“A Difficult Decision”: Cooperative Closes Outside Chicago Despite Federal and State Funding

 

362 thoughts on ““A Difficult Decision”: Cooperative Closes Outside Chicago Despite Federal and State Funding”

  1. According to AI, here are the reasons why Prarie Food Cooperative failed: “In short, the closure was due to chronic underperformance in sales, insufficient funding for a turnaround, and the inability to meet the financial thresholds needed to keep the co‑op viable.” According to AI, and contrary to some theory in Turley’s book, food cooperatives DO succeed:

    “Food cooperatives have a long history and a proven track record in certain contexts. In the U.S., the National Cooperative Grocers federation includes over 140 member co‑ops, and some agricultural cooperatives have celebrated 100 years in operation Wikipedia+1. Research shows that cooperatives can achieve longevity through factors such as:

    • Strong social capital and member trust
    • Adaptability to economic and social changes
    • Effective governance with member participation in decision‑making MDPI

    USDA case studies of rural co‑ops found that three of four studied co‑ops succeeded due to:

    Reasonable competitive pressure“

    Robust operational management

    Support from members, the community, and industry

    The Prarie Food Cooperative might well have worked if sales had been more robust, and perhaps part of the problem is the economy Trump has crapped on. The average American family has paid $2,500 more for basic needs just this year so far, due to the Trump tariffs that he is bragging are making us so “rich”. Inflation is up by 2.4% of September, shelter costs are up 6.8% in September, 2026, compared with September, 2024. Gas averages over $4.00 a gallon, and diesel averages $6.33 per gallon.

    1. Whole Foods started out as a cooperative. But its success came as it slowly shed its non-working socialist foundations.

      Regardless there is not any reason why a true private cooperative – which is a business like any other business can not succeed.

      The odds are they fail – because most startups fail.

      Government money does not help it actually makes things worse. Success is far more frequent when thee is no backstop. When those trying to accomplish something have bet their future on it, and will do the work and make the changes and learn as needed.

      You note several reasons why Prairie may have failed.

      Under peformance in sales – means you are not delivering what people want. Businesses that are not selling what people want for a price they are willing to pay … DIE.

      Under performance in sales is just proof that Prarie was living in a bubble – they tried to force dogma to work rather than trying to determine what the market wanted.

      Insufficient funding for a turnarround – A large high end grocery starts with maybe 500K – Prarie had 3 times that.

      Regardless investors will be happy to give you all the money you want -if you can convince them that you will be profitable.

      No one besides governmnt funds failure.

      Inability to meet thresholds – more word play to say BADLY MANAGED, FAILED TO UNDERSTAND THEIR MARKET.

      I would also note that our USDA study was of RURAL coops -= these are really no differnet from people getting together to star their own business.

      They are NOT government backed.

      Advocates of the free market has no problems with more players in a free market. Form a Coop, form a Grocery conglomerate.

      Private actors are free to seek success any way they wish – using their own resources.

      You seem to think this is about coops – it si not. It is about Government interfering in the market. That fails

      1. Nothing John Say can be taken at face value.

        Whole Foods Market did not start as a cooperative. It was started in 1980 in Austin, TX as a for profit company before being sold to Amazon in 2017.

        There is another completely different organization, Whole Foods Co-op, in Duluth, MN started in 1970 and still going strong to this very day. It is owned by 13,500 members who each invested $100 as equity, but anyone can shop there.

        There is yet another very successful co-op, originally known as Whole Foods Cooperative started in the late ’70s in Erie, PA. In 2021 it changed its name to Erie Co-op to avoid confusion with Amazon’s Whole Foods Market. It is owned by 7,000 members who paid $100 for an equity interest. It is still going strong to this very day.

        There are many other similar co-ops throughout the country that are thriving.

        John Say has no credibility whatsoever.

    2. admitting you can’t discover information, evaluate it, and think for yourself is not the ‘own’ you think it is.

  2. How much of the more than $1.5 million in taxpayer funds actually went toward the store and not into the pockets of politicians and others with the right connections? Has an actual audit been performed? That is, an audit performed by professionals not selected by those same politicians and others with the right connections?

    1. Unbeleivably important point.

      Virtually none of the spending that DOGE tried to cut – actually went to the purpose it was intended.

      The left is ranting about Trump allegedly getting richer off being president. While most of those claims have failed.

      It is still absolutely true that when Government gets into anything – myriads of the barriers against waste fraud and corruption fall.

      The country spent 4 years dwelling on the Biden corruption scandal. While there is no doubt the Bidens were crooked and never should have had power.

      It is also true that their corruption was TINY as govenrment corruption goes, and worse done incredibly badly.

      There are 10,000 more ways for corruption with anything involving government and far less ability to check them, worse still – many of them are legal – and can not be made illegal without violating the constitution.

      The reason that government should be as far away from the economy as possible is that corruption involving government is inevitble.

      In the private economy there is lots of you scratch my back I will scratch yours.

      But in the end a business must profit its owners and todo that it must deliver to its clients something they want and will pay for.

      NONE of that is true when govenrment is deeply involved.

      1. Every single claim in that post gets reality completely backward, John. Every. Single. One.

        Saying “virtually none of the spending that DOGE tried to cut actually went to the purpose it was intended” is absolute BS. Even DOGE’s own receipt tracker was caught mistaking $8 million for $8 billion, counting already-paid contracts as “savings,” and slashing congressionally appropriated medical research, veterans’ healthcare staff, and food-safety programs that were doing the exact work Congress funded—which is why DOGE never produced criminal fraud indictments to match its rhetoric.

