Submitted by Elaine Magliaro, Weekend Contributor
Neil deGrasse Tyson is an astrophysicist and director of the Natural History Museum’s Hayden Planetarium in New York City. He is also the host of Fox Networks’ new science series Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey. Last Sunday, Tyson appeared on CNN’s Reliable Sources program and spoke with Brian Stelter. During the program, Tyson talked about “the hypocrisy of people dismissing scientific theory while simultaneously embracing the fruits of scientific discovery ‘that we so take for granted today.’”
Tyson said that our civilization “is built on the innovation of scientists and technologists and engineers who have shaped everything that we so take for granted today. So some of the science deniers or science haters, these are people who are telling that to you while they are on their mobile phone. They are saying, ‘I don’t like science. Oh, GPS just told us to go left. So it’s time for people to sit back and reassess what role science has actually played in our lives. And learn how to embrace that going forward, because without it, we will just regress back into the caves.”
Stelter asked Tyson if he felt that the news media should feel a responsibility to portray science correctly—especially with regard to controversial issues such as climate change. Tyson said he thought the news media was wrong to give equal time to the “flat-earthers.” He thinks the media “should stop trying to ‘balance’ the debate on scientific issues by hosting people who deny science.”
Tyson said, “The media has to sort of come out of this ethos that I think was in principle a good one, but it doesn’t really apply in science. The principle was, whatever story you give, you have to give the opposing view. And then you can be viewed as balanced.” He continued, “You don’t talk about the spherical Earth with NASA, and then say let’s give equal time to the flat Earthers. Plus, science is not there for you to cherry pick.”
Tyson added, “The good thing about science is that it’s true whether or not you believe in it. Alright? I guess you can decide whether or not to believe in it, but that doesn’t change the reality of an emergent scientific truth.”
The great American science divide (CNN)
Recently, Tyson spoke about the new version of Carl Sagan’s Cosmos series on the Brian Lehrer Show on WNYC. Tyson said that science and religion should not be painted as being “diametrically opposed to each other.” He said there were many scientists who believe in God. He added, “The issue there is not religion versus non-religion or religion versus science, the issue there is ideas that are different versus dogma.”
Tyson explained, “If you start using your scripture, your religious text as a source of your science, that’s where you run into problems, and there is no example of someone reading their scripture and saying ‘I have a prediction about the world that no one knows yet because this gave me insight.’” He continued, “Enlightened religious people know this, and don’t try to use the Bible as a textbook.”
Chris Mooney of Mother Jones said that Tyson has emphasized that the stance of the science series Cosmos is anti-dogma—not anti-religion. Tyson was quoted as saying, “Any time you have a doctrine where that is the truth that you assert, and that what you call the truth is unassailable, you’ve got doctrine, you’ve got dogma on your hands. And so Cosmos is…an offering of science, and a reminder that dogma does not advance science; it actually regresses it.”
Katie Valentine of ThinkProgress noted that Tyson had spoken previously “about the need for the public to accept scientific facts rather than the talking points of politicians.” According to Valentine, the astrophysicist said in 2011 that climate change deniers should “be mature enough to recognize something can be true even if you don’t like the consequences of it. That’s what it means to be a mature adult.” Valentine also reported that while appearing on CNN in February, Tyson said that “he hopes America doesn’t wait until climate change has drastically changed the Earth’s landscape to realize that our policies haven’t done enough to prepare us.”
Tyson said that he doesn’t know what to say “when politicians start analyzing the science. “Are we going to wait until the coastlines get redrawn as the glaciers melt off of Antarctica and Greenland?”
Good question, Mr. Tyson, good question.
SOURCES
Neil deGrasse Tyson tells CNN: Stop giving ‘equal time to the flat Earthers’ (Raw Story)
Neil DeGrasse Tyson To Science Deniers: ‘Science Is Not There For You To Cherry Pick’ (ThinkProgress)
Neil DeGrasse Tyson: ‘Enlightened Religious People Don’t Use The Bible As A Textbook’ (Huffington Post)
paul
discussion over, you lost. Petes corollary to Godwins Law; whoever is the first to compare someone to Saul Alinsky has run out of anything meaningful to say.
