The NRA Has Blood on its Hands

220px-National_Rifle_Association_svg

Respectfully submitted by Lawrence E. Rafferty (rafflaw)- Weekend Contributor

 

It has happened again.  A mass killing at the hands of a person armed with knives and three semi-automatic handguns and 400 rounds of ammunition.  This time the alleged shooter stabbed three to death and then went on a shooting spree that ended with at least three more dead and a total of 8 injured/wounded people from gunshot wounds and 5 more injured by his knives or by being hit by his car.

The family of the alleged shooter requested a police intervention prior to the killings and the police did speak with the young man, but they did not have cause to search his apartment.  The police had other interactions with Elliot Rodger, age 22 and he later expressed concern that they did not find his weapons.

“Deputies also encountered Rodger earlier this year when he accused a roommate of stealing three candles, and in another case in which he claimed to be beaten but deputies suspected he was the aggressor.

Rodger detailed his plans in an extensive 141-page manifesto released Saturday and said he narrowly missed being found out when the officers knocked on his door.

Rodger expressed relief that his apartment wasn’t searched because they would have found his weapons and his writings.  When recounting his thinking about whether he should kill his father, Rodger expressed a sliver of acknowledgment that his plot, which included killing other family members, was wrong.

“I didn’t want it to come to this,” Rodger said. “I desperately wanted a way out.” He then immediately talks about his mother giving him a new car — a BMW coupe.” USA Today

This latest shooting spree is not the reason for this article.  It is merely one more example of why common sense gun control measures that could save innocent lives are needed.  When recent polls seem to indicate that a majority of Americans agree that common sense gun control regulations are needed, the NRA continually stands in the way of possibly life saving legislation.  However, the NRA is not just working to prevent any gun control legislation from proceeding, it is also standing in the way of attempts to have the Center for Disease Control (CDC) do research on gun prevention measures.

“But this past week we’ve seen the other side of the coin. How the NRA works to suppress information that would lead to treating a public health catastrophe that claims over 30,000 lives per year and injures over 100,000 as that very thing, while fighting to ensure we have as little access to information as possible that might help save lives.

The simple fact is, much like with their friends on the right from the tobacco industry to the oil industry to the megachurch, science and information are the enemies of the NRA. They have proven they will do whatever it takes to make sure we have less of it, and more Santa Barbaras.

The clearest example, of course, is the NRA’s labeling a bill sponsored by Rep. Carolyn Maloney (D-NY) and Senator Ed Markey (D-MA) to allow the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) to once again use its considerable expertise to research gun violence prevention, “unethical.” Yes, they actually said that.

Because anyone who does statistically significant research on a public health problem from the angle of helping people and not profiting from misery, and again and again finds obvious truths such as owning guns makes you more likely to get shot, is not someone the NRA and its allies will countenance without smearing. I debated one of these types from the Second Amendment Foundation on NPR recently regarding the CDC. It is amazing how tongue-tied they get when you present them with irrefutable information.” Reader Supported News

In what world is it “unethical” to research ways to prevent deaths?  Would the NRA consider it unethical to study ways to prevent automotive deaths?  Or deaths caused by contaminated food?  In the NRA’s world, massacres like the ones that happened in  Santa Barbara, Sandy Hook Elementary, Northern Illinois University, Virginia Tech, Columbine and countless others, can only be prevented by good guys carrying guns everywhere and anywhere.

When an organization like the NRA labels an attempt to investigate ways to reduce deaths as unethical, I have to wonder if this lobbyist organization has lost touch with reality.  How can we as a country not look into ways that we could possibly prevent some of the 30,000 deaths and 100,000 injured from gun actions?   How much longer can the United States of America go on allowing a company/lobbying organization to spend millions to block any and all reasonable actions that may save lives?

Shame on the NRA for blocking reasonable gun control legislation and for even trying to stop research into ways to reduce deaths from guns.  Shame on us for allowing it to continue.  How much longer will we, as a nation, stand by and watch innocents die?  How much longer until we listen to our hearts and our heads and stand up and insist that something be done?  Our lives and the lives of our children are at stake.  Our moral standing as a nation is also at stake.

