MSNBC Commentator Calls For Trump’s Removal Under The 25th Amendment Over The Disinfectant Controversy

MSNBC commentator Mike Barnicle this week called for the removal of President Donald Trump under the 25th Amendment for his bizarre suggestion that disinfectants might be injected into patients to clean their blood in minutes.  Many of us criticized the President for the comments and found his later claim to have been speaking “sarcastically” to a reporter as clearly untrue. Trump later suspended further briefings, which have served as a critical avenue for information from task force members like Dr. Fauci and Dr. Birx. Yet, despite my respect for Barnicle, it is important to be clear about what is a constitutional versus a political matter.  As I have previously written (here and here) and publicly discussed, the 25th Amendment was not designed and will not address this type of controversy.

Barnicle stated the view of many over the comments on the use of disinfectant, but suddenly took a constitutional turn:

“In a rational, political world, of which we are not part, we’re no longer a part of that, there is no longer a rational political world around us, I’ll tell you what might be on their minds: the 25th Amendment. Because yesterday, the president of the United States actually posed a threat to public safety, to the public safety of the citizens of this country … Those are the musings of a man who has spent a whole lot of his lifetime in a tanning bed. So, he’s been exposed to ultraviolet rays in order to look like he has a tan all the time. Those were the irrational rants of a man who, somewhere out there in this country, God forbid, some inherent of his, someone who follows him closely and adores him, and there are many people like that … will take a little sip of Clorox bleach today to ward off the potential of the virus, and they will die.”

There have been similar calls for over three years to use the 25th Amendment to address controversial statements and policies by the President.  Ironically, this type the amendment like a type of constitutional lysol that can be used wipe away a unduly elected but controversial president. That is not its function.

As I have previously written,Section 4 has, essentially, two avenues for dragging a president from the Oval Office. First, there is the mutiny option. A vice president and a majority of the Cabinet can agree that the president is “unable to discharge the powers and duties of his office” and notify Congress that the vice president intends to take over. If Vice President Pence could get eight Cabinet officers to sign a letter to that effect, he would immediately become the “Acting President.”  But if the president then declares to Congress that “no inability exists,” Trump could resume his powers. Pence and the rebellious Cabinet would then have to send another declaration within four days to the President pro tempore of the Senate and the Speaker of the House that says, more or less, don’t believe a word, he’s unfit. Once Congress had the second declaration, if not already in session, it would have 48 hours to assemble to debate the issue. It would then have 21 days to vote on the president’s fitness. To remove the president, two-thirds of both houses would have to agree. If Congress did not vote within 21 days, the president would get his power back.

In other words, the use of the 25th Amendment over this latest controversy would be unwarranted as it is unlikely.  The likelihood of removing Donald Trump under the 25th Amendment for this controversy is about as likely as his receiving an honorary medical degree.

184 thoughts on “MSNBC Commentator Calls For Trump’s Removal Under The 25th Amendment Over The Disinfectant Controversy”

  1. With all due respect, President Trump did not “suggest…that disinfectants might be injected into patients to clean their blood in minutes” Don’t contribute to the spread of inaccurate information .
    The transcript of what was said:, verified by multiple Trump-haters.
    Also, an interesting article (published journal) including the term “disinfectant”. Perhaps he had been briefed on this and a thousand other possibilities
    It should be no surprise by now that we have to Translate everything he says. No question that he sounds like an idiot…but he’s not. He’s an outlier that doesn’t fit with our experience with normal people. Not stupid though.

    1. David Benson is the God Emperor of Making Stuff Up and owes me forty-four citations (one from the OED, one from the town ordinances and two from the Old Testament), an equation and the source of a quotation, after seventy-two weeks, and needs to cite all his work from now on. – I am back up after a nice sleep. What the heck are you doing up? We are on the same time, buddy?

      1. In about 4 hours, Paul C Schulte needs to schedule an appointment with a mental health professional. 🔇

        1. David Benson is the God Emperor of Making Stuff Up and owes me forty-four citations (one from the OED, one from the town ordinances and two from the Old Testament), an equation and the source of a quotation, after seventy-two weeks, and needs to cite all his work from now on. – except for a slight case of cabin fever, my mental health is excellent.

    1. David Benson is the God Emperor of Making Stuff Up and owes me forty-four citations (one from the OED, one from the town ordinances and two from the Old Testament), an equation and the source of a quotation, after seventy-two weeks, and needs to cite all his work from now on. – pleading temporary insanity or mental defect will not help your case, David. Want to see that proof.

    2. David – You know exactly what a Brute-force attack is, as well as a DNS Hijack, you gave me a 👎 at the BF, which I agree, did not make any sense.

      I am sure you know what keylogging is too.

