thousand words,” they need only see the graphs published in the November 30th issue of Investor’s Business Daily.
What both the statistical tables in the “Economic Report of the President” and the graphs in Investor’s Business Daily show is that (1) tax revenues went up— not down— after tax rates were cut during the Bush administration, and (2) the budget deficit declined, year after year, after the cut in tax rates that have been blamed by Obama for increasing the deficit.
Indeed, the New York Times reported in 2006: “An unexpectedly steep rise in tax revenues from corporations and the wealthy is driving down the projected budget deficit this year.”
While the New York Times may not have expected this, there is nothing unprecedented about lower tax rates leading to higher tax revenues, despite automatic assumptions by many in the media and elsewhere that tax rates and tax revenues automatically move in the same direction. They do not.
The Congressional Budget Office has been embarrassed repeatedly by making projections based on the assumption that tax revenues and tax rates move in the same direction.
This has happened as recently as the George W. Bush administration and as far back as the Reagan administration. Moreover, tax revenues went up when tax rates went down, as far back as the Coolidge administration, before there was a Congressional Budget Office to make false
predictions. ”
http://jewishworldreview.com/cols/sowell120512.php3#.UMHxqa5PJ80
mespo,
Did I suggest that teachers bear no responsibility for failing schools? I don’t think all teachers are sterling examples of the profession. I had issues with a couple of my daughter’s own high school teachers.
People often paint with a broad stroke when talking about failing schools and schools being in decline. Do you really believe that ALL schools in this country are failing or in decline…that ALL schools systems need to be reformed? What types of communities have the most failing schools, do you suppose?
One of the things that I believe is hurting children and the educational process most these days–high stakes testing–wasn’t foisted on education by teachers. I can tell you that in my own state we educators were not happy about it–especially after we were shown some examples of the tests…and benchmark writing samples. As usual, the powers that be turned a deaf ear to teachers’ concerns.
I left the classroom because I didn’t think I’d be able to teach the way I had taught in the past. I knew I’d be pressured into prepping my students for tests in the future. I spent my last three years in education as school librarian. I know many of the teachers who are still working at my school. (Quite a number of them were in the habit of working until well after six o’clock.) Those teachers still work hard to make their classrooms inviting, interesting places where children learn, explore, and do creative projects. Unfortunately, they have to spend a lot more time on prepping kids for tests than they would like.
Teachers don’t advance their educations? They certainly did in the community where I taught–and in many of the cities and towns in the area where I live. Nearly all of the teachers in my school district had a masters plus more than thirty hours. Some had a CAGS (Certificate of Advanced Graduate Study).
“Amid all the political and media hoopla about the “fiscal cliff” crisis, there are a few facts that are worth noting.
First of all, despite all the melodrama about raising taxes on “the rich,” even if that is done it will scarcely make a dent in the government’s financial problems. Raising the tax rates on everybody in the top two percent will not get enough additional tax revenue to run the government for ten days.
And what will the government do to pay for the other 355 days in the year?
All the political angst and moral melodrama about getting “the rich” to pay “their fair share” is part of a big charade. This is not about economics, it is about politics. Taxing “the rich” will produce a drop in the bucket when compared to the staggering and unprecedented deficits of the Obama administration.
No previous administration in the entire history of the nation ever finished the year with a trillion dollar deficit. The Obama administration has done so every single year. Yet political and media discussions of the financial crisis have been focussed overwhelmingly on how to get more tax revenue to pay for past and future spending. ”
http://jewishworldreview.com/cols/sowell120412.php3#.UMHxta5PJ80
Elaine M:
No one here wants to vilify teachers, but neither should they be accorded sacred cow status either. Like every profession they are evaluated on what they do. If the overall status of education in the US is on the decline shouldn’t they bear at least SOME responsibility along with indifferent parents and poverty and petty bureaucrats? And while primary and secondary school teachers may not be compensated as well as other professions, they must admit that for the most part they haven’t invested in advanced education like other professions have. I share your admiration for excellent teachers (such as yourself) whom I credit extensively for any success I’ve enjoyed. I just don’t credit all of them.
Mike S:
“Inspiring concoction that has many examples like Donald Trump, the Koch Brothers and George W. Bush.”
*********************
For every one of those examples there are scads more counterexamples of folks who worked their way to the top with little or no family connections. This phenomena only happens in the Western democracies. Like the poor, the wealthy are always with us and vilifying them as a group makes no sense. Burke said long ago you cannot draw up an indictment against an entire people. What galls many on the left is the belief that all success is just a voyage on the sea of chance. For some that may be true but we do ourselves a disservice not to recognize merit where merit exists. It comes across as base envy.
As for the teachers union above, this is precisely what it looks like. Excuse making for poor performance is the business of the mediocre.
“Tinkle Down” economics.
Oh, stop demonizing teachers
By Eugene Robinson
Washington Post
September 18, 2012
http://www.ohio.com/editorial/eugene-robinson-oh-stop-demonizing-teachers-1.335645
Excerpt:
WASHINGTON: Teachers are heroes, not villains, and it’s time to stop demonizing them.
It has become fashionable to blame all of society’s manifold sins and wickedness on “teachers unions,” as if it were possible to separate these supposedly evil organizations from the dedicated public servants who belong to them. News flash: Collective bargaining is not the problem, and taking that right away from teachers will not fix the schools.
It is true that teachers in Chicago have dug in their heels against Mayor Rahm Emanuel’s demands for “reform,” some of which are not unreasonable. I’d dig in, too, if I were constantly being lectured by self-righteous crusaders whose knowledge of the inner-city schools crisis comes from a Hollywood movie.