Richard Martinez, the father of one of the Santa Barbara victims may have said it best as he reacted to the death of his child.  “Christopher Ross Michaels-Martinez, of Los Osos, California, was the last of six people killed by suspect Elliot Rodger before the gunman apparently shot and killed himself, authorities said.

Martinez choked back tears as he spoke, then grew angrier as he talked about gun laws and lobbyists.

“The talk about gun rights. What about Chris’ right to live?” Martinez said. “When will enough people say: ‘Stop this madness! We don’t have to live like this! Too many people have died!” MSN News

How much longer until we heed Mr. Martinez’ plea?

 

“The views expressed in this posting are the author’s alone and not those of the blog, the host, or other weekend bloggers. As an open forum, weekend bloggers post independently without pre-approval or review. Content and any displays or art are solely their decision and responsibility.”

 

 

 

854 thoughts on “The NRA Has Blood on its Hands”

  1. The NRA has a new theme song for those who accuse it of not properly washing their hands in public like Pontius Pilate did:

  2. Isla Vista is a college town. Pretty much everyone who lives there goes to UC Santa Barbara, or works there.

    Quite possibly, the distraught father of Chris Martinez would have been having a different day today if someone had a gun, took down the killer, and saved his child. Like an armed person in a church stopped a murderous rampage. Like an armed person in a mall stopped a murderous rampage. Like armed citizens in TX stopped a mass murderer on a clock tower.

    But college campuses and surrounding areas are gun free zones. Soft targets.

    Elliot Rogers also used his car to plow into people, like David Attias did. People who want to commit mass murder will use any tool at their disposal. Taking away one tool does not thwart them. It’s the person and intent, not the tool.

  3. lindylou22:

    it isnt gun nuts who are doing the killing, it is people who are nuts.

    Doctors kill more of us than guns do, same for cars and pools.

  4. For those who are comparing gun control to control of knives, cars, etc. Guns have one purpose, and that is to destroy, most likely to destroy flesh. This does not in any way compare to items that are necessities in daily life such as our cars and our kitchen utensils.

    If your guns give you a sense of security, how many anecdotes, how many statistics will it take to prove that your sense of security is false?

    Your fear has overtaken your ability to be rational and logical. Omigod Raff wants to take away all your guns. The sheer panic!

    Fear works, obviously. It’s in control of you gun fools.

    1. lindylou – AZ is concealed carry country. An armed society is a polite society. You have no idea how polite people in AZ are to each other. 😉

  5. Karen: Your comments are disappointing. I expressly stated in a response addressed to you that people living in rural areas, because of their inaccessibility, reasonably have a right to firearms. I also maintain that hunters, which I am, should retain their rights to firearms, as well. Hunting rifles, as you well know, bear little resemblance to the automatic assault weapons that our culture fetishes. I also side with you on suicide prevention, in case you were planning to go banging on about that. It seems you went to the same school of selective reading and denial as Jason.

    As for anyone foolish enough to go hiking around unprepared, I say let nature weed them out, not someone with a gun.

    Ted Morgan, in Wilderness at Dawn, quotes contemporary newspaper editorials along with George Washington, Ben Franklin, and others who expressed their views on the reasons we needed guns as I’ve laid out here. Whatever selectively edited quotes and distortions you’ve come across were twisted out of context by people who sat next to Jason and BobbieEsq in class.

    I haven’t seen LA Story yet, but I did witness a driveby shooting up close. About eight or nine years ago, some kids drove into Chicago from the nearby city of Elgin as part of a gang initiation rite. They got off the highway on the near north side of town, and made the first two right turns that would take them onto a side street. The waited behind me as a parked my car on one of Chicago’s notorious narrow sidestreets, pulled 50 feet ahead once I was parked and shot at a group of kids, thinking they were gang members. Except the kid they shot wasn’t a gang member, but a local kid from a good, decent family. He was on his way to or from somewhere, minding his own business. Possessing a gun would not have saved his life, nor could I if I had possessed one.