        Even funnier is your claim that “most of those claims [about Trump getting richer] have failed” while calling the Bidens “crooked.” House Republicans spent years investigating Joe Biden and never proved he pocketed a dime—whereas public financial disclosures and blockchain records show Trump’s family wealth surged by billions, BILLIONS! in his second term through World Liberty Financial crypto sales, $TRUMP meme coin fees, and foreign real-estate licensing deals while he dismantled Inspector General oversight.

        Finally, pretending private corporations only make money by “delivering to clients something they want” while government has “no barriers against fraud” erases Enron, WorldCom, Theranos, Purdue Pharma, FTX, and the 2008 Wall Street crash, did you really forget about that? And private-sector frauds hidden behind corporate secrecy until taxpayers got stuck with the cleanup bill. Public utilities and agencies face open-records laws, independent CPA audits, and voter accountability—none of which exist in a private boardroom.

        Come on John. The facts are just never in your favor.

        1. Proving that humans on occasion make math errors is not some refutation of DOGE.

          With respect to YOUR examples – absolutely DOGE does not get to count as saving expenditures that already happened in programs that got canceled – that does not change the fact that Canceling did not save pennies – those programs would have continued to spend Billions.

          I am going to specifically address Foreign aide – USAIDE.

          There is universal agreement among developmental economists that spending $1T over 40 years did not benefit Africa one Wit.

          Helping “the less fortunate” is unbeleivably hard. Government totally completely sucks at it and most foreign aide just ends up as corruption somewhere – in the US, in some middle mans pockets, in the target country. Even right in the community that receives it.

          Today starvation does not exist because we are short of food. Most every country in the world is capable of feedings its own people.

          Starvation exists because of politics – warring factions in undeveloped parts of the world use food as a weapon – they burn crops, they kill farm animals and they control the distribution of foreign food aid.

          An absolute rule – even for wealthy countries is no matter what your problems – YOU are the only person who can fix your life.

          The “curse” of lottery winners is famous – a significant portion of people blessed by randomly receiving hundreds of millions of dollars often quickly go bankrupt.

          Not all – but alot. Amounts of money that are so large it would be hard to lose it all if you tried disappears quickly.

          Acts of god from out of the ether DO NOT make our lives better.

          If there i a problem in your life – self inflicted, inflicted by others or just the overall unfairness of live – you you are disabled, have been raped, had a spouse murdered, become addicted to drugs – Ultimately only YOU can fix your life.

          Even the better charities know this – and real charities are 100 times better at helping people than government – primarily because what the good ones do is try to help people help themselves – and even at that – they are pretty bad – just not as bad as government.

          You can not make another persons life better – they must do that themselves.

          Regardless. you can disagree with my claim that helping people is incredibly hard and the primary issue is NOT money,

          Though the evidence of that is overwhelming. It is still a FACT that Foreign aide Generally – and with massive amounts of economic data over $1t in foreign aide to Africa by the West was a complete and total waste.

          NO USAID Nor any other form of US Foreign aide has ever been anything but Waste.

        2. DOGE’s job was not to produce Criminal fraud indictments. Nor is all govenrment waste and fraud and corruption criminal.

          I noted the damning history of aide to africa – which no one argues has provided a long term measurable benefit and many argue has made things worse.

          Was there criminla fraud involved ? Probably – did that involve crimes in the US – possibly not.

          I would further note that most of the ONGOING criminal investigations are he result of things that DOGE or DOGE related efforts uncovered.

          Finding waste in Government is a trivial excercise.

          Did DOGE identify wasteful programs that alwao had benefits – without a doubt – Spend a Billion dollars and there is probably someone somewhere who gets something of value – independent of the waste and fraud.

          With rare exceptions congress does not approve SPECIFIC programs – The executive does that Absolutely DOGE resulted i cuts to programs that congress had GENERALLY funded, But not ones it had specifically funded – there is no budget line item for Trans Gendered Opera in Columbia.

          If Trump cut SPECIFIC programs funded by congress – there would be lawsuits – and there were. There were some minor victories requiring government to pay forcontract work that had already been performed – even if it was wasteful spending. But no one won with respect to program terminations – nothing was terminated that the president did not have the power to terminate,

          With respect to your claim that this resulted in actual harm – Bollocks. I m going to keep using Africa – because the disaster that has been aide to africa has been incredibly well studied. No one argues with a straight face long term benefits in Africa from foreign aide. Through the 20th century Africa is the one part of the world that has seen no consequential improvement in standard of living – no mater what.

          Though I would note that the relatively famous “historical fiction” “The Ugly American” goes into significant detail documenting the US’s “fictional” aide failures in Asia that exactly match the real failures in Asia.

          The book is over 69 years old – and the story was the same 60 years ago – US Foreign aide likely causes more harm than good.

          I have harped on Africa – becaue it is well studied and because pretty close to NOTHING has improved in Africa in 70 years – probably not in 200 years.

          Because nothing has improved it i CLEAR that foreign aide did not help.

          But it is jus as arguable that foriegn aide has not helped ANYWHERE.

          And in fact it is arguable that All efforts at govenrment charity anywhere ever are at the very best massive wastes for poor return and often massive wastes for NO return.

        3. Trump and his family are absolutely doing quite well – and less than a fraction of a percent of that is tied in anyway to government.

          The single largest gain has been in Crypto – that Started before he ran for president.

          The other major gain has been in social media. Have the Trump family made a few million in ivestments in multi billion dollar companies that have contracts with Government – absolutely – But they do not even a few percent of these companies. They do not have controlling interests and they are not involved in contracts.

          With respect to the Bidens. Hunter Biden was found guilty of 9 separate tax crimes – this was much like Alcapone – for failing to pay taxes on illegal income.