(anybody can play calvinball)
RTC,
I had the great fortune to hear Gould speak many years ago when the National Council of Science Teachers held its annual convention in Boston. He was a brilliant man…and a very engaging speaker. I’ve read a number of his books–including The Mismeasure of Man, Hen’s Teeth and Horse’s Toes, and The Panda’s Thumb.
Of course, we have science experts here who think they know/pretend they know more than Gould.
Elaine – Gould was controversial at his own school and in his own discipline. And your backhanded snide comments do not help the discussion move forward. What you have to realize, Elaine, is that for science to properly work, it has to be constantly tested. There are serious problems with the Theory of Evolution which is why Gould proposed his hypothesis, hoping to explain the problems. Personally, I think if you add Chaos Theory to the Theory of Evolution it closes some of the holes, but not all of them. I am surprised you missed reading his “Male Nipples and Clitoral Ripples” I understand it is a page-turner. 🙂
Shillte: You’ve added nothing to debate
RTS – How would you know if I have added to the debate? You only attack!!! Alinsky is alive and well this morning. Marginalize, marginalize, marginalize.
Byron: Sounds like you’re doing an outstanding job with your yard. Keep up the good work. The only advice anyone could give you would be to ensure that as many of the plants in your yard are native to your area because those are the best food sources for pollinators and birds.
Thanks Elaine, this was my good read for the day, although I should point out that Gould was a well known commie liberal.;) No doubt this article will set a certain god-fearing theist’s teeth on edge.
Seriously, these are thoughts to consider when it comes to debating climate change.
Interesting bits:
How Reagan’s handlers included Christian FundaMental themes in his speeches as part of their effort to co-opt the movement. A convenient way to dumb down the country to ensure a more pliable – or gullible – electorate.
Gould’s contention that a ” ‘fact’ can only mean ‘confirmed to such a degree that it would be perverse to withhold provisional assent.’ ” How different that sounds from claiming such confirmation is only a “best guess”.
RTC
Elaine: I remember seeing a clip of Stephen Jay Gould about twenty years ago where he was explaining the trouble with the Christian Fundamentals and their efforts to deny the theory of evolution.
*****
Evolution as Fact and Theory
by Stephen Jay Gould
http://www.stephenjaygould.org/library/gould_fact-and-theory.html
Excerpt:
The basic attack of modern creationists falls apart on two general counts before we even reach the supposed factual details of their assault against evolution. First, they play upon a vernacular misunderstanding of the word “theory” to convey the false impression that we evolutionists are covering up the rotten core of our edifice. Second, they misuse a popular philosophy of science to argue that they are behaving scientifically in attacking evolution. Yet the same philosophy demonstrates that their own belief is not science, and that “scientific creationism” is a meaningless and self-contradictory phrase, an example of what Orwell called “newspeak.”
In the American vernacular, “theory” often means “imperfect fact”—part of a hierarchy of confidence running downhill from fact to theory to hypothesis to guess. Thus creationists can (and do) argue: evolution is “only” a theory, and intense debate now rages about many aspects of the theory. If evolution is less than a fact, and scientists can’t even make up their minds about the theory, then what confidence can we have in it? Indeed, President Reagan echoed this argument before an evangelical group in Dallas when he said (in what I devoutly hope was campaign rhetoric): “Well, it is a theory. It is a scientific theory only, and it has in recent years been challenged in the world of science—that is, not believed in the scientific community to be as infallible as it once was.”
Well, evolution is a theory. It is also a fact. And facts and theories are different things, not rungs in a hierarchy of increasing certainty. Facts are the world’s data. Theories are structures of ideas that explain and interpret facts. Facts do not go away when scientists debate rival theories to explain them. Einstein’s theory of gravitation replaced Newton’s, but apples did not suspend themselves in mid-air, pending the outcome. And humans evolved from apelike ancestors whether they did so by Darwin’s proposed mechanism or by some other, yet to be discovered.