    I joined a crowd, as we stood watching him die wretchedly. When his parents rushed to the scene, it was heart-rending. Am I emotional about gun-control, or motivated? in either case, I’m prepared to be reasonable, as I’ve expressed to you earlier. If yoou’re going to engage in histrionics, like your buddy Bob, or misconstrue and ignore what I’m saying, like Jason, then I’ll leave you guys to it, and continue to press my elected officials for gun regulations.

    In any event, you’re not going to rewrite the historical underpinnings of the 2d Am with false assertions made here.

    1. RTC, I found a comment from you that got trapped in the spam filter.

      Folks, RTC’s comment is above at 12:28

  6. http://talkingpointsmemo.com/livewire/joe-the-plumber-wurzelbacher-ucsb-shooting-dead-kids”

    Samuel Wurzelbacher gave his condolences this week to the families of the victims of the mass shooting near the University of California, Santa Barbara. But no tragedy is going to stop “Joe The Plumber” from defending the Second Amendment.

    In an open letter published Tuesday on the website Barbwire, Wurzelbacher went out of his way to explain to the victims’ parents that the deaths won’t undermine his “Constitutional rights.”

    “I am sorry you lost your child. I myself have a son and daughter and the one thing I never want to go through, is what you are going through now,” wrote Wurzelbacher, who became something of a mascot for John McCain’s failed 2008 presidential campaign. “But: As harsh as this sounds – your dead kids don’t trump my Constitutional rights.”

    Wurzelbacher singled out Richard Martinez, whose son Christopher was one of the six students killed by Elliot Rodger in Isla Vista, Calif. Since the deadly rampage, Martinez has twice railed against politicians and the National Rifle Association for the failure to pass new gun laws after the Sandy Hook Elementary School massacre.

    “There are no critical words for a grieving father. He can say whatever he wants and blame whoever he’d like – it’s okay by me. You can’t take a step in his shoes – at least I can’t,” Wurzelbacher wrote. “But the words and images of Mr. Martinez blaming ‘the proliferation of guns’, lobbyists, politicians, etc.; will be exploited by gun-grab extremists as are all tragedies involving gun violence and the mentally ill by the anti-Second Amendment Left.”

    Wurzelbacher added that he has a responsibility as a “father, husband and a man” to protect his family. Addressing Martinez directly, Wurzelbacher wrote that “anyone calling for more restrictions on American’s rights need to back off and stop playing into the hands of the folks who merely capitalize on these horrific events for their own political ends.”

    Wurzelbacher closed with an admonition.

    “In conclusion, I cannot begin to imagine the pain you are going through, having had your child taken away from you,” he wrote. “However, any feelings you have toward my rights being taken away from me, lose those.”

  7. RTC:

    Have you ever read the Athenian Constitution? Based on your answer, I will surmise you have not. The founders read that and other documents and constitutions concerning the nature of government.

    The 2nd Amendment was not about putting food on the table or Europeans, it was about the people protecting themselves against a tyrannical government.

  8. RTC: “The founding generation was pretty clear about what they needed guns for, and it was protection from Indians and Europeans. When the frontier was little more than a days ride from established cities and towns, it was deemed critical. The British army was not in our midst, they were just outside our borders to west and north, so you’re pulling an ‘F’ in history,”

    This is hysterical.

    Must be the fever brought on by your acute case of presentism.

  9. Yes, the Founders were indeed clear on their opinion of the right to bear arms.

  10. RTC:

    You’ll forgive me, but I believe that you are mistaken in your assertion that the Second Amendment was penned solely because of a frontier mentality that no longer exists. One has only to read the writings and letters of the founders to understand that they viewed this as a right, not merely a circumstantial necessity. You are to recall that these documents were created to address the wrongs of the Crown and how they envisioned a more perfect union. Through their travels to cities in Europe, they would be familiar with civilization sans frontier, and therefor would have remarked if the right to own weapons was deemed necessary until borders were secure.

    http://jpfo.org/filegen-n-z/six-about-2nd.htm

    Quotes from the founding fathers regarding the right to bear arms (for context):
    http://www.nsm88.org/articles/arms.htm

    You will note that Communist China and Cuba disarmed their people prior to their reign of terror and wave of public executions.