      Do not pretend, I know👽

  2. What’s the latest on Joe Bidens sexual allegations from the past. Oh I forgot, he’s a democrat.

  3. Trump, doesn’t know the meaning of “sarcastic”. Such a sick man. It’s a total disgrace that his family, are
    allowing this to continue. I guess the appearance of POWER is hard to relinquish and the PERKS are harder to distance ones self from. But shouldn’t the Republicans do something.? Or are they too drunk on Power too, to see reality.? This debacle will live on, long after these people are gone from the White House and every single person, associated with this sham, will be disgraced. As they are being already.

      1. What are you Brute-Force attacking?

        I doubt you could get a PW that fast, unless you have a tool

        Hrmmm 🤔

        1. Oh, sure, sure. You’re right, brut forcing does make no sense.

          DNS Hijacking?

          Old-fashion ping…haha, you kid.

            1. Oh, sure, sure…yes…Gobbledygook.

              Your ping-ing gives you away, btw, like an elephant…I do recall.

              1. Do elephants ping?
                I had thought that they trumpeted.
                Rather like our dear leader…


                1. Lol, waving the red flag, I see…this Nov should be quite interesting…

                  You never answered my question…when are we all going cashless like 🇸🇪 Sweden?

                  1. WW33, what is a “Nov”? I’m barely out of the punched card era…


                    1. Nov.= November

                      You’re pinging folks, but you only know punch cards. 😒

                      Interesting default.

                    2. David Benson is the God Emperor of Making Stuff Up and owes me forty-four citations (one from the OED, one from the town ordinances and two from the Old Testament), an equation and the source of a quotation, after seventy-two weeks, and needs to cite all his work from now on. – prove that WW33 does not have a name, including a middle name.

        2. This is no bueno…. now, i am going to have to go to command prompt and ipconfig /all…..pahtwoey, DBB, pahtwoey 😥

      2. WW33 – DBB is like Chevy Chase in “Community” trying to stay relevant. 😉

        1. Paul – 😆 smh

          I’m not meddling in you and DBB ongoing throw-down.

          I’ll gladly watch from the audience area.

    1. Scandalous, I am hobbling around over here like a pirate sardine in a tuna can, my equipment is hard to get to, ya know, one-legged and all.

      DNS Hijacking, perhaps, hrrmmm

      Which type though?


  4. Yo Marky Mark….yeah you know me….

    So tell us…who gonna save your beloved country in November? Uncle Joe?

    1. Re Tara Reade’s credible accusation of rape by her then boss, Sen. Joe Biden, here is Joe Biden’s response:

      “For a woman to come forward in the glaring lights of focus, nationally, you’ve got to start off with the presumption that at least the essence of what she’s talking about is real, whether or not she forgets facts…” – JoeBiden, 2018

    2. A real, authentic adult. One who demonstrates no readily-apparent mental disorder(s); understands the American form of government; has intelligence; empathy; honor; values the law and due process; and most importantly, possesses common decency.

      to “huh? hannity never mentioned that the day glo bozo is a lunatic” anon 1:50

      1. ‘One who demonstrates no readily-apparent mental disorder’….well that rules out demented Joe…”has intelligence”…that rules out dum dum Joe graduated bottom of his law school class….”values the law and due process”….also rules out Joe….”honor”…that’s a close call….”decency” dunno know about that one either….Biden is a life long career politican and corrupt as hell…take a look at his family fortunes…and sorry, being a career pol all but rules out “honor and decency”….take a look at his career….his plagiarism? his lies? what he did to Clarence Thomas? etc….you call that “honorable”?

        So I ask again, who is gonna save your beloved country in November?

        1. Ah, you’re apparently not aware that other bots have already checked in with today’s Pravda Faux News thinking points. So sorry to inform you that you won’t be getting that “personalized” text from hannity.

          this is to “i hates the guvernmint unlessen it’s a tellin them gurls that won’t talk to me that they can’ts git an abortion” anon 2:34.

          1. Yep, Marky Mark — we know that you know that it is Trump! who will save our beloved country (again!) in November. Buckle up its gonna be a wild ride 😉

  5. Yo Marky Mark….yeah you know me….

    So tell us…who gonna save your beloved country in November? Uncle Joe?

  6. Trump Claims ‘Sarcasm’ As Gaslighting Ruse

    Claiming he was being sarcastic after the fact allows Trump to turn the question back on his critics — “What, can’t you take a joke?” Trump did the same thing in August 2019 when he claimed that he was just being sarcastic when he called himself “the chosen one.” He was “kidding, being sarcastic, and just having fun,” Trump tweeted: “no more trust!”

