During the campaign, many people expressed outrage over Mitt Romney’s statement concerning the fact that almost fifty percent of the public do not pay pay income taxes. I well understood the anger, but I am a bit surprised that a video by the California Federation of Teachers has not produced the same outrage over its unfairness and frankly crudeness. The video shows a wealthy person urinating on the poor as part of a “Tax the Rich: An Animated Fairy Tale.” I readily admit that I am in the minority on our blog in opposing some of the tax increase proposals in this country and abroad as economically unwise. However, the demonization of the wealthy in this country has gone a bit far when a video of this kind is released by a major organization.
Real Clear Politics and a few sites ran a story on the urination scene, but the video below has the sound but not the image of actual urination. It is not clear if someone added the yellow image to the video or the producers removed the image. When you now hit on various sites that showed what they said was the image of the urination, a sign pops up that this is now a “private video.” I am unsure of what that means since the union reportedly put the video out to the public. However, there is no mention of the controversy that I could find on the union site.
The eight-minute video was written and directed by California Federation of Teachers’ communications director Fred Glass with voice over by Ed Asner. The mythical land describes rich evading taxes by investing in “Wall Street” — not quite mythical. “Don’t worry. This is good for you, too. Because it will trickle down from us to you.” You can still hear the sound of the rich man “trickling down” on the poor.
Viewers are urged to email their elected representatives to tell them to raise taxes on the wealthy in order to fund public services.
I happen to agree with the premise of raising revenues (though I oppose some of the tax proposals in this country and abroad). I am a long and vocal supporter for increasing funding for schools and teachers. However, I view this video as unfair and hyperbolic even without the yellow stream. The wealthy do pay considerable taxes and many support public programs and public causes. They also do pay the vast majority of taxes. Should they pay more in this economy. Yes, but it is grossly unfair to engage in this type of vilification. The video for example states that after the housing market crash the government printed money for “rich people” but they didn’t give any to “ordinary people whose houses and jobs were broken by the crash.” The video also states that after the collapse that rich people “love their money more than anything in the world.” That is simply outrageous. What would be the reaction to a business group releasing a video stating poor people do not care for other people and do not want to work? There would be justified anger and outrage, but the reaction to this video seems to be muted from the left. It is not enough to simply shrug and again blame the other side triggering such responses. Whatever the excesses of the other side of this debate, it does not relieve adults of being the obligations of accuracy and decency. As an educator myself, I am embarrassed to see any teacher’s organization engage in such attacks.
I am interested in whether the union did include the even more offensive image and removed it or whether it is claiming that conservative groups hacked their video. If it is the former, I do not believe that they have served the interests of teachers who generally strive to engage in reasoned and respectful debate. If it is the latter, I would love to know who added the yellow image and left the appearance that it was in the original video. The union itself has thus far said little on the controversy. [UPDATE: the original video is posted here and shows the yellow image. It would appear that the union has altered its own video though I cannot find any statement from it on this controversy].
The current video is shown below.
BTW, 223 comments at present — guess the teachers’ video caught out attention
Mike,
Has Nick ever told us how much time he spent in education? Has he told us how extensive his experience as a teacher was?
I don’t know what kind of fairy dust the 3Rs (SM: Radical Resentful Rich) are snorting, but look at all the magical goodness which comes from fewer jobs —
http://www.forbes.com/sites/kenfisher/2012/12/05/why-job-growth-is-overrated/
Magnificent, but apparently dead today. It could well be a standing topic:
Who is responsible for where we are today.
So many here trip themselves over their own tongue, figuratively.
Messpo, was especially “adroit”, but got none of GeneH. usual crtiticism for obvious logiical errors.
Messpo points to our miserable performance academically in international comparison, and yet compares that to the worldsleading results of our corporations. First he ignores that teachers and corps are operating in completely different arenas with different competitors and support systems.
Secondly he does not reflect that at least some of the American corporate success is due to the “success” of the education system. Corps are not totally manned by those who were immigrant students here once upon a time.
And GeneH, I will differ on the question of malice versus stupidity.
