
We have long discussed the authoritarianism of Vladimir Putin whose history of beating protesters and striping away press freedom was put aside briefly for the Olympic ceremonies. However, Putin appeared to be eager to stop the love fest and turn on Ukraine. For history buffs, however, there is something a bit unnerving in Putin invading a neighboring country to protect Russian-speakers who are welcoming the troops as protectors. In case the Sudetenland does not come to mind, Poland is now mobilizing troops along the border to bring the historical analogy home for the rest of the world. While I believe that this crisis will be contained and Putin is not ready for a wider war, it is no accident that the blind nationalism and authoritarianism would lead to expansionism. Ukraine is not the Sudetenland and Poland is no longer using horses to repel tanks. Putin’s desire for control of this port and Lebensraum may not be as easy to hold as it was to take.
Putin has already secured approval from the Duma to send in troops into Ukraine — notably not just the Crimea but the whole country. (I will note that our own Congress — both Democrats and Republicans alike — showed no more independence in approving the Iraq invasions. Indeed, some like Hillary Clinton are now frontrunners for the next presidency). Hitler cited the close ties to the region of Czechoslovakia and their common language as an excuse for the invasion while German-speakers in the country welcomed the occupation. To make the analogy even more interesting, this is the anniversary of the German invasion of March 1939.
The analogy has not escaped Poland which released the following statement: “History shows – although I don’t want to use too many historical comparisons – that those who appease all the time in order to preserve peace usually only buy a little bit of time.”
Putin’s move is a clear violation of international law. There was no serious unrest and no attack on Russian forces or territory. There was not even a basis for a preemptive attack in anticipation of such violence.
The combination of the invitation for invasion in the Crimea with today’s march in Moscow calling for invasion seems a case of history repeating itself.
Of course, the jitters of the world are not helped by the fact that this is the location of the Crimean War between 1853-56 between Russia and France, Britain, the Ottoman Empire, and Sardinia. Russia lost.
I do not see a major role for the United States at the moment. Our involvement is only likely to trigger even greater insecurities that are so prominent in Russian history over its borders. While people in Congress are screaming to “get tough,” any direct intervention would be a domestic political move and serve no one’s interest in the Ukraine.
None of this history is likely to phase Putin who remains as he once was: a humorless, self-infatuated KGB Lt. Colonel. The one promising fact is the crashing of Russian stock. It will be interesting to watch, in a much more economically connected world, how the likely market pressures will affect Putin’s calculations.
http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2014/03/no-american-weakness-didnt-encourage-putin-to-invade-ukraine/284168/But the Obama administration will also have to tell Kiev’s revolutionaries that while it supports a unified, democratic Ukraine, it does not support an anti-Russian Ukraine. Russia will not permit it, and at the end of the day, the United States cannot protect Ukraine from Russia’s wrath. It’s a bit like Finland’s dilemma during the Cold War or Taiwan’s now. Even if Ukraine regains control over its domestic affairs, it will never enjoy complete control over its foreign policy. The U.S. has a moral obligation to support democracy and self-determination. But it also has a moral obligation not to make promises it can’t keep.
That was true before Obama, and it will be true after he’s gone. And it has nothing to do with America being in retreat.
Also a coincidence that both countries hosted the Olympics before invading countries in which they had a large ethnic population residing there.
http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2014/03/02/ex-cia-chief-why-we-get-putin-wrong.html Putin invaded Georgia in 2008. These invasions are part of his plan.
We, in a cavalier manner, attack Putin as a megalomaniac, etc, etc, the list goes on and on. However, put him up alongside of the three stooges we allowed lead us for eight years, start and lose two wars, ruin our economy, land in fighter jets on carriers, say to Americans in response to criticism of our poor weaponry, “You go to war with what ya got.”, etc, etc, and on and on and on. Compare and contrast the last administration with Putin and Putin comes out way ahead. He is certainly more intelligent than the little brush. He may be arrogant and waltz around topless to his own narcissistic delight, but he is capable.