    * Samuel Adams: “The Constitution shall never be construed . . . to prevent the people of the United States who are peaceable citizens from keeping their own arms.” Just wondering how you viewed the Second Amendment as being a temporary right, no longer needed after the “frontier mentality” is gone.

  11. Well, I’ve missed a lot.

    How have I come to be viewed as “living in fear?” I’m an outdoors woman and have been raised to be prepared for anything. (It’s not just for Boy Scouts, you know.) I’ve walked into a mountain lion and a mama bear with 2 cubs, both times when I was alone. Worked out fine.

    Saying being prepared is living in fear is like two hikers from the city choosing a dry stream bed for their walk, in flash flood country, with a storm on the horizon. They don’t want to “live in fear” so they don’t take the trouble to learn the skills needed in the terrain.

    Darren’s post was spot on. What would be considered “reasonable” in Connecticut would be far different than what’s “reasonable” in Alaska. Apply CT’s laws to Alaska and you’ll have whole villages unable to get any food, hundreds of miles and a plane trip from the nearest grocery store. Hence why we’ve never federalized the gun laws. There are some instances where states govern themselves best.

    And I loved LA Story. One of my favorite comedies. The Spring season of drive bys was hilarious. Of course, here in reality, I’ve spent a lot of time in areas where hunting was big. Gun racks on lots of trucks. High firearm ownership. Didn’t have any Mad Max moments on roads.

  12. Al Z: Appropriately named I would say. The founding generation was pretty clear about what they needed guns for, and it was protection from Indians and Europeans. When the frontier was little more than a days ride from established cities and towns, it was deemed critical. The British army was not in our midst, they were just outside our borders to west and north, so you’re pulling an ‘F’ in history, Al the Pal.

    The Swiss make a bad comparison, because they are a more or less homogenous society. We have a far more divided society, racially and economically. Gun fanatics try to keep the frontier fear mentality stoked by exacerbating racial tension and class warfare. The Swiss are also a social democracy with a wide array of social safety measures, so that crime isn’t as a high as it is in America, where the dog-eat-dog, kill-or-be-killed attitude is fomented.

    You’re never going to fight the Koch Bros. with bullets and win. Even brandishing weapons plays into their hands. The only way to defeat the Koch agenda is with ballots.

  13. Jason:

    “You didn’t explicitly state this, but it is the conclusion that can logically drawn from your argument,”

    No it can’t.

    Yes, it can.

    “much like you’ve made conclusions from my argument but without the logic.”

    Such as?

    I refer to you to your comments above.

    You’ve not addressed your willingness to propose gun restrictions despite your obvious ignorance of the most basic firearm facts.

    I don’t the first thing about how a car works either, but I still asked the city council to put up a couple of stop signs in our neighborhood and reduce the speed limit because speeding drivers were creating a hazard for our kids.

    You’ve not explained what criteria you are using to determine which caliber is too deadly and which isn’t.

    Maybe if the CDC was allowed to collect data on gun-related deaths and injuries, I could develop a criteria.

    You’ve proposed magazine limits without a specific number nor the rationale for that number.

    Ten. And I thought my rationale could have been surmised from my comment to Karen about the Aurora movie shooter. There were several people carrying handguns in that theater at the time, but said they were unable to get a shot off because of the number rounds the shooter was able to fire. The nutjob that shot Gabby Giffords was stopped only after bystanders were able to rush him as he reloaded. Most people would conclude that my rationale for limiting magazine capacity is to require shooters to reload more frequently, giving people a chance to defend or escape, but I’ll spell it out just for you; I’m in favor of limiting magazine capacity is to require shooters to reload more frequently, giving people a chance to defend or escape. Claro?

    “The final conclusion I come to based on your argument is that you’re not reasonable…..Reasonable regulation is going to rquire reasonable people to gather and debate the issue.”

    Which is immediately followed by:

    “I favor the elimination of the 2d Am.”

    …thus rendering your claim to be a reasonable person, either philosophically or practically, false.