I would propose that it is not monkey see-monkey do either.
It is the the bottom line requirement that drives all corporations that are listed. All corps are lead by people who have several factors that determine if they get bonuses or even have a job. One of these is ROI to the stockholders, and the stock price development in a positive way.
And it is one of the closest things we have to real competition between companies in the same branch. They compete on the capital market.
If you don’t perform well, you’re out of a job, now and perhaps even in the future.
So, using the “knowledge” to produce acceptable ROI (yield–>dividends) and stock price development would seem to be the primary factors. This knowledge was at one time purchased and an intermal group maintains and betters it.
If it means covering yourself with a director of corporate ethics who goes to conferences concerned with employee safety, etc.,….this director is well informed on the situation and thus firm in his saying no to suppliers, which will consciouslly do evil to the workers. There is no other´choice.
The odd part in the case of Walmart is that it is privately owned, and the factors are determined by the owners and not in a market competing for capital from investors.
“Back to the substance. I was a teacher and have the same viewpoint as you. I came into teaching after having my own business and was appalled by the lack of work ethic. I’m not talking just a few, it’s systemic.”
Nick,
As you keep trying to prove to us time and again, you’re just SO SPECIAL. However, your use of anecdotes to prove your “points” does lack something in argument. It must be hard to live in a world where you are so competent and hardworking and those around you so incompetent and lazy? Also you define “substance” as drawing from your experiences in teaching, as noted from your “superior” point of view, that this is endemic countrywide. I hope you didn’t endeavor to teach either rhetoric, or logic. 🙂
There are two distinct threads of argument running through this one thread. The first is how unfair it was for this teacher’s union to attack the plutocracy of wealth in the manner they did by using a universal bodily function. The second thread is definitely, despite those who try to moderate their declarations, that teachers and their unions share a large burden of blame for the sorry state of our school systems nationwide. I’ll try to deal with both these lines of argument.
Mespo responds to my examples of Trump, Koch Brothers and G.W. Bush with:
“For every one of those examples there are scads more counterexamples of folks who worked their way to the top with little or no family connections.”
Perhaps this is so, but then it devolves on how one defines “scads” and that defined amount then measured as a percentage of the whole population. The quick, dirty, yet effective rejoinder to that is:
“In recent years several large studies have found that vertical inter-generational [economic] mobility is lower in the United States than in most developed countries.” http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_mobility#cite_note-DeParle-11
The truth is that the ability to lift oneself up by “their bootstraps” is a clever myth that has been sold in this country as “The American Dream”. It certainly makes many of us in the in the 99% looking up at our “betters” feel more comfortable, that with a little hard work and “pluck” (as Horatio Alger used to put it in his hugely influential American fantasies of success) about our own limited means. After all as Mespo alluded at one point, it is within our own power to succeed or fail. The studies cited above show that this is mere mythology, bought, by those on the bottom and sold by those on the top.
The American reality is this. Among the industrialized nations our country’s workforce works longer hours, with fewer benefits and far less leisure time as measured by vacation days allowed. We do so because we have been convinced by the “American Dream” that the collective “We” has it better than anywhere else in the world. As I’ve shown above not only isn’t this true, but the reality is that despite an individuals hard work they would have less chance of rising economically here, than in most other Western Nations. I’ve demolished this myth time and again in my guest blogs here, but because of WordPress constraints I must limit my links. (By typing in “Mike Spindell” in the search function at the top right you can see many of my guest blogs which deal with variations of this theme) The process by which this myth was sold ca also be viewed by typing in “Gene Howington” above for his excellent series on propaganda.
As for the second thread of argument that teachers and teachers unions are to blame, Elaine’s many comments and copious links refute that notion. Teachers Unions as “scapegoats” are merely part of the propaganda scam that it seems many who commented here have bought. This too is a part of the propaganda propounded by the Corporate Elite to not only divide us of the less worthy classes, but to misdirect us from the truth that the game is rigged in their favor. How often do we see the rants as to how easy the teachers have it and how much vacation time they get. Those same ranters never though contemplate how really easy our “corporate masters of the universe have it” and how pleasant are their lives. The elite live in a world where a four hour golf outing is written off as a business expense. Where dining at restaurants with obscene pricing and copious top shelf alcoholic beverages is considered part of their “long” work day.
