Respectfully submitted by Lawrence E. Rafferty (rafflaw)- Weekend Contributor
It has happened again. A mass killing at the hands of a person armed with knives and three semi-automatic handguns and 400 rounds of ammunition. This time the alleged shooter stabbed three to death and then went on a shooting spree that ended with at least three more dead and a total of 8 injured/wounded people from gunshot wounds and 5 more injured by his knives or by being hit by his car.
The family of the alleged shooter requested a police intervention prior to the killings and the police did speak with the young man, but they did not have cause to search his apartment. The police had other interactions with Elliot Rodger, age 22 and he later expressed concern that they did not find his weapons.
“Deputies also encountered Rodger earlier this year when he accused a roommate of stealing three candles, and in another case in which he claimed to be beaten but deputies suspected he was the aggressor.
Rodger detailed his plans in an extensive 141-page manifesto released Saturday and said he narrowly missed being found out when the officers knocked on his door.
Rodger expressed relief that his apartment wasn’t searched because they would have found his weapons and his writings. When recounting his thinking about whether he should kill his father, Rodger expressed a sliver of acknowledgment that his plot, which included killing other family members, was wrong.
“I didn’t want it to come to this,” Rodger said. “I desperately wanted a way out.” He then immediately talks about his mother giving him a new car — a BMW coupe.” USA Today
This latest shooting spree is not the reason for this article. It is merely one more example of why common sense gun control measures that could save innocent lives are needed. When recent polls seem to indicate that a majority of Americans agree that common sense gun control regulations are needed, the NRA continually stands in the way of possibly life saving legislation. However, the NRA is not just working to prevent any gun control legislation from proceeding, it is also standing in the way of attempts to have the Center for Disease Control (CDC) do research on gun prevention measures.
“But this past week we’ve seen the other side of the coin. How the NRA works to suppress information that would lead to treating a public health catastrophe that claims over 30,000 lives per year and injures over 100,000 as that very thing, while fighting to ensure we have as little access to information as possible that might help save lives.
The simple fact is, much like with their friends on the right from the tobacco industry to the oil industry to the megachurch, science and information are the enemies of the NRA. They have proven they will do whatever it takes to make sure we have less of it, and more Santa Barbaras.
The clearest example, of course, is the NRA’s labeling a bill sponsored by Rep. Carolyn Maloney (D-NY) and Senator Ed Markey (D-MA) to allow the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) to once again use its considerable expertise to research gun violence prevention, “unethical.” Yes, they actually said that.
Because anyone who does statistically significant research on a public health problem from the angle of helping people and not profiting from misery, and again and again finds obvious truths such as owning guns makes you more likely to get shot, is not someone the NRA and its allies will countenance without smearing. I debated one of these types from the Second Amendment Foundation on NPR recently regarding the CDC. It is amazing how tongue-tied they get when you present them with irrefutable information.” Reader Supported News
In what world is it “unethical” to research ways to prevent deaths? Would the NRA consider it unethical to study ways to prevent automotive deaths? Or deaths caused by contaminated food? In the NRA’s world, massacres like the ones that happened in Santa Barbara, Sandy Hook Elementary, Northern Illinois University, Virginia Tech, Columbine and countless others, can only be prevented by good guys carrying guns everywhere and anywhere.
When an organization like the NRA labels an attempt to investigate ways to reduce deaths as unethical, I have to wonder if this lobbyist organization has lost touch with reality. How can we as a country not look into ways that we could possibly prevent some of the 30,000 deaths and 100,000 injured from gun actions? How much longer can the United States of America go on allowing a company/lobbying organization to spend millions to block any and all reasonable actions that may save lives?
Shame on the NRA for blocking reasonable gun control legislation and for even trying to stop research into ways to reduce deaths from guns. Shame on us for allowing it to continue. How much longer will we, as a nation, stand by and watch innocents die? How much longer until we listen to our hearts and our heads and stand up and insist that something be done? Our lives and the lives of our children are at stake. Our moral standing as a nation is also at stake.