          SC Hurr made it clear WHILE Biden was president – that he was not prosecutable because he was demented.

          Regardless, Trump did not go after Hillary Criminally as president, he has not gone after Biden. And he could not get a conviction if he did.

          Hunter has been pardoned essentially for anything he may have ever done, and Joe is not competent to stand trial.

          If you wish to argue that compared to others in Washington – Pelosi, Clinton – the Bidens are petty criminals and bad criminals – fine.

          But no the Bidens are a bad crime family – meaning very bad at it. And yes they have been proven guilty – in Hunters case atleast 12 different crimes atleast 6 felonies. Hunter was convicted in Delaware – where he hoped for Jury nullification, and in California – Not Texas or Alabama.

          Arguing innocence on the part of the Bidens just makes you look foolish

        4. “Finally, pretending private corporations only make money by “delivering to clients something they want” while government has “no barriers against fraud” erases “Enron – did not commit fraud.”

          They made stupid decisions that bankrupted the business and hurt alot of people all of the few convictions were thrown out – because there were no crimes.

          I have never claimed that business do not do stupid things.

          Worldcom improperly recorded sales in the wrong year to make their financials look better. That is an incredibly common thing in business – often done for tax reasons. It is stupid, it is technically a crime and in a public company it is fraud. Though the norm (not true of Worldcom) is that it is tax fraud.

          Tax fraud of that type is almost never caught prosecuted or even looked for – it does not need to be. You can only push taxes forward so long. One of two things MUST happen – you have a real loss and the problem goes away and you lose a refund you would have received if you had paid the taxes when you should have.

          Or you do not have a real loss and either you face a massive tax bill from accumlated taxes pushed forward or you get caught and have a massive tax bill.

          Otherwise it is an inconsequential crime. In Worldcoms case false data to invesors is fraud.

          Regardless the Worldcom fraud – supposedly the larges business fraud in history – is a fraction of the entitlements fraud in CA and about the same as than in MN.

          Theranos was a huge story – but the actual scale of the fraud is about the same as that of one or two Somalis who were convicted in MN.

          The Sackler stuff is complete nonsense. Oxycontin is still being sold today. Nothing has changed. Absolutely people abused Oxycodone. But it is much harder to abuse than Heroine, and far more expensive.

          What is there purported big Crime ? That they New Oxycontin was not delivering a flat time release and therefore slightly more addictive.

          It was always classified as a narcotic. It was ALWAYS know that it could be ground up to defeat the time release. Just as people do with Aderal.

          Not only is Oxycontin wtill available the far more dangerous form – oxycodone – without any time release is also still available.

          There is a strong credible argument hat Oxycontin was significantly more beneficial than harmful.

          The entire Sackler story is really a subset of a much larger story where the Federal govenrment flipped from Encouraging the use of narcotics for people with severe pain problems to criminalizing the doctors and medical professionals that were providing narcotics to patients were nothing else worked.

          This was NEVER a problem govenrment belonged in – absolutely some doctors will provide narcotics to addicts. I is also true that doctors provide narcotics to people with debilitating pain that nothing else helps. The actual abuse involving doctors is rare – illegal drugs are far cheaper than prescription drugs.

          Bankman Fried was a major left wing nut and contibutor to left wing causes and politicians.

          His major “crime” – beyond arrogance and recklessness was securing his hedge fund with a line of credit from his independent crypto exchange – essentially he treate the crypto he was holding for others as funds his Hedge fund could draw against.

          While ultimtely an 11B judgement was entered against him – the actual looses were nearly entirely to the hedge fund. and do to mismanagement – not fraud.

          But as with Enron – when lots of money is lost we try to send someone to jail.

          I am angry because he gave government a lever to try to regulate crypto -which has absolutely no need of govenrment regulation.

          As to the Hedge fund – those are high risk high return investments. The people who invesed with Almeda knew or should have known the risk they faced.

          Every now and then here is going to be a hedge fund failure. If you bet money at Las Vegas – you are going to loose sometimes.

          Separately while Bankman-Freid had been very successful in the past, both his success and his recklessness were know.

          Bankman-fried lost alot of money ran his company incredibly badly and failed in a very predictable way. I have no sympathy for he people ho lost money,.

          zHe also made alot of people alot of money too. That is how hedge funds work. It is not a crime.

          You can not invest in a hedge fund unless you can demonstrate that you can afford to lose the money.

          Unlike Enron and Worldcom who destroyed peoples IRA’s – Bankman-fried lost the money of multi-millionaires and billionaires.

          And they punished him by jailing him.

          As to the 2008 Financial crisis – that was in all way caused by Government – Government pushing banks to make ever riskier loans,

          Government chaning the accounting rules suddenly. Government keeping interest rates too low for too long fueling malinvestment – BTW that wa also the cause for the great depression.

          “And private-sector frauds hidden behind corporate secrecy until taxpayers got stuck with the cleanup bill.”

          Tax payers should never be and need never be stuck with the Bill.

          “Public utilities and agencies face open-records laws, independent CPA audits”

          As do publicly traded companies, as well as banks.

          “voter accountability“

          Nope – I do not ever recall voting for anything related to a “public utility” – and BTW their records are less transparent than most public corporations.

          “none of which exist in a private boardroom.”

          Correct – in a private board room – the people who own the company – who own the stock, who will lose money if there is a failure, are the ones who have a voice”

          Bankman-Fried lost alot of money for alot of people who had alot of money – not drying in the slightest. If I had a billion dollars I would not have invested it with him. But there was no secret that he was a unstable genius left wing whack job. People knew what they were getting into.

          I have some problems with some of the ethically dubious things he did – treating FTX and Almeda as independent and intertewind when convenient.