We see critiques of athletes by sports team owners for being “overpaid”, when many of these owners are scions of inherited wealth whose entire success in life is due to Daddy and Mommy. The owners quickly forget as they sit in their luxury boxes, that it is the athletes who people come to see. I, on the other hand see parallels between the propagandized public scorn for “overpaid athletes and their money-grubbing unions” and the organized campaign nationally against teachers unions. Both arguments are fueled by corporatist propaganda and are directed at union activity, which is a main target of those who would reduce us to serfdom. Anyone incidentally who would like to argue pro athlete’s salaries with me is welcome to do so, but I give fair warning that this is an area in which I have some expertise. I don’t have to argue the teacher’s cause because Elaine has done so convincingly.
As for my arguments about the rich I inherit the excellent comments above by DonS and SwM and mine are merely supplements. Finally though, I will end this with another quotation from the link I provided above. This deals with the role of education in upward economic movement and is a sobering one, since it shows that economic conditions affect one’s educational potential, which in turn affects one upward financial mobility:
“It is a widespread belief that there is a strong correlation between obtaining an education and increasing one’s economic mobility. The education system in the United States has always been considered the most effective and equal process for all individuals to improve one’s economic standing.[18] Despite the increasing availability to education for all, family background continues to play a huge role in determining economic success. To individuals who do not have or cannot obtain an education, the greater overall levels of education can act as a barrier, increasing their chance of being left behind at the bottom of the economic or income ladder.
Studies have shown that education and family background has a great effect on economic mobility across generations. Family background or one’s socioeconomic status affects the likelihood that students will graduate from high school or college, what type of college or institution they will attend, and how likely they are to graduate and complete a degree. According to studies, when split into income quintiles including the bottom, second, middle, fourth and top, adult children without a college degree and with parents in the bottom quintile remained in the bottom quintile. But if the adult children did have a college degree, there was only a 16% chance that they would remain at the bottom of the quintile. Therefore, it was proven that education provided an increase in economic status and mobility for poorer families. Not only does obtaining a college degree make it much more likely for individuals to make it to the top two quintiles, education helps those who were born in the top quintiles to remain in the top quintiles. Therefore, hard work and increasing education from those who are born into the lower quintiles can boost economic status and help them move ahead, but children born into wealthier families do seem to have the advantage. Even when the likelihood of attending college is ignored, studies have shown that out of all the students that enroll in college, socioeconomic status or family background still has an effect on graduation rates with 53% of those from the top quintile receiving bachelor’s degrees along with 39% from the middle and 22% from the bottom quintile. According to the 2002 US Census, students can expect to earn on average about $2.1 million with a bachelor’s degree over the course of their working career. That is almost $1 million more than what individual’s without a college degree can expect to earn.”
Me 1, December 6, 2012 at 1:23 pm
Other things this pathetic non 1%er tells himself…
=========================================
You do not understand that in this context 1% and 99% are more than numbers.
They are people.
The metaphor 1% represents the plutocracy. To be a member of the plutocracy one must use the power of their money to rule by manipulating those in governmental offices in a manner that serves the interests of that plutocratic, blind selfishness.
Those you cite to play pretend the others do not exist fails.
You have the contempt of the typical bully religionist, and the hallucinations of Ayn Rand.
mespo, On a tangential note, I did not say nor did I think Elaine is “intimidated” by you..that’s your word. Being an attorney, you can read the transcript. My point was that you are afforded a certain decorum, most certainly earned, but you receive it nonetheless. Continuing that point is if I said the same as you, it would not be as eloquent but the substance the same, I would be vilified. And we are completely sympatico on the education and class thing. Finally, the point was not about me, but about the people who are run out of here because they simply don’t have your cred. I will never be run out of here.
