“Cosmos” Host Neil deGrasse Tyson Speaks Out about the News Media, Flat Earthers, Science Deniers, Climate Change Skeptics, Religion, and Dogma

NeildeGrasseTyson - CopySubmitted by Elaine Magliaro, Weekend Contributor

Neil deGrasse Tyson is an astrophysicist and director of the Natural History Museum’s Hayden Planetarium in New York City. He is also the host of Fox Networks’ new science series Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey. Last Sunday, Tyson appeared on CNN’s Reliable Sources program and spoke with Brian Stelter. During the program, Tyson talked about “the hypocrisy of people dismissing scientific theory while simultaneously embracing the fruits of scientific discovery ‘that we so take for granted today.’”

Tyson said that our civilization “is built on the innovation of scientists and technologists and engineers who have shaped everything that we so take for granted today. So some of the science deniers or science haters, these are people who are telling that to you while they are on their mobile phone. They are saying, ‘I don’t like science. Oh, GPS just told us to go left. So it’s time for people to sit back and reassess what role science has actually played in our lives. And learn how to embrace that going forward, because without it, we will just regress back into the caves.”

Stelter asked Tyson if he felt that the news media should feel a responsibility to portray science correctly—especially with regard to controversial issues such as climate change. Tyson said he thought the news media was wrong to give equal time to the “flat-earthers.” He thinks the media “should stop trying to ‘balance’ the debate on scientific issues by hosting people who deny science.”

Tyson said, “The media has to sort of come out of this ethos that I think was in principle a good one, but it doesn’t really apply in science. The principle was, whatever story you give, you have to give the opposing view. And then you can be viewed as balanced.” He continued, “You don’t talk about the spherical Earth with NASA, and then say let’s give equal time to the flat Earthers. Plus, science is not there for you to cherry pick.”

Tyson added, “The good thing about science is that it’s true whether or not you believe in it. Alright? I guess you can decide whether or not to believe in it, but that doesn’t change the reality of an emergent scientific truth.”

The great American science divide (CNN)

Recently, Tyson spoke about the new version of Carl Sagan’s Cosmos series on the Brian Lehrer Show on WNYC. Tyson said that science and religion should not be painted as being “diametrically opposed to each other.” He said there were many scientists who believe in God. He added, “The issue there is not religion versus non-religion or religion versus science, the issue there is ideas that are different versus dogma.”

Tyson explained, “If you start using your scripture, your religious text as a source of your science, that’s where you run into problems, and there is no example of someone reading their scripture and saying ‘I have a prediction about the world that no one knows yet because this gave me insight.’” He continued, “Enlightened religious people know this, and don’t try to use the Bible as a textbook.”

Chris Mooney of Mother Jones said that Tyson has emphasized that the stance of the science series Cosmos is anti-dogma—not anti-religion. Tyson was quoted as saying, “Any time you have a doctrine where that is the truth that you assert, and that what you call the truth is unassailable, you’ve got doctrine, you’ve got dogma on your hands. And so Cosmos is…an offering of science, and a reminder that dogma does not advance science; it actually regresses it.”

Katie Valentine of ThinkProgress noted that Tyson had spoken previously “about the need for the public to accept scientific facts rather than the talking points of politicians.” According to Valentine, the astrophysicist said in 2011 that climate change deniers should “be mature enough to recognize something can be true even if you don’t like the consequences of it. That’s what it means to be a mature adult.” Valentine also reported that while appearing on CNN in February, Tyson said that “he hopes America doesn’t wait until climate change has drastically changed the Earth’s landscape to realize that our policies haven’t done enough to prepare us.”

Tyson said that he doesn’t know what to say “when politicians start analyzing the science. “Are we going to wait until the coastlines get redrawn as the glaciers melt off of Antarctica and Greenland?”

Good question, Mr. Tyson, good question.