          But I am pretty sure FTX – the cyrpot exchange was made whole and Almeda the hedge fund had the losses – that is how it should be.

          Regardless – This is all you got ? Without a doubt there is alot more private secotr fraud than this. And it still does not hold a candle to public secotr fraud.

          Social Security is a Ponzi scheme and has liabilities of between 45-100+T that are unfunded – those will be paid for by taxpayers.

          No private actor would be allowed to create such a fraudulent structure.

        5. I want to address the financial crisis since you stupidly brought it up.

          The causes are government stupidity all arround.

          Mostly I am not going to further address those – The fed and some economists have tried to whitewash the feds role – but the understanding that virtually ALL macro economic shocks are monetrary in nature – NOT market driven. The FED was created because dicking with monetary policy is incredibly economically dangerous and before the Fed congress and the Treasury controlled it – that is as bad as it sounds, but the FED has historically done no better.

          mickey mousing with interest rates and money supply is unbeleiveably economically dangerous.

          I am NOT personally a “gold crank” – Gold is not significantly less “fiat” than paper money even today the entire value of gold is monetary not use based.

          Holding gold is a hedge against inflation.

          That said the Gold standard imposed monetary discipline that the Fed can not match. That can be accomplished without gold. But it can not be accomplished when Government controls money supply.

          The primary driver of the financial crisis was interest rates too low for too long. This is the most common cause of boom bust cycles. This has been well known atleast since the 1920’s Militon freidmen got his nobel in part for that.

          But past the causes – the “bailout” was entirely unnecescary and stupid.

          Banks – most of which had nothing to do with the mispriced risk in lending that always results from too low interest rates for too long – it is the FEDs job to know that if it screws up interest rates it will create an artifical boom that MUST eventually bust.

          All that said the Financial crisis – as opposed to the recession itself, was cause by Bad Government banking rules that have never been changed. The risk is still with us today. Nothing in Dodd Frank did a Damn thing to fix anything – even Glass-Steigal which had nothing to do with this was NOT reinstated.

          The primary cause was the Government rules on Banks lending reserve requirements. Banks were allowed to have investments – like stocks and bonds and securities as part of those reserves. For decades the banks could value those reserves. In November 2007 Basil II regs took effect that required banks to value securities at the last market price for those securities. This change – sounds reasonable, but it means that a volatile market will lock up the entire banking system

          Slowly through 2008 it became evident that the housing bubble had burst and financial paper tied to mortgages -= Mortgage backed securities were slowly collapsing in value in the market to reflect this. There was a housing bubble the bubble burst the value of housing dropped precipitously so the values of mortgages and securities tied to them tanked.

          All major banks holding Mortgage Backed Securites as part of their capital reserves saw the value of those reserves drop. While some bankruptcies were inevitable – THAT was not the real problem. The real problem is that as the value of reserves declined – Mark To Market for MBS’s Major banks were increasingly unable to legally lend money. They had money to lend, But that would reduce their reserves further.

          Nearly all this financial institutions were solvent. Further they had positive cashflow and were actually making money.

          But they were legally allowed to lend ever less money as the value of MBS’s finally hit 25 cents on the dollar in August 2028.

          At which point nearly all lending stopped.

          And that essentially stopped the economy.

          Companies that had their money invested and needed to borrow for payroll or operations – that is most of the economy could not borrow, not because of bad credit – but because he banks were not legally allowed to end.

          Tarp was supposed to fix this – Government would buy the MBS’s from banks – only two problems – the government was paying 25 cents on the dollar and no one would sell and that would not change the regulatory reserve problem.

          Later Congress decided to just Lend banks billions of dollars but Most banks did not have problems and did not want to borrow government money.

          So Tarp II made the borrowing Manditory. So your so called bailout was done a gun point.

          The recession was going to happen NO MATTER WHAT – if you cause an artifical boom your going to get a bust.

          But the financial crisis itself was unnecescary. All Government needed to do was wive refulator reserve requirments briefly or waive Mark To Market rules briefly.

          I would further note that in thory there was another completely non-government solution – and the reasons that never happened are instructive.

          AIG had provinde Bnaks with CDS and CDOs to “insure” their mortgage backed securities. These meant AIG would give banks Money and the banks woudl give AIG their mortgage backed securities. The CEO of AIG was fully prepared to honor this – and had lined up investors to allow him to buy the MBS’s

          But no bank asked AIG to go forward with this.

          Why ? EVERYBODY – banks, AIG, Government KNEW that the value of the MBS’s was NOT 25 cents to the dollar. The value of US housing had dropped about 10-15% and even that did not last for years. It did not actually drop 75% – and this is one of the huge problems with Mark To Market.

          A core law of economics is that the value of anything is ONLY what a willing buyer and a willing seller agree to.

          When sellors will not sell for what buyers offer – there is no know value. The head of Citibank had publicly stated in 2008 that it would be fiscal misconduct to sell Citibanks MBS’s for less than face value. Nearly everyone on the planet KNEW they would recover quickly.

          AIG was FORCED to borrow something like $114B – it never needed that money, and it repaid every penny with interest as fast as it was legally allowed to do – and AIG was the largest “bailout” in Tarp, and the CEO of AIG said that he coudl easily have raised that money privately for MBS’s that the Banks could force him to buy if they wanted, but were never going to – because it was a GREAT deal for AIG.

          The whole thing from beginning to end was government screw up after government screw up.

          If you are too stupid to understand that any other way – you should atleast grasp that Dobb-Frank did not make a single change in banking law that had anything to do with anything anyone claimed was a cause to the financial crisis.