Richard Martinez, the father of one of the Santa Barbara victims may have said it best as he reacted to the death of his child. “Christopher Ross Michaels-Martinez, of Los Osos, California, was the last of six people killed by suspect Elliot Rodger before the gunman apparently shot and killed himself, authorities said.
Martinez choked back tears as he spoke, then grew angrier as he talked about gun laws and lobbyists.
“The talk about gun rights. What about Chris’ right to live?” Martinez said. “When will enough people say: ‘Stop this madness! We don’t have to live like this! Too many people have died!” MSN News
How much longer until we heed Mr. Martinez’ plea?
“The views expressed in this posting are the author’s alone and not those of the blog, the host, or other weekend bloggers. As an open forum, weekend bloggers post independently without pre-approval or review. Content and any displays or art are solely their decision and responsibility.”

Yo: RTC: We needed to form a more perfect militia because we had a need to rebel against the standing army which existed in our midsts. i.e. that of Great Britain. We might need to create a militia to drive out the RedCoat Koch Brothers some time and it’s standing army. So, hence the need for guns in every home. THAT is also the Swiss way.
So, you are wrong RTC. The Framers knew that we need to have guns because there might be a need to rebel and thence a need to form a militia. The Confederates went off on that tangent and lost but it did not mean that the Framers did not know what they were doing. Stick your version of history up the alleyoop. Your notion of a more perfect Union is the same as the Koch Brothers and the military industrial complex. And if civilization couldn’t be had at the point of a gun then howcome the cops have them?
As I sometimes do, I wait until a thread begins to quiet down before writing and posting a comment.
In the whole of my life, as best I can remember it, I have never actually found anything whatsoever, except as I actually observed it, where and as it was, accurately.
I have a hunch that the causality of human destructive violence may be the most difficult problem in applied theoretical biology to yet garner public attention; a problem of such observably immense existential complexity as to elude any form of useful understanding that is derived through conventional science based on, and only on, the use of analytical reductionism.
Schulte: You’re understanding of the 2d Am is so deeply misconstrued that I’ve chosen not to even respond to it, except for this one last time: The founders thought the 2d Am was necessary because we did not have a standing army as you point out, and the entire nation was edged with frontier; continually expanding frontier populated with indigenous people who fought to defend their territory. Moreover, Britain, France, and Spain represented threats. Militias were thought to be more expedient and cost effective than maintaining a standing army. The 2d Am was written to ensure the states would have the capacity to raise these militia units.
Whatever confusion you seem to be having about the 2d’s history, you’re wrong. Period. End of my discussion about it. You will keep gabbling on, I’m sure, as though repeating it often enough will make it true. It will not.
The right to keep and bear arms developed because the entire country was under threat of imminent attack, either from Indians or European super-powers. That is the history of the 2d Am; it borne of a frontier mentality that no longer exists. Yet, many gun fanatics want the U.S. to remain a war zone.
The people closest in time to the founding era wished for a day when guns would no longer be necessary to survival. The citizens of Dodge city understood felt that way and understood that civilization couldn’t be had at the point of a gun.
RTC – you need to both relearn your history of the American Revolution and then relearn the creating of the Constitution. You have NO understanding of either.
RTC:
“You didn’t explicitly state this, but it is the conclusion that can logically drawn from your argument,”
No it can’t. Cite something I’ve said that even implies it.
“much like you’ve made conclusions from my argument but without the logic.”
Such as?
“The fact is, I’ve addressed your statements and questions rather directly. If you choose to pretend that I haven’t, then there ain’t much more to say.”
You’ve not addressed your willingness to propose gun restrictions despite your obvious ignorance of the most basic firearm facts. You’ve not explained what criteria you are using to determine which caliber is too deadly and which isn’t. You’ve proposed magazine limits without a specific number nor the rationale for that number.
“The final conclusion I come to based on your argument is that you’re not reasonable…..Reasonable regulation is going to rquire reasonable people to gather and debate the issue.”
Which is immediately followed by:
“I favor the elimination of the 2d Am.”