SOURCES

Neil deGrasse Tyson tells CNN: Stop giving ‘equal time to the flat Earthers’ (Raw Story)

Neil DeGrasse Tyson To Science Deniers: ‘Science Is Not There For You To Cherry Pick’ (ThinkProgress)

Neil deGrasse Tyson Chastises Media For Giving ‘Flat Earthers’ Equal Time in the Climate Change Debate (AlterNet)

Neil DeGrasse Tyson: ‘Enlightened Religious People Don’t Use The Bible As A Textbook’ (Huffington Post)

Neil deGrasse Tyson on Cosmos, How Science Got Cool, and Why He Doesn’t Debate Denier: The host of the stunning new Fox series wants you to understand how science works. (Mother Jones)

697 thoughts on ““Cosmos” Host Neil deGrasse Tyson Speaks Out about the News Media, Flat Earthers, Science Deniers, Climate Change Skeptics, Religion, and Dogma”

  1. Skip: I’m holding out one last hope for a sensible, concisely reasoned answer from either you or Shillte – not so much from Byron.

    But tell me this: What is the harm with reducing human green house gas (GHG) production?

    Why should we run a pipeline that is certain to rupture over one of the most valuable aquifers in the world?

    If you could answer these two questions without mentioning Cassisus Clay I would appreciate it.

    1. RTC – great questions. As you know, I believe that we have the technology right now to “really” take us into the 21st century and get us off of fossil fuels and nuclear. That this technology however, will be suppressed from getting to the market for some unknown period of time in the future, as they have done with cold fusion since 1989. There is substantive material evidence that proves cold fusion is now viable and has been suppressed. The question; is it still being suppressed and for how long will this continue. I don’t know but while speaking to some of those involved, there is still great concern and I have not seen the E-Cat, Hyperion or any other technologies being sold in any material quantities.

      As we have seen with Fukushima, it is erroneous to contend that there are guaranties with any relationship with nature that manmade structures machines, damns etc. are 100% safe and secure. We cannot obviously guaranty that there will not be a pipeline leak or if a leak would effect our environment. I don’t even really like dams as water tends to then seek the next lowest point and they do drastically effect the environment both a t the dam location and down stream. Another Issue though.

      Unless you still believe that Christopher Columbus discovered America; hint the Native American’s had long been here, you should know that government is and has been in the pockets of Big Business since at least the Civil War and that they, neither Government nor Big Business will likely be the ones that leads us into the next age of prosperity and enlightenment.

      So RTC, What is the harm with reducing human green house gas (GHG) production? Nothing we should do it, if not just for the pollution elements of the situation. Why should we run a pipeline that is certain to rupture over one of the most valuable aquifers in the world? Because that is the desire of Big business and government even though there are better alternatives today.

      I’ve decided to put together a group and try to help with this even more. We should have a website up in a couple of days. Anyone interested in joining or assisting in any way, contact me. I’m plastered all over the web.

  2. Nick: Is introvert another word for anti-social. Or shut-in?
    —————————————————————-
    Byron: It’s hard to understand you when you breathe through your mouth. There’s more to wildlife population dynamics than you would think, if you ever thought. And don’t fool yourself, backyards have the potential to serve as habitat for a wide range of wildlife, provided they have the right plants. I recommend Doug Tallamy’s, “Bringing Nature Home”, as a starting point.
    BTW: It’s great for improving property values.

  3. Elaine: I remember seeing a clip of Stephen Jay Gould about twenty years ago where he was explaining the trouble with the Christian Fundamentals and their efforts to deny the theory of evolution.

    He said that the effective length of a career for a researcher was about twenty years; unfortunately, it turned out to be somewhat shorter for him, but that’s about what he had it pegged at. Having to address the constant denials of what was so plainly obvious in the fossil record took valuable time away from the scientist to do research.

    1. annie – you are a one note band.

      RTR – I personally see no reason that you should not shut off your personal expulsion of greenhouse gases. I am behind that 100%

      I had a recognized wildlife preserve in my backyard, but had to clean it up to sell the house.

  4. Evangelicals Urge Obama To Discuss Climate Change With Pope Francis
    By Jack Jenkins, Guest Contributor
    March 19, 2014
    http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2014/03/19/3416401/evangelicals-petition-white-house/

    Excerpt:
    A group of faith-based environmental advocates are encouraging thousands of religious Americans to sign a petition asking President Barack Obama to discuss climate change with Pope Francis during their upcoming meeting on March 27.

    The online petition, which is posted on the White House’s “We the People” website, was created by Richard Cizik, head of the New Evangelical Partnership for the Common Good, a progressive evangelical Christian organization. In addition to asking President Obama to invite the pope to visit one of America’s national parks and monuments, the petition makes the religious case for action on climate change.