          1. Writing a 900-word wall of text doesn’t turn bad history into facts, John—and burying a thread in ten paragraphs of off-topic rambling is what people do when they can’t defend their actual claim.

            Almost every “fact” in your 2008 lecture is completely backwards. First, mark-to-market accounting wasn’t “Basel II”—it was FAS 157, issued by the Financial Accounting Standards Board (a private-sector accounting board), and post-crisis SEC and Fed studies proved banks failed because they were leveraged 30-to-1 on toxic subprime mortgages, not because of accounting rules.

            Second, your AIG fairy tale is pure fiction. AIG had written over $440 billion in credit default swaps without setting aside reserves, and in September 2008, counterparty banks demanded tens of billions in immediate contractual collateral calls AIG couldn’t pay. AIG was hours from total bankruptcy when the Fed stepped in with an $85 billion emergency bailout (eventually $182 billion), wiped out shareholders, and ousted its CEO.

            Third, there was no “TARP II,” and Dodd-Frank directly targeted what caused the crash—raising capital requirements, banning predatory no-doc subprime loans, imposing annual stress tests, and regulating the exact over-the-counter derivatives market that blew up AIG.

            Next time, try making a relevant point in two paragraphs instead of typing a thousand-word essay full of things you misremembered from 2008.

            You’ve been wrong in every single thing John. You’re just rambling long winded libertarian fever dreams and hoping nobody will challenge the long running posts.

  3. The food co-op collapse topic comes on the cusp of Thanksgiving. This holiday has its roots in a time of Pilgrim settlers before the Framers designed our representative democracy, including the ideas from Adam Smith’s 1776 book An Inquiry Into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations. 2020 was the last year of Rush Limbaugh’s annual reading of his True Story of Thanksgiving. Which annually produced Limbaugh Derangement Syndrome before the Trump Derangement Syndrome. His take, that to get success, Plymouth Colony Governor William Bradford had to dump a co-op design and go to a private property land parcel design remains argued. What is clear is that the principles of the 1600’s Plymouth events show up in Adam Smith’s 1776 book. I’d like to offer a thought on both the Framer’s design and the approach to Thanksgiving. It looks back to the history of Pericles and direct democracy. There is the notion that, from the golden age of Greece, the people cast a direct vote to enact a measure of law. What we have is delegation to an elected representative of the function of governing, and a retained individual vote with a dollar in the marketplace with a purchase and sale. And in that sense the dollar vote is the descendant of Pericles direct democracy that exists in parallel with representative democracy. It is inextricably intertwined with the Constitution’s blueprint of governance. Both contribute to why we revere Thanksgiving. Socialism looks to remove that dollar vote. You can’t vote to drive with a fossil fuel engine. You can’t vote  to buy a house heater that you can afford. Those votes are not necessary under the warmth of collectivism. In short Thanksgiving celebrates that our representative democracy does not see itself as the answer to everything.

    1. I’m not seeing the analogy. Consumer co-operatives are not engaged in production nor are they a source of income for aught but a few of their members. They are a means of providing retail trade services. They don’t compete very well.

      1. Del Monte went bankrupt recently. It was a wonderful product for decades in the United States. Del Monte had contracted with growers for many years in advance. It was a domino effect when Del Monte fell. The growers also went with them. It’s a kind of co-op.

    1. Those are institutions incorporated into the task of maintaining a military. They’re not meant to be competitive private enterprises nor do they displace private enterprise except in the most minor way.

    2. What about them ?

      Are you trying to say they are the same as grocery stores of food cooperatives ?

      Regardleess, the millitary is fully within the legitimate power of government.

      With respect to the legitimate tasks of government we tolerate inefficiency, lack of freedom, myriads of other problems Because government is inherently inefficient,

      And because efficient government – such as ACTUAL Nazis is a bad idea.

      WE do not want government to easily and efficiently use force.

  4. While this mess goes on, the public sector is not properly nurtured and disciplined to promote good performance of those tasks germane to the public sector. (Much of which involves the activities of the police forces, to which Democrats are hostile).

  5. Again, ‘investment’ by government agencies and government corporations should consist of conventional public works (roads, bridges, sewer systems, water systems, campuses providing work places for government employees, service points for the public, and dormitories for some employees and clients).

    ==

    Government lending should consist of the conventional operations of the central bank in conducting monetary policy. Government guarantees on loans and bond issues should be limited to what is necessary to contain the occasional banking crisis).

    ==

    Government grants to private enterprise and private philanthropy should be limited to (1) disaster relief to injured parties and (2) financing relief operations of agencies which have boots on the ground (and have not been blacklisted consequent to having previously laundered grants).

    ==

    Subsidized services provided or financed by governments (outside of emergency situations) should be limited to medical care, long term care, schooling, legal services, shipping-and-transportation, and burial expenses. There should in these regards be a bias in favor of issuing vouchers and insurance rather than direct provision by public employees or government contractors (though that would be apposite in some circumstances).

    ==

    Government provision of mundane household goods should (outside of emergencies) be limited to a situation where such provision is a conduit to providing some other service. For example, government housing should be limited to compounds for civilian government employees posted abroad, barracks and garrison housing for military dependents, dormitories for students boarding at public institutions, berths in government run long term care centers, and prison and jail berths. Government provision of commercial real estate should be limited to sites for public markets and trade marts. Government provision of meals should be limited to those venues and the occasional acute care or rehabilitation operated by a local government. Government subsidies to utility bills should be limited to regulatory prohibitions on cutting off service in wintertime.