…thus rendering your claim to be a reasonable person, either philosophically or practically, false.
“I strongly oppose conceal-carry laws.”
Why? There is no evidence that these laws are a net negative. There’s no evidence that they have much of any effect on crime rates one way or the other. But you’re against them because….
“I have expressed some but not all the exceptions to restrictions in this thread, but feel to keep pretending that I didn’t.”
I’m not pretending you’ve not expressed your ideas, just that they make no sense and are obviously based on ignorance and emotion.
“You seem to favor free and easy access to guns for all Americans, with no restrictions, including limits on killing capacity.”
I seem that way only in your head. Nothing I’ve said hints at that, which makes sense because I don’t think that. And I’m still waiting for you to come down from on high and tell us which guns are too deadly for us crazy folk to own and why.
“Your 45 years old and never been in a fist fight. So why the need for a gun? Your own personal history proves that people can step outside their homes without being attacked by homicidal maniacs.”
I’ve never had need for my seat belt, fire extinguishers, smoke detectors, etc. Still use them.
“For 30 years, you managed to avoid conflict, either through negotiating potential conflict situations or avoiding them altogether. It might also mean that you lack a certain amount of personal courage, and the resulting frustration might mean your a candidate for snapping and shooting someone for little provocation.”
There are pro-gun people in this thread who have made fallacious arguments, cited questionable facts, and in general not put our argument in the best light. I hope that the more reasonable people on your side of the debate feel the same about your posting. I’d wager that more than a few do.
I havent read through all 650 comments so I dont know if anyone has mentioned that drugs given by doctors were being taken by most if not all of the young men doing these shootings.
These drugs are not good and we are giving them to our children like candy. My personal feeling is that the AMA and APA have far more blood on their hands than does the NRA and I am not evening talking about the many suicides these drugs have caused.
It is quite convienent to use the NRA and guns as a scapegoat, it is equivalent to praising Shakespear’s pen for Hamlet and giving accolades to the goose for producing such a fine quill.
It is also anticipated given the lack of personal responsibility many in our culture embrace. Furthermore it goes to the “you didnt build this” mentality that many also embrace.
Byron – several times I have pointed out that the young man had not one but at least two mental health professionals that failed him and us, but you are the first to support my proposition. I think the APA has a great deal to answer for, especially since a new study has decided that the insane do not commit crimes, which seems dodgy to me (designed to get the APA off the legal hook).
Occasionally Paul does have a flash of humor…
Now it is all perfectly clear. Many thanks, Paul. Silly of me not to realize the simplicity of it all. But now that you have so persuasively presented your case, I am convinced.
Some here do seem to over-think things. You can certainly be forgiven for falling in with a bad crowd.
Hogwash, Paul. Hogwash.
Logic is logic. Calling it hogwash is beneath even you.
Darren
You’re right.
But it’s just more fun to annoy Nick. He’s so…so.. emphatic. And he does not like to be questioned. (insert smiley face)
But seriously…
The gun rights advocates are all for protecting their rights, but don’t seem to have much respect for others rights. The ‘hard core’ (and that would include the NRA) won’t be satisfied until everyone is able to buy a gun at a gun show and open carry at the local Chipolte.
Such policies will only produce more tragedies.
The rights that gun rights people are all for protecting everyone’s rights, not just theirs. Because, oddly enough, their rights are also your rights.
BTW Jason:
Your 45 years old and never been in a fist fight. So why the need for a gun? Your own personal history proves that people can step outside their homes without being attacked by homicidal maniacs.
For 30 years, you managed to avoid conflict, either through negotiating potential conflict situations or avoiding them altogether. It might also mean that you lack a certain amount of personal courage, and the resulting frustration might mean your a candidate for snapping and shooting someone for little provocation. Why else would you need a gun, if you’ve never been in a fight?
RTC – I am sure when the nice policeman says ‘If you are not hiding anything you will be happy to let me search your house.’ you comply because you have nothing to fear, you are not hiding anything.
Me, even if the house was completely stripped and empty, they would need a warrant. My house is my fortress of solitude.
