Authoritarian Nationalist Invades To Protect Common Language Speakers While Poland Mobilizes Troops . . . Sound Familiar?

225px-Vladimir_Putin_official_portrait230px-Bundesarchiv_Bild_183-S33882,_Adolf_Hitler_retouchedWe have long discussed the authoritarianism of Vladimir Putin whose history of beating protesters and striping away press freedom was put aside briefly for the Olympic ceremonies. However, Putin appeared to be eager to stop the love fest and turn on Ukraine. For history buffs, however, there is something a bit unnerving in Putin invading a neighboring country to protect Russian-speakers who are welcoming the troops as protectors. In case the Sudetenland does not come to mind, Poland is now mobilizing troops along the border to bring the historical analogy home for the rest of the world. While I believe that this crisis will be contained and Putin is not ready for a wider war, it is no accident that the blind nationalism and authoritarianism would lead to expansionism. Ukraine is not the Sudetenland and Poland is no longer using horses to repel tanks. Putin’s desire for control of this port and Lebensraum may not be as easy to hold as it was to take.

Bundesarchiv_Bild_183-H13160,_Beim_Einmarsch_deutscher_Truppen_in_EgerPutin has already secured approval from the Duma to send in troops into Ukraine — notably not just the Crimea but the whole country. (I will note that our own Congress — both Democrats and Republicans alike — showed no more independence in approving the Iraq invasions. Indeed, some like Hillary Clinton are now frontrunners for the next presidency). Hitler cited the close ties to the region of Czechoslovakia and their common language as an excuse for the invasion while German-speakers in the country welcomed the occupation. To make the analogy even more interesting, this is the anniversary of the German invasion of March 1939.

The analogy has not escaped Poland which released the following statement: “History shows – although I don’t want to use too many historical comparisons – that those who appease all the time in order to preserve peace usually only buy a little bit of time.”

Putin’s move is a clear violation of international law. There was no serious unrest and no attack on Russian forces or territory. There was not even a basis for a preemptive attack in anticipation of such violence.

The combination of the invitation for invasion in the Crimea with today’s march in Moscow calling for invasion seems a case of history repeating itself.

170px-Russo-French_skirmish_during_Crimean_WarOf course, the jitters of the world are not helped by the fact that this is the location of the Crimean War between 1853-56 between Russia and France, Britain, the Ottoman Empire, and Sardinia. Russia lost.

I do not see a major role for the United States at the moment. Our involvement is only likely to trigger even greater insecurities that are so prominent in Russian history over its borders. While people in Congress are screaming to “get tough,” any direct intervention would be a domestic political move and serve no one’s interest in the Ukraine.

None of this history is likely to phase Putin who remains as he once was: a humorless, self-infatuated KGB Lt. Colonel. The one promising fact is the crashing of Russian stock. It will be interesting to watch, in a much more economically connected world, how the likely market pressures will affect Putin’s calculations.

147 thoughts on “Authoritarian Nationalist Invades To Protect Common Language Speakers While Poland Mobilizes Troops . . . Sound Familiar?”

  1. nick, I don’t think there are any options in this situation. Some say sanctions but Europe does not want them because of natural gas.

  2. SWM, I DO NOT propose military intervention. That is not my point. That “red line” your guy drew in Syria is coming back to haunt us. Many leaders surmised Obama was weak, that confirmed any doubters. It is not force, it is the threat of force backed up w/ actions that keep people like Assad, Putin, etc. in line. Iran and North Korea now know he’s a paper tiger. We are in a VERY bad situation. I know that is hard for you to hear. I don’t say it to bust balls. Remember, I voted for Obama in 2008. I’m just secure enough to admit I f@cked up.

  3. Without absolving the current administration from its culpability, we need to look to another Democratic President for the cause of America’s weakness in the present crisis. Bill Clinton inherited a disintegrating Soviet Union ripe for final internment. The “don’t worry be happy” President allowed the Russian nukes to proliferate and the KGB types, like Czar Vladimir, to retain too much influence.

  4. Really nick, enabler or not… there is not much either Bush could do in 2008 or Obama can do now. I don’t think anyone wants to be involved in a war with Russia so no troops or aircraft carriers should go near there. What do you propose?

  5. nick,

    Same old…same old. Always looking to start an argument, aren’t you? Always ready to label people whose opinions you can’t abide. I’d say you’re the one who’s pathological. I have never been an enabler of President Obama. In fact, I have been quite critical of him.