    ==

    Public agencies and government corporations have their function: to produce and enforce the regulatory architecture of society (notably prohibition on collusion among producers and containing the discretion of monopoly producers), to produce goods and services which competitive enterprise cannot generate, to compose and implement schemes for allocating use of common property resources, to compose and implement schemes to contain externalities from productive activity, and to animate the ethic of common provision in society. This last can be accomplished through subsidized services or income transfers. (1) it is prudent to limit the share of personal income flow accounted for by subsidized services and income transfers and (2) it is prudent to set eligibility criteria for government programs so as to contain perverse incentives.

    ==

    State-owned enterprise and public agencies which produce services which could be vended on the open market should be limited to (1) natural monopolies, and (2) the conventionally philanthropic sectors noted above, and (3) some municipal amenities. Government involvement in retail trade – especially that with such low margins as the grocery business features – is gratuitous and should be eschewed.

    ==

    My brother and I have both belonged to co-op groceries. The town I grew up in is a dense settlement of about 600,000 people. I’m not sure there was more than one co-op grocery operating in 1995 and it’s gone now. The co-op managers even with the volunteer labor of members could not put produce on the shelves of a quality to attract customers sufficient to sustain the enterprise. Joan Mondale, who was a member of a consumer co-operative around Washington in the 1970s offered her take: that co-operative can succeed only where there is one person in charge to make command decisions; if everyone on a board has to have their say, it fails. Co-ops should follow their bliss without government support. There won’t be many of them.

    ==

    You have a vagrant population in this country, but it’s sufficiently small that provision of shelter and sustenance for them can be accomplished by private charity. Ditto community food cupboards. The contribution that the public sector can make is to assign police officers to assist with security around these agencies.

    ==

    One other thing, bar the issue of government agencies and corporations, bar natural monopolies and bar conventional restrictions on usury, prices should never be controlled. You might have regulations working toward making prices transparent and toward certain parties being given due notice of changes in prices, but, ultimately, prices must either be negotiated between parties or at the discretion of producers taking account of what the market will bear.

        1. Anon 1:09 is right. that x writes mumbo jumbo. He’s thinks he’s an intellectual, actually he’s a clown.

  6. Dear Prof Turley,

    Give me $1.5m, 10 acres of tillable ground in Central Park (I’m thinking Strawberry Fields forever.) along with 5 acres for cattle/hog run-in, and I’ll feed Manhattan for free.

    *yearly employment budget est. >$1.5m/yr.

    You can’t beat that at Winn Dixie.

  7. If and when the Mamdani 30% off all month stores open, I predict lots of bodega owners will shop there and restock their own shelves.

    When I was younger, my uncles owned 3 grocery stores. They were undercut by 2 chains, who sold produce for less than my uncles could be it. One of my uncles threatened to shop at the chain and buy out their stock.

    1. I miss independent groceries and independent pharmacies.

      ==

      There is no trade with lower margins than the grocery business. The notion it should be assumed by the public sector is madcap.

  8. So many things to criticize Turley’s op ed with here…

    Co ops don’t equal city run markets for one thing.

    E

    Turley’s cherry picking this one example for another (when there multiple city run markets that are successful).

    B

    Onward. Turley has become one of the most prolific right wing demagogues working today. His natural disingenuous combined with talking points he’s provided by fox guarantees this. Turley will be marked by history as one of the biggest American sell outs ever. He’s Roy Cohn with a few table manners…, but he’s rapidly dropped those table manners and is now just a snarling cliche.

    And the level of right wing discourse his blog attracts is now far below the lowest levels of stupid. Plus Estovir is a f’ing nazi. Curious if the turd magat is traumatized by what happened election night in Georgia? Bet he had conniptions.

    1. @can’t-beliece-you’ve-resurrected-this-sheet-and-expect-us-to-have-forgotten

      ‘So many things to criticize Turley’s op ed with here…’

      If you are you, sure, fine. The rest of us who are not insane/paid/bored/medicated, not so much.

      1. *Believe

        Sigh, phone.

        No one has forgotten, ‘elvis’. At this point, I’m almost certain George is all of these puppets.

      2. James,

        Oh, no we have not forgotten. The problem with these lower elevator level IQ types like bug, is he is not smart enough to understand criticizing leftists or illiberal policies is NOT being a right wing anything. It is just pointing out leftist or illiberal polices failing is not right wing. I can recall other Democrats pointing out Obamacare was not working and needed fixed. Were they right wingers too?

        https://apnews.com/article/b8dfc194826c4c85ae75ffc7e60545dc

        https://www.cnn.com/2016/10/04/politics/bill-clinton-obamacare-craziest-thing/

        And there are those of us who recall you usually comment from your phone, so, if I see something that does not make sense, I think on it for a second or two and figure out what you meant.

        1. Turley isn’t politically aligned and has a considerable history of criticizing Trump. The sorosphere appears to consider him a threat, so you have these Media Matters recruits lobbing accusations and insults at him but not engaging with his points. Ann Althouse is a similarly situated observer (though she tends to be non-committal) who attracts leftoid critics but avoids some of the obnoxious infiltration by having a strong moderator who warns the pricks, then bans them.

          1. x (the good one),

            I am of the opinion the good professor sees the changes in his party, what they are saying, their actions, is alarmed by it and sees these radical far leftists and illiberals as a real threat not only to his party but the nation as a whole. Hence he points that out. He is still a Democrat, for now. But in his pointing out the stupid and crazy, those far leftists and illiberals see him as a traitor. If you are not with them in their radical agenda, then you are against them. Then they have to resort to calling him right wing or MAGA. As liberals like Bill Maher have noted, they did not leave the party, the party left them for the stupid and crazy.

          2. x, Turley, and his family are Democrats, but he has admitted to drifting and becoming an independent. He has slightly left-leaning, classical liberal tendencies, but recently has criticized the outlandish behavior of the Democrats.