Jason:
““Your mistake in logic is thinking that more guns will prevent gun violence.”
You didn’t explicitly state this, but it is the conclusion that can logically drawn from your argument, much like you’ve made conclusions from my argument but without the logic.
The fact is, I’ve addressed your statements and questions rather directly. If you choose to pretend that I haven’t, then there ain’t much more to say. Moreover, I’ve made my positions quite clear to you and others, while you just pick around the edges of the debate. The final conclusion I come to based on your argument is that you’re not reasonable. Scalia, certainly no gun-control advocate, has stated that reasonable regulation is permissible under the constitution. Reasonable regulation is going to rquire reasonable people to gather and debate the issue.
I favor the elimination of the 2d Am. I favor a significant reduction in the number of guns in our culture. I strongly oppose conceal-carry laws. I have expressed some but not all the exceptions to restrictions in this thread, but feel to keep pretending that I didn’t. It won’t hurt the impression you’ve made here today.
You seem to favor free and easy access to guns for all Americans, with no restrictions, including limits on killing capacity. Therein lie two extremes. Could you please contact the most reasonable person you know and ask them to come and debate this issue?
RTC – first, are there any other amendments that you would like to get rid of? Perhaps the 1st or the 5th?
Now, I am going to cause you to hyperventilate, so hang on. Historically speaking the idea of the 2nd amendment was to help us defend us from ourselves. We did not have a standing army in the Constitution and there was a reason for that. We need weapons to protect us from the police and the military as well as various government agencies that are now arming themselves. We don’t need guns to walk in the Cascades. We need guns to protect you from us and us from you.
You have already seen how readily the police send out SWAT teams even for minor arrests. You have seen the number of citizens the police are killing, nay murdering regularly. We know that the military has been briefed on martial law orders with a special emphasis on those groups on the SPLC’s list of hate groups. We know that police departments are buying military grade weapons. If you are not seeing this, you are blind to what is happening in your own back yard.
Karen: I would not be in favor of restrictions on hunting rifles. I own one. I consider it a tool. I do not feel the need to carry it around with me. In fact, I’ve hiked around the Cascades down through the years checking out the progress after the eruption of Mt. St. Helens without a firearm of any sort, even though the region has a population of grizzlies. I believe bear spray is more effective protection than a gun.
I also believe you’re over-exaggerating the vulnerability of “the weak”, as you call them. I think, due to your far remove there in Alaska, your fear of urban and metropolitan America has caused your imagination to picture the worst, sort of like the way 15th century sailors were frightened of uncharted waters.
RTC – if you ever get to Phoenix, let me know and we will meet at a neutral spot. I will be happy to walk you thru parts of Phoenix that I think will have you changing your mind about urban areas. Of course, you will have to stay unarmed, I on the otherhand will be armed, but in the interest of proving your point, will not try to save you.
Hey John, don’t feel bad, my iPad hates me. It won’t even spell horseshi*.
Um.. John… That would be Professor Turley. No saying bull**it, bu horseshi seems to pass muster, go figure. 😕
I’m so embarrassed. My new spellcheck failed me, or I failed it. The previous post should have included the word duel. My apologies.
Who censors these threads? Show yourself, villain! I challenge you to a dual – figuratively speaking. Is that even legal anymore? How about a game of chess? I win, I get published. Whaddaya say?
John – are you sure it was not swallowed by the Vortex of Doom? Did it disappear instantly? Or did you actually see it in print on the site and then it disappeared?
fear
quota
It is in every way a national issue.
It is a national issue when western state A permits open carry without any restrictions and Joe from state A wants to go on vacation with his gun in Martha’s Vineyard which has strict requirements for open carry.
Didn’t something like this just happen in National Parks?
Notice it’s the guys who want unrestricted gun rights that are pushing the envelope.
These people be anything like the ones pushing the envelope on open sex marriage?
A national strategy is ludicrous. The attitude toward guns in New England is light years from any western state. This is a regional or state by state issue. It is not in any way a national issue.