    That plays into the whole worldview of Trump and his supporters, which relies on distrust, polarization and outrage to make sense of political information. Trump doesn’t make mistakes, actually, but the lying mainstream media says that he does (a frame of distrust). The lying mainstream media hate Republicans, which is why they never tell the truth about them (a frame of polarization). And the lying mainstream media are just trying to distort Trump’s words and turn them into something else to “get” Trump (a frame of outrage).

    And sure enough, Rush Limbaugh invoked all these frames to explain away Trump’s comments Friday.

    “Now, another controversy that sprung up out there that happens — I don’t know — at least once a week. The Drive-By Media is attempting to persuade and convince people that Donald Trump told people to drink Drano at the White House press briefing yesterday,” Limbaugh informed radio listeners. “That Donald Trump told people to go out and get a syringe and inject Clorox in their arms, and that this could be dangerous, that Donald Trump is killing people now in the White House press briefing. … Now you can’t watch mainstream media for 10 minutes without hearing about how some conservative or some network had somebody on it that said something that a bunch of doofus, dunce Americans listened to and now they’re dying.”

    Limbaugh’s version of the story was outrageous and absurd; it was tailor-made to reinforce distrust and polarization. Of course Trump didn’t tell people to go out and get a syringe, and reporters didn’t say he did, but that doesn’t matter: Limbaugh’s story was outrage bait. It was designed to reinforce the “us vs. them” frame — they make up stories and say that we are “doofus, dunce Americans,” when we’re just the victims. Limbaugh said that this kind of ginned-up, slanderous controversy happens at least once a week.

    Edited From: “When Trump Says He Was Being Sarcastic It’s Just Part Of His Gaslighting”

    Today’s Washington Post

  7. Yes, Jonathan Turley completely misinterpreted what the “commentator” stated. He just speculated about what might be on “their” minds.


  8. OK, Turley… you’re just being more of a total schmuck than btb! It wasn’t a “bizarre suggestion” — it was a question. I am no longer surprised that the creepy porn lawyer was one of your students.

  9. Two IP addresses using the handle “Seth Warner”. I should have thought that impossible.

  10. My boss is in the news again.

    I’ll be over after work, David. Of course I will bring pizza for all of the boys you have lined up for us. What are their ages this time?

    Soros-Funded David Brock Group Accused of Violating Tax Laws

    April 26, 2020

    The David Brock-founded far-left group ‘American Bridge 21st Century probably violated its tax-exempt status by engaging in political activities while illegally posing as a nonprofit, according to a complaint filed Thursday with the Internal Revenue Service.

    The Patriots Foundation filed a complaint with the IRS claiming that the Soros-funded group is largely a political organization and therefore has violated U.S. tax laws.

    “American Bridge has a super-PAC arm that can spend unlimited sums to influence elections. But the primary purpose of nonprofits organized under section 501(c)4 of the tax code like American Bridge cannot be politics. The complaint quotes material given to potential donors to the nonprofit arm in 2017 saying the organization’s mission is ‘to take on Donald Trump,’” Bloomberg reports.

    David Brock is a notorious Clinton operative who runs Media Matters for America – another Soros-funded group tasked with censoring social media of conservative and independent voices.

    Brock once boasted about lying in a book in order to ruin Anita Hill’s credibility on behalf of the Clintons.

    “Groups like American Bridge do not have to disclose their donors, which is why they are sometimes called ‘dark money,’” Bloomberg wrote in their report. reports: Liberal billionaire George Soros has been a prominent donor to American Bridge 21st Century and the group spends millions on ads attacking President Trump.

    The complaint accused American Bridge 21st Century Foundation of engaging in “serious and deliberate violations of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended (“IRC”) and abused its tax-exempt status” and outlined specific examples, referring to the far-left group as “AB21CF” throughout.

    “Specifically, as detailed below, AB21CF is not operated exclusively for an exempt- purpose; is operated primarily for political purposes; has participated in an impermissible excess benefit transaction with its founder David Brock and True Blue Media LLC; has provided an improper private benefit to Brock and True Blue; has used its income and assets for the personal gain of Brock; and has engaged in commercial, for-profit business activity through its investment in True Blue Media,” the complaint said.

    The complaint said “AB21CF appears to have abandoned any attempts at credibly describing itself as a social welfare organization under section 501(c)(4). Instead, it has become singularly focused on one mission, ‘to take on Donald Trump.’”

    The lengthy document claimed the group planned to create “a 47-person war room to take on Donald Trump with a staff of 23 researchers, a communications team of 16” who feed work to the press for the purposes of rapid-response.

    “This is not a proper nonprofit purpose,” the complaint said. “The IRS should undertake an examination of AB21CF to determine the extent to which it has misused its tax-exempt status.”

    The complaint concluded: “Further, the IRS should determine that AB21CF has engaged in egregious and systemic violations of its tax-exempt status, and take appropriate action as warranted including, but not limited to: revoking its tax- exempt status… imposing any appropriate penalties and additions to tax; and referring violations to the Department of Justice for possible criminal prosecution.