        2. Looks who calling people lower elevator IQ types. A fool with no high school diploma or a college degree. He claims to be a pig farmer. He even looks like a pig.

          1. You and I have never met. How would you know what I looked like?

            And that is lower elevator level IQ thinking for you.

            1. Mixed sites on which I have been active generally have at least one poster who does nothing but lob drive-by insults at starboard posters.

            2. What they write about you here, by all accounts, and your juvenile writings, you are less than a mid-wit, aka moron.

    2. “Co ops don’t equal city run markets for one thing.”

      Correct – but these received substantial govenrment funding and still failed.

      “Turley’s cherry picking this one example for another (when there multiple city run markets that are successful).”

      Then cite one. Government only succeeds competeing in free markets when it heavily subsidizes, or when it bankrupts private competition so that it can raise prices.

      “Onward. Turley has become one of the most prolific right wing demagogues working today.”

      No he is just not stupid enough to beleive the laws of economics can be repealed.

      Or that you can game basic math to make failure into sucess.

      “And the level of right wing discourse his blog attracts is now far below the lowest levels of stupid. Plus Estovir is a f’ing nazi.”

      The only people talking about Jewish Genocide are on the left.

      1. John Say……, one has already been cited…..multiple times. Kansas, St. Paul. Government run store been there since 2013. Still there. Not a failure. No gaming of the math either. Just a heads up.

        1. Its 2023 financial statement indicates it operated at a small loss. It’s a considerable distance from other stores.

  9. It is the canary in our society’s coal mine making it time again to check in with the National Debt Clock to remind us why government spending is the ultimate boondoggle predicting the worst that happens to prosperity when governments continue to spend even after they have run out of other people’s money. It is because of unchecked socialism that doomsday clocks keep ticking.

    https://www.usdebtclock.org/

    1. That canary only comes out when the Democrats have control of the Senate and the House.

      It hides away when the Republicans slash taxes for the corporations and the uber-rich while increasing spending.

      1. The canary isn’t watched to see if it “comes out” of its cage. It’s watched to see when it lies dead in its cage. You should begin looking for it when January begins.

        1. It’s your crappy use of the analogy – in fact, they don’t die, they pass out. Miners seeing the bird unconscious would supply oxygen immediately to revive it while making a speedy exit. The bird is under constant observation. “Come out” as in, the canary and it’s cage comes out of wherever it is kept to the mine face, not that it flies free.

          Nonetheless, the only time the Republicans care about the deficit is when the Democrats are in charge. Otherwise the Republicans are happy to pillage the middle class while passing the savings onto the oligarchs.

          1. No amount of an increase in anyone’s taxes will remedy the now historical and forever unsustainable national debt absent some drastic curtailments in government spending. Republicans for the most part understand and appreciate that relationship and democrats for the most part do not.

  10. A large percentage of small businesses fail – $1.5M isn’t a particularly large initial fund for something the size of a supermarket.

    Socialism is also called Christianity. Being against socialism is being against Christianity.

    As to spending and getting nothing for it, blowing $500M to lose the midterms? Priceless.

    1. One may blend characteristics of socialism and Christianity but no one should conclude they share the same religious and political philosophy. Christian socialism emerged on the heels of developing socialism in the mid-19th Century. It took what Christianity teaches about compassion but leaves aside what it teaches about volunteerism and one’s own will.

      1. Christianity is not socialist – ATS’s argument is crap.

        “Christ will say to those on his right, ‘Come, you who are blessed by my Father; take your inheritance, the kingdom prepared for you since the creation of the world. For I was hungry and you gave me something to eat, I was thirsty and you gave me something to drink, I was a stranger and you invited me in, I needed clothes and you clothed me, I was sick and you looked after me, I was in prison and you came to visit me.’

        Christianity is what YOU do for others – not what you lobbey govenrment to do with resources that you take from others.

        If YOU did not do it, then it has no merit.

      2. You could say the social encyclicals are a work in progress. It’s difficult to seen a path to practical implementation. Lots of Christian Democratic outfits in continental Europe. Not sure what their actual accomplishments are; the irony of their situation is that Christian observance is a single-digit popular phenomenon in most of Europe.

    2. Yeah clown Anonymous. A drop in the bucket compared to what Democrats spent.

      “Democrats spent approximately $5.52 billion in the 2026 midterm elections, which contributed to their decisive victories and control of both houses of Congress.” Brennan Center for Justice

    3. “A large percentage of small businesses fail – $1.5M isn’t a particularly large initial fund for something the size of a supermarket.”

      Actually it is.

      “Opening a supermarket typically costs between $250,000 and $1,000,000 depending on size and location, with medium-sized stores averaging $250,000 to $500,000.”

      Yes,m new businesss fail – and they lose INVESTORS money – people who choce to put that money in and who would be rewarded if the store succeeded.

      This was PUBLIC money – not private money – did YOU agree to invest ? To put your money at risk ?

      “Socialism is also called Christianity. Being against socialism is being against Christianity.”

      Not at all. Christ said render unto ceasar that which is ceasars.

      Charity is PRIVATE., and it is volunatary.

      Are you so stupid that you think you “do good” – act morally when you use force to steal from peter to pay paul ?

      Christinaity is when YOU go out and feed the poor. Tyrany aka socialism is when you use force to get others to do it.

      Actual christians must give of them selves to help others – otherwise there is no merit.

      Does the owner of a slave do good when they direct the slave to help someone else ?

      “As to spending and getting nothing for it, blowing $500M to lose the midterms? Priceless.”

      Was it your money ?

      This store lost the the peoples money. Not their own, not investors, not people who chose to risk the money.