Back to the substance. I was a teacher and have the same viewpoint as you. I came into teaching after having my own business and was appalled by the lack of work ethic. I’m not talking just a few, it’s systemic. Regarding “the evil rich”; I read recently that 80 of the Fortune 500 companies were founded by immigrants. All 4 of my grandparents were immigrants and my paternal grandfather worked his ass off to build his restaurant biz and pass it on to his sons. This class warfare is an anathema to everything I was taught by my family. It’s destructive to our culture which is built upon hard work and personal responsibility. I have said here many times I don’t like MOST large corporations. But no matter what laws are passed, they’ll do just fine. It’s the small businessman who will pay.
Some Billionaires Paying Less Than One Percent In Taxes [WATCH]
First Posted: 11/19/11
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/11/18/billionaires-taxes_n_1102234.html
Excerpt:
Despite making more than a billion dollars, some of the nation’s super rich manage to pay an extremely low tax rate.
The top 400 earners in the U.S. paid an average tax rate of 18 percent, according to a Bloomberg TV report noticed by Think Progress. And though that’s a far lower rate than the 26.5 percent that many families making less than $100,000 pay annually in taxes, some of America’s super-rich have been able to whittle their tax bill down even more, paying a tax rate as low as one percent, according to Bloomberg.
How? Many of the super rich take advantage of a variety of tax loopholes to lower their tax burden. For some of America’s rich, most of their wealth comes from stock appreciation, according to Bloomberg, which some billionaires don’t end up defining as taxable income.
These findings echo earlier reports, which suggest that the super rich may not be paying their full share in taxes. More than 1,400 millionaires paid no U.S. income taxes in 2009, according to an August report from the Internal Revenue Service.
In addition, 25 percent of all millionaires pay a smaller percentage of their income taxes than millions of middle class households.
But billionaires aren’t the only ones that use loopholes to pay lower taxes. Thirty of America’s most profitable corporations used rules like the “active financing exception” — allowing corporations to sidestep paying taxes on overseas profits if they were derived by “actively financing” some activity or deal — to pay less than zero in income taxes, according to a recent report from the Center for Tax Justice.
7,000 Millionaires Paid No Income Tax In 2011
Henry Blodget|Sep. 18, 2012
http://www.businessinsider.com/7000-millionaires-paid-no-income-tax-2012-9
Excerpt:
The chart below from the Tax Policy Center shows the distribution of federal income taxes paid by income level in 2011.
It contains a number of interesting factoids, including the following:
– 7,000 people made more than $1 million but paid no income tax.
– 22,000 people made between $500,000 and $1 million but paid no income tax.
– 81,000 people made between $200,000 and $500,000 but paid no income tax.
– 381,000 people made between $100,000 and $200,000 but paid no income tax.
So that’s 491,000 Americans who made more than $100,000 a year who paid no income tax. (Clearly dependent victims who refuse to take responsibility for their lives!)
Also:
– 45% of the country makes less than $30,000 per year.
– 30% of the country makes less than $20,000 per year.
– 15% of the country makes less than $10,000 per year.
Also:
– 60 million of the 76 million Americans who pay no income tax make $30,000 or less.
When Is Enough Enough?
John Galt Is A Crybaby And So Are You
By Richard (RJ) Eskow
Posted: 02/ 8/2012
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/rj-eskow/john-galt-is-a-crybaby-an_b_1263671.html
Excerpt:
Dear Self-Described “Producer”:
I received your hate mail this morning. Thank you for emerging from your self-creating illusion long enough to write it. I particularly enjoyed your unstated rhetorical debt to the John Galt character in Ayn Rand’s Atlas Shrugged, who isn’t acknowledged enough nowadays for his historical importance as the most long-winded and incoherent crybaby in literary history.
It’s reassuring to know that his tradition lives on.
I still have faith that there can be a productive exchange of ideas between rational libertarians and people on the left, who share a common perspective on certain issues. But a substrain of libertarian and conservative thought is characterized by a large and undeserved measure of self-regard, combined with an excess of self-pity and a lack of clear ideas.
For today’s purposes let us stipulate that your email is Exhibit A.