    BTW, did you miss this comment that I made earlier today?

    **********

    Elaine M. March 3, 2014 at 12:31 pm

    Our presidents are babes in the woods compared to Putin–who once led the KGB.

    Why Putin Plays Our Presidents for Fools
    I looked into his eyes once, and what I saw scared me half to death.
    By Ron Fournier
    3/2/14
    http://www.nationaljournal.com/white-house/why-putin-plays-our-presidents-for-fools-20140302

  6. Well, I didn’t want to bring it up again, but we’ve been pushing these revolutions on the world for a while now. Putin wasn’t going to let mob style government change go on in his backyard. Yes, just like Mexico. We certainly wouldn’t put up with that crap there (although what are the Chinese doing nosing around down there???). I’m sure the Russians have some kind of Monroe-doctrine thingy there too. But yes, Nuland was caught red-handed. I’ll be interested if this poor guy they propped up will get the Bay of Pigs treatment if Putin decides to sink his ships. “We said we would back you up… but.. ahh… sorry…” This is a big moment for Putin. He will have the high ground if (IF) he can keep the violence from happening. There’s those friendly (???) neo-nazis though… Nuland knows who they are.

  7. Something is missing from either this story or the entire set events leading up to this ‘war’: we (US) have been supplying weapons to both sides (yes, Russia has been our most valued customer. Every year, the US sends billions of dollars worth of weapons to not only Russia, but to every country in the world.).

    Why are we surprised if a war or conflict transpires? Did we only assume that UN members and other countries were going to play cops and robbers with-our-made-in-America toys?

    This has to be another form of population control (wondering how many millions of people are going to be eliminated or ‘cleansed’?).

    Someone needs to do an atricle about the dangers of Molecular Manufacturing, and how this event (Russia/Poland/Ukraine war), along with what’s going on in the middle east-don’t forget about the unrest in South America-ties into it……..

  8. Too bad you don’t bother condemning the coup that NATO and it thugs staged against the elected President. Think that one was OK? Think what the US would do if Russia and its allies staged a coup against the Mexican government. You are right that the Ukrainian nationalists are in charge and they have no love or consideration for nearly half of their citizens. From what I have read, they have banned the use of Russian, while when I was there in 1984, both languages were in use. NO more. Hell even the US uses Spanish in most things with even a smaller percentage of Spanish speakers. So it is rather disturbing to see so many on this site applauding what they would condemn in the US.

  9. Russia still holds several cards
    1. Gas supply to Europe
    2. Influence in Iran, which the US/Europe desperately want to stop from going nuclear
    3. A large land army next to small, weak, allies
    4. A populace that largely supports Putin. He has been peddling the fear of Western expansion. With Ukraine looking to join the EU, threatening Russia’s #1 naval base, and “interfering” with an area that is historically part of/close to Russia, the events on the ground confirm his propaganda. We just handed him a gift.

  10. Additionally, here is some other background that we won’t get to hear about in US newz:

    ” February 12, 2014

    Secret Tape Reveals US-backed Plot to Topple Ukraine’s Democratically-Elected President
    Caught Red-Handed
    by MIKE WHITNEY

    “In the latest debacle for the US State Department and the Obama Administration, US Assistant Secretary of State Victoria Nuland was caught on tape micro-managing Ukraine opposition party strategies with US Ambassador to Ukraine, Geoffrey Pyatt. That the Ukraine regime-change operation is to some degree being directed from Washington can no longer be denied….The taped conversation demonstrates in clear detail that while Secretary of State John Kerry decries any foreign meddling in Ukraine’s internal affairs, his State Department is virtually managing the entire process.”

    This is from Counterpunch. There is also current analysis which is helpful.

    This is a case of wheels w/in wheels. We should not so easily buy the story lines fed to us by our own corrupt administration. Putin is a evil man but he has some real good company in the “leadership” of the US.