  11. The US doesn’t manufacture anymore. It’s all from Shina. Fud is from Meheeco. The US is a parasitic culture now. If workers want 49% of profit, workers will need to pay for the capital and profit after capital and taxes might be workable. I really doubt the brains behand capitalism would do 49%. Workers from clerks to delivery people to managers would be paid the same wage? sure

    1. CD – everyone is free to be a “capitalist”

      Save a portion of your wages and invest them – you are a capitalist.

      As that investment grows you are an ever more consequential capitalist.

      When you invest you are creating jobs and also products other people value.

      1. No, you’re an entrepreneur or a proprietor.

        ==

        Capitalism refers to the division of labor between functions – production, management, distribution, finance, power generation.

  12. To anyone with a brain – so, NOT Democrat voters, or the cowardly “anonymous” commenters here defending it – seeing Socialism fail every single time it’s ever been tried would be enough proof that it will never work, and that only those who gain money/power by promoting it would benefit.

    That’s why Bernie and Fauxcahontas are millionaires.

    The main reason Socialism fails is that it denies human nature in two ways: (1) If I work harder than someone else, I feel I should be rewarded more than the lazy people who choose to live off of the work of others, and (2) It’s blatantly unfair for any government to take what I earn and give it to lazy losers and criminals.

    That this happened in IL, and will soon be repeated in NYC is not just a random occurrence. Obviously, they keep voting for failure (i.e., Democrats).

    Thanks to the Democrat propaganda media, teachers unions and college indoctrinators, this latest failure will be spun and absurdly blamed on Trump, Republicans and Capitalism. And the same lazy, indoctrinated people will nod in compliance with their puppet masters and keep voting for Democrats so they can keep getting their “free” (i.e., taken from others) stuff.

        1. I haven’t heard that from the GenZ’s in my family. You don’t hear much from them. They don’t take their faces away from their phones.

    1. I’m from Rochester, NY, the home of Wegmans food markets. Wegmans is planning to open a second store in NYC.

      I certainly hope that our governor, Kathy Hochul, is not inclined to subsidize any of these stores that Mayor Mamdani has in mind. New Yorkers cannot afford to squander taxpayer dollars on a negative net present value project.

      1. I think you’d have to scrounge to find an example of Hochul giving voice to an original observation. By all appearances, she’s a manager of the type you’d call a ‘multi-directional placator’. Not a leader at all. The only satisfactory governor New York has had since 1982 was David Patterson. He had an approval rating of about 17% near the end of his term. New Yorkers have an issue. It’s one they see in the mirror in the morning.

        1. I heard that there is a sign near the state border that reads: “LEAVING NEW YORK STATE LIKE EVERYONE ELSE “

    2. National Co+op Grocers [Saint Paul, MN USA]
      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Co+op_Grocers
      [Link] ncg.coop/

      Wiki: List of cooperatives [USA]
      [Link] en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cooperatives#United_States

      Wiki: History of the cooperative movement [USA]
      [Link] en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_cooperative_movement#U.S._Cooperatives

      Wiki: List of food cooperatives [USA: General, Student, Defunct]
      [Link] en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_food_cooperatives#United_States

  13. The war in the Middle East seems to be going well.

    Hegseth ordered the families of US soldiers stationed in the Middle East to download an Israeli missile warning app to their phones. The app requires constant connectivity and uses the GPS location of the phone to advise of incoming missiles. Because it requires constant connectivity, the families have run up many thousands of dollars in international roaming charges.

    Apparently the US military, under Hegseth, no longer has the capacity to monitor incoming missile attacks, so they have shifted the burden to the soldiers and their families who have to pay thousands of dollars out of their own pockets to protect themselves.

    1. P’SST, the article was about Prairie Food Co-Op. Just read the article first before you comment. Please try to follow along, for reading is fundamental.

      1. P’SST, the article is a completely pointless deflection designed to distract from reality, and stoke the rage of the MAGA mob.

        Turley is deliberately, and disingenuously stoking the rage that he so vehemently criticizes in others.

        1. That is not rage. Pointing out the obvious failures of leftist or illiberal polices is not rage. No one is raging. We look, see what is happening, do some thinking and come to a conclusion.

          In this particular case, the cooperation got seed money from the state and federal funding. Despite that, it went under. Personally I think more likely it was a mixture of factors of someone thought they had a good idea but could not capitalize on it. Likely poor management failure to recognize failing trend/s and adjust or pivot accordingly. Clearly 600 of the members did not recognize it as worth to continue supporting. That is their right.

  14. At first the warmth of collectivism is produced by bonfires fueled with the confiscated belongings of the bourgeoisie. Once those spoils are reduced to ash, the collective must sustain the fire by begging, borrowing, or stealing fuel from its neighbors. Finally, if it survives those conflicts and runs out of other people’s property to burn, its members will be forced to torch their own furniture and shrubbery in order to survive the winter—or else migrate to warmer climes.

  15. This is the problem with socialism. It is enthusiastically embraced by people who have accomplished nothing, with the requisite knowledge to match.

  16. Heads of state are currently burning through millions of dollars having another one of their fruitless meetings.

  17. Howard Lutnick upstaged Donald J. Trump’s trilateral summit on Thursday by becoming the first US Commerce Secretary to be named Employee of the Month by the Chinese Communist Party.

    Lutnick beat out a competitive field of candidates in November including former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang and Trump himself.

    “I hope this silences my critics,” a beaming Lutnick said as he accepted the plaque from Chinese President Xi Jinping. “Scott Bessent can bite me.”

    For his part, Trump admitted he was “envious as hell” that Lutnick had bested him for November’s honor, but noted, “By the end of this summit, I’ll be a lock for December.”

Leave a Reply