    You leave out the part where I say that elimination of the 2d Am represents one pole of the extremes, and that something reasonable lies in between. With editing skills like that, it’s a wonder you can’t make me appear in favor of unrestricted gun ownership.

    And I thought I told you to find a reasonable person. No luck, huh?

    “I strongly oppose conceal-carry laws.”

    Why? There is no evidence that these laws are a net negative. There’s no evidence that they have much of any effect on crime rates one way or the other.

    Yes, there is. NPR ran a story a year ago about a university study that found a rise in gun violence. The findings also show that the rise was occurring in instances where the combatants would normally have chosen to walk away from confrontations but were emboldened because they possessed a gun. in cases where an altercation would have resulted inevitably, fistfights would have occurred, thus limiting the physical harm, and avoiding death in most cases.

    Also, we’d have better data if the CDC were allowed to collect it.

    “You seem to favor free and easy access to guns for all Americans, with no restrictions, including limits on killing capacity.”

    I seem that way only in your head. Nothing I’ve said hints at that, which makes sense because I don’t think that. And I’m still waiting for you to come down from on high and tell us which guns are too deadly for us crazy folk to own and why.

    Your argumentation makes you seem like you oppose restrictions. Turns out, you’re the one who hasn’t proposed anything position. When you tackle someone proposing restrictions, the logical conclusion is that oppose restrictions. To maintain otherwise is sophistry.

    Also, when I said I opposed military assault weapons, I thought that seemed to indicate that I oppose military assault weapons. Umm, OK, again: I oppose high powered military assault weapons capable of firing many rounds per second.

    Are you sure you don’t know any reasonable people who would be willing to have this debate?

    “Your 45 years old and never been in a fist fight. So why the need for a gun? Your own personal history proves that people can step outside their homes without being attacked by homicidal maniacs.”

    I’ve never had need for my seat belt, fire extinguishers, smoke detectors, etc. Still use them.

    Good point. But your odds of being in a car accident or having a house fire are far higher than being in a situation where lethal force is necessary to defend yourself.

    “For 30 years, you managed to avoid conflict, either through negotiating potential conflict situations or avoiding them altogether. It might also mean that you lack a certain amount of personal courage, and the resulting frustration might mean your a candidate for snapping and shooting someone for little provocation.”

    There are pro-gun people in this thread who have made fallacious arguments, cited questionable facts, and in general not put our argument in the best light. I hope that the more reasonable people on your side of the debate feel the same about your posting. I’d wager that more than a few do.

    I’m sorry, what’s the fallacy you’re seeing here? You avoided fistfights for 30 years before getting a gun – Fact. Somehow you managed and I give you credit for conflict avoidance. I also posit a potential condition which i’m technically not qualified to make. But I don’t need to be a plumber to see when the pipes are clogged and guess how they got that way. I might need to a licensed plumber to figure out how to fix the system, however, so I always suggest that people consult with licensed professionals. Jason.

    Thanks for conceding that the pro-gun fanatics are making fallacious arguments, using questionable facts. I couldn’t have said it better myself. If gun-control advocates think I’ve erred in my comments, I welcome the criticism. I have an open mind, because I’m reasonable.

    Have a good summer, Jason. Don’t shoot yourself.

  14. Schulte: Why would I favor eliminating the 1st or 5th Am?

    You bring up a good point worth mentioning, that citizens need to defend themselves against the govt and police, and if we take away guns, or limit killing capacity, then the govt will essentially “control” us. BS.

    First off, I’m not letting police enter my home to search it without a warrant. But if the FBI showed up at my door, or even the local police departmet and demanded entry, I’d be a fool, probably a dead fool, to resist them, no matter how well armed I might be.

    You said it yourself, local PD’s are purchasing military grade weapons. They have superior forces and resources. It is pure fantasy to think that you’re going to resist without getting yourself and your family killed or seriously wounded. Therefore, the argument that citizens need to defend themselves against the govt is a non-starter, and made by the mentally unbalanced anti-social types who refuse to broadly recognize society. I don’t think you are among that crowd.

    The way to end abuse of police powers is best handled through the courts and administratively.

    1. RTC – and just how has handling police abuse through the courts been working out?

Comments are closed.