Moreover, “fact” does not mean “absolute certainty.” The final proofs of logic and mathematics flow deductively from stated premises and achieve certainty only because they are not about the empirical world. Evolutionists make no claim for perpetual truth, though creationists often do (and then attack us for a style of argument that they themselves favor). In science, “fact” can only mean “confirmed to such a degree that it would be perverse to withhold provisional assent.” I suppose that apples might start to rise tomorrow, but the possibility does not merit equal time in physics classrooms.
Evolutionists have been clear about this distinction between fact and theory from the very beginning, if only because we have always acknowledged how far we are from completely understanding the mechanisms (theory) by which evolution (fact) occurred. Darwin continually emphasized the difference between his two great and separate accomplishments: establishing the fact of evolution, and proposing a theory—natural selection—to explain the mechanism of evolution. He wrote in The Descent of Man: “I had two distinct objects in view; firstly, to show that species had not been separately created, and secondly, that natural selection had been the chief agent of change. . . . Hence if I have erred in . . . having exaggerated its [natural selection’s] power . . . I have at least, as I hope, done good service in aiding to overthrow the dogma of separate creations.”
Thus Darwin acknowledged the provisional nature of natural selection while affirming the fact of evolution. The fruitful theoretical debate that Darwin initiated has never ceased. From the 1940s through the 1960s, Darwin’s own theory of natural selection did achieve a temporary hegemony that it never enjoyed in his lifetime. But renewed debate characterizes our decade, and, while no biologist questions the importance of natural selection, many doubt its ubiquity. In particular, many evolutionists argue that substantial amounts of genetic change may not be subject to natural selection and may spread through the populations at random. Others are challenging Darwin’s linking of natural selection with gradual, imperceptible change through all intermediary degrees; they are arguing that most evolutionary events may occur far more rapidly than Darwin envisioned.
Scientists regard debates on fundamental issues of theory as a sign of intellectual health and a source of excitement. Science is—and how else can I say it?—most fun when it plays with interesting ideas, examines their implications, and recognizes that old information might be explained in surprisingly new ways. Evolutionary theory is now enjoying this uncommon vigor. Yet amidst all this turmoil no biologist has been lead to doubt the fact that evolution occurred; we are debating how it happened. We are all trying to explain the same thing: the tree of evolutionary descent linking all organisms by ties of genealogy. Creationists pervert and caricature this debate by conveniently neglecting the common conviction that underlies it, and by falsely suggesting that evolutionists now doubt the very phenomenon we are struggling to understand.
A scientific theory summarizes a hypothesis or group of hypotheses that have been supported with repeated testing. If enough evidence accumulates to support a hypothesis, it moves to the next step—known as a theory—in the scientific method and becomes accepted as a valid explanation of a phenomenon.
scientific theoryPin It A scientific theory summarizes a hypothesis or group of hypotheses that have been supported with repeated testing.
Credit: alphaspirit/ShutterStockView full size image
When used in non-scientific context, the word “theory” implies that something is unproven or speculative. As used in science, however, a theory is an explanation or model based on observation, experimentation, and reasoning, especially one that has been tested and confirmed as a general principle helping to explain and predict natural phenomena.
Any scientific theory must be based on a careful and rational examination of the facts. In the scientific method, there is a clear distinction between facts, which can be observed and/or measured, and theories, which are scientists’ explanations and interpretations of the facts. Scientists can have various interpretations of the outcomes of experiments and observations, but the facts, which are the cornerstone of the scientific method, do not change.
A theory must include statements that have observational consequences. A good theory, like Newton’s theory of gravity, has unity, which means it consists of a limited number of problem-solving strategies that can be applied to a wide range of scientific circumstances. Another feature of a good theory is that it formed from a number of hypotheses that can be tested independently.
A scientific theory is not the end result of the scientific method; theories can be proven or rejected, just like hypotheses. Theories can be improved or modified as more information is gathered so that the accuracy of the prediction becomes greater over time.
Theories are foundations for furthering scientific knowledge and for putting the information gathered to practical use. Scientists use theories to develop inventions or find a cure for a disease.
A few theories do become laws, but theories and laws have separate and distinct roles in the scientific method. A theory is an explanation of an observed phenomenon, while a law is a description of an observed phenomenon.
