DePaul Students File Complaint Against Professor For Using N-Word In Class Hypothetical On Fighting Words

We recently discussed the cancellation of a Princeton class on oppressive language when the professor used the n-word.  I was strongly critical of actions in the controversy and the ultimate cancellation as an attack on both academic freedom and a reflection of the loss of objectivity on our campuses.  Now, law students have made a similar complaint to DePaul University.  Professor Donald Hermann  is under fire for using the word in a hypothetical.  It is particularly distressing to see law students objecting to the use of this word, which arises often in legal cases and was used for a legitimate purpose by Professor Hermann.

We previously discussed DePaul University’s failure to protect free speech on campus, but this controversy attacks the very heart of academic freedom and objectivity.

The hypothetical in the class was fairly conventional: A white supremacist at a funeral of a civil rights leader uses the N-word, causing the crowd to come after him. If the white supremacist shoots and kills someone, can he claim self-defense?

Ironically, Hermann’s view was that the white supremacist is guilty of murder because he was the aggressor with his use of the racial slur.

Students have also objected to Hermann’s use of other disparaging terms in his class discussion.


Hopefully the law school will be more supportive of free speech and academic freedom than the university as a whole in this controversy.  What concerns me is that students are now coming to our graduate schools after being taught that they should be insulated from then insults, slurs, and opposing views in the world.  Even in seeking to join a profession that deals with those issues, they want to sanitize the facts to avoid insult or discomfort.  We work as lawyers in the real world and address real problems like the one that Professor Hermann was trying to explore in his class. That is a valuable lesson in itself.

57 thoughts on “DePaul Students File Complaint Against Professor For Using N-Word In Class Hypothetical On Fighting Words

  1. I’m trying to remember Thurgood Marshall’s comment about the zuse of “Afriican-American”..anybody remember.? I guess we should bring back all the good old ethic slurs..”Dago”, ( they’re always greasy”, “Kike”( or “Christ Killers”), “Spics”(always ready with a knife) ad naseum…….I guess we’ll never learn to get one who went to a very integrated jschool system in Philly, most of my classmates of color were extremely bright…and a typical public school………

  2. Is the word “Negro” acceptable? Is the word “Colored” acceptable? If Colored is not acceptable then then the NAACP will have to change its name.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s