Putin may be securing a predominantly Russian populated area of Ukraine from the chaos and potential police action of Kiev or he may be up to his old tricks of trying to solidify Russia after the explosion of states after the break up of the USSR. Whatever he does it amounts to a hill of beans to the slaughter this country has performed in Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan, and other so called independent and autonomous countries.
Some Americans from their xenophobic couch wax on ignorantly and hypocritically at everything knowing next to nothing.
Elaine M.
How soon we forget the feckless George Bush and his Darth Vader overlord Dick Cheney who started a preemptive war with another country. Didn’t Congress give Bush the unilateral power to invade Iraq?
=============
Good point Elaine.
We wrote the book Putin is using.
nick spinelli
Believe me Dredd, I know the US is culpable in much violence both internally and internationally. I don’t think we are as bad as Russia. A low bar indeed, but nonetheless a bar we are above …
============
I used to live above a bar once.
It was part of my green thing … not driving much … you know, saving on fossil fuel use.
How soon we forget the feckless George Bush and his Darth Vader overlord Dick Cheney who started a preemptive war with another country. Didn’t Congress give Bush the unilateral power to invade Iraq?
nick spinelli
Dredd, How would the polling go today?
==============
That is this year’s (2014) report based on end of year (2013) data.
At the end of this year another poll will be taken.
This history of Crimea is Russian. It was given by the USSR from Russia to Ukraine. Ukraine has other sea ports on the Black Sea. And Ukraine needs Russian oil and natural gas. It may be time to give Crimea back to Russia in exchange for reaching some peaceful accommodations on the rest of the issues. And sure, Putin is a bully. But we need to live with him for now.
Believe me Dredd, I know the US is culpable in much violence both internally and internationally. I don’t think we are as bad as Russia. A low bar indeed, but nonetheless a bar we are above
Dredd, How would the polling go today?
nick spinelli
I have been scoffed @ here by alleged intellectuals when I said Putin is the most dangerous man in the world.
…
==========
We have our opinions, and the world around us has theirs:
(The Country Posing The Greatest Threat to Peace as 2013 Ends is …). Just sayin’ …
Bron, Obama is weak and feckless but has errand boys and a compliant press telling him he’s the greatest. A dangerous combo.
nick:
all those intellectuals laughed at Palin in 2008 when she said Putin would invade Ukraine because Obama was weak.
Personally, I am with AY on this. Let it go as it will. We have no interest in this dispute. How would we like the Russians in Mexico helping one faction throw out a legitimately elected government?
The only thing that Putin answers to is money. We need to cut off the flow of money or tie up Russian investments. That will make him more nervous than any troop movements or military aid.
Another free-speech viewpoint:
“You’ll be hearing these two assertions repeated, made by someone who voted for the Iraq War in the 21st Century, a lot in coming days” …:
“I guess someone in the Obama White House believed that if we call Vladimir Putin weak after he’s just called our bluff, it will get him to back down, even as Putin knows we have no great options against him.”
“But it all shows one of the downsides of having so badly spent our moral standing already this century. Whatever the objective of these statements, whether in other circumstances they might have worked, they just come off as a joke. Especially coming from Kerry.”(Empty Wheel, “On America’s Spent Moral Standing“).
Our stock market took a big hit this morning too!
I have been scoffed @ here by alleged intellectuals when I said Putin is the most dangerous man in the world. He is Cold War KGB and he has pimp slapped this administration for 6 years. Our foreign policy is in shambles and our economy is a paper tiger. We have paid a steep price for incompetence and the bills are rolling in now. Great time to cut military!!
I do not see where this whole event is a surprise. Just looking at history, one would conclude Russia would push back eventually. He may be a brute, but he’s not stupid. Lot’s of money at stake there now. That’s the real deal here.
I’m not so sure I agree with you totally on this one…. Crimea is a key area for a Russia…. They still have nuclear arms in the country…. I’m thinking we should just sit this out and let it fall where it does….. There are too many oil interests and bankers that will loose everything If the US takes affirmative sides in any area….of potential conflict…..