The problems that afflict public education go far beyond what George W. Bush memorably called “the soft bigotry of low expectations.” They go beyond whatever measure of institutional sclerosis may be attributed to tenure, beyond the inevitable cases of burnout, beyond the fact that teachers in some jurisdictions actually earn halfway decent salaries.
The fact is that teachers are being saddled with absurdly high expectations. Some studies have shown a correlation between student performance and teacher “effectiveness,” depending how this elusive quality is measured. But there is a whole body of academic literature proving the stronger correlation between student performance and a much more important variable: family income.
Yes, I’m talking about poverty. Sorry to be so gauche, but when teachers point out the relationship between income and achievement, they’re not shirking responsibility. They’re just stating an inconvenient truth.
According to figures compiled by the College Board, students from families making more than $200,000 score more than 300 points higher on the SAT, on average, than students from families making less than $20,000 a year. There is, in fact, a clear relationship all the way along the scale: Each increment in higher family income translates into points on the test.
Professor Sean Reardon of Stanford University’s Center for Education Policy Analysis concluded in a recent study that the achievement gap between high-income and low-income students is actually widening. It is unclear why this might be happening; maybe it is due to increased income inequality, maybe the relationship between income and achievement has somehow become stronger, maybe there is some other reason.
Whatever the cause, our society’s answer seems to be: Beat up the teachers.
The brie-and-chablis “reform” movement would have us believe that most of the teachers in low-income, low-performing schools are incompetent — and, by extension, that most of the teachers in upper-crust schools, where students perform well, are paragons of pedagogical virtue.
But some of the most dedicated and talented teachers I’ve ever met were working in “failing” inner-city schools. And yes, in award-winning schools where, as in Lake Wobegon, “all the children are above average,” I’ve met some unimaginative hacks who should never be allowed near a classroom.
It is reasonable to hold teachers accountable for their performance. But it is not reasonable — or, in the end, productive — to hold them accountable for factors that lie far beyond their control. It is fair to insist that teachers approach their jobs with the assumption that every single child, rich or poor, can succeed. It is not fair to expect teachers to correct all the imbalances and remedy all the pathologies that result from growing inequality in our society.
Demonizing Teachers’ Unions
By Nicole Belle
3/27/12
http://crooksandliars.com/nicole-belle/demonizing-teachers-unions
If there is any particular Republican framing that grinds my teeth to see the left adopt–other than the term “entitlements” to refer to Medicare and Social Security–it is the pointing the finger at teachers’ unions as the obstacle to education reform. No one–not one person–who enters the teacher profession, particularly at the K-12 level, does so because they’re looking for a financial windfall. The teachers’ unions in many cases have made accommodations to states pleading poverty, relinquishing pensions, salaries, health care, even acceding to furloughs. I never thought that the Democratic Party would need to be reminded just how underpaid and unappreciated teachers are and how their unions are the last line of defense in a country going into default on its social contract.
How refreshing in a media climate where even rising star lefties go to union-basher and cheat Michelle Rhee (I’m looking at you, Gavin Newsom) for their ideas on demonizing teachers some more, Melissa Harris-Perry invites an actual teacher on to point out that it’s pretty frickin’ dispiriting to be a teacher these days. What other profession can one be part of where the pay is low, the conventional wisdom (so aptly portrayed in this clip by Bloomberg’s Jonathan Alter) blames teachers for all ills, they have no control over curriculum, they’re penalized for teaching kids to think instead of mindlessly parroting test answers and yet somehow they’re supposed to rise above it and teach our little darlings?
Look, I speak as a parent and as a product of California public schools at a time when they were ranked at the top instead of the lower 10 percent: we have deep, deep problems in education. California is the eighth largest economy in the world and we spend approximately 50 percent of the General Fund on education But that money isn’t making it to the student. And we keep circling around teachers unions as the problem.
Here’s an idea: let’s look at inequality as a problem. Why shouldn’t everyone have access to quality education regardless of zip codes? Let’s look food insecurity, where one in five children goes without a single daily decent meal. Let’s look at the disparity in parental involvement and try to figure out a way to get parents invested in their kids’ education. Let’s give teachers more autonomy over their classrooms. Let’s stop wasting money on private testing organizations and looking at for-profit charter businesses as the silver bullet that “fixes” education. All of these forces have far more to do with the state of education today. And I think reform in these areas will immediately yield better results than the ability to fire the bottom 10 percent of teachers.
But let’s also stop framing this debate as to what’s best for children is de facto not good for their teachers.
mespo,
We had a number of student teachers who trained at our elementary school. They had left the private sector for teaching because they thought it would be a much easier job. Just one of them stuck with the profession. The others discovered teaching young children was more difficult than they had expected.
I realize that not all school cultures are the same. My teaching experience was quite different from your father’s.
More people voted for Al Gore than George W. Bush in the 2000 election–yet Bush became president. We don’t always get what we vote for.
Teachers are waging economic class warfare? I’d say that’s a bit hyperbolic–especially when one considers that the rich have been getting richer by leaps and bounds in the past couple of decades–while many people are falling out of the middle class.
So…those who use their riches to bribe/buy politicians aren’t at fault for perverting the political system to their benefit? Much of this has gone on behind the scenes for many years. We are just beginning to learn about ALEC and the impact the organization has had in state legislatures across the country. You don’t fault the wealthy for their actions–just the middle class and poor.