———-
The problem with the Theory of Evolution is that testing is included in selected areas. My favorite paper title in the area is Stephen Gould’s “Male Nipples and Clitoral Ripples”.
rafflaw,
How about a Pliny the Tiny?
pete,
I read about Atanus yesterday. Maybe she’s got the answer for climate change: God’s mad about gays and same-sex marriage–so he’s warming the planet!
😉
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/03/19/susanne-atanus-congress-_n_4993555.html?utm_hp_ref=fb&src=sp&comm_ref=false
paul
reincarnation
Tina, there are a few of us who disagree with you 🙂
I am familiar with a lot of Roman and Greek plays and I do not remember that one. I am curious as to how you know the length of the run.
Man, and what a home run Cosmos is, too, right? Good for him for nailing that gig, lol. Its considerably better than the original, IMO.
I seem to recall there was an early roman play called “Pliny in the Middle”. It had a short run.
Byron
about a month ago i took a nap on the couch and woke up to the dog and cats going nuts. i thought it was because i had slept through their feeding time. while prepping the cat food i realized the animal by my foot was not a cat but a possum.
fun with nature
Chuck,
Was there a Pliny the Oldest? 🙂
rafflaw – it is Pliny the Elder.
Byron,
I suspect that variations of that quote have been made by many people over the years….or centuries. In fact, it reminds me of some of the things written by Pliny the Younger. And speaking of Pliny, I remember reading somewhere that a friend asked Pliny the Elder why there wasn’t a statue of him in a prominent place.
He replied, “I would rather people ask, ‘Why isn’t there a statue of Pliny,’ than, ‘Why is there a statute of Pliny.’ “
RTC:
I plant fruit trees, grapes, blackberrys, sunflowers, marigolds, and milo, millet and peanuts in the backyard and make brush piles and place gourds around the yard for bird houses. In addition my wife puts out wool for the birds and squirrels. And I need to put up some bat houses.
I imagine there are other things to do but we have fox, turkey, hawks, squirrels, chipmonks, mice, shrews, groundhogs and assorted birds in our yard. We also have plenty of snakes and lizards because we have wood piles and mulch piles for them to lay their eggs in.
I probably dont have it covered to the extent your reference has but stuff like this was being done by my grandmother when I was a boy so it isnt really new.
Anonymous
“nicky, you especially should take this to heart.
Better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to speak out and remove all doubt.
Abraham Lincoln”
I think you need to take that quotation to heart.
“The wonderful Yale Book of Quotations (YBQ) investigated the saying and presented the earliest known attribution to Lincoln in Golden Book magazine in November 1931: 23
Better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to speak and to remove all doubt.
— ABRAHAM LINCOLN.
Since Lincoln died in 1865 this is a suspiciously late instance, and it provides very weak evidence. Further, YBQ indicated that the phrase was in use years before this date with no attachment to Lincoln. The ascription of the saying to Mark Twain is also dubious.
When Ken Burns filmed a documentary about Mark Twain in 2001 a companion book was released, and it listed the following version of the quote in a section titled “What Twain Didn’t Say”: 4
Better to keep your mouth shut and appear stupid than to open it and remove all doubt.
The earliest known appearance of the adage discovered by QI occurred in a book titled “Mrs. Goose, Her Book” by Maurice Switzer. The publication date was 1907 and the copyright notice was 1906. The book was primarily filled with clever nonsense verse, and the phrasing in this early version was slightly different: 5
It is better to remain silent at the risk of being thought a fool, than to talk and remove all doubt of it.
Most of the humorous content of “Mrs. Goose, Her Book” has the imprint of originality, and based on currently available data QI believes that Maurice Switzer is the leading candidate for originator of the expression. This 1906 citation was also given in “The Dictionary of Modern Proverbs”, an indispensable new reference work from Yale University Press. ”
http://quoteinvestigator.com/2010/05/17/remain-silent/
The rest is pretty interesting as well. If you are going to insult someone, at least have the decency to do it without ambiguity.
You stop citing them, I stop singing, deal?