    The Patriots Foundation also filed similar complaints against Media Matters For America and The Franklin Education Forum.

    American Bridge president Bradley Beychok dismissed any wrongdoing by the far-left group.

    “The Patriots Foundation has chosen to purposely mislead the public in order to further its right wing agenda,” Beychok told Bloomberg.

    “He added that Brock resigned from the organization in 2016, before the transfers to True Blue Media were made, and that the group’s board of directors determined the investment would further the mission of American Bridge,” Allison added.


        That commenter pretending to be me, and the one below it pretending to be Commenter Natacha, is a rightwing stooge of some kind possibly enabled by Turley’s ‘Moderator’.

        For months this stooge has been logging comments totally inappropriate for a professional setting. No academic of any prominence should want comments like these on their blog.

        So it becomes a mystery why Johnathan Turley allows this to continue. Does he actually want his reputation linked to this stooge?

        It illustrates how Donald Trump and his followers draw the stupidest of minds. While men of prominence like Turley get burned in the process.

        1. Are you sure that it isn’t you? Maybe all the lying and DNCshilling has caused you to have a psychic split? You know, the part of you that is sickened by what you do everyday, lying and deceiving people. Maybe this has caused a traumatic multiple personality thing and created a Good Seth – and the Bad Seth, this one, does not remember what the Good Seth did.

          Squeeky Fromm
          Girl Reporter

  11. I thought most Americans had already gotten the word that the cure was ice cream.

  12. “13 hours of Trump: The president fills briefings with attacks and boasts, but little empathy”


    On Thursday, when a Post reporter noted that people tuning into the briefings “want to get information and guidance and want to know what to do,” Trump turned his frustration on the reporter, whom he dismissed as “a total faker.”

    “I’m the president and you’re fake news,” Trump said.

    Cecil, the Democratic super PAC head, said his reaction was initially mixed when Trump began dominating the briefings. “You always have to be concerned when one side monopolizes so much of the coverage,” he said.

    But Cecil said he thinks the daily routine will “ultimately hurt” Trump, especially as voters assess the president’s performance against their own suffering. His super PAC has already produced ads using Trump’s own words from the briefings against him and plans to continue doing so going forward.

    “It’s much different to process these press conferences when the coverage before and after is the unprecedented number of people dying, the fact that we don’t have tests,” he said. “Long term it is hurting the president, because people can see with their own eyes and what they are feeling in their own communities what the consequences are.”

    -Washington Post — or to all the Trump-Twits: “Fake News”

    1. The WH communications shop has leaked that it will be testing a new press conference format. It’s called “Survivor style”….the public gets to call in and vote which fake news reporter asked the worst q’s and no longer deserves a seat in the press room….and then Trump pushes the big red EJECT button and that reporter is gone. Next!

  13. Trump is finished, and I’m sad to see him go out this way. Sure, the 25th won’t work, but there’s a good chance the GOP will lose TOTAL in November, including the senate, and kiss liberty goodbye. Pence has acquitted himself well, in a difficult spot, and he may at least prevent a Dem landslide if he topped the ticket. The ONLY chance is to get Trump to step down immediately! Buy him off, whatever.

      1. Better get to work, Squeekers. There’s always preppin’ to be done. It’s a way of life for folks like you.

        1. Anon @6:35p – Preppers ain’t so crazy now, eh? I bet Squeeky’s got a good stash of TP compared to your dwindling supply. 😉

          1. I have plenty of TP, honey, and I’m not a prepper. And I have masks, as well — masks of the right type — masks that provide good protection.

            Squeeker forgot about masks, she said. Poor baby. So much for preppin’.

            Anyway, it’s often what one least expects that gets one in the end. There’s only so much that one can do to prepare.

            And the average prepper is still pretty crazy, IMHO.

            1. Live and learn, but since I am quite content to stay at home, I don’t really need that many masks. I have a couple that I bought when I was painting something, and they are somewhere in all the hardware and tool stuff. And yes, I have plenty of paper goods. And a freezer full of meat. And other stuff. I am just chilling at home, Plenty of coffee and plenty of tea and tobacco. I sleep with a gun beside me in case Antifa or other Democrats decide to raid my fortress. I also need more liquor, so I may have to do a drive-thru liquor purchase to restock a few things. St. Brendans and Malibu Rum.

              Squeeky Fromm
              Girl Reporter

          2. Anonymous – I do not know how many of you follow Red Letter Media, however as of this morning Mike had the gun and liquor, while Jay had all all the TP and hand sanitizer.

      2. Biden won’t be the nominee. Dems know he is a mess. The Dem plans are in the works…gonna be quite a convention to watch.

Comments are closed.