    “We ask that President Obama give the Pope a photograph of one of our majestic parks or new national monuments as an example of America’s proud tradition of conservation leadership, and discuss the sacred obligation of people across faiths to protect God’s creation,” the petition read, adding, “Conservation is a moral responsibility.”

  5. It does appear the malcontents aren’t happy w/ their little echo chamber and cowardly return. Sad.

  6. Looks like somebody is mad because they can’t contribute to a discussion intelligently.

  7. nicky, you especially should take this to heart.

    Better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to speak out and remove all doubt.
    Abraham Lincoln

  8. I can see why some people don’t comment much and just give links. I was taught to keep your mouth shut unless you had something to say.

  9. Neil deGrasse Tyson Squashes Creationist Argument Against Science on National TV
    Watching the Christian Right struggle to counter “Cosmos” each week is like watching a frightened, cornered animal that knows it’s about to die.
    By Dan Arel
    http://www.alternet.org/news-amp-politics/neil-degrasse-tyson-squashed-creationist-argument-against-science-national-tv

    Excerpt:
    March 17, 2014 |

    Episode two of “Cosmos,” hosted by Neil deGrasse Tyson, aired this week. Toward the end of the program, Tyson made one of the best statements one could hope would sink into the minds of young and old viewers alike and—most importantly—creationists.

    The astrophysicist proclaimed that there is no shame in admitting you do not know something and that the real shame is pretending to know everything.

    Just as we saw Ken Ham do when debating evolution with Bill Nye, Ham was able to claim he knew everything Nye honestly claimed he did not know by simply saying, “Bill, I do know how X happened, it’s all explained in this book,” referencing the Bible. Ham is ashamed about the fact that he cannot admit what he does not know. Instead, he would rather go on pretending to know things he does not know, which is the definition of faith.

    Ham even claimed he believes in his views so strongly that nothing can change his mind — a sure sign of someone who believes to know things they do not know and does not care about finding the truth, only sticking to what he wants to believe.

    During this week’s episode, Tyson discussed the evolution of the eye, something declared for years by creationists as unexplainable by evolution, and thus evidence that life must be intelligently designed. Tyson masterfully explained how the eye evolved and how well scientists understand this evolution.

    The “Cosmos” host also touched on how many species have evolved an eye, but did leave out the fact that there are over 40 known independent eye evolutions, something that very clearly discredits any intelligent design.

    However, these facts mean nothing to creationists. Not long after “Cosmos” aired, Jay W. Richards, a senior fellow at the Discovery Institute (DI), a non-science, religious based foundation that fights to discredit evolution and replace it with faith based creationism, tweeted:

    On eye evolution, the #Cosmos editors again failed to do a Google Search[.]

    Richards’ Twitter missive linked to a Discovery Institute PDF download that supposedly debunks the evolution of the eye claim. Yet the PDF is nothing more than praise for the Christian Right pundit Ann Coulter and a lambasting of Richard Dawkins, DI’s public enemy number one.

    Watching the Christian Right, especially the creationist wing, struggle to counter “Cosmos” each week is like watching a frightened, cornered animal that knows it is about to die. What else could explain the weekly grasping at straws, and the unremitting blasting of social media links meant to reel their following back in as their eyes are opened to the scientific method’s greatness.

    1. Elaine quoted another propaganda piece: “The astrophysicist proclaimed that there is no shame in admitting you do not know something and that the real shame is pretending to know everything. … During this week’s episode, Tyson discussed the evolution of the eye…”

      This guy keeps digging his own grave deeper and deeper. How much you want to bet that he did not discuss the problems of convergent evolution of the eye? For example, did he point out how much the eye of the squid is like the human eye? What are the chances of that evolving entirely on its own along a completely separate evolutionary tree? How many times do people have to be told that telling a good story is not science. Science is proving it has happened. Science is about what is, not what might have happened. Science is about reality.