Letter from a Galtian
“I am really curios (sic) to know what motivates the mind of a socialist,” you write. “Why do you think its (sic) fair to penalize those of us who produce while rewarding those who do not?”
(Apparently the email software used by producers doesn’t have a spell-check function. Fitting, I guess, for people whose fictional hero described scientists and other educated members of society as “parasites of subsidized classrooms.”)
Later you ask, “What happens when the government has exhausted the money acquired from the producers? I have a feeling producers will stop producing if the government is just going to take it.”
I don’t know you personally, and you didn’t sign your name. (Until the novel’s end, everybody knows Galt’s name but he refuses to speak. His legions of anonymous Internet followers like it the other way around.) I have no way of knowing if you’ve read the book or just imbibed Rand’s ideas second-hand.
Either way you’re a follower of John Galt, who, in Rand’s famous (and entirely implausible) climax, leads a “strike” of job-producing visionaries rebelling against taxes and regulation.
Quitting Time
Atlas Shrugged is so revered in right-wing circles that, as one ex think tanker admitted, people who hadn’t read it were described as “virgins.” (Without the readership of virgins it would have languished in obscurity.) Rand’s acolytes are always threatening to “go Galt” and deprive us of their beautiful minds, but they never really get around to it. Like the old Dan Hicks song says, “How can we miss you if you won’t go away?”
Most parasites of the subsidized classroom know that, in Greek mythology, Atlas holds up the world. One Rand character asks another, “What would you tell him?”
“To shrug.”
Warning to would-be Galts: Shrugging while holding a heavy globe on your neck and shoulders is orthopedically unsound and could lead to severe cervical spine injury. Anyone with a rudimentary knowledge of physics knows that the easiest way to unload a heavy planet by simply standing up straight.
When was the last time you stood up straight? You, like John Galt, have been benefiting from government services all your life. The upstanding thing to do is to acknowledge that fact, and then man up and pay your fair share. (I assume you’re a man by your prose style, your chosen pen name – and by the fact that most of Rand’s followers are.)
Instead, you guys are always threatening to “go Galt.” Which raises the question: Who’s stopping you?
DonS, They are resentful over the fact they might not get to keep all of the windfall they received through the Bush tax cuts and other loopholes. They also wanted the estate tax repealed and it is not going to happen.
Elaine, “there are none so blind as those who will not see”. Could make you cry.
Mike & Don,
We can let our infrastructure and schools fall apart and eliminate services and social programs for the majority of folks. We just can’t ask the ultra rich to contribute a little bit more of their wealth for the betterment of society.
“The “radical resentful rich” . . .”
Wait a minute SM, we’ve been instructed that those of ‘us’, er, disgruntled prols, are the ones exhibiting the sin of envy.
Bron, so there’s nothing to be done. Rollover and take it like a wo/man, eh?
Oh nevermind.
Bron,
Does Romney invest his money in Cayman Island banks?
You mean if Romney was required to pay the same tax rate as the average working American, he wouldn’t be able to buy a new car or boat or fourth or fifth home? Really? Cars and yachts and vacation homes must have gotten really expensive if a man of his means couldn’t afford to buy any of them if he had to pay more than 15% on his capital gains. Poor little rich boy. I promise not to pick on Romney ever again!!!
*****
How much is Mitt Romney worth? ‘Forbes’ says $230M
http://content.usatoday.com/communities/onpolitics/post/2012/05/mitt-romney-net-worth-forbes-/1
Oh Bron, poor Bron, your taxes are going up and you think it so unfair. You present graphs from your Right Wing source as concocted by little Tommy Sowell, defender of the prerogatives of wealth as their loyal liege-man. Little Tommy forgot one thing in his musings about the National Debt during the Bush years and that was the two wars whose expenditures were kept “off-budget”. Ah but actual economic truths won’t deter Little Tommy, since he takes his role as “Defender of the Rich and Powerful” seriously. It pays well. Those truths will also not deter you since your chief political concern is taking care of you and yours.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/rj-eskow/the-radical-rich-from-rom_b_1896687.html The “radical resentful rich” want more and more money. There is never enough.