  11. When will the coddlers of Obama stop saying” Yeah but Bush, Chebey..” Enablers are pathological.

  12. Here is some other background that we won’t get to hear about in US newz:

    ” February 12, 2014

    Secret Tape Reveals US-backed Plot to Topple Ukraine’s Democratically-Elected President
    Caught Red-Handed
    by MIKE WHITNEY

    “In the latest debacle for the US State Department and the Obama Administration, US Assistant Secretary of State Victoria Nuland was caught on tape micro-managing Ukraine opposition party strategies with US Ambassador to Ukraine, Geoffrey Pyatt. That the Ukraine regime-change operation is to some degree being directed from Washington can no longer be denied….The taped conversation demonstrates in clear detail that while Secretary of State John Kerry decries any foreign meddling in Ukraine’s internal affairs, his State Department is virtually managing the entire process.”

    This is from Counterpunch. There is also current analysis which is helpful.

    This is a case of wheels w/in wheels. We should not so easily buy the story lines fed to us by our own corrupt administration. Putin is a evil bastard but he has some real good company in the “leadership” of the US..

  13. There is a bigger picture in the Crimea. When Russia conquered the Crimea, it became Russia’s frontier. Catherine the Great then invited foreigners to settle in the frontier, motivated less by any generosity, more by the desire to have a buffer, a DEW LINE, against foreign enemies. By the late 1800’s, after far more than a century, things began to go south for the settlers who had made quite a name for themselves as wealthy farmers and entrepreneurs (my own ancestors), eventually drawing the envy of the Bolsheviks, who grew out of Russia’s emancipation of surfs, predating our own emancipation of slaves, forcing settlers from Russia to the US and other places, the remaining settlers, if not executed during the Russian Revolution, were deported to Siberia or starved during the Great Famine under Stalin. It is not known how many of my ancestors had perished at the hands of the Bolsheviks, the revolution and the USSR, but the fall of the USSR has made it possible for us to find a handful of long lost surviving family members in Siberia. It is a similar story in Ukraine and the Crimea for other people who can and will never forget the horrors of communism. For these reasons, together with the will of the people of the world, Putin will never ever prevail. Like all bullies when overcome by fear, he will back down. The Crimea should never revert back to Russia any more than California should revert back to Mexico just because Hispanics have become a majority in the “peninsula” of LA.

  14. Russian occupation of Crimea, is a peaceful gesture compared to the WMD Iraq attack less by GWB and his band of war mongers. EU needs Russian gas, so they will talk tough but not act at all. US has no legitimate interest in Ukraine, so it will speak loudly and carry a small stick. Ukraine will agree with Russian ‘proposals’ and this will end without any large conflict…..if cooler heads prevail.

  15. Sarah Palin didn’t know what she was talking about in 2008 any more than she does now. Of course Putin is an old cold warrior who will maintain his KGB mindset until he dies. It doesn’t require any intellectual effort to understand that. However, there are significant economic sanctions that could be brought to bear against Russia, and it is time to begin imposing them. Putin needs to understand that is isn’t 1956 and the Crimea isn’t Hungary.

  16. Our presidents are babes in the woods compared to Putin–who once led the KGB.

    *****

    Why Putin Plays Our Presidents for Fools
    I looked into his eyes once, and what I saw scared me half to death.
    By Ron Fournier
    3/2/14
    http://www.nationaljournal.com/white-house/why-putin-plays-our-presidents-for-fools-20140302

    Excerpt:
    In June 2001, George W. Bush and Vladimir Putin ended their first face-to-face meeting with an outdoor news conference beneath a craggy mountaintop in Slovenia. “Is this a man that Americans can trust?” I asked Bush as Putin glared at me.

    “Yes,” Bush replied, before allowing Putin to answer a separate question. A few minutes later, the American president elaborated: “I looked the man in the eye. I found him to be very straightforward and trustworthy. We had a very good dialogue. I was able to get a sense of his soul, a man deeply committed to his country and the best interests of his country,” Bush said, adding a few sentence later, “I wouldn’t have invited him to my ranch if I didn’t trust him.”

    While Bush spoke, Putin fixed his eyes on mine—a look so cold and dark that I wondered whether those eyes were, for some unfortunate Cold Warriors, the last thing they saw.

    Disclosure: I don’t pretend to read people as well as Bush, nor am I a foreign policy expert. Just three months after the Slovenia summit, Putin cooperated with Bush during the 9/11 attacks, and did so more broadly in the months that followed. Perhaps Bush saw goodness in Putin. And perhaps I spotted something else, because Russia’s advances on Georgia in 2008 and on Ukraine today suggest that Putin is an easy guy to misjudge.

Comments are closed.