      Here’s another embarrassing quote from Tyson about the possibility of life on one of Saturn’s moons, Titan:

      “When it rains on Titan, it rains methane. Could there be life in Titan’s hydrocarbon lakes? That might depend on your definition of life: It would probably be quite different. You’d have creatures that inhale nitrogen instead of oxygen from the atmosphere, and exhale methane instead of carbon dioxide, and maybe use acetylene instead of sugar as an energy source. Perhaps one day we’ll send a mission to Titan to find out.”

      http://www.latimes.com/entertainment/tv/showtracker/la-et-st-cosmos-recap-20140314,0,194326.story#ixzz2wiK38Q00

      Really? This is the kind of story telling Tyson engages in. This is not science. We are going to send a mission to Titan and discover life? These stories use to be told about Mars. I guess the fantasy story tellers have to keep moving out further and further from earth to make the stories more believable.

      Here’s another blatantly false characterization concerning science:

      “Tyson tells us that evolution is a theory, but what science means by theory is fact. It happened. It’s as real as gravity. It can be described literally and now rendered literally.”

      The nature of inductive inference, which is logic arguing from specific observations to a general framework of understanding, results in conclusions that are always tentative. Therefore, while deductive inference leads to proof, inductive inference, which is what theories are, always lead to tentative conclusions. Graduate students in science are hammered with the concept that all conclusions of science are tentative and subject to change. It is the very nature of the statistical analysis used in hypothesis testing that one might make a Type I or Type II error even when everything is done correctly. For most situations, that chance is about 5% for being wrong. Now we have Tyson undoing all this understanding. High school teachers unfortunately will believe this series. It will lead to bad public education for years to come. I use to teach science to high school teachers during summer seminars at the university, and it was so difficult to get them to understand hypothesis testing, statistics, or even just what a null hypothesis is. My children suffer the same kind of poor quality education in public schools. This series will aggravate the problem even more because it obviously is not being produced by scientists but rather by so-called science educators who dumb down the information for presentational reasons.

      Tyson talks out of both sides of his mouth, claiming there is no shame in admitting you don’t know something, but then claiming he does know it about evolution. No wonder they have an astrophysicist present this indoctrination piece on biological evolution.

  10. Have you noticed that in addition to adds that break up the program, the cable companies now present a logo for other programs or product, usually at the bottom of the screen, throughout much of the program.

    Even when you should be able to see the program the cable company is monetizing what you have already paid for. It would seem that if you pay to see the program, the cable company ought to at least give you a clear view of it.

    Also the cable company charges you for 24 hours of programming but on many channels, for many hours the programs are infomercials.

    How many hours of actual news and entertainment do cable companies actually provide in a month?

    And how many times has your movie channel run the same movie this year?

    How many times this year have you seen The Departed, one of the Godfather series, one of the Rockie series, a transformer movie, Woody slaying zombies, or Mel Gibson beating the English?

    Now these are all truly great entertainment. But how many times can you watch them with out reciting the dialog a beat ahead of the character on the screen?

  11. Last night my girlfriend and I finally decided that we are tired of being ripped off by the TV cable providers and we’ve tried three prominent ones all over the last 5 or 6 years.

    Since all the “progressives” on this site are always complaining about big bad corporations, wages, bla bla bla, I thought that it would be a good idea to get a boycott going. Boycotts and passive resistance has been two the most successful means of creating real change throughout history. You want to shake up Wall Street a little. Put down your stupid signs and start using your brains. It doesn’t have to be for very long, just a well coordinated.

    Here is the ultimatum and why:
    1. Either give us free television programing with advertising or;
    2. Give us advertising free programing, if we want to pay for it.

    Why: In all do respect to the program creators, if you take away the sales programs like beautiful butts in 4 weeks, etc, children programs, network programs and PBS that are free anyway, the religious channels, HBO and the sports networks which you pay extra for, there are only a handful of programs that are worth a crap. The History Channel, Smithsonian, TLC, Nat Geo, Fuel etc.

    The advertising on some of these programs feel like they are 50% of the programing.

    Come on, don’t tell me you can’t do this for a week or two. Read a book, have sex with your favorite pet or do something constructive.

  12. RTC:

    ” Wildlife Population Dynamics”

    you can actually take a course in that subject? Food, prey/predator, environment and reproductive rates.

    You paid money to have someone “educate” you on that type of thing? I bet the class on the backyard ecosystem was fascinating. Is that when you learned that insects are attracted to light and spiders spin webs to catch food?

Comments are closed.